8chan/8kun QResearch Posts (38)
#24496250 at 2026-04-13 20:50:43 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #29874 Ebake
#29871 >>24494121
>>24494135 Aussie: "Drill baby drill" Pauline Hanson says we must become Self-Reliant
>>24494163 The New Modern first female Chief of the Australian Army, Lieutenant General Susan Coyle.
>>24494494 ICYMI: PRESIDENT TRUMP goes hard on POPE LEO: "I'm not a big fan of Pope Leo. A very liberal person and a man that doesn't believe in stopping crime!"
>>24494389 ICYMI: @realDonaldTrump Trump as Healer
>>24494399 Watch LIVE as Nigel Farage and Zia Yusuf reveal the true cost of the Boriswave.
>>24494515 President Trump Speaks to Reporters from Joint Base Andrews - Vid
>>24494453 U.S. to Blockade Ships Entering or Exiting Iranian Ports
>>24494466 The U.S. naval blockade of the Strait of Hormuz would cost Iran approximately $276M/day in lost exports and disrupt $159M/day in imports, a combined economic damage of ~$435M/day, or $13B/month.
>>24494475 Ghalibaf and chief negotiator has mocked the US plan to blockade the Strait of Hormuz, warning Americans they may soon long for today's fuel
>>24494498, >>24494530 As we were passing through a Haitian street market in the Dominican Republic, we noticed a bag of rice from USAID.
>>24494528 The Knights Templar Order and its ruling Council demand that this offensive and blasphemous image be removed forthwith !
>>24494545 Billionaire Kicks Swalwell Out of Mansion, Wants $1M in Donations Back Following Rape Allegations
>>24494551 #29871
#29870 >>24493289
>>24493597 Iran has a 'very difficult' decision to make: Mike Pompeo
>>24493664 Biased anti-Trump report of Trump's supposed plans (KEK)
>>24493674 Analysis: 1/10 The U.S. naval blockade of the Strait of Hormuz would cost Iran approximately $276M/day in lost exports and disrupt $159M/day in imports, a combined economic damage of ~$435M/day, or $13B/month.
>>24493691 RT claim: The UK will not take part in President Trump's planned blockade of Iran-linked vessels in the Strait of Hormuz
>>24493697 Map if Europe/Middle East showing "all assets still in theater…non-stop resupply trains…"
>>24493911, >>24493955, >>24493957, >>24493945 Anons discuss what Trump really said about Strait of Hormuz
>>24493973, >>24493451 CENTCOM says American forces will begin implementing a blockade of maritime traffic entering and exiting Iranian ports on April 13 at 10 a.m. ET, following a proclamation by President Donald Trump.
>>24494078 Andrew Leyden - The @POTUS returned to the White House after a weekend in Florida where he announced a new blockade of the Straights of Hormuz.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
>>24493472 ICYMI: Eric Swalwell 'suspends' California gubernatorial campaign amid sexual misconduct allegations
>>24493515 Support Grows in Congress to Remove Rep. Eric Swalwell
>>24493537 Swalwell denied a claim that Attorney General Pam Bondi was fired for leaking information to him about a decade-old investigation into his relationship with an alleged Chinese spy (last Thurs)
>>24493486 Musk responds to Swalwell's announcement
>>24493509 JUST IN - Elon Musk says Soros Organization has taken over Hungary after election results
- - - - - - - - - - - -
>>24493465 Treasury, IRS Propose Rules For 1 Percent Remittance Tax On Some Money Sent To Foreign Countries
>>24493478 Mamdani to announce new city-owned grocery store during 100-day speech
>>24493482 Massachusetts Dems Advance Bill To Limit How Far You Can Drive In Your Own Car
>>24493512 For aging US Supreme Court justices, the politics of retirement looms large
>>24493580 Okay Ben Roberts-Smith but what of Australians fighting for the IDF?
>>24493729 Hemp Cars: Are Hemp-Based Fuel and Plastic the Future?
>>24493739 China's REE Empire: only possible due to lax environmental regs
>>24493741 Sperry: Tomorrow I'm told almost 400 pages of long-secret documents newly declassified by DNI Tulsi Gabbard will be released that will reveal evidence of an Intelligence Community conspiracy to dirty-up President Trump ... developing ...
>>24493764, >>24493771 Musk: Each cross is a white farmer murdered in S Africa
>>24493767 What Hungarian election results mean for Israel
>>24493794 Katie Porter and influencer behind Swalwell allegations "don't have a relationship to speak of," campaign says (CBS)
>>24493864 Reminder from Mar 2026: CDC Buried COVID Vaccine Death Data in Lancet Study
>>24493881 Mark Levin: "MAGA, Conservatism, and Republicanism" is "not about anti-Semitism and isolationism"
>>24493914 A recent study shows that US students use their phones an average of 64 times per school day ruining concentration and cognitive abilities
>>24493918 UK seeks to jail Palestine Action for 'terrorism' amid UK media blackout
>>24494037 Ukraine tried to attack Russian space base during Starlink rival launch – Roscosmos chief
>>24494045 Mass resignations in Victorian government, as three Ministers quit
>>24494107 #29870
#24496230 at 2026-04-13 20:31:04 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #29874: Iran's Navy - 158 ships laying bottom of the sea DESTROYED Edition
#29870 >>24493289
>>24493597 Iran has a 'very difficult' decision to make: Mike Pompeo
>>24493664 Biased anti-Trump report of Trump's supposed plans (KEK)
>>24493674 Analysis: 1/10 The U.S. naval blockade of the Strait of Hormuz would cost Iran approximately $276M/day in lost exports and disrupt $159M/day in imports, a combined economic damage of ~$435M/day, or $13B/month.
>>24493691 RT claim: The UK will not take part in President Trump's planned blockade of Iran-linked vessels in the Strait of Hormuz
>>24493697 Map if Europe/Middle East showing "all assets still in theater…non-stop resupply trains…"
>>24493911, >>24493955, >>24493957, >>24493945 Anons discuss what Trump really said about Strait of Hormuz
>>24493973, >>24493451 CENTCOM says American forces will begin implementing a blockade of maritime traffic entering and exiting Iranian ports on April 13 at 10 a.m. ET, following a proclamation by President Donald Trump.
>>24494078 Andrew Leyden - The @POTUS returned to the White House after a weekend in Florida where he announced a new blockade of the Straights of Hormuz.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
>>24493472 ICYMI: Eric Swalwell 'suspends' California gubernatorial campaign amid sexual misconduct allegations
>>24493515 Support Grows in Congress to Remove Rep. Eric Swalwell
>>24493537 Swalwell denied a claim that Attorney General Pam Bondi was fired for leaking information to him about a decade-old investigation into his relationship with an alleged Chinese spy (last Thurs)
>>24493486 Musk responds to Swalwell's announcement
>>24493509 JUST IN - Elon Musk says Soros Organization has taken over Hungary after election results
- - - - - - - - - - - -
>>24493465 Treasury, IRS Propose Rules For 1 Percent Remittance Tax On Some Money Sent To Foreign Countries
>>24493478 Mamdani to announce new city-owned grocery store during 100-day speech
>>24493482 Massachusetts Dems Advance Bill To Limit How Far You Can Drive In Your Own Car
>>24493512 For aging US Supreme Court justices, the politics of retirement looms large
>>24493580 Okay Ben Roberts-Smith but what of Australians fighting for the IDF?
>>24493729 Hemp Cars: Are Hemp-Based Fuel and Plastic the Future?
>>24493739 China's REE Empire: only possible due to lax environmental regs
>>24493741 Sperry: Tomorrow I'm told almost 400 pages of long-secret documents newly declassified by DNI Tulsi Gabbard will be released that will reveal evidence of an Intelligence Community conspiracy to dirty-up President Trump ... developing ...
>>24493764, >>24493771 Musk: Each cross is a white farmer murdered in S Africa
>>24493767 What Hungarian election results mean for Israel
>>24493794 Katie Porter and influencer behind Swalwell allegations "don't have a relationship to speak of," campaign says (CBS)
>>24493864 Reminder from Mar 2026: CDC Buried COVID Vaccine Death Data in Lancet Study
>>24493881 Mark Levin: "MAGA, Conservatism, and Republicanism" is "not about anti-Semitism and isolationism"
>>24493914 A recent study shows that US students use their phones an average of 64 times per school day ruining concentration and cognitive abilities
>>24493918 UK seeks to jail Palestine Action for 'terrorism' amid UK media blackout
>>24494037 Ukraine tried to attack Russian space base during Starlink rival launch – Roscosmos chief
>>24494045 Mass resignations in Victorian government, as three Ministers quit
>>24494107 #29870
Previous Notables
>>24492437 #29868, >>24493500 #29869
>>24490045 #29865, >>24490771 #29866, >>24491589 #29867
>>24488104 #29862, >>24488578 #29863, >>24489446 #29864
>>24485709 #29859, >>24486558 #29860, >>24487333 #29861
Aggregators: qresear.ch | qnotables.com | qproofs.com | Qlock.neocities.org
Q Research Notables Archive Board >>>/qnotables/
Q Research Notables #31: No Noise. No Mercy. To the END. >>24293748
This is a useful tool for doing research. Thank you to the opensource developers that worked on it. Let's do some digging.
To file a DMCA takedown notice or abuse report, please email reporting@isitwetyet.com.
#24495347 at 2026-04-13 16:24:41 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #29873: "Healer" Post Now Deleted, Pope Troll Complete Edition
International Q Research Threads
>>24354649 Australia #45
>>22975806 Brazil #2
>>24441319 Canada #91
>>21284558 France #8
>>22976021 Germany #108
>>23176389 Japan #28
>>23118337 Nederland #11
>>22976797 QAJF #3
>>24355994 Scotland #14
>>21699204 Singapore #1
>>22970962 South Africa #14
>>22753901 UK #52
GLOBALS
KNOW YOUR BUNKER: https://endchan.org/qrbunker/catalog.html
Baking Tools & Guidelines: >>17322509, >>19089065
Posting Guidelines etc. for Anons: >>20022853
PROTO Instructions & Troubleshooting >>18024378, >>18561054, >>21587855
Pastebins: fullchan.net | pastebin.us | privatebin.io | controlc.com
Why some breads get baked earlier than @751: >>24311595
@Jimwatkins Would you pray with me? >>24362873
WHAT TO DO if you get an error message about illegal content when trying to post ordinary images on QR >>24468436
IF 8kun.top is DOWN, try 8ch.net >>24477887
Please Support #8KUN
Jim Watkins email: jimwatkins007@pm.me
Follow The Owner: Jim Watkins https://x.com/Jimwatkins
Bookmark Watkins Report: https://watkinsreport.com/
Advertise Here: ads@isitwetyet.com
Donate Bitcoin: 1KiJD44WeWKaDb4Newr7bDXadtGn21ACqY
Proto Membership: https://shop.isitwetyet.com/p/Proto-membership/ (Coin Accepted)
Send Anonymous Money Orders: Is It Wet Yet, Inc at 2118 Wilshire Blvd #403 Santa Monica, CA. 90403
Buy Merchandise: (Coin Accepted)
- https://shop.isitwetyet.com/ (proto levels / donations)
- https://shoppers.isitwetyet.com/ (misc.)
- https://goodstuffcoffee.com/8kuncoffee/ (covfefe)
ANONS: Stay positive, Eyes on the GOAL, not the OBSTACLES
NOTABLES ARE NOT ENDORSEMENTS
#29872 >>24494555
>>24494970 12:00 PM EDT LIVE: White House News: President Trump's Blockade in Iran, VP Visits Pakistan, and More - 4/13/26
- - - - - - - - - - - - -
>>24494899, >>24495164 @realDonaldTrump Iran's Navy is laying at the bottom of the sea, completely obliterated - 158 ships. What we have not hit are their small number of, what they call, "fast attack ships," because we did not consider them much of a threat. Warning: If any of these ships come anywhere close to our BLOCKADE, they will be immediately ELIMINATED, using the same system of kill that we use against the drug dealers on boats at Sea. It is quick and brutal. P.S. 98.2% of Drugs coming into the U.S. by Ocean or Sea have STOPPED! Thank you for your attention to this matter. President DJT
>>24494839 Today in Q Post History we have - 03 Deltas and 03 Posts that mention today's date of April 13
>>24494562 9:00 AM EDT Secretary Marco Rubio meets with Finnish Foreign Minister Elina Valtonen
>>24494565 3rd IMF-IOSCO Conference on Market-Based Finance
>>24494573 Coverage of the rendezvous and capture of NASA's Northrop Grumman CRS-24 mission at the International Space Station
>>24494597 Ursula von der Leyen reacts to Hungary's election results: "It is a victory for fundamental freedoms" and says EU should look at the lessons learned like moving "to qualified majority voting in foreign policy... to avoid systemic blockages as we've seen in the past."
>>24494601, >>24494612, >>24494622, >>24494650 Pope Leo says he doesn't want to get into it with Trump
>>24494636 The Vatican is two weeks away from developing a nuclear weapon. For The Keks!
>>24494617 Pistachio prices surge to an eight-year high amid supply disruptions in Iran.
>>24494618 Trump is literally forcing Catholic Church hierachy in the US to come out and loudly complain and attack him because he...
>>24494623 CALL FOR SUPPORT We Got Twitter Bashing
>>24494635 Ahoy The Ship Show - 04/13/2026
>>24494670, >>24494680, >>24494683 Swampenins Stank
>>24494672 Irish Government Caves to Anti-Fuel Tax Protests, Announces Half-Billion Euro Support Package
>>24494677 The Swamp Today posted in End Bunker
>>24494759 British Citizenship Test Now Requires Applicants to Know the Difference Between Eid Al-Fitr and Eid Al-Adha
>>24494773 Telegram's Durov says 'your nudes are safe with us'
>>24494825 Ukraine tried to attack Russian space base during Starlink rival launch – Roscosmos chief
>>24494842 Cardinal Robert McElroy of Washington, D.C. went on 60 Minutes (@60Minutes) tonight and confessed his hate for Trump & love of open borders.
>>24494866 NASA Astronomy Picture of the Day NGC 602 and Beyond
>>24494907, >>24494989 Mamdani mocked Margaret Thatcher's famous warning about socialism during his 100-day address
>>24494951, >>24495051, >>24495200, >>24495222, >>24495238, >>24495262, >>24495286 Space/NASA
>>24494992, >>24495205 Hormuz Blockade: Europe Mobilizing Against the U.S., Not the Iran Regime
>>24495037 Patriotic pub landlord loses appeal to keep giant St George's cross on the side of his venue - after ONE complaint
>>24495059, >>24495079, >>24495186 @C__Herridge NEW RECORDS VIA @DNIGabbard ATKINSON TRANSCRIPTS
>>24495060 Soros has 'taken over' Hungary – Musk
>>24495064 ?? Spanish Prime Minister Pedro S?nchez's wife has been charged with corruption, bribery, and influence peddling
>>24495126 @Southcom A F/A-18E Super Hornet, attached to the "Kestrels" of Strike Fighter Squadron (VFA) 137, prepares to land on the flight deck of the aircraft carrier USS Nimitz (CVN 68) in the Pacific Ocean, April 10, 2026.
>>24495143 @DOWResponse WAR.GOV/JOINTHEFIGHT THAT OTHERS MAY LIVE
>>24495141, >>24495276 Boat Faggin/A ship tracking firm reports 121 empty oil tankers are making their way to the United States...
>>24495160 @WH 2026 Masters Champion, Rory McIlroy ????
>>24495178 'MAY GET ACTIVATED': Chilling new warning on Iranian threat inside US
>>24495208 Trump has removed the Jesus post from the Truth Social.
>>24495227 'FINISH THE JOB': Gulf states CHEERING Trump's new Iran strategy
>>24495252 @CENTCOM USS Tripoli (LHA 7) conducts night flight operations while sailing in the Arabian Sea
>>24495264 Federal Court Strikes Down 158-Year-Old Home Distilling Ban
>>24495292 PF: It appears CP-3243 has crashed after departing La Paz, Bolivia earlier today
>>24495332 U.S. announces a defense partnership with Indonesia.
>>24495335 @25thID This training fuses SEE/SENSE that enables the STRIKE.
>>24495344 #29872
#29871 >>24494121
>>24494135 Aussie: "Drill baby drill" Pauline Hanson says we must become Self-Reliant
>>24494163 The New Modern first female Chief of the Australian Army, Lieutenant General Susan Coyle.
>>24494494 ICYMI: PRESIDENT TRUMP goes hard on POPE LEO: "I'm not a big fan of Pope Leo. A very liberal person and a man that doesn't believe in stopping crime!"
>>24494389 ICYMI: @realDonaldTrump Trump as Healer
>>24494399 Watch LIVE as Nigel Farage and Zia Yusuf reveal the true cost of the Boriswave.
>>24494515 President Trump Speaks to Reporters from Joint Base Andrews - Vid
>>24494453 U.S. to Blockade Ships Entering or Exiting Iranian Ports
>>24494466 The U.S. naval blockade of the Strait of Hormuz would cost Iran approximately $276M/day in lost exports and disrupt $159M/day in imports, a combined economic damage of ~$435M/day, or $13B/month.
>>24494475 Ghalibaf and chief negotiator has mocked the US plan to blockade the Strait of Hormuz, warning Americans they may soon long for today's fuel
>>24494498, >>24494530 As we were passing through a Haitian street market in the Dominican Republic, we noticed a bag of rice from USAID.
>>24494528 The Knights Templar Order and its ruling Council demand that this offensive and blasphemous image be removed forthwith !
>>24494545 Billionaire Kicks Swalwell Out of Mansion, Wants $1M in Donations Back Following Rape Allegations
>>24494551 #29871
#29870 >>24493289
>>24493597 Iran has a 'very difficult' decision to make: Mike Pompeo
>>24493664 Biased anti-Trump report of Trump's supposed plans (KEK)
>>24493674 Analysis: 1/10 The U.S. naval blockade of the Strait of Hormuz would cost Iran approximately $276M/day in lost exports and disrupt $159M/day in imports, a combined economic damage of ~$435M/day, or $13B/month.
>>24493691 RT claim: The UK will not take part in President Trump's planned blockade of Iran-linked vessels in the Strait of Hormuz
>>24493697 Map if Europe/Middle East showing "all assets still in theater…non-stop resupply trains…"
>>24493911, >>24493955, >>24493957, >>24493945 Anons discuss what Trump really said about Strait of Hormuz
>>24493973, >>24493451 CENTCOM says American forces will begin implementing a blockade of maritime traffic entering and exiting Iranian ports on April 13 at 10 a.m. ET, following a proclamation by President Donald Trump.
>>24494078 Andrew Leyden - The @POTUS returned to the White House after a weekend in Florida where he announced a new blockade of the Straights of Hormuz.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
>>24493472 ICYMI: Eric Swalwell 'suspends' California gubernatorial campaign amid sexual misconduct allegations
>>24493515 Support Grows in Congress to Remove Rep. Eric Swalwell
>>24493537 Swalwell denied a claim that Attorney General Pam Bondi was fired for leaking information to him about a decade-old investigation into his relationship with an alleged Chinese spy (last Thurs)
>>24493486 Musk responds to Swalwell's announcement
>>24493509 JUST IN - Elon Musk says Soros Organization has taken over Hungary after election results
- - - - - - - - - - - -
>>24493465 Treasury, IRS Propose Rules For 1 Percent Remittance Tax On Some Money Sent To Foreign Countries
>>24493478 Mamdani to announce new city-owned grocery store during 100-day speech
>>24493482 Massachusetts Dems Advance Bill To Limit How Far You Can Drive In Your Own Car
>>24493512 For aging US Supreme Court justices, the politics of retirement looms large
>>24493580 Okay Ben Roberts-Smith but what of Australians fighting for the IDF?
>>24493729 Hemp Cars: Are Hemp-Based Fuel and Plastic the Future?
>>24493739 China's REE Empire: only possible due to lax environmental regs
>>24493741 Sperry: Tomorrow I'm told almost 400 pages of long-secret documents newly declassified by DNI Tulsi Gabbard will be released that will reveal evidence of an Intelligence Community conspiracy to dirty-up President Trump ... developing ...
>>24493764, >>24493771 Musk: Each cross is a white farmer murdered in S Africa
>>24493767 What Hungarian election results mean for Israel
>>24493794 Katie Porter and influencer behind Swalwell allegations "don't have a relationship to speak of," campaign says (CBS)
>>24493864 Reminder from Mar 2026: CDC Buried COVID Vaccine Death Data in Lancet Study
>>24493881 Mark Levin: "MAGA, Conservatism, and Republicanism" is "not about anti-Semitism and isolationism"
>>24493914 A recent study shows that US students use their phones an average of 64 times per school day ruining concentration and cognitive abilities
>>24493918 UK seeks to jail Palestine Action for 'terrorism' amid UK media blackout
>>24494037 Ukraine tried to attack Russian space base during Starlink rival launch – Roscosmos chief
>>24494045 Mass resignations in Victorian government, as three Ministers quit
>>24494107 #29870
Previous Notables
>>24492437 #29868, >>24493500 #29869
>>24490045 #29865, >>24490771 #29866, >>24491589 #29867
>>24488104 #29862, >>24488578 #29863, >>24489446 #29864
>>24485709 #29859, >>24486558 #29860, >>24487333 #29861
Aggregators: qresear.ch | qnotables.com | qproofs.com | Qlock.neocities.org
Q Research Notables Archive Board >>>/qnotables/
Q Research Notables #31: No Noise. No Mercy. To the END. >>24293748
#24494553 at 2026-04-13 12:36:16 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #29872: GM Moab Panic Monday: Blockade "NO DEALS" Ultimatum Edition
International Q Research Threads
>>24354649 Australia #45
>>22975806 Brazil #2
>>24441319 Canada #91
>>21284558 France #8
>>22976021 Germany #108
>>23176389 Japan #28
>>23118337 Nederland #11
>>22976797 QAJF #3
>>24355994 Scotland #14
>>21699204 Singapore #1
>>22970962 South Africa #14
>>22753901 UK #52
GLOBALS
KNOW YOUR BUNKER: https://endchan.org/qrbunker/catalog.html
Baking Tools & Guidelines: >>17322509, >>19089065
Posting Guidelines etc. for Anons: >>20022853
PROTO Instructions & Troubleshooting >>18024378, >>18561054, >>21587855
Pastebins: fullchan.net | pastebin.us | privatebin.io | controlc.com
Why some breads get baked earlier than @751: >>24311595
@Jimwatkins Would you pray with me? >>24362873
WHAT TO DO if you get an error message about illegal content when trying to post ordinary images on QR >>24468436
IF 8kun.top is DOWN, try 8ch.net >>24477887
Please Support #8KUN
Jim Watkins email: jimwatkins007@pm.me
Follow The Owner: Jim Watkins https://x.com/Jimwatkins
Bookmark Watkins Report: https://watkinsreport.com/
Advertise Here: ads@isitwetyet.com
Donate Bitcoin: 1KiJD44WeWKaDb4Newr7bDXadtGn21ACqY
Proto Membership: https://shop.isitwetyet.com/p/Proto-membership/ (Coin Accepted)
Send Anonymous Money Orders: Is It Wet Yet, Inc at 2118 Wilshire Blvd #403 Santa Monica, CA. 90403
Buy Merchandise: (Coin Accepted)
- https://shop.isitwetyet.com/ (proto levels / donations)
- https://shoppers.isitwetyet.com/ (misc.)
- https://goodstuffcoffee.com/8kuncoffee/ (covfefe)
ANONS: Stay positive, Eyes on the GOAL, not the OBSTACLES
NOTABLES ARE NOT ENDORSEMENTS
#29871 >>24494121
>>24494135 Aussie: "Drill baby drill" Pauline Hanson says we must become Self-Reliant
>>24494163 The New Modern first female Chief of the Australian Army, Lieutenant General Susan Coyle.
>>24494494 ICYMI: PRESIDENT TRUMP goes hard on POPE LEO: "I'm not a big fan of Pope Leo. A very liberal person and a man that doesn't believe in stopping crime!"
>>24494389 ICYMI: @realDonaldTrump Trump as Healer
>>24494399 Watch LIVE as Nigel Farage and Zia Yusuf reveal the true cost of the Boriswave.
>>24494515 President Trump Speaks to Reporters from Joint Base Andrews - Vid
>>24494453 U.S. to Blockade Ships Entering or Exiting Iranian Ports
>>24494466 The U.S. naval blockade of the Strait of Hormuz would cost Iran approximately $276M/day in lost exports and disrupt $159M/day in imports, a combined economic damage of ~$435M/day, or $13B/month.
>>24494475 Ghalibaf and chief negotiator has mocked the US plan to blockade the Strait of Hormuz, warning Americans they may soon long for today's fuel
>>24494498, >>24494530 As we were passing through a Haitian street market in the Dominican Republic, we noticed a bag of rice from USAID.
>>24494528 The Knights Templar Order and its ruling Council demand that this offensive and blasphemous image be removed forthwith !
>>24494545 Billionaire Kicks Swalwell Out of Mansion, Wants $1M in Donations Back Following Rape Allegations
>>24494551 #29871
#29870 >>24493289
>>24493597 Iran has a 'very difficult' decision to make: Mike Pompeo
>>24493664 Biased anti-Trump report of Trump's supposed plans (KEK)
>>24493674 Analysis: 1/10 The U.S. naval blockade of the Strait of Hormuz would cost Iran approximately $276M/day in lost exports and disrupt $159M/day in imports, a combined economic damage of ~$435M/day, or $13B/month.
>>24493691 RT claim: The UK will not take part in President Trump's planned blockade of Iran-linked vessels in the Strait of Hormuz
>>24493697 Map if Europe/Middle East showing "all assets still in theater…non-stop resupply trains…"
>>24493911, >>24493955, >>24493957, >>24493945 Anons discuss what Trump really said about Strait of Hormuz
>>24493973, >>24493451 CENTCOM says American forces will begin implementing a blockade of maritime traffic entering and exiting Iranian ports on April 13 at 10 a.m. ET, following a proclamation by President Donald Trump.
>>24494078 Andrew Leyden - The @POTUS returned to the White House after a weekend in Florida where he announced a new blockade of the Straights of Hormuz.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
>>24493472 ICYMI: Eric Swalwell 'suspends' California gubernatorial campaign amid sexual misconduct allegations
>>24493515 Support Grows in Congress to Remove Rep. Eric Swalwell
>>24493537 Swalwell denied a claim that Attorney General Pam Bondi was fired for leaking information to him about a decade-old investigation into his relationship with an alleged Chinese spy (last Thurs)
>>24493486 Musk responds to Swalwell's announcement
>>24493509 JUST IN - Elon Musk says Soros Organization has taken over Hungary after election results
- - - - - - - - - - - -
>>24493465 Treasury, IRS Propose Rules For 1 Percent Remittance Tax On Some Money Sent To Foreign Countries
>>24493478 Mamdani to announce new city-owned grocery store during 100-day speech
>>24493482 Massachusetts Dems Advance Bill To Limit How Far You Can Drive In Your Own Car
>>24493512 For aging US Supreme Court justices, the politics of retirement looms large
>>24493580 Okay Ben Roberts-Smith but what of Australians fighting for the IDF?
>>24493729 Hemp Cars: Are Hemp-Based Fuel and Plastic the Future?
>>24493739 China's REE Empire: only possible due to lax environmental regs
>>24493741 Sperry: Tomorrow I'm told almost 400 pages of long-secret documents newly declassified by DNI Tulsi Gabbard will be released that will reveal evidence of an Intelligence Community conspiracy to dirty-up President Trump ... developing ...
>>24493764, >>24493771 Musk: Each cross is a white farmer murdered in S Africa
>>24493767 What Hungarian election results mean for Israel
>>24493794 Katie Porter and influencer behind Swalwell allegations "don't have a relationship to speak of," campaign says (CBS)
>>24493864 Reminder from Mar 2026: CDC Buried COVID Vaccine Death Data in Lancet Study
>>24493881 Mark Levin: "MAGA, Conservatism, and Republicanism" is "not about anti-Semitism and isolationism"
>>24493914 A recent study shows that US students use their phones an average of 64 times per school day ruining concentration and cognitive abilities
>>24493918 UK seeks to jail Palestine Action for 'terrorism' amid UK media blackout
>>24494037 Ukraine tried to attack Russian space base during Starlink rival launch – Roscosmos chief
>>24494045 Mass resignations in Victorian government, as three Ministers quit
>>24494107 #29870
#29869 >>24492489
>>24493411 @realDonaldTrump Pope Leo is WEAK on Crime, and terrible for Foreign Policy. He talks about "fear" of the Trump Administration, but doesn't mention the FEAR that the Catholic Church, and all other Christian Organizations, had during COVID when they were arresting priests, ministers, and everybody else, for holding Church Services, even when going outside, and being ten and even twenty feet apart. I like his brother Louis much better than I like him, because Louis is all MAGA. He gets it, and Leo doesn't! I don't want a Pope who thinks it's OK for Iran to have a Nuclear Weapon. I don't want a Pope who thinks it's terrible that America attacked Venezuela, a Country that was sending massive amounts of Drugs into the United States and, even worse, emptying their prisons, including murderers, drug dealers, and killers, into our Country. And I don't want a Pope who criticizes the President of the United States because I'm doing exactly what I was elected, IN A LANDSLIDE, to do, setting Record Low Numbers in Crime, and creating the Greatest Stock Market in History. Leo should be thankful because, as everyone knows, he was a shocking surprise. He wasn't on any list to be Pope, and was only put there by the Church because he was an American, and they thought that would be the best way to deal with President Donald J. Trump. If I wasn't in the White House, Leo wouldn't be in the Vatican. Unfortunately, Leo's Weak on Crime, Weak on Nuclear Weapons, does not sit well with me, nor does the fact that he meets with Obama Sympathizers like David Axelrod, a LOSER from the Left, who is one of those who wanted churchgoers and clerics to be arrested. Leo should get his act together as Pope, use Common Sense, stop catering to the Radical Left, and focus on being a Great Pope, not a Politician. It's hurting him very badly and, more importantly, it's hurting the Catholic Church! President DONALD J. TRUMP
>>24493209 @realDonaldTrump Congratulations to Paulo Costa on a Great UFC Fight last night in Miami. He will absolutely be a future Champion. It was great talking to him outside the ring after his Big Victory last night in Miami! President DONALD J. TRUMP
>>24492526 @USSpaceForce From Monitoring to Maneuvering: Bounty Hunter and the USSF Shift to active defense
>>24492545 Peter Magyar: 10 key facts to know about next Hungary PM after Viktor Orban concedes
>>24492732, >>24492819, >>24493007 Viktor Orban LOSES Hungary election after 16 years in power
>>24492580, >>24492584, >>24492597 8Ch.net is currently down - 8kun.top is up and working
>>24492601 JUST IN: ?? Switzerland offers to mediate between US and Iran to end the war.
>>24492612 @vonderleyen gloats - The Union grows stronger. Hungary has chosen Europe.
>>24492632 Swalwell staffers in unsigned statement: 'We're horrified' by accusations
>>24492639 Sunday Morning Futures with Maria Bartiromo - POTUS calls in - 4/12/26 FULL SHOW 41 minutes
>>24492648 CENTCOM announces that a blockade of all maritime traffic entering and exiting Iranian ports will begin on April 13 at 10 a.m. ET.
>>24492687 Massachusetts Dems Advance Bill To Limit How Far You Can Drive In Your Own Car
>>24492854, >>24492858 NBC - Details and takeaways on Vance-led negotiations in Islamabad
>>24492880 Ali Nikzad "The world will experience a new form of management in the Strait of Hormuz"
>>24492904 Youtube just suspended Goldie Ghamari's Iran Revolution livestreaming while they were live Day 106
>>24492904 IRAN REVOLUTION LIVE WITH IRANIAN HOSTS GOLDIE AND ARMIN: DAY 106 Rumble Live
>>24492950, >>24492972, >>24493013, >>24493026 Iran Int'l Updates mocking US naval blockade
>>24493021, >>24493025 5 teaching hospitals in Tx require all students to get a Covid shot, Dr Bowden providing exemptions AND a lawyer if it's denied
>>24493044 CENTCOM: blockade of maritime traffic to Iranian ports begins Monday 10 AM EASTERN
>>24493081 Cut off The Money – U.S Military Will Start Enforcing Embargo of Product No One is Supposed to be Buying
>>24493127 ELIMINATING RISK': US minesweepers head to the Strait of Hormuz
>>24493160 Trump gives MAJOR ultimatum to Iran amid high-stakes talks: 'I WANT EVERYTHING'
>>24493194 'SICK AND DISGUSTING': Dem reacts to bombshell Swalwell allegations(The other pervert points his finger at the current pervert)
>>24493204, >>24493210, >>24493216 ??The new Hungarian leader delivered a victory speech.
>>24493265 MAMDANI: "There are many who use 'socialist' as a dirty word ... but we will not be ashamed"
>>24493281, >>24493283 ICYMI: A truce for the world, a reckoning for Iran's economy
>>24493311 NATO's Double Standard on Iran, Europe's Drift, and the Fraud Crisis at Home | Victor Davis Hanson
>>24493315 Iran played its biggest card and the main result is that the United States became the world's emergency gas station and China's cheap energy subsidy evaporated.
>>24493368 Skyhorse Publishing to start a new imprint in partnership with Tucker Carlson
>>24493500 #29869 posted in 29870
Previous Notables
>>24492437 #29868
>>24490045 #29865, >>24490771 #29866, >>24491589 #29867
>>24488104 #29862, >>24488578 #29863, >>24489446 #29864
>>24485709 #29859, >>24486558 #29860, >>24487333 #29861
Aggregators: qresear.ch | qnotables.com | qproofs.com | Qlock.neocities.org
Q Research Notables Archive Board >>>/qnotables/
Q Research Notables #31: No Noise. No Mercy. To the END. >>24293748
#24494113 at 2026-04-13 05:10:54 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #29871: Baker Crossin' His Fingers, Server Be Good! Edition
International Q Research Threads
>>24354649 Australia #45
>>22975806 Brazil #2
>>24441319 Canada #91
>>21284558 France #8
>>22976021 Germany #108
>>23176389 Japan #28
>>23118337 Nederland #11
>>22976797 QAJF #3
>>24355994 Scotland #14
>>21699204 Singapore #1
>>22970962 South Africa #14
>>22753901 UK #52
GLOBALS
KNOW YOUR BUNKER: https://endchan.org/qrbunker/catalog.html
Baking Tools & Guidelines: >>17322509, >>19089065
Posting Guidelines etc. for Anons: >>20022853
PROTO Instructions & Troubleshooting >>18024378, >>18561054, >>21587855
Pastebins: fullchan.net | pastebin.us | privatebin.io | controlc.com
Why some breads get baked earlier than @751: >>24311595
@Jimwatkins Would you pray with me? >>24362873
WHAT TO DO if you get an error message about illegal content when trying to post ordinary images on QR >>24468436
IF 8kun.top is DOWN, try 8ch.net >>24477887
Please Support #8KUN
Jim Watkins email: jimwatkins007@pm.me
Follow The Owner: Jim Watkins https://x.com/Jimwatkins
Bookmark Watkins Report: https://watkinsreport.com/
Advertise Here: ads@isitwetyet.com
Donate Bitcoin: 1KiJD44WeWKaDb4Newr7bDXadtGn21ACqY
Proto Membership: https://shop.isitwetyet.com/p/Proto-membership/ (Coin Accepted)
Send Anonymous Money Orders: Is It Wet Yet, Inc at 2118 Wilshire Blvd #403 Santa Monica, CA. 90403
Buy Merchandise: (Coin Accepted)
- https://shop.isitwetyet.com/ (proto levels / donations)
- https://shoppers.isitwetyet.com/ (misc.)
- https://goodstuffcoffee.com/8kuncoffee/ (covfefe)
ANONS: Stay positive, Eyes on the GOAL, not the OBSTACLES
NOTABLES ARE NOT ENDORSEMENTS
#29870 >>24493289
>>24493597 Iran has a 'very difficult' decision to make: Mike Pompeo
>>24493664 Biased anti-Trump report of Trump's supposed plans (KEK)
>>24493674 Analysis: 1/10 The U.S. naval blockade of the Strait of Hormuz would cost Iran approximately $276M/day in lost exports and disrupt $159M/day in imports, a combined economic damage of ~$435M/day, or $13B/month.
>>24493691 RT claim: The UK will not take part in President Trump's planned blockade of Iran-linked vessels in the Strait of Hormuz
>>24493697 Map if Europe/Middle East showing "all assets still in theater…non-stop resupply trains…"
>>24493911, >>24493955, >>24493957, >>24493945 Anons discuss what Trump really said about Strait of Hormuz
>>24493973, >>24493451 CENTCOM says American forces will begin implementing a blockade of maritime traffic entering and exiting Iranian ports on April 13 at 10 a.m. ET, following a proclamation by President Donald Trump.
>>24494078 Andrew Leyden - The @POTUS returned to the White House after a weekend in Florida where he announced a new blockade of the Straights of Hormuz.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
>>24493472 ICYMI: Eric Swalwell 'suspends' California gubernatorial campaign amid sexual misconduct allegations
>>24493515 Support Grows in Congress to Remove Rep. Eric Swalwell
>>24493537 Swalwell denied a claim that Attorney General Pam Bondi was fired for leaking information to him about a decade-old investigation into his relationship with an alleged Chinese spy (last Thurs)
>>24493486 Musk responds to Swalwell's announcement
>>24493509 JUST IN - Elon Musk says Soros Organization has taken over Hungary after election results
- - - - - - - - - - - -
>>24493465 Treasury, IRS Propose Rules For 1 Percent Remittance Tax On Some Money Sent To Foreign Countries
>>24493478 Mamdani to announce new city-owned grocery store during 100-day speech
>>24493482 Massachusetts Dems Advance Bill To Limit How Far You Can Drive In Your Own Car
>>24493512 For aging US Supreme Court justices, the politics of retirement looms large
>>24493580 Okay Ben Roberts-Smith but what of Australians fighting for the IDF?
>>24493729 Hemp Cars: Are Hemp-Based Fuel and Plastic the Future?
>>24493739 China's REE Empire: only possible due to lax environmental regs
>>24493741 Sperry: Tomorrow I'm told almost 400 pages of long-secret documents newly declassified by DNI Tulsi Gabbard will be released that will reveal evidence of an Intelligence Community conspiracy to dirty-up President Trump ... developing ...
>>24493764, >>24493771 Musk: Each cross is a white farmer murdered in S Africa
>>24493767 What Hungarian election results mean for Israel
>>24493794 Katie Porter and influencer behind Swalwell allegations "don't have a relationship to speak of," campaign says (CBS)
>>24493864 Reminder from Mar 2026: CDC Buried COVID Vaccine Death Data in Lancet Study
>>24493881 Mark Levin: "MAGA, Conservatism, and Republicanism" is "not about anti-Semitism and isolationism"
>>24493914 A recent study shows that US students use their phones an average of 64 times per school day ruining concentration and cognitive abilities
>>24493918 UK seeks to jail Palestine Action for 'terrorism' amid UK media blackout
>>24494037 Ukraine tried to attack Russian space base during Starlink rival launch – Roscosmos chief
>>24494045 Mass resignations in Victorian government, as three Ministers quit
>>24494107 #29870
#24494107 at 2026-04-13 05:09:07 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #29870: Third Time's the Charm Edition
#29870 >>24493289
>>24493597 Iran has a 'very difficult' decision to make: Mike Pompeo
>>24493664 Biased anti-Trump report of Trump's supposed plans (KEK)
>>24493674 Analysis: 1/10 The U.S. naval blockade of the Strait of Hormuz would cost Iran approximately $276M/day in lost exports and disrupt $159M/day in imports, a combined economic damage of ~$435M/day, or $13B/month.
>>24493691 RT claim: The UK will not take part in President Trump's planned blockade of Iran-linked vessels in the Strait of Hormuz
>>24493697 Map if Europe/Middle East showing "all assets still in theater…non-stop resupply trains…"
>>24493911, >>24493955, >>24493957, >>24493945 Anons discuss what Trump really said about Strait of Hormuz
>>24493973, >>24493451 CENTCOM says American forces will begin implementing a blockade of maritime traffic entering and exiting Iranian ports on April 13 at 10 a.m. ET, following a proclamation by President Donald Trump.
>>24494078 Andrew Leyden - The @POTUS returned to the White House after a weekend in Florida where he announced a new blockade of the Straights of Hormuz.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
>>24493472 ICYMI: Eric Swalwell 'suspends' California gubernatorial campaign amid sexual misconduct allegations
>>24493515 Support Grows in Congress to Remove Rep. Eric Swalwell
>>24493537 Swalwell denied a claim that Attorney General Pam Bondi was fired for leaking information to him about a decade-old investigation into his relationship with an alleged Chinese spy (last Thurs)
>>24493486 Musk responds to Swalwell's announcement
>>24493509 JUST IN - Elon Musk says Soros Organization has taken over Hungary after election results
- - - - - - - - - - - -
>>24493465 Treasury, IRS Propose Rules For 1 Percent Remittance Tax On Some Money Sent To Foreign Countries
>>24493478 Mamdani to announce new city-owned grocery store during 100-day speech
>>24493482 Massachusetts Dems Advance Bill To Limit How Far You Can Drive In Your Own Car
>>24493512 For aging US Supreme Court justices, the politics of retirement looms large
>>24493580 Okay Ben Roberts-Smith but what of Australians fighting for the IDF?
>>24493729 Hemp Cars: Are Hemp-Based Fuel and Plastic the Future?
>>24493739 China's REE Empire: only possible due to lax environmental regs
>>24493741 Sperry: Tomorrow I'm told almost 400 pages of long-secret documents newly declassified by DNI Tulsi Gabbard will be released that will reveal evidence of an Intelligence Community conspiracy to dirty-up President Trump ... developing ...
>>24493764, >>24493771 Musk: Each cross is a white farmer murdered in S Africa
>>24493767 What Hungarian election results mean for Israel
>>24493794 Katie Porter and influencer behind Swalwell allegations "don't have a relationship to speak of," campaign says (CBS)
>>24493864 Reminder from Mar 2026: CDC Buried COVID Vaccine Death Data in Lancet Study
>>24493881 Mark Levin: "MAGA, Conservatism, and Republicanism" is "not about anti-Semitism and isolationism"
>>24493914 A recent study shows that US students use their phones an average of 64 times per school day ruining concentration and cognitive abilities
>>24493918 UK seeks to jail Palestine Action for 'terrorism' amid UK media blackout
>>24494037 Ukraine tried to attack Russian space base during Starlink rival launch – Roscosmos chief
>>24494045 Mass resignations in Victorian government, as three Ministers quit
#29870
FINAL
#24493942 at 2026-04-13 04:22:22 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #29870: Third Time's the Charm Edition
#29870 >>24493289 @400
>>24493472 ICYMI: Eric Swalwell 'suspends' California gubernatorial campaign amid sexual misconduct allegations
>>24493515 Support Grows in Congress to Remove Rep. Eric Swalwell
>>24493537 Swalwell denied a claim that Attorney General Pam Bondi was fired for leaking information to him about a decade-old investigation into his relationship with an alleged Chinese spy (last Thurs)
>>24493486 Musk responds to Swalwell's announcement
>>24493509 JUST IN - Elon Musk says Soros Organization has taken over Hungary after election results
- - - - - - - - - -
>>24493465 Treasury, IRS Propose Rules For 1 Percent Remittance Tax On Some Money Sent To Foreign Countries
>>24493478 Mamdani to announce new city-owned grocery store during 100-day speech
>>24493482 Massachusetts Dems Advance Bill To Limit How Far You Can Drive In Your Own Car
>>24493512 For aging US Supreme Court justices, the politics of retirement looms large
>>24493580 Okay Ben Roberts-Smith but what of Australians fighting for the IDF?
>>24493597 Iran has a 'very difficult' decision to make: Mike Pompeo
>>24493664 Biased anti-Trump report of Trump's supposed plans (KEK)
>>24493674 Analysis: 1/10 The U.S. naval blockade of the Strait of Hormuz would cost Iran approximately $276M/day in lost exports and disrupt $159M/day in imports, a combined economic damage of ~$435M/day, or $13B/month.
>>24493691 RT claim: The UK will not take part in President Trump's planned blockade of Iran-linked vessels in the Strait of Hormuz
>>24493697 Map if Europe/Middle East showing "all assets still in theater…non-stop resupply trains…"
>>24493729 Hemp Cars: Are Hemp-Based Fuel and Plastic the Future?
>>24493739 China's REE Empire: only possible due to lax environmental regs
>>24493741 Sperry: Tomorrow I'm told almost 400 pages of long-secret documents newly declassified by DNI Tulsi Gabbard will be released that will reveal evidence of an Intelligence Community conspiracy to dirty-up President Trump ... developing ...
>>24493764, >>24493771 Musk: Each cross is a white farmer murdered in S Africa
>>24493767 What Hungarian election results mean for Israel
>>24493794 Katie Porter and influencer behind Swalwell allegations "don't have a relationship to speak of," campaign says (CBS)
>>24493864 Reminder from Mar 2026: CDC Buried COVID Vaccine Death Data in Lancet Study
>>24493881 Mark Levin: "MAGA, Conservatism, and Republicanism" is "not about anti-Semitism and isolationism"
>>24493911 Iranians are not blockading their own ports. They are blockading the Hormuz and charging a fee for safe passage. The US will blockade Iranian ports.
>>24493914 A recent study shows that US students use their phones an average of 64 times per school day ruining concentration and cognitive abilities
>>24493918 UK seeks to jail Palestine Action for 'terrorism' amid UK media blackout
#24493824 at 2026-04-13 03:46:13 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #29870: Third Time's the Charm Edition
halfway thru
#29870 >>24493289
>>24493472 ICYMI: Eric Swalwell 'suspends' California gubernatorial campaign amid sexual misconduct allegations
>>24493515 Support Grows in Congress to Remove Rep. Eric Swalwell
>>24493537 Swalwell denied a claim that Attorney General Pam Bondi was fired for leaking information to him about a decade-old investigation into his relationship with an alleged Chinese spy (last Thurs)
>>24493486 Musk responds to Swalwell's announcement
>>24493509 JUST IN - Elon Musk says Soros Organization has taken over Hungary after election results
- - - - - - - - - -
>>24493465 Treasury, IRS Propose Rules For 1 Percent Remittance Tax On Some Money Sent To Foreign Countries
>>24493478 Mamdani to announce new city-owned grocery store during 100-day speech
>>24493482 Massachusetts Dems Advance Bill To Limit How Far You Can Drive In Your Own Car
>>24493512 For aging US Supreme Court justices, the politics of retirement looms large
>>24493580 Okay Ben Roberts-Smith but what of Australians fighting for the IDF?
>>24493597 Iran has a 'very difficult' decision to make: Mike Pompeo
#24493580 at 2026-04-13 02:10:12 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #29870: Third Time's the Charm Edition
Okay Ben Roberts-Smith but what of Australians fighting for the IDF?
A choice has been made to prosecute Ben Roberts-Smith and an Australian militant in Ukraine but not returning IDF soldiers involved in genocide
This publication raised an uncomfortable question in February. It went unanswered. This week, the Australian government made that silence considerably harder to maintain.
On April 7, two Australians were arrested for what they did in foreign conflicts. Same day. Same country. Same federal police force.
Ben Roberts-Smith was taken off a flight at Sydney Airport by AFP officers and charged with five counts of war crime murder over the alleged killing of unarmed Afghan civilians between 2009 and 2012. He is the most decorated soldier this country has produced.
He faces life in prison.
The charges are the product of the Brereton inquiry, a process that ran for years, deployed 54 investigators through the Office of the Special Investigator, and consumed somewhere north of two hundred million dollars of public money.
Two hundred million.
To pursue one man and the broader culture of conduct he allegedly represented.
By nightfall the same day, a 25-year-old army reservist named Vincent Tong-Vuong Tran from Felixstow in Adelaide was in the Adelaide Magistrates Court. His offence was serving as a drone operator for Ukrainian forces from May 2025 until January this year, without federal authorisation.
AFP officers had already raided his home, taken his phone and laptop, and forensically examined the devices. Images on those devices allegedly placed him in a foreign conflict.
He was charged under section 115A of the Defence Act. Twenty years is the maximum sentence. The AFP noted, with some pride, that this was the first time anyone had been charged under this provision.
Where are the IDF charges?
An estimated one thousand former and current soldiers of the Israel Defense Forces are living in Australia. Some of them were in Gaza. The International Court of Justice has found a plausible risk of genocide in that operation.
Not a suspicion. Not an allegation from a protest group.
A formal legal finding from the highest court on earth, accompanied by binding provisional measures. The International Criminal Court is separately pursuing war crimes and crimes against humanity arising from the same conflict.
Vincent Tran had his phone seized within months of returning to Australia. The AFP forensically examined it. They found what they were looking for.
Has a single returned IDF soldier had their phone examined?
Has one been called in for questioning? Has the AFP executed one search warrant? Has the Attorney General issued one referral?
Has anyone in the Albanese government commissioned a legal assessment of whether section 268 of the Criminal Code, the provision that covers genocide and war crimes and applies to Australian citizens regardless of which uniform they wore, has any relevance here?
The answer to every one of those questions is no.
In February, senior human rights lawyer Chris Sidoti stated publicly that Australians who served in Gaza could face criminal liability if genocide or war crimes are established, and that you do not need to have pulled a trigger for liability to attach.
Facilitation is enough. Knowing participation is enough.
The government did not dispute the legal analysis. It simply ignored it and moved on.
https://michaelwest.com.au/okay-Ben-Roberts-Smith-but-what-of-australians-fighting-for-the-idf/
#24477434 at 2026-04-08 01:41:12 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #29848: 2 MORE WEEKS! This will be a double sided CEASEFIRE! CountDownDun Edition
Notables @575
Noter TAPs
#29848 >>24476684
>>24476989, >>24477416 @realDonaldTrump The alleged Statement put out by CNN World News is a FRAUD, as CNN well knows. The false Statement was linked to a Fake News site (from Nigeria) and, of course, immediately picked up by CNN, and blared out as a "legitimate" headline. The Official Statement by Iran was just released, and posted on TRUTH, below. Authorities are looking to determine whether or not a crime was committed on the issuance of the Fake CNN World Statement, or was it a sick rogue player? CNN is being ordered to immediately withdraw this Statement with full apologies for their, as usual, terrible "reporting." Results of the investigation will be announced in the near future. President DONALD J. TRUMP
>>24476889 @realDonaldTrump OFFICIAL STATEMENT OF IRAN:
>>24476712 ICYMI: Ceasefire with Iran
>>24476714 MAHA Leaders Demand EPA Protect Americans From Toxic Chemicals
>>24476778 Orange County Man Pleads Guilty to Orchestrating Fraud Scheme that Submitted Nearly $270 Million in Bogus Claims to Medi-Cal
>>24476798, >>24476800 Call to invoke 25th on Trump
>>24476823 O'Keefe Media Group: Bismarck Obando Press Sec for Newsom's controller admits in OMG undercover recording that fraud is 'EVERYWHERE' in California
>>24476833, >>24476827 Missiles launched from YEMEN'S ANSAR ALLAH toward Israel, moments after 2-week Iran-US-Israeli was ceasefire announced...
>>24476841 Today marks the first conviction under the Take It Down Act - protecting victims from non-consensual AI-generated sexually explicit images, cyberstalking, and threats of violence
>>24476844 U.S. Marshals RAID Home of Former Republican Lobbyist Jim Courtovich
>>24476847 Trey Yingst: What you're seeing is a 'war crime'
>>24476850 Iran has launched another missile barrage toward Israel's Negev
>>24476874 Vance puts Trump on speaker before ROARING Hungarian crowd
>>24476885 Aussie: Gina Rinehart asks how investigation into Ben Roberts-Smith can be 'justified'
>>24476895 X22 Ep 3878b - Sleepers [Pro] Trump,Shift [Nay],[DS] Is About To Lose Everything,Unconditional Surrender
>>24476901 Todd Blanche shares details on anti-fraud efforts
>>24476940 Iraqi Protesters Overrun Kuwait Consulate, Angry Over Role In US Actions
>>24476946, >>24476948 MISSILE WARNINGS ISSUED IN……/live cams
>>24476947 Massive "Treasure Trove" 3,000-Year-Old Silk Road City Discovered In Uzbekistan
>>24476980 Power outages in a number of areas in Kuwait from Iranian strikes
>>24477016 Russia, China Block Hormuz Action at UN as Shipping Crisis Continues
>>24477064 Bret Baier: Here's why Kharg Island matters
>>24477066 8A DOW announcement
>>24477118, >>24477154 found some documents in the Ingersoll Lockwood website hidden easter eggs
>>24477206 'GOOD SURVIVOR': Former A-10 pilot details intense survival training
>>24477261 High-cost coastal housing markets like NYC and Seattle lose Americans each year. Here's how their housing markets absorb it
>>24477331 New Quebec 'secularism' law puts restrictions on public prayer and religious symbols
>>24477390 Trump-Endorsed Clayton Fuller Wins Georgia Special Election to Replace Marjorie Taylor Greene
#24477170 at 2026-04-08 00:48:05 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #29848: 2 MORE WEEKS! This will be a double sided CEASEFIRE! CountDownDun Edition
@460
Noter Notables
#29848 >>24476684
>>24476989 @realDonaldTrump The alleged Statement put out by CNN World News is a FRAUD, as CNN well knows. The false Statement was linked to a Fake News site (from Nigeria) and, of course, immediately picked up by CNN, and blared out as a "legitimate" headline. The Official Statement by Iran was just released, and posted on TRUTH, below. Authorities are looking to determine whether or not a crime was committed on the issuance of the Fake CNN World Statement, or was it a sick rogue player? CNN is being ordered to immediately withdraw this Statement with full apologies for their, as usual, terrible "reporting." Results of the investigation will be announced in the near future. President DONALD J. TRUMP
>>24476889 @realDonaldTrump OFFICIAL STATEMENT OF IRAN:
>>24476712 ICYMI: Ceasefire with Iran
>>24476714 MAHA Leaders Demand EPA Protect Americans From Toxic Chemicals
>>24476778 Orange County Man Pleads Guilty to Orchestrating Fraud Scheme that Submitted Nearly $270 Million in Bogus Claims to Medi-Cal
>>24476798, >>24476800 Call to invoke 25th on Trump
>>24476823 O'Keefe Media Group: Bismarck Obando Press Sec for Newsom's controller admits in OMG undercover recording that fraud is 'EVERYWHERE' in California
>>24476833, >>24476827 Missiles launched from YEMEN'S ANSAR ALLAH toward Israel, moments after 2-week Iran-US-Israeli was ceasefire announced...
>>24476841 Today marks the first conviction under the Take It Down Act - protecting victims from non-consensual AI-generated sexually explicit images, cyberstalking, and threats of violence
>>24476844 U.S. Marshals RAID Home of Former Republican Lobbyist Jim Courtovich
>>24476847 Trey Yingst: What you're seeing is a 'war crime'
>>24476850 Iran has launched another missile barrage toward Israel's Negev
>>24476874 Vance puts Trump on speaker before ROARING Hungarian crowd
>>24476885 Aussie: Gina Rinehart asks how investigation into Ben Roberts-Smith can be 'justified'
>>24476895 X22 Ep 3878b - Sleepers [Pro] Trump,Shift [Nay],[DS] Is About To Lose Everything,Unconditional Surrender
>>24476901 Todd Blanche shares details on anti-fraud efforts
>>24476940 Iraqi Protesters Overrun Kuwait Consulate, Angry Over Role In US Actions
>>24476946, >>24476948 MISSILE WARNINGS ISSUED IN……/live cams
>>24476947 Massive "Treasure Trove" 3,000-Year-Old Silk Road City Discovered In Uzbekistan
>>24476980 Power outages in a number of areas in Kuwait from Iranian strikes
>>24477016 Russia, China Block Hormuz Action at UN as Shipping Crisis Continues
>>24477064 Bret Baier: Here's why Kharg Island matters
>>24477066 8A DOW announcement
>>24477118, >>24477154 found some documents in the Ingersoll Lockwood website hidden easter eggs
#24476329 at 2026-04-07 21:46:07 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #29847: THE ENTIRE WORLD IS WATCHING - Enjoy The Show - DAY 101 Edition
Aussie vet vents on Ben Roberts Smith AUS Afghanistan soldier and his treatment.
#23069950 at 2025-05-22 22:51:50 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #28144: SECURE THE ELECTIONS #MEOW Edition
Kerry Stokes and Channel 7 spend over $50 million to protect some of Australia's vilest criminals
Kerry Stokes and Channel 7 have used a war of law and their media to protect some of the vilest criminals in Australia such as war criminal and murderer Ben Roberts-Smith, rapist Bruce Lehrmann and convicted child abuser former My Kitchen Rules star Claudean Uamaki-Mu.
Ben Roberts-Smith lost his defamation appeal on Friday (16/5/25) and claims he will appeal to the High Court of Australia which I will deal with in a minute. But firstly, lets look at Kerry Stokes' MKR cover-up.
Kerry Stokes' and Channel 7's MKR cover-up
Former My Kitchen Rules star Claudean Uamaki-Mu and her partner Anthony Mu were originally facing more serious charges, which included the rape of a child, and they had their names suppressed in September 2023.
Lawyers for Claudean Uamaki-Mu even sent me a copy of the suppression orders which I published in an article.
It is widely believed that Kerry Stokes' Channel 7 paid for lawyers for Claudean Uamaki-Mu and Anthony Mu to obtain the suppression orders as Stokes and Seven were worried about the fallout and it's impact on their My Kitchen Rules television show.
The suppression orders were lifted on the 30th of April 2025 after Claudean Uamaki-Mu "pleaded guilty to kicking, spitting on and hitting children."
Kerry Stokes' Channel 7 paying for lawyers for the suppression orders to protect Seven and MKR seems to be supported by Claudean Uamaki-Mu saying "she didn't ever want her name suppressed after being charged."
While Claudean Uamaki-Mu and her partner Anthony Mu still face further charges, numerous charges have been dropped. News.com reported on 1/5/25:
Uamaki-Mu is still due to stand trial in the District Court on 12 charges, including unlawful assault occasioning actual bodily harm, indecent treatment and rape, following a committal hearing in January.
Mu is also due to stand trial in the Magistrates Court on a later date.
He is facing eight counts of assault occasioning actual bodily harm (two while in company), two counts of common assault and one count of observations in breach of privacy. (Click here to read more)
Seven West Media shareholders should be asking what Kerry Stokes and Channel 7 are doing paying for lawyers to conceal from the public child abuse crimes by Claudean Uamaki-Mu and assault crimes by Anthony Mu.
Ben Roberts-Smith failed defamation appeal
Kerry Stokes has financed, and controls, Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation case and is up for an estimated $30 to $35 million costs for the original hearing and another $5 million or so for the appeal.
The court published a summary on Friday as per below. They are yet to publish the full judgement likely because the government has to approve it because of some of the evidence given included classified information.
https://kangaroocourtofaustralia.com/2025/05/18/kerry-stokes-and-channel-7-spend-over-50-million-to-protect-some-of-australias-vilest-criminals/
Kerry Stokes is one of the elite pedos named in police records in Aus then covered up by the Howard Government with a 90 year suppression order
#23040128 at 2025-05-16 03:40:56 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #28112: Meddle Recklessly, Reap Consequence Edition
Decorated Australian veteran loses his defamation appeal over killings in Afghanistan
Australia's most decorated living war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith on Friday lost his appeal of a civil court ruling that blamed him for unlawfully killing four Afghans while he served in Afghanistan.
Three federal court judges unanimously rejected his appeal of a judge's ruling in 2023 that Roberts-Smith was not defamed by newspaper articles published in 2018 that accused him of a range of war crimes.
Justice Anthony Besanko had ruled that the accusations were substantially true to a civil standard and Roberts-Smith was responsible for four of the six unlawful deaths he had been accused of.
https://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/decorated-australian-veteran-loses-defamation-appeal-killings-afghanistan-121861951
#19036044 at 2023-06-20 03:28:08 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #23375: GOLD or WTF? Edition
Jacqui Lambie refers ADF leadership to International Criminal Court declaring the top brass 'got a free pass' from war crimes investigations
Senator Jacqui Lambie has revealed in an emotional statement she has referred Australia's top military brass to the International Criminal Court to investigate their "criminal liability" in alleged war crimes.
Senator Jacqui Lambie has sensationally referred Australia's Defence Force leadership to the International Criminal Court.
In an emotionally charged statement to the Senate, the former military officer condemned the "culture of coverup at the highest levels" of the country's military.
Senator Lambie blasted the decision by Major General Paul Brereton to exempt senior defence commanders from his war crimes investigation.
She said as a result, Australia's military leaders "got a free pass while our diggers were thrown under the bus".
As she denounced the previous government for not taking action, Senator Lambie revealed she had referred the matter to the International Criminal Court war crimes prosecutor in The Hague under Article 15.
"This asked him to look at Australia's higher commanders through the lens of command responsibility," Senator Lambie said on Tuesday.
"The law of command responsibility is a method of criminal liability where commanders have failed to do their duty.
"The International Criminal Court is a court of last resort... they can only do this if the state party, in this case Australia, has failed to investigate higher command for their breach of duty.
"Australia has in fact set up two systems of criminality, one for Australia's top military commanders and another for commanders from the rest of the world.
"Quite frankly I feel embarrassed that Australia's in this situation."
During her impassioned plea for the new Labor government to take action, Senator Lambie cited evidence from "multiple sources" outside of the Brereton inquiry including from the recent defamation case of Ben Roberts-Smith in which these sources claimed "the leadership knew".
https://www.skynews.com.au/australia-news/politics/jacqui-lambie-refers-adf-leadership-to-international-criminal-court-declaring-the-top-brass-got-a-free-pass-from-war-crimes-investigations/news-story/f8b04dad4d658975963cb410cbc613cb
#16168277 at 2022-04-28 03:10:00 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #20450: CodeMonkey Debating Edition
Will Kerry Stokes, Ryan Stokes and Seven West Media directors face criminal charges now the first SAS soldier has been arrested?
Kerry Stokes, Ryan Stokes and other Seven West Media directors could be in big trouble as a former SAS soldier has been arrested in Sydney charged with obstructing/hindering/intimidating a Commonwealth official and causing harm to a law officer. The arrest is linked to the ongoing war crimes investigations run by federal agencies.
It has been reported that the former SAS soldier is "Person 5" who gave evidence for Ben Roberts-Smith last week and on Tuesday this week in his defamation trial against Nine.
A quick overview of the matter is that in the years between 2005 and 2016 some Australian SAS soldiers are alleged to have committed war crimes including murder in Afghanistan. The Brereton Inquiry was set up in 2016 and delivered its final report on 6 November 2020. The report found evidence of 39 murders of civilians and prisoners by (or at the instruction of) members of the Australian special forces, which were subsequently covered up by ADF personnel.
Since then, there are a number of related ongoing investigations to determine if criminal charges can be instituted. (Click here to read more) Media started reporting some of the alleged murders and other alleged war crimes and named Ben Roberts-Smith who instituted defamation proceedings.
Nick McKenzie, one of the journalists being sued by Ben Roberts Smith tweeted on Wednesday (27/4/22) "Ben Roberts-Smith's key defamation case rebuttal witness was in court this week, denying war crimes. Hours after he finished giving evidence, he was confronted by federal war crimes detectives. He's now in a court cell, charged with obstructing these detectives. Extraordinary." (Click here to see on Twitter)
"Person 5" was granted bail on Wednesday afternoon (27/4/22) and is allowed to travel to his overseas home until he is next required in court.
Further details were reported later: The veteran had returned to his hotel room when he was confronted by Australian Federal Police who had a warrant for his mobile phone, NCA Newswire understands. It's understood the SAS veteran allegedly pushed one of the officers away and told them not to touch him before he was arrested and had his devices confiscated. (Click here to read more)
The warrant for the mobile phone reminded me of a report from last year, where Ben Roberts-Smith's phone calls were tapped, which said:
Mr Roberts-Smith also reveals how he talks to Mr Stokes on "encrypted" phone applications and "intelligence agencies cannot recover it". "So if I am talking to KMS for example - Kerry - we only talk on Telegram and then delete the messages after ... People use them so it can't be intercepted," he says.
https://kangaroocourtofaustralia.com/2022/04/28/will-kerry-stokes-ryan-stokes-and-seven-west-media-directors-face-criminal-charges-now-the-first-sas-soldier-has-been-arrested/
#16020180 at 2022-04-06 01:36:22 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #20262: Sussman/FBI Gifts That Keep Giving Edition
Case against SAS soldier accused of mistreating corpses in East Timor collapsed after New Zealand witnesses were denied identity protections
The NZ Defence Force has told Four Corners it was "not an unusual requirement" for Kiwi SAS witnesses to have their identities shielded, and it "cannot confirm the details of why" this was rejected in the 2003 case.
The decision robbed defence prosecutors of their only eyewitnesses. As a result, the Australian soldier accused of brutalising corpses in East Timor in 1999 was found not guilty.
Secret documents obtained by Four Corners show the New Zealand SAS repeatedly raised concerns about their Australian comrades in East Timor, which was the last time they fought together.
While the Australian military court records remain suppressed, Four Corners has learned a defence magistrate ruled the New Zealanders should be named in proceedings out of fairness to the soldier, whom Four Corners has called Operator K.
Following this ruling, the NZ SAS witnesses did not take the stand.
The NZDF said in a statement "protection of the identity of members of the NZDF NZSAS is a fundamental aspect of the operational capability".
The conditions of anonymity outlined by the NZDF were the same as those granted to Australian SAS witnesses in the defamation trial involving Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith.
"We believe that our requirement was our standard procedures for ID protection, i.e. that NZSAS personnel would only be known by names such as 'Trooper B'," the NZDF said.
"It would also be common practice to have NZSAS witnesses screened in court, and prevent their names from being used or published.
"Their actual names would be provided to the court and defence on paper. ?
"This is not an unusual requirement.
"We cannot confirm the details of why the ID protection measures were not met in this case."??
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-04-06/why-sas-east-timor-case-collapsed/100957664
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-04-06/why-sas-east-timor-case-collapsed/100957664
#15742170 at 2022-02-28 03:14:05 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #19905: The Ghost Of Kekistan Edition
Ben Roberts-Smith kicked handcuffed Afghan man over slope, former soldier tells court
A former elite soldier has told a Sydney court he witnessed war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith kick and "catapult" an unarmed, handcuffed Afghan man over a slope before he was shot dead.
The incident is one of the central allegations in the defamation trial
Mr Roberts-Smith has denied all elements of the story
Today's witness told the court the incident left him "in shock"
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times newspapers for defamation in the Federal Court, claiming a series of 2018 articles contained false allegations of unlawful killings, bullying and domestic violence.
One of the central allegations in the stories was that an unarmed, handcuffed Afghan farmer named Ali Jan was kicked over a cliff during a September 2012 mission in the village of Darwan.
Publisher Nine Entertainment is relying on a truth defence.
Mr Roberts-Smith has previously told the court a suspected Taliban "spotter" was killed in a cornfield that day, denying all elements of the story about the cliff.
A former Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) witness codenamed Person 4 today told the court of an Afghan man with a donkey who was searched, questioned and taken prisoner - becoming a PUC (person under control) of the Australian soldiers - as his patrol waited to be extracted from Darwan that day.
He said he later saw the handcuffed and detained man being held by a colleague, Person 11, by the right shoulder with his back towards a slope.
"At the same time, I noticed Ben Roberts-Smith, he had walked to a position maybe three to four metres away," Person 4 said.
"As I was trying to understand what was happening, he turned around and walked forward and kicked the individual in the chest.
"The individual was catapulted backwards and fell down the slope.
"I saw the individual's face strike a large rock and sustain a serious injury. He had knocked out a number of his teeth, including his front teeth."
Person 4 said he was "in shock at that point".
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-02-28/Ben-Roberts-Smith-trial-hears-more-evidence-from-afghanistan/100856732
#15734722 at 2022-02-27 04:32:49 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #19896: 9 Out of 10 Approve Edition
#19892
>>15731666, >>15731676, >>15731698 United States, Canada, European allies move to block 'selected' Russian banks from SWIFT
>>15731698, >>15732036 EU to ban certain Russian banks from #SWIFT, paralyze assets of the Russian central bank, and further freeze assets of oligarchs
>>15731674, >>15731720, >>15731768 Proverbs 29:11 A fool gives full vent to his spirit, but a wise man quietly holds it back
>>15731683 Does this look like a hot war? Or are we watching a movie/show?
>>15731693, >>15731707, >>15731700 4chan is out-faking the fake news
>>15731709 Masks Still Required For Air Travel Despite CDC's New Guidance
>>15731723 Powerful prima facie case to charge billionaire Kerry Stokes, Ryan Stokes and Ben Roberts-Smith with attempting to pervert the course of justice
>>15731730, >>15731735 Never seen before 911 Video drops same day as Ukraine invasion
>>15731737 Starlink service is now active in Ukraine. More terminals en route.
>>15731742, >>15731761, >>15731824, >>15731825, >>15731848, >>15731851, >>15732325, >>15732328 Muh WW3
>>15731871, >>15731874, >>15731891, >>15732011, >>15731930, >>15731973, >>15732011 Muh WW3
>>15731828, >>15732020, >>15732031 Rocket Man getting in on the action!
>>15731836 Trump's motorcade arrives ar CPAC greeted by crowd of supporters. #CPAC
>>15731846 CIA is teaching covert ops to Ukraine forces
>>15731880 Physicists test real quantum theory in an optical quantum network
>>15731879, >>15731986 Trump is getting ready to speak @ CPAC
>>15732000, >>15732018 "Russian" 9K35 Strela-10 apparently swerving to run over a civilian vehicle is false / fake news. now archived in Wag The Dog thread
>>15732020 North Korea fires unidentified projectile eastward
>>15732036, >>15732099, >>15732109,>>15732133 EU, US Agree To Expel "Selected Russian Banks" From SWIFT, Sanction Russian Central Bank?
>>15732051 Sen. John Kennedy Full Remarks at CPAC 2022 in Orlando
>>15732115 Kiev Live Feed
>>15732044, >>15732088 Social disruption followed by alternative media/network & Q 4511
>>15732214,>>15732248 President Donald J. Trump will hold a rally in Florence, South Carolina, on Saturday, March 12, 2022, at 7:00PM EST
>>15732221 Russian Solders address the Ukrainian army
>>15732223 Lt Dan poll on whether the Government should be able to see your banking transactions
>>15732245 "The resistance from the Ukrainians is stronger than the Russians anticipated" + additional obstacles
>>15732288 NASA Will Keep Its Partnership With Russian Space Agency
>>15732298 YouTube Blocks Monetization of Russia-Affiliated Channels, Including RT
>>15732311 Facebook, YouTube and Twitter limit ads over Russia's invasion of Ukraine
>>15732339 How RINO Paul Ryan is Connected to Biden's Radical Leftist SCOTUS Pick
>>15732345 US DoD funds Ukraine Biolabs PROOF & SITE GONE
>>15732369 #19892
Previously Collected
>>15731602 #19891
>>15729246 #19888, >>15730047 #19889, >>15730815 #19890
>>15727910 #19885, >>15728024 #19886, >>15728495 #19887
>>15724300 #19882, >>15725053 #19883, >>15725869 #19884
>>15722467 #19879, >>15722735 #19880, >>15723503 #19881
>>15720366 #19877, >>15721187 #19878, >>15722467 #19879
>>15718620 #19874, >>15718851 #19875, >>15719610 #19876
>>15715719 #19871, >>15716517 #19872, >>15717295 #19873
General Notable Pins: https://ghostbin.com/14ehq
TripCode feed: https://8kun.top/qresearch/tripcode.xml
Aggregators: https://qnotables.com | https://anontimes.com/
>>15406645 Notables #11: Never Back Down!
#15733931 at 2022-02-27 02:41:10 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #19895: Best Speech Ever By Q+ Edition
#19892
>>15731666, >>15731676, >>15731698 United States, Canada, European allies move to block 'selected' Russian banks from SWIFT
>>15731698, >>15732036 EU to ban certain Russian banks from #SWIFT, paralyze assets of the Russian central bank, and further freeze assets of oligarchs
>>15731674, >>15731720, >>15731768 Proverbs 29:11 A fool gives full vent to his spirit, but a wise man quietly holds it back
>>15731683 Does this look like a hot war? Or are we watching a movie/show?
>>15731693, >>15731707, >>15731700 4chan is out-faking the fake news
>>15731709 Masks Still Required For Air Travel Despite CDC's New Guidance
>>15731723 Powerful prima facie case to charge billionaire Kerry Stokes, Ryan Stokes and Ben Roberts-Smith with attempting to pervert the course of justice
>>15731730, >>15731735 Never seen before 911 Video drops same day as Ukraine invasion
>>15731737 Starlink service is now active in Ukraine. More terminals en route.
>>15731742, >>15731761, >>15731824, >>15731825, >>15731848, >>15731851, >>15732325, >>15732328 Muh WW3
>>15731871, >>15731874, >>15731891, >>15732011, >>15731930, >>15731973, >>15732011 Muh WW3
>>15731828, >>15732020, >>15732031 Rocket Man getting in on the action!
>>15731836 Trump's motorcade arrives ar CPAC greeted by crowd of supporters. #CPAC
>>15731846 CIA is teaching covert ops to Ukraine forces
>>15731880 Physicists test real quantum theory in an optical quantum network
>>15731879, >>15731986 Trump is getting ready to speak @ CPAC
>>15732000, >>15732018 "Russian" 9K35 Strela-10 apparently swerving to run over a civilian vehicle is false / fake news. now archived in Wag The Dog thread
>>15732020 North Korea fires unidentified projectile eastward
>>15732036, >>15732099, >>15732109,>>15732133 EU, US Agree To Expel "Selected Russian Banks" From SWIFT, Sanction Russian Central Bank?
>>15732051 Sen. John Kennedy Full Remarks at CPAC 2022 in Orlando
>>15732115 Kiev Live Feed
>>15732044, >>15732088 Social disruption followed by alternative media/network & Q 4511
>>15732214,>>15732248 President Donald J. Trump will hold a rally in Florence, South Carolina, on Saturday, March 12, 2022, at 7:00PM EST
>>15732221 Russian Solders address the Ukrainian army
>>15732223 Lt Dan poll on whether the Government should be able to see your banking transactions
>>15732245 "The resistance from the Ukrainians is stronger than the Russians anticipated" + additional obstacles
>>15732288 NASA Will Keep Its Partnership With Russian Space Agency
>>15732298 YouTube Blocks Monetization of Russia-Affiliated Channels, Including RT
>>15732311 Facebook, YouTube and Twitter limit ads over Russia's invasion of Ukraine
>>15732339 How RINO Paul Ryan is Connected to Biden's Radical Leftist SCOTUS Pick
>>15732345 US DoD funds Ukraine Biolabs PROOF & SITE GONE
>>15732369 #19892
Previously Collected
>>15731602 #19891
>>15729246 #19888, >>15730047 #19889, >>15730815 #19890
>>15727910 #19885, >>15728024 #19886, >>15728495 #19887
>>15724300 #19882, >>15725053 #19883, >>15725869 #19884
>>15722467 #19879, >>15722735 #19880, >>15723503 #19881
>>15720366 #19877, >>15721187 #19878, >>15722467 #19879
>>15718620 #19874, >>15718851 #19875, >>15719610 #19876
>>15715719 #19871, >>15716517 #19872, >>15717295 #19873
General Notable Pins: https://ghostbin.com/14ehq
TripCode feed: https://8kun.top/qresearch/tripcode.xml
Aggregators: https://qnotables.com | https://anontimes.com/
>>15406645 Notables #11: Never Back Down!
#15733136 at 2022-02-27 01:19:44 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #19894: Rally Bread Is The Best Bread Edition
#19892
>>15731666, >>15731676, >>15731698 United States, Canada, European allies move to block 'selected' Russian banks from SWIFT
>>15731698, >>15732036 EU to ban certain Russian banks from #SWIFT, paralyze assets of the Russian central bank, and further freeze assets of oligarchs
>>15731674, >>15731720, >>15731768 Proverbs 29:11 A fool gives full vent to his spirit, but a wise man quietly holds it back
>>15731683 Does this look like a hot war? Or are we watching a movie/show?
>>15731693, >>15731707, >>15731700 4chan is out-faking the fake news
>>15731709 Masks Still Required For Air Travel Despite CDC's New Guidance
>>15731723 Powerful prima facie case to charge billionaire Kerry Stokes, Ryan Stokes and Ben Roberts-Smith with attempting to pervert the course of justice
>>15731730, >>15731735 Never seen before 911 Video drops same day as Ukraine invasion
>>15731737 Starlink service is now active in Ukraine. More terminals en route.
>>15731742, >>15731761, >>15731824, >>15731825, >>15731848, >>15731851, >>15732325, >>15732328 Muh WW3
>>15731871, >>15731874, >>15731891, >>15732011, >>15731930, >>15731973, >>15732011 Muh WW3
>>15731828, >>15732020, >>15732031 Rocket Man getting in on the action!
>>15731836 Trump's motorcade arrives ar CPAC greeted by crowd of supporters. #CPAC
>>15731846 CIA is teaching covert ops to Ukraine forces
>>15731880 Physicists test real quantum theory in an optical quantum network
>>15731879, >>15731986 Trump is getting ready to speak @ CPAC
>>15732000, >>15732018 "Russian" 9K35 Strela-10 apparently swerving to run over a civilian vehicle is false / fake news. now archived in Wag The Dog thread
>>15732020 North Korea fires unidentified projectile eastward
>>15732036, >>15732099, >>15732109,>>15732133 EU, US Agree To Expel "Selected Russian Banks" From SWIFT, Sanction Russian Central Bank?
>>15732051 Sen. John Kennedy Full Remarks at CPAC 2022 in Orlando
>>15732115 Kiev Live Feed
>>15732044, >>15732088 Social disruption followed by alternative media/network & Q 4511
>>15732214,>>15732248 President Donald J. Trump will hold a rally in Florence, South Carolina, on Saturday, March 12, 2022, at 7:00PM EST
>>15732221 Russian Solders address the Ukrainian army
>>15732223 Lt Dan poll on whether the Government should be able to see your banking transactions
>>15732245 "The resistance from the Ukrainians is stronger than the Russians anticipated" + additional obstacles
>>15732288 NASA Will Keep Its Partnership With Russian Space Agency
>>15732298 YouTube Blocks Monetization of Russia-Affiliated Channels, Including RT
>>15732311 Facebook, YouTube and Twitter limit ads over Russia's invasion of Ukraine
>>15732339 How RINO Paul Ryan is Connected to Biden's Radical Leftist SCOTUS Pick
>>15732345 US DoD funds Ukraine Biolabs PROOF & SITE GONE
>>15732369 #19892
#19891
>>15730896, >>15730902, >>15731049, >>15731171, >>15731215, >>15731155, >>15731188, >>15730980, >>15731139 New Dan on Facebook, Jack of clubs? Tiffany Blue?
>>15730901, >>15731098, >>15731124, >>15731075, >>15731191, >>15731198 Latest Ukraine/Russia spin, warmongering and propaganda
>>15730918, >>15730942, >>15731058, >>15731062 Ukraine Fake news Debunked: WW2 Tanks, old photos, fake clips
>>15730979, >>15731029 Flucelvax Quadrivalent contains thimerosal, a mercury derivative, added as a preservative. Each 0.5 mL dose contains 25 mcg mercury
>>15731001 RE: Medical Malpractice, 'Medical System Kills People deliberately and directly, for ? $$$?'
>>15731109 ICYMI: US Embassy in #Ukraine deleted all documents about 11 Pentagon-funded biolaboratories in Ukraine from its website yesterday
>>15731174 Canada Protests & the West: The Right to be Heard, interview with Protester who got bashed in Ottawa
>>15731269 President Trump's speech in Orlando tonight 7pm EST will be carried on CSPAN online and on TV, and other outlets
>>15731347 "It's political party time with world leaders for George Soros' son" - NYP
>>15731349 Wag The Dog Thread Created, dedicated to proven Ukraine/Russia War Debunks
>>15731462 Top manager of Gazprom's treasury committed suicide near St. Petersburg
>>15731541 OHIO Governor orders halt to state purchase and sale of Russian vodka - WLWT
>>15731542 @NavalInstitute Proceedings Photo of the Week: U.S. Marines with Marine Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Squadron (VMU)
>>15731587 Gazprom Treasury Top Manager Found Dead in Monopoly "Nest" in Leninsky
>>15731602 #19891
#15732396 at 2022-02-27 00:17:38 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #19893: A Fool Gives Vent To His Spirit, But Wise Men Quietly Hold Back Edition
GLOBALS
>>15487554 How get get bans lifted & do bug reports on /tech/
>>15443568 HOW TO BAKE Thread
>>15568669 Bakers - how to format notable buns (including two-post buns)
>>15620842 Guidelines for General banners
>>15676854 Bakers: no board politics in notables pls
>>15717142, >>15717237 Scavino deletion - looks like a tech glitch
>>15731793 Organizing notes on Ukraine (etc) to avoid "wall-of-text buns NEW
NOTABLES ARE NOT ENDORSEMENTS
#19892
>>15731666, >>15731676, >>15731698 United States, Canada, European allies move to block 'selected' Russian banks from SWIFT
>>15731698, >>15732036 EU to ban certain Russian banks from #SWIFT, paralyze assets of the Russian central bank, and further freeze assets of oligarchs
>>15731674, >>15731720, >>15731768 Proverbs 29:11 A fool gives full vent to his spirit, but a wise man quietly holds it back
>>15731683 Does this look like a hot war? Or are we watching a movie/show?
>>15731693, >>15731707, >>15731700 4chan is out-faking the fake news
>>15731709 Masks Still Required For Air Travel Despite CDC's New Guidance
>>15731723 Powerful prima facie case to charge billionaire Kerry Stokes, Ryan Stokes and Ben Roberts-Smith with attempting to pervert the course of justice
>>15731730, >>15731735 Never seen before 911 Video drops same day as Ukraine invasion
>>15731737 Starlink service is now active in Ukraine. More terminals en route.
>>15731742, >>15731761, >>15731824, >>15731825, >>15731848, >>15731851, >>15732325, >>15732328 Muh WW3
>>15731871, >>15731874, >>15731891, >>15732011, >>15731930, >>15731973, >>15732011 Muh WW3
>>15731828, >>15732020, >>15732031 Rocket Man getting in on the action!
>>15731836 Trump's motorcade arrives ar CPAC greeted by crowd of supporters. #CPAC
>>15731846 CIA is teaching covert ops to Ukraine forces
>>15731880 Physicists test real quantum theory in an optical quantum network
>>15731879, >>15731986 Trump is getting ready to speak @ CPAC
>>15732000, >>15732018 "Russian" 9K35 Strela-10 apparently swerving to run over a civilian vehicle is false / fake news. now archived in Wag The Dog thread
>>15732020 North Korea fires unidentified projectile eastward
>>15732036, >>15732099, >>15732109,>>15732133 EU, US Agree To Expel "Selected Russian Banks" From SWIFT, Sanction Russian Central Bank?
>>15732051 Sen. John Kennedy Full Remarks at CPAC 2022 in Orlando
>>15732115 Kiev Live Feed
>>15732044, >>15732088 Social disruption followed by alternative media/network & Q 4511
>>15732214,>>15732248 President Donald J. Trump will hold a rally in Florence, South Carolina, on Saturday, March 12, 2022, at 7:00PM EST
>>15732221 Russian Solders address the Ukrainian army
>>15732223 Lt Dan poll on whether the Government should be able to see your banking transactions
>>15732245 "The resistance from the Ukrainians is stronger than the Russians anticipated" + additional obstacles
>>15732288 NASA Will Keep Its Partnership With Russian Space Agency
>>15732298 YouTube Blocks Monetization of Russia-Affiliated Channels, Including RT
>>15732311 Facebook, YouTube and Twitter limit ads over Russia's invasion of Ukraine
>>15732339 How RINO Paul Ryan is Connected to Biden's Radical Leftist SCOTUS Pick
>>15732345 US DoD funds Ukraine Biolabs PROOF & SITE GONE
>>15732369 #19892
#19891
>>15730896, >>15730902, >>15731049, >>15731171, >>15731215, >>15731155, >>15731188, >>15730980, >>15731139 New Dan on Facebook, Jack of clubs? Tiffany Blue?
>>15730901, >>15731098, >>15731124, >>15731075, >>15731191, >>15731198 Latest Ukraine/Russia spin, warmongering and propaganda
>>15730918, >>15730942, >>15731058, >>15731062 Ukraine Fake news Debunked: WW2 Tanks, old photos, fake clips
>>15730979, >>15731029 Flucelvax Quadrivalent contains thimerosal, a mercury derivative, added as a preservative. Each 0.5 mL dose contains 25 mcg mercury
>>15731001 RE: Medical Malpractice, 'Medical System Kills People deliberately and directly, for ? $$$?'
>>15731109 ICYMI: US Embassy in #Ukraine deleted all documents about 11 Pentagon-funded biolaboratories in Ukraine from its website yesterday
>>15731174 Canada Protests & the West: The Right to be Heard, interview with Protester who got bashed in Ottawa
>>15731269 President Trump's speech in Orlando tonight 7pm EST will be carried on CSPAN online and on TV, and other outlets
>>15731347 "It's political party time with world leaders for George Soros' son" - NYP
>>15731349 Wag The Dog Thread Created, dedicated to proven Ukraine/Russia War Debunks
>>15731462 Top manager of Gazprom's treasury committed suicide near St. Petersburg
>>15731541 OHIO Governor orders halt to state purchase and sale of Russian vodka - WLWT
>>15731542 @NavalInstitute Proceedings Photo of the Week: U.S. Marines with Marine Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Squadron (VMU)
>>15731587 Gazprom Treasury Top Manager Found Dead in Monopoly "Nest" in Leninsky
>>15731602 #19891
#15732369 at 2022-02-27 00:15:26 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #19892: The Cougar of Kiev Edition
>>15731621 Dough
#18892 FINAL
>>15731666, >>15731676, >>15731698 United States, Canada, European allies move to block 'selected' Russian banks from SWIFT
>>15731698, >>15732036 EU to ban certain Russian banks from #SWIFT, paralyze assets of the Russian central bank, and further freeze assets of oligarchs
>>15731674, >>15731720, >>15731768 Proverbs 29:11 A fool gives full vent to his spirit, but a wise man quietly holds it back
>>15731683 Does this look like a hot war? Or are we watching a movie/show?
>>15731693, >>15731707, >>15731700 4chan is out-faking the fake news
>>15731709 Masks Still Required For Air Travel Despite CDC's New Guidance
>>15731723 Powerful prima facie case to charge billionaire Kerry Stokes, Ryan Stokes and Ben Roberts-Smith with attempting to pervert the course of justice
>>15731730, >>15731735 Never seen before 911 Video drops same day as Ukraine invasion
>>15731737 Starlink service is now active in Ukraine. More terminals en route.
>>15731742, >>15731761, >>15731824, >>15731825, >>15731848, >>15731851, >>15732325, >>15732328 Muh WW3
>>15731871, >>15731874, >>15731891, >>15732011, >>15731930, >>15731973, >>15732011 Muh WW3
>>15731828, >>15732020, >>15732031 Rocket Man getting in on the action!
>>15731836 Trump's motorcade arrives ar CPAC greeted by crowd of supporters. #CPAC
>>15731846 CIA is teaching covert ops to Ukraine forces
>>15731880 Physicists test real quantum theory in an optical quantum network
>>15731879, >>15731986 Trump is getting ready to speak @ CPAC
>>15732000, >>15732018 "Russian" 9K35 Strela-10 apparently swerving to run over a civilian vehicle is false / fake news. now archived in Wag The Dog thread
>>15732020 North Korea fires unidentified projectile eastward
>>15732036, >>15732099, >>15732109,>>15732133 EU, US Agree To Expel "Selected Russian Banks" From SWIFT, Sanction Russian Central Bank?
>>15732051 Sen. John Kennedy Full Remarks at CPAC 2022 in Orlando
>>15732115 Kiev Live Feed
>>15732044, >>15732088 Social disruption followed by alternative media/network & Q 4511
>>15732214,>>15732248 President Donald J. Trump will hold a rally in Florence, South Carolina, on Saturday, March 12, 2022, at 7:00PM EST
>>15732221 Russian Solders address the Ukrainian army
>>15732223 Lt Dan poll on whether the Government should be able to see your banking transactions
>>15732245 "The resistance from the Ukrainians is stronger than the Russians anticipated" + additional obstacles
>>15732288 NASA Will Keep Its Partnership With Russian Space Agency
>>15732298 YouTube Blocks Monetization of Russia-Affiliated Channels, Including RT
>>15732311 Facebook, YouTube and Twitter limit ads over Russia's invasion of Ukraine
>>15732339 How RINO Paul Ryan is Connected to Biden's Radical Leftist SCOTUS Pick
>>15732345 US DoD funds Ukraine Biolabs PROOF & SITE GONE
#19892
#15732282 at 2022-02-27 00:08:16 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #19892: The Cougar of Kiev Edition
>>15731621 Dough
#18892 Last Call
>>15731666, >>15731676, >>15731698 United States, Canada, European allies move to block 'selected' Russian banks from SWIFT
>>15731698, >>15732036 EU to ban certain Russian banks from #SWIFT, paralyze assets of the Russian central bank, and further freeze assets of oligarchs
>>15731674, >>15731720, >>15731768 Proverbs 29:11 A fool gives full vent to his spirit, but a wise man quietly holds it back
>>15731683 Does this look like a hot war? Or are we watching a movie/show?
>>15731693, >>15731707, >>15731700 4chan is out-faking the fake news
>>15731709 Masks Still Required For Air Travel Despite CDC's New Guidance
>>15731723 Powerful prima facie case to charge billionaire Kerry Stokes, Ryan Stokes and Ben Roberts-Smith with attempting to pervert the course of justice
>>15731730, >>15731735 Never seen before 911 Video drops same day as Ukraine invasion
>>15731737 Starlink service is now active in Ukraine. More terminals en route.
>>15731778, >>15731742, >>15731761, >>15731824, >>15731825, >>15731848, >>15731851, >>15731871, >>15731874, >>15731891, >>15732011, >>15731930, >>15731973, >>15732011 MUH WW3
>>15731828, >>15732020, >>15732031 Rocket Man getting in on the action!
>>15731836 Trump's motorcade arrives ar CPAC greeted by crowd of supporters. #CPAC
>>15731846 CIA is teaching covert ops to Ukraine forces
>>15731880 Physicists test real quantum theory in an optical quantum network
>>15731879, >>15731986 Trump is getting ready to speak @ CPAC
>>15732000, >>15732018 "Russian" 9K35 Strela-10 apparently swerving to run over a civilian vehicle is false / fake news. now archived in Wag The Dog thread
>>15732020 North Korea fires unidentified projectile eastward
>>15732036, >>15732099, >>15732109,>>15732133 EU, US Agree To Expel "Selected Russian Banks" From SWIFT, Sanction Russian Central Bank?
>>15732051 Sen. John Kennedy Full Remarks at CPAC 2022 in Orlando
>>15732115 Kiev Live Feed
>>15732044, >>15732088 Social disruption followed by alternative media/network & Q 4511
>>15732214,>>15732248 President Donald J. Trump will hold a rally in Florence, South Carolina, on Saturday, March 12, 2022, at 7:00PM EST
>>15732221 Russian Solders address the Ukrainian army
>>15732223 Lt Dan poll on whether the Government should be able to see your banking transactions
>>15732245 "The resistance from the Ukrainians is stronger than the Russians anticipated" + additional obstacles
#19892
#15732080 at 2022-02-26 23:47:50 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #19892: The Cougar of Kiev Edition
>>15732038
handoff confirmed
>>15731821
pls note the dough update for new global
Notables are not endorsements
>>15731621
>>15731666, >>15731676, >>15731698 United States, Canada, European allies move to block 'selected' Russian banks from SWIFT
>>15731698, >>15732036 EU to ban certain Russian banks from #SWIFT, paralyze assets of the Russian central bank, and further freeze assets of oligarchs
>>15731674, >>15731720, >>15731768 Proverbs 29:11 A fool gives full vent to his spirit, but a wise man quietly holds it back
>>15731683 Does this look like a hot war? Or are we watching a movie/show?
>>15731693, >>15731707, >>15731700 4chan is out-faking the fake news
>>15731709 Masks Still Required For Air Travel Despite CDC's New Guidance
>>15731723 Powerful prima facie case to charge billionaire Kerry Stokes, Ryan Stokes and Ben Roberts-Smith with attempting to pervert the course of justice
>>15731730, >>15731735 Never seen before 911 Video drops same day as Ukraine invasion
>>15731737 Starlink service is now active in Ukraine. More terminals en route.
>>15731778, >>15731742, >>15731761, >>15731824, >>15731825, >>15731848, >>15731851, >>15731871, >>15731874, >>15731891, >>15732011, >>15731930, >>15731973, >>15732011 MUH WW3
>>15731828, >>15732020, >>15732031 Rocket Man getting in on the action!
>>15731836 Trump's motorcade arrives ar CPAC greeted by crowd of supporters. #CPAC
>>15731846 CIA is teaching covert ops to Ukraine forces
>>15731880 Physicists test real quantum theory in an optical quantum network
>>15731879, >>15731986 Trump is getting ready to speak @ CPAC
>>15732000, >>15732018 "Russian" 9K35 Strela-10 apparently swerving to run over a civilian vehicle is false / fake news. now archived in Wag The Dog thread
@420
nom if missed
https://controlc.com/f498f6c6
#15731873 at 2022-02-26 23:24:36 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #19892: The Cougar of Kiev Edition
Notables are not endorsements
>>15731621
>>15731666, >>15731676, >>15731698 United States, Canada, European allies move to block 'selected' Russian banks from SWIFT
>>15731698 EU to ban certain Russian banks from #SWIFT, paralyze assets of the Russian central bank, and further freeze assets of oligarchs
>>15731674, >>15731720, >>15731768 Proverbs 29:11 A fool gives full vent to his spirit, but a wise man quietly holds it back
>>15731683 Does this look like a hot war? Or are we watching a movie/show?
>>15731693, >>15731707, >>15731700 4chan is out-faking the fake news
>>15731709 Masks Still Required For Air Travel Despite CDC's New Guidance
>>15731723 Powerful prima facie case to charge billionaire Kerry Stokes, Ryan Stokes and Ben Roberts-Smith with attempting to pervert the course of justice
>>15731730, >>15731735 Never seen before 911 Video drops same day as Ukraine invasion
>>15731737 Starlink service is now active in Ukraine. More terminals en route.
>>15731741, >>15731770, >>15731778, >>15731742, >>15731761, >>15731824, >>15731825, >>15731848, >>15731851 MUH WW3 BUN
>>15731836 Trump's motorcade arrives ar CPAC greeted by crowd of supporters. #CPAC
>>15731846 CIA is teaching covert ops to Ukraine forces
nom if missed
@211
Baker is Requesting handoff
#15731723 at 2022-02-26 23:01:31 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #19892: The Cougar of Kiev Edition
Powerful prima facie case to charge billionaire Kerry Stokes, Ryan Stokes and Ben Roberts-Smith with attempting to pervert the course of justice
There is an extremely powerful prima facie case to charge billionaire Kerry Stokes, Ryan Stokes, Seven CEO James Warburton, Seven executive Bruce McWilliam and Seven West Media's other directors with numerous crimes including attempting to pervert the course of justice and intimidating witnesses.
Ben Roberts-Smith is in a lot of trouble with his defamation case with numerous soldiers and ex-soldiers giving evidence against him with one soldier saying in court on Tuesday (22/2/22) "Ben Roberts-Smith ordered mock execution of civilian during training drill" and then Roberts-Smith spoke about how they cover-up the murders. (Click here to read more) But in this article I want to focus on the alleged crimes committed in Australia by Ben Roberts-Smith to cover-up the alleged war crimes with the evidence pointing to numerous people helping him.
It has always been obvious to me and many others that Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation case is about trying to avoid war crimes and I wrote in June 2021:
Ben Roberts-Smith's main objective in suing the media companies and journalists is not the alleged defamation. His main goal is to avoid being charged with war crimes allegedly committed in Afghanistan and other crimes he has allegedly committed in Australia which would have a long jail sentence attached if he was charged and found guilty. So, there is no chance Roberts-Smith will be withdrawing the defamation case the same way Christian Porter and Alan Jones did when their defamation cases looked like exposing them for who they really are.
The legal game plan
Ben Roberts-Smith will see the defamation case through to the end hoping if he wins that will put pressure on the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions not to charge him with criminal offences. And if he loses the defamation case, he will see that as him being in no worse a position than he would have been in if he hadn't sued for defamation as he was already being accused of war crimes by the media and former soldiers on a regular basis. (Click here to read more)
The powerful evidence to support possible charges against Kerry Stokes etc. has been heard publicly over the last few months in the Federal Court of Australia with some of it coming from a private investigator who did work for Ben Roberts-Smith which included sending a threatening letter to one witness and making a false complaint to police about another witness which resulted in a police raid on that witness. (Click here to read more)
Some of the key evidence by the private investigator was supported by Ben Roberts-Smith ex-wife who also said she was asked to lie by Ben Roberts-Smith. (Click here to read more)
https://kangaroocourtofaustralia.com/2022/02/26/powerful-prima-facie-case-to-charge-billionaire-kerry-stokes-ryan-stokes-and-Ben-Roberts-Smith-with-attempting-to-pervert-the-course-of-justice/
https://kangaroocourtofaustralia.com/2022/02/26/powerful-prima-facie-case-to-charge-billionaire-kerry-stokes-ryan-stokes-and-Ben-Roberts-Smith-with-attempting-to-pervert-the-course-of-justice/
#14197975 at 2021-07-25 21:09:46 (UTC+1)
Q Research General: #17961: Thank You CERTIFIED Collectors... Pre-E-Bake Certified Edition
Liberal and National Party MPs attack free speech and political communication with 4 defamation cases in the Federal Court
Three Liberal Party MP's, Peter Dutton, Andrew Laming and Christian Porter, and one National Party MP, NSW Deputy Premier John Barilaro, currently have defamation cases in the Federal Court of Australia which I suspect is a record for the number of politicians suing social media users and journalists at any one given time.
The 4 court cases by themselves are an attack on free speech and political communication and while Porter has in theory settled his defamation case, and he has tried to claim a win, it is still afoot. And if the other three were to win their cases it would have a huge negative effect on free speech and political communication in this country. How much coordination has happened between the 4 is unknown but there would likely of been at least some discussion between a couple of them if not all of them.
Christian Porter sued the ABC and journalist Louise Milligan for defamation and while Porter has settled the defamation case elements of the case have not been finalised. (Click here and here to read more) Porter has been using the lawyer Rebekah Giles who runs the law firm Company Giles and he used the barrister Sue Chrysanthou SC before she was restrained by the court from representing Porter anymore.
Federal MP Andrew Laming, who is also suing journalist Louise Milligan, is also using lawyer Rebekah Giles and it is hard to believe he would not have consulted Christian Porter before hiring Rebekah Giles. Which barrister Mr Laming is using at this point is unknown.
"lawyers acting on behalf of Laming lodged documents in the federal court alleging Milligan had "gravely injured" the embattled MP's "character and reputation" in a series of tweets on 28 March relating to a photo he took of a woman Bending over at a Brisbane landscaping business in 2019."
The claim, seen by the Guardian, alleges that Milligan "intended" for the "sensational, accusatory and spiteful" tweets to "irrevocably damage" Laming's "personal and professional reputation". (Click here to read more)
Federal MP Peter Dutton is suing Twitter user Shane Bazzi for one Tweet and is using the law firm Baker & Mckenzie. Which barrister Mr Dutton is using at this point is unknown.
Peter Dutton has followed through with his threat to sue social media users for defamation by starting proceedings against Twitter user Shane Bazzi for calling Dutton a "rapist apologist". But there is a video and a Twitter message below of Peter Dutton saying, "QLD Premier Palaszczuk should be shamed into joining a federal push for a public sex offender register" and asking "why Premier Palaszczuk is siding with and protecting paedophiles and sex offenders is just beyond anyone's comprehension and it is for her to explain". (Click here to read more)
NSW Deputy Premier John Barilaro is suing YouTube comedian FriendlyJordies (Jordan Shanks-Markovina) and Google who own YouTube. Barilaro is using the law firm Mark O'Brien Legal, who also represent Ben Roberts-Smith, and Christian Porter's former barrister Sue Chrysanthou SC who was in her usual fine form in the Federal Court on Friday. FriendlyJordies have raised over $1million for their legal defence for the defamation matter as well as criminal charges against employee Kristo Langker who has been charged with stalking Barilaro which based on video evidence is a false charge.
At Friday's pre-trial hearing in the Barilaro v FriendlyJordies matter his barrister Sue Chrysanthou SC argued:
"John Barilaro boasting about pork barrelling government grants may be "the wrong thing to do", but it does not show the New South Wales deputy premier is a corrupt conman, his lawyers have argued in court." (Click here to read more)
https://kangaroocourtofaustralia.com/2021/07/25/liberal-and-national-party-mps-attack-free-speech-and-political-communication-with-4-defamation-cases-in-the-federal-court/
#13910040 at 2021-06-15 16:49:08 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #17608: Tippy Top Of The Morning Ebake Edition
>>13910038
Spy author John Le Carré told doctors he wanted to 'go home and look after his sick wife' before he died after a fall at his home aged 89, inquest hears
Daily Mail on MSN.com|2 hours ago
John Le Carré, aged 89, suffered fractured ribs following the incident at his home in Cornwall. His condition worsened and he was rushed to hospital where he died on December 12 last year.
US journalist held by Myanmar's military junta for three months is RELEASED and deported
Daily Mail|5 hours ago
Nathan Maung was jailed while working for local online news agency Kamayut Media, one of nearly 100 journalists detained following the coup in Myanmar in February.
Action man Rishi! Publicity-hungry 'PM-in-waiting' dons army fatigues during adventure-packed visit to Catterick Garrison (while his boss Boris Johnson is holding a children's …
Daily Mail|13 days ago
Mr Sunak, 41, looked every inch the statesman in his combat trousers and white t-shirt while he walked around the military town near Richmond, North Yorkshire.
Probe launched as names of SAS troops are revealed in Army email blunder
Daily Mail|13 days ago
Fourteen Special Air Service (SAS) soldiers, five members of the Special Reconnaissance Regiment (SRR) and four Special Boat Service (SBS) troops were listed.
Poet Roger McGough pens a tribute to the Mail's Great British Spring Clean heroes… with a verse that imagines Admiral Lord Nelson coming down from his Trafalgar Square column …
Daily Mail on MSN.com|4 days ago
Mr McGough, 83, who lives in Barnes, south-west London with his wife said he is a fan of the Mail-backed Great British Spring Clean campaign, which ends this weekend.
Thanks a million! That's how many miles of Britain you've pledged to spruce up for the Mail's campaign
Daily Mail|11 days ago
Joining in with the Great British Spring Clean is going to help lift the spirits of the pupils and staff at Dorridge Primary School in Solihull.
Can I burrow some bullets? Badger sparks security scare by breaking into ammunition compound at army base
Daily Mail on MSN.com|12 days ago
The Ministry of Defence was forced to put in an 'anxious' call to wildlife officers after a badger 'penetrated secure fencing' as it dug its way into an ammunition compound in Wiltshire last month.
Ben Roberts-Smith goes into battle with media giant over allegations he committed war crimes
Daily Mail|8 days ago
Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith will spend the next two months in room 18D of the Federal Court in Sydney's central business district defending himself against allegations he is a war criminal.
Chinese scientist 'filed patent for a COVID vaccine BEFORE the virus was declared a global pandemic'
Daily Mail|9 days ago
Yusen Zhou, who worked for the People's Liberation Army (PLA), lodged the paperwork on behalf of the Chinese political party on February 24 2020, according to The Australian newspaper.
#13910038 at 2021-06-15 16:48:54 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #17608: Tippy Top Of The Morning Ebake Edition
Two paratroopers found dead in Fort Bragg were 'involved with illicit drugs'
Daily Mail|20 hours ago
Fort Bragg paratroopers Spc. Joshua Diamond, 35, and Pfc. Matthew Disney, 20, were found dead in their barracks room on Friday in a suspected illegal drugs overdose.
Neo-Nazi former Ukip member and Army driver, 34, who stockpiled chemicals and collected terrorism manuals and instructions on how to make homemade bombs and weapons is jailed …
Daily Mail|22 hours ago
Dean Morrice, 34, from Paulton, Somerset, stockpiled chemicals to make explosives and collected terrorism manuals and instructions on how to make bombs and weapons.
Ben Roberts-Smith hired a private investigator to follow his mistress to hospital after she told him she was going to abort their child while he was separated from his wife
Daily Mail|7 hours ago
Ben Roberts-Smith hired a private investigator to follow his mistress to hospital after she told him she was going to abort their child while he was separated from his wife.
Fifth soldier died at army's Deepcut barracks where four recruits died between 1995 and 2002
Daily Mail|4 days ago
Five soldiers and not the previously thought four were found dead at the Deepcut barracks in Surrey amid allegations of a culture of bullying and abuse.
Defence minister is 'very concerned' that no one knows why new £3.5billion army tanks are so noisy that they make crews sick and can't be driven faster than 20mph
Daily Mail on MSN.com|7 days ago
Jeremy Quin, the minister for defence procurement, said the government was 'very concerned' that a new fleet of Ajax tanks for the Army were reportedly causing excessive noise and vibrations.
Army's new £3.5bn tanks WILL be delivered on time, Government insists - after leaked report said they can't fire on the move, cannot exceed 20mph and make crews sick with noise
Daily Mail on MSN.com|6 days ago
The government had ordered more than 580 of the tanks in a range of US-designed models which are being built in Merthyr Tydfil, South Wales.
Army's new £5.5bn Ajax tank fleet make crew using them sick, can't be driven over 20mph and vibrate so much they can't fire shells on the move, leaked report reveals
Daily Mail on MSN.com|13 days ago
The Ministry of Defence (MoD) has confirmed it paused trials of its new £3.47 billion fleet of army tanks over design issues which reportedly include them being unable drive at top speed safely.
Army lance corporal, 33, three times the drink drive limit was so drunk she tried to order from a police officer called to arrest her at a McDonald's drive-thru
Daily Mail|11 days ago
Kayleigh Marie Goodall, 33, was spotted 'driving erratically all over the road' at Catterick Garrison in Yorkshire before trying to order fast food from a police officer, a court heard.
Palestinians call for a 'Day of Rage' as far-right Israeli groups prepare to march
Daily Mail|1 hour ago
Violence erupted near the Damascus Gate in the Old City as far-right Israeli groups prepared to march through the capital in a delayed celebration of Jerusalem Day.
'Shut down these sick suicide sites': Victims' families call for end of 'death cult' online forums where members encourage others to take their own life
Daily Mail|2 days ago
Websites, found through a simple internet search, connect vulnerable people with thousands of forum members who provide instructions on how to end their lives.
Chinese troll army floods the internet with vile claims the Queen has died
Daily Mail|8 days ago
Thousands of posts from Chinese bot accounts responded to the British embassy in Beijing with messages saying 'R.I.P the Queen' to distract from Tiananmen Square commemorations.
Chinese army researchers 'engineered mice with humanized lungs' in 2019 to test viruses, report says
Daily Mail|10 days ago
Medical researchers with the Chinese army engineered mice with humanized lungs in 2019 to test viruses on them, it has been reported.
WWII veteran Henry 'Corky' Caldwell, who never missed an ANZAC Day march, has died at age 101
Daily Mail|3 days ago
Anzac mechanic Henry 'Corky' Caldwell who saw gruesome sights in the Middle East during World War II has suddenly died aged 101 when he was at home 'eating an ice cream'.
Thousands of ticketless Scotland fans are urged to stay away from Wembley amid fears of trouble if they can't watch due to the lack of a London fan zone
Daily Mail on MSN.com|16 hours ago
The Scottish Football Supporters Association expects as many as 6,000 Scots will be making the trip south on Friday, while others say it could be 20,000 people.
'You can't run society purely to stop the hospitals being full': Jacob Rees-Mogg gives first sign of Cabinet dissent on lockdown delay after Michael Gove insists July 19 …
Daily Mail|1 hour ago
Jacob Rees-Mogg today gave the first sign of Cabinet dissent over Boris Johnson's decision to delay the final stage in his lockdown exit roadmap.
#13814341 at 2021-06-02 17:18:41 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #17487: Confessions Are Awesome Edition
'Hundreds' of photos show Aussie troops chugging beer from dead Afghan's prosthetic leg, court is told
Lawyers for a soldier suing several media outlets for defamation have claimed that hundreds of photographs exist showing Australian troops drinking from a prosthetic leg allegedly taken from a dead Afghan.
Several photographs of Aussie soldiers guzzling alcohol from the artificial limb were published in December, and became graphic displays of alleged gross misconduct by Australian troops stationed in Afghanistan. However, it now appears that the macabre drinking ritual, which purportedly took place at an underground bar located at an Australian military base in Afghanistan, was far more widespread than previously known.
One of the soldiers connected to the story, Ben Roberts-Smith, is suing three Australian outlets - the Age, the Sydney Morning Herald and the Canberra Times - for defamation over reports from 2018 which detail alleged war crimes that he took part in. According to the disputed reports, the leg was "souvenired" from an Afghan civilian who had been shot and killed by Ben Roberts-Smith in 2009.
The soldier's lawyers have claimed that the limb belonged to a Taliban fighter and that Roberts-Smith did not shoot him. Furthermore, Roberts-Smith never drank from the prosthetic leg and found the idea of taking the fake body part as a souvenir "disgusting," his complaint states.
But with the case set to begin next week, Roberts-Smith's lawyers have told the federal court that they are struggling to meet the deadline to itemize all the photographs included as evidence.
"We cannot do that for hundreds of images of soldiers drinking from the leg - it's too onerous, it's too long," Matthew Richardson, one of the lawyers, told the court in a pre-trial hearing, as cited by the media.
According to reports, the artificial limb became a coveted trophy of the Australian soldiers. It was allegedly mounted on a wooden plaque, alongside an Iron Cross - a military decoration used in imperial and Nazi Germany. The display was allegedly captioned with "Das Boot."
The publication of several of the potentially incriminating photographs in December followed the conclusion of a four-year probe which found "credible evidence" of war crimes committed by elite Australian troops in Afghanistan. The Australian military has since apologized to Kabul "for any wrongdoing by Australian soldiers."
https://www.rt.com/news/525474-australia-afghanistan-prosthetic-leg-photos/
#13082443 at 2021-03-02 01:41:23 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #16662: Make It Rain Edition
National security watchdog launches investigation into secret trial of Witness J
An investigation into the top secret trial, sentencing and jailing of a former military intelligence officer has been restarted by the national security watchdog.
Key points:
The investigation will look at the effect of national security legislation on the justice system
Witness J, a former intelligence officer, was sentenced and imprisoned in secret
A public hearing by the national security watchdog will be held in June
The man, referred to as Witness J, was convicted of mishandling classified information which potentially revealed the identities of agents who had been recruited by Australian intelligence agencies.
The incredible details of his plight only became public after an investigation by the ABC, sparking a debate about transparency in Australia's legal system.
Last year the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor (INSLM), James Renwick, launched an inquiry into whether the overreach of national security legislation was responsible for the total secrecy in the case.
Witness J was given the moniker of "Alan Johns" for the purpose of the inquiry.
Dr Renwick's probe was scuttled by the COVID-19 pandemic, hampering the gathering of information before his term as INSLM ended in mid-2020.
Inside the secret case of Witness J
The Federal Government didn't want you to know about Witness J. Here's the story of his secret trial, conviction and imprisonment.
Read more
His successor, Grant Donaldson, has now launched his own investigation which will examine the effect of the National Security Information (NSI) Act on the justice system.
The NSI Act is very broad in its application, allowing the government to request strict suppression orders if it is concerned sensitive and classified information would be aired in court, potentially prejudicing the nation's national security operations.
The evidence would need to be heard as part of a trial process, but the restrictions would allow the details to remain inside the four walls of the court.
Mr Donaldson hinted at his desire to look into the issue last month, when his office's annual report was tabled in Parliament.
"Because of the extraordinary nature of the orders made in the Alan Johns matter, I am likely to review at least certain parts of the NSI Act and commence this promptly," he wrote.
"I have seen correspondence from interested parties wishing to be consulted about this matter."
Mr Donaldson noted he wanted to review the entire NSI Act, but could not do so given high profile cases currently before the courts which are covered by the strict laws.
These include the prosecution of lawyer Bernard Collaery and the former senior spy known as 'Witness K', and defamation proceedings launched by Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-03-02/investigation-restarted-witness-j-secret-trial/13206154
#11770576 at 2020-11-24 22:10:00 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #15024: Work Together Edition
PM Scott Morrison and Kerry Stokes lead the charge to cover-up war crimes exposed by the Brereton Report
Kerry Stokes has been involved in trying to cover-up alleged Afghan war crimes since at least June 2018 when Stokes' employee and alleged war criminal Ben Roberts-Smith secretly met with former AFP Commissioner Mick Keelty. At the meeting, Keelty gave Ben Roberts-Smith illegally gained inside information from the AFP about whether or not they were investigating Roberts-Smith for war crimes. (Click here to read more)
But Stokes has now stepped up his defence to all the soldiers accused of war crimes. Many people have pointed out there is a conflict given Stokes is Chairman of the War Memorial Council but what is worse is that Stokes has a long history of using the legal system to try and cover-up his own criminal and corrupt conduct as well as the crimes of his staff.
Overview of the Brereton Report as per Wikipedia (Click here for a full copy of the Brereton Report)
The Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry Report, commonly known as the Brereton Report, is a report into war crimes committed by the Australian Defence Force (ADF) during the War in Afghanistan between 2005 and 2016. The investigation was led by Major General Paul Brereton. The independent commission was initiated by the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force in 2016 and delivered its final report on 6 November 2020. The redacted version was released publicly on 19 November 2020.
The report found evidence of 39 unlawful killings, primarily of civilians and prisoners, which had subsequently been covered up by ADF personnel. The report stated 25 ADF personnel were involved in the killings, including those who were "accessories" to the incident. The unlawful killings discussed by the report began in 2009, with most occurring in 2012 and 2013. (Click here to read more)
When the Brereton Report was released last Thursday (19/11/20), outlining alleged war crimes, it didn't take long for Kerry Stokes to issue a statement saying that he was funding Ben Roberts-Smith's legal fees for his defamation claim against The SMH and The Age newspapers. Stokes has continually refused to answer my emailed questions on the issue. (Click here and here to see the emails in previous articles)
Kerry Stokes also stated and/or implied that he would also likely fund other soldiers accused of alleged war crimes which drew plenty of criticism in the media. There was an obvious conflict in that Kerry Stokes is also chairman of the War Memorial and I Tweeted last Thursday (19/11/20):
https://kangaroocourtofaustralia.com/2020/11/25/scott-morrison-and-kerry-stokes-lead-the-charge-to-cover-up-war-crimes-exposed-by-the-brereton-report/
#11436828 at 2020-11-03 23:23:07 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #14607: Holding The Line Edition
>>11436589,Election Results trackers
#14606
>>11436589,Election Results trackers
>>11436711 New POTUS - WE ARE LOOKING REALLY GOOD ALL OVER THE COUNTRY. THANK YOU!
>>11436125 Election Night 2020 LIVE Coverage & Results 11/3/20
>>11436170 Troll Farms in India Made Up Large Portion of Biden Following on Twitter
>>11436171 The MSM needs to be switched off for GOOD. this fuckery is treasonous
>>11436173 David Icke has been suspended from Twitter. The election purge of accounts continues.
>>11436191 UPDATE: #Republicans now lead by in #Florida by 205,413 votes. Per FL GOP GOTV Tracker.
>>11436199 Flip this Anons!!
>>11436204 Today's the day. General Paul M. Nakasone
>>11436218 OPINION: This writer is a fake and gay
>>11436226 Call sign SPADESMA. Up from Holloman AFB to Hill AFB for a couple hours. Now up again. Top speed looks to be around 600 knots. ICAO hexidecimal code AE6B64 returns no results.
>>11436236 Portland Declares State Of Emergency Ahead Of Election Results
>>11436248 WarRoom: Global Election Night Special 2020 - Steve Bannon
>>11436264 BREAKING: USPS fails to meet deadline set by U.S. District Judge Emmet Sullivan to sweep facilities and immediately deliver remaining mail ballots. As of this week, USPS said there were some 300,000 ballots that lacked a delivery scan
>>11436267 NEW YORK TIMES DELETES TWEET
>>11436289 The Battle Hymn of the Republic
>>11436304 Philadelphia City Commissioners Say They Are Investigating After Video Allegedly Shows GOP Poll Watcher Getting Kicked Out Of Polling Place
>>11436320 Google Engineer Dies While Kayaking in Maine Pond
>>11436359 Trump Tower in New York is being surrounded with NYPD vehicles and personnel.
>>11436375 Bricks already showing up in Chicago and Denver. Keep yo head on a swivel
>>11436383 Navy Prepares For Integration Of MQ-25 Tanker Drones With E-2 Hawkeye Squadrons
>>11436386 National Guard units activated in 16 US states ahead of possible post-election unrest
>>11436426 GOING DARK
>>11436459 Terrorist Threat in Switzerland High, No Data About Possible Attacks, Intelligence Service Says
>>11436468 James Woods - This
>>11436513 "The Trump campaign, exuding eleventh-hour confidence, is revealing raw voter data that suggests to it that Joe Biden's lead in early voting will be swamped by a red wave of GOP voters on Election Day
>>11436518 NASCAR Driver Kyle Larson Fired From Racing Team For Using The N-Word
>>11436554 Trump: 'They Say You Cannot Win Without Big Tech, We're Going to Find Out'
>>11436558 Video of Amish Horse and Buggy Trump Train Goes Viral on Election Day
>>11436624 Governor Cuomo Calls into Question Federal Administration's Demand for ID Numbers of New Yorkers Who Receive COVID-19 Vaccine
>>11436629 Man drives 1,217 miles from LA to Texas to vote after not receiving mail-in ballot
>>11436730 Seven West Media executive and alleged war criminal Ben Roberts-Smith caught lying and deceiving the public in defamation case
>>11436758 Tracker on the Real Clear Politics home page.
>>11436791 Hunter Biden's Money Sex relationship: Credit card company messages reveal Hunter & Hallie have a joint credit card
>>11436815 #14606
Previously Collected Notables
>>11434526 #14603, >>11435273 #14604, >>11436052 #14605
>>11432215 #14600, >>11432992 #14601, >>11433737 #14602
>>11429557 #14597, >>11430674 #145978, >>11431423 #14599
>>11425869 #14593, >>11430531 #14594, >>11428207 #14596
>>11424316 #14591, >>11425112 #14592(p2), >>11425125 #14592(p1)
>>11421994 #14588, >>11422702 #14589, >>11423492 #14590
>>11418947 #14584, >>11420467 #14586, >>11421183 #14587
>>11416608 #14581, >>11417417 #14582, >>11418176 #14583
>>11414299 #14578, >>11415084 #14579, >>11415874 #14580
>>11411906 #14575, >>11412680 #14576, >>11413512 #14577
>>11409619 #14572, >>11410362 #14573, >>11411152 #14574
Notables Aggregators: https://wearethene.ws & https://qnotables.com
#11436815 at 2020-11-03 23:22:35 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #14606: We Shall Prevail Edition
#14606
>>11436589,Election Results trackers
>>11436711 New POTUS - WE ARE LOOKING REALLY GOOD ALL OVER THE COUNTRY. THANK YOU!
>>11436125 Election Night 2020 LIVE Coverage & Results 11/3/20
>>11436170 Troll Farms in India Made Up Large Portion of Biden Following on Twitter
>>11436171 The MSM needs to be switched off for GOOD. this fuckery is treasonous
>>11436173 David Icke has been suspended from Twitter. The election purge of accounts continues.
>>11436191 UPDATE: #Republicans now lead by in #Florida by 205,413 votes. Per FL GOP GOTV Tracker.
>>11436199 Flip this Anons!!
>>11436204 Today's the day. General Paul M. Nakasone
>>11436218 OPINION: This writer is a fake and gay
>>11436226 Call sign SPADESMA. Up from Holloman AFB to Hill AFB for a couple hours. Now up again. Top speed looks to be around 600 knots. ICAO hexidecimal code AE6B64 returns no results.
>>11436236 Portland Declares State Of Emergency Ahead Of Election Results
>>11436248 WarRoom: Global Election Night Special 2020 - Steve Bannon
>>11436264 BREAKING: USPS fails to meet deadline set by U.S. District Judge Emmet Sullivan to sweep facilities and immediately deliver remaining mail ballots. As of this week, USPS said there were some 300,000 ballots that lacked a delivery scan
>>11436267 NEW YORK TIMES DELETES TWEET
>>11436289 The Battle Hymn of the Republic
>>11436304 Philadelphia City Commissioners Say They Are Investigating After Video Allegedly Shows GOP Poll Watcher Getting Kicked Out Of Polling Place
>>11436320 Google Engineer Dies While Kayaking in Maine Pond
>>11436359 Trump Tower in New York is being surrounded with NYPD vehicles and personnel.
>>11436375 Bricks already showing up in Chicago and Denver. Keep yo head on a swivel
>>11436383 Navy Prepares For Integration Of MQ-25 Tanker Drones With E-2 Hawkeye Squadrons
>>11436386 National Guard units activated in 16 US states ahead of possible post-election unrest
>>11436426 GOING DARK
>>11436459 Terrorist Threat in Switzerland High, No Data About Possible Attacks, Intelligence Service Says
>>11436468 James Woods - This
>>11436513 "The Trump campaign, exuding eleventh-hour confidence, is revealing raw voter data that suggests to it that Joe Biden's lead in early voting will be swamped by a red wave of GOP voters on Election Day
>>11436518 NASCAR Driver Kyle Larson Fired From Racing Team For Using The N-Word
>>11436554 Trump: 'They Say You Cannot Win Without Big Tech, We're Going to Find Out'
>>11436558 Video of Amish Horse and Buggy Trump Train Goes Viral on Election Day
>>11436624 Governor Cuomo Calls into Question Federal Administration's Demand for ID Numbers of New Yorkers Who Receive COVID-19 Vaccine
>>11436629 Man drives 1,217 miles from LA to Texas to vote after not receiving mail-in ballot
>>11436730 Seven West Media executive and alleged war criminal Ben Roberts-Smith caught lying and deceiving the public in defamation case
>>11436758 Tracker on the Real Clear Politics home page.
>>11436791 Hunter Biden's Money Sex relationship: Credit card company messages reveal Hunter & Hallie have a joint credit card
#11436737 at 2020-11-03 23:18:50 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #14606: We Shall Prevail Edition
#14606
>>11436589,Election Results trackers
>>11436711 New POTUS
>>11436125 Election Night 2020 LIVE Coverage & Results 11/3/20
>>11436170 Troll Farms in India Made Up Large Portion of Biden Following on Twitter
>>11436171 The MSM needs to be switched off for GOOD. this fuckery is treasonous
>>11436173 David Icke has been suspended from Twitter. The election purge of accounts continues.
>>11436191 UPDATE: #Republicans now lead by in #Florida by 205,413 votes. Per FL GOP GOTV Tracker.
>>11436199 Flip this Anons!!
>>11436204 Today's the day. General Paul M. Nakasone
>>11436218 OPINION: This writer is a fake and gay
>>11436226 Call sign SPADESMA. Up from Holloman AFB to Hill AFB for a couple hours. Now up again. Top speed looks to be around 600 knots. ICAO hexidecimal code AE6B64 returns no results.
>>11436236 Portland Declares State Of Emergency Ahead Of Election Results
>>11436248 WarRoom: Global Election Night Special 2020 - Steve Bannon
>>11436264 BREAKING: USPS fails to meet deadline set by U.S. District Judge Emmet Sullivan to sweep facilities and immediately deliver remaining mail ballots. As of this week, USPS said there were some 300,000 ballots that lacked a delivery scan
>>11436267 NEW YORK TIMES DELETES TWEET
>>11436289 The Battle Hymn of the Republic
>>11436304 Philadelphia City Commissioners Say They Are Investigating After Video Allegedly Shows GOP Poll Watcher Getting Kicked Out Of Polling Place
>>11436320 Google Engineer Dies While Kayaking in Maine Pond
>>11436359 Trump Tower in New York is being surrounded with NYPD vehicles and personnel.
>>11436375 Bricks already showing up in Chicago and Denver. Keep yo head on a swivel
>>11436383 Navy Prepares For Integration Of MQ-25 Tanker Drones With E-2 Hawkeye Squadrons
>>11436386 National Guard units activated in 16 US states ahead of possible post-election unrest
>>11436426 GOING DARK
>>11436459 Terrorist Threat in Switzerland High, No Data About Possible Attacks, Intelligence Service Says
>>11436468 James Woods - This
>>11436513 "The Trump campaign, exuding eleventh-hour confidence, is revealing raw voter data that suggests to it that Joe Biden's lead in early voting will be swamped by a red wave of GOP voters on Election Day
>>11436518 NASCAR Driver Kyle Larson Fired From Racing Team For Using The N-Word
>>11436554 Trump: 'They Say You Cannot Win Without Big Tech, We're Going to Find Out'
>>11436558 Video of Amish Horse and Buggy Trump Train Goes Viral on Election Day
>>11436624 Governor Cuomo Calls into Question Federal Administration's Demand for ID Numbers of New Yorkers Who Receive COVID-19 Vaccine
>>11436629 Man drives 1,217 miles from LA to Texas to vote after not receiving mail-in ballot
>>11436730 Seven West Media executive and alleged war criminal Ben Roberts-Smith caught lying and deceiving the public in defamation case
#11436730 at 2020-11-03 23:18:27 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #14606: We Shall Prevail Edition
Seven West Media executive and alleged war criminal Ben Roberts-Smith caught lying and deceiving the public in defamation case
Alleged war criminal Ben Roberts-Smith is digging a massive hole for himself trying to avoid criminal charges for alleged war crimes by running a blocking manoeuvre by suing for defamation hoping that will stifle any criminal charges being laid.
The latest reports have Mr Roberts-Smith wife giving evidence in the defamation matter via an affidavit that Mr Roberts-Smith asked her to lie and say they were separated when he had an affair with a lawyer who he allegedly punched in the face after a function at parliament house.
To make matters worse Ben Roberts-Smith's lawyers and/or PR people leaked the documents to the media but blacked out the part where his wife said she was asked to lie. On Monday (2/11/20) lawyers for The SMH and The Age were in court and complained. Not long after the SMH published an article and said:
Mr Roberts-Smith is currently suing Nine Entertainment papers The SMH and The Age "over reports he allegedly committed murder on deployments to Afghanistan and that he punched his mistress in the face in Canberra."
He denies the allegations and says the reports are defamatory because they portray him as a criminal.
The news outlets are defending the claim on a truth defence. The defamation trial is to start next year.
Ben Roberts-Smith asked his wife to lie about an affair he had with another woman, a court has heard, amid revelations the former Australian soldier heavily redacted information from documents sent to news outlets as part of a defamation case.
On Monday the Federal Court was told that without its permission Mr Roberts-Smith redacted information from documents before they were sent to the news outlets as part of the defamation case.
Barrister Lyndelle Barnett, appearing for the news outlets, told the court on Monday the information in the affidavits raised questions about the credibility of Mr and Ms Roberts-Smith, which could be an issue at trial. Ms Roberts-Smith is expected to be called as a witness for her husband.
Bruce McClintock, SC, appearing for Mr Roberts-Smith, said the material was redacted from the documents because it was "deeply personal" and irrelevant to the allegations at the centre of the defamation trial.
But Ms Barnett said a party didn't have the right to redact information without a court's permission. (Click here to read more)
Earlier in the day on Monday, before they went to court, journalist Nick McKenzie, who is also being sued by Ben Roberts-Smith in the same defamation matter, Tweeted the below Tweet.
https://kangaroocourtofaustralia.com/2020/11/04/seven-west-media-executive-and-alleged-war-criminal-Ben-Roberts-Smith-caught-lying-and-deceiving-the-public-in-defamation-case/
#7551395 at 2019-12-18 23:52:58 (UTC+1)
Q Research General #9660: Rally Bread! Hold the Line!! Edition
On the run with fugitive Australian journalist Shane Dowling
I'm arguably a fugitive journalist given I moved interstate to avoid the police and courts in NSW but the main person chasing me and trying to jail me again is actually the media companies Seven West Media, the Channel Seven Network and SWM's nutter chairman Kerry Stokes.
The definition of a fugitive is: "A fugitive from justice, also known as a wanted person, can be a person who is either convicted or accused of a crime and hiding from law enforcement in the state or taking refuge in a different country in order to avoid arrest"
While I am not quite there yet, Seven West Media and the Channel Seven Network, under the instruction of Kerry Stokes, have told me in an email they will be seeking to have me jailed again next year and I moved interstate after harassment by NSW judges who made it clear I will not receive justice in NSW courts and also after the Supreme Court sent NSW police to harass me further. I figured between Stokes, Seven West Media, the NSW Supreme Court judges and the NSW police someone was going to stitch me up for jail again in the near future so it was time to move.
Some people might try and blame me because of the articles I write, but right on cue, it was reported on Melbourne's The Age website that Kerry Stokes is trying the same game against Nine Entertainmnet journalist Nick McKenzie and Chris Masters.
The Age reported (16/12/19) that "The Australian Federal Police has launched a second war crimes investigation into Australia's most decorated living soldier, former special services corporal Ben Roberts-Smith."
Trouble for Ben Roberts-Smith grows by the day as the investigation into his conduct grows wider but that is not what this article is about. What is relevant to this article is what The Age said in relation to what Kerry Stokes and Ben Roberts-Smith have done to try and silence The Age's journalists:
Mr Roberts-Smith has hired a team of lawyers including top barrister, Arthur Moses SC, and a public relations firm to counter the allegations, which he vehemently denies. Experienced PR executive Sue Cato and former journalist Ross Coulthart are being supported by billionaire media mogul, Seven West Media chairman Kerry Stokes, a backer of Mr Roberts-Smith who employed him as a senior manager in 2015.
Mr Stokes is also backing the defamation proceedings Mr Roberts-Smith has launched against Fairfax Media - now known as Nine - for a series of investigative reports about his alleged misconduct. Last week, Nine Entertainment lawyers fought efforts in the Federal Court brought by Mr Roberts-Smith to force journalists to reveal their sources.
On Friday, the federal president of the journalists' union, Marcus Strom, issued a statement backing Nine's legal fight to protect its reporters' sources by invoking source shield laws.
"There is no higher principle for journalists the world over," Mr Strom said. "To discard the shield at a time when the public's right to know is already under assault would further damage press freedom in Australia."
The Age and Herald have already flagged an appeal if they should lose the battle to keep their sources protected.
The court has reserved its decision (Click here to read the full article)
https://kangaroocourtofaustralia.com/2019/12/17/on-the-run-with-fugitive-australian-journalist-shane-dowling/
8chan/8kun QResearch AUSTRALIA Posts (277)
#21755103 at 2024-10-13 03:31:27 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #37: EVERYTHING IS AT STAKE Edition
#36 - Part 49
Australian Politics and Society - Part 25
>>21575731 Military is happy to buy arms off Israel, says Chief of Army - Israel's top arms companies have defied protesters and rising international criticism over the war in Gaza to spruik cutting-edge capabilities at the Land Forces expo in Melbourne, as Australia's Chief of Army declared he had no problem buying weapons from the Jewish state. As pro-Palestine protests turned violent outside the biennial weapons fair, Israel's biggest weapons manufacturer IAI said it was ready to provide the ADF with "whatever they need" at a "competitive price" to deal with advanced threats. Another Israeli company, ?Rafael, said its air defence systems offered "amazing interception rates", pointing to the country's almost complete success in taking out more than 300 Iranian drones and missiles in April. Chief of Army Lieutenant General Simon Stuart said he saw no obstacle to the service purchasing more Israeli equipment if it could protect Australian personnel. "We've certainly purchased a range of (Israeli) equipment over the years," he told The Australian. "What we want to do is ensure we've got the best possible equipment we can possibly get our hands on to ensure that our people have the best chance of fulfilling their mission ... and coming home to their families." The West's biggest weapons companies, including the US's Lockheed Martin, Raytheon, and Northrop Grumman, and Britain's BAE Systems, are among hundreds of exhibitors at the three-day Land Forces expo.
>>21575759 'National shame': Richard Marles strips medals from Afghanistan war commanders - Defence Minister Richard Marles has stripped distinguished service medals from commanding officers who held senior roles during the war in Afghanistan, taking up the key remaining recommendation of the Brereton inquiry into alleged war crimes by Australian troops. Marles' long-awaited move, which comes just days after the release of the final royal commission report into veteran suicide, has infuriated veterans groups who say the officers involved are being unfairly punished for others' alleged wrongdoing. The decision does not affect those accused of war crimes themselves, such as Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith. A Federal Court judge, applying the civil standard of the balance of probabilities, found that Roberts-Smith was complicit in the murder of four unarmed civilians in Afghanistan during a defamation case against this masthead last year. He has not been charged with any crime and maintains his innocence. A government source said the Brereton report did not deal with bravery medals such as the Victoria Cross, and that Marles' response was limited to responding to that inquiry. The honours issue has been sitting on Marles' desk since May 2023, when then-Defence Force chief Angus Campbell wrote to a small group of Afghan veterans to inform them he had recommended the minister terminate their awards for distinguished and conspicuous service on warlike operations. The government has declined to identify the names of the officers who have been stripped of their medals, and has not revealed exactly how many people received letters from Marles informing them of his decision. Government sources who were not authorised to speak publicly said that up to nine people had been stripped of their awards and fewer than 15 people received letters from Marles. This suggests Marles rejected Campbell's recommendation for a handful of officers, allowing them to retain their honours. Most are understood to have left the Defence Force.
>>21575904 U.S. Embassy Australia Tweet: Charg? d'Affaires Erika Olson joined Chief of @AustralianArmy Lieutenant Stuart and @USARPAC General Flynn in Melbourne to remember the 2,977 lives lost - including the lives of 10 Australians - on September 11, 2001.
>>21575909 General Charles A. Flynn Tweet: Lest we forget... Honored to join LTGEN Stuart, CdA Erika Olson, GEN Rainey and LtGen Turner at the 9/11 memorial service at the Shrine of Remembrance in Melbourne, Australia. "We will remember them" with our @AustralianArmy allies. #ArmyinthePacific #AlliesandPartners
>>21575913 U.S. Embassy Australia Tweet: Today, we remember the 2,977 lives lost - including 10 Australians - on September 11, 2001. To honor them, our embassy community gathered for a moment of reflection.
#21575759 at 2024-09-12 09:16:00 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #37: EVERYTHING IS AT STAKE Edition
>>21561766
'National shame': Richard Marles strips medals from Afghanistan war commanders
Matthew Knott - September 12, 2024
1/2
Defence Minister Richard Marles has stripped distinguished service medals from commanding officers who held senior roles during the war in Afghanistan, taking up the key remaining recommendation of the Brereton inquiry into alleged war crimes by Australian troops.
Marles' long-awaited move, which comes just days after the release of the final royal commission report into veteran suicide, has infuriated veterans groups who say the officers involved are being unfairly punished for others' alleged wrongdoing.
The decision does not affect those accused of war crimes themselves, such as Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith.
A Federal Court judge, applying the civil standard of the balance of probabilities, found that Roberts-Smith was complicit in the murder of four unarmed civilians in Afghanistan during a defamation case against this masthead last year. He has not been charged with any crime and maintains his innocence.
A government source said the Brereton report did not deal with bravery medals such as the Victoria Cross, and that Marles' response was limited to responding to that inquiry.
The honours issue has been sitting on Marles' desk since May 2023, when then-Defence Force chief Angus Campbell wrote to a small group of Afghan veterans to inform them he had recommended the minister terminate their awards for distinguished and conspicuous service on warlike operations.
The government has declined to identify the names of the officers who have been stripped of their medals, and has not revealed exactly how many people received letters from Marles on Wednesday informing them of his decision.
Government sources who were not authorised to speak publicly said that up to nine people had been stripped of their awards and fewer than 15 people received letters from Marles.
This suggests Marles rejected Campbell's recommendation for a handful of officers, allowing them to retain their honours.
Most are understood to have left the Defence Force.
In a speech to parliament on Thursday, Marles said the Brereton inquiry had examined "arguably the most serious allegations of Australian war crimes in our history".
"This will always be a matter of national shame," he said.
Marles said his decision to remove honours from some commanders "was consistent with the findings and recommendations of the Brereton report".
"In accordance with obligations owed to individuals involved, including under the Privacy Act, I am prohibited from disclosing the details and outcomes," he said.
Marles paid tribute to the "sacred service" of the vast majority of Australian Defence personnel and commended those who told the truth about what happened in Afghanistan.
"These people whose names are not heralded, have changed our country for the better. Today, we honour them."
The decision does not have any promotion consequences for those who have been stripped of their honours, and it is up to individuals to decide whether they want to surrender their physical medals.
Opposition defence spokesman Andrew Hastie said it was important for Australia to "learn from this tragic and bitter chapter in our military history", but did not directly address the stripping of medals from the former commanders.
"The Brereton report was painful as it unearthed painful truths about some of our conduct in the Afghan war," Hastie, a former SAS soldier who served in Afghanistan, said in a reply to Marles' speech. "Reputations both personal and institutional have been damaged."
He choked with emotion in his response, saying "our soldiers must tell the truth, and those in leadership must seek it out. If both our soldiers and our leaders had done so, we might not be in this place today. But here we are, and it has been a tough reckoning."
(continued)
#21326176 at 2024-07-31 11:11:10 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #37: EVERYTHING IS AT STAKE Edition
Afghanistan medal decision before election, says Deputy Prime Minister
Robert Dougherty - 30 JULY 2024
Australian Deputy Prime Minister Richard Marles has confirmed a decision will be made about stripping medals from Australian Defence Force personnel, before the next election.
The Ministry for Defence confirmed that a decision regarding those accused of conducting war crimes in Afghanistan would be made 'before the election' and 'soon', earlier this week. The date of the next Federal Election has not been confirmed, but is expected before May next year.
The discussion follows the release findings from the 2020 Brereton inquiry, which investigated alleged war crimes committed by Australian Defence Force during the War in Afghanistan between 2005 and 2016.
Former Chief of the Australian Defence Force Angus Campbell had also reportedly written to current and former ADF members notifying that honours for distinguished and conspicuous service on warlike operations could be withdrawn.
"I will be making the decision before the election, I can tell you that. I'll be making that decision soon," Deputy PM Marles said during an interview with Sky News on July 28.
"Just to be clear, this is a decision not in relation to the person (Ben Roberts-Smith) that you mentioned, but in relation to those who had command authority.
"That is a process that I've wanted to go through thoroughly to make sure that we get the answers to this right.
"It is one that has been on my desk and we've been going through in an enormous amount of detail, but it won't be long before we are able to make those decisions and certainly, they'll be made before the election."
Earlier this month, the Australian Government reportedly unveiled compensation plans for families of victims unlawfully killed or abused by Australian special forces in Afghanistan. A newly established Afghanistan Inquiry Compensation Advocate will assess claims referred by the Chief of Defence Force, but final decisions rest with the CDF.
The Deputy PM also encouraged patience as another inquiry continues into the 2023 Lindeman Island MRH-90 Taipan crash, in which four Australian Army aircrew were lost, on 28 July 2023.
The crash, in which an Australian Army MRH-90 Taipan helicopter impacted waters near Lindeman Island during a night-time training activity as part of Exercise Talisman Sabre 2023, recently passed its first anniversary this month.
"This is a significant day. It's a very difficult day for the families of Captain Lyon, Lieutenant Nugent, Warrant Officer Laycock and Corporal Naggs," according to the Deputy PM.
"These four Australians, who had given great service to our country wearing our nation's uniform, lost their lives a year ago. I know that this is a really difficult day for their families, for the 6th Aviation Regiment, of which they were a part.
"And it's a reminder that the work that our men and women who wear our uniform do is dangerous, even when they're engaging in exercises and their service, and indeed, their sacrifice is as meaningful as that of anyone who has worn our nation's uniform.
"The inquiry in relation to this proceeds, it needs to take the time that it takes because we need to find out what happened here and we need to learn the lessons.
"It's really important that those lessons are learnt for future safety. And we don't do that off the back of speculation, we do it off the back of facts and this is just going to take the time that it takes. But obviously we work with the families to let them know how the investigations are proceeding and they will continue to go on until we get the answers behind this terrible tragedy."
https://www.defenceconnect.com.au/land/14478-afghanistan-medal-decision-before-election-says-deputy-prime-minister
#20959181 at 2024-06-03 10:04:46 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #36: BADGE OF HONOR Edition
>>20945301
The four reasons Bruce Lehrmann thinks his appeal should succeed
Michaela Whitbourn - June 3, 2024
Bruce Lehrmann has urged an appeal court to overturn a finding that he raped his then-colleague Brittany Higgins in Parliament House, arguing that the evidence before the court did not support that conclusion.
In a notice of appeal, filed in the Federal Court on Friday, Lehrmann sets out four grounds of appeal against the landmark decision of Justice Michael Lee on April 15 to dismiss his defamation suit against Network Ten and high-profile presenter Lisa Wilkinson.
Lehrmann has asked the Full Court of the Federal Court to set aside Lee's decision and enter judgment in his favour. The handwritten words "Bruce Lehrmann" appear next to a line on the appeal form asking who prepared the document.
It is not yet clear if a solicitor or barrister will act for him during any hearing.
'Credibility problems'
The former federal Liberal staffer claims he was denied procedural fairness during his defamation case. He alleges Lee made findings in relation to Ten and Wilkinson's successful truth defence that were not put to him when he gave evidence in the Federal Court last year.
The judge's finding that the truth defence was established was "contrary to evidence" and did not meet the standard of proof, Lehrmann claims.
He alleges Higgins had "significant credibility problems" and the court should not have been satisfied on the balance of probabilities that Lehrmann had raped Higgins in Parliament House in 2019, in light of a principle known as the Briginshaw standard that requires a court to proceed cautiously in making grave findings.
Lee said in his judgment that he had "considerable doubts about the authenticity" of a photo purportedly of a bruise on Higgins' leg. The judge said he fell "well short of being satisfied" Lehrmann caused a bruise, and was not satisfied Higgins fell up a flight of stairs at a nightclub "so as to sustain the bruise".
Lehrmann claimed that Ten and Wilkinson regarded this photo as "cornerstone 'evidence' " and, following the judge's finding about this photo and other evidence, it "was not open to the Judge to find the case he did".
Hypothetical damages inadequate
Lehrmann also says Lee's assessment that he would only have been entitled to $20,000 if he had won the defamation case was "wholly inadequate".
Lehrmann launched defamation proceedings against Ten and Wilkinson last year over a February 2021 interview with Higgins, aired on The Project.
Defamatory meanings
He claimed the broadcast conveyed a series of defamatory meanings including that he raped Higgins in Parliament House, continued to rape her "after she woke up mid-rape and was crying and telling him to stop at least half a dozen times", and "crushed his leg against her leg so forcefully as to cause a large bruise". Lehrmann denied there was any sexual contact between the pair at all.
Lee found on the balance of probabilities that Lehrmann had raped Higgins, and was indifferent to whether she was consenting. The judge did not accept that it had been established that Higgins woke up mid-rape and was crying and telling Lehrmann to stop, or that he caused a large bruise on her leg.
But the judge found that the "defamatory sting" of each of the meanings was that Lehrmann raped Higgins, and the truth defence had been established by proving that assault.
Lehrmann has fashioned an appeal ground from that finding. He says that The Project broadcast suggested "a violent rape" and this was "contrary to the non-violent rape … which was ultimately found".
Funds for appeal
It is not yet clear how Lehrmann, who is an unemployed law student, would fund an appeal.
War veteran Ben Roberts-Smith agreed last year to orders requiring him to pay almost $1 million as security to cover the legal costs of Nine newspapers in the event he loses his appeal against his own devastating defamation loss. Ten and Wilkinson may also seek security for costs from Lehrmann.
An appeal would not require witnesses, including Higgins and Wilkinson, to give evidence afresh.
If the appeal proceeds, either of Wilkinson or Ten may opt to challenge the judge's finding that their fallback defence of qualified privilege would have failed if the truth defence had not been established.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/the-four-reasons-bruce-lehrmann-thinks-his-appeal-should-succeed-20240603-p5jisf.html
#20886325 at 2024-05-19 08:31:20 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #36: BADGE OF HONOR Edition
#35 - Part 54
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial
>>20864699 David McBride: Australian army whistleblower jailed for leaking documents - A whistleblower who helped expose allegations of Australian war crimes in Afghanistan has been sentenced to five years and eight months in jail. David McBride pleaded guilty to stealing and sharing military secrets on the eve of his trial last year, after legal rulings sunk his defence. An ex-military lawyer, McBride said he felt a moral duty to speak up. A landmark inquiry later found evidence that Australian forces had unlawfully killed 39 Afghans during the war. McBride's case has sparked uproar in Australia, putting a spotlight on what some say are flimsy whistleblower protections and slow progress towards prosecuting soldiers alleged to have killed with impunity under its flag. McBride, 60, admits he gave troves of document to the Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC), saying he was concerned about the attitudes of commanders and what he then thought was the "over-investigation" of troops, the court heard. But instead the information he provided underpinned a series of reports in 2017 called The Afghan Files, which gave unprecedented insight into the operations of Australia's elite special forces in Afghanistan, and contained allegations of war crimes.
>>20864718 David McBride sentenced to five years, eight months jail for leaking classified military documents - Former army legal officer David McBride, 60, has been sentenced to five years and eight months jail, with a non-parole period of 27 months, for stealing classified ?Defence secrets and sharing them with journalists. ACT Supreme Court Justice David Mossop found McBride had committed a "gross breach of trust" and had shown "no contrition for his offending". McBride's supporters cried "shame on you" as Justice Mossop delivered the sentence. His legal team vowed an appeal. McBride - who served two tours in Afghanistan - leaked the classified documents to the ABC, which used them to produce its 2017 Afghan Files reports alleging a cover-up of war crimes by Australian soldiers. The judge said McBride's conduct had caused significant harm to the commonwealth by releasing Defence ?secrets, including its rules of engagement in Afghanistan. He said Australia's foreign partners had to be informed of the leak, which may have "reduced their willingness to share information with Australia". Justice Mossop said the release of the information risked informing Australia's adversaries on the ADF's use of force and its limitations, offering them a "technical advantage".
>>20868853 Diggers' anger as commanders duck responsibility for war crimes, report warns - The refusal of the nation's military leaders to accept responsibility for war crimes in Afghanistan has generated "anger and bitter resentment" among serving personnel and veterans that will take years to overcome, an independent panel has warned. The Afghanistan Inquiry Implementation Oversight Panel says in its final report to Anthony Albanese and Defence Minister Richard Marles that it does not accept the Brereton inquiry's finding that senior commanders should not be held accountable for the murders of 39 Afghans by up to 25 special forces soldiers. It says there has been "an unmet need for Defence senior leadership to communicate to the serving and ex-serving ranks of the ADF that they collectively accept organisational responsibility and accountability for part of what went wrong in Afghanistan". "There is ongoing anger and bitter resentment amongst present and former members of the special forces, many of whom served with distinction in Afghanistan, that their senior officers have not publicly accepted some responsibility for policies or decisions that contributed to the misconduct, such as the overuse of special forces," the panel warns. The report, obtained by The Australian, says the resentment among special forces soldiers was "expressed forcefully and repeatedly to the panel by Defence members of all ranks" during visits to SAS and 2nd Commando Regiment headquarters.
#20545591 at 2024-03-10 08:49:07 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #34: UNITED AGAINST THE INVISIBLE ENEMY OF ALL HUMANITY Edition
#34 - Part 32
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 2
>>20400727 'No evidence' slain Afghan men were armed, Roberts-Smith appeal told - There was "no evidence" that two Afghan men allegedly murdered by or at the direction of Ben Roberts-Smith were armed at the time of their death, the barrister acting for the newspapers at the centre of the former elite soldier's high-stakes defamation appeal has said. There is no dispute the two Afghan men were killed during this mission, but Roberts-Smith gave evidence during the trial that they were enemy combatants killed lawfully in action by him and a second soldier. Roberts-Smith told the court the two men were armed with a machine-gun and a rifle respectively, which were shown in a photo tendered in court. But a serving SAS soldier dubbed Person 18, who was called by the newspapers to give evidence at the trial, told the court that he found those specific guns among a weapons cache in a hay store at Whiskey 108. Besanko accepted Person 18's account on this point and rejected Roberts-Smith's evidence.
>>20405678 Witnesses to murder by Roberts-Smith gave strikingly similar accounts, appeal told - The evidence of three key witnesses about the murder of a prisoner with a prosthetic leg by disgraced SAS soldier Ben Roberts-Smith was strikingly coherent and contained only very minor differences, a court has heard. Nicholas Owens SC, acting for the newspapers, is urging the full court of the Federal Court not to overturn Besanko's decision, and argued on Tuesday the court should believe the accounts of three witnesses, dubbed Persons 41, 14 and 24, in relation to two of the alleged murders.
>>20411157 Judges urged to ignore 'attack' on Afghans who gave evidence of Roberts-Smith murder - Afghan witnesses who gave detailed evidence about the murder of villager Ali Jan by Australian soldier Ben Roberts-Smith should be believed, despite efforts by the disgraced SAS soldier's legal team to attack their credibility during his defamation trial, a court has been told. Nicholas Owens SC on Wednesday attacked the substance of Roberts-Smith's appeal, urging the justices to believe the evidence given by witnesses from a remote Afghan village who were present when Roberts-Smith murdered Jan in 2012.
>>20417104 'Event of startling gravity': Newspapers back SAS soldier's account of execution - The newspapers defending Ben Roberts-Smith's high-stakes defamation appeal have told a court an elite soldier who testified that the war veteran ordered an unlawful execution with the words "shoot him, or I will" could hardly have misremembered an event of such "startling gravity". Nicholas Owens, acting for The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald, told the Full Court of the Federal Court in Sydney on Thursday that a serving Special Air Service soldier, dubbed Person 14, called by the newspapers to give evidence in the defamation trial, had "stuck to his guns" when accused of lying by Roberts-Smith's team. He was "ultimately vindicated, and powerfully so", Owens said, because key parts of his account that had been disputed by Roberts-Smith's camp were found to be supported by objective evidence.
>>20422752 Roberts-Smith's barrister cautions court against 'amateur sleuthing' - Sydney silk Bret Walker SC, the barrister acting for Ben Roberts-Smith in his high-stakes defamation appeal, has cautioned the Federal Court against "amateur sleuthing" as he urged a trio of judges to overturn a devastating decision dismissing the war veteran's lawsuit. Walker said "the heart of our case" was that "weight is to be given to the presumption of innocence" and "exactness of proof is expected". In this case, "you certainly don't have that", Walker told the three-judge Bench of the evidence marshalled by The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald.
#20545589 at 2024-03-10 08:48:34 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #34: UNITED AGAINST THE INVISIBLE ENEMY OF ALL HUMANITY Edition
#34 - Part 31
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 1
>>20359662 No 'nefarious' cover up in Ben Roberts-Smith case, soldier's lawyers say - Evidence relied upon in throwing out former SAS soldier Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation case against Nine newspapers was at times contradicted official military documentation, the Federal Court has heard. Roberts-Smith appeared at the Federal Court on Monday morning for the first day of his appeal against a landmark defamation judgement handed down by Justice Anthony Besanko, who found that he was involved in the unlawful killings of four prisoners in Afghanistan. Roberts-Smith, who has consistently denied the allegations, is arguing Justice Besanko erred in his findings regarding the six articles in The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times, and has asked the court to set aside the judgment. Leading appellate silk Bret Walker SC on Monday argued Roberts-Smith was entitled to a presumption of innocence, and claimed Justice Besanko did not properly give regard to the gravity of the allegations when he made his findings.
>>20365364 Planting object on Afghan's body may not point to murder cover-up, Roberts-Smith appeal told - The barrister acting for war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith in his appeal against the loss of his defamation case has told an appeal court that even a finding that Australian soldiers planted a Taliban-issued radio on an Afghan man's body would not necessarily suggest a murder cover-up. Roberts-Smith is appealing against a damaging decision by Federal Court Justice Anthony Besanko last year, which dismissed his defamation suit against The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald and found the newspapers had proven he was complicit in the murder of four unarmed prisoners while on deployment in Afghanistan. Of the four murders found proven by Besanko, one involved an allegation the former Special Air Service corporal kicked an unarmed and handcuffed Afghan villager named Ali Jan off a small cliff in Darwan on September 11, 2012, before procuring a soldier under his command to shoot him. Under the rules of engagement that bound the SAS, killing unarmed prisoners is a war crime. Roberts-Smith's barrister, Bret Walker, SC, told the Full Court of the Federal Court on Tuesday that there was insufficiently cogent evidence available to Besanko to make such a grave finding.
>>20371359 'Tell him to shoot him or I will': Dispute over key SAS witness - There was "nowhere near" enough evidence for the judge presiding over Ben Roberts-Smith's high-profile defamation case to find the war veteran ordered the unlawful execution of an Afghan prisoner by uttering the words "tell him to shoot him or I will", his barrister has told an appeal court. Roberts-Smith's 10-day appeal over his devastating defamation loss against The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald entered its third day on Wednesday as his barrister, Bret Walker, SC, told the Full Court of the Federal Court that murder findings should not have been made against his client.
>>20383213 'Not like a detective novel': Court urged to reject Roberts-Smith appeal - Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation case was "not like a detective novel" where there could be multiple explanations for killings in Afghanistan, and a decision finding he engaged in war crimes should not be overturned, the barrister acting for the media outlets at the centre of the lawsuit has said. Nicholas Owens, SC, acting for The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald, urged the Full Court of the Federal Court on Friday to reject the former soldier's appeal against Justice Anthony Besanko's historic decision last year dismissing his multimillion-dollar defamation suit against the newspapers. Owens told the court that Roberts-Smith's barrister, Bret Walker, SC, had raised hypothetical scenarios during the appeal, including that Australian soldiers might be motivated to plant a Taliban-issued object on the body of an Afghan man killed legitimately in war to help avoid unnecessary questions about whether the killing was in fact lawful.
#20520000 at 2024-03-05 09:01:23 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #34: UNITED AGAINST THE INVISIBLE ENEMY OF ALL HUMANITY Edition
>>20519996
2/2
In a statement published on her Facebook page, Reynolds said the settlement was the "fifth defamation claim I have resolved to my satisfaction".
"Since the conclusion of the criminal trial R v Lehrmann and Ms Brittany Higgins' compensation claim against the Commonwealth, I have set about vindicating my reputation, which I consider has been wrongly damaged," the senator said.
The ACT government said it "unreservedly retracts those allegations … [and] sincerely apologises for the damage, distress and embarrassment it has caused to Senator Reynolds."
Separately, the ACT Supreme Court's Acting Justice Stephen Kaye found on Monday that the Board of Inquiry finding that Mr Drumgold's cross examination was unethical should be set aside.
Justice Kaye found that Mr Drumgold had failed to establish seven of the eight arguments pursued on the ground of legal unreasonableness, but ruled that Sofronoff's finding that Drumgold had behaved unethically in his questioning of Senator Reynolds during Lehrmann's trial was unreasonable.
Senator Reynolds, who was awarded $90,000 by the ACT Government on Monday in a separate action, has also secured an undisclosed legal settlement from HarperCollins over Aaron Patrick's book Ego.
The Liberal Senator is seeking an apology and damages over the tweets, which they said were "inaccurate and professionally damaging."
Ms Higgins is represented by top silk Nicholas Owens, SC, who led Nine's successful defence in the Ben Roberts-Smith matter.
Meanwhile, the man who led the judicial inquiry into the Lehrmann trial, Walter Sofronoff, has been criticised over "private and secret" text messages with a columnist at The Australian Janet Albrechtsen that gave rise to "a reasonable apprehension of bias" against the former top prosecutor Shane Drumgold.
In a written judgement published on Monday afternoon, Justice Stephen Kaye likened the journalist and the judge to "fellow travellers".
However, he upheld the majority of Mr Sofronoff's findings against Mr Drumgold.
"The fair-minded observer might fairly apprehend that, at that point, Mr Sofronoff regarded himself as a 'fellow traveller' of Ms Albrechtsen in respect of the views that she had expressed and maintained in her publications about the plaintiff," Justice Kaye wrote.
"The observer might also apprehend that, as such, Mr Sofronoff regarded it as appropriate to exchange views with Ms Albrechtsen about specific issues which he was required to determine in the inquiry."
Justice Kaye also found that the criticism of Mr Drumgold's cross examination of Senator Reynolds was unreasonable.
"I have concluded that the finding by the first defendant that the plaintiff had engaged in grossly unethical conduct in his cross examination as Senator Reynolds is legally unreasonable," he said.
https://www.news.com.au/national/courts-law/linda-reynolds-defamation-action-could-bankrupt-brittany-higgins-partner-david-sharaz/news-story/098189b7333a283fe0eb326791c16291
#20422752 at 2024-02-16 12:12:47 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #34: UNITED AGAINST THE INVISIBLE ENEMY OF ALL HUMANITY Edition
>>20359662
Roberts-Smith's barrister cautions court against 'amateur sleuthing'
Michaela Whitbourn - February 16, 2024
The barrister acting for Ben Roberts-Smith in his high-stakes defamation appeal has cautioned a court against "amateur sleuthing" as he urged a trio of judges to overturn a devastating decision dismissing the war veteran's lawsuit.
Sydney silk Bret Walker, SC, who has acted in a string of high-profile appeals, delivered submissions in reply on Friday after The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald argued the Full Court of the Federal Court should not overturn Justice Anthony Besanko's decision delivered last year. It marked the final day of the 10-day appeal and the court reserved its decision.
Besanko last June found the newspapers had proven to the civil standard - on the balance of probabilities - that Roberts-Smith was complicit in the murder of four unarmed prisoners while on deployment in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012. This is lower than the criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt. Roberts-Smith maintains his innocence.
Walker said "the heart of our case" was that "weight is to be given to the presumption of innocence" and "exactness of proof is expected". In this case, "you certainly don't have that", Walker told the three-judge Bench of the evidence marshalled by the newspapers.
"Of course it is possible in a case such as the present for the court to think there is something in the allegations brought against the person in question," Walker said.
But he said it was also possible that, notwithstanding any misgivings, "there cannot be a finding with the sufficient degree of cogency required" in light of the gravity of the allegations.
Addressing one alleged murder, Walker said: "There is absolutely no evidence on the basis of which there can or should be amateur sleuthing in this court, I say that with great respect, concerning the scatter or otherwise of blood on things thought to be, or posited to be, held by a person who's been shot."
He said there was "simply no evidentiary basis for any of that".
During Friday's hearing, Walker was asked a series of questions by the court concerning findings made by Besanko that were not the subject of a challenge by Roberts-Smith's team in the appeal.
He agreed the Roberts-Smith camp did not challenge the judge's findings that a serving Special Air Service soldier dubbed Person 18, one of the newspapers' witnesses, was honest and reliable.
However, Walker said later that "the fact that we don't challenge something doesn't mean ... that my client accepts anything", and the court could take it that "my client doesn't accept that he lied".
"Lest there be any doubt, can I spell that out," he said.
The appeal court will deliver its decision at a later date.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/Roberts-Smith-s-barrister-cautions-court-against-amateur-sleuthing-20240216-p5f5jl.html?js-chunk-not-found-refresh=true
#20417104 at 2024-02-15 09:03:49 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #34: UNITED AGAINST THE INVISIBLE ENEMY OF ALL HUMANITY Edition
>>20359662
'Event of startling gravity': Newspapers back SAS soldier's account of execution
Michaela Whitbourn - February 15, 2024
The newspapers defending Ben Roberts-Smith's high-stakes defamation appeal have told a court an elite soldier who testified that the war veteran ordered an unlawful execution with the words "shoot him, or I will" could hardly have misremembered an event of such "startling gravity".
Roberts-Smith is seeking to overturn a landmark decision by Federal Court Justice Anthony Besanko last year which dismissed his multimillion-dollar defamation case against The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald and found he was complicit in the murder of four unarmed Afghan prisoners.
Besanko found the newspapers had proven to the civil standard - on the balance of probabilities - that Roberts-Smith was involved in the murders while on deployment in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012. This is lower than the criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt.
Nicholas Owens, acting for The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald, told the Full Court of the Federal Court in Sydney on Thursday that a serving Special Air Service soldier, dubbed Person 14, called by the newspapers to give evidence in the defamation trial, had "stuck to his guns" when accused of lying by Roberts-Smith's team.
He was "ultimately vindicated, and powerfully so", Owens said, because key parts of his account that had been disputed by Roberts-Smith's camp were found to be supported by objective evidence.
Person 14 told the Federal Court defamation trial in 2022 that he witnessed Roberts-Smith ordering the unlawful execution of an unarmed Afghan prisoner in 2012. Under the rules of engagement that bound the SAS, killing unarmed prisoners is a war crime.
According to Person 14's account, Roberts-Smith directed an interpreter to tell an Afghan Partner Force soldier: "Tell him to shoot him, or I will."
The direction was relayed, Person 14 told the court, and a subordinate of the Afghan Partner Force soldier shot the man dead. Roberts-Smith has denied giving any such direction.
Owens told the appeal court on Thursday that Roberts-Smith's challenge to Person 14's evidence "can only be a wholesale honesty attack".
"It has to be Person 14 is just making up this account of seeing an execution because, in a way, it's an event of such startling gravity that it's hard to see how one could ... have misremembered it in any fundamental way," Owens said.
"That's why we do say all of the independent corroboration that [Person 14] gets from ... objective material, and in particular material that he couldn't have known about, is powerful and important."
Among the objective material raised by Owens included chat records pointing to a reduction in the number of prisoners around the time of the alleged execution.
Roberts-Smith's legal team, led by high-profile silk Bret Walker, SC, has argued Besanko did not have sufficiently cogent evidence before him to justify making such grave findings against their client when he was entitled to the presumption of innocence.
Parts of the appeal are being held in closed court to hear submissions relating to national security information. The hearing continues.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/event-of-startling-gravity-newspapers-back-sas-soldier-s-account-of-execution-20240215-p5f56b.html
#20411157 at 2024-02-14 09:06:42 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #34: UNITED AGAINST THE INVISIBLE ENEMY OF ALL HUMANITY Edition
>>20359662
Judges urged to ignore 'attack' on Afghans who gave evidence of Roberts-Smith murder
David Estcourt - February 14, 2024
Afghan witnesses who gave detailed evidence about the murder of villager Ali Jan by Australian soldier Ben Roberts-Smith should be believed, despite efforts by the disgraced SAS soldier's legal team to attack their credibility during his defamation trial, a court has been told.
Roberts-Smith is seeking to reverse his legal loss against The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald after Federal Court Justice Anthony Besanko last year dismissed his multimillion-dollar defamation case and found he was complicit in the murder of four unarmed Afghan prisoners.
Besanko found the newspapers had proven on the balance of probabilities that Roberts-Smith was involved in the murders while on deployment in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012. The judge's finding is lower than the criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt.
The former Special Air Service corporal's legal team - led by high-profile silk Bret Walker, SC - argued last week that Besanko did not have sufficiently cogent evidence before him to justify making such grave findings against their client when the former soldier was entitled to the presumption of innocence.
But Nicholas Owens, SC - acting for the newspapers - on Wednesday attacked the substance of Roberts-Smith's appeal, urging the justices to believe the evidence given by witnesses from a remote Afghan village who were present when Roberts-Smith murdered Jan in 2012.
Owens told the court that when the justices undertook examination of the evidence provided by the Afghan witnesses, they should recall the "the absolutely full-throated ... nature of the attack on them at trial" by Roberts-Smith's lawyers.
"It wasn't, 'Let's look at the detail of your case' - it really was ... every time [an Afghan witness said] something, if it happens to be right, that's because someone told [the witness] to say it, not because [they] were there."
Masters was present in court on Wednesday.
Owens also argued that there were three corroborating witnesses, including a soldier dubbed Person 4, who attested that Roberts-Smith had kicked Jan into a ditch, a finding that should not be overturned by the court.
"In terms of the kick itself, we emphasise there is corroborating evidence from Person 4 on the one hand and two of the Afghan witnesses, Mohammed Hanifa and Shahzada [Fatih]," Owens argued.
"They all give fundamentally consistent accounts of Ali Jan being kicked off the cliff."
Owens labelled the sum total of the evidence "highly probative".
Besanko found Roberts-Smith killed Jan, who was unarmed and defenceless, by kicking him off a cliff and instructing the soldiers under his command to shoot him.
Roberts-Smith disputes Besanko's finding.
Besanko's findings included that Roberts-Smith was involved in three murders, as alleged in a series of articles in 2018, as well as a fourth murder that did not appear in the reports but was part of the newspapers' defence in court.
The appeal is expected to run for 10 days and does not involve hearing from witnesses afresh.
Owens indicated that most of his remaining argument would take place in a closed court on Thursday as the hearings continue.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/victoria/judges-urged-to-ignore-attack-on-afghans-who-gave-evidence-of-Roberts-Smith-murder-20240214-p5f4ri.html
#20405678 at 2024-02-13 09:29:54 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #34: UNITED AGAINST THE INVISIBLE ENEMY OF ALL HUMANITY Edition
>>20359662
Witnesses to murder by Roberts-Smith gave strikingly similar accounts, appeal told
David Estcourt - February 13, 2024
The evidence of three key witnesses about the murder of a prisoner with a prosthetic leg by disgraced SAS soldier Ben Roberts-Smith was strikingly coherent and contained only very minor differences, a court has heard.
Roberts-Smith is seeking to reverse a decision by Federal Court Justice Anthony Besanko last year which dismissed his multimillion-dollar defamation case against The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald and found he was complicit in the murder of four unarmed Afghan prisoners.
Besanko found the newspapers had proven on the balance of probabilities that Roberts-Smith was involved in the murders while on deployment in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012. The judge's finding is lower than the criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt.
The former Special Air Service corporal's legal team, led by high-profile silk Bret Walker, SC, has argued in Roberts-Smith's appeal that Besanko did not have sufficiently cogent evidence before him to justify making such grave findings against their client, when the former soldier was entitled to the presumption of innocence.
But Nicholas Owens, SC, acting for the newspapers, is urging the full court of the Federal Court not to overturn Besanko's decision, and argued on Tuesday the court should believe the accounts of three witnesses - dubbed Persons 41, 14 and 24 - in relation to two of the alleged murders.
The witnesses gave an account of a man being roughly manhandled by Roberts-Smith outside a compound called Whiskey 108 on Easter Sunday 2009.
"There is no question that it was Mr Roberts-Smith who killed the man in that location with the machine gun, and it was the man with the prosthetic leg," Owens said.
"All three of them support that coherent and essential narrative.
"To the extent there are differences between them, they are very minor differences around the very edges of that, which we would say is capable of being explained by the passage of time [and] the natural tendency to focus on the most arresting event."
There is no dispute the two Afghan men were killed during the mission, but Roberts-Smith gave evidence during the defamation trial that they were enemy combatants killed lawfully in action by him and a second Australian soldier.
Owens also argued that another witness, Person 40, also heard shots and saw the aftermath of the killings.
Roberts-Smith told the defamation trial the two Afghan men were armed with a machine-gun and a rifle respectively, which were shown in a photo tendered to the court.
On Tuesday, Owens also touched on the death of Afghan civilian Ali Jan in September 2012.
Besanko found Roberts-Smith killed Jan, who was unarmed and defenceless, by kicking him off a cliff and procuring the soldiers under his command to shoot him. Roberts-Smith disputes Besanko's finding.
Owens drew together witness evidence that was challenged by Roberts-Smith's legal team, and argued that the totality of their evidence shows the consistency of the newspaper's case at least up to when Jan was killed.
"The combined force of that evidence is clearly sufficient, we say, to induce the state of comfortable satisfaction in our case," Owens said.
He told the appeal that Besanko had been detailed and careful in his examination of the entirety of the case.
"I can't make such a facile submission as to say, 'Look how long this judgment is already. Are you really saying it should be longer?'" Owens said.
"But there is something to be said that one cannot seriously contend that this judgment does not reflect a very careful and thorough analysis of the issues - factual and legal - that we're throwing up in a very complicated case."
The newspapers alleged the two Afghan men killed on Easter Sunday 2009 had emerged unarmed from a tunnel at Whiskey 108 and were taken prisoner before they were executed by Roberts-Smith and a "rookie" soldier acting on his instruction.
The mastheads called seven current and former SAS soldiers to give evidence supporting that account. But Roberts-Smith and four of his former SAS comrades told the defamation trial there were no men in the tunnel.
The appeal is expected to run for 10 days and does not involve hearing from witnesses afresh.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/witnesses-to-murder-by-Roberts-Smith-gave-strikingly-similar-accounts-appeal-told-20240213-p5f4gh.html
#20400727 at 2024-02-12 08:56:51 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #34: UNITED AGAINST THE INVISIBLE ENEMY OF ALL HUMANITY Edition
>>20359662
'No evidence' slain Afghan men were armed, Roberts-Smith appeal told
Michaela Whitbourn - February 12, 2024
There was "no evidence" that two Afghan men allegedly murdered by or at the direction of Ben Roberts-Smith were armed at the time of their death, the barrister acting for the newspapers at the centre of the former elite soldier's high-stakes defamation appeal has said.
Roberts-Smith is seeking to overturn a landmark decision by Federal Court Justice Anthony Besanko last year which dismissed his multimillion-dollar defamation case against The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald and found he was complicit in the murder of four unarmed Afghan prisoners.
Besanko found the newspapers had proven to the civil standard - on the balance of probabilities - that Roberts-Smith was involved in the murders while on deployment in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012. This is lower than the criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt.
The former Special Air Service corporal's legal team, led by high-profile silk Bret Walker, SC, has argued Besanko did not have sufficiently cogent evidence before him to justify making such grave findings against their client when he was entitled to the presumption of innocence.
But Nicholas Owens, SC, acting for the newspapers, has urged the Full Court of the Federal Court not to overturn Besanko's decision. In submissions on Monday, Owens focused on the evidence marshalled by the newspapers in relation to two of the alleged murders, which were said to have occurred on Easter Sunday 2009 during a mission to a compound dubbed Whiskey 108.
There is no dispute the two Afghan men were killed during this mission, but Roberts-Smith gave evidence during the trial that they were enemy combatants killed lawfully in action by him and a second soldier. Roberts-Smith told the court the two men were armed with a machine-gun and a rifle respectively, which were shown in a photo tendered in court.
But a serving SAS soldier dubbed Person 18, who was called by the newspapers to give evidence at the trial, told the court that he found those specific guns among a weapons cache in a hay store at Whiskey 108. Besanko accepted Person 18's account on this point and rejected Roberts-Smith's evidence.
The newspapers alleged the two Afghan men killed emerged unarmed from a tunnel at Whiskey 108 and were taken prisoner before they were executed by Roberts-Smith and a "rookie" soldier acting on his instruction. The mastheads called seven current and former SAS soldiers to give evidence in support of that account. But Roberts-Smith and four of his SAS comrades told the court there were no men in the tunnel.
Owens told the appeal court on Monday that a "sensitive site exploitation" or SSE report from the mission "attribute[d] items to people who are either taken prisoner or killed", and there were "no items attributed to" the two Afghan men killed.
"There is no evidence that they were armed [or] that they were carrying any sort of military equipment that would identify them as demonstrating hostile intent, leading to it being lawful to kill them," Owens told the three-judge Bench.
"So, we think it is either uncontroversial or, if it is not uncontroversial, it is a fact that your honours should … find is clearly more likely than not that these two men weren't armed."
This was an important fact when looking at "the whole picture", Owens said.
He said Besanko had accepted that the newspapers' witnesses presented a "coherent and plausible account" of the mission, notwithstanding any inconsistencies, and he had noted the "chaotic nature of the scene" that day.
But Walker said during his submissions last week that a patrol debrief, a written record of the mission, differed from the account offered by military witnesses called by the newspapers. He said Besanko was required to explain why he had determined that the alleged murders happened when the written record did not support their account.
Owens said the Roberts-Smith appeal was a "particularly powerful case to demonstrate the proposition ... that trial judges have an advantage not just of seeing witnesses but in seeing the evidence unfold" over time, in this case over 100 days.
The appeal is slated to run for 10 days and does not involve hearing from witnesses afresh.
https://www.theage.com.au/national/no-evidence-slain-afghan-men-were-armed-Roberts-Smith-appeal-told-20240212-p5f46b.html
#20383213 at 2024-02-09 09:38:05 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #34: UNITED AGAINST THE INVISIBLE ENEMY OF ALL HUMANITY Edition
>>20359662
'Not like a detective novel': Court urged to reject Roberts-Smith appeal
Michaela Whitbourn - February 9, 2024
Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation case was "not like a detective novel" where there could be multiple explanations for killings in Afghanistan, and a decision finding he engaged in war crimes should not be overturned, the barrister acting for the media outlets at the centre of the lawsuit has said.
Nicholas Owens, SC, acting for The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald, urged the Full Court of the Federal Court on Friday to reject the former soldier's appeal against Justice Anthony Besanko's historic decision last year dismissing his multimillion-dollar defamation suit against the newspapers.
Besanko found the newspapers had proven to the civil standard - on the balance of probabilities - that Roberts-Smith was complicit in the murder of four unarmed prisoners while on deployment in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012. This is lower than the criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt.
Owens told the court that Roberts-Smith's barrister, Bret Walker, SC, had raised hypothetical scenarios during the appeal, including that Australian soldiers might be motivated to plant a Taliban-issued object on the body of an Afghan man killed legitimately in war to help avoid unnecessary questions about whether the killing was in fact lawful.
Walker stressed that his client, a Victoria Cross recipient, did not give evidence that this had ever occurred.
Owens said that the hypothesis "must be excluded because if it was to be raised ... one would have expected that to be given" in evidence by the former Special Air Service corporal or another soldier in court.
In his judgment in June, Besanko found that either Roberts-Smith or his friend, a soldier dubbed Person 11, planted a Taliban-issued radio on an unarmed Afghan prisoner known as Ali Jan in 2012 to make his unlawful killing by Person 11 on Roberts-Smith's instruction appear legitimate. Under the rules of engagement that bound the SAS, killing unarmed prisoners is a war crime.
"It's to be remembered, of course, that these murders are not like a detective novel where people stumble across a body in the library bleeding from the head and there's a whole range of questions about how did they die, who killed them, for what reason, et cetera," Owens said.
He said that in general "we know who killed" the four Afghan men in question and "we know how they were killed", by gunshot.
"The only dispute is in effect the immediate circumstances," Owens said, which pointed to whether the killings involved the lawful engagement of enemy combatants or unlawful killings of unarmed prisoners.
He said there was "no third hypothesis that's available on the evidence, or … if it's available, it must be of a probability that is so low that it cannot possibly affect the outcome of the case when the standard of proof is balance of probabilities".
Owens submitted on Friday that "the fundamental flaw in the arguments advanced by the appellant in this court lies in a failure to make ... any serious attempt to place particular pieces of evidence that they have seized upon in the context of the evidence as a whole".
He said the court had heard detailed submissions from Roberts-Smith's barristers, pointing to alleged problems in the evidence against their client.
"Our response to those submissions ... ranges from, at the one end, denying that there is a problem with the evidence ... to, at the other end, accepting completely that there is a valid point to be made," Owens said.
But he said that "the real question … is when all of the evidence, with all of those imperfections, with all of those contradictions, is considered as a whole, does it combine to produce the requisite state of comfortable satisfaction that our case is more likely than not?"
Roberts-Smith's legal team say the evidence against their client is insufficiently cogent to justify the grave findings made by Besanko, and his decision should be overturned.
The war veteran has consistently denied wrongdoing, and wants the court to set aside Besanko's decision and enter judgment in his favour. He also wants it to award damages or to send the matter to a different Federal Court judge to determine damages.
Parts of the appeal are being held in closed court to hear submissions relating to national security information. The hearing continues on Monday.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/not-like-a-detective-novel-court-urged-to-reject-Roberts-Smith-appeal-20240209-p5f3oc.html
#20371359 at 2024-02-07 09:18:44 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #34: UNITED AGAINST THE INVISIBLE ENEMY OF ALL HUMANITY Edition
>>20359662
'Tell him to shoot him or I will': Dispute over key SAS witness
Michaela Whitbourn - February 7, 2024
There was "nowhere near" enough evidence for the judge presiding over Ben Roberts-Smith's high-profile defamation case to find the war veteran ordered the unlawful execution of an Afghan prisoner by uttering the words "tell him to shoot him or I will", his barrister has told an appeal court.
Roberts-Smith's 10-day appeal over his devastating defamation loss against The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald entered its third day on Wednesday as his barrister, Bret Walker, SC, told the Full Court of the Federal Court that murder findings should not have been made against his client.
In his decision last year dismissing Roberts-Smith's defamation suit, Federal Court Justice Anthony Besanko found the newspapers had proven the former Special Air Service corporal was complicit in the murder of four unarmed Afghan prisoners while on deployment in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012.
Under the rules of engagement that bind the SAS, killing unarmed prisoners is a war crime.
Besanko's findings included that Roberts-Smith was involved in three murders as alleged in a series of articles in 2018, as well as a fourth murder that did not appear in the reports but was part of the newspapers' defence in court.
The fourth murder related to directions Besanko found Roberts-Smith gave via an interpreter for an unarmed Afghan prisoner to be shot by a member of the Afghan Partner Force in 2012.
Besanko found Roberts-Smith's actions in delivering that instruction resulted in him being "complicit in and responsible for murder".
A serving SAS soldier dubbed Person 14 gave evidence during the defamation trial in 2022 that this prisoner was killed after a weapons cache was found in a wall.
Person 14 told the court that combat engineers came in to clear the cache, and Roberts-Smith directed an interpreter to tell an Afghan Partner Force soldier: "Tell him to shoot him or I will."
The direction was relayed, Person 14 told the court, and a subordinate of the Afghan Partner Force soldier shot the man dead.
Walker told the court that the combat engineers Person 14 referred to in his evidence did not give evidence at the trial.
He said Person 14's evidence about the alleged killing should have been rejected by Besanko as "nowhere near sufficiently cogent as to make out the very serious misconduct alleged" and the judge had not engaged with whether the killing was likely in light of the "very tight if not impossible" timeline of events as alleged.
"Person 14 doesn't do anything by way of reporting it," Walker said of his actions in the aftermath of the alleged murder. He submitted that this had a bearing on the credibility and reliability of his evidence.
Besanko's findings were made to the civil standard - on the balance of probabilities - rather than the higher criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt. Roberts-Smith has consistently denied wrongdoing.
The Victoria Cross recipient wants the court to set aside Besanko's decision and enter judgment in his favour, and to award damages or to send the matter to a different Federal Court judge to determine damages.
Parts of the appeal are being held in closed court to hear submissions relating to national security information. The hearing continues on Thursday.
https://www.theage.com.au/national/tell-him-to-shoot-him-or-i-will-dispute-over-key-sas-witness-20240207-p5f30y.html
#20365364 at 2024-02-06 08:20:00 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #34: UNITED AGAINST THE INVISIBLE ENEMY OF ALL HUMANITY Edition
>>20359662
Planting object on Afghan's body may not point to murder cover-up, Roberts-Smith appeal told
Michaela Whitbourn - February 6, 2024
The barrister acting for war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith in his appeal against the loss of his defamation case has told an appeal court that even a finding that Australian soldiers planted a Taliban-issued radio on an Afghan man's body would not necessarily suggest a murder cover-up.
Roberts-Smith is appealing against a damaging decision by Federal Court Justice Anthony Besanko last year, which dismissed his defamation suit against The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald and found the newspapers had proven he was complicit in the murder of four unarmed prisoners while on deployment in Afghanistan.
Of the four murders found proven by Besanko, one involved an allegation the former Special Air Service corporal kicked an unarmed and handcuffed Afghan villager named Ali Jan off a small cliff in Darwan on September 11, 2012, before procuring a soldier under his command to shoot him.
Under the rules of engagement that bound the SAS, killing unarmed prisoners is a war crime.
Roberts-Smith's barrister, Bret Walker, SC, told the Full Court of the Federal Court on Tuesday that there was insufficiently cogent evidence available to Besanko to make such a grave finding.
Roberts-Smith told the Federal Court during the defamation trial that there was "no cliff" and "no kick". The man in question was not a farmer but a suspected Taliban "spotter" reporting on the movement of coalition forces, he said, and both he and a soldier dubbed Person 11 lawfully fired shots at the man in a cornfield. Person 11, a friend of Roberts-Smith, supported this account.
Two other soldiers, along with three Afghan villagers who gave evidence via an audiovisual link from Kabul, gave a different account in evidence called by the newspapers.
The newspapers alleged that either Roberts-Smith or Person 11 planted a Taliban-issued radio known as an ICOM on Ali Jan's body after the killing, in an action known as a throwdown, to make the killing appear legitimate.
Besanko concluded in his judgment in June last year that "an ICOM radio was placed on Ali Jan's body by either the applicant [Roberts-Smith] or Person 11" before photographs were taken, and that Roberts-Smith "falsely reported that Ali Jan was a spotter who had been engaged in the cornfield".
Walker told the Full Court that even if a throwdown had occurred, although this was not his client's case, it "does not at all necessarily involve the cover-up by deception; the deflection of the truth" of an unlawful killing.
This was because an item might be placed on a body as part of "the false enhancement of a position which is in any event true", he said, namely that the killing was lawful.
"The enemy fleeing with a small knife, not in a position to return fire, might excite in those reading a report of that [incident] a question whether they were legitimately killed," Walker said.
"But if there is a concern raised, obviously those on the site can employ what are called throwdowns. I stress, we didn't have to say that is what happened."
He said he was putting the argument to point out that any evidence of a throwdown was "equivocal" as to whether a killing was unlawful.
He said there was also "no evidence" Roberts-Smith had been seen with an ICOM shortly before the killing.
Walker said there was "some variability" in records associated with the mission and said he would refer in a closed-court portion of the hearing to one of the reports.
Besanko's findings were made to the civil standard - on the balance of probabilities - rather than the higher criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt. Roberts-Smith has consistently denied wrongdoing.
Walker has told the Full Court that rejecting Roberts-Smith's evidence does not lead automatically to the acceptance of the newspapers' case and "it's always possible that a fact-finder can't be satisfied one way or another" in relation to events at the centre of a case.
Parts of the appeal are being held in closed court to hear submissions relating to national security information. The hearing continues on Wednesday.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/planting-object-on-afghan-s-body-may-not-point-to-murder-cover-up-Roberts-Smith-appeal-told-20240206-p5f2pi.html
#20359662 at 2024-02-05 09:21:12 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #34: UNITED AGAINST THE INVISIBLE ENEMY OF ALL HUMANITY Edition
No 'nefarious' cover up in Ben Roberts-Smith case, soldier's lawyers say
ELLIE DUDLEY - FEBRUARY 5, 2024
1/2
Evidence relied upon in throwing out former SAS soldier Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation case against Nine newspapers was at times contradicted official military documentation, the Federal Court has heard.
Roberts-Smith appeared at the Federal Court on Monday morning for the first day of his appeal against a landmark defamation judgement handed down by Justice Anthony Besanko, who found that he was involved in the unlawful killings of four prisoners in Afghanistan.
Roberts-Smith, who has consistently denied the allegations, is arguing Justice Besanko erred in his findings regarding the six articles in The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times, and has asked the court to set aside the judgment.
Leading appellate silk Bret Walker SC on Monday argued Roberts-Smith was entitled to a presumption of innocence, and claimed Justice Besanko did not properly give regard to the gravity of the allegations when he made his findings.
Mr Walker told appeal Justices Nye Perram, Anna Katzmann and Geoffrey Kennett that Justice Besanko's findings in relation to the unlawful killing of two unarmed prisoners at a compound known as Whiskey 108 was based on the evidence of military witnesses that contradicted an official patrol document.
In June, Justice Besanko found Roberts-Smith was involved in four unlawful killings, including two at Whiskey 108 involving a couple of Afghan men who emerged from a secret tunnel at the compound.
However, Mr Walker told the court that Justice Besanko had not explained why he preferred the testimony of military witnesses called by the newspapers over documents created closer in time to the incident.
He claimed the judge had failed to explain how the document could have been "nefariously corrupted" to cover up the murders.
"You obviously don't infer from a discrepancy between a later purported recollection and a contemporaneous record that the record must be wrong or must have been corrupted," Mr Walker said. "That would be absurd and unfair and purely speculative."
Mr Walker, in opening submissions on Monday, told the Bench that the difference between "civilised" and uncivilised killing must be at the centre of the matter.
"The difference between killing that occurs in the course of duty permitted by a civilised system of law and killing which is not so authorised and is therefore not excused by the activities of war," he said.
"That difference is of course at the heart of the case."
Mr Walker also stressed the importance of determining whether the evidence presented in the original trial was "cogent".
"It is important to note that the question is not which side's witnesses or argument was preferred, but rather, whether the material marshalled by way of evidence and argument in support of such serious allegations was sufficiently cogent … to justify the making of the final adjudication in favour of those allegations," he said.
(continued)
#19822048 at 2023-10-29 04:50:01 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #32: YOU ARE NOT ALONE IN THIS FIGHT Edition
#32 - Part 27
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial
>>19511867 Australian War Memorial adds panel with context of Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation case to uniform display - The Australian War Memorial (AWM) has added information to a plaque commemorating Corporal Ben Roberts-Smith's Victoria Cross medal, to reflect recent court rulings over his alleged conduct in Afghanistan. The AWM has added details about a Federal Court ruling in a defamation case brought by Mr Roberts-Smith against media groups, which found there was substantial truth to allegations he had been involved and complicit in unlawful killings in Afghanistan. Mr Roberts-Smith is currently challenging the ruling with an appeal, and has not been charged with any criminal offence. The revised text panel reads in part: "Accounts of alleged misconduct by a small number of Australian Special Forces soldiers in Afghanistan began appearing in the media from late 2016. Claims were later heard in a civil defamation case brought by Roberts-Smith against media outlets and journalists. In June 2023 a Federal Court Judge determined that there was "substantial truth" to the allegations that Roberts-Smith had been involved and complicit in unlawful killings in Afghanistan. Roberts-Smith has appealed this decision. Roberts-Smith has not been charged with any offence under criminal law."
>>19656323 Death threats from Ben Roberts-Smith supporters aimed at journalist - Supporters of disgraced former SAS soldier Ben Roberts-Smith have directed a number of death threats at investigative reporter for The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age Nick McKenzie since May, when a judge ruled in favour of his reporting on alleged war crimes committed by Roberts-Smith. In June, Justice Anthony Besanko ruled that on the balance of probabilities Roberts-Smith was guilty and complicit in the murder of four unarmed prisoners in Afghanistan. It was a decision several years in the making, following extensive reporting by McKenzie and Chris Masters, who were both subsequently sued for defamation by the former soldier and former Seven Network executive. "Good morning Nick. I hope you receive the same punishment that Ali Jan allegedly received... just sleep on it mate," McKenzie was told in a phone message in July, referencing one of the victims of Roberts-Smith. Members of a Facebook group "We stand with Ben Roberts-Smith VC MG" lobbied others to attend scheduled dates for McKenzie's and Masters' book tours in July and August. The group, which has more than 3700 members, was made private in July after one of its admins, Western Australian woman Linda Deval, was contacted by this masthead over a post claiming it had the support of Roberts-Smith and his family. "Will be there in Canberra July 26th to let him know fear," read one comment under the username Gary Redman, residing in the NSW town of Bermagui, on a post urging members to attend dates on McKenzie's book tour.
>>19712747 British army 'was told SAS lied to justify killing of Afghans' - Senior British military officers were warned that SAS units were planting evidence to try to justify the killings of dozens of innocent civilians during raids in Afghanistan, an inquiry has been told. The deaths allegedly stemmed from an unofficial policy within the British special forces to "execute Afghan males of fighting age" even when they posed no threat. High-level concerns about the alleged killings prompted one senior military officer to say that justifications given were "logic-defying". Other staff used internal emails to lament a "casual disregard for life". Details of the killings emerged on the first day of a public inquiry into the behaviour of elite military units. It will examine claims that more than 80 Afghans were summarily killed between 2010 and 2013. The Ministry of Defence ordered the inquiry last year after campaigning by victims' families and claims by the BBC program Panorama that one unit may have unlawfully killed 54 people in one six-month tour. Opening the inquiry at the Royal Courts of Justice in London, Lord Justice Haddon-Cave, the chairman, said the allegations were "extremely grave". The inquiry would examine claims that the allegations were "covered up at all levels over the last decade" and that investigations by the Royal Military Police were not fit for purpose. The inquiry heard evidence from internal emails between officials in which they referred to the official explanation about raids as "bollocks".
#19656323 at 2023-10-03 09:14:56 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #32: YOU ARE NOT ALONE IN THIS FIGHT Edition
>>19417651 (pb)
Death threats from Ben Roberts-Smith supporters aimed at journalist
Calum Jaspan - October 3, 2023
Supporters of disgraced former SAS soldier Ben Roberts-Smith have directed a number of death threats at investigative reporter for The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age Nick McKenzie since May, when a judge ruled in favour of his reporting on alleged war crimes committed by Roberts-Smith.
In June, Justice Anthony Besanko ruled that on the balance of probabilities Roberts-Smith was guilty and complicit in the murder of four unarmed prisoners in Afghanistan.
It was a decision several years in the making, following extensive reporting by McKenzie and Chris Masters, who were both subsequently sued for defamation by the former soldier and former Seven Network executive.
"Good morning Nick. I hope you receive the same punishment that Ali Jan allegedly received... just sleep on it mate," McKenzie was told in a phone message in July, referencing one of the victims of Roberts-Smith.
Members of a Facebook group "We stand with Ben Roberts-Smith VC MG" lobbied others to attend scheduled dates for McKenzie's and Masters' book tours in July and August.
The group, which has more than 3700 members, was made private in July after one of its admins, Western Australian woman Linda Deval, was contacted by this masthead over a post claiming it had the support of Roberts-Smith and his family.
"Will be there in Canberra July 26th to let him know fear," read one comment under the username Gary Redman, residing in the NSW town of Bermagui, on a post urging members to attend dates on McKenzie's book tour.
"Do everyone a favour and walk in front of a bus you piece of scum," read an email sent directly to McKenzie from an account under the name Gary Redman.
Redman purchased a ticket to one of McKenzie's public tour events at the Australian National University, however according to security advice, was excluded from attending the event.
McKenzie said: "I've had many veterans contact me with messages of support, including special forces soldiers, who have read my book and realise it celebrates the brave SAS whistleblowers and witnesses who stood up to Roberts-Smith and who represent the military moral majority.
"I've also been issued multiple threats of death and violence from people who haven't bothered to do any research and who fire themselves up in social media echo chambers. Some of the attacks are aimed at my family, which is revolting."
A Meta spokesperson said keeping people safe on its apps was critical and that it continued to invest in technology to keep abuse off its platforms. The company said it doesn't allow death threats, hate speech or calls for violence on Facebook and Instagram.
None of the examples provided to Meta were deemed breaches of its policies against online abuse, this masthead understands. "We have a dedicated safety website to support journalists in having a safe experience on our platform so they continue their important work," Meta's spokesperson said.
In August, prominent neo-Nazi Thomas Sewell voiced support for Roberts-Smith at a meeting held at Altona RSL in suburban Melbourne. Sewell and others chanted "Heil Ben Roberts-Smith" and "down with Nick McKenzie".
An appeal by Roberts-Smith over the decision is set to be heard in the Federal Court in February.
https://www.theage.com.au/business/companies/death-threats-from-Ben-Roberts-Smith-supporters-aimed-at-journalist-20230716-p5doke.html
#19511867 at 2023-09-08 14:33:30 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #32: YOU ARE NOT ALONE IN THIS FIGHT Edition
>>19231979 (pb)
>>19231995 (pb)
Australian War Memorial adds panel with context of Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation case to uniform display
Elizabeth Byrne and Charlotte Gore - 8 September 2023
The Australian War Memorial (AWM) has added information to a plaque commemorating Corporal Ben Roberts-Smith's Victoria Cross medal, to reflect recent court rulings over his alleged conduct in Afghanistan.
The AWM has added details about a Federal Court ruling in a defamation case brought by Mr Roberts-Smith against media groups, which found there was substantial truth to allegations he had been involved and complicit in unlawful killings in Afghanistan.
Mr Roberts-Smith is currently challenging the ruling with an appeal, and has not been charged with any criminal offence.
In a statement this morning, an AWM spokesperson said the memorial had added further context to displays that included Mr Roberts-Smith.
"A revised text panel acknowledging the status of the defamation case is now on display," they said.
The revised text panel reads in part:
Accounts of alleged misconduct by a small number of Australian Special Forces soldiers in Afghanistan began appearing in the media from late 2016.
Claims were later heard in a civil defamation case brought by Roberts-Smith against media outlets and journalists.
In June 2023 a Federal Court Judge determined that there was "substantial truth" to the allegations that Roberts-Smith had been involved and complicit in unlawful killings in Afghanistan.
Roberts-Smith has appealed this decision.
Roberts-Smith has not been charged with any offence under criminal law.
Following the outcome of the defamation case in June this year, Greens senator David Shoebridge called on the War Memorial to remove the former special forces commander's display - something the AWM said at the time it would not do, but would consider adding the context of his defamation case somewhere in the exhibit.
The War Memorial said the purpose of the memorial was to assist in remembering, interpreting and understanding the national experience of war and its enduring impact, and that included "the causes, conduct and consequences of war".
Today, Senator Shoebridge said adding extra information to the display was "a very modest step forward".
"But it hardly balances the rest of the exhibition, which glorifies Ben Roberts-Smith," he said.
"What needs to be told here is the whole truth of Australia's 20-year-long conflict in Afghanistan.
"That includes the voices of Afghan civilians who lost their families and loved ones to brutal acts of war ... and it should not contain a shrine to Ben Roberts-Smith."
Senator Shoebridge said the display still placed Mr Roberts-Smith "at the heart of Australia's involvement in Afghanistan and in the role of a hero".
University of Sydney Challis chair of international law Ben Saul agreed with Senator Shoebridge that the plaque did not resolve the issue.
"It minimises what happened in Afghanistan because it makes no reference to the broader context of up to 39 unlawful killings identified in the Brereton Report," he said.
"The impression visitors to the memorial would come away with is still that Ben Roberts-Smith is mainly a war hero."
The AWM has also taken two portraits of Mr Roberts-Smith off display, but a memorial spokesperson said that was part of the $500 million redevelopment currently underway at the site.
"The removal of more than 300 collection items relating to Peacekeeping and more recent Middle East operations took place in August 2023," they said.
"This gallery change has been planned since 2021 to support the development project and exhibition displays within the new galleries in the new Anzac Hall.
"Two Ben Roberts-Smith portraits have been decanted as part of these planned gallery works.
"The memorial will display 1,000s of new objects in an expanded Peacekeeping and Middle East galleries in the new Anzac Hall."
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-09-08/act-australian-war-memorial-Ben-Roberts-Smith-display-plaque/102832720
#19487526 at 2023-09-04 10:04:32 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #32: YOU ARE NOT ALONE IN THIS FIGHT Edition
#31 - Part 29
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 2
>>19297998 Defence blocks FOI on war crimes letters between the US and Australia - Defence has refused to release documents setting out US warnings that alleged war crimes by Australian troops in Afghanistan threatened to derail special forces co-operation between the allies. The department rejected a Freedom of Information request on the matter by Greens senator David Shoebridge, who blasted the "wall of silence" over the fallout from the Brereton war crimes report on Australia-US military ties. Defence said there were six separate items of correspondence on the matter but refused to release them on the grounds they could undermine Australia's relations with the US.
>>19417651 Ben Roberts-Smith will fight his defamation loss at a ten-day hearing - War veteran Ben Roberts-Smith says a judge was mistaken in finding that he was involved in four murders of unarmed prisoners following a landmark defamation loss to three newspapers. In the notice of appeal, Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers said he "appeals from the whole of the judgment". His representatives argue that Justice Besanko "erred in his findings" Mr Roberts-Smith was involved in the four murders of unarmed prisoners. Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers claim the judge "erred by impermissibly construing the evidence" of Person 41, who witnessed the execution of Ali Jan and should not have been regarded as a reliable witness. "The primary judge added to and cherry picked the evidence of a witness whose evidence he otherwise found to be reliable without adequately explaining the basis for doing so," the appeal states. They also claim the judge denied procedural fairness, as he did not ask for the "rookie soldier", known as Person 4, to give evidence about what happened at the compound and placed too great a weight on the evidence of Afghan villagers.
>>19427909 Police, war crimes investigators seek access to documents in Roberts-Smith case - The Australian Federal Police and war crimes investigators are seeking access to restricted documents from Ben Roberts-Smith's failed defamation case amid dozens of active investigations into allegations that Australian soldiers broke the rules of engagement in Afghanistan. Federal Court Justice Anthony Besanko revealed in a judgment on Friday that the Commonwealth had applied for changes to national security orders to allow the AFP and the Office of the Special Investigator to seek access to sensitive court documents. This would include transcripts of parts of the trial heard behind closed doors and documents tendered during those hearings. The OSI is the agency investigating war crimes allegations against Australian soldiers in Afghanistan.
#19487524 at 2023-09-04 10:04:14 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #32: YOU ARE NOT ALONE IN THIS FIGHT Edition
#31 - Part 28
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 1
>>19220746 Why Ben Roberts-Smith defamation ruling has a long way to play out - "In order to make sense of the Ben Roberts-Smith case, one important point needs to be kept in mind: this was not a war crimes trial or a murder trial - at least not officially. Allegations of murder and war crimes were at the heart of the argument. But the reality is that this was merely an expensive, complex private dispute. It is important to be clear about the difference between civil and criminal justice. Even if the different standards of proof are put to one side, the judge's finding that the murders took place was made on the available evidence - which falls short of the evidence that would have been available to a criminal court. It must therefore be less reliable than a finding by a criminal court." - Chris Merritt, vice-president of the Rule of Law Institute of Australia - theaustralian.com.au
>>19231979 War Memorial installs plaques noting 'gravity' of Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case - The Australian War Memorial has installed plaques next to displays honouring disgraced former soldier Ben Roberts-Smith that say the museum is considering what further content should be added to the exhibits after a landmark defamation case found he was a murderer and war criminal. The plaques read: "The memorial assists in remembering, interpreting and understanding Australia's experience of war and its enduring impact. This includes the causes, conduct and consequences of war. The memorial acknowledges the gravity of the decision in the Ben Roberts-Smith VC MG defamation case and its broader impact on all involved in the Australian community. This is the outcome of a civil legal case, and one step in a longer process. Collection items relating to Ben Roberts-Smith VC MG, including his uniform, equipment, medals and associated artworks, are on display in the memorial's galleries. We are considering carefully the additional content and context to be included in these displays. The memorial acknowledges Afghanistan veterans and their families, who may be affected at this time."
>>19231995 War Memorial 'acknowledges gravity' of Ben Robert-Smith murder finding - The Australian War Memorial has quietly added a notice to its displays honouring Ben ?Roberts-Smith "acknowledging the gravity" of the finding in his failed defamation case that he murdered unarmed detainees in Afghanistan. The AWM has previously stated it would leave displays featuring Mr Roberts-Smith in place, despite calls for the collections to be removed from display or contextualised with information about defamation court findings. Greens senator David Shoebridge has called for these items to be removed from display immediately, while former principal AWM historian Peter Stanley has suggested "we might pause before effacing him from our national war museum". "Removing his portrait and uniform might satisfy a modish desire to obliterate the memory of his actions but by "cancelling" him, we would lose the chance to tell the truth; to explain how the trial's evidence contradicts the heroic story that the memorial, among others, cultivated," Professor Stanley said.
#19487387 at 2023-09-04 09:10:11 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #31: MAGIC SWORD - IN THE FACE OF EVIL Edition
#31 - Part 29
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 2
>>19297998 Defence blocks FOI on war crimes letters between the US and Australia - Defence has refused to release documents setting out US warnings that alleged war crimes by Australian troops in Afghanistan threatened to derail special forces co-operation between the allies. The department rejected a Freedom of Information request on the matter by Greens senator David Shoebridge, who blasted the "wall of silence" over the fallout from the Brereton war crimes report on Australia-US military ties. Defence said there were six separate items of correspondence on the matter but refused to release them on the grounds they could undermine Australia's relations with the US.
>>19417651 Ben Roberts-Smith will fight his defamation loss at a ten-day hearing - War veteran Ben Roberts-Smith says a judge was mistaken in finding that he was involved in four murders of unarmed prisoners following a landmark defamation loss to three newspapers. In the notice of appeal, Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers said he "appeals from the whole of the judgment". His representatives argue that Justice Besanko "erred in his findings" Mr Roberts-Smith was involved in the four murders of unarmed prisoners. Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers claim the judge "erred by impermissibly construing the evidence" of Person 41, who witnessed the execution of Ali Jan and should not have been regarded as a reliable witness. "The primary judge added to and cherry picked the evidence of a witness whose evidence he otherwise found to be reliable without adequately explaining the basis for doing so," the appeal states. They also claim the judge denied procedural fairness, as he did not ask for the "rookie soldier", known as Person 4, to give evidence about what happened at the compound and placed too great a weight on the evidence of Afghan villagers.
>>19427909 Police, war crimes investigators seek access to documents in Roberts-Smith case - The Australian Federal Police and war crimes investigators are seeking access to restricted documents from Ben Roberts-Smith's failed defamation case amid dozens of active investigations into allegations that Australian soldiers broke the rules of engagement in Afghanistan. Federal Court Justice Anthony Besanko revealed in a judgment on Friday that the Commonwealth had applied for changes to national security orders to allow the AFP and the Office of the Special Investigator to seek access to sensitive court documents. This would include transcripts of parts of the trial heard behind closed doors and documents tendered during those hearings. The OSI is the agency investigating war crimes allegations against Australian soldiers in Afghanistan.
#19487386 at 2023-09-04 09:09:33 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #31: MAGIC SWORD - IN THE FACE OF EVIL Edition
#31 - Part 28
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 1
>>19220746 Why Ben Roberts-Smith defamation ruling has a long way to play out - "In order to make sense of the Ben Roberts-Smith case, one important point needs to be kept in mind: this was not a war crimes trial or a murder trial - at least not officially. Allegations of murder and war crimes were at the heart of the argument. But the reality is that this was merely an expensive, complex private dispute. It is important to be clear about the difference between civil and criminal justice. Even if the different standards of proof are put to one side, the judge's finding that the murders took place was made on the available evidence - which falls short of the evidence that would have been available to a criminal court. It must therefore be less reliable than a finding by a criminal court." - Chris Merritt, vice-president of the Rule of Law Institute of Australia - theaustralian.com.au
>>19231979 War Memorial installs plaques noting 'gravity' of Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case - The Australian War Memorial has installed plaques next to displays honouring disgraced former soldier Ben Roberts-Smith that say the museum is considering what further content should be added to the exhibits after a landmark defamation case found he was a murderer and war criminal. The plaques read: "The memorial assists in remembering, interpreting and understanding Australia's experience of war and its enduring impact. This includes the causes, conduct and consequences of war. The memorial acknowledges the gravity of the decision in the Ben Roberts-Smith VC MG defamation case and its broader impact on all involved in the Australian community. This is the outcome of a civil legal case, and one step in a longer process. Collection items relating to Ben Roberts-Smith VC MG, including his uniform, equipment, medals and associated artworks, are on display in the memorial's galleries. We are considering carefully the additional content and context to be included in these displays. The memorial acknowledges Afghanistan veterans and their families, who may be affected at this time."
>>19231995 War Memorial 'acknowledges gravity' of Ben Robert-Smith murder finding - The Australian War Memorial has quietly added a notice to its displays honouring Ben ?Roberts-Smith "acknowledging the gravity" of the finding in his failed defamation case that he murdered unarmed detainees in Afghanistan. The AWM has previously stated it would leave displays featuring Mr Roberts-Smith in place, despite calls for the collections to be removed from display or contextualised with information about defamation court findings. Greens senator David Shoebridge has called for these items to be removed from display immediately, while former principal AWM historian Peter Stanley has suggested "we might pause before effacing him from our national war museum". "Removing his portrait and uniform might satisfy a modish desire to obliterate the memory of his actions but by "cancelling" him, we would lose the chance to tell the truth; to explain how the trial's evidence contradicts the heroic story that the memorial, among others, cultivated," Professor Stanley said.
#19427909 at 2023-08-25 14:40:54 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #31: MAGIC SWORD - IN THE FACE OF EVIL Edition
>>19220746
>>19417651
Police, war crimes investigators seek access to documents in Roberts-Smith case
Michaela Whitbourn - August 25, 2023
The Australian Federal Police and war crimes investigators are seeking access to restricted documents from Ben Roberts-Smith's failed defamation case amid dozens of active investigations into allegations that Australian soldiers broke the rules of engagement in Afghanistan.
Federal Court Justice Anthony Besanko revealed in a judgment on Friday that the Commonwealth had applied for changes to national security orders to allow the AFP and the Office of the Special Investigator to seek access to sensitive court documents. This would include transcripts of parts of the trial heard behind closed doors and documents tendered during those hearings.
The OSI is the agency investigating war crimes allegations against Australian soldiers in Afghanistan.
In a historic decision on June 1, Besanko dismissed Roberts-Smith's multimillion-dollar defamation case against The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age.
Besanko found the newspapers had proven to the civil standard - on the balance of probabilities - that Roberts-Smith was a war criminal who was complicit in the murder of four unarmed prisoners in Afghanistan. He also found the news outlets had proven the former Special Air Service corporal had bullied a fellow soldier.
Roberts-Smith's lawyers filed a notice of appeal in the Federal Court in July. The former soldier is appealing against the whole of Besanko's judgment, and is seeking in particular to overturn damning findings that he murdered unarmed prisoners in Afghanistan.
Besanko said the OSI's director of investigations, Ross Barnett, had advised in an affidavit filed in court that the agency was "currently conducting a number of joint investigations with the AFP into the alleged commission of criminal offences under Australian law arising from or related to breaches of the law of armed conflict by members of the ADF in Afghanistan from 2005 to 2016".
"The joint investigations are collectively known as Operation Emerald," Besanko said.
Besanko said Barnett had given evidence that "Operation Emerald currently consists of approximately 40 investigations", all of which were active, although "the level of investigative focus varies across the investigations from time to time".
"Criminal offences of the kind being investigated are extremely grave and their thorough investigation is of national and international importance," Besanko said.
Besanko said the OSI's director of investigations was "able to say that there is an overlap between the subject matter of the investigations and the subject matter of the defamation proceedings".
Roberts-Smith's lawyers applied to have a new judge decide the Commonwealth's application for changes to national security orders, which were made in Roberts-Smith's case in 2020 to protect sensitive information, and a separate application by the OSI for access to the court documents.
The former soldier's application was made on the grounds of apprehended bias, which is not an allegation that a judge is, in fact, biased. It involves a consideration of whether a "fair-minded observer" might reasonably consider that a judge might not bring an impartial mind to resolving a matter.
"I consider the circumstances of this case are unusual, particularly in light of the strong findings I have made against [Roberts-Smith]. I have reached the conclusion … that the fair-minded lay observer might reasonably apprehend that I might not bring an impartial mind to the resolution of the Commonwealth's applications (emphasis in original)," Besanko said in his decision on Friday.
He ordered that the Commonwealth's application and the OSI's request for access to documents "be referred to another judge for hearing and determination".
"The legal test for apprehended bias does not involve an examination by the judge of his or her state of mind or tendencies," Besanko said. "The issue is assessed and resolved by the use of a legal construct of the fair-minded observer or hypothetical reasonable observer to whom the law attributes certain characteristics, including a fair and reasonable approach."
https://www.theage.com.au/national/police-war-crimes-investigators-seek-access-to-documents-in-Roberts-Smith-case-20230825-p5dzf9.html
#19417651 at 2023-08-24 10:01:39 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #31: MAGIC SWORD - IN THE FACE OF EVIL Edition
>>19220746
Ben Roberts-Smith will fight his defamation loss at a ten-day hearing
The disgraced Australian soldier has accused a judge of making a mistake and "cherry picking" evidence when he found newspapers proved he was a war criminal.
Lauren Ferri - August 24, 2023
1/2
War veteran Ben Roberts-Smith says a judge was mistaken in finding that he was involved in four murders of unarmed prisoners following a landmark defamation loss to three newspapers.
The Victoria Cross recipient sued The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times over a series of articles published in 2018 that accused him of war crimes.
Federal Court Justice Anthony Besanko dismissed the proceedings in June after finding the six articles proved - to the standard of the balance of probabilities - the most serious imputations.
He also found the newspapers made out the defence of contextual truth for the remainder of the untrue imputations.
With one day left until the deadline, Mr Roberts-Smiths' legal team filed a notice of intention to appeal with the Federal Court on July 11.
The matter appeared in court on Thursday in front of Justice Nye Perram for the first case management hearing since the appeal was lodged.
Matthew Richardson, SC, acting for Mr Roberts-Smith, told the court that his side would be able to address the court within 3? days.
He said the grounds of appeal arise from four murders of unarmed prisoners in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012.
Nicholas Owens, SC, representing the newspapers, told the court that his submissions could be kept to five days, with Justice Perram setting the matter down for 10 days in total.
"It is obvious why the applicant would wish to, or the appellant or I should say, would wish to present the appeal, as if it can be reduced to a number of just very discreet little points about the evidence," Mr Owens told the court.
"From my client's point of view, an important part of making sure the Full Court is in a position to discharge its function on a re-hearing is overcoming that advantage and the corresponding disadvantage in the Full Court as best we can."
The 10-day appeal will include sessions of closed court to accommodate sensitive Commonwealth information.
The appeal is aimed at finding error in Justice Besanko's factual findings and is expected to cost about $1m, on top of the $25m already spent in legal fees throughout the case.
(continued)
#19231995 at 2023-07-24 12:24:05 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #31: MAGIC SWORD - IN THE FACE OF EVIL Edition
>>19220746
>>19231979
War Memorial 'acknowledges gravity' of Ben Robert-Smith murder finding
STEPHEN RICE - JULY 24, 2023
The Australian War Memorial has quietly added a notice to its displays honouring Ben ?Roberts-Smith "acknowledging the gravity" of the finding in his failed defamation case that he murdered unarmed detainees in Afghanistan.
The AWM has previously stated it would leave displays featuring Mr Roberts-Smith in place, despite calls for the collections to be removed from display or contextualised with information about defamation court findings.
The notices have been installed next to collections featuring the Victoria Cross recipient's uniforms and portrait, bearing a statement from AWM chairman Kim Beazley AC, on behalf of the war memorial's council.
"The memorial assists in remembering, interpreting and understanding Australia's experience of war and its enduring impact. This includes the causes, conduct and consequences of war," the notice reads.
"The memorial acknowledges the gravity of the decision in the Ben Roberts-Smith VC MG defamation case and its broader impact on all involved in the Australian community."
The wording of the notices reflect a statement issued by Mr Beazley soon after judge Anthony Besanko handed down his findings almost two months ago that several allegations of war crimes against Mr Roberts-Smith by newspapers he was suing were substantially true.
Mr Beazley noted "this is the outcome of a civil legal case, and one step in a longer process".
"We are considering carefully the additional content and context to be included in these displays. The memorial acknow?ledges Afghanistan veterans and their families who may be affected at this time."
Greens senator David Shoebridge has called for these items to be removed from display immediately, while former principal AWM historian Peter Stanley has suggested "we might pause before effacing him from our national war museum".
"Removing his portrait and uniform might satisfy a modish desire to obliterate the memory of his actions but by "cancelling" him, we would lose the chance to tell the truth; to explain how the trial's evidence contradicts the heroic story that the memorial, among others, cultivated," Professor Stanley said.
The War Memorial holds Mr Roberts-Smith's VC and other medals. The memorial galleries also display two portraits of him by artist Michael Zavros, one in formal uniform, the other in a combat stance holding a pistol.
Zavros is quoted in AWM collection material stating: "I like the idea that we see him momentarily isolated, at one with himself, potentially in a moment of reflection. Less the brave war hero, rather a man, singled out and celebrated. It is an honour that sits well on him at the same time that it sits heavily."
Former AWM director Brendan Nelson was a notable supporter of Mr Roberts-Smith during the trial, and the case was largely bankrolled by billionaire Kerry Stokes, a former chair of the memorial's council. Both provided character references for the soldier.
Dr Nelson awarded the former soldier greater prominence at the memorial than many other VC recipients, extolling his courage and commitment.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/defence/war-memorial-acknowledges-gravity-of-Ben-robertsmith-murder-finding/news-story/3387c4d35922698a3bae460aecbbfbff
#19231979 at 2023-07-24 12:18:08 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #31: MAGIC SWORD - IN THE FACE OF EVIL Edition
>>19220746
War Memorial installs plaques noting 'gravity' of Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case
Natassia Chrysanthos - July 24, 2023
The Australian War Memorial has installed plaques next to displays honouring disgraced former soldier Ben Roberts-Smith that say the museum is considering what further content should be added to the exhibits after a landmark defamation case found he was a murderer and war criminal.
Signs featuring a statement by War Memorial Council chair and former Labor leader Kim Beazley have been included next to two displays in the museum after Beazley last month confirmed Roberts-Smith's uniform, medals and portraits would remain in place despite the court ruling.
According to photos supplied to and verified by this masthead, the plaques read: "The memorial assists in remembering, interpreting and understanding Australia's experience of war and its enduring impact. This includes the causes, conduct and consequences of war.
"The memorial acknowledges the gravity of the decision in the Ben Roberts-Smith VC MG defamation case and its broader impact on all involved in the Australian community. This is the outcome of a civil legal case, and one step in a longer process.
"Collection items relating to Ben Roberts-Smith VC MG, including his uniform, equipment, medals and associated artworks, are on display in the memorial's galleries.
"We are considering carefully the additional content and context to be included in these displays. The memorial acknowledges Afghanistan veterans and their families, who may be affected at this time."
One of the plaques has been installed next to an exhibit of Roberts-Smith's uniform outside the Hall of Valour, and the other next to two artworks of the soldier that were commissioned by the War Memorial in 2012 and are displayed as part of the Afghanistan War gallery.
The first display describes Roberts-Smith as "an imposing figure on the battlefield" who was "instrumental in inflicting a significant defeat upon a determined and well-entrenched enemy" in the Afghan village of Tizak in 2010.
The second, which features two portraits by Australian artist Michael Zavros, includes the following quote from Zavros: "We see him momentarily isolated, at one with himself, potentially in a moment of reflection. Less the brave war hero, rather a man, singled out and celebrated. It is an honour that sits well on him at the same time that it sits heavily."
There is no plaque or annotation next to Roberts-Smith's medals in the Hall of Valour itself, which honours the 101 Australians who have received the Victoria Cross and the nine Australian Defence Force personnel who have directly been awarded the George Cross.
The Greens had called on the War Memorial to remove Roberts-Smith's artefacts, while international law professor Ben Saul said they should be recontextualised to show the soldier committed horrific acts in addition to his bravery. Last month, Beazley said the memorial would consider ways to add context to the exhibits, rather than remove them.
Beazley said on Monday the plaques had been displayed "for several weeks now" following a council decision on June 2.
"They went up after some deliberation on what should be the response at this point as we continue to consider carefully additional context and content," he said.
"In the frame of that consideration, adjustments will be made. We note that Mr Roberts-Smith VC MG is appealing the decision."
Roberts-Smith, a former Special Air Service corporal, launched defamation action against The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times in 2018 over a series of stories alleging he committed war crimes in Afghanistan.
After years of legal proceedings, Federal Court Justice Anthony Besanko dismissed the multimillion-dollar defamation case on June 1. Besanko found the newspapers had proven to the civil standard - on the balance of probabilities - that Roberts-Smith was a war criminal who was complicit in the murder of four unarmed prisoners in Afghanistan.
Roberts-Smith is seeking to overturn the findings as part of an appeal launched this month.
https://www.theage.com.au/politics/federal/war-memorial-installs-plaques-noting-gravity-of-Ben-Roberts-Smith-libel-case-20230724-p5dqr2.html
#19220746 at 2023-07-22 02:23:26 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #31: MAGIC SWORD - IN THE FACE OF EVIL Edition
>>18934029 (pb)
Why Ben Roberts-Smith defamation ruling has a long way to play out
CHRIS MERRITT - JULY 21, 2023
1/2
In order to make sense of the Ben Roberts-Smith case, one important point needs to be kept in mind: this was not a war crimes trial or a murder trial - at least not officially.
Allegations of murder and war crimes were at the heart of the argument. But the reality is that this was merely an expensive, complex private dispute.
The media defended the truth of reports that this man, a recipient of the Victoria Cross, murdered people in Afghanistan.
This vindicated the three journalists who had pursued him: Nick McKenzie, Chris Masters and David Wroe. But this affair is not over.
The judge's ruling is subject to appeal and media reports say Roberts-Smith - who I will refer to as BRS - is under investigation by the Office of the Special Investigator.
This is the federal agency responsible for pursuing suspected war crimes and preparing briefs of evidence for the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions.
But BRS is still entitled to a presumption of innocence.
That flows from one of the fundamental principles of the rule of law: that everyone is entitled to a presumption of innocence until a criminal court rules otherwise.
That has not happened. And there is no certainty it will ever happen.
A criminal trial would use a higher standard of proof than the standard that was applied in the defamation case.
There are also significant procedural differences in criminal justice to ensure the immense power of the state does not result in unfairness when that power is directed against individuals.
Prosecutors, for example, have a duty of fairness that requires them to disclose not just details of the prosecution case, but details that the prosecution uncovers that could Benefit the accused.
The judge in the defamation case recognised these differences when he referred to arguments that his court did not have all the evidence that would ordinarily be available in a criminal trial.
That last point - about missing evidence - is troubling.
It means the court made a finding of murder on the civil standard of proof without having all of the evidence that would have been available in a criminal trial.
So even if the outcome of the defamation case is upheld on appeal, any criminal prosecution would have different procedures, different rules and different evidence.
That means the prospect of a different outcome - that is, an acquittal - cannot be ruled out.
All this puts us in a very strange position.
The journalists in this case have successfully defended their reports that BRS committed murder. His reputation is in tatters. So is it legitimate to refer to him as a murderer?
Those who choose to refer to him in that manner can find support in the findings of fact in the massive judgment that was produced by Federal Court Justice Anthony Besanko.
But describing BRS as a murderer, without clearly explaining the significant differences between defamation and criminal justice, adds to confusion and could eventually undermine public confidence in Australian justice.
Consider the alternative: If, after the defamation case, it is legitimate to refer to BRS in an unqualified manner as a murderer, imagine the ludicrous situation that would arise if he were to be tried on criminal charges and acquitted?
He would simultaneously be a "murderer" and acquitted of murder.
This is why it is important to be clear about the difference between civil and criminal justice.
Even if the different standards of proof are put to one side, the judge's finding that the murders took place was made on the available evidence - which falls short of the evidence that would have been available to a criminal court.
It must therefore be less reliable than a finding by a criminal court.
(continued)
#19188895 at 2023-07-16 09:33:52 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #31: MAGIC SWORD - IN THE FACE OF EVIL Edition
#30 - Part 40
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 4
>>19037124 Video: Jacqui Lambie wants International Criminal Court to investigate military commanders for alleged war crimes - Tasmanian senator Jacqui Lambie has requested the International Criminal Court (ICC) in The Hague investigate senior Australian Defence Force (ADF) commanders over their knowledge of alleged war crimes in Afghanistan. Senator Lambie has been scathing in her assessment of Major General Paul Brereton's landmark inquiry into allegations of serious misconduct by Australian special forces - a redacted version of which was made public in late 2020. She has argued the ADF's high command has avoided scrutiny and accountability over what they knew of unlawful killings and cruel treatment of prisoners, despite recollections from former SAS personnel and testimony in court suggesting rumours were well known by the top brass.
>>19075534 War crimes investigators want access to Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case secret file Federal investigators are poised to access secret files from Ben Roberts-Smith's failed defamation case in a development that indicates prosecutors intend to use previously undisclosed evidence from the trial about the killing of unarmed prisoners in a future war crimes trial. A letter sent by the Australian Government Solicitor on Friday to both sides in the defamation case, seen by The Australian, says the Office of the Special Investigator -- the agency set up to investigate war crimes by Australian soldiers in Afghanistan - requires access to the case's Sensitive Court File. The highly protected Sensitive Court File contains hundreds of classified documents and photographs, the identities of all the Special Air Service witnesses in the case and transcripts of evidence given in closed sessions of the trial, including by Mr Roberts-Smith himself.
>>19104491 OPINION: I exposed war crimes among the SAS. A few weeks ago, my car was repossessed - "When my car was repossessed by debt collectors a few weeks ago, amid wrapping up loose ends after my company went into liquidation, it made me reflect on the life I once led and the one I lead now. For me, it all began on Australia Day 2016. That was the day I submitted a report to army chief General Angus Campbell that would trigger the biggest inquiry into war crimes in Australia's history. When the war crimes allegations emerged, then-defence minister Peter Dutton said he had made it "very clear" to Defence that I should not be awarded further contracts. That he did not want the military to be "distracted by things that have happened in the past". My credibility was questioned repeatedly by Jacqui Lambie and reiterated in the Murdoch press. In a letter I received from the government solicitor's office shortly after publication, I was told my conduct and public statements had "harmed the Commonwealth". The result was that my ongoing work with the government was "terminated for convenience". The implications for me, my family, my business, and my staff were profound. The message had been sent to the department loud and clear that I was now a liability and a risk. No work would follow. Work in the pipeline was stopped indefinitely. I'd told the truth, so they cut me out. After that my business collapsed and my mental health declined amid the endless stream of misogynistic threats through social media. Work from other organisations was not forthcoming. I gather this was because most businesses hire consultants to tell them what they want to hear, not uncover what is really at the heart of their problems." - Samantha Crompvoets, sociologist and expert in organisational culture - theage.com.au
>>19160231 Ben Roberts-Smith appeals major defamation loss - Disgraced soldier Ben Roberts-Smith has launched an appeal of the judgment in his failed defamation action against The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times, which ruled he is a war criminal, murderer and a bully. On Tuesday Mr Roberts-Smith filed a notice of appeal in the Federal Court. According to the notice, Mr Roberts-Smith is appealing on the grounds that Justice Besanko erred in finding the former soldier ordered executions and murdered Afghans. This includes the finding that he kicked an unarmed Afghan civilian off a cliff in 2012 and ordered his execution, as well as killing an elderly Afghan in 2009 with a machine gun. Nine managing director of publishing James Chessell said: "We believe the Federal Court's judgment is comprehensive and categorical. The appeal will be opposed. We will always stand up for journalism that is in the public interest."
#19188894 at 2023-07-16 09:33:33 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #31: MAGIC SWORD - IN THE FACE OF EVIL Edition
#30 - Part 39
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 3
>>18977671 Video: Ben Roberts-Smith alleged to have directed the killing of elderly imam in Afghanistan - Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith directed one of his SAS comrades to kill an elderly man who was dragged from a mosque in Afghanistan, according to allegations uncovered by ABC Investigations. ABC Investigations can reveal the disgraced war hero's alleged involvement in the killing, which sparked a diplomatic row for Australia. The Australian government was quick to defend the August 2012 killing of Haji Raz Mohammad, an imam in the village of Sola, in Uruzgan province, claiming he was an insurgent. ABC Investigations understands the alleged incident is now in the hands of Australia's war crimes agency, the Office of the Special Investigator (OSI).
>>19005517 'Massive blow': AFP war crimes probe collapses over risk of tainted evidence - A five-year Australian Federal Police inquiry into Ben Roberts-Smith's alleged involvement in the execution of three Afghan captives has collapsed after Commonwealth prosecutors ruled investigators may have unwittingly used tainted evidence. The Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions' (CDPP) decision not to prosecute Roberts-Smith based on evidence gathered during the AFP probe has led to a new joint taskforce being set up to investigate the alleged executions. The taskforce comprises detectives from the specialist war crimes agency, the Office of the Special Investigator (OSI), and a new team of federal police investigators not connected to the abandoned AFP probe. The CDPP concluded in March that the five-year AFP probe should not lead to a prosecution because of the risk it was unwittingly compromised by the receipt of certain information from the Brereton inquiry, a military inspector general probe which ran from 2016-2020 and used special coercive powers to question SAS soldiers.
>>19016850 War crimes 'will be prosecuted' says Andrew Hastie - Opposition defence spokesman and former SAS captain Andrew Hastie says he is confident special forces war criminals will be brought to justice despite the collapse of a five-year investigation into allegations of murder against Australia's most decorated soldier, Ben Roberts-Smith. The Australian Federal Police defended its conduct on Wednesday after it was forced to junk its investigation into Mr Roberts-Smith's alleged involvement in the execution of three Afghan prisoners, amid concerns over tainted evidence. The AFP and detectives from the nation's war crimes agency, the Office of the Special Investigator, have now started a fresh probe into the alleged murders, which sources warn could take years. Mr Hastie said he was not privy to the reasons behind the decision, but declared: "The Office of the Special Investigator is active".
>>19016902 Video: No apologies as Roberts-Smith returns to Australia following defamation judgment - Former SAS corporal Ben Roberts-Smith has ruled out apologising to the families of the victims affected by his actions in Afghanistan. Roberts-Smith - arriving into Perth on a Qantas flight shortly after 9pm on Wednesday - said he was devastated by the outcome of his high-profile defamation case against The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times, adding that he was "100 per cent" proud of his behaviour while serving in the Defence Force. It is the first time Roberts-Smith has spoken publicly since the case ended, spending the days prior to the court judgment in Bali.
>>19037107 Be brave, strip soldiers' medals, says expert who sparked war crimes inquiry - The sociologist who triggered the Brereton war crimes inquiry has urged Defence Minister Richard Marles to stare down veterans' groups by stripping medals from soldiers who oversaw alleged wrongdoing in Afghanistan, saying it will reflect poorly on the nation if no action is taken. Samantha Crompvoets, an expert on organisational culture, was commissioned by the Department of Defence in 2015 to produce a report that led to military personnel disclosing claims of unlawful behaviour including alleged war crimes. In her first interview since a Federal Court judge found Ben Roberts-Smith to be a murderer and war criminal when dismissing his defamation case last week, Crompvoets said the decorated former soldier should lose his Victoria Cross for bringing the Australian Defence Force into disrepute. Crompvoets said Australians should prepare to hear confronting allegations at possible future criminal trials flowing from the Brereton inquiry.
#19188893 at 2023-07-16 09:33:16 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #31: MAGIC SWORD - IN THE FACE OF EVIL Edition
#30 - Part 38
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 2
>>18939574 A profound blow to our many honourable soldiers, but Army must be bound by rule of war - "The devastating loss by Ben Roberts-Smith in his defamation case will deliver a profound blow to the morale of the army and the Australian Defence Force generally. It was always a difficult case to understand. At some level, Roberts-Smith must believe himself innocent, or either remember or construe his actions differently from the way the court has. On the other hand, the evidence against him was strong. Still, we should remember this was not a criminal case and Roberts-Smith has not been charged with any crime and he has not been found guilty of anything to a criminal standard of proof. Nonetheless, taken in combination with the Brereton report, there is overwhelming evidence that there was grave misconduct by some Australian soldiers in Afghanistan." - Greg Sheridan - theaustralian.com.au
>>18955265 'Not an honest and reliable witness': Judge's scathing assessment of Roberts-Smith - Disgraced former soldier Ben Roberts-Smith gave false evidence, threatened a former comrade who later testified against him and arranged "unusual" legal fee payments for supportive witnesses, the judge who dismissed his multimillion-dollar defamation lawsuit said. In the full reasons for the judgment, released on Monday, Federal Court judge Anthony Besanko said the former Special Air Service corporal was "not an honest and reliable witness in ... many areas". He endorsed the credibility and honesty of witnesses who detailed Roberts-Smith's wrongdoing.
>>18955292 Ben Roberts-Smith may have committed criminal offence, judge in defamation trial finds - War veteran Ben Roberts-Smith may have committed a criminal offence by sending threatening letters to a former SAS colleague, a Federal Court judge has found. Mr Roberts-Smith sued The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age, The Canberra Times and three journalists, denying allegations contained in a series of 2018 reports of war crimes, bullying and domestic violence. The judge was satisfied, to the civil standard of the balance of probabilities, that allegations Mr Roberts-Smith was involved or complicit in four unlawful killings in Afghanistan were substantially true. Mr Roberts-Smith had also denied sending anonymous, threatening letters to a former SAS colleague in 2018 by asking a private detective, John McLeod, to post material on his behalf. In the full judgement, published today, Justice Anthony Besanko said the sending of the letters may constitute a criminal offence; either perverting the course of justice or using a postal service to menace, harass or cause offence. "I am satisfied on the evidence that the applicant, through Mr McLeod, arranged for two threatening letters to be sent to Person 18."
>>18960215 Going woke risks destroying the ADF as a real fighting force - "The government is now pushing a great deal of politically correct nonsense on the army. It has restored the rainbow morning teas. It rejoices in its membership of LGBTQ lobby groups. Diversity, equity and inclusion are all the rage. Recruitment advertisements make no mention of combat or what a life of service in the army is really all about. I am strongly in favour of diversity in the army and the ADF. But diversity should work this way: you encourage people from widely diverse backgrounds to apply, but then the selection and promotion procedures should be absolutely colourblind and gender-blind. We forget what the army is for. The key role of the army is to close with and destroy the enemy. You hope you never need to do that, but that's what you have a military for. The Australian Army, like many Western armies, is now subject to a bewildering range of woke requirements that have nothing to do with being an effective army, nor indeed with being an ethical and moral military either. Given the emphasis on teamwork and group cohesion, this kind of poison can spread through a military at devastating speed." - Greg Sheridan - theaustralian.com.au
#19188892 at 2023-07-16 09:33:00 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #31: MAGIC SWORD - IN THE FACE OF EVIL Edition
#30 - Part 37
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 1
>>18934029 Ben Roberts-Smith: Top Australian soldier loses war crimes defamation case - Australia's most-decorated living soldier Ben Roberts-Smith has lost a historic defamation case against three newspapers that accused him of war crimes in Afghanistan. The outlets were sued over articles alleging he killed unarmed prisoners. The civil trial was the first time a court has assessed accusations of war crimes by Australian forces. Justice Anthony Besanko said four of the six murder allegations, all denied by the soldier, were substantially true. These included - A handcuffed farmer the soldier had kicked off a cliff, a fall which knocked out the man's teeth, before he was subsequently shot dead - A captured Taliban fighter who was shot at least 10 times in the back, before his prosthetic leg was taken as a trophy and later used by troops as a drinking vessel - Two murders which were ordered or agreed to by Mr Roberts-Smith to initiate or "blood" rookie soldiers.
>>18934054 Ben Roberts-Smith loses mammoth defamation battle against newspapers, reporters - A defamation case by war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith against three newspapers has been dismissed, after a judge found defences of substantial or contextual truth had been established over alleged unlawful killings, bullying and domestic violence. The Victoria Cross recipient sued The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age, The Canberra Times and three journalists in the Federal Court over a series of stories published in 2018. Mr Roberts-Smith said they contained false allegations of war crimes in Afghanistan, bullying of his former Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) colleagues and domestic violence against a woman in a Canberra hotel room.
>>18934081 Ben Roberts-Smith: SAS veteran a murderer with a cross to bear - Australia's most decorated living soldier, Ben Roberts-Smith, callously murdered four unarmed ?civilians while serving with the Special Air Service in Afghanistan, a judge has found, and now faces the prospect of serious criminal charges and being stripped of his Victoria Cross. Handing down his decision in the high-stakes defamation action brought by the former soldier against Nine newspapers, Federal Court judge Anthony Besanko ruled on Thursday that Mr ?Roberts-Smith had murdered four prisoners, including a ?farmer who was kicked off a cliff in the village of Darwan, and a one-legged man dragged from a tunnel at the compound known as ?Whiskey 108.
>>18939562 Rogues in the ranks await their fate as a giant is toppled - The trials of Ben Roberts-Smith and a raft of other SAS soldiers who served with him in Afghanistan are only just beginning. We are now likely to see a slew of criminal prosecutions for war crimes in Afghanistan that will cast a dark shadow over Australia's military for many years. Even though this was a civil case and therefore had a lower burden of proof than a criminal prosecution, the result offers further confirmation that Australian soldiers participated in horrific war crimes in Afghanistan. It adds to the findings of the 2020 Brereton report which found "credible" evidence of allegations 25 Australian soldiers murdered 39 Afghan civilians. So far only one former SAS soldier, Oliver Schultz, has been charged with murder. But more criminal charges are now expected, with the Office of the Special Investigator examining "between 40 and 50" further allegations of war crimes.
>>18939570 Courtroom void tells us something about the man - "Ben Roberts-Smith won his cherished Victoria Cross charging towards danger. He lost the honour it bestowed while draped across a sun lounge by a pool in Bali. It's hard to imagine a greater fall from grace - harder still to know why he chose not to front up on the day of judgement. Roberts-Smith had turned up to court every day of the trial, sharply dressed, shoes polished, ready to stare down his accusers. Not on Thursday, when Judge Anthony Besanko sat down to deliver his verdict. The void in Courtroom 1 where Roberts-Smith should have stood on Thursday tells us something about the man. It speaks of contempt for a judicial system that, once he got a whiff it wasn't working for him the way he'd planned, could be left at the door like last night's room service. The war hero brought this case on but wouldn't see it through to the end." - Stephen Rice - theaustralian.com.au
#18422552 at 2023-02-28 05:48:04 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #27: THEY ARE IN FULL BLOWN PANIC MODE Edition
#27 - Part 23
Cardinal George Pell - Sexual Abuse and Vatican Financial Scandal Allegations - Part 4
>>18269401 Video: 'Not a priest for the survivors': Melbourne families grapple with Pell's legacy - As the late Cardinal George Pell was laid to rest in Sydney, Chrissie Foster struggled to reconcile the eulogies with her memories of the man she once asked for help - Foster, who went to Pell with her husband Anthony when they discovered their two young daughters were being raped by parish priest Kevin O'Donnell, said the divisive cardinal was hardly a martyr or a saint - "The problem I have is people from on high like [former prime minister Tony] Abbott saying he's like a saint, and someone else said he was martyred like Jesus was," she said - "They obviously have not been to one royal commission session or read one of their reports on George Pell. Go to the funeral, yes, but don't say those things. It's just so not true."
>>18386830 School stares down bid to restore George Pell's name - Cardinal George Pell's alma mater is resisting moves by his supporters in Ballarat to have his name reinstated at St Patrick's College in country Victoria
#27 - Part 24
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial
>>18180377 Video: War crimes investigators narrow focus to three key targets, including Roberts-Smith - Three former SAS soldiers and their associates have emerged as the key targets of the secretive agency investigating war crimes by Australian soldiers, which aims to lay its first criminal charges this year - The Office of the Special Investigator has focused on the "SAS three": Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith and two former SAS three-squadron members, including a soldier allegedly seen in helmet camera footage shooting an apparently unarmed Afghan man in a wheat field
>>18293647 SAS veteran pleads guilty to hindering AFP after giving evidence in Ben Roberts-Smith lawsuit - A former SAS soldier who testified in the defamation trial of Ben Roberts-Smith has pleaded guilty to hindering Australian Federal Police after they confronted him in a Sydney hotel - Police were there to execute two warrants on Person X, one for his phone and the other for his hotel room
#27 - Part 25
Julian Assange Indictment and Extradition
>>18046505 Julian Assange to ask for prison release to attend Vivienne Westwood's funeral - Stella Assange says her husband, Julian Assange, will apply to British authorities for leave from Belmarsh Prison to attend the funeral of their dear friend, Dame Vivienne Westwood
>>18064748 Edward Snowden Tweet: Free Julian Assange. - https://qalerts.app/?q=snowden - https://qalerts.app/?q=roadmap
>>18097124 The year Assange walks free? Why there are cautious hopes - "We can feel that the momentum is building," Assange's brother Gabriel Shipton says
>>18115350 Assange denied request to leave UK prison to attend the funeral of his friend and supporter Vivienne Westwood
>>18153898 CIA Pushes For Dismissal Of Lawsuit Against Alleged Spying On Assange Visitors - The Central Intelligence Agency and former CIA director Mike Pompeo notified a federal court in New York that they intend to push for the dismissal of a lawsuit that alleges that they were involved in spying against attorneys and journalists who visited WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange in Ecuador's London embassy
>>18221245 Assange a scoundrel who raped America: Pompeo - The former secretary of state says he'll be 'delighted' to see Julian Assange in a US prison, revealing the WikiLeaks founder made him 'as mad as I have ever been in my life' - Former US secretary of state Mike Pompeo, a likely Republican contender for president in 2024, has slammed Julian Assange as a "scoundrel" who "raped America", revealing he would be "delighted" when the Australian founder of WikiLeaks was "thrown into an American federal Penitentiary" - Mr Pompeo, in Never Give an Inch: Fighting for the America I Love, widely seen as laying the groundwork for a presidential bid, wrote he was "as mad as I have ever been in my life over the exposure of some of the CIA's most sensitive espionage tools", mocking the idea Mr Assange was a journalist but rather "a useful idiot for Russia to exploit"
>>18247142 My drunken night with Julian Assange, by Pamela Anderson - "My friendship with Julian Assange has been invigorating, sexy, and funny. Though his circumstances are not funny at all. Ten years incarcerated, in one way or another"
>>18263761 Penny Wong dashes hopes of Julian Assange breakthrough - She said the rule of law prevails in regards to the Assange case, dashing immediate hopes that direct entreaties by Prime Minister Anthony Albanese with American officials could result in any breakthrough
#18293647 at 2023-02-06 09:27:20 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #27: THEY ARE IN FULL BLOWN PANIC MODE Edition
>>18180377
SAS veteran pleads guilty to hindering AFP after giving evidence in Ben Roberts-Smith lawsuit
An SAS veteran has pleaded guilty to hindering AFP officers after he had given evidence in the defamation trial launched by Ben Roberts-Smith.
Perry Duffin and NCA Newswire - February 6, 2023
A former SAS soldier who testified in the defamation trial of Ben Roberts-Smith has pleaded guilty to hindering Australian Federal Police after they confronted him in a Sydney hotel.
The case marks the first actions of clandestine war crime investigators - set up in the wake of allegations against some Diggers in Afghanistan - though no war crime charges have been laid against anyone.
A veteran soldier, identified only as "Person X", testified in 2022 in the defamation lawsuit launched by Mr Roberts-Smith against Nine Newspapers over a series of articles published in 2018.
Dozens of serving and former SAS soldiers gave evidence under pseudonyms both for and against Mr Roberts-Smith during the mammoth defamation trial including Person X.
Person X was arrested last year, following his evidence, after being confronted by the AFP at his hotel in Sydney CBD.
The court heard police were there to execute two warrants on Person X, one for his phone and the other for his hotel room, but the former soldier wanted to call his lawyer and moved towards the elevator.
A CCTV camera, inside the lift, caught a glimpse of the AFP agents clustered around Person X as he tried to leave.
Magistrate Miranda Moody said the agreed police fact sheet showed Person X had acted like a "drunken fool".
"He'd made a jolly nuisance of himself," Magistrate Moody said, noting Person X had sworn and been very rude to the officers.
Person X, on Monday, pleaded guilty to hindering a Commonwealth official - the AFP officers.
The veteran's lawyers told the court he had been given one of the highest commendations for bravery in Australia for his heroic actions in the SAS.
He had protected then-Prime Minister John Howard and other high ranking officials while deployed and his time in the SAS amounted to a "significant contribution to the community", Magistrate Moody concluded.
Magistrate Moody dismissed the charge without recording a conviction against Person X.
The court did not hear that the AFP officers that awaited Person X in the hotel were acting on the orders of the Office of the Special Investigator.
The OSI was set up following the findings of a defence force investigation that concluded there was "credible evidence" that war crime murders were carried out by Australian special forces.
The OSI has done very little in public and has laid no charges - and there is no suggestion Person X is facing any allegations of war crimes.
Officers from the AFP sat in court on Monday as Person X pleaded guilty.
The veteran's lawyer, Robert Ranken, told the court Person X had been under stress giving evidence and being cross-examined in the days before his arrest.
Person X's evidence in the defamation trial cannot be revealed as part of a raft of suppression and non-publication orders to keep him, and other SAS witnesses, from being publicly identified.
The high profile defamation case, launched by Mr Roberts-Smith, made headlines around the world because he is one of the Commonwealth's most decorated soldiers.
Mr Roberts-Smith received the Victoria Cross and Medal of Gallantry for his actions in Afghanistan.
Mr Roberts-Smith denies all the allegations and sued Nine saying they had falsely painted him as a war criminal.
Nine is defending the stories as true in the Federal Court.
Justice Anthony Besanko, the judge presiding over the defamation trial, has yet to deliver his verdict.
https://www.news.com.au/national/nsw-act/courts-law/sas-veteran-pleads-guilty-to-hindering-afp-after-giving-evidence-in-Ben-robertssmith-lawsuit/news-story/5e8a214deca2e16328648ec7850a0c8c
#18180377 at 2023-01-20 13:27:32 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #27: THEY ARE IN FULL BLOWN PANIC MODE Edition
War crimes investigators narrow focus to three key targets, including Roberts-Smith
Nick McKenzie - January 20, 2023
1/3
Three former SAS soldiers and their associates have emerged as the key targets of the secretive agency investigating war crimes by Australian soldiers, which aims to lay its first criminal charges this year.
The Office of the Special Investigator has focused on the "SAS three": Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith and two former SAS three-squadron members, including a soldier allegedly seen in helmet camera footage shooting an apparently unarmed Afghan man in a wheat field.
The ramping up of investigations into the three ex-SAS members and a small number of their associates comes as former special forces soldiers and their supporters have mounted a campaign to smear those they suspect of co-operating with war crimes investigators.
As the ongoing war crimes probe divides the nation's defence community, a company recently founded by five veterans has produced and is marketing bottles of whiskey named after an alleged war crimes incident currently under active investigation. Promotional material for the whiskey published on the liquor company's website glorifies the involvement of some in the SAS in "violence, drinking and theft".
The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald have spoken to almost two dozen sources, including defence insiders who have been contacted by the Office of the Special Investigator (OSI) and asked to provide the agency with information or witness statements about incidents in Afghanistan. Several serving and former SAS soldiers are co-operating.
There is no suggestion that the SAS three are guilty of a war crime, only that they are the key targets of the OSI teams of investigators and analysts.
In the cases of the SAS three, the OSI has obtained information, including from witnesses, that implicates them in alleged summary executions of "persons under control", the official term for detainees, or non-combatants.
The three-squadron wheat field killer was captured on helmet camera vision killing an apparently unarmed Afghan man. The vision, broadcast by the ABC in 2020, shows him asking his patrol commander if he should "drop", or shoot the man. The commander's response is inaudible.
A lawyer for the ex-soldier did not respond to questions but multiple sources said OSI officials had privately expressed confidence he would be charged with war crimes.
The OSI, which was set up by the government two years ago as the investigation and prosecution agency for war crimes, has been examining the wheat field killing, along with the veteran's involvement in two other alleged war crimes incidents.
The second former three-squadron soldier is under investigation for his involvement in at least two alleged war crimes in 2012. This soldier's alleged breaches of the Geneva Conventions were first uncovered and exposed in 2019 by The Age and Herald and involved the death of an injured Afghan who was removed from the care of an SAS medic by the soldier.
The highest profile member of the SAS three under the OSI microscope is Roberts-Smith, who denies all wrongdoing and who is suing this masthead for defamation for previously exposing his alleged involvement in war crimes.
(continued)
#18046084 at 2022-12-31 08:46:59 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #27: THEY ARE IN FULL BLOWN PANIC MODE Edition
#26 - Part 12
Cardinal George Pell - Sexual Abuse and Vatican Financial Scandal Allegations
>>17463555 Sustaining our liberal ideals the best hope in dark times - "I don't think Australian life is rotten at the core but times are changing, and not always for the better." - George Pell - theaustralian.com.au
>>17565989 STANDING WITH THE WORD OF GOD - George Cardinal Pell - firstthings.com
>>17613395 Prosecution calls witnesses as Vatican finance trial resumes - After a break of over two months, the Vatican trial on financial corruption in the Secretariat of State continued this week with the interrogation of witnesses for the prosecution
#26 - Part 13
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial
>>17531189 Ben Roberts-Smith to attend Queen Elizabeth funeral commemorations - Controversial former soldier Ben Roberts-Smith will travel to London to participate in the official commemorations for the late Queen Elizabeth II, reflecting his status as a recipient of the prestigious Victoria Cross
>>17531176 Defence ducks probe into war crimes accountability - Defence has avoided an inquiry into the accountability of senior commanders for war crimes ?despite the findings of an independent panel, which said it failed to face up to its "corporate responsibility" for the murders of Afghan civilians and prisoners identified in the Brereton report
>>17548305 Video: Videos shot by Australian soldiers in Afghanistan raise questions about conduct of 2nd Commando Regiment
>>17554591 Video: Australian Commandos in Afghanistan filmed discussing 'quota' - 7.30 has obtained hours of footage of Australian Commandos in action. The raw footage from the soldiers' own handheld and mounted cameras shows the incredible dangers they faced, but also moments that raise questions about their conduct, including one scene where the men boast about hitting "the quota". Some of these commandos are now under investigation by Australia's war crimes agency. - ABC News (Australia)
>>17554623 Former Australian commando under investigation over 2012 Afghanistan rotation - A former Australian Special Forces commando is a target of a war crimes investigation for the alleged killing of at least one unarmed detainee during a deployment to Afghanistan
>>17560414 Former Australian commando faces Afghanistan war crimes investigation - A former Australian special forces soldier who allegedly confessed to executing an Afghan prisoner in October 2012 is now the target of a major war crimes inquiry, and was stopped at an airport where his phone was seized on return from an overseas trip in April
>>17560432 Australian commando under investigation over 2012 Afghanistan rotation - 7.30 has new accounts of a deadly raid carried out in Helmand province in 2012. Multiple witnesses have told 7.30 that seven Afghans were killed, some allegedly shot after they were detained by a small group of Australian soldiers. We'll hear an account of a commando's remorse at his alleged actions in that operation. - ABC News (Australia)
>>17827648 Australian Defence Force chief gives Afghanistan veterans 28 days to explain why they should keep war honours and medals awarded during the Afghanistan war, as the fallout from the Brereton Inquiry into alleged war crimes continues
#17453436 at 2022-08-28 07:13:12 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
#25 - Part 9
Malka Leifer Extradition and Prosecution
>>16940806 Australian Jewish principal Malka Leifer's sexual abuse trial to begin - Malka Leifer, former principal of an ultra-Orthodox Jewish girls' school in Melbourne, is being charged with 74 counts of sexual abuse of students
>>16940806 Manny Waks Facebook Post: The Malka Leifer trial will finally commence on Monday 1 August at the County Court of Victoria in Australia…..We look forward to finally seeing some semblance of justice prevail and stand with the courageous Nicole, Dassi and Elly.
>>16944062 Malka Leifer's trial date is pushed back - The trial of former Melbourne principal Malka Leifer has been postponed to August 22 - Pre-trial arguments before Judge Gamble continue
>>17381391 Israeli Ex-minister Gets Probation for Assisting Malka Leifer in Australia Sex Abuse Case - Former Health Minister Litzman pled guilty to pressuring ministry employees to alter psychiatric evaluations, in a bid to help Leifer avoid extradition to Australia. He resigned from parliament to avoid a harsher sentence
>>17381397 Litzman gets minor fine, no jail for shielding alleged pedophile Leifer from justice - Lenient sentence comes as part of plea deal; ex-health minister has admitted to unsuccessfully working to undermine extradition of accused sexual predator Malka Leifer to Australia
>>17381398 Malka Leifer case: Court endorses suspended sentence for Litzman - Former minister and United Torah Judaism MK Ya'acov Litzman's sentence will be eight-months in prison and an NIS 3,000 fine
#25 - Part 10
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial
>>16755924 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial begins hearing closing submissions after 100 days of testimony
>>16755934 'Reviled as a murderer': Roberts-Smith closes case against Nine with fiery speech - His lawyers accusing Nine newspapers of a "sustained campaign" to falsely smear the Victoria Cross recipient as a war criminal, bully and domestic abuser with unfounded articles and a contorted court case
>>16761512 One key question in Roberts-Smith defamation 'trial of the century' - "How could a group of illiterate Afghan villagers, and an elite SAS soldier, all recount the same harrowing details of an alleged war crime murder if it never happened?"
>>16761530 Afghan villagers and soldiers told the truth about Ben Roberts-Smith, defamation trial told - The only plausible explanation why three illiterate Afghan villagers and two former elite soldiers all implicated Ben Roberts-Smith in the alleged murder of an Afghan prisoner was that all were telling the truth, the Federal Court has heard in the final days of the war veteran's defamation case
>>16767613 Ben Roberts-Smith prepared to 'lie under oath', judge told in defamation trial
>>16767627 Ben Roberts-Smith told a "deliberate lie" to conceal his involvement in the alleged execution of an unarmed prisoner in Afghanistan, the war veteran's defamation case has been told
>>16773197 Witness in Ben Roberts-Smith trial threatened with 'bullet in his head', judge hears
>>16779737 Ben Roberts-Smith legal counsel says witnesses who gave evidence against the war veteran are liars
>>16779745 Media outlets 'haven't proven murder', Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case told
>>16787498 As the Roberts-Smith case nears its end, barrister returns to where he began: 'Someone is lying.'
>>16802161 Roberts-Smith alleged kick due to 'laugh' - Highly trained and experienced war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith allegedly lost control and kicked an unarmed Afghan man off a cliff because he laughed at him
>>16802176 'Bigger knolls at Bondi': Ben Roberts-Smith barrister rejects cliff kick claim - War veteran Ben Roberts-Smith did not kick a handcuffed Afghan prisoner off a cliff and there was no cliff at the site of the alleged incident, his barrister has told his Federal Court defamation case
>>16840379 Defence force documents disprove allegation Ben Roberts-Smith killed teenager in Afghanistan, defamation trial hears - Former soldier's lawyer says defence documents show teenager was released unharmed but newspapers say they are not accurate
>>16840826 'Most heinous acts of criminality': Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial ends - Four years after it began, the defamation trial of Ben Roberts-Smith has finally closed, with a judge now left to decide the verdict
>>16937440 Ben Roberts-Smith's fate in the hands of one man - Whatever judge Anthony Besanko's final ruling, expected to be handed down in six to 12 months' time, the case will endure as a legal landmark for decades to come
#17381367 at 2022-08-12 10:44:33 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
'I will continue killing foreigners': soldier who shot dead unarmed Australians treated as 'returning hero' by Taliban
Exclusive: Hekmatullah, who killed three Australian soldiers, is living in a heavily protected luxury Kabul home after being freed from prison
Ben Doherty - 8 Aug 2022
1/2
Hekmatullah, the rogue Afghan soldier who killed three unarmed Australian diggers in Afghanistan a decade ago, is living in a luxury home in the capital Kabul, treated as a "returning hero" by the Taliban who released him from prison.
He has said he does not regret killing Australian soldiers, and has vowed he would again kill Australians, or anyone who opposes the Taliban.
"If I am released I will continue killing foreigners," Hekmatullah told an official of the former Afghan government when his release was being negotiated.
"I will continue killing Australians and I will kill you as well because you are a puppet of foreigners," he said.
"I am among my brothers, we will be free, Afghanistan will be free. We will kill you."
Since returning to Afghanistan, Hekmatullah has reportedly been housed in the former diplomatic quarter of Wazir Akbar Khan. He lives in a heavily secured property in a district adjacent to the clandestine former home of Ayman al-Zawahiri, the former al-Qaida leader assassinated eight days ago by a US drone strike as he stood on the balcony of his villa.
Hekmatullah's release from prison in 2020 was fiercely resisted by Australia, with the government previously conceding it did not know where he had been since being freed.
Of 5,000 prisoners the Taliban wanted released as part of peace deal negotiations with the US, Hekmatullah was one of six terrorists that western governments fiercely resisted being pardoned, because they had either killed unarmed foreign nationals, were unrepentant about their crimes, or had vowed to commit further acts of violent terrorism.
A former senior official in the democratically elected government of Afghanistan - overthrown in August 2021 - has confirmed to the Guardian Hekmatullah's return to Afghanistan.
"He was welcomed back to Kabul as a hero ... with a house, car, guards, an amnesty for his crimes, his expenses are being paid for. He is being treated as a hero."
The Guardian has independently confirmed Hekmatullah's repatriation to Afghanistan. Family members of the Australian soldiers killed have said they have not been updated on his whereabouts.
On 29 August 2012, at Wahab, a patrol base in Afghanistan's Uruzgan province, Hekmatullah, then an Afghan National Army sergeant, drew his M16 and fired more than 30 rounds from close range at Australian troops. He killed three: L/Cpl Stjepan Milosevic, 40, Spr James Martin, 21, and Pte Robert Poate, 23.
Hekmatullah fled the base into the Baluchi valley and was designated a "high-value" target for the Australian SAS in Afghanistan within 24 hours. He was the sole target of a controversial SAS mission to the village of Darwan in Uruzgan province on 11 September 2012, based on - ultimately flawed - intelligence he was hiding in the village.
The mission was the subject of extensive evidence presented during the long-running defamation trial brought by the former SAS corporal Ben Roberts-Smith, who denies all wrongdoing in relation to an allegation he participated in the murder of an Afghan national during that mission.
Two other Australian SAS soldiers have also been accused of unlawfully killing Afghan nationals during the raid - allegations they deny.
It was not until February 2013 that Hekmatullah was arrested after being found hiding in Pakistan's lawless border region. Charged, tried and convicted of three counts of murder, Hekmatullah was sentenced to death, but served only seven years in Bagram prison before being moved to Qatar in 2020, where he lived under house arrest.
After the fall of Kabul to the Taliban, he returned to Afghanistan, where he now lives in Kabul.
(continued)
#16937440 at 2022-07-30 14:08:30 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
>>16755924
Ben Roberts-Smith's fate in the hands of one man
Deborah Snow and Michaela Whitbourn - July 30, 2022
1/3
There were no handshakes or back-slaps as the curtain fell on the epic Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case, at 12.44 pm sharp in Sydney's Federal Court on Wednesday. The soldier, as he had done for months, sat masked and unreadable in the back row of the courtroom, his parents Len and Sue nearby.
The judge, Anthony Besanko, quietly thanked the legal teams - including lawyers for the Commonwealth, which kept a gimlet eye on proceedings throughout to guard national security secrets - and uttered the words: "I reserve my judgment. Adjourn."
Then the two opposing sides withdrew to their separate meeting rooms for a last debrief. And it was over.
It seemed an oddly muted end to hearings which have kept the nation transfixed for more than a year, with the airing of alleged war crimes by Roberts-Smith and some of his elite military brethren in Afghanistan, the exposure of his extramarital affair, bitter rivalries inside the Special Air Service and alleged attempts by the Victoria Cross recipient and his inner circle to intimidate witnesses and cover up evidence. Throughout, the former SAS corporal has denied all wrongdoing.
Whatever the judge's final ruling - expected to be handed down in six to 12 months' time - the case will endure as a legal landmark for decades to come.
University of Melbourne Law School Associate Professor Jason Bosland, director of its media and communications law research network, describes it as "the most significant defamation case in the history of Australian defamation litigation".
"If Ben Roberts-Smith wins, then I think the damages payout will [set a new] record. On the other hand, if the media win, it will be very significant in terms of investigative journalism because the media will have succeeded on the truth defence, and historically that has been so difficult [for media outlets] to rely upon," Bosland says.
He adds, "Of course, if they do succeed on truth, it will operate as a quasi-investigation into war crimes as well, which is also significant in and of itself".
Few would wish themselves in the shoes of Besanko, who now has to sift through a mountain of evidence, elicited from more than 40 witnesses delivered over 110 days, to decide whether Roberts-Smith will forever be branded a man who murdered Afghan prisoners, bullied former comrades and struck his former lover.
Nine's newspapers, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age, have taken the calculated risk of mounting a truth defence. That means their legal team, headed by Nicholas Owens, SC, had to convince the judge that the war crimes and other wrongdoing alleged by star investigative reporters Nick McKenzie and Chris Masters were, on the balance of probabilities, true.
But Roberts-Smith's legal team, headed by Arthur Moses, SC, and Matthew Richardson, SC, have urged the judge to be rigorous in applying what is known as the Briginshaw standard.
This is an evidentiary principle derived from a 1938 divorce suit, which holds that even in a civil suit like this - with a lower standard of proof than in a criminal case - the court must take particular care in weighing the strengths and weaknesses of the evidence if there are grave consequences for those involved.
(continued)
#16840826 at 2022-07-27 09:46:03 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
>>16755924
'Most heinous acts of criminality': Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial ends
Four years after it began, the defamation trial of Ben Roberts-Smith has finally closed, with a judge now left to decide the verdict.
Perry Duffin - July 27, 2022
1/2
Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial of the century against Nine newspapers has finished with final overtures for a court to condemn, or clear, Australia's most venerated living soldier from allegations he committed "the most heinous acts of criminality" while serving with the SAS.
Now begins the anxious wait for the elite veteran, and his journalist accusers, as the judge retires to consider the verdict in a years-long case that has already redefined Australia's war in Afghanistan.
Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers are hoping a finding in his favour will clear his name and land the largest defamation payout in history while a finding for Nine could be seen as vindication for their claims he killed unarmed prisoners.
The case finally closed on Wednesday after more than 100 days of evidence, more than $25 million in legal fees and two weeks of closing speeches.
Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Arthur Moses SC, used is final moments on his feet to remind Justice Anthony Besanko that Nine bore the heavy burden of proving his client was a murderer.
The entirety of the evidence, Mr Moses told the court, shows Nine had no basis and no proof to publish grave claims Mr Roberts-Smith killed six unarmed Afghans.
"(Nine) published allegations and stories as fact that condemned Mr Roberts-Smith as being guilty of the most heinous acts of criminality that could be made against a member of the Australian Defence Force, and indeed any citizen," he said.
"It depends upon recollection of events that occurred during missions more than 10 years ago... Recollections which are contradicted either by their own witnesses, our witnesses and Defence Force documents."
"They have urged upon the court a case which is one of mere suspicion, surmise and guesswork to condemn a man, who served his nation with great distinction, as a war criminal."
He called on the judge to reject Nine's case "in all forms".
Nine's barrister, Nicholas Owens SC, closed his case without the grandiosity and colour of his opponents, instead returning to the claims and counterclaims in forensic detail.
One question that Nine has never answered, according to Mr Roberts-Smith, is what motive did he have to kill six detained Afghans when he had transported hundreds more safely back to Australian bases.
Mr Owens opened his case in June 2021 saying that even "the most brutal, vile member of the Taliban imaginable" cannot be killed once detained and "to do so is murder".
On Wednesday, more than 12 months after speaking those words, Mr Owens returned to the question of motive saying Mr Roberts-Smith killed detainees simply because they were "enemy combatants".
"We say that was a powerful motive that operated in relation to all of these incidents... it was a motive to kill Taliban insurgents regardless of the lawfulness of doing so," Mr Owens told the court.
(continued)
#16840379 at 2022-07-27 06:27:34 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
>>16755924
Defence force documents disprove allegation Ben Roberts-Smith killed teenager in Afghanistan, defamation trial hears
Former soldier's lawyer says defence documents show teenager was released unharmed but newspapers say they are not accurate
Ben Doherty - 26 Jul 2022
1/2
The allegation Ben Roberts-Smith murdered a teenager with his pistol in Afghanistan and boasted about it days later as "the most beautiful thing I've ever seen" should be disregarded by the judge in his defamation trial, the former soldier's lawyers have told the federal court.
Arthur Moses SC, acting for Roberts-Smith, said there were no witnesses to the alleged murder, and that "contemporaneous defence force documents" show the teenager was released unharmed.
But the newspapers Roberts-Smith is suing have alleged in court those documents are not accurate, and do not disprove the allegation.
The allegation of the teenager's execution, which a a former SAS soldier anonymised before court as Person 16 claimed Roberts-Smith told him about, was one of the most dramatic testimonies of Roberts-Smith's year-long defamation trial.
Roberts-Smith, a recipient of Australia's highest military honour, the Victoria Cross, is suing the Age, the Sydney Morning Herald and the Canberra Times for defamation over a series of ?reports he alleges are defamatory and portray him as committing war crimes, including murder.
The newspapers are pleading a defence of truth. Roberts-Smith denies all wrongdoing.
On 5 November 2012, Roberts-Smith conducted his final operation of his final tour of Afghanistan, to Fasil in southern Uruzgan province.
In his evidence during the trial, Person 16 told the court he was manning a road checkpoint on the mission, when he took into custody and handcuffed two of four men stopped in a Toyota Hilux, including an adolescent: "I made him out to be late teens ... not a fully beard, a bit chubby, and shaking in terror."
"He appeared extremely nervous and trembling uncontrollably."
Person 16 told the court he handcuffed both prisoners and handed them over to Roberts-Smith. He said he did not see the two men again.
Person 16 said about 15 minutes after handing over the two men - described as PUCs, "persons under control" - to Roberts-Smith, Roberts-Smith said over the troops' radio "two EKIA". EKIA is an initialism for "enemy killed in action".
In the days after the mission, Person 16 said he crossed paths with Roberts-Smith in the accommodation lines at the SAS's Camp Russell within Australia's Tarin Kowt base.
He told the court he asked Roberts-Smith: "What happened to that young fella who was shaking like a leaf?"
Person 16 said Roberts-Smith replied: "I shot that cunt in the head ... I pulled out my 9mm, shot the cunt in the side of the head, blew his brains out. It was the most beautiful thing I've ever seen."
Person 16 said he could not recall what he said in reply to Roberts-Smith "because I was shocked at what he'd said". He said he did not report the conversation at the time because of a powerful "a code of silence" within the SAS.
In court, Person 16 was shown pictures of a dead Afghan male whom he identified as the teenager he had taken into custody.
The body was photographed with an AK-47 beside it, but Person 16 said the teenager was unarmed.
(continued)
#16802176 at 2022-07-25 11:11:37 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
>>16755924
'Bigger knolls at Bondi': Ben Roberts-Smith barrister rejects cliff kick claim
Michaela Whitbourn - July 25, 2022
War veteran Ben Roberts-Smith did not kick a handcuffed Afghan prisoner off a cliff and there was no cliff at the site of the alleged incident, his barrister has told his Federal Court defamation case.
The court is hearing closing submissions in the defamation suit brought by the decorated former soldier against The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times. The media outlets allege Roberts-Smith was complicit in five unlawful killings of Afghan prisoners between 2009 and 2012.
One of the newspapers' key allegations was that Roberts-Smith kicked an unarmed and handcuffed villager named Ali Jan off a cliff in Darwan on September 11, 2012, before the man was shot dead. But Arthur Moses, SC, acting for Roberts-Smith, told the court on Monday there was "no clear contemporaneous evidence as to the geography of the area - including, importantly, the cliff … which it is said Ali Jan was kicked off".
He said a "photo from an overwatch position, which is in evidence", was not clear and "with all due respect, Your Honour, there is no cliff".
"It's more like a sandy knoll. I mean, there are bigger knolls at Bondi Beach here in Sydney or Henley Beach in Adelaide," he told Justice Anthony Besanko, who is based in Adelaide but has travelled to Sydney for the trial.
"We say this was just part of the drama that was attached to a false story that has been circulating."
Roberts-Smith claims the newspapers wrongly accused him of war crimes in Afghanistan, as well as bullying former colleagues and striking a former lover. The media outlets are seeking to rely chiefly on a defence of truth.
A former Special Air Service comrade, Person 4, told the court he saw Roberts-Smith kick the cuffed man off a cliff before he heard shots fired, and saw a second soldier, Person 11, with his rifle raised in a firing position.
Another former soldier, Person 56, said that either Person 4 or Person 11 disclosed after the Darwan mission that "an individual had been kicked off a cliff and … shot".
Three Afghan villagers told the court via audiovisual link from Kabul that the man killed was Ali Jan, a Darwan farmer who was not connected to the Taliban, and that a "big soldier" kicked him off a cliff.
But Roberts-Smith told the court there was "no cliff" and "no kick". The man in question was not a farmer but a suspected Taliban "spotter" reporting on the movement of coalition forces, he said, and both he and a soldier dubbed Person 11 lawfully fired shots at the man in a cornfield. Person 11, a friend of Roberts-Smith, supported this account.
Moses told the court the three Afghan witnesses were "entirely reliant on the financial support" of the newspapers for rent, food and medical expenses for more than a year "in a war-torn country with poverty so extreme that none of us in this courtroom could be said to experience it, let alone understand it".
"One cannot rule out the possibility that this may have influenced their evidence," he said. "That is one of the reasons why the court needs to approach their evidence with caution."
The newspapers had sought to prove as part of their truth defence that Roberts-Smith was complicit in six alleged killings in Afghanistan.
However, the media outlets accepted last week that one of the allegations cannot be proven because a former soldier they claimed was central to proving the crime declined to give evidence in court on the basis of self-incrimination.
The trial continues.
https://www.theage.com.au/national/bigger-knolls-at-bondi-Ben-Roberts-Smith-barrister-rejects-cliff-kick-claim-20220725-p5b4ao.html
#16802161 at 2022-07-25 11:05:56 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
>>16755924
Roberts-Smith alleged kick due to 'laugh'
Greta Stonehouse - July 25 2022
Highly trained and experienced war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith allegedly lost control and kicked an unarmed Afghan man off a cliff because he laughed at him.
In the second and final week of defamation trial closing submissions on Monday, barrister Arthur Moses SC said the Federal Court was asked to find his client's motivation for the allegation was "this man laughed at Mr Roberts-Smith twice".
"That a trained Australian soldier of the calibre of Mr Roberts-Smith and his undisputed record would so impulsively and cruelly first assault and then order the execution of an unarmed civilian in response of the slightest provocations is inherently improbable," Mr Moses said.
The Victoria Cross recipient is suing The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times over 2018 reports claiming he committed war crimes in Afghanistan including murder, and acts of bullying and domestic violence.
The 43-year-old denies all claims of wrongdoing, while the newspapers are defending them as true.
He is accused of kicking an innocent farmer called Ali Jan off the cliff and down into a river bed in September 2012 at Darwan.
The handcuffed prisoner was allegedly shot by another soldier, both alleged to be working in a joint criminal enterprise to carry out the murder.
Afghan eyewitnesses to the event were found through a middleman "fortuitously as luck would have it," and then set up with the mastheads who paid their rent, food and medical expenses for more than a year so they could give the evidence via videolink from Kabul, Mr Moses said.
"One cannot rule out the possibility this may have influenced their evidence."
He also pointed to another witness dubbed Person Seven, saying he was so obsessed that Mr Roberts-Smith was awarded the prestigious and rare medal that he sought to destroy his reputation using the media.
"To do all that he can to throw mud at (Mr Roberts-Smith) … and engaged in a war of words … in the dark and through the media.
"Person Seven heard rumours … and because of the Victoria Cross he starts hunting for war crimes."
The barrister submitted another former SAS soldier dubbed Person 14 lied to the court about a story that "flip-flopped" on numerous occasions.
"The lies drip from this man's evidence," Mr Moses said.
Person 14 testified that he observed a soldier wearing Mr Roberts-Smith's distinctive camouflage paint carrying his automatic Minimi weapon on a mission to a Taliban compound dubbed Whiskey 108 in 2009.
He said the soldier threw a figure to the ground before unloading an extended burst of Minimi fire upon them.
The barrister said notes from journalist Chris Masters dated February 2018 about his meeting with Person 14 stated that it was another soldier who shot the prisoner with a fake leg.
"But he told Your Honour that he told Mr Masters that it was Mr Roberts-Smith who shot the man with a prosthetic leg," Mr Moses said.
"He never told Mr Masters that, that would have been red hot for Mr Masters, he would have been tripping over himself to get to the editor's room.
"He contorted and twisted himself until the stage of lacking any credibility at all by the time he left the witness box."
Person 14 also told the court he saw Mr Roberts-Smith order Afghan soldiers to shoot a detained local man "or I will" during a 2012 mission in Khaz Uruzgan, something he denies.
Barrister Nicholas Owens SC on behalf of the newspapers last week said Mr Roberts-Smith colluded with several of his witnesses and good friends through clandestine meetings and swapping of evidence, and showed a guilty conscience of war crimes.
The trial is expected to resume in closed court on Tuesday.
Lifeline 13 11 14
https://www.lifeline.org.au
Open Arms 1800 011 046
https://www.openarms.gov.au
https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/7833246/Roberts-Smith-alleged-kick-due-to-laugh/
#16787498 at 2022-07-23 13:11:34 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
>>16755924
As the Roberts-Smith case nears its end, barrister returns to where he began: 'Someone is lying.'
Deborah Snow - July 23, 2022
1/2
Closing the long arc of the Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case this week, Nicholas Owens, SC, barrister for Nine's newspapers The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age, returned to the stark proposition he'd put at the beginning of hearings a year ago: that "someone is lying".
So irreconcilable were the differences between the version of events put forward by Nine's witnesses, and those of Roberts-Smith's backers, they could not be explained away as "honest or innocent or otherwise unwitting differences in perception or recollection", he said.
Indeed, Owens argued, not just one but multiple witnesses on the Roberts-Smith side had colluded, stitching up a false version of events to protect their friend, the once-storied war hero - a charge hotly denied by the soldier's legal team.
If there seemed to be an air of deja vu about the proceedings this week, that was the point. This was the summing up, a last chance to press home the case for each side before the judge retires to consider the verdict, which may not come for many more months.
Owens held centre stage for much of the week, speaking - with barely a reference to notes - for hours each day, hands in constant motion as he methodically drew the threads of Nine's case together, weaving back and forth across evidence elicited from more than 40 witnesses.
In the absence of a jury, this was about technical and forensic skill, not flights of oratory. The case in Sydney's Federal Court will be determined by one man - presiding justice Anthony Besanko, who's remained inscrutable throughout.
As ever, Roberts-Smith sat watching silently from the back of the court, with his parents once again in attendance.
Nine has set itself the task of proving the truth of its allegations. If Owens succeeds it will forever brand the Victoria Cross recipient a bully, a man capable of hitting a woman, and a murderer or facilitator of the murder of unarmed prisoners of war and therefore a war criminal.
Arthur Moses, SC, for Roberts-Smith, began an indignant counter-attack on Friday and will continue into next week seeking to demolish, piece by piece, Nine's allegations.
The key contention of the soldier's legal team remains that the media's stories are the product of "years of character assassination by disgruntled members" of the SAS, who "fed" information to Nine's investigative journalists Nick McKenzie and Chris Masters. The pair were not qualified war crimes investigators, Moses said. Nine instead carelessly portrayed Roberts-Smith as a "homicidal psychopath" through advancing a "fanciful and salacious case theory based on conjecture, speculation and imprecise testimony".
Nine originally laid six killings at the feet of Roberts-Smith. Owens conceded this week that one of those murders (said to have taken place near the village of Siah Chow) can no longer be made out, owing to Besanko's decision not to compel a key witness - Person 66 - to testify, because the man believed he might incriminate himself.
Owens had previously maintained that proving the Siah Chow murder alone would have given him an "independent path home to victory".
That leaves five other killings which Owens is resting the murder allegations on.
These include the much-publicised allegation that Roberts-Smith kicked an unarmed villager named Ali Jan off a cliff in the village of Darwan in September 2012 before conspiring with another soldier, Person 11, to kill the man and plant a radio device on him, falsely branding him a spotter for the Taliban.
Also given top billing by Owens are the events which took place at an Afghan compound designated Whiskey 108 on Easter Sunday 2009. There, the media outlets say, Roberts-Smith was responsible for the slaying of two unarmed Afghan prisoners, machine-gunning one himself and ordering the shooting of another. One of the prisoners possessed an artificial leg, which was later bizarrely re-purposed by the SAS as a drinking vessel.
The fourth and fifth killings are alleged to have taken place at the villages of Fasil and Chenatu (also known as Chenar Tu) in Afghanistan in late 2012.
Despite the gravity of the allegations, Owens says because it is a civil case he only has to prove that, on the balance of probabilities, the events occurred as Nine has described.
But Moses has warned "it will not be good enough for the media to point to the evidence and say 'we nearly got there'."
(continued)
#16779745 at 2022-07-22 10:28:44 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
>>16755924
Media outlets 'haven't proven murder', Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case told
Michaela Whitbourn - July 22, 2022
A trio of media outlets being sued for defamation by Ben Roberts-Smith have not proved the war veteran was complicit in the murder of Afghan prisoners, his barrister has told the Federal Court.
The court is hearing closing submissions in the defamation suit brought by the decorated former soldier against The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times. Roberts-Smith claims the newspapers wrongly accused him of war crimes in Afghanistan, bullying fellow soldiers, and an act of domestic violence against a former lover.
The media outlets are seeking to rely on a defence of truth but Arthur Moses, SC, acting for Roberts-Smith, told the court on Friday that "the evidence in this case does not establish any of the grave allegations which have been propounded" by the newspapers.
"Just because you say it doesn't make it true. Just because you believe it doesn't make it true," Moses said. "Facts are stubborn things."
He said the newspapers and their reporters "went big with their allegations as they attempted to paint themselves as pseudo war crimes investigators" but they had "come a cropper in this case".
Moses told the court that "you should not label a person a war criminal who has not been charged, let alone tried in a court of law", and his client "was, and is, entitled to the presumption of innocence, which the respondents ignored by alleging and convicting him of multiple murders in their publications".
Nicholas Owens, SC, acting for the newspapers, submitted during his closing address earlier this week that "a culture of silence" existed within the Special Air Service which led to Australian soldiers failing to report war crimes in Afghanistan.
In a reference to the famed military courtroom drama, Moses retorted on Friday that "this is not A Few Good Men" and there was "no evidence" such a culture existed.
He opened his closing address by quoting from Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's The Sign of Four: "How often have I said to you that, when you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth?"
Those words, Moses told the court, "were said by Sherlock Holmes to his friend Dr Watson" and had been cited in British and Australian judgments. He accused the newspapers of urging the court to adopt the "unjudicial" approach of the fictional detective.
"They want the court to accept a fanciful and salacious case theory based on conjecture, speculation and imprecise testimony," he said. "The case, with all due respect, is a nonsense, and quite frankly embarrassing."
Moses said the newspapers' defence was "more like a Walter Mitty production", in a reference to the fictional fantasist created by James Thurber, "than an attempt to mimic Sherlock Holmes".
Roberts-Smith, a former SAS corporal, is suing the newspapers over a series of articles in 2018 that he says portray him as a war criminal who was complicit in the unlawful killing of unarmed Afghan prisoners. Under the rules of engagement that bound the SAS, prisoners could not be killed. The former SAS corporal maintains any killings happened lawfully in the heat of battle.
The newspapers are seeking to rely on a defence of truth and alleged in a written defence that Roberts-Smith was involved in six unlawful killings in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012.
However, Owens has said the newspapers accepted they could not prove one of those murders because a former soldier the media outlets submitted was crucial to establishing the allegation, dubbed Person 66, objected to giving evidence on the grounds of self-incrimination.
Moses said the newspapers "haven't proven murder", and made submissions on one of the newspapers' centrepiece allegations, namely that Roberts-Smith was involved in the murder of two unarmed Afghan prisoners in 2009 at a compound dubbed Whiskey 108.
"There were no murders at Whiskey 108," Moses said. There was "no evidence" that any bodies had been exhumed or had been the subject of forensic examination, he said, or that ballistics evidence had been examined.
He also took aim at the newspapers for failing to call a senior Afghan soldier dubbed Person 12, whom the media outlets allege was directed by Roberts-Smith to order a second Afghan soldier to kill an unarmed prisoner in 2012.
"Is there an apprehension that he may not support their case?" he said.
The trial continues.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/media-outlets-haven-t-proven-murder-Roberts-Smith-defamation-case-told-20220722-p5b3sg.html
#16779737 at 2022-07-22 10:25:57 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
>>16755924
Ben Roberts-Smith legal counsel says witnesses who gave evidence against the war veteran are liars
Jamie McKinnell - 22 July 2022
Witnesses who gave evidence against Ben Roberts-Smith in his defamation case have been labelled liars, perjurers and gossips during a closing address by the war veteran's counsel.
The long-running trial is in its final stage, where barrister Arthur Moses SC is making closing submissions to the Federal Court in Sydney.
He took aim at the truth defence of publisher Nine Entertainment, which is being sued over newspaper stories published in 2018, and said its case was built on imprecise testimony, contradictory evidence, conjecture and speculation.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing over what he says are false allegations published in the stories, including that he committed war crimes in Afghanistan, was a bully to SAS colleagues, and was a perpetrator of domestic violence.
An SAS witness called by Nine, Person 14, previously claimed in court he witnessed Mr Roberts-Smith direct, via an interpreter, an Afghan soldier to execute an unarmed local man during a 2012 mission.
Another witness, Person 7, made allegations Mr Roberts-Smith used unnecessary force on Afghan civilians and claimed to have once heard him speak about a desire to "choke a man to death with my bare hands".
Mr Moses said the two were "plain and simple liars and perjurers".
"Person 14 repeatedly lied to Your Honour over at least 15 pages of his evidence. The lies were dripping from the pages," Mr Moses said.
That was, Mr Moses said, until the notes of Chris Masters were produced, detailing what Person 14 had told the journalist, which prompted his lies to unravel.
Mr Moses dismissed Person 7's testimony as "quite frankly embarrassing".
"Person 7 is a man possessed and obsessed with Mr Roberts-Smith's Victoria Cross, to the point of his partner telling him to stop talking about it, on his own admission," Mr Moses said.
He said Person 7 was not an eye witness, but "a gossip".
"He would even make Mrs Mangel from Neighbours blush, in respect of his amount of gossiping concerning Mr Roberts-Smith," he said.
Another witness, Person 24, previously told the court he saw Mr Roberts-Smith execute an Afghan man with a machine gun during the 2009 raid of a Taliban compound known as Whiskey 108.
"That man is a liar," Mr Moses said, pointing to the "inconsistent versions" the soldier had previously supplied.
"That witness subscribed to the unjudicial dictum of 'it's not a lie if you believe it', with apologies to George Costanza from Seinfeld," Mr Moses said.
Mr Moses told Justice Anthony Besanko that Nine had not established any of the "grave allegations" it propounded, and said the "vice" of its truth defence was its opacity and lack of precision.
Mr Roberts-Smith was accused in Nine's defence case of committing or being complicit in six murders in Afghanistan, but Mr Moses said the details of some of them had evolved over time.
"It has been truly a shifting sands approach to how they allege certain murders occurred, who was involved, or why they occurred," he said.
"A sliding factual substratum which they have impermissibly sought to adapt to whatever argument might advance their case, in a desperate bid to justify their unjustifiable publications."
The closing submissions are expected to last until Wednesday.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-07-22/Ben-Roberts-Smith-witnesses-liars-and-gossips-court-hears/101261392
#16773197 at 2022-07-21 10:22:20 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
>>16755924
Witness in Ben Roberts-Smith trial threatened with 'bullet in his head', judge hears
AAP - Jul 21, 2022
One of the most impressive witnesses to be called out of dozens in the defamation trial launched by Ben Roberts-Smith was threatened with a "bullet in his head" by the war veteran, a judge has been told.
Barrister Nicholas Owens SC said in his closing address for the media outlets being sued that Australia's most decorated soldier savagely bullied the still serving SAS soldier dubbed Person One.
In 2016, Roberts-Smith allegedly hit him in the back of the head multiple times, spat in front of him and regularly slammed doors in his face.
But most seriously was the threat to his life, Owens said.
"(He said) words to the effect: 'If your performance doesn't improve in the next patrol you're going to get a bullet in the back of the head'," Person One said in evidence.
"It made me fearful for my own personal safety. It made me lose more confidence. It made my performance worse."
Owens said on Thursday that Person One "interpreted those words as meaning that Roberts-Smith was going to shoot him in the back of the head".
The barrister submitted that Person One "was one of the most impressive witnessed to be called … on either side," due to him openly admitting his failings during his first four weeks of deployment in Afghanistan in 2006.
The incident dredged up from 15 years ago was a source of "enormous embarrassment" to the soldier given his illustrious and distinguished career that followed, including "uniformly glowing appraisals," since he left Roberts-Smith's patrol.
Person One testified that he failed to bring machine gun oil on one mission, which led to "stoppages" of his weapon not firing, and in extreme circumstances admitted this could have led to deaths of his comrades.
Owens also pointed to the credibility of Roberts-Smith's alleged mistress who says the Victoria Cross recipient punched her in a hotel room after she was drunk at a Canberra function and "embarrassed him" in March 2018.
Roberts-Smith's lawyers submit the woman is a liar and a fantasist and repeatedly point out that she is married, independently wealthy and has a prestigious job.
"The fundamental point seems to be that because she is capable of intelligent thought, because she was wealthy, educated and able to make decisions for herself, her conduct in the aftermath of the incident is so inconsistent with an assault having occurred that Your Honour would find it did not occur," Owens said.
"The implicit suggestion seems to be that wealthy educated people would act in a particular way, if they were a victim of assault.
"We respectfully submit that line of argument goes absolutely nowhere."
Roberts-Smith is suing The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald - owned by Nine, the publisher of this website - and The Canberra Times over 2018 reports claiming he committed war crimes in Afghanistan including murder, and acts of bullying and domestic violence.
The 43-year-old denies all claims of wrongdoing, while the mastheads are defending them as true.
Earlier, Arthur Moses SC, on behalf of Roberts-Smith, submitted the media waged a sustained attack on the war hero based on rumour, hearsay and contradictory accounts from jealous and obsessed former colleagues.
Moses said it shattered his reputation and even if vindicated in what was often described as the trial of the century, it would take years for it to fully recover.
The trial continues.
https://www.9news.com.au/national/Ben-Roberts-Smith-defamation-trial-media-outlet-barrister-nicholas-owens-closing-address/8c5ee08a-76ee-4342-a54e-d950504bd709
#16767627 at 2022-07-20 10:24:09 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
>>16755924
Roberts-Smith told 'deliberate lie' to conceal killing, court hears
Michaela Whitbourn - July 20, 2022
1/2
Ben Roberts-Smith told a "deliberate lie" to conceal his involvement in the alleged execution of an unarmed prisoner in Afghanistan, the war veteran's defamation case has been told.
The Federal Court is hearing closing submissions in the defamation suit brought against The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times. The decorated former soldier claims the newspapers wrongly accused him of being complicit in war crimes and the media outlets are seeking to rely chiefly on a defence of truth.
The newspapers allege Roberts-Smith was involved in the murder of five Afghan prisoners, including by directing an Afghan soldier working with Australian forces to order one of his subordinates to shoot an unarmed prisoner in October 2012. The media outlets say Roberts-Smith's direction was relayed by the Afghan soldier, dubbed Person 12, and the man was shot dead by a second Afghan soldier.
Nicholas Owens, SC, acting for the newspapers, alleged on Wednesday there had been a "concerted effort" by Roberts-Smith and four of his witnesses to give "false evidence" about the alleged incident, but their efforts were "frustrated" when the Defence Department produced "a large volume of contradictory material" last year.
Person 14, a serving SAS soldier who gave evidence for the newspapers, has told the court he witnessed the alleged execution, but Roberts-Smith and a series of his witnesses have said Person 12 was not there on the day in question. Roberts-Smith has also denied giving any such direction.
Two of Roberts-Smith's witnesses later admitted to making mistakes about the presence or otherwise of the Afghan soldier, but another former soldier said he was told in July 2012 that Person 12 had been "stood down from command" after an "incident". Another witness for Roberts-Smith said the incident in question was that Person 12 had shot at a dog and unintentionally injured a soldier.
Roberts-Smith conceded in court on June 11 last year that, based on material produced by the Defence Department on the eve of the trial, his explanation in a written outline of evidence about Person 12 being stood down for shooting a dog was wrong. However, he maintained the Afghan soldier was not there.
Owens alleged Roberts-Smith's claims about Person 12 were "a deliberate lie … which evidences a consciousness of guilt". He submitted that Person 12 was present on the day in question "beyond a shadow of a doubt", and the evidence of Person 14 was honest and accurate.
The "dog-shooting story" was "calculated to undermine the evidence" of Person 14, Owens said, and "remove Person 12 from the … mission". The most probable inference that arose from multiple witnesses having the same "demonstrably false recollection" about Person 12 was "dishonest collusion", he said.
(continued)
#16767613 at 2022-07-20 10:16:38 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
>>16755924
Ben Roberts-Smith prepared to 'lie under oath', judge told in defamation trial
Jamie McKinnell - 20 July 2022
War veteran Ben Roberts-Smith's credit as a witness in his defamation case has been seriously - if not irretrievably - damaged because he has "shown himself prepared to lie under oath", a judge has been told.
The submission was made by Nine Entertainment's barrister Nicholas Owens SC, on a third day of closing addresses in the Federal Court in Sydney.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing Nine over several 2018 newspaper articles in The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times, which he claims falsely painted him as a war criminal, a bully and a perpetrator of domestic violence.
Nine claims one alleged unlawful killing occurred during an October 2012 mission in Khaz Oruzgan, where Mr Roberts-Smith is accused of ordering, via an interpreter, a member of the Afghan Partner Force to shoot a local man being questioned.
The allegation, which Mr Roberts-Smith denies, created a dispute about whether the Afghan soldier, codenamed Person 12, was present because outlines of proposed evidence from the veteran and four of his SAS witnesses suggested otherwise.
The documents contained varying versions of the suggested reason why; that Person 12 was removed from the team months earlier, after he shot a dog and a ricocheting bullet injured an Australian soldier.
The four witnesses who raised the suggestion were Person 27, Person 32, Person 35 and Person 39.
Person 27 conceded in court his outline of evidence contained an error, while Person 32 said he had always been "under the assumption" the dog shooter was Person 12, and maintained that.
Person 35 admitted during his evidence that he had "remembered incorrectly" after being showed documents in closed court.
Person 39 told the judge he was informed during a briefing that Person 12 was the culprit.
Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team denied collusion.
Mr Owens today made submissions about possible inferences to be drawn from the "lie", including impacts upon the credit of the witnesses.
He said the impact on Person 35 and Person 32's credit was "devastating".
"One then starts to build, well what is the probability of multiple people having the same assertedly innocent but wholly implausible false recollection?" he said.
"We say that the sheer improbability of one person having it is one thing, but once multiple witnesses start to have the same demonstrably false recollection, that leads squarely, as the most probable inference, to both deliberate dishonesty and collusion between them."
The barrister said Mr Roberts-Smith's credit was "seriously damaged, if not irretrievably", because his "false" evidence can only be seen as an attempt to corroborate two of his ex-colleagues.
"Mr Roberts-Smith has shown himself prepared to lie, under oath, on matters squarely relevant to the substantive issues in these proceedings," Mr Owens said.
Mr Owens said Mr Roberts-Smith was "either the architect or the knowing Beneficiary of the collusion" and outlined why Justice Anthony Besanko could use the issue as a basis from which to infer a "consciousness of guilt".
Mr Roberts-Smith denies all wrongdoing and earlier this week, his barrister told the judge he was the victim of a "sustained campaign" from Nine to unfairly create the belief he committed war crimes.
Arthur Moses SC said the stories were based on rumour, hearsay and contradictory accounts from former colleagues, some of whom were "jealous" or "obsessed" with the veteran.
Closing submissions are expected to continue for another week.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-07-20/Ben-Roberts-Smith-lied-under-oath-court-hears/101254038
#16761530 at 2022-07-19 10:44:47 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
>>16755924
Afghan villagers and soldiers told the truth about Ben Roberts-Smith, defamation trial told
Michaela Whitbourn - July 19, 2022
1/2
The only plausible explanation why three illiterate Afghan villagers and two former elite soldiers all implicated Ben Roberts-Smith in the alleged murder of an Afghan prisoner was that all were telling the truth, the Federal Court has heard in the final days of the war veteran's defamation case.
The court is hearing closing submissions in the case brought against The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times. The decorated former soldier claims the newspapers wrongly accused him of being complicit in war crimes and the media outlets are seeking to rely chiefly on a defence of truth.
On Tuesday, the newspapers' barrister, Nicholas Owens, SC, focused on two of the media outlets' centrepiece allegations. The first was that Roberts-Smith was involved in the murder of two Afghan men in 2009 at a compound called "Whiskey 108", an alleged incident Owens said pointed to "a culture of silence within the SAS".
The second was that Roberts-Smith had kicked an unarmed and handcuffed villager off a cliff in Darwan on September 11, 2012, before the man was shot dead.
A former Special Air Service comrade, Person 4, told the court he saw Roberts-Smith kick the cuffed man off a cliff before he heard shots fired, and saw a second soldier, Person 11, with his rifle raised in a firing position. Another former soldier, Person 56, said that either Person 4 or Person 11 disclosed after the Darwan mission that "an individual had been kicked off a cliff and … shot".
Three Afghan villagers told the court via audiovisual link from Kabul that the man killed was Ali Jan, a Darwan farmer who was not connected to the Taliban, and that a "big soldier" kicked him off a cliff.
Owens submitted to the court on Tuesday: "How is it that three illiterate Afghan villagers on the other side of the world with no connection whatsoever to Person 4 have given evidence which in all material respects corresponds with what Person 4 says happened?
"They all spoke of … seeing someone kicked off a cliff, all at the exact same time, the exact same date and the exact same location that Person 4 described.
"There is no explanation for how it is that the evidence of those two completely unconnected groups of witnesses could possibly correspond to the extent it does."
Owens said "a second powerful source of corroboration for Person 4 is found in the evidence of Person 56".
Roberts-Smith told the court there was "no cliff" and "no kick". The man in question was not a farmer but a suspected Taliban "spotter" reporting on the movement of coalition forces, he said, and both he and a soldier dubbed Person 11 lawfully fired shots at the man in a cornfield. Person 11, a friend of Roberts-Smith, supported this account.
(continued)
#16761512 at 2022-07-19 10:40:09 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
>>16755924
One key question in Roberts-Smith defamation 'trial of the century'
PERRY DUFFIN - JULY 19, 2022
Nine newspapers' final attempt to defeat a mammoth defamation lawsuit, launched by venerated SAS soldier Ben Roberts-Smith, can be distilled to one single question and one single moment in the remote and dusty hills of Afghanistan one decade ago.
How could a group of illiterate Afghan villagers, and an elite SAS soldier, all recount the same harrowing details of an alleged war crime murder if it never happened?
The Federal Court, in Sydney, is in the final stages of the defamation trial of the century between the Victoria Cross recipient and the media company.
Justice Anthony Besanko has heard evidence from dozens of SAS veterans over more than 100 days of evidence.
One soldier, known as Person 4, emerged as perhaps the most critical witness in the trial.
Person 4 refused to testify on one allegation that he executed a prisoner on Mr Roberts-Smith's orders in 2009.
But he did testify about a mission in 2012, in the town of Darwan, where he claimed Mr Roberts-Smith kicked a detained shepherd, named Ali Jan, off a cliff.
Person 4 claimed he watched the handcuffed Afghan tumble down the slope, his head hitting a rock "exploding" a tooth from his mouth, before the badly injured man came to rest in a dry creek bed.
The SAS soldier claimed a third soldier, his best mate known as Person 11, then executed the Afghan while Mr Roberts-Smith watched on.
Person 4's evidence, Nine claims, lines up with what three villagers from Darwan told the court on a videolink from Kabul.
Nine's barrister, on Tuesday, cast the evidence from Person 4 and the Afghans as an undeniable consistency that points only to Mr Roberts-Smith's guilt.
"(The Afghans) all spoke of being in that final compound set, seeing a tall soldier wet from the waist down, seeing someone kicked off a cliff all at the exact same time, the exact same date, in the exact same location, that Person 4 described," Mr Owens told the court.
"There is no attempt (from Mr Roberts-Smith) to explain how it is that the evidence of Person 4, a soldier on this side of the world, could correspond so closely with the evidence of the three Afghan witnesses on the other side of the world."
Mr Owens claimed one of the villagers correctly described the SAS' military working dog, the number of ADF helicopters, the movements of troops, "the cliff kick" - all in line with what SAS witnesses later told the court.
The details offered up by the villagers could not be "cunningly" inserted or "manufactured" unless they were true Darwan locals and true witnesses to the raid, Mr Owens told the court.
Mr Owens' comments come at the very end of the trial, 10 years since the SAS raid on Darwan and four years since Nine newspapers first published war crime allegations against Mr Roberts-Smith.
Those articles prompted Mr Roberts-Smith to sue for defamation - he denied every single allegation while Nine mounted a truth defence.
The newspapers ultimately claimed, in their case, that Mr Roberts-Smith either pulled the trigger or ordered his patrol mates to execute six unarmed and detained Afghan men.
Mr Roberts-Smith's barristers, on Monday, urged Justice Besanko to see the case as an attempt to restore the good name of a war hero and a human being who has been falsely accused of murder.
"A human being who has suffered, who was once known as a hero but now, thanks to (Nine) is a man widely reviled as a murderer and an abuser of women," barrister Matthew Richardson SC said.
The closing submissions continue.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/breaking-news/one-key-question-in-robertssmith-defamation-trial-of-the-century/news-story/e0ac468366a17016d44f838e967a90d5
#16755934 at 2022-07-18 10:44:47 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
>>16755924
'Reviled as a murderer': Roberts-Smith closes case against Nine with fiery speech
PERRY DUFFIN - JULY 18, 2022
1/2
Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial is at the beginning of the end with his lawyers accusing Nine newspapers of a "sustained campaign" to falsely smear the Victoria Cross recipient as a war criminal, bully and domestic abuser with unfounded articles and a contorted court case.
The newspapers have claimed, in their final address, that Mr Roberts-Smith and his mates "calculated" and lied to hide the truth about brutal killings by the SAS.
Two full weeks of closing submissions are now underway in what has variously been called the trial of the century, a proxy war crime trial and an attack on the free press.
But Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers, on Monday, said their lawsuit is nothing but an attempt to clear the name of one of Australia's most venerated soldiers.
Behind the endless discussions about damages and defamation law is "a case about a human being", one of Mr Roberts-Smith's barristers told the court on Monday.
"A human being who has suffered, who was once known as a hero but now, thanks to (Nine) is a man widely reviled as a murderer and an abuser of women," Matthew Richardson SC said.
The barrister quoted Mr Roberts-Smith, in his evidence a year ago, who said "it was traumatising" to be at the centre of war crime accusations.
"I served with honour and distinction and I always followed the laws of armed conflict," Mr Roberts-Smith told the court.
"These people, using smears from people who don't like me, have written articles that suggest I'm a war criminal."
Mr Roberts-Smith said he was sent to Afghanistan at the behest of the Australian government and he always did the correct thing - even when those things were horrific.
"What is the legacy of my family now because of those articles?" he asked rhetorically.
"It's something that crushes me, crushes my soul, because I gave so much to that job and it's all lies."
Mr Roberts-Smith launched legal action against the publishers and journalists behind a series of articles in the Sydney Morning Herald and The Age newspapers in mid-2018.
The articles claimed Mr Roberts-Smith killed or was complicit in the murder of six unarmed prisoners on the battlefields of Afghanistan during his deployment with the SAS.
The articles further alleged Mr Roberts-Smith bullied other soldiers and physically abused a woman he was dating while back in Australia.
Mr Roberts-Smith emphatically denies every allegation made by Nine while the newspapers mounted a truth defence when the elite soldier sued them for defamation.
After more than 100 days of evidence, legal teams for Mr Roberts-Smith and Nine have begun summarising their cases to Federal Court Judge Anthony Besanko.
Mr Roberts-Smith's main barrister, Arthur Moses SC, began his closing address with a blistering denouncement of Nine's conduct, claiming the newspapers had refused to back down from errors in their stories, even in the face of contradictory evidence, and instead used the court to launch more unfounded allegations.
"This is not about a path home to victory, as (Nine) have at one time put their case," Mr Moses said.
"Rather this is about (Nine) using the processes of this court to make allegations of murder which will have national and international repercussions the applicant and other members of the Australian Defence Force who they have accused of murder."
Nine's barrister, Nicholas Owens SC, painted the case very differently.
He said it was no coincidence that his reluctant and disconnected witnesses all gave sworn evidence that pointed to Mr Roberts-Smith's guilt, particularly on a crucial mission from 2009 known as Whiskey 108.
Nine claims the SAS found two Afghans hiding in a tunnel and detained them before Mr Roberts-Smith executed one and forced a junior soldier to execute the second.
The SAS soldiers, on the ground at Whiskey 108, have given totally contradictory evidence about the raid.
(continued)
#16755924 at 2022-07-18 10:42:32 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial begins hearing closing submissions after 100 days of testimony
Jamie McKinnell - 18 July 2022
1/2
Ben Roberts-Smith's barrister has told a judge the war veteran was an exceptional soldier who was subject to a sustained campaign from newspapers to create a belief he was a war criminal.
After more than 100 days since it began, closing submissions have started in the Victoria Cross recipient's defamation case against The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald, The Canberra Times, and three journalists.
He claims he was falsely portrayed in 2018 articles as a war criminal, a bully and a perpetrator of domestic violence.
The veteran's barrister, Arthur Moses SC, began by telling Justice Anthony Besanko the proceedings had been called "a great many things", including the "trial of the century", a "proxy war-crimes trial" and an "attack" on press freedom.
"It is none of these," Mr Moses told the Federal Court in Sydney.
"This has been a case about how Mr Roberts-Smith, the most decorated Australian soldier, and a man with a high reputation for courage, skill and decency in soldiering, had that reputation destroyed by the respondents".
Mr Roberts-Smith served in the SAS between 1996 and 2013, including multiple deployments to Afghanistan.
Ben Roberts-Smith's barrister has told a judge the war veteran was an exceptional soldier who was subject to a sustained campaign from newspapers to create a belief he was a war criminal.
After more than 100 days since it began, closing submissions have started in the Victoria Cross recipient's defamation case against The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald, The Canberra Times, and three journalists.
He claims he was falsely portrayed in 2018 articles as a war criminal, a bully and a perpetrator of domestic violence.
The veteran's barrister, Arthur Moses SC, began by telling Justice Anthony Besanko the proceedings had been called "a great many things", including the "trial of the century", a "proxy war-crimes trial" and an "attack" on press freedom.
"It is none of these," Mr Moses told the Federal Court in Sydney.
"This has been a case about how Mr Roberts-Smith, the most decorated Australian soldier, and a man with a high reputation for courage, skill and decency in soldiering, had that reputation destroyed by the respondents".
Mr Roberts-Smith served in the SAS between 1996 and 2013, including multiple deployments to Afghanistan.
"As the evidence demonstrated, Mr Roberts-Smith was an exceptional soldier - highly organised, a leader, resourceful and exceptionally brave," Mr Moses said.
Mr Moses said Mr Roberts-Smith was competent in battle, effective in killing anti-coalition militia, and never sought a defence honour or recognition.
"What he did not expect was that having been awarded the Victoria Cross, he would have a target on his back," the barrister continued.
"The publications of the respondents were based on rumour, hearsay and contradictory accounts from former colleagues who were, some, jealous, and/or obsessed with Mr Roberts-Smith."
(continued)
#16701712 at 2022-07-10 01:20:42 (UTC+1)
Q Research Australia #25: My Koala Hates Spam Too Edition
#23 and #24 - Part 11
Cardinal George Pell and Vatican Financial Scandal Allegations
>>16580173 Vatican Cardinals Laud US Supreme Court's Dobbs Decision - Cardinals Burke, Pell, Kasper, M?ller and Czerny welcome last week's landmark decision and discuss its implications
#23 and #24 - Part 12
Malka Leifer Extradition and Prosecution
>>16384807 Israeli legislator Yaakov Litzman leaves Knesset after assisting accused Australian pedophile - Ultra-Orthodox former minister indicted for breach of trust and obstruction of justice in Leifer affair when he offered promotions to psychiatrists in exchange for their evaluation that she is unfit to stand trial
>>16424977 Haredi Lawmaker Convicted Under Plea Deal Over Malka Leifer Affair - Former Health Minister Yaakov Litzman pleaded guilty to breach of trust in the sex abuse case of Malka Leifer, but is expected to remain politically active
#23 and #24 - Part 13
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial
>>16349807 Missing witness and a change of government: the latest delays in Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation case - Trial held up due to Covid and fall of Kabul now waits for evidence release by new attorney general and reappearance of Person 27
>>16366989 SAS soldier recalled after puzzling evidence in Ben Roberts-Smith case - A witness codenamed Person 27 being recalled to testify in closed court
>>16379348 Senior SAS officer backs Ben Roberts-Smith on a key piece of evidence
>>16384791 Ex-soldier 'couldn't say' whether Roberts-Smith was complicit in murders, court told
>>16403584 Inside SAS raid at centre of Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial: photos - Never-before-seen photos of the moments after a bomb fell on a Taliban compound and a soldier allegedly pilfered a leg from a dead insurgent can now be revealed
>>16434662 Redacted reports, letters to The Hague: secretive investigations coinciding with BRS' defamation lawsuit - With all eyes on Roberts-Smith's defamation case, it's easy to forget a team of war crime investigators are picking through allegations against the SAS and writing letters to The Hague with criminal prosecutions in mind
>>16543835 Royal Commission into Defence and Veteran Suicide hears of problems in Defence Abuse Response Taskforce (DART) - Former chair Leonard Roberts-Smith (father of Ben Roberts-Smith) gave his frank assessment of the body as he gave evidence
>>16543859 If we fail to prosecute war crimes, the law is a 'dead letter,' says inquiry judge NSW Court of Appeal Justice Paul Brereton -
>>16586834 Give time for 'shameful episode' to be investigated - A probe into alleged war crimes by Australian troops in Afghanistan must be given time to run its course, Defence Minister Richard Marles says
#16655177 at 2022-07-07 08:40:08 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #24: TRUMP CARD COMING Edition
#23 - Part 10
Cardinal George Pell and Vatican Financial Scandal Allegations
>>16580173 Vatican Cardinals Laud US Supreme Court's Dobbs Decision - Cardinals Burke, Pell, Kasper, M?ller and Czerny welcome last week's landmark decision and discuss its implications
#23 - Part 11
Malka Leifer Extradition and Prosecution
>>16384807 Israeli legislator Yaakov Litzman leaves Knesset after assisting accused Australian pedophile - Ultra-Orthodox former minister indicted for breach of trust and obstruction of justice in Leifer affair when he offered promotions to psychiatrists in exchange for their evaluation that she is unfit to stand trial
>>16424977 Haredi Lawmaker Convicted Under Plea Deal Over Malka Leifer Affair - Former Health Minister Yaakov Litzman pleaded guilty to breach of trust in the sex abuse case of Malka Leifer, but is expected to remain politically active
#23 - Part 12
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial
>>16349807 Missing witness and a change of government: the latest delays in Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation case - Trial held up due to Covid and fall of Kabul now waits for evidence release by new attorney general and reappearance of Person 27
>>16366989 SAS soldier recalled after puzzling evidence in Ben Roberts-Smith case - A witness codenamed Person 27 being recalled to testify in closed court
>>16379348 Senior SAS officer backs Ben Roberts-Smith on a key piece of evidence
>>16384791 Ex-soldier 'couldn't say' whether Roberts-Smith was complicit in murders, court told
>>16403584 Inside SAS raid at centre of Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial: photos - Never-before-seen photos of the moments after a bomb fell on a Taliban compound and a soldier allegedly pilfered a leg from a dead insurgent can now be revealed
>>16434662 Redacted reports, letters to The Hague: secretive investigations coinciding with BRS' defamation lawsuit - With all eyes on Roberts-Smith's defamation case, it's easy to forget a team of war crime investigators are picking through allegations against the SAS and writing letters to The Hague with criminal prosecutions in mind
>>16543835 Royal Commission into Defence and Veteran Suicide hears of problems in Defence Abuse Response Taskforce (DART) - Former chair Leonard Roberts-Smith (father of Ben Roberts-Smith) gave his frank assessment of the body as he gave evidence
>>16543859 If we fail to prosecute war crimes, the law is a 'dead letter,' says inquiry judge NSW Court of Appeal Justice Paul Brereton -
>>16586834 Give time for 'shameful episode' to be investigated - A probe into alleged war crimes by Australian troops in Afghanistan must be given time to run its course, Defence Minister Richard Marles says
#16554400 at 2022-06-29 12:02:10 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #23: HOUSE OF CARDS Edition
>>16554395
2/3
'Shame and threats': ADFA culture discouraged reporting abuse
A TASKFORCE set up to examine abuse in the Defence Force found more than 60 alleged perpetrators linked to serious issues at the Australian Defence Force Academy in the 1980s to 2000s were still serving in the ranks when it handed down its report.
The Defence Abuse Reform Taskforce (DART) and its 2014 report remains a focus as the Royal Commission into Defence and Veteran Suicide continues its public hearings in Townsville.
Retired judge and former DART chair Leonard Roberts-Smith told the government at the time that it should hold a Royal Commission into sexual abuse claims at ADFA in the 1990s.
DART assessed 50 accusations at ADFA as having one or more plausible allegations of abuse with 33 cases reporting sexual abuse and 18 reporting sexual harassment.
He told the commission he was "disturbed" that the task force's 2014 report was not more accessible online.
"I think they would be a very valuable resource ... there is no point doing this over and over again from the start," he said.
He said the taskforce reported a number of allegations to the Chief of the Defence Force for potential administrative or disciplinary action but that even after his tenure ended he was not aware of any action against alleged abusers who were still serving.
During his evidence, Mr Roberts-Smith said the culture at ADFA did not support reporting abuse, in many cases, protected the abuser and treated abuse as an "integral" part of life at the institution.
"Those who did report were subject to stigma and shame and threats and fear of reprisals," he said.
"It not only dissuaded reporting but encouraged further abuse.
"These officer cadets go through ADFA and get their commissions and the very next day they go out in leadership roles ... and what they carry with them will be how they start their leadership careers."
He told the commission that DART identified at least 60 individuals from the 1980s to 2000s who were allegedly responsible for alleged sexual and physical abuse or harassment and bullying at ADFA who were still serving in the permanent or reserve force.
DART also identified another 10 alleged abusers who had been transferred to the inactive standby or standby reserve forces.
Mr Roberts-Smith said the community was dissatisfied with Defence's response to the number of abuse claims linked to the academy.
"The response generally, certainly to the end of my tenure ... was Defence was unable in broad terms to take any further action in relation to these cases," he told the commission.
Mr Roberts-Smith said while this was the case in some situations where complainants would not consent to action being taken, it was not always the case.
"It was difficult simply receiving the constant response that because, primarily, these are historical cases there is nothing we can do about them and that was certainly not a response which was well received by the community," he said,
"In relation to the ADFA cases ... it seemed to me that whilst these responses from Defence might well be right, I wasn't entirely sure that was the case.
"And it seemed to me that there was scope for further examination."
Former Judge Advocate General of the Australian Defence Force, Mr Roberts-Smith is the father of Victoria Cross recipient and accused war criminal Ben Roberts-Smith.
(continued)
#16543859 at 2022-06-28 10:00:15 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #23: HOUSE OF CARDS Edition
>>16543835
If we fail to prosecute war crimes, the law is a 'dead letter,' says inquiry judge
Nick McKenzie and Chris Masters - June 18, 2022
1/2
The senior judge who led the biggest and most damning war crimes inquiry in Australian history has said that investigating and prosecuting war crimes is vital to preserve the nation's "reputation and standing".
In a rare public foray, NSW Court of Appeal Justice Paul Brereton warned in a speech earlier this month that Australian laws prohibiting war crimes "are pointless if they are not enforced, and a law which is not enforced soon becomes a dead letter". He also flagged "the risk that national chauvinism might trump justice according to the international law of armed conflict".
Brereton conducted the long-running military inspector-general's inquiry into war crimes in Afghanistan, which issued its explosive public report in November 2020.
His comments come as the Australian Federal Police's (AFP) parallel war crimes inquiry passed its four-year anniversary this month, having not laid a single charge or absolved any suspect since beginning in June 2018. Since May 2020, the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions, Sarah McNaughton, SC, has been analysing interim briefs of evidence compiled by the police inquiry.
Complicated investigations can take years for police and prosecutors to resolve, either by reaching a decision to prosecute or by concluding there is insufficient evidence to charge. But the four years and counting timeline of the AFP's Afghan war crimes investigation is causing concern among lawyers and supporters of witnesses.
According to sources dealing with police witnesses, some have not heard from the AFP in many months and they are concerned that, as more time passes, memories will fade.
Concern about the AFP's ability to handle the multiple war crimes allegations arising out of the Brereton inquiry led to the creation of a dedicated war crimes agency, the Office of the Special Investigator, in early 2021. While the OSI has launched its own inquiries, the AFP has retained carriage of the probes it began in 2018.
In a lecture at the Military History Society on June 4, Brereton did not mention Afghanistan and spoke only of war crimes case studies dating back decades. But his public comments are significant because his investigation was the catalyst for the police inquiries into multiple Australian soldiers over allegations they executed prisoners in Afghanistan.
The judge's speech was made all the more remarkable by the attendance of another judicial heavyweight, Len Roberts-Smith, a former West Australian Supreme Court judge and the father of Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith. In his role as military inspector-general probing alleged war crimes, Brereton referred Roberts-Smith and two other former soldiers to the Chief of the Defence Force in May 2018, triggering the AFP's ongoing inquiry.
Roberts-Smith jnr has previously publicly attacked the work of the Brereton Inquiry, claiming it was based on rumours rather than evidence.
Len Roberts-Smith, also a former judge advocate general for the Australian Defence Force, sat in the front row of the small auditorium, a few feet from Brereton, during the speech. Earlier this year, Roberts-Smith snr regularly attended the defamation trial launched by his son against The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times for implicating him in war crimes allegations.
In June last year, Roberts-Smith snr issued a statement attacking the allegations. "We never expected that our son would be unfairly attacked in this manner after he served his country in Afghanistan with distinction and risked his life," it said.
(continued)
#16543835 at 2022-06-28 09:52:55 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #23: HOUSE OF CARDS Edition
>>16476580
Royal commission hears of problems in Defence Abuse Response Taskforce
The Royal Commission into Defence and Veteran Suicide has heard that a taskforce set up to probe abuse in the Australian Defence Force struggled to cope with a series of challenges.
Leighton Smith - June 28, 2022
A GOVERNMENT taskforce set up to probe abuse in the Australian Defence Force had a limited scope and had no legal powers to compel anyone to speak to it.
The former chair of the Defence Abuse Response Taskforce (DART) Leonard Roberts-Smith gave his frank assessment of the body as he gave evidence before the Royal Commission into Defence and Veteran Suicide in Townsville.
DART was established in November 2012 to provide respite to people who claimed to have suffered physical or sexual abuse within the ADF prior to April 2011.
This included 24 serious allegations of abuse at Australian Defence Force Academy and other abuse allegations at the tarnished HMAS Leeuwin.
The former judge told the commission DART was initially given six staff members and a 12 month time frame to achieve its goals but that when abuse claims started pouring in it didn't even have an office or a computer system to record them.
"As at day one, there were seven of us and we had to build the taskforce and everything that that entailed," he said.
"Once the announcement had been made by the government, we started receiving allegations of abuse from complainants directly to the taskforce.
"Our first task was simply to collect these (allegations) as they came in to log them, yet bearing in mind we didn't even have a computer system at that time and we had to log them physically."
He said that as horrific stories of abuse were logged with DART the team was tasked with finding office accommodation, setting up computers, case management, accounting and logistics systems and recruiting more staff.
Mr Roberts-Smith said the taskforce faced a number of legal and confidentially challenges, including initially accessing information from Defence although this issue was eventually resolved.
"It was a rather challenging environment in which to operate," he said.
He said DART received extensive support from the then Attorney-General, Minister for Defence and the then Chief and Secretary of the Defence Force.
"There were some practical problems which were not in any way contrived," he said.
"There is quite often still a general resistance in some parts of Defence given the beast that it is ... but we overcame all of those."
During his evidence Mr Roberts-Smith described poor record keeping and archiving of files and records, which in some cases had been disposed of or never made in the first place.
Mr Roberts-Smith told the commission multiple abuse victims who spoke to DART expressed they had contemplated suicide or actually attempted to take their lives.
He said another collective message from complainants was that they felt "failed" or "betrayed" by their service and that this was the fundamental driver for them to come forward about their abuse.
"It is no exaggeration to say that in very many, if not most of the cases that came to the taskforce the person who had been abused had his or her life literally destroyed as a consequence," he said.
"What we found we were getting more commonly than not was the reaction that: 'no I don't actually care about the (person/s) that did this to me. What really disturbed me is the fact that the service I was in ... let me down'."
"They are supposed to look after me but they let it happen to me. I reported it and they didn't do anything'."
He said Defence brushed off reports of serious abuse at the Fremantle Navy Training base HMAS Leeuwin as simply historical.
"Defence in responding to anything we might say about (historic abuse at HMAS Leeuwin) in responding to anything we might say about that, would characterise it as being historical and of no particular relevance.
"Even though these might have been quite historical events ... the effects of the abuse suffered ... was still current," he said.
"We are talking about men in their 60s and 70s whose lives had been destroyed by the abuse."
The taskforce, among other things, ultimately found that allegations of serious abuse at ADFA and HMAS Leeuwin were more widespread and persistent than previous government inquiries found and were present at other ADF training institutions.
DART made reparation payments to 1723 people totalling $66.63 million, referred 133 complaints to police and 132 complaints to the Chief of the Defence Force, a government report says.
Former Judge Advocate General of the Australian Defence Force, Mr Roberts-Smith is the father of Victoria Cross recipient and accused war criminal Ben Roberts-Smith.
https://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/townsville/royal-commission-hears-of-problems-in-defence-abuse-response-taskforce/news-story/fe9f05d73706b9f40ee2d4e309172bc0
#16434662 at 2022-06-12 10:58:51 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #23: HOUSE OF CARDS Edition
>>16349807
Redacted reports, letters to The Hague: secretive investigations coinciding with BRS' defamation lawsuit
With all eyes on Roberts-Smith's defamation case, it's easy to forget a team of war crime investigators are picking through allegations against the SAS and writing letters to The Hague with criminal prosecutions in mind.
Perry Duffin - June 12, 2022
1/2
The coming verdict in Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial is unlikely to silence war crime allegations against the SAS - instead it is potentially the first of many public reckonings with Australia's war in Afghanistan.
Now-Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said Australia "must act on the Brereton Report findings and never hide from the truth of our past" as the Morrison Government established a new investigative body and an oversight panel.
Major General Paul Brereton, head of the IGADF, concluded there was credible information that 39 Afghans were murdered by Australian special forces in 23 incidents after interviewing many SAS soldiers.
"None of these alleged crimes was committed during the heat of battle. The alleged victims were non-combatants or no longer combatants," the damning report concluded in November 2020.
The Office of the Special Investigator (OSI) works with Australian Federal Police investigators to pick through the evidence that went before Brereton and likely much more.
The Brereton report, with pages after page entirely blacked out, offers no insight into exactly which incidents and soldiers the OSI has in its sights.
As the report made headlines across the world, Nine was quietly finalising its truth defence against Mr Roberts-Smith's lawsuit.
The decision essentially transformed the civil case into a proxy war crime trial but, unlike the IGADF, it would take place largely in public.
For many of the 99 days of evidence that followed the doors to the court were shut in order to protect the closely guarded identities of the SAS witnesses.
A videolink, instead, beamed out images of the multimillion-dollar legal teams, Justice Anthony Besanko or the silver coat of arms on the courtroom wall as soldiers audibly described prisoners shot dead in dusty compounds.
They told the court Afghans were killed as part of exhibition executions or macabre bonding rituals known as "blooding".
Others denied the claims, saying medal envy over Mr Roberts-Smith's Victoria Cross had birthed a jealous conspiracy in the broken squadron.
But the closed-circuit of the case broke in May when one witness, who had testified for Mr Roberts-Smith, was arrested by the AFP hours before he was to leave the country.
(continued)
#16403584 at 2022-06-06 10:56:06 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #23: HOUSE OF CARDS Edition
>>16349807
Inside SAS raid at centre of Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial: photos
Never-before-seen photos of the moments after a bomb fell on a Taliban compound and a soldier allegedly pilfered a leg from a dead insurgent can now be revealed.
Perry Duffin - June 6, 2022
1/2
For the first time, exclusive photos reveal the chaos, rubble and darkness that met the SAS as they stormed a shattered Taliban base during the 2009 mission that would become the backdrop for the most brutal allegations against Ben Roberts-Smith.
The never-before-seen images, captured in Afghanistan in 2012, illustrate crucial parts of the case; including the moment one of Mr Roberts-Smith's detractors allegedly pillaged a prosthetic leg from a dead insurgent.
For years Mr Roberts-Smith has denied allegations he was involved in two war crime executions in the Taliban base known as Whiskey 108 on Easter Sunday, 2009.
One image offers a rare glimpse into the raid which a dozen soldiers now have been asked to relive in the defamation trial.
It depicts the shattered but still standing walls of the mud compound, with soldiers picking through the debris.
A 500-pound American war head had just been dropped on the insurgent hide-out which had been nestled in the "green belt", the dense vegetation that runs alongside Afghan rivers.
Ten SAS soldiers have been called to give evidence about their precise movements in the dangerous battlefield and vigorously questioned on blank spots and contradictions in their decade-old memories.
That's because one curious discovery at Whiskey 108 defined and divided so much of the trial - a subterranean tunnel.
Exactly what 10 SAS soldiers remember about the tunnel is crucial; five have said one thing, five have said the complete opposite.
Five soldiers, and Nine newspapers, claim two Afghans were found cowering in the concealed tunnel during the raid and detained.
One Afghan was elderly, the other was middle-aged and had a fake leg, the court has heard.
Nine claims the two prisoners were handed over to Mr Roberts-Smith's patrol group before being executed - war crime murders.
Nine alleges Mr Roberts-Smith machine gunned the man with a prosthetic leg and ordered a rookie SAS soldier to shoot the elderly Afghan so he could be "blooded".
Mr Roberts-Smith and his five SAS supporters have testified no one was hiding in the tunnel.
The Victoria Cross recipient's case is that it follows that no executions happened at Whiskey 108.
The one-legged man, photographed dead on the ground, was shot in a legitimate engagement, Mr Roberts-Smith insists.
What all sides agree on is that the dead man's fake leg was taken from Whiskey 108 strapped to the back of a patrol commander known as Person 6.
One image, obtained by The Daily Telegraph, shows the high ranking soldier posing with his men and the leg in front of armoured Australian vehicles.
The image of the leg, on Person 6's back, also features two other soldiers who testified against Mr Roberts-Smith.
Person 14 and Person 24 both posed cheekily with the leg in the gloomy dark despite telling the court they watched Mr Roberts-Smith execute its owner just a short time earlier.
"(Mr Roberts-Smith) marched approximately 15 metres directly out from that entrance, dropped the man on the ground and immediately began with a machine gun burst into his back," Person 24 said in his evidence.
"I recall saying to Person 14 at the time, 'Did we just witness an execution?'"
(continued)
#16384791 at 2022-06-02 10:36:40 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #23: HOUSE OF CARDS Edition
>>16349807
Ex-soldier 'couldn't say' whether Roberts-Smith was complicit in murders, court told
Michaela Whitbourn - June 2, 2022
A former senior Special Air Service soldier who served in Afghanistan with war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith has told the Federal Court he couldn't say whether Roberts-Smith was complicit in the murder of two Afghan prisoners and he relied on his subordinates to give truthful reports about any killings.
Person 81, a former SAS troop commander whose identity is suppressed for national security reasons, was the final witness to give evidence in Roberts-Smith's defamation case against The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times. He was cross-examined about a key issue in the trial, namely the circumstances in which two Afghan men died during a mission at a compound dubbed Whiskey 108 in 2009.
Roberts-Smith is suing The Age, the Herald and The Canberra Times for defamation over a series of articles in 2018 he says portray him as a war criminal who was involved in the unlawful killing of unarmed Afghan prisoners. Under the rules of engagement that bound the SAS, prisoners could not be killed.
The decorated former soldier denies all wrongdoing and has said any killings in Afghanistan, including two during the Whiskey 108 mission, happened lawfully in the heat of battle. The media outlets are seeking to rely on a defence of truth and allege Roberts-Smith was involved in six unlawful killings in Afghanistan, including the execution of two men who emerged from a tunnel at Whiskey 108.
Person 81, who was called by Roberts-Smith's legal team to give evidence, was troop commander in Afghanistan during the Whiskey 108 mission. He said on Wednesday that he was not informed by his soldiers that any men had been discovered in a tunnel.
During cross-examination by the newspapers' barrister, Nicholas Owens, SC, on Thursday Person 81 agreed he was unable to say one way or another whether there were people in the tunnel, only that he didn't see any himself.
"I take it, in your role as commander, you are, in fact, quite busy at all times during the mission?" Owens asked. "That is very correct," Person 81 replied.
Person 81 told the court he had a memory of seeing fighting-age Afghan men inside Whiskey 108, but could not remember where.
Roberts-Smith has told the court no men were found inside the tunnel and two insurgents were killed lawfully outside Whiskey 108, including one man killed by him. He called four SAS witnesses who supported his account about the tunnel. Another soldier, Person 27, said he did not have "any recollection of anyone coming out of a tunnel", although he was not in the area.
SAS witnesses called by the newspapers have said at least two men were found in a tunnel at Whiskey 108 and taken prisoner. A serving SAS soldier, Person 41, told the court he saw Roberts-Smith execute one unarmed Afghan man that day and direct another soldier, Person 4, to kill a second man. The newspapers allege the men were taken from the tunnel.
Person 81 agreed on Thursday he "wouldn't know" whether two men killed on the day of the Whiskey 108 mission were prisoners. He also "couldn't say" whether one of the men was executed by Roberts-Smith, or whether the second man was executed by Person 4 with Roberts-Smith's encouragement. He did not see anything that made him suspect this had occurred, he said.
Person 81 agreed he relied on patrol commanders, who headed smaller teams of soldiers within the troop, to give honest and accurate information about any killings.
Roberts-Smith will officially close his case on Friday before the parties return to court in July for final submissions.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/ex-soldier-couldn-t-say-whether-Roberts-Smith-was-complicit-in-murders-court-told-20220602-p5aqlo.html
#16379348 at 2022-06-01 09:45:16 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #23: HOUSE OF CARDS Edition
>>16349807
Senior SAS officer backs Ben Roberts-Smith
Greta Stonehouse - June 1, 2022
A senior SAS soldier who will likely be the final witness to testify in the protracted defamation trial launched by Ben Roberts-Smith has backed the war veteran on a key piece of evidence.
The serving elite soldier dubbed Person 81 began his evidence in the Federal Court on Wednesday nearly a year after the trial began.
He had risen through the ranks to captain and was heading the patrol to a Taliban compound known as Whiskey 108 in Afghanistan's Uruzgan province in 2009.
He ordered the patrol commanders to clear the compound after Australian troops had dropped a series of 500-pound bombs on it.
After the infrastructure had been "significantly destroyed" Person 81 entered and distinctly recalls an Afghan woman was sweeping, and body parts among rocket paraphernalia.
And while he does remember a secret tunnel was found, he is unsure of where he was and how he was told.
Defence barrister Arthur Moses SC, representing Mr Roberts-Smith, asked if anyone informed him if Afghan fighting-aged males were found inside the tunnel.
"No," he said.
The Victoria Cross recipient is suing for defamation The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times over 2018 reports claiming he committed war crimes in Afghanistan including murder, and acts of bullying and domestic violence.
The 43-year-old denies all claims of wrongdoing, while the mastheads are defending them as true.
The newspapers allege two men did willingly surrender from hiding in the tunnel at Whiskey 108, and were subsequently taken prisoner by Australian forces.
The war hero is accused of throwing one of the men who had a prosthetic leg onto the ground and opening fire on his back
"It was an exhibition execution, he wanted people to see he was going to kill someone out there in front of everyone," another soldier dubbed Person 24 previously told the court.
Another former SAS soldier testified that Mr Roberts-Smith forced the other prisoner to kneel and ordered his younger colleague to shoot him.
But the captain at the time denies ever seeing fighting-aged males coming out of the tunnel, nor did he see any prisoners taken captive.
And nobody in his troop told him unlawful activity had occurred that day, he said.
"What would you have done (if they had)?" Mr Moses asked.
"I would have reported it," he said.
Most of Person 81's evidence on Wednesday was concealed behind a closed courtroom.
He is due to resume his testimony on Thursday morning when the trial before Justice Anthony Besanko resumes.
Lifeline 13 11 14
Open Arms 1800 011 046
https://www.lifeline.org.au/
https://www.openarms.gov.au/
https://www.perthnow.com.au/news/crime/senior-sas-officer-backs-Ben-Roberts-Smith-c-7017587
#16366989 at 2022-05-30 09:27:31 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #23: HOUSE OF CARDS Edition
>>16349807
SAS soldier recalled after puzzling evidence in Ben Roberts-Smith case
An SAS soldier who gave evidence about a strange issue at the Ben Roberts-Smith trial has been brought back for one reason.
Perry Duffin - May 30, 2022
An SAS soldier, who testified for Ben Roberts-Smith about a puzzling war story, has been recalled to give more evidence behind closed doors in the marathon defamation case.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing Nine newspapers over a series of articles in which they claimed he committed war crime murders in Afghanistan.
The Victoria Cross recipient denies each allegation and has been calling witnesses for over a month to testify in his case.
The court, on Monday, heard a witness codenamed Person 27 was now being recalled to testify in closed court.
He had been overseas until this weekend and the court had struggled to locate him - but he will now give evidence on Tuesday afternoon.
It's not yet clear if the public will learn what Person 27 is being recalled over - but the SAS soldier previously told the court Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers were behind a strange comment that has appeared in multiple court documents.
The court has heard claims Mr Roberts-Smith, at the end of 2012, ordered an Afghan special forces soldier to execute a detained civilian after the SAS discovered a weapons cache.
Some soldiers have claimed they witnessed the killing - others, including Mr Roberts-Smith, deny any such shooting took place.
Mr Roberts-Smith and four other SAS soldiers submitted outlines of evidence to the court that said Nine's allegation was wrong.
Their reason was simple and clear - an Afghan soldier, which Nine claims was also involved in the killing, was not working with the Australians at that time in 2012.
Person 27 was among those witnesses who said that particular Wakunish soldier, or "Waka", had been removed from service because he shot a dog.
The bullet ricocheted and hit an Australian soldier in the rear, Mr Roberts-Smith's witnesses said in their outline of evidence.
But Person 27, speaking on the stand this month, told the court that the outline of evidence was incorrect.
The Wakunish soldier Mr Roberts-Smith's side accused of shooting the dog, known only as Person 12, had not been removed from service, the court has now repeatedly heard.
"Who first used Person 12's name?" Nine's barrister asked.
"Ben's lawyers," Person 27 responded.
Last month Nine's barrister, Nicholas Owens SC, accused Mr Roberts-Smith's witnesses of "colluding" to give false evidence that would make Nine's allegation impossible.
Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team deny there was any collusion.
Person 27's evidence is expected to last just one day before the court prepares to hear from a high ranking SAS officer.
The officer, who cannot be identified, will give evidence on another mission in which Nine claims Mr Roberts-Smith carried out war crimes.
The multi-year case is expected to close on Friday.
https://www.news.com.au/national/courts-law/sas-soldier-recalled-after-puzzling-evidence-in-Ben-robertssmith-case/news-story/a38b5c367d54bb7fe5daff1f9eb358a8
#16349807 at 2022-05-27 10:18:35 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #23: HOUSE OF CARDS Edition
Missing witness and a change of government: the latest delays in Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation case
Trial held up due to Covid and fall of Kabul now waits for evidence release by new attorney general and reappearance of Person 27
Ben Doherty - 27 May 2022
Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation case - first filed in 2018 - has borne delays for Covid and national security concerns, been rearranged because of the fall of Kabul, and now, in its final days of evidence, has been further stalled by a change of government and witnesses who can't be found.
The nearly year-long trial, has only two witnesses left to appear - both subpoenaed by Roberts-Smith: two serving SAS members, anonymised as Person 27 and Person 81.
Roberts-Smith, a Victoria Cross recipient, is suing three newspapers for defamation over a series of reports he alleges portray him as committing war crimes, including murder.
The newspapers are pleading a defence of truth. Roberts-Smith denies any wrongdoing.
Person 27 has already given evidence in this trial, but is being recalled to be re-cross-examined over alleged inconsistencies in his evidence.
But efforts to find him have thus far proven fruitless.
The court heard Friday morning it was believed he was "out of the jurisdiction ... that is overseas" on military service, "but we haven't been able to confirm that," the barrister for Roberts-Smith, Arthur Moses SC, told the court.
The appearance of the final witness has been delayed by Australia's change of government at the weekend. Person 81 is a serving member of the SAS, and a senior officer in the regiment.
About 30 defence documents relating to his evidence need to be released by the government, requiring the commonwealth attorney general to sign off because of national security concerns.
With the change in government after last weekend's election result, that signoff has been delayed. ACT Senator Katy Gallagher has been sworn in as interim attorney general and is expected to make a decision on whether to release the documents early next week.
It is expected that the final two witnesses will give evidence next week. After a break, the trial will then hear closing submissions, before Justice Anthony Besanko retires to make a ruling and deliver his judgment.
Roberts-Smith's defamation action was filed in 2018, but the trial did not begin hearing evidence until the middle of 2021.
The evidence of three Afghan witnesses was brought forward in July that year due to deteriorating security conditions in Afghanistan. In a brutal and swift coup, Kabul fell back under the control of the Taliban a month later.
The trial was then delayed by Sydney's Covid-19 delta outbreak and the closure of some of Australia's internal borders. Many of the SAS witnesses in Perth were unable to attend court in Sydney without becoming stranded because of Western Australia's strict Covid restrictions. Given the sensitive nature of their evidence relating to national security, they could not appear by video link.
Lawyers for Roberts-Smith told the court he was being disadvantaged by the constant delays in the trial, and argued hearings should be moved to a new city, lest it become indefinitely delayed. Lawyers for the commonwealth argued against moving, citing the extraordinary and costly national security protocols that had been put in place in Sydney to run the trial.
The trial was kept in Sydney, but was put on hiatus for nearly six months, before resuming in February this year.
The last weeks of evidence have been slowed by scheduling issues around witnesses, including one soldier who was forbidden from giving evidence at the last minute by the foreign military with which he now serves.
The trial will resume next week, with evidence expected to be completed by the end of the week. A judgment could be months, even up to a year, away.
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2022/may/27/missing-witness-and-a-change-of-government-the-latest-delays-in-Ben-Roberts-Smiths-defamation-case
#16343598 at 2022-05-26 08:34:05 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #23: HOUSE OF CARDS Edition
#22 - Part 16
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 2
>>16207281 'No-one in the tunnel,' says former SAS soldier backing Ben Roberts-Smith in defamation case
>>16213397 Witness for Ben Roberts-Smith denies emails show the pair colluded to make sure their evidence aligned
>>16233968 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case focuses on who shot dog as two witnesses recant evidence
>>16239824 'No mention of war crimes': SAS leader denies soldiers accused Ben Roberts-Smith of executions
>>16246817 SAS soldier says he and Ben Roberts-Smith killed Taliban 'spotter'
>>16252767 Ben Roberts-Smith's friend declined interview with Australian Federal Police, court told
>>16252773 Ben Roberts-Smith witness gives icy response to suggestions he is motivated to lie
>>16259739 YouTube videos of Ben Roberts-Smith trial cut after sensitive information exposed
>>16259743 Captive Afghan teenage boy allegedly shot in the head, Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial hears
>>16283691 SAS soldier says he only learned of an allegation Ben Roberts-Smith kicked an Afghan prisoner off a cliff in 2012 from the Brereton War Crimes Inquiry in 2017
>>16290115 Ben Roberts-Smith wins bid to call SAS top brass to defamation trial
>>16296843 Fourth ex-SAS soldier backs Ben Roberts-Smith's account of key mission
>>16303124 Soldier allegedly bullied by Ben Roberts-Smith was below standard, court told
>>16309230 Roberts-Smith punched soldier who acted 'jovial' after bungled mission, court told
>>16325827 Afghan soldier absent on day of alleged killing, says Ben Roberts-Smith witness
>>16331751 Election delays top witness in Ben Roberts-Smith trial - The change of government will delay the evidence of the highest ranking SAS soldier to testify in the defamation trial of Ben Roberts-Smith
#16343597 at 2022-05-26 08:33:38 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #23: HOUSE OF CARDS Edition
#22 - Part 15
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 1
>>16053237 An emotionally vulnerable SAS soldier felt 'threatened' by Nine newspapers to testify against Ben Roberts-Smith
>>16059144 Seven senior army officers escape punishment for failing to prevent SAS soldier war crimes in Afghanistan
>>16073688 Roberts-Smith prepares to call first witness as Nine evidence wraps up
>>16086498 Marathon Ben Roberts-Smith trial reaches crucial watershed
>>16104779 Witness in Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case denies 'blooding' claims
>>16128151 Former soldier called to give evidence for Ben Roberts-Smith denies giving false account in return for ongoing payment of his legal fees
>>16128172 Ben Roberts-Smith trial witness denies lying about 'distinctive' camouflage paint in court
>>16128192 Ben Roberts-Smith witness denies calling junior colleagues "rookies" and rejects accusations of lying in court
>>16155530 Ben Roberts-Smith's former patrol commander probed on images from 2009 mission to a Taliban compound dubbed Whiskey 108
>>16155546 'Not a real Australian': bold claim made in Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case
>>16162836 Roberts-Smith witness contradicts key allegation from Nine
>>16162846 Former SAS member tells Ben Roberts-Smith trial he found weapons but no insurgents inside tunnel at Afghan compound
>>16162853 Former SAS soldier who gave evidence in Ben Roberts-Smith trial charged with obstructing and harming war crimes investigators
>>16169484 'Memory failure': Ben Roberts-Smith's witness backtracks on potentially crucial 'dog shot' claim
>>16175864 Ben Roberts-Smith witness is being investigated over alleged murder, court hears
>>16175881 Former SAS soldier testifying for Ben Roberts-Smith denies colluding with witnesses to defeat murder claim
>>16182508 'You can't handle the truth': Ben Roberts-Smith witnesses react to the scrutiny - Ex-SAS soldier Person 35 bristled with irritation in court that his former comrade was being scrutinised by lawyers and journalists from the sanctuary of Australia
>>16182579 Hotel fisticuffs, bags of cash and a witness own-goal in Ben Roberts-Smith's court battle
>>16200063 Ben Roberts-Smith witness admits 'error' in identifying culprit of dog shooting
>>16200089 Prosthetic leg taken from dead Afghan man was a trophy, Ben Roberts-Smith's friend tells court
#16343529 at 2022-05-26 08:08:02 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
#22 - Part 16
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 2
>>16207281 'No-one in the tunnel,' says former SAS soldier backing Ben Roberts-Smith in defamation case
>>16213397 Witness for Ben Roberts-Smith denies emails show the pair colluded to make sure their evidence aligned
>>16233968 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case focuses on who shot dog as two witnesses recant evidence
>>16239824 'No mention of war crimes': SAS leader denies soldiers accused Ben Roberts-Smith of executions
>>16246817 SAS soldier says he and Ben Roberts-Smith killed Taliban 'spotter'
>>16252767 Ben Roberts-Smith's friend declined interview with Australian Federal Police, court told
>>16252773 Ben Roberts-Smith witness gives icy response to suggestions he is motivated to lie
>>16259739 YouTube videos of Ben Roberts-Smith trial cut after sensitive information exposed
>>16259743 Captive Afghan teenage boy allegedly shot in the head, Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial hears
>>16283691 SAS soldier says he only learned of an allegation Ben Roberts-Smith kicked an Afghan prisoner off a cliff in 2012 from the Brereton War Crimes Inquiry in 2017
>>16290115 Ben Roberts-Smith wins bid to call SAS top brass to defamation trial
>>16296843 Fourth ex-SAS soldier backs Ben Roberts-Smith's account of key mission
>>16303124 Soldier allegedly bullied by Ben Roberts-Smith was below standard, court told
>>16309230 Roberts-Smith punched soldier who acted 'jovial' after bungled mission, court told
>>16325827 Afghan soldier absent on day of alleged killing, says Ben Roberts-Smith witness
>>16331751 Election delays top witness in Ben Roberts-Smith trial - The change of government will delay the evidence of the highest ranking SAS soldier to testify in the defamation trial of Ben Roberts-Smith
#16343528 at 2022-05-26 08:07:26 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
#22 - Part 15
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 1
>>16053237 An emotionally vulnerable SAS soldier felt 'threatened' by Nine newspapers to testify against Ben Roberts-Smith
>>16059144 Seven senior army officers escape punishment for failing to prevent SAS soldier war crimes in Afghanistan
>>16073688 Roberts-Smith prepares to call first witness as Nine evidence wraps up
>>16086498 Marathon Ben Roberts-Smith trial reaches crucial watershed
>>16104779 Witness in Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case denies 'blooding' claims
>>16128151 Former soldier called to give evidence for Ben Roberts-Smith denies giving false account in return for ongoing payment of his legal fees
>>16128172 Ben Roberts-Smith trial witness denies lying about 'distinctive' camouflage paint in court
>>16128192 Ben Roberts-Smith witness denies calling junior colleagues "rookies" and rejects accusations of lying in court
>>16155530 Ben Roberts-Smith's former patrol commander probed on images from 2009 mission to a Taliban compound dubbed Whiskey 108
>>16155546 'Not a real Australian': bold claim made in Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case
>>16162836 Roberts-Smith witness contradicts key allegation from Nine
>>16162846 Former SAS member tells Ben Roberts-Smith trial he found weapons but no insurgents inside tunnel at Afghan compound
>>16162853 Former SAS soldier who gave evidence in Ben Roberts-Smith trial charged with obstructing and harming war crimes investigators
>>16169484 'Memory failure': Ben Roberts-Smith's witness backtracks on potentially crucial 'dog shot' claim
>>16175864 Ben Roberts-Smith witness is being investigated over alleged murder, court hears
>>16175881 Former SAS soldier testifying for Ben Roberts-Smith denies colluding with witnesses to defeat murder claim
>>16182508 'You can't handle the truth': Ben Roberts-Smith witnesses react to the scrutiny - Ex-SAS soldier Person 35 bristled with irritation in court that his former comrade was being scrutinised by lawyers and journalists from the sanctuary of Australia
>>16182579 Hotel fisticuffs, bags of cash and a witness own-goal in Ben Roberts-Smith's court battle
>>16200063 Ben Roberts-Smith witness admits 'error' in identifying culprit of dog shooting
>>16200089 Prosthetic leg taken from dead Afghan man was a trophy, Ben Roberts-Smith's friend tells court
#16331751 at 2022-05-24 08:56:27 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16315617
>>16053237
Election delays top witness in Ben Roberts-Smith trial
The change of government will delay the evidence of the highest ranking SAS soldier to testify in the defamation trial of Ben Roberts-Smith.
Perry Duffin - May 24, 2022
The change of government has thrown a spanner in the works of Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial as the most senior SAS soldier in the case prepares to take the stand.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing Nine newspapers claiming they defamed him in articles that alleged he committed war crimes in Afghanistan.
The marathon trial was supposed to be in its final week of evidence but Labor's victory in Canberra has changed that, the Federal Court heard on Tuesday.
Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team were calling an SAS commander, known as Person 81, to testify about a mission in Afghanistan in 2009.
Nine claims Mr Roberts-Smith, during that mission, was involved in two war crime murders.
The Victoria Cross recipient denies every allegation against him.
Some SAS witnesses have placed Person 81, who was then a senior officer in the regiment, in the Taliban compound now at the centre of the case.
Person 81 was expected to be questioned about the raid but top secret ADF documents would need to be released to the legal teams from the Commonwealth government before he took the stand.
The defeat of the Coalition means Labor is yet to appoint a full time Attorney-General to sign off on the release of the documents.
The court, on Tuesday, heard an interim A-G may sign off on the documents but it was not clear if that was going to happen before next week.
It means Person 81 will now not be called until late next week, delaying the end of the gripping case until the start of June.
https://www.news.com.au/national/nsw-act/courts-law/election-delays-top-witness-in-Ben-robertssmith-trial/news-story/70c5b0389130ee172bd3f9b703e8783e
#16325827 at 2022-05-23 09:40:29 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Afghan soldier absent on day of alleged killing, says Ben Roberts-Smith witness
Michaela Whitbourn - May 23, 2022
An Afghan soldier who was allegedly directed by Ben Roberts-Smith to order the unlawful execution of a prisoner was not present on the day in question, according to a former elite soldier supporting the war veteran in his defamation case.
Person 39, a former Special Air Service soldier whose identity cannot be revealed for national security reasons, gave evidence in the Federal Court on Monday about his service alongside Roberts-Smith in Afghanistan in 2012.
He was asked about a key detail relating to a mission in October that year, during which The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times have alleged Roberts-Smith directed an Afghan soldier working with the SAS, dubbed Person 12, to shoot a prisoner or order one of his subordinates to do it.
Under the rules of engagement, prisoners could not be killed.
Person 39, a former British Special Boat Service soldier, described himself as Roberts-Smith's senior on that deployment, adding that "I still view myself more as a mentor kind of older person".
He said he was informed at a briefing in 2012 that Person 12 had been stood down from working with the SAS in late July, meaning that the Afghan soldier could not have been present with Roberts-Smith in October. Person 39 agreed he had neither met nor worked with Person 12.
Roberts-Smith is suing the newspapers for defamation over a series of articles in 2018 that he says accuse him of war crimes including the unlawful killing of Afghan prisoners. He maintains any killings were carried out lawfully in the heat of battle.
The newspapers are seeking to rely on a defence of truth and allege Roberts-Smith was involved in six unlawful killings, including by directing Person 12 to shoot a prisoner or to order one of his subordinates to do it. Roberts-Smith has denied the alleged incident took place and has said Person 12 was not there on the day in question.
The presence or otherwise of Person 12 on the mission in October 2012 has been a much-debated issue in the defamation trial. Roberts-Smith conceded in court last year that, based on material produced by the Defence Department, the explanation in his written outline of evidence that Person 12 had been stood down was wrong. However, he maintains the Afghan soldier was not there.
Some of Roberts-Smith's witnesses have maintained Person 12 had been stood down for shooting at a dog and inadvertently injuring an SAS soldier, while others have said they were mistaken about this account. Roberts-Smith's witnesses have denied colluding over this evidence.
A serving SAS soldier dubbed Person 14, called to give evidence by the newspapers in February, told the court he witnessed Roberts-Smith tell an interpreter during the October 2012 mission to direct Person 12 to shoot a prisoner, "or I will". That direction was ultimately relayed and a member of the partner force shot the Afghan man dead, he said.
The trial continues.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/afghan-soldier-absent-on-day-of-alleged-killing-says-Ben-Roberts-Smith-witness-20220523-p5anoh.html
#16309230 at 2022-05-20 11:11:51 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Roberts-Smith punched soldier who acted 'jovial' after bungled mission, court told
Michaela Whitbourn - May 20, 2022
A former elite soldier supporting Ben Roberts-Smith in his Federal Court defamation case has given evidence that the war veteran punched a comrade who acted "jovial" after a bungled mission in Afghanistan.
Roberts-Smith has admitted punching the soldier, dubbed Person 10, after the mission on July 15, 2012, during which Person 10 has said he inadvertently fired shots near a woman and child. Nobody was injured in the incident, the court has heard.
Roberts-Smith rejects an allegation that punching Person 10 amounted to bullying, and is suing The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times for defamation over a series of articles in 2018 that he says accuse him of bullying fellow soldiers and the unlawful killing of Afghan prisoners. The media outlets are seeking to rely on a defence of truth.
A friend of Roberts-Smith, a former Special Air Service soldier known as Person 22, gave evidence on Friday that he was on the mission with Roberts-Smith and Person 10 in 2012.
Person 22 said Person 10 started shooting at one stage, but it was unclear "what he was shooting at". He said Person 10 did not respond to requests for information about his target.
Person 10 told the court this year that shots were fired in the direction of his patrol, he perceived a threat and he "did not fire willingly at a woman and child". He said a separate accusation that he fired at a "friendly call sign", meaning other SAS troops, was false.
Roberts-Smith told the court last year that Person 10 "giggled" during a subsequent patrol debrief, and he punched him to underscore the gravity of the incident. Person 10 has denied giggling.
On Friday, Person 22 told the court that Person 10 was not laughing or giggling before Roberts-Smith punched him, but was "jovial" and "not grasping the situation". He said Roberts-Smith had previously asked Person 10 if he had fired at a friendly patrol or women and children.
One of Roberts-Smith's barristers, Bruce McClintock, SC, said last year that his client punched Person 10 and "he should not have done so" but the court should find it was "not bullying in that situation".
But Person 10 said this year: "I'd say … punching someone in the face, berating them in front of their patrol, could be a form of bullying."
The trial continues.
https://www.theage.com.au/national/Roberts-Smith-punched-soldier-who-acted-jovial-after-bungled-mission-court-told-20220520-p5an2p.html
#16303124 at 2022-05-19 10:01:50 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Soldier allegedly bullied by Ben Roberts-Smith was below standard, court told
Michaela Whitbourn - May 19, 2022
A friend of Ben Roberts-Smith has defended the war veteran against accusations he bullied a comrade, telling the Federal Court he believed the soldier in question performed poorly during deployment in Afghanistan.
Person 36, a former SAS soldier who served alongside Roberts-Smith in Afghanistan in 2006, gave evidence on Thursday supporting the decorated former soldier in his defamation case against The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times.
He said he did not hear Roberts-Smith bully, threaten, assault or spread rumours about a serving SAS soldier dubbed Person 1 during 2006. He became aware in 2013 that Person 1 had made a bullying allegation against Roberts-Smith.
Person 36 told the court that Person 1, who was called to give evidence by the newspapers this year, performed in a manner that was "questionable and potentially below standard" in Afghanistan in 2006 and "appeared to need extra supervision".
Person 36 said that at one time Person 1 was very reluctant, slow and ineffective in using his specialist weapon on the thick walls of a mud compound that housed insurgents. On another occasion Person 1 had to be ordered three times to discard his lunch to attend to a task, Person 36 said.
Person 36 said he ultimately put forward a recommendation in a performance review that Person 1 be reviewed for his suitability as an SAS soldier. He said this was based on his "inability to perform basic tasks" and to show progression or improvement.
Under cross-examination by the newspapers' barrister, Nicholas Owens, SC, Person 36 did not agree that Person 1 was a young soldier who needed mentoring. He also disagreed he was an ineffective mentor of Person 1.
He denied that both he and Roberts-Smith criticised Person 1 so relentlessly that he was unable to perform to standard in the men's patrol.
"What I want to put to you is that once he was removed from an environment in which he was relentlessly criticised, Person 1 has gone on to have a very successful career in the SAS," Owens suggested.
"I don't believe that to be true," Person 36 replied.
Person 1 has previously given evidence that Roberts-Smith told him in 2006 that "if your performance doesn't improve on our next patrol you're going to get a bullet in the back of the head".
He told the court he interpreted the comment as a death threat and "it made me fearful for my own personal safety". Person 1 alleged Roberts-Smith bullied and undermined him for years, including pushing him in the chest during a later incident in 2010 and telling him to "get out of my way, c-nt, or I'll kill you".
Roberts-Smith alleges a series of articles published by the media outlets in 2018 portray him as a war criminal and a bully. He denies all wrongdoing and has said he had raised legitimate concerns about Person 1's performance. The media outlets are seeking to rely on a defence of truth.
Person 1 has agreed he made a mistake during a mission in Afghanistan in June 2006, during which he failed to bring oil for his machine gun and the weapon jammed a number of times while he was firing it. He has agreed that this put the lives of fellow soldiers at risk.
One of Roberts-Smith's barristers, Bruce McClintock, SC, put it to Person 1 that his client had said words to the effect of "if you don't improve your performance you're going to get shot by the enemy".
"No," Person 1 replied.
Asked if he agreed that it was never acceptable to make a death threat against a fellow soldier, Person 36 said on Thursday that a "direct death threat", meaning a comment that could not be misinterpreted, would not be acceptable.
The court has heard Person 1's performance reviews improved when he was moved out of Roberts-Smith's patrol in 2006.
A performance appraisal from July 7, 2006, five days after he was moved, recorded that Person 1 was "hard-working and [got] along with all members of the patrol" and "maintained a positive attitude despite the beating [his] confidence has suffered".
The trial continues.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/soldier-allegedly-bullied-by-Ben-Roberts-Smith-was-below-standard-court-told-20220519-p5amsn.html
#16296843 at 2022-05-18 10:14:45 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Fourth ex-SAS soldier backs Ben Roberts-Smith's account of key mission
Michaela Whitbourn - May 18, 2022
A fourth former Special Air Service soldier has supported Ben Roberts-Smith's account of a key mission in Afghanistan as the war veteran rejects claims he was involved in the unlawful execution of prisoners.
Person 38, a friend of Roberts-Smith whose identity cannot be revealed for national security reasons, gave evidence on Wednesday supporting the decorated former soldier in his defamation case against The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times.
He rejected an accusation by the newspapers' barrister, Nicholas Owens, SC, that he had invented a story about a 2009 mission to a compound codenamed Whiskey 108 to help his friend.
Roberts-Smith alleges the newspapers defamed him in a series of articles in 2018 by suggesting he was a war criminal who was involved in the unlawful killing of unarmed Afghan prisoners. He denies all wrongdoing.
The media outlets are seeking to rely on a defence of truth and allege Roberts-Smith was involved in six such killings, including two men who were discovered in a tunnel at Whiskey 108 and taken prisoner. Under the rules of engagement that bound the SAS, prisoners could not be killed.
Person 38 was also present at Whiskey 108 and told the Federal Court that no men were found inside the tunnel.
He said a soldier dubbed Person 35 went into the tunnel while another soldier, Person 29, held onto him to ensure he had backup if Taliban insurgents were hiding inside.
Person 38 said Person 35 called "clear" to indicate that nobody was inside, and told Person 29 "and anyone else in the vicinity that he'd found a bunch of equipment in the tunnel".
Persons 29 and 35 have also given evidence supporting Roberts-Smith and said no men were inside the tunnel. Roberts-Smith's patrol commander at the time, Person 5, has given the same account.
A fifth former SAS soldier dubbed Person 27 has given evidence broadly supporting Roberts-Smith, telling the court he did not have "any recollection of anyone coming out of a tunnel". However, he did not go into the part of the compound where the tunnel was found.
The existence or otherwise of Afghan men inside the tunnel at Whiskey 108 is a key issue in the trial.
A serving SAS soldier dubbed Person 40, called to give evidence by the newspapers in March, told the court that two Afghan men were pulled from the tunnel and "marched off to another area" for what he assumed was tactical questioning by Roberts-Smith and Person 35.
A former SAS soldier, Person 43, also gave evidence in March that he was involved in capturing an elderly Afghan man in the tunnel.
Yet another serving SAS soldier, Person 41, called by the newspapers in February, told the court that he saw Roberts-Smith execute an unarmed Afghan prisoner on the day in question and direct another soldier, Person 4, to kill a second prisoner.
But Person 38 said on Wednesday that Person 41 helped him clear an orchard outside the compound just after the tunnel was found, placing him outside Whiskey 108 at a critical time.
Owens put it to Person 38 that he had "invented" a story on Wednesday that placed Person 41 outside Whiskey 108 in order to help Roberts-Smith win his defamation case.
Person 38 agreed the evidence he gave about Person 41 was not in his written outline of evidence, previously filed in court, but insisted it was the truth. He said the evidence did not seem relevant earlier.
The trial continues.
https://www.theage.com.au/national/fourth-ex-sas-soldier-backs-Ben-Roberts-Smith-s-account-of-key-mission-20220518-p5amdd.html
#16290115 at 2022-05-17 08:58:37 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Ben Roberts-Smith wins bid to call SAS top brass to defamation trial
PERRY DUFFIN - MAY 17, 2022
An SAS soldier says Ben Roberts-Smith never ordered the execution of a prisoner in a remote Afghan village and has told a court he has one good reason for knowing his accusers are wrong.
The testimony, which corroborates Mr Roberts-Smith's evidence, comes as the Victoria Cross recipient won a bid to get one of the most senior SAS officers to testify in his case.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing Nine newspapers over articles alleging he ordered or carried out war crime murders during deployments with the SAS while in Afghanistan.
He denies the six war crime claims including, as alleged in Nine's court documents, that he ordered an Afghan special forces soldier to execute a prisoner in the village of Chenartu in late 2012.
Nine claims a soldier known as Person 14 was standing outside the room in which Mr Roberts-Smith and a cohort of Afghan Wakunish soldiers were questioning detained locals.
Person 14 told the court he kicked a discoloured patch of wall and items fell out - it was a weapons cache.
Nine claims Mr Roberts-Smith then told the Afghan soldiers to execute the prisoner who was being questioned, a man in white robes who was clutching a grey waistcoat.
A Wakunish soldier stepped forward and opened fire into the man's neck multiple times, Nine claims.
Person 32, on Tuesday, said that execution never happened and the story is wrong because Person 14 never discovered a cache.
"I was there when two caches were discovered, which is a big thing," Person 32 told the court on Tuesday.
"I have no memory of being there when Person 14 discovered a cache."
Nine's barrister accused Person 32 of lying to help Mr Roberts-Smith's case when he said he had no recollection of the Afghan soldiers executing one of their own countrymen on Mr Roberts-Smith's order.
"The reason you are falsely denying that you have recollection (of the events) is that you're trying to assist Mr Roberts-Smith in this case," Nine barrister Nicholas Owens SC said.
"No, it's not true," Person 32 said.
This week the court heard a secretive witness, known only as Person 81, will be subpoenaed to give evidence in the high profile defamation suit.
Person 81 was on another mission, in 2009, where Mr Roberts-Smith is accused of two more prisoner executions - both of which he denies.
Mr Roberts-Smith won a bid to subpoena Person 81, who is now one of the top brass in the SAS regiment, after other witnesses said he was present when a tunnel was found Beneath a Taliban compound known as Whiskey 108.
Nine claims two Afghans were found in the tunnel and detained by the SAS before Mr Roberts-Smith executed one and ordered a rookie soldier to shoot the second.
Mr Roberts-Smith and his supporters deny anyone was executed at Whiskey 108 and further deny anyone was found inside the tunnel Beneath the insurgent base.
Person 81, according to other witnesses, was present when the tunnel was discovered.
It's not yet known what the senior officer will say about the raid on Whiskey 108 because much of the legal argument was heard behind closed doors.
What is known is that Person 81's subordinates have, so far, testified in one of two ways; some say no one was found in the tunnel, others say the SAS covered up a war crime.
The trial continues.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/breaking-news/Ben-robertssmith-wins-bid-to-call-sas-top-brass-to-defamation-trial/news-story/5a755ebfc689e7104a8d8c12813c874c
#16283691 at 2022-05-16 08:52:29 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
SAS soldier says he only learned cliff kick accusation against Roberts-Smith in Brereton Inquiry
PERRY DUFFIN - MAY 16, 2022
1/2
An SAS soldier has told a court the first time he heard an allegation Ben Roberts-Smith kicked an Afghan prisoner off a cliff in 2012 was from a war crime inquiry five years later.
The court has previously heard the same soldier has been accused of a war crime killing that has been slammed as a "blatant lie" cooked up by an Afghan journalist and villagers.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing Nine newspapers over articles alleging he killed detained prisoners in Afghanistan while deployed with the SAS.
He insists Nine's articles are wrong, Nine argues they are true.
Person 32 told the court he was part of a mission, alongside Mr Roberts-Smith, to the Afghan region of Chenartu in late 2012.
A soldier known as Person 14 told the court he kicked a wall and dislodged a weapons cache on the mission.
Mr Roberts-Smith was standing nearby, questioning detained Afghan men with the help of Afghan soldiers known as Wakunish, the court has heard.
It's alleged Mr Roberts-Smith, upon seeing the weapons, ordered the Wakunish soldiers to execute one of the detained Afghans - and they did.
Person 32 told the court no such thing ever happened.
He has become the latest SAS soldier to deny the allegation after one of Mr Roberts-Smith's friends, Person 11, told the court he was standing in the room the entire time and no execution took place.
Nine also claims Mr Roberts-Smith had kicked an Afghan farmer off a cliff and the man was then executed in a raid on the village of Darwan in September 2012, one month before Chenartu.
One soldier told the court he witnessed the kick and the execution, claiming Person 11 pulled the trigger and killed the badly injured farmer.
Other soldiers have told the court there was chatter among the SAS about the cliff kick immediately after the raid in September 2012 and it was even allegedly raised with a senior SAS officer up the chain of command.
That senior officer denied anyone raised war crime allegations at that time.
Person 32, on Monday, told the court he did not hear the allegation about a person under confinement, or PUC in military slang, being kicked off a cliff until years after the raid on Darwan.
Person 32 said he first heard the allegation while meeting with the Inspector General of the Australian Defence Force, which was investigating war crime allegations, in around 2017.
"When did you become aware of an allegation that Mr Roberts-Smith kicked a PUC off a cliff at Darwan?" Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Arthur Moses SC, asked.
"In the IGADF," Person 32 responded.
Person 32 told the court he only heard about the IGADF and met with them in 2017 and 2018 meaning, on his evidence, he did not hear the cliff kick allegation until years after Darwan.
(continued)
#16259743 at 2022-05-12 10:15:35 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Captive Afghan teenage boy allegedly shot in the head, Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial hears
Former comrade called as witness by Roberts-Smith denies seeing teen alive or recognising photo of dead body
Ben Doherty - 12 May 2022
1/2
A missing photograph of a prisoner, which should have been marked "GB2", has dominated evidence in Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial on Thursday, with allegations before the federal court that "GB2" was a terrified captive teenage boy shot in the head by Roberts-Smith.
A retired SAS comrade, anonymised before the court as Person 11, has been called by Roberts-Smith to give evidence in his defamation action against three Australian newspapers, whom he says defamed him in a series of reports that alleged he committed war crimes, including murder.
The newspapers are pleading a defence of truth. Roberts-Smith denies any wrongdoing.
On his third day in the witness box, the questioning of Person 11, a close friend of Roberts-Smith's, focused on a November 2012 SAS mission to Fasil, in Afghanistan's southern Uruzgan province.
Under cross-examination, Person 11 was shown photographs of three prisoners, allegedly taken from a Toyota Hilux ute interdicted by Australian troops on a road through the village. The prisoners - known as Pucs for "person under control" - have tape on the back of their clothing giving details on where they were arrested including VEH for "vehicle", RD for "road", and, on one man's tape, "driver".
The three men are marked with the callsign of the soldiers who detained them - Gothic Bravo. The men are marked GB1, GB3, GB4. Their photographs - front and back - were taken at the Australian base at Tarin Kowt.
Person 11 told the court he did not recognise the men in the pictures.
Nicholas Owens SC, acting for the newspapers, told the court there was "no picture of GB2 in existence", because the second prisoner detained from the Hilux never made it to the Australian base.
Owens showed Person 11 a photograph of a young Afghan man who had been shot dead, his body lying next to an AK47.
Person 11 said he had never seen the young man alive, nor did he recognise the photograph of his body.
Owens put it to Person 11 that the young man was GB2, and that he had been pulled from the car by Australian soldiers, detained, and handed over to Person 11 and Roberts-Smith during the raid on Fasil.
"Mr Owens I don't recognise these individuals nor do I recall having Pucs handed over to me," Person 11 replied.
Owens alleged the young man was taken into a compound by Roberts-Smith, who then shot the man with his pistol.
"I reject that, Mr Owens."
Owens said: "I want to put it to you that the reason there is no photograph of the second Puc from Gothic Bravo is that he was murdered by Mr Roberts-Smith in the compound."
Person 11: "I disagree with that."
(continued)
#16259739 at 2022-05-12 10:05:47 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
YouTube videos of Ben Roberts-Smith trial cut after sensitive information exposed
Jamie McKinnell - 12 May 2022
1/2
The Federal Court will no longer upload regular YouTube videos of the high-profile defamation case of war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith, after "persons outside Australia" used them to publish information identifying sensitive witnesses.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times newspapers over a series of 2018 stories which, he claims, contained false allegations of unlawful killings, bullying and domestic violence.
Much of the trial has involved hearing from former and current Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) soldiers, whose identities cannot be revealed for national security reasons.
In an effort to accommodate open justice while COVID-19 restrictions reduced the capacity of courtrooms, videos showing a limited view of the court during appearances of such "sensitive witnesses" have been published to YouTube on a delayed basis.
This allowed for the editing out of any so-called "inadvertent disclosure" of sensitive information - which has occasionally occurred, usually by soldier witnesses who are required to use pseudonyms when referring to most other witnesses - from a live feed provided to journalists and streamed into another room of Sydney's Law Courts building.
However, the Youtube videos of sensitive witness evidence will cease after Justice Anthony Besanko heard an application from the Commonwealth in closed court.
A judgement detailing reasons for the decision reveals the Commonwealth became aware "persons outside Australia" were using the videos for "analysis of information from different sources".
This had then been used to "publish information which identifies, or tends to identify, Sensitive Witnesses", including names or initials.
Justice Besanko said the effect was to undermine the integrity of court orders prohibiting such information being published.
"Action against a person to correct the situation is made difficult, if not impossible, where the person is located outside of Australia," he noted.
Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team supported the application, arguing that anything that made "the possible intimidation of witnesses" easier should be carefully considered.
In opposing the change, publisher Nine Entertainment highlighted the importance of open justice and suggested geo-blocking as a potential solution.
"The difficulty with geo-blocking was identified by the Commonwealth. It can be rendered ineffective by the use of a Virtual Private Network which is a widely commercially-available service," Justice Besanko said.
While the application was heard in closed court, Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Arthur Moses SC, alluded to a "flagrant breach of the court's orders" in late April, and requested to discuss the matter in a closed session.
A room in the Law Courts building will be open to the public for a broadcast of the proceedings, subject to capacity constraints.
Justice Besanko ruled the requirements of open justice were satisfied by that provision, without the addition of YouTube videos of sensitive witness evidence.
(continued)
#16252773 at 2022-05-11 09:30:23 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Ben Roberts-Smith witness gives icy response to suggestions he is motivated to lie
Harriet Alexander - May 11, 2022
"I disagree with you, respectfully, Mr Owens."
The transcript of evidence given by Person 11 under cross-examination by Nicholas Owens, SC, reads as courtesy personified. Yet his answers were delivered in cubes of ice.
A friend and former comrade of Ben Roberts-Smith, Person 11 is a key witness in the defamation trial against The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times, because he pulled the trigger at one of the alleged murders.
Another former SAS soldier dubbed Person 4, who gave evidence for the newspapers about the same incident in February, was the best man at Person 11's wedding. They have not spoken in four years.
Because while the newspapers alleged that the deceased was a handcuffed prisoner who Person 11 shot at close range after Roberts-Smith kicked him down a cliff, Roberts-Smith and Person 11 have testified that they shot him in a cornfield where he was acting as a spotter for Taliban fighters.
Person 11 gave vivid testimony when questioned by Roberts-Smith's lawyer, Arthur Moses, SC, on Tuesday. He spoke for 15 minutes about a 2012 battle for which Roberts-Smith was given a commendation for distinguished service, recalling the shapes of the enemy moving along the creek line in the early light and the intensity of the Taliban attack.
But when he was cross-examined by Owens on Wednesday about a different battle, the one in which it's alleged he murdered a prisoner, Person 11's recollections oscillated between clarity and fogginess. He was unsure how much time had passed, which soldiers were present, the women and children located or detained.
On the other hand, he was certain there were no Afghan villagers detained in the final compound that he cleared with his patrol (subtext: it was not detainees who were killed). He was certain that the villager moving through the cornfields was holding a radio, which he could use to communicate with fellow Taliban (subtext: the deceased Afghan was an enemy insurgent).
Owens: "How is it that you could have seen an insurgent through 15 metres of thickly planted crops that were five to seven feet tall?"
Person 11: "Because I could."
The mutual contempt was palpable, and as the evidence progressed, Owens went for the jugular. The court heard that Person 11 had been called to give evidence to the inspector-general's investigation into allegations of war crimes four times and the Australian Federal Police were conducting an investigation into his conduct.
Owens put it to the witness that he was motivated to lie to the court because if Roberts-Smith won his defamation trial, it would weaken the Australian Federal Police investigation into him. And if either Roberts-Smith or Person 11 testified against the other, it would present an "almost insuperable" obstacle to the other person's case.
But Person 11 held firm.
Owens: "I put to you that you've come here to give a false account of Darwan because the truth will have very serious consequences for both you and Mr Roberts-Smith."
Person 11: "That's not true. The truth will have the opposite effect. I'm here to tell the truth and the truth will prevail and will clear."
The trial continues.
https://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/national/Ben-Roberts-Smith-witness-gives-icy-response-to-suggestions-he-is-motivated-to-lie-20220511-p5akei.html
#16252767 at 2022-05-11 09:26:40 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Ben Roberts-Smith's friend declined interview with Australian Federal Police, court told
Michaela Whitbourn - May 11, 2022
A former elite soldier who has been accused of murdering an Afghan prisoner with his friend Ben Roberts-Smith was twice invited by the Australian Federal Police to an interview but his lawyers declined on his behalf, a court has heard.
Person 11, a former Special Air Service soldier, rejected allegations that he shot a handcuffed Afghan prisoner in the village of Darwan in 2012 after Roberts-Smith, his patrol commander, kicked the man off a cliff. The rules of engagement that bound the SAS provided that prisoners could not be killed.
The man was giving evidence in the Federal Court on Wednesday supporting Roberts-Smith in the decorated former soldier's defamation case against The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times.
Under cross-examination by the newspapers' barrister, Nicholas Owens, SC, Person 11 agreed the AFP had requested to interview him on two occasions but said he was unaware of any "ongoing investigation" into his alleged conduct.
"Have you been told that an investigation has been stopped?" Owens asked.
"I'm not aware of any investigation," Person 11 said.
Person 11 was shown an email from his lawyer dated December 5, 2019, stating that their client "respectfully declines the offer to participate in a record of interview as part of the AFP investigation into his conduct during ADF operations in Afghanistan".
Asked if he was aware of an investigation as at December 2019, he said that "to the best of my knowledge I was just aware they wanted to question me".
Person 11 and Roberts-Smith have told the court that the man killed in Darwan in 2012 was not a prisoner but a Taliban insurgent moving suspiciously in a cornfield. Both men say they shot at the man because they assessed that he was a threat, and he was killed lawfully.
Person 11, whose identity cannot be revealed for national security reasons, denied that he was giving false evidence because he realised the truth would have serious consequences for him and Roberts-Smith.
The court heard Roberts-Smith had arranged legal representation for Person 11 as he was called to give evidence as part of a Defence Inspector-General inquiry into allegations of misconduct and war crimes by Australian soldiers.
Person 11 agreed he had not paid any of the $125,000 in legal fees the court heard he had racked up to date but said "I had no idea what the deal was with fees" and "I stand ready to pay any bills that come due".
"I don't know of any arrangement for picking up the tab for these fees," he said.
He denied that he understood he needed to give evidence supportive of Roberts-Smith in order to keep receiving free legal advice.
Roberts-Smith is suing the newspapers for defamation over a series of stories in 2018 that he says portray him as a war criminal who was involved in the unlawful killing of Afghan prisoners. He has told the court any killings were carried out lawfully in the heat of battle.
The newspapers are seeking to rely on a defence of truth and allege Roberts-Smith was involved in six unlawful killings, including the execution of the man at Darwan. The newspapers have previously called SAS and Afghan witnesses who have given evidence about that alleged killing.
A former SAS soldier dubbed Person 4, who was a member of Roberts-Smith's patrol and was called to give evidence by the newspapers in February, has given a different account of Darwan mission.
Person 4 said he witnessed Roberts-Smith kick the handcuffed man off a cliff, causing him to sustain a "serious facial injury" when his face hit a rock. He told the court Roberts-Smith then instructed him and Person 11 to drag the man across a dry creek bed towards a tree.
Roberts-Smith and Person 11 had a quick conversation before "a number of shots rang out," he said. He told the court he saw Person 11 with his rifle raised in a firing position after he heard shots fired.
Person 11 told the court on Wednesday that Person 4 had been a "mentor and good friend not just professionally but personally" but that their friendship was over when he discovered Person 4 had made this allegation against him.
The trial continues.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/Ben-Roberts-Smith-s-friend-declined-interview-with-australian-federal-police-court-told-20220511-p5ak99.html
#16246817 at 2022-05-10 10:11:27 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
SAS soldier says he and Ben Roberts-Smith killed Taliban 'spotter'
STEPHEN RICE - MAY 10, 2022
An SAS soldier has described how he and Ben Roberts-Smith engaged and killed a Taliban "spotter" carrying a radio and hiding in a cornfield, directly contradicting claims by Nine newspapers that the pair murdered a detainee who had been kicked off a cliff.
The newspapers allege Mr Roberts-Smith kicked a handcuffed Afghan farmer named Ali Jan off a cliff in the ?village of Darwan in September 2012, and then - with another soldier codenamed Person 11 - dragged him aside in a dry creek bed and shot him.
However Person 11, gave a very different account of the incident in the Federal Court on Tuesday, insisting that the Afghan man he encountered was lawfully engaged under the rules of war.
The soldiers were hunting for a rogue Afghan army sergeant who two weeks earlier had killed three Australian soldiers.
"I saw this person was carrying a radio which led me to make the assessment that this was a spotter that had come to report on our dispositions and movements," he said.
"The individual trying to remain concealed. Our helicopters were on approach and I assessed this person posed a direct threat to our extraction and to friendly forces so I engaged him."
Person 11 said he fired a burst of 3 or 4 rounds at the man with his M4 rifle, and realised Mr Roberts-Smith, behind him, was also shooting at the man.
Person 11 said that at this point he couldn't see another member of the patrol known as Person 4, who was serving as second in command to Mr Roberts-Smith.
Person 4 has previously given evidence on behalf of the newspapers that Mr Roberts-Smith had kicked a detainee down a cliff at this point in the mission.
Person 4 said the man was "catapulted backwards and fell down the slope", where he landed in a dry creek bed, crashing into a rock so forcefully it knocked out many of his teeth.
Person 4 said Mr Roberts-Smith then instructed him and Person 11 to drag the man to a nearby tree. He then heard shots ring out and turned to see Person 11 with his rifle in the firing position.
Nine claims Mr Roberts-Smith or Person 11 or both killed Ali Jan.
Mr Roberts-Smith has previously given evidence that the incident did not happen.
Person 11 also gave evidence about another killing at Darwan earlier in the mission, before the alleged incident ?involving Ali Jan.
Nine originally claimed in its truth defence - though not in its newspaper articles - that Mr Roberts-Smith had shot dead an unarmed man after swimming across the Helmand River to search for a suspected spotter. The newspapers later dropped the claim.
On Tuesday Person 11 recounted how he had seen an individual moving on the other side of the river carrying a weapon slung in a sack under his arm and partly concealed, but which appeared to be an AK47 assault rifle.
Person 11 said the man was a legitimate target trying to flee, and at the point thought it could even have been the turncoat Afghan soldier they were hunting.
Mr Roberts-Smith removed his body armour and other equipment, and mostly waded across the river, Person 11 said, where he searched among the rocks for the man.
He said Mr Roberts-Smith eventually emerged, dragging the man's body so it could be photographed.
He returned across the river carrying the AK47, which had been impacted by a round, evidently from the shots the soldiers had fired, and detonators taken from the body.
The trial continues.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/sas-soldier-says-he-and-Ben-robertssmith-killed-taliban-spotter/news-story/835b5f1f152ab6791568cea9a785f343
#16239824 at 2022-05-09 09:04:32 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
'No mention of war crimes': SAS leader denies soldiers accused Ben Roberts-Smith of executions
PERRY DUFFIN - MAY 9, 2022
A senior leader of the SAS has refuted claims junior soldiers raised allegations of war crimes against Ben Roberts-Smith but were met with silence by the top brass.
Nine newspapers are being sued by Mr Roberts-Smith after they claimed in articles that he is a war criminal killer and known bully within the elite fighting force.
Mr Roberts-Smith, who denies the claims, called an SAS Major known as Person 100 to testify in support of his case on Monday.
Person 100 served as the SAS' Regimental Sergeant Major (RSM) which he described as a non-commanding role akin to a "senior adviser" for the regiment in 2013.
The court has previously heard that the SAS leaders were told Mr Roberts-Smith had been accused of killing outside the rules of engagement while in Afghanistan.
Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Arthur Moses SC, asked Person 100 if any such disclosure had been made in the meeting with the sergeants.
"Did any of the sergeants at that meeting raise concerns that Mr Roberts-Smith had broken the rules of engagement while serving in Afghanistan?" Mr Moses asked.
"There was no mention of that and no hint of it mentioned either," Person 100 said.
Instead, Person 100 told the court, an SAS officer known as Person 7 was concerned that Mr Roberts-Smith was not a "fit and proper person" to hold the Victoria Cross.
"He stated to me 'I have concerns about Mr Roberts-Smith being a fit and proper person to be given the Victoria Cross, he had bullied (Person 7) and others and he had also claimed to have carried out actions that others believed they'd carried out'," Person 100 said.
One sergeant said Mr Roberts-Smith had been accused of "bashing" and bullying a junior soldier who had forgotten to take machine gun oil on a mission causing the gun to jam years earlier.
Person 100 said he told the sergeants the SAS leadership didn't have the capacity to rescind Mr Roberts-Smith's VC, as Person 7 wanted, but allegations of bullying would be followed up.
The former RSM said he reported the meeting to his own bosses and was instructed to investigate the bullying allegations.
A few days later, the court heard, Person 100 met with four corporals and the concerns were the same; Mr Roberts-Smith had stolen credit for a kill and was a bully.
Two of those corporals, Persons 4 and 18, gave vastly different evidence when they took the stand for Nine earlier this year.
Person 4 told the court he saw Mr Roberts-Smith kick a farmer off a cliff in the village of Darwan in 2012 before the Afghan was executed by another soldier.
Person 18 said he watched Person 4 break down in tears recounting the alleged war crime and watched as the distraught soldier raised the killing again in the meeting with Person 100.
"(Person 100) said it was out of his hands, it was way above his head and he didn't know what to do with it," Person 18 told the court.
Mr Roberts-Smith vehemently denied kicking any Afghan off a cliff and Person 100 said no such incident was raised in the meeting with the corporals either.
Nine's barrister, Nicholas Owens SC, said Person 100 was hesitant to investigate bullying allegations made against Mr Roberts-Smith because he feared upsetting the famed VC recipient.
Person 100 denied that and denied he'd been told about war crimes under cross-examination.
"It's correct that Person 7 said to you 'I've been told an allegation of a war crime'?" Mr Owens asked.
"Incorrect, sir," Person 100 responded.
Mr Owens also said Person 100 did not want to "invite scandal into the SAS" with investigations into Mr Roberts-Smith - the former RSM denied that too.
Person 100 said he was aware of allegations that someone had been kicked off a cliff but he did not know the details until April 2020.
"I didn't know about any allegations of war crimes in 2013," Person 100 said.
"I could not investigate anything because I had no knowledge of them, sir."
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/latest-news/no-mention-of-war-crimes-sas-leader-denies-soldiers-accused-Ben-robertssmith-of-executions/news-story/32927e4fb7faa889055e99efc9097039
#16233968 at 2022-05-08 09:01:49 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case focuses on who shot dog as two witnesses recant evidence
Jamie McKinnell - 8 May 2022
1/2
In a high-stakes defamation case involving a decorated war veteran and allegations of unlawful killings in Afghanistan, another question has recently taken prominence: who shot the dog?
The mystery is linked to an allegation against Ben Roberts-Smith outlined in court documents from Nine Entertainment, the publisher of newspapers he's suing in the Federal Court, which the Victoria Cross recipient denies.
According to those documents, during a 2012 mission in Khaz Oruzgan, Mr Roberts-Smith allegedly directed, via an interpreter, an Afghan soldier codenamed Person 12 to shoot a man who was being questioned or get another soldier to do it.
A suggestion has emerged, in the outlines of proposed evidence from some witnesses, that Person 12 wasn't present on the mission because months earlier he shot a dog and was removed from the team after a ricochet injured an Australian soldier.
It's a suggestion two witnesses have now recanted.
Concessions of an error
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times newspapers over several 2018 stories which contained what he argues were false allegations of unlawful killings, bullying and domestic violence.
Current SAS soldier Person 27, who was this week called as a witness by Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team, admitted it was an "error" to say Person 12 shot the dog, as was included in his outline.
He also conceded it was something about which he had no direct knowledge.
"Who is the first person who used the name of Person 12?" Nine's barrister Nicholas Owens SC asked during cross-examination.
"Ben's lawyers," the witness replied, recalling a June 2019 teleconference from which a written summary of proposed evidence would be sent to him.
He said he was asked if he remembered the incident.
Person 27 told the court he advised the lawyers he was "not sure" about Person 12's involvement and would check with the soldier who was injured, Person 57.
Months later, that soldier told the witness the dog shooter's identity was wrong, however, the information remained in the outline, which Person 27 said he didn't read thoroughly and was "naive" in believing it wasn't final.
Mr Owens said Person 27 was one of five witnesses whose outlines contained the dog incident, but Person 27 said he only recently realised others made the same claim when he read an ABC article listing the witness pseudonyms Mr Owens raised while questioning another soldier last week.
That soldier, Person 35, also initially pointed the finger at Person 12 as the culprit in the dog shooting, however after he was shown classified documents in closed court, he conceded his memory was wrong.
Mr Owens suggested there had been collusion on the part of Mr Roberts-Smith's ex-comrades, which they denied.
(continued)
#16213397 at 2022-05-05 08:30:54 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Witness for Ben Roberts-Smith denies emails show the pair colluded to make sure their evidence aligned
Jamie McKinnell - 5 May 2022
An elite soldier has denied emails he exchanged with Ben Roberts-Smith showed they had colluded on the evidence they would give at the war veteran's defamation trial to make sure their stories matched up.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times newspapers in the Federal Court over a series of articles published in 2018.
The veteran said they contained false allegations of bullying, domestic violence and unlawful killings, two of which are alleged to have occurred during a raid on a Taliban compound dubbed "Whiskey 108" in April 2009.
The newspapers are pleading a defence of truth.
Mr Roberts-Smith insists two men killed at the compound were armed and shot outside the building, within the rules of engagement.
A witness codenamed Person 29, who was at the time a SAS patrol commander, is the third witness called by Mr Roberts-Smith's team to back up the veteran's claim no insurgents surrendered from a secret tunnel discovered within Whiskey 108.
Under cross-examination by publisher Nine Entertainment's barrister, Nicholas Owens SC, Person 29 was today shown an email sent to him by Mr Roberts-Smith on July 3, 2019, nine days before outlines of evidence were due.
Mr Owens showed Person 29 an attachment to the email: an image of Whiskey 108 with markings on it.
The barrister put it to Person 29 that he was speaking "very regularly" to Mr Roberts-Smith at this time.
"I can't say we were talking regularly ... but the Whiskey 108 mission would have been a topic of conversation," Person 29 replied.
Mr Owens suggested a small blue box drawn on the photograph represented the position Mr Roberts-Smith was intending to give as the location where an insurgent was shot by him outside the building.
Person 29 said that was incorrect.
"I want to put to you again, when you had a conversation with Mr Roberts-Smith about this document, it was for the purpose of aligning your stories about Whiskey 108 in key respects, do you agree?" Mr Owens asked
"No, I don't agree," the witness replied.
Person 29 admitted he didn't produce the email despite receiving a subpoena calling for all communications between himself and the veteran related to Whiskey 108.
He said he deleted the email, as he "habitually" deletes emails he does not need.
Person 29 agreed it was possible he had visited Mr Roberts-Smith's Queensland home a few days after the email.
Mr Owens suggested the two sat in the veteran's study looking at Whiskey 108 imagery on a computer as they prepared their proposed evidence.
"No, that's not correct," Person 29 said.
In Nine's court documents, it is alleged two men were taken prisoner in Whiskey 108, and that one was allegedly shot by Mr Roberts-Smith outside the compound, while the second was allegedly shot by a colleague, Person 4, at the direction of his superior, Person 5.
Several of the publisher's witnesses have given evidence of seeing a man or men emerge from the tunnel.
The trial, before Justice Anthony Besanko, continues.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-05-05/Ben-Roberts-Smith-witness-denies-emails-colluding/101041208
#16207281 at 2022-05-04 09:10:22 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
'No-one in the tunnel,' says former SAS soldier backing Ben Roberts-Smith in defamation case
Michaela Whitbourn - May 4, 2022
A third former Special Air Service soldier has supported Ben Roberts-Smith in his defamation case as the decorated former soldier rejects allegations he was involved in the unlawful execution of Afghan prisoners.
Person 29, a former comrade of Roberts-Smith and godfather to one of his children, backed his friend's version of events about a key mission in Afghanistan as he gave evidence in Roberts-Smith's defamation case against The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times.
Roberts-Smith alleges the newspapers defamed him in a series of articles in 2018 by suggesting he was a war criminal who was involved in the unlawful killing of unarmed Afghan prisoners. He denies all wrongdoing.
The media outlets are seeking to rely on a defence of truth and allege Roberts-Smith was involved in six such killings, including two at a compound dubbed Whiskey 108 in 2009. Person 29, whose identity cannot be revealed for national security reasons, was also present on that mission.
The newspapers have called SAS witnesses who have told the Federal Court that Roberts-Smith killed one of the men himself and directed a "rookie" soldier, dubbed Person 4, to kill the second man after both men were pulled from a tunnel at Whiskey 108.
Roberts-Smith has told the court that no men were found in the tunnel. He said the Afghan men who were killed by him and Person 4 on that day were enemy combatants killed lawfully in the heat of battle.
Person 29, who remains in the Australian Defence Force, told the court on Wednesday that he "came across basically a steel mesh grate that was covering … a hole in the ground, which ended up being a tunnel" and alerted other soldiers at Whiskey 108. He said another soldier, Person 35, volunteered to clear the tunnel.
He grabbed the back of Person 35's pants as he entered the tunnel, he told the court, and it was about "15, 20 seconds before he wriggled to let me release him".
"Person 35 communicated to me verbally that the tunnel was clear [of people] but there was, I think in his terms, there was a lot of shit in the tunnel," Person 29 said, referring to a weapons cache.
Person 35 is also a friend of Roberts-Smith and has given similar evidence to the court.
"Did any fighting-age males come out of the tunnel?" Roberts-Smith's barrister, Arthur Moses, SC, asked.
"No," Person 29 replied.
Whether Afghan men were found inside the tunnel is a key issue in the trial. A serving SAS soldier dubbed Person 40, called to give evidence by the newspapers in March, told the court that two Afghan men were pulled from the tunnel at Whiskey 108 and "marched off to another area" for what he assumed was tactical questioning by Roberts-Smith and Person 35.
A former SAS soldier dubbed Person 43 also gave evidence in March that he was involved in capturing an elderly Afghan man in the tunnel.
Yet another serving SAS soldier, dubbed Person 41, called by the newspapers in February, told the court that he saw Roberts-Smith execute an unarmed Afghan prisoner on the day in question and direct Person 4 to kill a second prisoner.
The trial continues.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/no-one-in-the-tunnel-says-sas-soldier-backing-Ben-Roberts-Smith-in-defamation-case-20220504-p5aigp.html
#16200089 at 2022-05-03 09:10:19 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Prosthetic leg from Afghan man was a trophy, Ben Roberts-Smith's friend tells court
Michaela Whitbourn - May 2, 2022
A serving Special Air Service soldier supporting war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith in his defamation case has said he drank from a prosthetic leg "trophy" taken from a dead Afghan man because it appeared to be the done thing.
Person 27, who described himself as a good friend of Roberts-Smith, gave evidence in the Federal Court on Monday about a key mission in Afghanistan in 2009 during which the leg was souvenired by Australian soldiers and subsequently mounted in their unofficial bar, the Fat Lady's Arms.
Roberts-Smith is suing The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times for defamation over a series of articles in 2018 that he says portray him as a war criminal who was involved in the unlawful killing of Afghan prisoners.
The newspapers are seeking to rely on a defence of truth and allege Roberts-Smith was involved in six unlawful killings of Afghan prisoners including two during the 2009 mission. Under the rules of engagement that bound the SAS, prisoners could not be killed.
SAS witnesses called by the media outlets have given evidence that two Afghan men were discovered during the 2009 mission in a tunnel at a compound dubbed Whiskey 108.
But Roberts-Smith has told the court that no men were found in the tunnel, and that two men, including a man with a prosthetic leg, were discovered outside the compound and killed lawfully in the heat of battle.
Giving evidence on Monday, Person 27 said he was not made aware during the mission that any tunnel had been discovered, and did not see a tunnel entrance. He said the first he heard of an allegation that two men came out of a tunnel at Whiskey 108 was in 2017, but admitted later in his evidence that he heard a rumour earlier than that date that two people behind a trap door or in a tunnel had been shot.
He said he became aware at some stage that a prosthetic leg from the 2009 mission was taken back to the soldiers' base in Tarin Kowt, "mounted and put into the bar as a trophy". He said he was told it was from the body of a combatant.
Person 27 said he drank from the leg because it "seemed to be the thing that was done". Roberts-Smith has told the court he did not drink from the leg and it was souvenired by another soldier.
A former SAS soldier called to give evidence last week by Roberts-Smith, Person 35, said he had entered and cleared the tunnel at Whiskey 108, and nobody was found inside it.
But a serving SAS soldier dubbed Person 40, called to give evidence by the newspapers in March, told the court that two Afghan men were pulled from the tunnel at Whiskey 108 and "marched off to another area" for what he assumed was tactical questioning by Roberts-Smith and Person 35.
A former SAS soldier dubbed Person 43, who also gave evidence for the newspapers in March, said that he was involved in capturing an elderly Afghan man in the tunnel.
Yet another serving SAS soldier, dubbed Person 41, called by the newspapers in February, told the court that he saw Roberts-Smith execute an unarmed Afghan prisoner on the day in question and direct another soldier to kill a second prisoner.
Later on Monday, Person 27 said he had made an error in a written outline of his evidence that was previously filed in court.
The newspapers have alleged Roberts-Smith directed an Afghan soldier dubbed Person 12, via an interpreter, to order one of his subordinates in the Afghan partner force to shoot an unarmed prisoner during a separate mission in October 2012. He denies the allegation and has said Person 12 was not there.
Person 27 had said in his outline that Person 12 had been stood down at this time and could not have been on the mission in question. He conceded on Monday that "the identity of the person was never known to me because I wasn't there".
Person 35 also admitted last week that he "must have remembered incorrectly" when he said Person 12 had been stood down.
The trial continues.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/prosthetic-leg-from-afghan-man-was-a-trophy-Ben-Roberts-Smith-s-friend-tells-court-20220502-p5ahu7.html
#16200063 at 2022-05-03 08:59:17 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Ben Roberts-Smith witness admits 'error' in identifying culprit of dog shooting
Jamie McKinnell - 3 May 2022
An elite soldier giving evidence for Ben Roberts-Smith in the war veteran's defamation case has conceded his outline of evidence contained erroneous information about an incident he had no direct knowledge about.
The witness, a current member of the SAS codenamed Person 27, was called by Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team as the veteran sues three newspapers over a series of 2018 articles.
Mr Roberts-Smith claims they contained false allegations of unlawful killings, bullying and domestic violence, and denies any wrongdoing.
The Federal Court has previously heard one unlawful killing is alleged to have occurred on a 2012 mission in Khaz Oruzgan, where Mr Roberts-Smith is accused of directing, via an interpreter, a member of the Afghan Partner Force to shoot a local man being questioned.
Several of the veteran's witnesses have suggested, in their outlines of evidence, that the partner force member, codenamed Person 12, was not present, according to publisher Nine Entertainment.
It's been suggested this was because he was removed due to an incident months earlier in which he shot a dog and the bullet ricocheted, injuring an Australian soldier codenamed Person 57.
Person 27 has conceded his outline contained the same "error" about Person 12 being involved in the dog incident.
"It's correct, isn't it, that you never had direct knowledge of the … partner force member who shot a dog and injured Person 57?" Nine's barrister Nicholas Owens SC asked today during cross-examination.
"That is correct," Person 27 replied.
The witness said the first time he heard Person 12 shot the dog was when he met with Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers, who asked "if I remember the incident".
He recalled a June 2019 teleconference which resulted in a written "outline summary" being sent to him.
"I said I'm not sure about that, I can find out because I'm able to talk to Person 57 but I was not there, I have no idea who any of those partner force were because they were not the partner force I was working with."
Person 27 has said in subsequent months he checked with Person 57, who told him the soldier involved in the dog incident was "not the bloke that everyone thinks it is".
He also contacted Mr Roberts-Smith and passed on a message that Person 57 could speak to the veteran about the issue, but denied discussing his outline of evidence.
Person 27 told the court he did not say anything to Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers.
"To be honest, I still didn't have a lawyer from Defence," he said.
"I was fairly naive thinking that outline of evidence was just an outline and I would redo it.
"I hadn't signed it, I thought I would have to sign it … I didn't give it much thought after 2019 at all."
A previous witness, Person 35, has also accepted he was mistaken in thinking Person 12 shot the dog.
Mr Owens accused Person 35 of colluding with four others, including Person 27 and Mr Roberts-Smith, to all tell the same "lie", which Person 35 denied.
The trial, before Justice Anthony Besanko, continues.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-05-03/Ben-Roberts-Smith-defamation-trial-person-27-admits-error/101033788
#16182579 at 2022-04-30 13:39:33 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Hotel fisticuffs, bags of cash and a witness own-goal in Ben Roberts-Smith's court battle
STEPHEN RICE - APRIL 30, 2022
1/2
It was meant to have been the week Ben Roberts-Smith launched his all-guns-blazing demolition job on the claims of former SAS comrades that he committed multiple murders in Afghanistan.
Instead it ended with his closest mate in handcuffs after a night on the town celebrating the end of three days on the stand; his most important witness forced to explain why he went to a party dressed as a member of the Ku Klux Klan (answer: because someone else was coming in blackface); and yet more questions about who was paying the bills, this time in bags of cash.
Then there was the matter of Person 35, the witness with a penchant for "liking" Instagram posts that celebrated the upcoming death of the barrister about to interrogate him. That this was not the wisest move became apparent to the witness when the barrister concerned, Nicholas Owens SC, began his cross-examination on Thursday.
Owens: Person 35, you're an active user of social media, correct?
Owens: Do you remember that one of the posts that you liked yesterday morning before court started off with this? "When some f.ckwit in a suit starts questioning your integrity and using his f.cktard's snake logic he learnt ... at their nonbinary law school, remember one thing: that this c.nt will be one of the first to be held down and drowned in a muddy puddle for his fancy jacket when society crumbles." Do you remember liking a post that said that?
Witness: I seem to remember liking that.
Owens: Who did you understand the comment in that post to be referring to?
Witness: I have no idea.
Owens: It was me, wasn't it?
Witness: No, sorry, I don't follow you, why would it be you?
Owens: Who else would it be?
Witness: I don't know.
All this before the VC recipient even begins to deal with the claims by his ex-wife that he cheated on her, and the far more damaging allegation by his former lover that he bashed her.
But don't write off Roberts-Smith just yet.
The first week in which he was able to call his own witness to rebut the claims of war crimes made by Nine newspapers certainly did not go to plan, though it started well enough. The war hero's former patrol commander, a gruff ex-Royal Marine codenamed Person 5, stepped into the witness box and gave a detailed account of the assault on the Taliban compound known as Whiskey 108.
Critically, he rejected the evidence of several of Nine's witnesses that two unarmed Afghans - including the now notorious "man with the prosthetic leg" - were hauled from a tunnel inside the compound and later executed. Roberts-Smith has always said the two men were armed and that they were killed outside the compound. His friend Person 5, also not a man to back away from a fight, engaged in several heated exchanges with Owens.
"You and Mr Roberts-Smith have discussed over many years, how to tell the story ... to explain away war crimes, correct?" asked Owens.
"There's been collusion - just not from our side," the combative soldier shot back. "Your witnesses have been colluding for the last 12 years."
Person 5's contempt for the soldiers who have broken ranks and given evidence for the newspapers was barely contained. The 20-year SAS veteran recounted how he had asked Roberts-Smith at the compound what had happened to the prosthetic leg because it was no longer beside the man's body.
"That dickhead's got it," Roberts-Smith replied, according to Person 5. That was a reference to Person 6, a still-serving SAS soldier who commandeered the prosthetic leg and took it back to the base, where it became a novelty drinking vessel at the soldiers' unofficial bar, the Fat Lady's Arms.
Person 6 has not been called by either side but his ghostly presence has permeated the trial. He was Roberts-Smith's arch enemy within the regiment and the person he claims rounded up disgruntled soldiers, jealous of his VC, to speak to the Nine journalists.
(continued)
#16182508 at 2022-04-30 13:25:31 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
'You can't handle the truth': Ben Roberts-Smith witnesses react to the scrutiny
Ex-SAS soldier Person 35 bristled with irritation in court that his former comrade was being scrutinised by lawyers and journalists from the sanctuary of Australia.
Harriet Alexander - APRIL 30, 2022
1/2
In the climactic scene to the courtroom drama A Few Good Men, base commander Colonel Nathan Jessup, played by Jack Nicholson, flares at the suggestion that he should have to answer to a jumped-up lawyer who has never been outside the line yet has the temerity to cast moral aspersions on actions by the military in the national interest.
"You can't handle the truth," he tells his interrogator. "Son, we live in a world that has walls and those walls have to be guarded by men with guns … You don't want the truth because deep down in places you don't talk about at parties, you want me on that wall, you need me on that wall."
As Ben Roberts-Smith's witnesses took to the stand this week in the marathon defamation case he has brought against The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times, the fault lines between troops in the Special Air Service have emerged.
The witnesses called by the newspapers varied in their opinions of Roberts-Smith personally, but disapproved of the actions he is alleged to have taken on the battlefield.
The witnesses called by Roberts-Smith to date are united in their loyalty to him and dismiss those who allege that he participated in unlawful killings as poor soldiers and liars.
So when ex-SAS soldier Person 35 was cross-examined on his evidence for Roberts-Smith, he bristled with the same irritation as Colonel Jessup that his former comrade was being scrutinised by lawyers and journalists from the sanctuary of Australia over actions he had taken in Afghanistan.
'Rats and snitches'
An indication of Person 35's view of the proceedings could be found in an Instagram meme that he "liked" on the morning of his second day giving evidence. It featured a woman who was wearing a tag that read "SAS whistleblowers", her mouth smeared with a white substance and a grinning man labelled "Fairfax Media", the name of the company that owned the newspapers when the articles were published. Beneath the picture were these words.
"When some f-ckwit in a suit starts questioning your integrity using his f-cktard snake logic he learned getting his tonsils bruised by some lecturer's spotty dick at their non-binary law school remember one thing, that this c-nt will be one of the first to be held down and drowned in a muddy puddle for his fancy jacket when society crumbles.
"If/when society crumbles, it will be thanks to him and people like him thinking we all live on f-cking Sesame Street and everyone adhering to their putrid way of thinking."
Under questioning by the barrister for the newspapers, Nicholas Owens, SC, Person 35 did not concede that the meme accurately reflected his views. But he agreed he was upset that Roberts-Smith was being scrutinised and thought it was destructive to question the conduct of individual soldiers who had served overseas. He also agreed that he had liked other Instagram posts that described the witnesses against Roberts-Smith as "rats" and "snitches".
These people were liars, he told the court, though he admitted he was not present during the events that they described in their evidence. "I know my friend Ben, and I know he wouldn't do that," he said.
Owens: "And that is the point, is it not: you are prepared to say that things didn't happen, not because of what you've seen or heard but because of the strength of your friendship with Mr Roberts-Smith?"
Person 35: "I can speak to the man's character, yes, and I don't believe he did that. I do not."
(continued)
#16175881 at 2022-04-29 11:56:02 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Former SAS soldier testifying for Ben Roberts-Smith denies colluding with witnesses to defeat murder claim
Jamie McKinnell - 29 April 2022
An ex-soldier testifying for Ben Roberts-Smith in his defamation case has denied colluding with the war veteran and three other witnesses to give false evidence intended to defeat an allegation of murder.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times newspapers over 2018 articles he claims contained false allegations of unlawful killings, bullying and domestic violence.
According to publisher Nine Entertainment's court documents, during an October 2012 mission in Khaz Oruzgan, Mr Roberts-Smith allegedly directed, via an interpreter, a member of the Afghan Partner Force, Person 12, to shoot an Afghan man who was being questioned, or get one of his men to do so.
Mr Roberts-Smith denies all wrongdoing.
An ex-SAS soldier codenamed Person 35, who was called by Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team, has previously said Person 12 was removed from the team months earlier.
He had claimed this was over a separate incident in which Person 12 shot a dog and the bullet ricocheted, injuring an Australian soldier.
After being shown documents in closed court, Person 35 conceded he "must have remembered incorrectly" and agreed Person 12 was not the person involved in the dog incident.
Nine's barrister, Nicholas Owens SC, today put to Person 35 that he was one of five witnesses, including Mr Roberts-Smith, whose outlines of evidence contain an account of Person 12 shooting the dog and subsequently being removed from the deployment.
"I wasn't aware of how many other people said that," the witness replied.
Person 35 agreed he had "monthly" conversations with those other witnesses - Person 32, Person 27, Person 39 - and they were friends but insisted he had not discussed allegations linked to the defamation case.
"You discussed with each of those people the lie that you were going to tell about Person 12 shooting a dog, correct?" Mr Owens said.
"That's incorrect Mr Owens," the witness replied.
"You thought that if several people told the same lie, it would be more believable," the barrister said.
"It's not a lie," Person 35 replied.
The witness denied that he spoke with Mr Roberts-Smith about a way to place Person 12 away from the scene of the alleged murder to "defeat" the accusation.
"You have colluded with each of those witnesses … with the intention of giving false evidence to this court about Person 12 to advance Mr Roberts-Smith's interests," Mr Owens said.
"That's incorrect Mr Owens," Person 35 said.
Mr Roberts-Smith told the court, during his time in the witness box last year, that he served his country with honour and distinction and never broke the rules of engagement.
Earlier this year, a current SAS member called by Nine codenamed Person 14 gave evidence about the 2012 mission and Person 12's alleged involvement.
He told the court he was present in a room when an Afghan man was being questioned and a hidden weapons cache was discovered.
According to that witness, Mr Roberts-Smith allegedly told an interpreter, while pointing in the direction of Person 12, to "tell him to shoot him or I will".
Person 14 said the Afghan man was then shot dead, leaving him "perplexed".
The trial, before Justice Anthony Besanko, continues.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-04-29/Ben-Roberts-Smith-trial-witness-denies-colluding-alleged-murder/101025450
#16175864 at 2022-04-29 11:52:04 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Ben Roberts-Smith witness is being investigated over alleged murder, court hears
Michaela Whitbourn - April 29, 2022
A second former Special Air Service soldier who has given evidence supporting war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith in his defamation case has admitted that he is the subject of an investigation into an alleged murder in Afghanistan.
Roberts-Smith is suing The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times for defamation over a series of articles in 2018 that he says portray him as a war criminal who was involved in the unlawful killing of six unarmed Afghan prisoners. He denies all wrongdoing.
During cross-examination by the media outlets' barrister, Nicholas Owens, SC, on Friday, Person 35, a former elite soldier who served alongside Roberts-Smith in Afghanistan, admitted that the Office of the Special Investigator was examining an allegation that he was himself involved in an unlawful killing of an Afghan man in a compound in September 2012 where two men were killed.
Person 35 told the court that both killings were lawful. He has also told the Federal Court that he did not witness Roberts-Smith commit war crimes on deployment.
The OSI is the agency investigating war crimes allegations against Australian soldiers in Afghanistan.
"Now, certainly as at today's date, it's correct, isn't it, that you understand that … two alleged murders at compound 31 in [the Afghan village of] Darwan are being investigated by the Office of the Special Investigator?" Owens asked.
"I am aware that that is being investigated," Person 35 replied. He said a media report referring to those allegations was "a lie".
"Those two insurgents that were engaged in that compound were legally engaged, lawfully engaged," he said. He agreed he killed one of the men and said his comrade, dubbed Person 32, killed the other man but they were insurgents killed in the heat of battle.
Person 35 told the court that Robert-Smith's boss, Seven West Media chairman Kerry Stokes, was covering the cost of his lawyers for the defamation case and the OSI inquiry.
"You remain concerned to ensure that you will have high-quality legal representation going forward; correct?" Owens said.
"Depending on what the OSI finds and yes, I will always seek professional legal representation. I've had false allegations levelled against me, so why would I not seek professional legal representation?" Person 35 replied.
"You understood very clearly that if Mr Stokes was to continue paying for your legal fees, you would need to stay, if I can put it colloquially, on Team Mr Roberts-Smith, correct?" Owens said.
"That's incorrect, Mr Owens," Person 35 replied.
The trial continues.
https://www.theage.com.au/national/Ben-Roberts-Smith-witness-is-being-investigated-over-alleged-murder-court-hears-20220429-p5ahao.html
#16169484 at 2022-04-28 10:57:53 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
'Memory failure': Ben Roberts-Smith's witness backtracks on potentially crucial 'dog shot' claim
PERRY DUFFIN - APRIL 28, 2022
1/2
An SAS witness for Ben Roberts-Smith made a "mistake" when he accused an Afghan soldier of accidentally shooting an Australian soldier and a dog in evidence that could have delivered a "knockout blow" against Nine newspapers.
The same soldier also told a court he won best costume when he dressed as a Ku Klux Klansman, triumphing over another soldier in blackface, at a drunken party in Afghanistan.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing Nine newspapers over a series of allegations he committed war crimes in Afghanistan.
Nine insists the articles are true and are now cross examining SAS witnesses who are testifying for Mr Roberts-Smith in the defamation trial in the Federal Court.
Person 35 told the court he cleared out a hidden tunnel in a Taliban base and found no men hiding inside during the raid.
That contradicts claims by Nine and other soldiers that two Afghan men were found in the tunnel before Mr Roberts-Smith killed one and watched on as the second was executed.
Mr Roberts-Smith has also denied Nine's allegation he ordered an Afghan Partner Force soldier to execute another detainee at Khaz Uruzgan in late 2012.
Nine claims the soldier who pulled the trigger is an Afghan known as Person 12.
Mr Roberts-Smith's witnesses, in legal documents, say that is incorrect because Person 12 was not even allowed to work with the SAS at that time.
Multiple SAS witnesses, including Person 35, claim Person 12 was kicked off the partnership after he shot a dog and the bullet ricocheted and wounded an Australian soldier.
But on Thursday Person 35 conceded he "remembered incorrectly" and agreed Coalition military documents showed Person 12 was not kicked off the force.
Person 35 denied he had deliberately lied to the court to protect Mr Roberts-Smith in his evidence about Person 12.
The soldier said his memory simply did not align with the official documents but accepted he was wrong about Person 12.
Mr Roberts-Smith, in his own evidence, maintained that Person 12 was not at Khaz Uruzgan so could not have pulled the trigger, as Nine claims.
Proving Person 12 was not at Khaz Uruzgan would have been a "knockout blow", Nine's barrister has previously told the court.
Nine has alleged Mr Roberts-Smith and his witnesses colluded to accuse Person 12 of the dog shooting in a separate legal challenge while Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers say the newspapers are trying to prejudice the public and the court.
(continued)
#16162853 at 2022-04-27 11:17:29 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Former SAS soldier who gave evidence in Ben Roberts-Smith trial charged with obstructing and harming war crimes investigators
Jake Lapham - 27 April 2022
A former elite soldier who gave evidence in war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial has been charged with obstructing and harming war crimes investigators.
A non-publication order was placed on the man's identity when the matter was heard in Central Local Court this afternoon.
A magistrate ordered that he be referred to as Person X to protect the integrity of the Federal Court proceedings, the safety of the defendant and national security interests.
He is charged with obstructing, hindering and intimidating a Commonwealth official and harming a Commonwealth law officer.
Person X appeared via videolink, wearing a black suit and a white shirt, and showed no emotion during the short hearing.
His application for bail was not opposed by the prosecution and was granted.
His lawyer Rob Rankin made no comment to waiting media as he left court.
Person X will face court again in June.
The former soldier was one of several ex-Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) members to be called to give evidence in Mr Roberts-Smith defamation trial.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times for defamation in the Federal Court, claiming articles in the publications falsely accused him of unlawful killings, bullying and domestic violence.
The newspapers are pleading a defence of truth.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-04-27/witness-in-Ben-Roberts-Smith-trial-charged/101020252
#16162846 at 2022-04-27 11:13:29 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Former SAS member tells Ben Roberts-Smith trial he found weapons but no insurgents inside tunnel at Afghan compound
Jamie McKinnell - 27 April 2022
1/2
A former elite soldier has told a Sydney court how he found a cache of weapons but no insurgents inside a tunnel at an Afghan compound that has become central to war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation case.
Evidence from the ex-Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) soldier codenamed Person 35, who has been called as a witness by Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team, contradicted that given by a number of previous witnesses, who were members of his patrol.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times newspapers over 2018 stories that included what he claims are false allegations of unlawful killings, bullying and domestic violence.
A major focus of the case has been an April 2009 mission at an Afghan compound dubbed "Whiskey 108", known to be a Taliban stronghold, where the secret tunnel was discovered.
Previous witnesses called by Nine's defence lawyers have claimed two unarmed Afghan men emerged from the tunnel after it was detected by the Australian patrol.
In court documents, Nine alleges one of the men was executed by a soldier codenamed Person 4 at the direction of his superior, Person 5, while the second man was killed by Mr Roberts-Smith with a machine gun outside the compound.
Mr Roberts-Smith denies the allegation and previously told the court two armed insurgents were legitimately engaged outside the building.
Person 35 today told the judge that after the compound had been bombed and searched, he entered the tunnel, armed with a pistol and wearing night-vision goggles, to make sure it was clear.
He described the tunnel entrance as a "rough-cut hole" with "earth-cut steps down under the ground", which was "difficult to manoeuvre through" and which opened up into a larger room.
"Did you locate or observe any individuals in the tunnel?" Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister Arthur Moses SC asked.
"No," the witness replied.
He said on entering the tunnel, he noticed a mat covering the ground.
"On that mat, there was AK-variants, chest rigs, there was documents, communication devices," he said.
"Hidden in the rafter areas of the roof of the tunnel was more batteries, more communication devices, those sorts of things."
(continued)
#16162836 at 2022-04-27 11:06:23 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Roberts-Smith witness contradicts key allegation from Nine
PERRY DUFFIN - APRIL 27, 2022
Ben Roberts-Smith is accused of killing two unarmed Afghans who were pulled from a tunnel Beneath a Taliban compound - but now the soldier who was sent into the dark crevice has told a court there was no one hiding inside.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing Nine newspapers after a series of articles claimed he and his fellow SAS soldiers carried out illegal killings of detained Afghans in circumstances amounting to war crimes.
Nine insists the articles are true and Mr Roberts-Smith, this month, began calling former squadmates to testify against the newspapers in the Federal Court defamation lawsuit.
This week the evidence has focused on a raid on a Taliban compound in 2009 and the deaths of two Afghans during the mission.
The newspapers further claims Mr Roberts-Smith shot one man dead with a machine gun and stood by while a "rookie" soldier, Person 4, allegedly executed the second detained Afghan on the orders of a patrol commander.
The Victoria Cross recipient has long maintained there were no Afghans found inside the tunnel of Whiskey 108.
His former squadmate, Person 35, told the court he was the only SAS soldier who went inside the tunnel and he found no people inside.
"The actual tunnel itself, it wasn't a complex room system or anything that needed multiple angles, it just went down, left for a bit, opened into a room that was easy enough to clear," Person 35 told the court.
Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Arthur Moses SC, asked Person 35 if he had seen any Afghan nationals inside the tunnel.
"No," Person 35 responded.
Multiple SAS soldiers, called by Nine newspapers earlier this year, insist they saw Afghans emerge from the tunnel unarmed before being detained.
Some soldiers gave descriptions of the mens' clothes and ages, and one SAS soldier said Afghan women inside Whiskey 108 had raised the alarm about the tunnel.
"Some males came out of the tunnel ... there were at least two but could easily have been three," a soldier told the court in February.
"They were compliant ... they came out unarmed, they came out freely, relatively quickly once given commands."
Person 35 told the court, on Wednesday, that no one shouted commands into the tunnel because it would have tipped off potential Taliban as to the SAS' next move.
Everyone in the trial agrees that one of the Afghans killed at Whiskey 108 had a prosthetic leg which became a trophy and drinking vessel for the SAS.
Mr Roberts-Smith told the court he shot the man dead after spotting the suspected insurgent running with a rifle outside Whiskey 108.
Nine and their SAS witnesses claim the one-legged man came out of the tunnel and was frogmarched outside by Mr Roberts-Smith before being executed.
Earlier this week Mr Roberts-Smith's close friend and former patrol commander, Person 5, denied Nine's allegations he ordered the rookie to execute the second Afghan.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/breaking-news/robertssmith-witness-contradicts-key-allegation-from-nine/news-story/33343ad130d9d6799cf990874ba1b8cf
#16155546 at 2022-04-26 11:01:41 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
'Not a real Australian': bold claim made in Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case
STEPHEN RICE - APRIL 26, 2022
An SAS soldier giving evidence in the Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case has claimed that during an attempted rescue mission of a dual Australian/British national in Afghanistan, the head of Australian special forces in Afghanistan made the disparaging comment that the woman was "not a real Australian anyway".
The SAS soldier said the comment was made in 2016 by Australian Special Operations Commander Jeff Sengelman during a video teleconference, as Australian special forces were trying to get more back up to support them on the mission.
The soldier, known as Person 5, says he decided to leave the military after this episode.
The reference appears to be to a mission to rescue abducted aid worker Kerry Jane Wilson, who was held for four months after she was kidnapped at gunpoint from her office in the country's east.
At the time, the Afghan intelligence agency, National Directorate for Security (NDS), would only say that special forces had staged the overnight rescue operation to secure Wilson's freedom, and arrested four suspects in connection with the kidnapping.
Then Australian Foreign Minister Julie Bishop confirmed Wilson had been released unharmed and thanked Afghan authorities.
"I deeply appreciate the work of the authorities in Afghanistan whose support and assistance facilitated her release, as well as Australian consular staff who continue to provide assistance to Ms. Wilson and her family," Ms Bishop said in a statement.
Wilson's charity had been helping women in Afghanistan to start their own businesses. She has been working out of Kabul for nearly two decades.
Counsel for Mr Roberts-Smith, Arthur Moses, asked the Person 5 on Tuesday why he had decided to leave the Australian Defence Force.
"It was a comment by someone on a VTC (video teleconference) when I was on a hostage rescue in Jalalabad," Person 5 replied.
"What was the comment?"
"That the person we were going to rescue was half Australian, half British. When we were trying to push forward to get more assets and get the troop in to go after the hostage, the comment was made: she's not a real Australian anyway."
Major-General Sengelman has been credited in some quarters with initiating the inquiries into alleged war crimes in Afghanistan, after hearing rumours from soldiers. He commissioned sociologist Dr Samantha Crompvoets to undertake more research into what he was hearing which in part led to the Brereton Inquiry.
That inquiry found credible evidence of up to 39 murders, with 19 current or former soldiers, almost exclusively from the SAS, to face criminal investigation.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/not-a-real-australian-bold-claim-made-in-Ben-robertssmith-defamation-case/news-story/b74e7cb76b68f8f59601eed1157e236e
#16155530 at 2022-04-26 10:55:41 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Roberts-Smith's friend probed on images
Greta Stonehouse - April 26 2022
Ben Roberts-Smith's former patrol commander has denied changing his evidence to counteract alleged flaws and inconsistencies that make his story implausible, a court was told.
The witness codenamed Person Five on Tuesday returned to the Federal Court witness box for his fourth day of evidence.
The former SAS soldier is appearing on behalf of his good friend Mr Roberts-Smith who is suing The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times for defamation.
The war veteran denies all reported claims he committed war crimes in Afghanistan including murder, and acts of bullying and domestic violence, while the mastheads are defending them as true.
Barrister Nicholas Owens SC on behalf of the newspapers has accused Person Five of giving false evidence about key allegations said to have occurred on a 2009 mission to a Taliban compound dubbed Whiskey 108.
Person Five says he ran out from a meeting after hearing shots fired and was told by Mr Roberts-Smith that he and a young trooper had engaged two insurgents, and quickly returned inside the compound.
Mr Owens submitted if that was true, he would have stayed and further inquired as to where the men had come from to better understand the nature of the threat more enemies potentially posed.
"No," he responded.
The media outlets allege two men were found in a secret tunnel and claim Person Five ordered "rookie" Person Four to execute one, to get his first kill in action.
His second-in-command Mr Roberts-Smith was allegedly left to facilitate this command, and is accused of executing the other prisoner with a prosthetic leg.
Both men deny this occurred or that any men emerged from the tunnel.
Mr Owens pointed to an image of an old man's body, showing a significant amount of brain matter and blood all around it.
He submitted it showed the body was photographed near the tunnel entrance and had clearly not been moved before it was photographed, as Person Five has testified.
"I'm not a forensics expert, I can't comment on that," he responded.
"There is no trail of blood to show the body had been moved," Mr Owens said.
Person Five agreed he could not see any trail of blood.
"You thought you couldn't trust the Afghan judicial system to keep these two men off the battlefield," Mr Owens said.
"No it was accepted as part of the game, we knew the judicial system was corrupt," Person Five said, adding he'd seen hundreds of prisoners return to the battleground.
Mr Owens argued that Person Five believed these two prisoners were Taliban, and if handed over may potentially end up back in conflict injuring Australian soldiers.
"I don't agree."
Person Five also denied later being frustrated with his 2IC that these two executions was performed in the open, and not concealed out of sight from air surveillance.
Another witness has testified of hearing this conversation, with Person Five saying to Mr Roberts-Smith: "You've just done this while the ISR is still flying above and may have recorded you".
He said the Victoria Cross recipient responded with a hint of panic in his voice.
The trial continues.
Lifeline 13 11 14
https://www.lifeline.org.au/
Open Arms 1800 011 046
https://www.openarms.gov.au/
https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/7712500/Roberts-Smiths-friend-probed-on-images/
#16128192 at 2022-04-22 13:20:25 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Ben Roberts-Smith witness grilled over 'rookie' note in court
A key witness for Ben Roberts-Smith has denied calling junior colleagues "rookies" and rejected accusations of lying in court.
Anton Nilsson - April 22, 2022
A key witness for Ben Roberts-Smith has denied he lied about a tunnel where Nine newspapers allege two Afghans were discovered and executed.
The witness, codenamed Person 5, was cross-examined for a second day on Friday by Nine's barrister Nicholas Owens SC.
Person 5 and Mr Roberts-Smith, who is suing the newspapers for defamation, both deny Nine's allegations two men were found in a tunnel in a compound called Whiskey 108, detained and then executed.
The former soldiers further deny Nine's claim Person 5 ordered a "rookie" soldier to shoot one of the men so he could be "blooded" by making his first kill.
In Person 5 and Mr Roberts-Smith's version of events, the men were legitimately killed in action and were never in the tunnel.
Some of the day's evidence concerned Person 5's stated belief the tunnel had a second exit, which Nine says is false.
Mr Owens told the court he believed Person 5 was lying about that belief, because it would bolster his "false" account that no insurgents were found down there.
In fact, Mr Owens said, pictures from inside the tunnel proved it would have been "blindingly obvious" the tunnel didn't lead anywhere.
Person 5 said on Friday he had for years after the 2009 mission "assumed" the tunnel had another exit, but revealed he had been "set straight ... a couple of years ago" by another soldier, known as Person 35, who explained there was no other exit.
"Sorry what did Person 35 tell you?" Mr Owens replied.
"He told me he had looked for another exit but hadn't found one."
The revelation led Mr Owens to allege that Person 5 had lied in his outline of evidence to the court, where Mr Owens said he had claimed there were two exits.
"You knew the outline contained a falsehood," Mr Owens said.
"No ... (Person 35's) opinion was that there wasn't (a second exit), and mine was that there was " Person 5 responded.
Mr Owens suggested the opinion of Person 35 should have had more weight than Person 5, because the former had been inside the tunnel.
It prompted Person 5 to reveal he too had gone down into the tunnel.
"I went in there too," he said.
Mr Owens contended that if Person 5 had been down there, it should have been clear there was no second exit.
Person 5 also denied colluding with Mr Roberts-Smith and other witnesses about their evidence of the Whiskey 108 mission.
Person 5 agreed he sent the Victoria Cross recipient a drone image of the compound but denied trying to get their stories straight over what happened there.
"I don't have to get my story straight, I know exactly what happened," the witness said.
Person 5 was asked by Mr Owens if he had ever referred to Person 4 and another soldier, Person 8 as "rookies" or "rookie fucks".
Mr Owens suggested Person 4 was "the rookie" during their 2009 deployment and that the new "rookie" during a deployment the following year was Person 8.
"No," Person 5 responded.
Mr Owens suggested to Person 5 his denials that he ever used the term or heard it during the deployments were false and intended to make Mr Roberts-Smith's case seem more plausible.
"That's not correct," Person 5 responded.
Mr Owens then made reference to what he said was a piece of paper that had been pinned to a patrol room door during Person 5's 2010 deployment.
"It was divided into six squares, and each square had the name of the patrol member ... only instead of Person 8's name, the word 'Rookie' appeared," Mr Owens said.
"I don't remember that," Person 5 responded.
Mr Owens then asked the court to be temporarily closed to the public.
Also on Friday, a different judge denied a request by Nine to get access to documents related to the preparation of the outline of evidence, which the newspaper had applied to earlier this month.
The hearing continues.
https://www.news.com.au/national/courts-law/Ben-robertssmith-witness-person-5-denies-calling-junior-colleagues-rookies-during-afghanistan-war/news-story/a0326bf4627a66a06895492cf76194ae
#16128172 at 2022-04-22 13:16:39 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Ben Roberts-Smith trial witness denies lying about 'distinctive' camouflage paint in court
Jamie McKinnell - 22 April 2022
A former elite soldier has denied lying in court about "distinctive" camouflage paint worn by Ben Roberts-Smith's patrol on the day the war veteran is accused of executing an unarmed Afghan man.
Mr Roberts-Smith denies the allegation and has similarly rejected accusations of other unlawful killings, bullying and domestic violence published in newspapers in 2018.
The Victoria Cross recipient is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times for defamation in the Federal Court, which is now hearing from witnesses called by Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team.
Mr Roberts-Smith's former Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) patrol commander, codenamed Person 5, yesterday recalled wearing brown, green and black paint, "like 99 per cent of all camouflage paint".
A previous witness for publisher Nine Entertainment, Person 14, told the court that during a 2009 mission at a Taliban compound nicknamed Whiskey 108, he saw an Australian soldier shoot what appeared to be a human body.
While Person 14 couldn't identify the soldier, he said grey and brown camouflage paint made it "easy" to identify as a member of Person 5's patrol, which included Mr Roberts-Smith.
Nine's barrister Nicholas Owens SC highlighted Person 5 mentioned grey as a paint colour for the first time today.
Mr Owens put to the witness that he "realised you were about to be caught out in a lie".
"No, that's not correct," Person 5 replied.
Asked whether he agreed Mr Roberts-Smith's paint included "a distinctive light grey", Person 5 told the court he couldn't remember and "it was 13 years ago".
The witness was shown a photograph of Mr Roberts-Smith on the day of the mission showing the paint.
According to Nine's defence documents, Person 5 allegedly ordered a "rookie" colleague, Person 4, to execute another Afghan man at the compound in order to "blood" the soldier, but Person 5 has denied giving such an order to anyone.
Another witness, Person 41, has given a slightly different account and told the court Person 4 asked to borrow his weapon's suppressor after being directed by Mr Roberts-Smith to execute the Afghan man.
That witness said he stepped into another area, heard a gunshot, and returned to see the man's dead body.
During cross-examination, Person 5 agreed he enforced a procedure that all his soldiers were to carry suppressors, although they were not to be used during daylight.
Mr Owens put it to Person 5 that it was "far from improbable" that if a person only intended to fire one shot, they would borrow a suppressor already fitted to another soldier's weapon as opposed to finding their own in their pack.
"I don't agree with that," the witness said.
Mr Owens suggested that if it could be made to seem "implausible" Person 4 needed to borrow a suppressor, the newspapers' case is less likely to succeed.
"He wouldn't have had to borrow a suppressor," Person 5 said.
During his time in the witness box, Person 4 objected to answering a question about what happened at Whiskey 108, triggering a legal debate which resulted in Justice Anthony Besanko ruling he should not be directed to give the evidence.
Person 5 has denied repeated suggestions from Mr Owens that he colluded with Mr Roberts-Smith to "get his story straight" about Whiskey 108.
He insisted they remain friends and the frequency of their contact did not change because of Mr Roberts-Smith's two interviews for an inquiry by the Inspector General of the Australian Defence Force.
The witness further denied colluding with three other witnesses all expected to appear for Mr Roberts-Smith - Person 29, Person 35 and Person 38 - in the weeks before their outlines of evidence were due in the lead-up to the defamation case.
Person 5 said it was "no surprise" he had spoken to the men because they were friends and denied discussing the evidence they planned to give.
"Are you saying because there's a trial on, you can't speak to your friends anymore?" Person 5 replied at one point.
The trial continues.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-04-22/Ben-Roberts-Smith-witness-denies-lying-in-court-about-paint/101008426
#16128151 at 2022-04-22 13:10:12 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Former soldier called to give evidence for Ben Roberts-Smith denies giving false account in return for ongoing payment of his legal fees
Jamie McKinnell - 21 April 2022
A former soldier has denied giving evidence favourable to Ben Roberts-Smith to ensure that the boss of the Seven Network, Kerry Stokes, keeps paying his legal fees.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times newspapers for defamation over several 2018 stories he says contained false allegations of unlawful killings, bullying and domestic violence.
Mr Roberts-Smith has taken leave from his role as an executive of Seven's Queensland operations during the defamation proceedings, which are being financially backed by billionaire businessman Mr Stokes.
The first witness called by Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team, a former Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) patrol commander codenamed Person 5, told the Federal Court he only found out on Tuesday morning that the Seven Network had been paying his legal fees since 2020.
This included the cost of his legal representation during that period in connection with the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force (IGADF) inquiry into possible war crimes in Afghanistan.
The witness denied giving favourable evidence to ensure that arrangement continued into the future, saying he had $100,000 saved in an account to pay for his legal costs.
"Did you ever have a conversation about fees [with your lawyer]?" Nine's lawyer Nicholas Owens SC asked.
"No, I didn't. I just waited for the bill to come through," Person 5 replied.
"They are paying your legal fees because you're giving evidence for Ben Roberts-Smith?" Mr Owens asked.
"Yes," Person 5 replied.
"In relation to IGADF [the Australian Defence Force inquiry], because you were adopting a position supportive of him?" Mr Owens continued.
"Correct," Person 5 replied.
The witness had previously contradicted evidence given by several other soldiers, telling the court that no-one was found hiding in a tunnel during a 2019 raid by the SAS on a compound in southern Afghanistan known as Whiskey 108.
"You are here to give a false account of Whiskey 108 to ensure you have the best chance of receiving this very valuable financial Benefit into the future?" Mr Owens asked.
"That is not correct," Person 5 said.
Earlier, the court heard that Person 5 was interviewed in May 2018 as part of the Australian Defence Force inquiry into the conduct of Australian soldiers in Afghanistan.
He said he told Mr Roberts-Smith, who he described as a friend, about his interview afterwards.
"I told him to prepare himself, it was a witch-hunt," Person 5 said.
The court heard after Person 5 moved to the United States in 2018, he emailed Mr Roberts-Smith a document complaining about his treatment at the IGADF inquiry, referring to it as an "interrogation".
He said that was so the veteran could pass it on to his lawyers.
"I was without legal representation in Australia, I'd moved to a different country," he said.
"I wanted to complain about the treatment and that was the avenue I took."
The witness initially objected to answering questions about the document, based on possible self-incrimination.
He was offered and accepted a certificate of protection under the Evidence Act, after his barrister said the evidence may tend to prove he had breached rules about not disclosing the contents of his IGADF interview.
Person 5 said "the majority" of the document's contents were "in the media anyway", including allegations that a rookie soldier had been "blooded" by executing an unarmed Afghan man.
The ex-soldier gave a detailed account of the 2010 Battle of Tizak, for which Mr Roberts-Smith was awarded the Victoria Cross.
He said immediately after the award was announced, a media article detailed allegations of bullying against Mr Roberts-Smith.
"The military was in a bit of a spin about it because they'd just announced they were awarding this guy the Victoria Cross," Person 5 said.
The court heard another soldier, Person 18, later approached Person 5 and said he believed he too deserved an award for the battle.
Person 5 said that the wife of a different colleague who was also on that mission, Person 4, approached him at a troop function sometime in 2011 to "chest poke" him about why her husband also deserved to be recognised.
"I told her to wind her neck in ... which means 'mind your own business', Your Honour," Person 5 said.
Mr Roberts-Smith's barristers have previously suggested his Victoria Cross put "a target" on his back and stoked jealousy and bitterness, providing a potential motive for former colleagues called by publisher Nine Entertainment to fabricate allegations.
The trial, before Justice Anthony Besanko, continues.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-04-21/Ben-Roberts-Smith-warned-inquiry-australian-afghanistan-actions/101005590
#16104779 at 2022-04-19 09:56:24 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Witness in Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case denies 'blooding' claims
STEPHEN RICE - APRIL 19, 2022
On the first day of Ben Roberts-Smith's counter-attack against claims he committed war crimes, his former SAS patrol commander has emphatically denied ever killing an unarmed Afghan, or ordering anyone else to do so.
The soldier, known as Person 5, also gave evidence that a tunnel discovered in an Afghan compound was empty, countering claims by Nine newspapers that he had ordered the execution of an elderly man found hiding in it.
The newspapers claim Mr Roberts-Smith was present when Person 5 ordered another Australian soldier - Person 4 - to execute the man, so that Person 4 could be "blooded".
Person 5, now retired from the military, is the first SAS witness to be called by the Victoria Cross winner in his defamation action against Nine newspapers.
The veteran soldier was part of a raid on a compound known as Whiskey 108 in Uruzgan province on Easter Sunday in 2009.
Person 5 gave evidence about the moment a tunnel was discovered Beneath a suspicious-looking mound of hay in the compound. Several soldiers volunteered to enter the tunnel to search it but the task eventually fell to a soldier known as Person 35, chosen because his slight stature would make it easier to navigate the confined space.
Person 35 took off his body armour and armed only with a pistol entered the tunnel, re-emerging after a couple of minutes to announce the tunnel was clear, Person 5 testified.
Person 5 said he then went to a meeting a short distance away with other team commanders. After hearing gunshots he ran towards the sound, where he saw Mr Roberts-Smith and another soldier, Person 4 in the north west corner of the compound.
He shouted to Mr Roberts-Smith, who told him they had just engaged two Taliban.
"KIA (killed in action)?" Person 5 asked.
"Yes", Mr Roberts-Smith replied.
Person 5 returned to the meeting and reported the two KIA, he testified. The meeting then resumed to discuss how to destroy the large cache of weapons and ammunition that had been discovered at the compound.
Person 4 has refused to answer questions about his action in Whiskey 108 on the grounds of self-incrimination.
Another soldier, Person 41, has alleged it was Mr Roberts-Smith who ordered the execution of the Afghan man.
In previous evidence for the newspapers, a soldier known as Person 24 told the court that just before the Whiskey 108 mission, he saw Person 5 at SAS headquarters in a jovial mood, "dancing a bit of a jig".
"He said that we are going to 'blood the rookie'," Person 24 alleged.
However in evidence on Tuesday Person 5 denied he had ever used the term, and had not even heard of it until the newspaper's allegation.
He denied ever saying he was going to 'blood the rookie' or that he had ever killed a PUC (person under control) or ordered anyone else to do so.
The hearing continues.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/witness-in-Ben-robertssmith-defamation-case-denies-blooding-claims/news-story/93cdcdc2ea6eb91d797192cec39bc2a1
#16086498 at 2022-04-16 11:47:58 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Marathon Ben Roberts-Smith trial reaches crucial watershed
Deborah Snow - April 16, 2022
1/3
There have been few civil courtroom contests in Australia to match the sheer scale and drama of the Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case as it has unfolded over the last three months.
Gripping headlines have sprung from allegations of skulduggery on and off the battlefield, raw emotion has spilt into the courtroom as the one-time war hero's most intimate personal relationships have been pulled apart, there have been guest appearances (on opposing sides) by Assistant Defence Minister Andrew Hastie and former defence minister Dr Brendan Nelson, and rare insights into the minds and methods of SAS elite soldiers.
Add to that the proxy contest between two of the country's largest media conglomerates - Seven West Media, whose chair, Kerry Stokes, is bankrolling Roberts-Smith's lawsuit, and Nine, the owners of this masthead - and the label "marathon" doesn't begin to do the saga justice.
The trial began in the middle of last year after two-and-a-half years of preliminary procedural skirmishing. But it was forced into temporary suspension as the pandemic raged. When hearings resumed at the start of February this year, there were confident predictions it would all be wrapped up within 10 weeks.
Instead, 11 weeks on, Nine has only just called the last of its witnesses while Roberts-Smith's military allies will not begin testifying until Tuesday.
This week, then, marks an important watershed. Despite the wave of negative headlines for the Victoria Cross recipient (who instigated the action), it's still too early to predict who will emerge the ultimate victor. But many of Nine's witnesses have exceeded the expectations of its legal team.
The company's mastheads, the Sydney Morning Herald and The Age, are defending their stories on the grounds of truth, meaning there's little room for shades of grey in the competing narratives.
Nine's barrister, Nicholas Owens, SC, acknowledged as much when he advised presiding judge Anthony Besanko at the outset that: "Your honour will be asked to choose between two diametrically opposed stories incapable of being reconciled to one another."
A unique feature of the case is its hybrid nature - what the president of the Australian Bar Association, Matt Collins, QC, calls a war crimes trial "masquerading as a defamation action".
The gravest allegations the media outlets have levelled against Roberts-Smith are the six unlawful killings of prisoners which they say he committed or was complicit in over the course of several missions to Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012.
Nine has also alleged that the Victoria Cross recipient brutalised prisoners, bullied two junior soldiers, endeavoured to intimidate several other SAS troopers to get them to change or drop their evidence to the Brereton inquiry (which was conducting its own probe inside government into war crimes allegations) and that he sought to conceal evidence by burying USB sticks with classified photos on them in his backyard and setting fire to his laptop.
He has also been accused of striking his former lover, Person 17, after she fell drunkenly down a set of stairs at a Parliament House dinner. His estranged wife, Emma Roberts, swore he'd threatened her with the loss of their children if she didn't back up his alleged lie that he was separated at the time of the affair.
Roberts-Smith has denied all wrongdoing. He says the stories have ruined his life and reputation. He insists the only people he ever killed in Afghanistan were lawfully slain during combat. His senior barristers, Arthur Moses, SC, and Bruce McClintock, SC, say the media outlets have been drip-fed rumours and gossip by bitter former comrades, jealous because of Roberts-Smith's high profile, his Victoria Cross and other military awards. There has been evidence from some soldiers of "pro" and "anti" Roberts-Smith camps inside the regiment.
(continued)
#16073688 at 2022-04-14 11:05:31 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
>>16053237
Roberts-Smith prepares to call first witness as Nine evidence wraps up
PERRY DUFFIN - APRIL 14, 2022
Nine newspapers have wrapped up their defence against Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation lawsuit, opening the door for the Victoria Cross recipient to begin calling his witnesses from next week.
The newspapers have been calling witnesses since February to help substantiate articles that claimed Mr Roberts-Smith is a war criminal, bully and abuser.
Mr Roberts-Smith, a highly decorated SAS veteran, denies each of Nine's claims and launched defamation proceedings in 2018.
For weeks dozens of the normally secretive SAS community have walked into Sydney's Federal Court and claimed they witnessed executions and brutality from Mr Roberts-Smith and other comrades.
Among the documents were interviews between Mr Roberts-Smith and officials from the Australian War Memorial, phone records related to prepaid phones and sensitive documents from the Department of Defence.
Mr Roberts-Smith gave evidence in the middle of 2021 in which he disputed every one of Nine's claims of illegality and explained the hurt caused by the articles and allegations.
But from Tuesday a very different cohort of SAS soldiers will step into court, this time it is expected they will testify Mr Roberts-Smith did not carry out execution killings in Afghanistan.
The first will be a senior soldier known as Person 5 who is expected to deny he or Mr Roberts-Smith ordered a junior soldier to execute an Afghan in 2009 so he could be "blooded".
Then another soldier, known as Person 11, is expected to deny he shot and killed an unarmed farmer who Mr Roberts-Smith had allegedly kicked down a hill.
Person 11 is expected to testify, as did Mr Roberts-Smith, that they shot dead a Taliban spotter in a cornfield during that raid.
More soldiers will likely denounce a culture of rumours and gossip within the elite fighting force which Mr Roberts-Smith has claimed triggered the media firestorm in 2018.
There will be approximately 20 witnesses in total testifying in support of Mr Roberts-Smith's case before Justice Anthony Besanko begins considering his verdict.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/breaking-news/robertssmith-prepares-to-call-first-witness-as-nine-evidence-wraps-up/news-story/a799cdaab2ac89cc549972564b8a09be
#16053237 at 2022-04-11 10:11:33 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
SAS soldier felt 'threatened' to testify against Ben Roberts-Smith
PERRY DUFFIN - APRIL 11, 2022
An emotionally vulnerable SAS soldier has told a court he felt "threatened" Nine newspapers would accuse him of a war crime murder unless he came to court to testify against Ben Roberts-Smith.
The soldier, anonymised as Person 56, stepped into the Federal Court witness stand on Monday morning as the high profile defamation trial resumed after a week of silence.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing Nine newspapers claiming they falsely defamed him as a war criminal.
Nine insists the stories are true and has called multiple SAS soldiers to testify in support of their allegations.
Person 56 was asked first about a mission to the Afghan village of Darwan where Mr Roberts-Smith is accused of kicking an unarmed farmer down a steep drop into a dry creek bed.
Nine claims Mr Roberts-Smith ordered another soldier to execute the wounded Afghan - claims denied by the Victoria Cross recipient.
Person 56, on Monday, told the court he did not witness any kick or execution and was not with Mr Roberts-Smith through the entire raid.
The soldier said he didn't hear anything said over troop radio about enemies killed in action but there was talk of someone being kicked down a cliff when the elite troops returned to base.
Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Arthur Moses SC, did not begin by asking questions about Darwan, however.
Instead he focused his cross examination on communications between lawyers for Person 56 and Nine newspapers.
Person 56 agreed he did not want to be involved in the high profile defamation lawsuit and repeatedly refused Nine's requests to meet and discuss the allegations.
But in August 2021, the court heard, Nine's lawyers contacted Person 56 and said they knew he was "exposed" because of a second mission weeks later.
Nine's lawyers told Person 56 he and Mr Roberts-Smith were accused of killing two detainees, known as PUCs, at the town of Fasil in October 2012.
"(Nine) believes that Person 56 and BRS are the two individuals responsible for the execution of the PUCs at Fasil," Nine's lawyers told Person 56's lawyers.
The lawyers told Person 56 they could "steer clear" of the allegation if he agreed to speak about Darwan, the court heard.
Person 56 agreed he felt "threatened" to testify for Nine or they would out him about Fasil.
"(You understood) if you did not agree to speak with the respondent's lawyers about Darwan and help them get what they need for their case against Mr Roberts-Smith, then they would subpoena you as a hostile witness and ask you questions about other matters, including Fasil?" Mr Moses asked.
"And you considered that to be a threat?"
"Yes," the soldier replied to each question.
The SAS soldier objected to giving evidence about Fasil on the grounds of self incrimination and Justice Anthony Besanko ruled he would not need to testify on the mission.
Person 56 has mental health issues and his wife has terminal cancer, the court heard.
Nine claims Mr Roberts-Smith's patrol detained and executed two Afghans after they were found with explosive components in their HiLux at Fasil.
Another SAS soldier on the mission, Person 16, told the court a young Afghan was "shaking like a leaf" after they were detained by the road side and led away by Mr Roberts-Smith.
Person 16 said he later asked Mr Roberts-Smith what happened to the scared teenager.
"I shot that c*nt in the head," Person 16 claims Mr Roberts-Smith responded.
"(I) blew his brains out, it was the most beautiful thing I've ever seen."
Mr Roberts-Smith totally denies he killed anyone and denies those comments.
Earlier this year, Nine asked Justice Anthony Besanko to allow them to subpoena Person 56 to give evidence - the SAS soldier simultaneously asked the court to leave him out of the trial.
Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers also asked for Person 56 to be excused, but Justice Besanko allowed Nine to subpoena the soldier.
After months of evidence Nine is nearing the end of its extensive witness list - though at least one soldier is expected to be recalled.
Mr Moses, on Monday, said he believed one of Nine's witnesses had perjured himself and the barrister wants to question him further.
From next week the trial will dramatically change pace as Mr Roberts-Smith begins calling his own witnesses who are expected to cast doubt on Nine's claims he killed six unarmed Afghans and bullied his fellow soldiers.
The trial continues.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/breaking-news/sas-soldier-felt-threatened-to-testify-against-Ben-robertssmith/news-story/4f90bc780bc8f94c1224aef9f82caac3
#16040658 at 2022-04-09 05:20:20 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
#21 - Part 11
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 2
>>15859641 'Did we just witness an execution?': Former SAS soldier describes alleged killing by Ben Roberts-Smith
>>15866438 Ben Roberts-Smith machine-gunned Afghan with prosthetic leg as 'an exhibition execution', witness alleges
>>15881223 Ben Roberts-Smith trial hears claims war veteran wanted to 'choke a man to death with my bare hands'
>>15881925 'Bit rich' for Roberts-Smith to back mental health charity, soldier tells court
>>15889909 SAS whistleblower could not ignore war crime allegation against Ben Roberts-Smith, court hears
>>15916667 SAS whistle blower denies speaking to media about alleged war crimes in Afghanistan as a move to "tarnish" the reputation of decorated veteran Ben Roberts-Smith
>>15916673 Ben Roberts-Smith's former girlfriend tells defamation trial he punched her in face in Canberra hotel room
>>15932396 MP Andrew Hastie tells court Ben Roberts-Smith had a reputation for bullying fellow soldier
>>15940091 Andrew Hastie 'pities' Ben Roberts-Smith, tells court alleged SAS war crimes were 'incentivised'
>>15945927 I blew the whistle on VC hero Ben Roberts-Smith, says Andrew Hastie
>>15962224 Roberts-Smith in 'alternate universe': MP Andrew Hastie - Government MP and former soldier Andrew Hastie has defended speaking to journalists about alleged war crimes, saying he wanted to shed light on the situation
>>15968651 Legal stoush after key witness attempts to avoid testifying at Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial
>>15968660 'Self incrimination of the gravest kind': SAS witness may be compelled to give 'murder' evidence at Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial
>>15975044 SAS witness who allegedly murdered an Afghan prisoner under orders from war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith has not been forced by the Federal Court to speak about the mission
>>15981895 Roberts-Smith punched SAS soldier in jaw and ordered mock execution, court told
>>15989384 Ex-soldier tells court he didn't fabricate allegations against Ben Roberts-Smith to hide his own 'abysmal failure'
>>16002446 Roberts-Smith trial enters 'Heart of Darkness' territory - "Some guys went up the Congo, the others didn't."
>>16008514 SAS soldier told Ben Roberts-Smith to 'pull his head in' over alleged mock execution, court hears
>>16015002 Ben Roberts-Smith and patrol let down by 'weak leadership' in SAS, court hears
>>16034770 Roberts-Smith may have 'colluded' with witnesses in defamation case, court told
#16040655 at 2022-04-09 05:20:02 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #22: THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 3-YEAR ELECTION Edition
#21 - Part 10
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 1
>>15600712 Ben Roberts-Smith described alleged execution of Afghan teen as 'beautiful thing', court hears
>>15640446 Ben Roberts-Smith trial: SAS Soldier tells court at least two men pulled from tunnel in Afghanistan compound - Ben Roberts-Smith told court "There were no people in the tunnel at Whiskey 108"
>>15648230 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial told of 'bullet in the head' threat to ex-SAS soldier
>>15656298 Soldier tells court he didn't 'fabricate' Ben Roberts-Smith death threats
>>15680825 Army officer tells Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial VC recipient threatened to 'smash his face in'
>>15689163 Former soldier tells court Ben Roberts-Smith ordered mock execution of unarmed prisoner during training exercise
>>15697917 'Weak dog': Private eye and former policeman John McLeod denies leaking to the media, turns on Ben Roberts-Smith in court
>>15708130 Ben Roberts-Smith told another soldier in Afghanistan 'I just want to kill', showed photos of dead insurgents on his iPod, court hears
>>15727122 A vigilant Commonwealth government keeps watchful eyes on the Roberts-Smith case - Afghanistan war crimes investigations ongoing
>>15743221 Ben Roberts-Smith kicked an unarmed and handcuffed man off a cliff, says witness
>>15751401 Former soldier objects to answering questions on alleged murder in Ben Roberts-Smith case
>>15761426 Ben Roberts-Smith's accuser risked his life in Taliban battle but 'politics' robbed him of top medal, court hears
>>15770041 Tensions boil in Ben Roberts-Smith trial as soldier says he was 'manipulated'
>>15779131 Ben Roberts-Smith checked whether drone recorded events on day of alleged murders, court told
>>15787690 SAS senior command knew in 2013 of allegations Ben Roberts-Smith kicked detainee off cliff, court hears
>>15802905 SAS soldier cried describing Roberts-Smith kicking man off cliff, court told
>>15810421 'Toxic' SAS was like 'country wives club' and 'rumour mill', Ben Roberts-Smith trial hears
>>15819129 Afghan man with prosthetic leg 'marched off' by Roberts-Smith before being killed, court told
>>15819137 SAS soldier sensationally accused of war crimes after an anonymous threat was aired in Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial
>>15836644 Ben Roberts-Smith was a 'bully' and VC was given in error, former SAS patrol commander tells court
#16040572 at 2022-04-09 05:04:15 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
#21 - Part 11
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 2
>>15859641 'Did we just witness an execution?': Former SAS soldier describes alleged killing by Ben Roberts-Smith
>>15866438 Ben Roberts-Smith machine-gunned Afghan with prosthetic leg as 'an exhibition execution', witness alleges
>>15881223 Ben Roberts-Smith trial hears claims war veteran wanted to 'choke a man to death with my bare hands'
>>15881925 'Bit rich' for Roberts-Smith to back mental health charity, soldier tells court
>>15889909 SAS whistleblower could not ignore war crime allegation against Ben Roberts-Smith, court hears
>>15916667 SAS whistle blower denies speaking to media about alleged war crimes in Afghanistan as a move to "tarnish" the reputation of decorated veteran Ben Roberts-Smith
>>15916673 Ben Roberts-Smith's former girlfriend tells defamation trial he punched her in face in Canberra hotel room
>>15932396 MP Andrew Hastie tells court Ben Roberts-Smith had a reputation for bullying fellow soldier
>>15940091 Andrew Hastie 'pities' Ben Roberts-Smith, tells court alleged SAS war crimes were 'incentivised'
>>15945927 I blew the whistle on VC hero Ben Roberts-Smith, says Andrew Hastie
>>15962224 Roberts-Smith in 'alternate universe': MP Andrew Hastie - Government MP and former soldier Andrew Hastie has defended speaking to journalists about alleged war crimes, saying he wanted to shed light on the situation
>>15968651 Legal stoush after key witness attempts to avoid testifying at Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial
>>15968660 'Self incrimination of the gravest kind': SAS witness may be compelled to give 'murder' evidence at Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial
>>15975044 SAS witness who allegedly murdered an Afghan prisoner under orders from war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith has not been forced by the Federal Court to speak about the mission
>>15981895 Roberts-Smith punched SAS soldier in jaw and ordered mock execution, court told
>>15989384 Ex-soldier tells court he didn't fabricate allegations against Ben Roberts-Smith to hide his own 'abysmal failure'
>>16002446 Roberts-Smith trial enters 'Heart of Darkness' territory - "Some guys went up the Congo, the others didn't."
>>16008514 SAS soldier told Ben Roberts-Smith to 'pull his head in' over alleged mock execution, court hears
>>16015002 Ben Roberts-Smith and patrol let down by 'weak leadership' in SAS, court hears
>>16034770 Roberts-Smith may have 'colluded' with witnesses in defamation case, court told
#16040569 at 2022-04-09 05:03:43 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
#21 - Part 10
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 1
>>15600712 Ben Roberts-Smith described alleged execution of Afghan teen as 'beautiful thing', court hears
>>15640446 Ben Roberts-Smith trial: SAS Soldier tells court at least two men pulled from tunnel in Afghanistan compound - Ben Roberts-Smith told court "There were no people in the tunnel at Whiskey 108"
>>15648230 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial told of 'bullet in the head' threat to ex-SAS soldier
>>15656298 Soldier tells court he didn't 'fabricate' Ben Roberts-Smith death threats
>>15680825 Army officer tells Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial VC recipient threatened to 'smash his face in'
>>15689163 Former soldier tells court Ben Roberts-Smith ordered mock execution of unarmed prisoner during training exercise
>>15697917 'Weak dog': Private eye and former policeman John McLeod denies leaking to the media, turns on Ben Roberts-Smith in court
>>15708130 Ben Roberts-Smith told another soldier in Afghanistan 'I just want to kill', showed photos of dead insurgents on his iPod, court hears
>>15727122 A vigilant Commonwealth government keeps watchful eyes on the Roberts-Smith case - Afghanistan war crimes investigations ongoing
>>15743221 Ben Roberts-Smith kicked an unarmed and handcuffed man off a cliff, says witness
>>15751401 Former soldier objects to answering questions on alleged murder in Ben Roberts-Smith case
>>15761426 Ben Roberts-Smith's accuser risked his life in Taliban battle but 'politics' robbed him of top medal, court hears
>>15770041 Tensions boil in Ben Roberts-Smith trial as soldier says he was 'manipulated'
>>15779131 Ben Roberts-Smith checked whether drone recorded events on day of alleged murders, court told
>>15787690 SAS senior command knew in 2013 of allegations Ben Roberts-Smith kicked detainee off cliff, court hears
>>15802905 SAS soldier cried describing Roberts-Smith kicking man off cliff, court told
>>15810421 'Toxic' SAS was like 'country wives club' and 'rumour mill', Ben Roberts-Smith trial hears
>>15819129 Afghan man with prosthetic leg 'marched off' by Roberts-Smith before being killed, court told
>>15819137 SAS soldier sensationally accused of war crimes after an anonymous threat was aired in Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial
>>15836644 Ben Roberts-Smith was a 'bully' and VC was given in error, former SAS patrol commander tells court
#16034770 at 2022-04-08 08:44:21 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Roberts-Smith may have 'colluded' with witnesses in defamation case, court told
Michaela Whitbourn - April 8, 2022
1/2
Three newspapers defending a defamation suit brought against them by war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith have alleged the decorated former soldier and four of his prospective witnesses appear to have colluded to give false evidence in the case.
The allegation prompted a furious response from Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Arthur Moses, SC, who told the Federal Court on Friday it was baseless and may prejudice the court and the public by suggesting the witnesses were involved in a conspiracy. He accused the newspapers of "throwing allegations around like confetti".
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times for defamation over a series of articles in 2018 that he says portray him as a war criminal who was involved in the unlawful killing of Afghan prisoners.
The newspapers are seeking to rely on a defence of truth. They applied on Friday for access to documents related to the preparation of written outlines of evidence anticipated to be given in court by Mr Roberts-Smith, who appeared in the witness box last year, and four witnesses expected to be called by his legal team this year.
Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers say the documents are covered by legal professional privilege and cannot be produced. But Nicholas Owens, SC, acting for the news outlets, said the documents may shed light on an alleged fraud or impropriety, and the court should order that the material be produced.
Mr Owens said the five outlines contained "a highly specific, and we will say false, account of a material matter" in the case, which provided a "negative alibi" for a soldier in the Afghan partner force dubbed Person 12.
The newspapers allege Mr Roberts-Smith directed Person 12, via an interpreter, to shoot an unarmed Afghan prisoner in October 2012. The rules of engagement provide a killing in those circumstances is murder.
Mr Roberts-Smith denies the allegation and had said in his outline of evidence that Person 12 was not on the mission because he had been stood down from the Afghan National Army earlier that year for wounding a soldier by shooting at a dog.
The proposed evidence about Person 12 was offered as a "knockout blow" to the newspapers' allegation, Mr Owens said.
But Mr Roberts-Smith conceded in court on June 11 last year that his explanation about Person 12 being stood down was wrong, based on material produced by the Defence Department on the eve of the trial. He maintained the Afghan soldier was not there.
(continued)
#16015002 at 2022-04-05 08:20:09 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Ben Roberts-Smith and patrol let down by 'weak leadership' in SAS, court hears
Witness in defamation case brought by Roberts-Smith tells court SAS command should have 'dealt with' war crimes allegations earlier
Ben Doherty - 4 Apr 2022
1/2
"Weak leadership" of Australia's SAS "let down" Ben Roberts-Smith and members of his patrol by failing to investigate allegations of war crimes and allowing the rumours to circulate publicly, the federal court has heard.
A former SAS corporal, anonymised before the court as Person 31, told the court in evidence on Monday he was concerned enough by allegations he heard from Robert-Smith's own patrol members that he confronted the Victoria Cross winner about them.
Person 31 was subpoenaed to give evidence in court by three newspapers defending a defamation action brought by Roberts-Smith, his former comrade and Victoria Cross recipient.
Roberts-Smith alleges the newspapers' reports portrayed him as committing war crimes, including murder, as well as acts of bullying and domestic violence. The newspapers are pleading a defence of truth. Roberts-Smith denies all wrongdoing.
Person 31 told the court he was told that one of Roberts-Smith's patrol mates had watched Roberts-Smith kick an unarmed Afghan prisoner off a cliff in the village of Darwan in 2012, he said.
Further allegations "came to light", Person 31 said, as he neared his retirement from the military in 2014.
Person 31 said he believed SAS command failed its soldiers.
"I felt the system let down the members of his patrol and Mr Roberts-Smith himself," Person 31 told the court.
"Those accusations that were brought out of the patrol should have been dealt with in the command.
"It wasn't, I understand, due to weak leadership at the time. Hence we're now dealing with this in court where no one wants to be."
Earlier evidence in this trial has heard that SAS senior command were alerted to war crimes allegations as early as 2013, but that soldiers believed no action was taken.
Person 31 said he was involved in a training drill at Lancelin base in Western Australia in 2012, where SAS soldiers rehearsed "clearing" Afghan-style compounds.
Last week, another soldier known as Person 10 gave evidence Roberts-Smith ordered him to carry out a mock execution of a prisoner, actually another soldier, Person 9, acting in the role of a detained Afghan "person under control".
Person 9 was kneeling, facing a wall, when Person 10 said he was called into a rear room of the compound. Person 10 said Roberts-Smith gave him an order.
"He said words to the effect of 'shoot him'."
"But it's Person 9," Person 10 told the court her replied.
Person 10 said Roberts-Smith reaffirmed the order: "Shoot him."
"I went 'bang bang'."
Roberts-Smith allegedly said to Person 10: "That's how it's going to be on the day."
(continued)
#16008514 at 2022-04-04 09:31:11 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
SAS soldier told Ben Roberts-Smith to 'pull his head in' over alleged mock execution, court hears
Michaela Whitbourn - April 4, 2022
1/2
A former elite soldier has told the Federal Court that he warned war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith to "pull his head in" after he heard the decorated soldier had ordered the mock execution of a comrade posing as a prisoner.
The former soldier known as Person 31 said he was told in 2012 that Mr Roberts-Smith had directed another soldier, Person 10, to pretend to execute a fake Afghan prisoner during a training exercise.
He recalled seeing Persons 9, 10 and Mr Roberts-Smith from a distance in a mock Afghan compound during the exercise, he told the court.
After the training session, Person 31 said, a soldier dubbed Person 7 said words to the effect of: "Oh, for f-ck's sake, Mr Roberts-Smith has had Person 10 do a scenario of executing a PUC," meaning a person under the control of Australian troops. He said he was told the soldier posing as the prisoner was Person 9.
Person 10 gave evidence last week that Mr Roberts-Smith ordered him to carry out the mock execution, and he responded with "bang, bang" to indicate he had shot Person 9.
Person 31, a former Special Air Service soldier whose identity cannot be revealed for national security reasons, said the alleged incident was "spoken of" and was "somewhat concerning".
"I recall walking past Mr Roberts-Smith outside the mess accommodation and … we had a quick chat," he said.
Person 31 said he had told Mr Roberts-Smith words to the effect of: "F-ck, you know, pull your head in, you can't be doing that shit." He said it was "a very quick conversation" and Mr Roberts-Smith looked down, grunted, nodded, and walked off.
Asked by Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Arthur Moses, SC, if he explained what "that shit" was, Person 31 said he "didn't spell it out". "I felt that we both knew what we were talking about," he said. He denied he was making up the conversation, or that the conversation with Person 7 hadn't happened.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times for defamation over a series of articles in 2018 that he says portray him as a bully and a war criminal who was involved in the unlawful killing of Afghan detainees. Prisoners cannot be killed under the rules of engagement.
The newspapers are seeking to rely on a defence of truth. Mr Roberts-Smith denies all wrongdoing and told the court earlier this year that the mock execution did not happen. He says he did not bully soldiers and any killings in Afghanistan occurred lawfully in the heat of battle.
(continued)
#16002446 at 2022-04-03 08:33:32 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15945927
Roberts-Smith trial enters 'Heart of Darkness' territory
Deborah Snow - April 2, 2022
1/2
It's rare for a serving minister of the Crown to be called as a witness in a high-profile court case, let alone face a grilling about his or her dealings, on and off the record, with two of the country's most prominent journalists.
But if Assistant Defence Minister Andrew Hastie felt exposed this week in the full glare of the Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial, he didn't show it. Instead, he cut loose: both about the failure of culture within some parts of the elite SAS, in which he once served as a captain, and about the vital role of public interest journalism in holding institutions to account.
The up-and-coming Western Australian also offered the court some astonishingly frank commentary on how Australia's mission in Afghanistan had played out. Parts of it will not sit well with some of his Coalition colleagues.
Notes taken by veteran investigative journalist Chris Masters and colleague Nick McKenzie, defendants in the case along with Nine's mastheads the Sydney Morning Herald and The Age, provided the catalyst for this line of questioning.
The notes surfaced after a successful application to produce them by Roberts-Smith's barrister Arthur Moses, SC.
"There were days where I felt it was a closed universe, where you can make up your own morality on the grounds you wanted to, and it was a dark and haunting and incredibly unnatural feeling," the notes recorded Hastie saying, in language reminiscent of Joseph Conrad's dystopian novel Heart of Darkness.
Did he say this to Masters, Moses asked.
Yes, Hastie said, explaining he'd meant it as a reference to Australia's Afghanistan mission as a whole.
"We were there at gunpoint imposing our own standards on the Afghan people, trying to build a fledgling judicial system and pretending that, you know, we could police things but essentially making arbitrary judgments about who was good and who was bad," Hastie told the court.
Moses read out another excerpt from McKenzie's notes: "Some guys went up the Congo, the others didn't."
Hastie confirmed this was a direct reference to Conrad's novel, set in central Africa, and the movie Apocalypse Now, based on the novel but set in Vietnam, which charts the descent into murderous tyranny of rogue army colonel Kurtz.
What did he mean by saying some soldiers had gone "up the Congo", Moses asked.
"That time in the Congo has degraded [Kurtz's] moral faculties, and he's now operating according to his own standards," Hastie replied.
"I think I said some guys went up the Congo, and I think, yes, [that] could have applied to Mr Roberts-Smith, but I think just generally."
Giving a frank insight into his own struggles with the aftermath of wartime experience, he described dreams he'd had where "we have killed one of our own guys and covered it up". It spoke to "moral trauma", he said. "I took the dream to be a sort of metaphor for what we had done to ourselves."
Hastie told the court there was a "warrior culture" afoot more generally in parts of the storied SAS at the time, and "it was shorn of just-war theory. You know, killing became a sacrament in itself."
It was extraordinary testimony, especially coming from a man who now carries partial political responsibility for running Australia's military.
But pressed on whether he had told others that Roberts-Smith was a war criminal, Hastie denied doing so: "I said that serious allegations have been levelled and they need to be answered."
The media outlets have accused the Victoria Cross recipient of committing or being party to six unlawful killings in Afghanistan, but Roberts-Smith denies all wrongdoing and insists he only killed men lawfully in combat.
(continued)
#15989384 at 2022-04-01 13:12:57 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Ex-soldier tells court he didn't fabricate allegations against Ben Roberts-Smith to hide his own 'abysmal failure'
Jamie McKinnell - 1 April 2022
A former elite soldier who has claimed in court Ben Roberts-Smith bullied him has denied making allegations against the war veteran to explain his own "abysmal failure" in the Defence Force.
Codenamed Person 10, the ex-Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) operator was called by publisher Nine Entertainment in its defence of a case Mr Roberts-Smith initiated over newspaper articles.
The war veteran claims the stories, published in 2018, contained false allegations of unlawful killings, bullying and domestic violence.
Person 10 has told the Federal Court Mr Roberts-Smith ordered him to mock execute a fellow soldier who was pretending to be a prisoner during a pre-deployment training drill in WA, which the veteran denies.
The court also heard Mr Roberts-Smith punched Person 10 in the face following a battlefield mishap during a 2012 mission in the Chora Valley, in which Person 10 fired at what he thought was a "threat" in his peripheral vision.
He later saw a woman carrying a birdcage and a child emerge from a river bed.
Under cross-examination by Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister Arthur Moses SC, the witness was shown documents of his performance reviews.
He was removed from Mr Roberts-Smith's patrol, and ultimately from the SAS.
Person 10 agreed they raised issues around his lack of maturity.
"You've never come to grips with the fact that you are a failed SASR soldier, have you?" Mr Moses asked.
"I have, Mr Moses, I've moved on," Person 10 replied.
The witness did not accept that at the time of his removal from the unit, he attempted to blame others.
"You've sought to raise allegations concerning Mr Roberts-Smith after you've left the unit in order to justify to yourself why you were an abysmal failure as an SASR operator, do you accept that?" the barrister asked.
"Incorrect, Mr Moses," Person 10 replied.
The witness has told the court alcohol was raised as one performance issue during a meeting, however believed he had been told not to drink to excess "like the others".
Mr Moses raised an incident in Kabul around 2012 when Person 10 was "so drunk" he took a phone from a female intelligence liaison officer and took photos of his genitals.
Person 10 accepted that incident took place.
He denied he had fabricated evidence about the mock execution after speaking with an ex-colleague.
When he gave evidence last year, Mr Roberts-Smith did not deny punching the ex-soldier.
But the Victoria Cross recipient said it happened after Person 10 "giggled" during a debrief and was to reinforce the seriousness of what took place on the battlefield, along with its potential repercussions on the unit.
Person 10 yesterday told the judge he believed punching someone in the face and "berating them in front of the patrol" could be considered a form of bullying.
The trial, before Justice Anthony Besanko, continues on Monday.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-04-01/ex-soldier-tells-Roberts-Smith-trial-he-didnt-fabricate-evidence/100958934
#15981895 at 2022-03-31 09:55:40 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Roberts-Smith punched SAS soldier in jaw and ordered mock execution, court told
Michaela Whitbourn - March 31, 2022
1/2
A former elite soldier has told the Federal Court that his troop commander, Ben Roberts-Smith, told him to "shoot" a soldier posing as a detainee during a training exercise and punched him in the jaw after a subsequent mission in Afghanistan.
Person 10, a former Special Air Service soldier whose identity cannot be revealed for national security reasons, told Mr Roberts-Smith's defamation case in Sydney on Thursday that the decorated former soldier called him into a compound during a "mission rehearsal exercise" in Perth in 2012 and ordered the mock execution.
"There was a PUC, person under confinement, who was bound. He was on his knees facing the corner," Person 10 said. He said another soldier, Person 9, was playing the role of the prisoner.
Person 10 said Mr Roberts-Smith told him to shoot the prisoner.
"I said, 'but it's Person 9,'" he told the court. Person 10 said Mr Roberts-Smith repeated: "Shoot him."
Person 10 said he responded with "bang, bang" to indicate that he had shot the man.
He said Mr Roberts-Smith replied: "That's how it's going to be on the day."
Person 10 told the court that Person 9 referred to the incident later and said "words to the effect of, 'don't get involved in that shit, it's not good.'"
Person 10 is among a number of current and former soldiers called to give evidence for The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times in the defamation suit filed against the mastheads by Mr Roberts-Smith.
Mr Roberts-Smith alleges a series of articles published in 2018 portray him as a war criminal who bullied Australian soldiers and was involved in unlawful killings of Afghan detainees.
The media outlets are seeking to rely on a defence of truth and allege Mr Roberts-Smith committed or was involved in six murders of Afghans under the control of Australian troops, when they cannot be killed under the rules of engagement.
Mr Roberts-Smith denies all wrongdoing and maintains any killings in Afghanistan were carried out lawfully in the heat of battle.
Person 10 also gave evidence about a mission in Afghanistan in mid-2012, during which he said he saw a fighting-age Afghan man acting suspiciously. He said shots were "fired in our general direction" and he saw movement in his peripheral vision and fired back. He was told later the shots were fired by another SAS soldier.
He said he stopped shooting when Mr Roberts-Smith yelled: "Ceasefire, ceasefire, ceasefire." Shortly after he stopped firing, another SAS patrol set off blue smoke to indicate their position and "a woman and child emerged … and the woman was holding a bird cage", Person 10 said.
He said he "did not fire willingly at a woman and child" but he had perceived a threat. He said a separate accusation that he had fired at a "friendly call sign", meaning other SAS troops, was "simply false".
Person 10 told the court that Mr Roberts-Smith told him to stand up during a debriefing in the troops' patrol room after the incident and punched him in the jaw.
"It rattled me, I did not expect to be punched. After that I can't recall what he said but he was shouting at me," Person 10 said. He said Mr Roberts-Smith went on to say that "nothing leaves this room".
(continued)
#15975044 at 2022-03-30 07:03:49 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
SAS witness excused from 'murder' evidence
Greta Stonehouse - March 30, 2022
An SAS witness who allegedly murdered an Afghan prisoner under orders from war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith has not been forced by the Federal Court to speak about the mission.
Justice Anthony Besanko on Wednesday said the elite soldier codenamed Person 66 was not required to give evidence about a 2012 mission in the Syahchow region where the alleged war crime occurred.
Nicholas Owens SC, representing the newspapers Mr Roberts-Smith is suing for defamation, then asked another two questions but both were successfully objected to under Justice Besanko's ruling.
The questions pertained to whether Person 66 shot a person under control (PUC) and whether Mr Roberts-Smith directed him to do so.
After Person 66 refused to answer the questions, he was freed from his testimony.
Mr Roberts-Smith, 43, is suing The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times over reports claiming he committed war crimes and murders in Afghanistan between 2006 and 2012.
Australia's most decorated living war hero denies all the claims against him, while the media outlets are defending them as true.
Person 66 first entered the witness box on Monday, but soon objected to giving evidence due to "self-incrimination" his lawyer described as being "of the gravest kind".
The news outlets allege in court documents that the young trooper in 2012 was ordered to execute the unarmed Afghan prisoner by Mr Roberts-Smith, who is accused of "blooding the rookie".
The phrase refers to a fresh soldier getting their first kill in action.
Mr Roberts-Smith earlier testified insurgents were shot within the rules of engagement during that mission, and flatly denied ordering Person 66 to shoot an Afghan prisoner.
On Tuesday, Mr Owens pressed for the evidence to be given, saying proving the incident alone could prove key to his case.
"It is … possible that I could win this case by only proving the murder at Syahchow."
"It is an independent path home to victory."
Person 66's barrister Jack Tracey argued against his client speaking, saying he ran the risk of prosecution in the International Criminal Court and an unfair trial at home if charges were to eventuate.
He also presented documents to the court pertaining to Person 66's mental ill-health.
"(The) effect of giving evidence in this proceeding would put his wellbeing and life at risk," he said.
The only other SAS witness who objected to speaking about another alleged execution, even granted a certificate of immunity from Justice Anthony Besanko, was Person Four.
Mr Owens did not compel Person Four to speak about the alleged war crime he is said to have carried out, saying there were other witnesses to that event to create the "rich mosaic" Justice Besanko could make findings from.
But only the evidence from Person 66 would explain the circumstances of how those at Syahchow were killed in action, Mr Owens said.
The next witness to be called by the media outlets is another SAS soldier they say was bullied by Mr Roberts-Smith.
The trial continues.
https://www.perthnow.com.au/news/crime/decision-for-sas-witness-on-alleged-murder-c-6254530
#15968660 at 2022-03-29 08:06:51 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
'Grave': SAS witness may be compelled to give 'murder' evidence at Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial
PERRY DUFFIN - MARCH 29, 2022
A court will consider compelling an SAS soldier to give evidence about the alleged murder of an unarmed Afghan in the defamation trial launched by Ben Roberts-Smith despite his lawyer warning it could expose him to war crime prosecution.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing Nine newspapers for a series of articles that claim he killed unarmed Afghans while fighting with the SAS.
Nine insists their articles are true while Mr Roberts-Smith denies every allegation.
The newspapers have called multiple SAS witnesses who claim they have witnessed or participated indirectly in alleged war crimes.
One crucial witness, known only as Person 66, stepped into the witness box this week to give evidence about a mission in the Afghan region of Syahchow in 2012.
Nine claims Mr Roberts-Smith forced an Afghan detainee to kneel in a field outside the village and ordered Person 66 to execute the unarmed man so the junior soldier could be "blooded" with a kill.
Mr Roberts-Smith denies that.
Person 66 objected to answering questions about his 2012 military operations with Mr Roberts-Smith citing "self-incrimination".
That means Justice Anthony Besanko must now determine if the man should be compelled to give evidence.
The stakes could not be higher - Person 66 is being asked to confess to murder, Nine's barrister Nicholas Owens SC told the court.
Nine hopes to convince the court that Mr Roberts-Smith is a war criminal based on the evidence of other SAS witnesses who claim he killed unarmed Afghans during other SAS raids.
But, Mr Owens said, proving the killing at Syahchow would be an "independent path home to victory" for the newspapers.
In other words - even if Nine fails to prove every other killing was a war crime they would still win the case if they proved Mr Roberts-Smith ordered a murder at Syahchow.
Person 66 is the only eye witness to the alleged killing at Syahchow, the court heard.
But the SAS soldier's barrister, Jack Tracey, asked Justice Besanko to allow his client to stay silent.
"The particular evidence is of a nature that, if it were given, it would involve self incrimination of the gravest kind," Mr Tracey said.
A report by the Inspector General of the Australian Defence Force, in 2020, found "credible information" that 39 people were killed unlawfully in Afghanistan.
Australian authorities are now investigating those allegations.
Person 66 is not charged and is facing no pending charges, Mr Tracey said, but the investigations still weighed against the soldier giving evidence.
"The court should consider it a heightened risk that, just by reason of those investigations occurring, my client may potentially be charged in the future," Mr Tracey said.
Mr Tracey said there was also a low but present risk that the International Criminal Court would listen in to the evidence and consider taking action against the SAS soldier.
Mr Tracey warned there were doubts the so-called immunity certificates, offered to witnesses including Person 66, would actually protect the SAS soldiers either in Australia or internationally.
The court must consider balancing between a civil court case against Person 66's liberty, which was now at stake, he said.
"At the end of the day, the balance of the interest of justice lies with my client not being required to give the evidence," Mr Tracey said.
Nine's barrister, Mr Owens, disagreed that the ICC would prosecute Person 66 saying the global war crime court would not interfere while Australia was investigating its own soldiers.
Mr Owens said he argued there was "zero risk" of an ICC prosecution, contrasted to another soldier who faced a "theoretical risk".
"Australia wouldn't supply compelled testimony to the ICC used against the witness and even if that happened the ICC wouldn't be able to use that evidence against the witness," he told the court.
The court also heard Person 66 has PTSD, though the court heard some of his symptoms had settled. But Mr Tracey warned about the impact of giving evidence on the soldier.
"The effect of having him give evidence would put his well being and, indeed, his life at risk," he said.
Justice Besanko will return his decision on Wednesday.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/defence/grave-sas-witness-may-be-compelled-to-give-murder-evidence-at-Ben-robertssmith-defamation-trial/news-story/6cc6ff425f8ec6ae1097dae43714a8f3
#15968651 at 2022-03-29 08:02:14 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Legal stoush after key witness attempts to avoid testifying at Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial
Jamie McKinnell - 29 March 2022
A key defence witness who allegedly killed an Afghan man during a 2012 mission after receiving orders from Ben Roberts-Smith is attempting to avoid testifying at the veteran's defamation trial.
The witness, codenamed Person 66, was subpoenaed by publisher Nine Entertainment, which is being sued by Mr Roberts-Smith over newspaper articles published in 2018.
The war veteran claims he was defamed by false allegations in those stories of unlawful killings, bullying and domestic violence.
Person 66 had not killed anyone prior to a mission in Syahchow during one of his deployments to Afghanistan in October 2012, according to Nine's court documents.
Mr Roberts-Smith allegedly directed Person 66 to shoot an Afghan man who was, at the time, a PUC (person under control), and he allegedly "did so".
After the incident, Mr Roberts-Smith allegedly said he had "blooded" Person 66, a phrase referring to junior operators getting their first kill in action.
Person 66 initially objected to answering a question about the number of missions he took part in when Mr Roberts-Smith was a patrol commander, citing potential self-incrimination.
His position remained unchanged despite being offered a certificate under the Evidence Act which would mean his evidence could not be used against him in an Australian court.
Nine's barrister, Nicholas Owens SC, sought to have the witness directed to give evidence, triggering a lengthy legal debate.
Barrister Jack Tracey, representing Person 66, said the expected evidence was "of a nature that if it were given, would involve self-incrimination of the gravest kind".
Mr Tracey argued there was a "heightened risk" of future charges due to investigations by Australian Federal Police and the Office of the Special Investigator.
"If that occurred … his forensic disadvantage would be very substantial and that's notwithstanding the existence of a certificate," Mr Tracey said.
The barrister also cited his client's post-traumatic stress disorder and said the effect of him giving evidence would "put his wellbeing and indeed his life at risk".
The court heard there was no other eyewitness testimony concerning the alleged incident at Syahchow.
Mr Owens argued Person 66's evidence was "highly relevant", including towards establishing the substantial truth of two central imputations in the case.
Proving the Syahchow incident represented "an independent path home to victory", Mr Owens said.
Last year, Mr Roberts-Smith was asked in the witness box whether he ordered Person 66 to kill a prisoner and he replied: "I did not."
The veteran told the court during the mission, insurgents were shot in an "agriculture area" outside some compounds, but he could not recall who initiated the engagement.
He said he threw a grenade because there was no return fire or yelling and they needed to ascertain if the insurgents were dead.
Two dead insurgents were found in vegetation, Mr Roberts-Smith said.
The veteran said he didn't know whether any PUCs were taken.
Former elite soldier and Assistant Defence Minister Andrew Hastie, who was also on the mission, previously told the court it was his view "Person 66 was blooded".
He recalled seeing "12 to 15" PUCs up against a wall being tactically questioned and Person 66 "looking nervous".
"I just thought that's not the person I know, happy-go-lucky sort of country Aussie," he said.
Mr Hastie said he went to another area and heard a radio call that shots had been fired, but did not hear any.
He said Mr Roberts-Smith later walked past him and said: "Just a couple more dead c*nts."
Justice Anthony Besanko will make a decision about Person 66's evidence tomorrow afternoon.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-03-29/defence-witness-tries-to-avoid-testifying-at-Roberts-Smith-trial/100947798
#15962224 at 2022-03-28 09:24:10 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Roberts-Smith in 'alternate universe': MP Andrew Hastie
Government MP and former soldier Andrew Hastie has defended speaking to journalists about alleged war crimes, saying he wanted to shed light on the situation.
Tiffanie Turnbull - 28 March 2022
Federal government MP Andrew Hastie has defended speaking to journalists about Ben Roberts-Smith, telling a court he wanted to shed light on alleged war crimes.
The former Special Air Service Regiment captain gave evidence on Monday about speaking to the media while an inquiry into war crime allegations in Afghanistan was underway.
The assistant minister for defence was accused by barrister Arthur Moses SC, on behalf of Mr Roberts-Smith, for not having courage to put his name to those allegations.
Mr Hastie said the accusations were put by numerous special forces members and he was providing support appearing in an interview on the Nine Network's 60 Minutes program.
"The reason these allegations have come to light is because the systems have failed thus far," he told the Federal Court.
He said the "fourth estate" was doing important work shedding light on incidents that helps "keeps democracy healthy".
Mr Roberts-Smith, 43, is suing The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times over reports claiming he committed war crimes and murders in Afghanistan between 2006 and 2012.
The Victoria Cross recipient denies all the claims against him, while the media outlets are defending them as true.
Mr Hastie said Mr Roberts-Smith's recollection of a 2012 mission to Syahchow both soldiers took part in painted an "alternate universe" to the one the minister had experienced.
During the de-brief with their officer in command, Mr Hastie said he was "naive" listening to his colleague provide a "different summary" of events that made little sense to him.
News outlets allege Mr Roberts-Smith ordered a young trooper to execute a prisoner during that mission.
Mr Hastie said he was made aware weeks later but that it was a "big step to accuse someone of unlawful conduct".
"I had a gut feeling something wasn't right."
"I remember saying things didn't add up on that job," and that "the numbers" weren't stacking up, he said.
Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers have repeatedly suggested allegations against the war hero were made up by a small group of peers who were jealous of his military accolades.
Mr Hastie previously listed to the court 20 people who had suggested to him that Mr Roberts-Smith was a hypocrite - that "the outward facing picture of Mr Robert-Smith was at odds with his battlefield conduct".
He initially highly regarded Mr Roberts-Smith, but no longer was proud of him, he said, while denying that he disliked him.
"I pity him," he said on Friday.
"I don't want to be here… this is terrible for our country. It's terrible for the SAS. It's terrible for the army."
Mr Hastie denied he had been critical of Mr Roberts-Smith to raise his own profile as a parliamentarian or that he had come to court to support the newspaper's claims because they were giving him financial assistance in another legal matter.
The trial continues.
https://7news.com.au/news/crime/hastie-to-continue-Roberts-Smith-evidence-c-6226713
#15945927 at 2022-03-26 02:59:34 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
I blew the whistle on VC hero Ben Roberts-Smith, says Andrew Hastie
Ben PACKHAM - MARCH 25, 2022
Assistant Defence Minister ?Andrew Hastie has outed himself as a source for articles alleging Victoria Cross winner Ben Roberts-Smith is a war criminal, ?revealing he suspected by 2013 that the decorated soldier had been involved in executing ?Afghan prisoners.
The federal Liberal MP and former SAS captain told the Federal Court on Friday that there were persistent rumours within the Special Air Service Regiment that Mr Roberts-Smith kicked an Afghan prisoner off a cliff in 2012, and he believed he may have ?ordered a subordinate to kill an unarmed prisoner the same year.
Mr Hastie, an SAS captain for five years before he stood for parliament, said he spoke informally to his commanders in 2012 about alleged war crimes by the SASR in Afghanistan, amid rumours and "a gut feeling that something wasn't right".
But said he did not have enough evidence at the time to make a formal complaint about any individual, warning instead a policy to release suspected Taliban members "incentivises killing rather than capturing".
Mr Hastie said he had spoken on and off the record about war-crime allegations to Nine journalists Nick McKenzie and Chris Masters, and had "probably" passed on rumours Mr Roberts-Smith had committed war crimes.
But he rejected suggestions by Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, ?Arthur Moses SC, that he had provided them with information to secure "favourable" coverage for himself as a politician.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing Nine newspapers and journalists for defamation after they published articles saying he killed six unarmed Afghans while ?deployed with the SAS. He denies each allegation, while Nine is ?defending the case on the grounds the allegations are true.
Mr Hastie told the court of a 2014 "pastoral care" conversation with another soldier, known as Person 7, who was "greatly vexed" that his reporting of "certain incidents" involving Mr Roberts-Smith in Afghanistan had not been acted on. The court heard Person 7 raised with commanders the ?alleged kicking of the prisoner off a cliff, Mr Roberts-Smith's ?alleged shooting of an already-dead person, and claims over the accuracy of his Victoria Cross ?citation.
Under questioning by Mr Moses, who asked if he was aware that Person 7 had an "intense dislike" of his client, Mr Hastie said: "I would say he has a dislike of Mr Roberts-Smith, compounded by a sense of injustice."
Mr Hastie said he'd had ?conversations with at least 20 SAS soldiers who had suggested Mr Roberts-Smith was a hypocrite, because "bad stuff had happened in Afghanistan, and yet the outward-facing picture of Mr Roberts-Smith was at odds with his battlefield conduct".
Mr Hastie said he had started out in the SAS with a high regard for Mr Roberts-Smith, but he was "no longer proud" of him.
"I don't dislike Mr Roberts-Smith at all. I pity him, I pity this whole process," Mr Hastie said. "This is terrible for our country, terrible for the SAS, terrible for the army. It's touched a lot of lives and no one wants to see this. But until we deal with it we can't move forward."
Mr Hastie relayed a conversation with his troop sergeant in 2013, in which the soldier ?expressed his concerns to him in stark terms. "(He said) 'I'm not going to ?Afghanistan to put dirt farmers on their knees and shoot them in the back of the head'," Mr Hastie said.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/media/i-blew-the-whistle-on-vc-hero-Ben-robertssmith-says-andrew-hastie/news-story/dff07012a71b30ca8899f5a2211675e8
#15940091 at 2022-03-25 11:12:00 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Andrew Hastie 'pities' Ben Roberts-Smith, tells court alleged SAS war crimes were 'incentivised'
PERRY DUFFIN - MARCH 25, 2022
SAS officer turned MP Andrew Hastie warned top military brass that Australian troops were "incentivised" to execute detained Afghans because the suspected Taliban insurgents were being released within days of capture, a court has heard.
The shocking insight came as the MP became emotional telling a court he was praying for Ben Roberts-Smith while testifying against the elite soldier.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing Nine newspapers and journalists for defamation after they published articles saying he killed six unarmed Afghans while deployed with the SAS.
He denies every allegation while Nine maintains they are true.
Mr Hastie served as an officer in the SAS on missions alongside Mr Roberts-Smith in 2012 though the pair had very limited contact, the MP told the Federal Court on Friday.
During that time, the court has heard, the SAS were detaining suspected insurgents while raiding Taliban compounds and questioning them.
Some were taken into the Afghan judicial system, Mr Hastie told the court, but Coalition troops had just three days to provide evidence of wrongdoing or the detainee was released as a matter of policy.
The former Captain told the court there were rumours the "capture and release" policy was having an unintended effect.
"This system incentivises killing rather than capturing," Mr Hastie said he told his superiors in 2012.
"Did I raise the catch and release policy and the way it incentivises extrajudicial killing with my superiors? Yes I mentioned this."
The MP could not recall if he told the superiors about specific allegations against any soldiers "taking the law into their own hands" by killing Afghans.
But by 2013-2014, Mr Hastie, said multiple soldiers were claiming Victoria Cross recipient Mr Roberts-Smith had kicked a man off a cliff.
Mr Hastie became emotional in court moments earlier, explaining he "pitied" Mr Roberts-Smith, who sat silently in the furthest corner of Sydney's Federal Court.
"I don't dislike Mr Roberts-Smith at all, I pity him, I pity this whole process," Mr Hastie said.
The MP told the court he called his father and asked for his prayers - his father also prayed for Mr Roberts-Smith.
"This is terrible for our country, terrible for the SAS, terrible for the army. It's touched a lot of lives and no one wants to see this," he said.
"But until we deal with it we can't move forward."
Nine's truth defence means they effectively must prove the allegations against Mr Roberts-Smith are likely true - that has forced the civil lawsuit to drill down into evidence about Australia's alleged war crimes.
Mr Hastie revealed he had a "gut feeling something wasn't right" in the elite fighting force around 2012.
The then-SAS officer claimed one commander explained it wasn't his job to take Australian troops to Afghanistan to kill people - his job was to stop that happening.
"You're not going to Afghanistan to put dirt farmers on their knees and shoot them in the back of the head," Mr Hastie said, recounting words from his superiors.
Mr Roberts-Smith denies Nine's claim he kicked a detained shepherd off a cliff during a raid on the Afghan village of Darwan in September 2012.
He further denies Nine's claims he watched or ordered another Australian soldier to execute the injured Afghan.
That allegation was raised in a meeting by one of Mr Roberts-Smith's most vehement critics within the unit during a meeting with a commander, Mr Hastie told the court.
"Person 7 was greatly vexed that incidents overseas had not been dealt with by the chain of command," Mr Hastie said.
"(Person 7) was frustrated and said words to the effect of 'Mr Roberts-Smith was father of the year and enjoying a high profile in the community'."
The trial continues.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/andrew-hastie-pities-Ben-robertssmith-tells-court-alleged-sas-war-crimes-were-incentivised/news-story/c04424fb3b8eac18b1cceb06e60ac0ec
#15932396 at 2022-03-24 09:43:52 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
MP Andrew Hastie tells court Ben Roberts-Smith had a reputation for bullying fellow soldier
Jamie McKinnell - 24 March 2022
1/2
Federal MP Andrew Hastie has told a Sydney court war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith had a reputation for bullying a fellow elite soldier during his time in the Special Air Service Regiment (SAS).
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing three newspapers over a series of 2018 articles which he says contained false allegations of unlawful killings, bullying and domestic violence.
Mr Hastie was called as a witness by publisher Nine Entertainment, which is seeking to rely on truth defence.
The Assistant Minister for Defence was a captain in the SAS prior to entering politics and spent time on deployment in Afghanistan with Mr Roberts-Smith.
"There was always, in the background, people who had a strong view on Mr Roberts-Smith and the way he conducted himself with other members of the regiment," Mr Hastie told the Federal Court.
When asked by Nine's barrister, Nicholas Owens SC, whether he had any reputation regarding one specific colleague, who's been codenamed Person 1, he said multiple people had mentioned bullying.
"Over the period of my five-and-a-half years' service in SASR, if I was to summarise it, that Person 1 was the victim of bullying at the hands of Mr Roberts-Smith," Mr Hastie said.
He described Person 1, who Mr Roberts-Smith has denied bullying, as "a very bright person, confident and very competent".
Mr Hastie recalled crossing paths with Person 1 through regimental life before getting to know him well in the later half of 2013 during training.
He recalled one morning soldiers were eating breakfast when Mr Roberts-Smith was shown on a morning television show, wearing his uniform and medals, while speaking about mental health charities he supported.
Mr Hastie said another colleague, Person 68, stood up and loudly said: "RS gave Person 1 depression, now he's going to help him fight it."
He said everyone laughed, but not at the expense of Person 1.
Earlier today, Mr Roberts-Smith's former girlfriend denied, under cross-examination, using a pregnancy and miscarriage during their affair in a "campaign of deceit".
Codenamed Person 17 said she became pregnant with what she knew must have been the war veteran's child in early 2018, during a five-month extramarital affair.
The court has heard the two discussed a termination, however Person 17 said she had a miscarriage on March 2 that year.
(continued)
#15916673 at 2022-03-22 07:38:51 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Ben Roberts-Smith's former girlfriend tells defamation trial he punched her in face in Canberra hotel room
Jamie McKinnell - 22 March 2022
Ben Roberts-Smith's ex-girlfriend has told a Sydney court the war veteran punched her in the face in a Canberra hotel room and told her to lie about the injury to her husband.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times newspapers over a series of articles published in 2018.
The Victoria Cross recipient claims he was defamed by false allegations in those stories of an act of domestic violence against the woman, bullying of his Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) colleagues and unlawful killings in Afghanistan.
Codenamed Person 17, the woman today told the Federal Court the two met at a charity event in October 2017 before they flirted and spoke about both having marital problems.
Person 17 said she told the veteran she thought she was falling in love with him and he replied: "You don't want to fall in love with me, I'm not the greatest guy."
The court heard they saw each other roughly every 10 days in what she described as a "fast moving" and "all-consuming" relationship.
She said by late 2017, they'd spoken about long-term plans to leave their respective marriages and move to the United States.
In March the following year, she said she fell pregnant and knew it was Mr Roberts-Smith's child, and the pair spoke about a termination before she miscarried.
The court has previously heard Mr Roberts-Smith paid a private detective to follow Person 17 to an abortion clinic because he suspected he was being "manipulated".
Person 17 told the court the veteran made her take two pregnancy tests in front of him in a Brisbane hotel, at which point she tearfully told him about the miscarriage.
She recalled at a Parliament House function in Canberra on March 28, Mr Roberts-Smith was "looking at me from the stage and subtly shaking his head", which she assumed related to her drinking and speaking to men at her table.
Person 17 said she was "quite drunk" by the time she left and fell down some stairs, causing a bruise to her thigh.
At their Canberra hotel room, she said Mr Roberts-Smith became "really angry".
"He was sort of up in my face just inside the doorway and he was shaking me by the shoulders and he said: 'What the f*** have you done.'" Person 17 said.
"He said: 'What have you done... you were all over the other men at dinner, they're all going to know we're having an affair, I should have just left you there, you made a big scene as we were leaving.'
"He said: 'I let you into my world and I trusted you and you just treated it like a high school formal.'"
Person 17 told the judge she repeatedly apologised.
"I said to him: 'My head's hurting… let's just go to bed, let's forget about it,'" the witness said.
"He'd been pacing around in the lounge area and was getting angry with me.
"He punched me with his right fist on the left side of my face and eye."
Person 17 said she fell backwards towards a bed.
"I just lay there still, I didn't know what he was going to do next," she told the court.
Last year, Mr Roberts-Smith denied hitting the woman and described domestic violence as "deplorable", "reprehensible" and "a disgusting act of cowardice".
Today, the court heard after the two flew back to Brisbane the following day, Mr Roberts-Smith asked her if she remembered what happened in the hotel.
"I said no, he said something like: 'Good girl, you hurt yourself when you fell over.'"
Asked why she didn't admit that she remembered, Person 17 replied: "I was afraid of what he would do if I didn't say that."
The trial, before Justice Anthony Besanko, continues on Wednesday.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-03-22/Ben-Roberts-Smith-punched-woman-in-face-at-hotel-court-told/100930366
#15916667 at 2022-03-22 07:35:23 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Soldier denies 'tarnishing' Roberts-Smith
Australian Associated Press - March 21 2022
An SAS whistle blower has denied speaking out to media about alleged war crimes in Afghanistan as a move to "tarnish" the reputation of decorated veteran Ben Roberts-Smith.
The warrant officer class two, codenamed Person Seven, spent his fourth day in the witness box at the civil trial brought by Mr Roberts-Smith against three newspapers he says defamed him in reports of alleged war crimes and murders in Afghanistan between 2006 and 2012.
Person Seven was one of two anonymous sources who appeared on the Nine Network's 60 Minutes program in 2019 in breach of Australian Defence policy.
On Monday, Person Seven rejected claims put to him by Mr Roberts-Smith's counsel, Arthur Moses SC, that his motivation in speaking to journalists was to "tarnish" the Victoria Cross winner's reputation.
"No I don't accept that … I wanted Australia to take these allegations seriously," he told the court.
Queried about Mr Roberts-Smith's VC citation for actions at the battle of Tizak, Person Seven said he believed the document contained "lies and embellishments", including about whether an insurgent killed in the firefight was armed, the intensity of gunfire in the battle, and whether an enemy position was fortified and elevated.
The trial has previously been told that a basis on which Mr Roberts-Smith was awarded his VC was storming machine gun positions at Tizak.
Both Mr Roberts-Smith and Person Seven fought in the 2010 battle, the trial heard.
Mr Moses suggested to Person Seven that he had "just not let go" of Mr Roberts-Smith being awarded the VC for his actions at Tizak.
"I let this go a long time ago," the witness replied.
The court heard Person Seven declined to take the initiative to neutralise machine guns in the battle because he was "trying to stay alive", rejecting the claim he had become "consumed by the thought" he chose not to assault the machine guns.
"I do not regret anything at the battle of Tizak … my personal performance," he said.
He conceded not being brave enough to attack the machines guns, but denied the barrister's claims this had caused him to resent the war hero.
"Not at all," he said.
Person Seven also denied he became "filled with anger and frustration" on a 2011 military speaking tour he and Mr Roberts-Smith participated in about Tizak.
"I've got on with my life," he said.
Also on Monday, the court heard Person Seven was the source of an article which claimed Mr Roberts-Smith kneed an Afghan "in the guts" and "smashed" him in the cheek.
Quizzed over the alleged incident, Person Seven said it was what he saw, heard, and said, and rejected the barrister's assertion he divulged it to portray himself as a hero, and to "character assassinate" the former SAS corporal.
"Mr Moses, I'm completely unknown … No one has a clue who I am," he said.
The trial has previously been told Person Seven watched the war hero attack an unarmed Afghan prisoner, bully a comrade and threaten to strangle a man.
The soldier has also testified that a trooper, dubbed Person Four, told him Mr Roberts-Smith kicked an unarmed Afghan prisoner off a cliff in Darwan in 2012.
The SAS member has denied being entrenched with a group of soldiers against Mr Roberts-Smith, or "dumping on" him in interviews with journalists.
Mr Roberts-Smith denies all the accusations against him.
The trial continues on Tuesday.
Lifeline 13 11 14
https://www.lifeline.org.au/
Open Arms 1800 011 046
https://www.openarms.gov.au/
https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/7665915/soldier-denies-tarnishing-Roberts-Smith/
#15889909 at 2022-03-18 11:32:46 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
SAS whistleblower could not ignore war crime allegation against Ben Roberts-Smith, court hears
Witness tells defamation trial he knew appearing on 60 Minutes in 2019 breached defence force rules but does not regret it
Ben Doherty - 17 Mar 2022
1/2
An SAS whistleblower who spoke to the media about a war crime allegedly committed by Ben Roberts-Smith has told the federal court he knew he was defying orders in doing so, but felt he couldn't walk past such an "egregious" allegation.
A soldier anonymised as Person 7, a still-serving SAS veteran of multiple deployments to Afghanistan with the SAS, spent a second day under cross-examination in Roberts-Smith's defamation case on Thursday. He was questioned extensively about his service alongside Roberts-Smith and their fractious relationship.
Roberts-Smith, a recipient of the Victoria Cross and one of Australia's most decorated soldiers, is suing the Age, the Sydney Morning Herald and the Canberra Times for defamation over a series of ?reports he alleges portray him as committing war crimes, including murder.
The newspapers are pleading a defence of truth. Roberts-Smith denies all wrongdoing.
Person 7 told the federal court he was one of two SAS sources who appeared anonymously on 60 Minutes in 2019 in breach of defence force protocols. He alleged he had been told by another soldier that Roberts-Smith had kicked a bound, unarmed prisoner off a cliff during an SAS mission.
Person 7 said that he had initially declined to speak to the media but that he ultimately agreed to because he "wanted to be a voice from within".
Person 7 denied he appeared on the program out of malice and "jealousy" towards Roberts-Smith, saying he was motivated by a desire to hold his former comrade accountable for his actions.
"I am a senior [non-commissioned officer] in the army, I was told of an allegation of an egregious nature, I am not walking past that," he said on Thursday. Person 7 said he raised the allegation with senior command within the SAS as long ago as 2013.
Person 7 said he had been told by another soldier, known as Person 4, that Roberts-Smith had kicked an unarmed Afghan prisoner off a cliff during a raid in the village of Darwan in 2012.
He said he was told the story on three separate occasions, including details that Person 4 watched the Afghan man's head hit a rock as he fell, sending his teeth flying out of his head.
Person 4 has earlier given evidence in this trial, telling the court he saw Roberts-Smith kick the bound prisoner off the cliff, falling to a dry riverbed below. Person 4 told the court the man was still alive when the soldiers reached the creek bed. He said Roberts-Smith then ordered he and another soldier to drag the badly injured man under a tree where he was shot dead on Roberts-Smith's orders.
Person 4 objected to giving evidence about his actions on other SAS missions in Afghanistan on the grounds of "self-incrimination" and denied suggestions by Roberts-Smiths lawyers that health issues had affected his memory.
(continued)
#15881925 at 2022-03-17 08:01:47 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
'Bit rich' for Roberts-Smith to back mental health charity, soldier tells court
Michaela Whitbourn - March 17, 2022
An elite soldier has told the Federal Court it was a "bit rich" for war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith to be patron of a mental health charity because he believed the decorated former soldier was a bully who had caused a comrade to develop depression.
Person 7, a senior Special Air Service soldier whose identity cannot be revealed for national security reasons, told Mr Roberts-Smith's defamation case on Thursday that he spoke to investigative journalist Chris Masters about the former soldier, including allegations of bullying and war crimes.
Person 7 also appeared on screen, with his face and voice obscured, in an interview with The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald's investigative reporter Nick McKenzie on Nine's 60 Minutes in 2019, in which he named Mr Roberts-Smith as being responsible for kicking an unarmed Afghan man off a cliff in 2012.
Person 7 has agreed in court that he did not see the alleged incident but said he believed an account of it given to him by a former SAS soldier, Person 4, who has previously told the court he was an eyewitness to the cliff kick.
Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Arthur Moses, SC, referred to notes taken by Mr Masters in early 2016, and asked Person 7 whether he had said of Mr Roberts-Smith's charity work in recent years: "Beforehand he did not give a shit about charities. I've got my views. He's trying to make his reputation look squeaky clean by taking insurance."
Person 7 said he could not recall the exact words, but "very possibly" he did make those comments.
"I can say this: [serving SAS soldier] Person 1 was suffering depression, and I thought it was interesting that one of the charities that RS then went and fronted was a mental health charity, considering that Person 1 has told me that the depression he suffered was because of his association and experiences with RS."
"Do you know for a fact that Mr Roberts-Smith gave depression to Person 1?" Mr Moses asked.
"Person 1 told me that, yes. I believe that allegation."
He said he was "trying to imply, Mr Moses, that I feel that it's a bit rich that you've given a soldier depression, and then you go and become a patron, or whatever the position was, of a mental health charity."
Asked if he was jealous that Mr Roberts-Smith was doing charity work, Person 7 replied: "Mr Moses, I can tell you now, I have never been jealous of RS."
Person 7 told the court on Wednesday that he had supported Person 1 in making a bullying complaint against Mr Roberts-Smith, and had witnessed Mr Roberts-Smith disparaging and "character assassinating" the SAS soldier.
Person 7 had been Person 1's troop commander and first encountered him in 2007 or 2008, when he found him to be a "good, steady soldier".
He denied that he was seeking to "bring down" Mr Roberts-Smith or tarnish his reputation, but said some of the things he told Mr Masters, including about Mr Roberts-Smith's marriage, amounted to "petty, immature, childish gossip".
He agreed that he likened Mr Roberts-Smith to a frilled-neck lizard who would "back off" if confronted, and told Mr Masters he had stood up to him and "seen how he starts lying straight away".
Person 7 also agreed that appearing on 60 Minutes was a mistake because it was contrary to Defence Force policy to speak to the media without authorisation.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Age, the Herald and The Canberra Times for defamation over a series of articles that he says accuse him of being a war criminal and engaging in a campaign of bullying against another soldier.
The media outlets are seeking to rely on a defence of truth and allege Mr Roberts-Smith committed or was involved in six murders of Afghans under the control of Australian troops, when they cannot be killed under the rules of engagement, and that he bullied a fellow soldier.
Mr Roberts-Smith maintains any killings in Afghanistan were carried out lawfully in the heat of battle and that he did not engage in bullying.
The trial continues.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/bit-rich-for-Roberts-Smith-to-back-mental-health-charity-soldier-tells-court-20220317-p5a5fn.html
#15881223 at 2022-03-17 05:14:35 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Ben Roberts-Smith trial hears claims war veteran wanted to 'choke a man to death with my bare hands'
Jamie McKinnell - 16 March 2022
1/2
An elite soldier has told a Sydney court war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith once declared he was going to "choke a man to death" and "watch the life drain out of his eyes" in Afghanistan.
The witness was called by publisher Nine Entertainment in its defence of a defamation case brought by Mr Roberts-Smith over a series of 2018 newspaper articles in The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times.
The Victoria Cross recipient claims they contained false allegations of unlawful killings, bullying of his Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) colleagues and domestic violence against a woman in a Canberra hotel room.
The witness, codenamed Person 7, told the Federal Court the alleged choking comment was made in the days after Sergeant Blaine Diddams was killed on a mission in Afghanistan in 2012.
He said he was in a "ready room" preparing his assault bag when he heard Mr Roberts-Smith behind him say: "Hey mate, I'm going to talk the talk, I want you to make sure I walk the walk."
Person 7 claimed Mr Roberts-Smith then said: "Before this trip's over, I'm going to choke a man to death with my bare hands, I'm going to look him in the eye and I'm going to watch the life drain out of his eyes."
Mr Roberts-Smith denied making the comment when he gave evidence last year, dismissing it as "ridiculous".
"He's got a flair for the dramatic," he said of Person 7.
"That is not how I speak. I never have and I never will."
Person 7 recalled a later mission in the area where Sergeant Diddams was killed.
He told the court Mr Roberts-Smith commented: "If those f*ckers are up there, we're going to kill every one of those f*ckers."
Person 7 claimed in another incident, he saw Mr Roberts-Smith "jumper punch" an Afghan man up against a wall in an area where up to 20 people had been detained, or become PUCs (Person Under Control).
He said Mr Roberts-Smith punched the man four times while a young girl was nearby, and when the Afghan man was released the little girl ran over to him.
Person 7 recalled asking: "What's going on here RS?"
"He just said 'he's a f*cking bad c*nt'," Person 7 said.
The witness said when he asked Mr Roberts-Smith why, the veteran said that during questioning, the Afghan "hesitated" when he was asked his daughter's name.
Person 7 also claims to have seen Mr Roberts-Smith order the mock execution of a "detainee", a role being played by a soldier, during a pre-deployment training exercise in 2012.
He told the court Mr Roberts-Smith then put his hand on the shoulder of the colleague who was ordered to shoot, Person 10.
"[Mr Roberts-Smith] said, 'Are you good with that, cause that's how it's going to be when we're over there'," Person 7 said.
(continued)
#15866438 at 2022-03-15 07:33:02 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Ben Roberts-Smith machine-gunned Afghan with prosthetic leg as 'an exhibition execution', witness alleges
Roberts-Smith 'wanted people to see he was going to kill someone', former comrade tells defamation trial during cross-examination
Ben Doherty - 15 Mar 2022
1/2
Ben Roberts-Smith machine-gunned an Afghan prisoner to death as an "exhibition execution", a comrade has told the federal court during cross-examination.
"He wanted people to see he was going to kill someone out there in front of everyone," the former SAS soldier, anonymised before court as Person 24, testified during a combative, and at times emotional, second day in the witness box.
Roberts-Smith is suing the Age, the Sydney Morning Herald and the Canberra Times for defamation over reports he alleges portray him as committing war crimes, including murder.
The newspapers are pleading a defence of truth. Roberts-Smith denies all wrongdoing.
Person 24 told the court on Monday that he witnessed Roberts-Smith carry an Afghan man - whom he later discovered had a prosthetic left leg - outside of a village compound being raided by Australian troops.
"Mr Roberts-Smith walked out of the compound ... at this stage he was holding a man in his hand, it appeared he [the man] had come off the ground, he was being held by his pants or back of the shirt.
"He [Roberts-Smith] marched about 15 metres directly out - he dropped the man on to the ground - and immediately put a machine-gun burst into his back."
Person 24 said the machine-gun burst was "eight to 10 rounds" and told the court he said to a comrade standing next to him, "did we just witness an execution?".
The compound, codenamed Whiskey 108, was being "cleared" by Australian SAS troops, in the village of Kakarak, in Afghanistan's southern Uruzgan province, in the late afternoon of 12 April 2009.
Person 24 is the third Australian soldier to give similar - though not identical - evidence they saw an Australian soldier shoot the man with the prosthetic leg outside Whiskey 108, and the second witness to identify Roberts-Smith as the soldier allegedly responsible. He told the court he saw the soldier side-on from a distance of 20 metres, and while he did not see his face, he identified Roberts-Smith by his size, gait and "physical demeanour".
Other soldiers have given evidence they saw a man with a prosthetic leg, who was discovered hiding in a secret tunnel inside the compound, taken into the custody of Australian troops before being "marched off" by Roberts-Smith.
Roberts-Smith does not dispute he shot and killed the man with the prosthetic leg but says the man was legitimately engaged in battle.
Roberts-Smith was extensively questioned about the Whiskey 108 mission when he gave evidence in this trial last year: he said he saw the man carrying a weapon and running, and killed him in accordance with troops' rules of engagement.
"He had his hand over the top of the weapon, because he was carrying it down next to his body like that ... hunched over, as in, running like that with his shoulders down."
(continued)
#15859641 at 2022-03-14 06:57:51 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
'Did we just witness an execution?': Former SAS soldier describes alleged killing by Ben Roberts-Smith
Michaela Whitbourn - March 14, 2022
1/2
A former elite soldier has told the Federal Court he saw war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith drop a man to the ground in Afghanistan and machine-gun him in the back, prompting the soldier to turn to a comrade and ask if they had just witnessed an execution.
Person 24, a former Special Air Service soldier, gave evidence in Mr Roberts-Smith's defamation case on Monday that he saw the decorated former soldier march out of a compound dubbed Whiskey 108 in 2009 holding an Afghan man by his shirt or pants. He believed the man was alive because he was making a noise like a grunting sound, he said.
Mr Roberts-Smith dropped the man to the ground, Person 24 said, and immediately fired eight to ten rounds into his back.
Person 24, whose name cannot be revealed for national security reasons, said he turned to another soldier, Person 14, and said: "Did we just witness an execution?"
Person 14, who was a member of Person 24's patrol and is still serving in the SAS, has previously told the court that he saw three Australian soldiers on that day with "a black object which was … similar to a human". The object was thrown to the ground, Person 14 said in February, before one soldier raised a "distinctive" machine gun known as an F89 Para Minimi and fired "an extended burst".
Person 14 told the court that he later discovered that Mr Roberts-Smith was carrying a machine gun matching that description.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times for defamation over a series of articles in 2018 that he says portray him as a war criminal.
The media outlets are seeking to rely on a defence of truth and allege Mr Roberts-Smith committed or was involved in six murders of Afghans under the control of Australian troops, when they cannot be killed under the rules of engagement. Mr Roberts-Smith has said any killings were carried out lawfully in the heat of battle.
Person 24 was called this week to give evidence for the newspapers relating to the mission at Whiskey 108, about which a number of current and former SAS soldiers have given evidence.
Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Arthur Moses, SC, put it to Person 24 that his evidence about the alleged killing was false.
"I wouldn't be in a court of law giving that evidence if it was false. I've just sworn an oath, Mr Moses," Person 24 replied.
Asked how he knew the man he saw was Mr Roberts-Smith, he said it was the soldier's size and gait.
"I could not see his face; they were camouflaged. I couldn't see face definition," he said.
He said the Afghan man killed by Mr Roberts-Smith had a prosthetic leg, which was removed from the body by another soldier, Person 6.
(continued)
#15836644 at 2022-03-11 09:00:07 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Ben Roberts-Smith was a 'bully' and VC was given in error, former SAS patrol commander tells court
abc.net.au - 11 March 2022
A former Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) patrol commander has admitted in court he told comrades Ben Roberts-Smith's Victoria Cross award was "in doubt" and that the war veteran was "a bully".
Mr Roberts-Smith received the VC, the country's highest military honour, for his actions during the 2010 Battle of Tizak in Afghanistan, when his patrol came under heavy enemy fire.
The veteran is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times for defamation over what he says were false allegations of unlawful killings, bullying and domestic violence, published in 2018.
Codenamed Person 43, the witness was called by publisher Nine Entertainment and today detailed his doubts about the VC citation.
"I have said that often it was in doubt and there should have been more investigation before the awarding of it," he told the Federal Court.
Person 43 conceded he didn't observe Mr Roberts-Smith's actions in Tizak.
"The only witnesses were his team, there were no other witnesses," he said.
"Does that mean it's in doubt?" barrister Arthur Moses SC, for Mr Roberts-Smith, asked.
"Absolutely," the witness replied.
Person 43 admitted he told "a lot of people" about his "personal opinion", which he said was formed when he became aware the award was being given.
"The awarding of the VC... was done in secrecy without involvement of the rest of the troop," he said.
Person 43 said his opinion was also based on the fact the citation failed to mention that a comrade, Person 4, was alongside Mr Roberts-Smith during the mission, and the "actual wording of the award", he believed, was "incorrect".
He agreed he'd also told other colleagues Mr Roberts-Smith was "a bully" but said the VC and Mr Roberts-Smith's behaviour were "two separate things".
Under cross-examination from Mr Moses, Person 43 denied he was "bitter" about not receiving an award himself.
"I'm not an attention seeker," he said.
He denied his evidence was designed to be "favourable" to the newspapers' defence.
The court has heard Person 43 was present during a separate mission in April 2009 at a Taliban compound dubbed "Whiskey 108".
He gave evidence of helping remove an "elderly" Afghan man from a secret tunnel, who he said would have then been searched and handcuffed before questioning.
The court has previously heard a man with a prosthetic leg was later seen dead, and Mr Roberts-Smith denies allegations he was responsible for an unlawful killing.
Person 43 told the court that immediately after the mission, rumours began to circulate that two PUCs (persons under control) had been "executed".
"It was discussed a lot amongst a lot of people," he said.
But Person 43 could not recall who he heard the rumours from and denied spreading them himself.
A previous witness, Person 41, claimed to have seen Mr Roberts-Smith "frogmarch" an Afghan man outside the compound and shoot him in the back with three to five rounds of machine gun fire.
Mr Roberts-Smith last year told the court he shot dead an armed insurgent who was coming around the corner of the compound.
The trial, before Justice Anthony Besanko, continues.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-03-11/Roberts-Smith-court-bully-war-nine-defamation-witness-/100902594
#15819142 at 2022-03-09 08:26:02 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15819137
2/2
Person 18 told the court the threats, which were sent to him at the SAS base in Perth, leaked to Nine and appeared on a 60 Minutes episode - but he was not the leak.
The mention of the two PUCs at Tizak were not broadcast in the 60 Minutes episode.
Ben Roberts-Smith had been asked about the allegations when Nine revealed them in June 2021.
He told the court he had "no idea" if the claims against Person 18 were accurate.
Another soldier, Person 40, was called on Wednesday afternoon to testify about a 2009 raid on a Taliban compound known as Whiskey 108.
Person 40 told the court he was inside Whiskey 108 when he heard a tunnel had been discovered and Australian troops were in a "commotion" over the unusual discovery.
The soldier told the court the troop's interpreter was speaking to two insurgents as they came out of the tunnel.
One was limping, Person 40 told the court, and they were very frightened.
"One had a distinctive limp - the person with the prosthetic leg - immediately upon coming out of the tunnel he lifted his trousers, pointed to the prosthetic leg expecting some sort of sympathy from the troops," Person 40 told the court.
Mr Moses told Person 40 there was no interpreter in Whiskey 108 during the raid.
Person 40 disagreed - insisting there was an interpreter with the SAS.
The soldier said the troop was preparing to extract from Whiskey 108 when he heard a burst of machine gun fire.
As the SAS left, Person 40 continued, he saw the man with the fake leg shot dead.
Nine has claimed Mr Roberts-Smith executed the man with the fake leg outside Whiskey 108.
They also claim he either ordered or was present when another senior soldier ordered the SAS troop's "rookie" shoot the other Afghan so the new soldier could be "blooded".
He denies both allegations.
Person 40 denied claims, raised by Mr Moses, that he had been ejected from the SAS patrol group over "poor performance".
Rather, Person 40 told the court, the patrol was "toxic" and its commander, Person 29, had effectively complained so he would be moved.
Person 40 told the court that patrol commander, Person 29, approached him last year and delivered a message about giving evidence in the court case.
"(Person 29 said) 'You don't need to be a witness, speak to Roberts-Smith's lawyers they'll get you to sign a piece of paper so you don't have to be a witness'," Person 40 told the court.
"I was very surprised, I said 'yep okay', his other comment was 'if you don't he'll see you in court'."
The trial continues.
https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/breaking-news/sas-soldier-accused-of-war-crimes-after-threat-aired-in-Ben-robertssmith-trial/news-story/a89a682b28009cf85d99cb45a01687a0
#15819137 at 2022-03-09 08:25:10 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
SAS soldier accused of war crimes after threat aired in Ben Roberts-Smith trial
An SAS soldier has been accused of war crimes after the defamation trial of Ben Roberts-Smith heard an anonymous threat read in full.
Perry Duffin - March 9, 2022
1/2
An SAS soldier has been sensationally accused of war crimes after an anonymous threat was aired in Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial.
Meanwhile another elite soldier has been accused of misremembering key details and had his service history questioned after giving evidence about another key war crime allegation.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing Nine newspapers and journalists over a series of articles which he claims falsely accused him of war crimes and bullying while in the SAS.
Nine is defending the articles as true while Mr Roberts-Smith denies every allegation.
An SAS witness, known to the Federal Court as Person 18, has spent days giving evidence about rumours that swirled around the SAS regiment about Mr Roberts-Smith.
Some rumours stemmed from the 2010 battle of Tizak which both Mr Roberts-Smith and Person 18 fought.
Other rumours claimed Mr Roberts-Smith killed detained Afghans known as Persons Under Confinement or PUCs in other missions.
Person 18 has told the court the SAS leadership were initially reluctant to deal with the rumours circulating around the "country wives' club" regiment.
The soldier had also told the court he received threatening letters, in June 2018, from someone calling themselves "a friend of the regiment".
The letters warned Person 18 about spreading lies and told him to recant his evidence to a war crime inquiry run by the Inspector General of the Australian Defence Force.
Nine claims Mr Roberts-Smith authored the letters - the Victoria Cross recipient denies that.
Person 18's evidence was at its end on Tuesday afternoon when Nine's lawyers asked Justice Anthony Besanko to allow more questions about one letter..
The letter, read to the court, claimed Person 18 was himself involved in war crimes.
"We are very aware of your murderous actions over many tours in Afghanistan," the letter read, warning Person 18 would be criminally investigated.
"Just like when you participated in the execution of two PUCs from the Taliban's makeshift medical compound following the battle in Tizak."
"You know what you have done and so do we."
The letter had been hinted at by Nine's barristers, and the accusations partly aired in June 2021, but Wednesday marked the first time the allegations against Person 18 were fully put to the soldier.
Person 18 initially objected to answering questions about the allegation on the grounds of "self-incrimination" but then changed his mind - agreeing to answer questions from Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister.
Under cross examination Person 18 said he had not mentioned the allegations against him during his days of evidence out of "embarrassment".
"It's just not something I openly talk about with people, it's an embarrassing claim," he told the court.
Person 18 said he instead just told the court the threat's author had an "extensive knowledge" of his "service history".
The SAS soldier denied he was at the medical compound in Tizak.
(continued)
#15819129 at 2022-03-09 08:17:31 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Afghan man with prosthetic leg 'marched off' by Roberts-Smith before being killed, court told
Michaela Whitbourn - March 9, 2022
Two "frightened" Afghan men were pulled from a tunnel by Australian troops and taken away for questioning by war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith and another soldier before one of the men was killed, an elite soldier has told the Federal Court.
Person 40, a serving Special Air Service soldier, gave evidence in Mr Roberts-Smith's defamation case on Wednesday that he was present during a mission in Afghanistan in 2009, during which two men, including one with a prosthetic leg, were discovered in a compound dubbed Whiskey 108.
"They came out, obviously very frightened, one had a distinctive limp, that's the person with the prosthetic leg... he was lifting his trouser, sort of pointing to the prosthetic leg, expecting some sort of sympathy from the troops," Person 40 told the court.
He said the men were searched and "marched off to another area" for what he assumed was tactical questioning by Mr Roberts-Smith and a second solider, Person 35. He later heard machine gun fire and saw the man with the prosthetic leg had been killed.
Person 40 was called on Wednesday to give evidence for The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times in the defamation suit filed against the mastheads by Mr Roberts-Smith.
He told the court that another soldier, dubbed Person 29, told him "out of the blue" last year after he was subpoenaed to give evidence in the trial that "RS knows you're going to be a witness for this defamation case".
He said Person 29 went on to say "words to the effect of, 'you don't have to be a witness if you … speak to RS's lawyers, they'll get you to sign some sort of a piece of paper and you won't have to act as a witness'."
Person 40 said he was "very surprised" by the conversation.
"I sort of said, 'yep, okay.' His other comment at the end was, 'If you don't, he'll see you in court.'"
Mr Roberts-Smith alleges a series of articles published in 2018 portray him as a war criminal. The newspapers are seeking to rely on a defence of truth and allege Mr Roberts-Smith committed or was involved in six murders of Afghans under the control of Australian troops, when they cannot be killed under the rules of engagement.
Mr Roberts-Smith maintains any killings in Afghanistan were carried out lawfully in the heat of battle, and that no men were discovered in the tunnel at Whiskey 108.
Person 40, whose identity cannot be revealed for national security reasons, told the court that Mr Roberts-Smith was the "lead tactical questioner on the ground" at Whiskey 108, and it was standard procedure for suspected Taliban insurgents to be taken back to the troops' base at Tarin Kowt.
He said he could not recall whether the men were handcuffed but it was standard for suspected insurgents to be searched and cuffed "so they can't use their hands in any shape, way or form".
He said that within about 25 minutes after the men were found he heard "a burst of machine gun fire" from what he believed was a light machine gun, the F89 Para Minimi.
"I walked past the person with the prosthetic leg … He was killed," Person 40 said. He said no prisoners were brought back to Tarin Kowt.
A second serving SAS soldier, Person 18, has given evidence that Mr Roberts-Smith was carrying a light machine gun matching that description on that day, while a third SAS soldier, Person 14, said he discovered later that day that Mr Roberts-Smith was carrying the "distinctive" weapon.
The trial continues.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/afghan-man-with-prosthetic-leg-marched-off-by-Roberts-Smith-before-being-killed-court-told-20220309-p5a330.html
#15810421 at 2022-03-08 08:32:24 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
'Toxic' SAS was like 'country wives club' and 'rumour mill', Ben Roberts-Smith trial hears
Jamie McKinnell - 8 March 2022
1/2
An elite soldier giving evidence in the Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial has denied fuelling a "rumour mill" within the Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) about the death of an Afghan man with a prosthetic leg.
Mr Roberts-Smith, a Victoria Cross recipient, is suing three newspapers after denying allegations of unlawful killings in Afghanistan, bullying and domestic violence published in 2018 articles.
One of the allegations involved an April 2009 mission at a Taliban compound dubbed "Whiskey 108", in which the war veteran is accused of shooting an Afghan man with a prosthetic leg.
An SAS witness called by publisher Nine Entertainment and codenamed Person 18 has told the Federal Court he was clearing a tunnel in the compound during that mission when he heard a burst of "roughly five rounds" of gunfire.
He claimed he turned to a colleague and waited for further reaction before continuing to examine the site.
Person 18 has likened the SAS to a "country wives club", where rumours are spread and expand "tenfold".
He's referred to the unit as "toxic" and an "alpha environment", with members constantly trying to outdo one another.
Under cross-examination from barrister Arthur Moses SC, Person 18 today agreed he heard rumours after the mission about the alleged murder of a man with a prosthetic leg.
He said the main rumour was more "a joke or a stab at the team" because they'd "engaged a person with one leg … engaged a cripple essentially", which he said wasn't the case.
Mr Moses accused the witness of giving false evidence about hearing a burst of ammunition.
"That's just something you've decided to throw into the rumour mill, isn't it?" the barrister asked.
"No," Person 18 replied.
The witness admitted he'd drunk from the prosthetic leg multiple times after it was taken back to an unofficial soldiers' bar.
Mr Roberts-Smith has previously told the court a person he shot that day was a legitimately engaged, armed insurgent coming around the corner of the compound.
Person 18 has further claimed he overheard Mr Roberts-Smith and a colleague, Person 5, at the compound discussing whether a drone had been recording the mission.
Person 18 searched the body of the man with the prosthetic leg and said the "unique" incident later attracted discussion, but insisted he wasn't contributing to the "rumour mill".
"It's not a good feeling to be asked … 'what was it like to pull someone's prosthetic leg off'," he said.
"I didn't really talk about it."
(continued)
#15802905 at 2022-03-07 08:24:07 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
SAS soldier cried describing Roberts-Smith kicking man off cliff, court told
Michaela Whitbourn - March 7, 2022
An elite soldier has told the Federal Court that he saw a comrade break down in tears while recounting an alleged incident involving war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith kicking an Afghan man off a cliff.
Person 18, a serving Special Air Service soldier whose identity cannot be revealed for national security reasons, gave evidence in Mr Roberts-Smith's defamation case on Monday that a former soldier dubbed Person 4 told him in late 2012 that he saw Mr Roberts-Smith kick a detainee off a cliff earlier that year in Darwan, Afghanistan.
Person 18, who was not present on the mission in Darwan, said Person 4 would "break down in tears" every time he recounted the alleged incident.
Person 4 told him that he saw a fellow SAS soldier holding an Afghan detainee before "Ben Roberts-Smith kick[ed] him off the cliff", Person 18 said on Friday.
Person 18 said he "stopped the conversation" because "this was another night where [I was] watching friends break down over things that happened in Afghanistan and … I was sick of it."
Person 18 was called to give evidence for The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times in the defamation suit filed against the mastheads by Mr Roberts-Smith.
Mr Roberts-Smith alleges a series of articles published in 2018 portray him as a war criminal. The media outlets are seeking to rely on a defence of truth and allege Mr Roberts-Smith committed or was involved in six murders of Afghans under the control of Australian troops, when they cannot be killed under the rules of engagement.
Mr Roberts-Smith maintains any killings in Afghanistan were carried out lawfully in the heat of battle. The decorated former soldier has previously told the court that the Afghan man was first seen in a field and was showing hostile intent.
Mr Roberts-Smith said last year that another soldier, Person 11, spotted the Afghan man and started firing, before he fired from behind his comrade. The Afghan man had "fallen", Mr Roberts-Smith said, and he believed Person 11 fired further rounds.
Person 4 has previously told the court that the Afghan man had a donkey with him and was unarmed.
The court heard on Monday that Person 18 was present during a 2010 battle in Tizak, Afghanistan, for which Mr Roberts-Smith was awarded Australia's highest military honour, the Victoria Cross.
Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team have alleged that their client's reputation was destroyed by a campaign led by "bitter people" in the SAS who were "aided by credulous journalists".
Person 18 said he had never spoken to the media about Mr Roberts-Smith.
Asked whether he had heard soldiers express the view that Mr Roberts-Smith did not deserve the Victoria Cross, Person 18 said it had been a "common rumour for the last 12 years" within the SAS.
He likened the SAS to a "country wives' club" and said rumours were rife. It was a "very toxic environment" in which "any rumour is expanded tenfold"
The hearing continues.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/sas-soldier-cried-describing-Roberts-Smith-kicking-man-off-cliff-court-told-20220307-p5a2by.html
#15787690 at 2022-03-05 08:41:05 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
SAS senior command knew in 2013 of allegations Ben Roberts-Smith kicked detainee off cliff, court hears
No action taken after the alleged incident was reported to regimental sergeant major, court hears in defamation action brought by Roberts-Smith
Ben Doherty - 4 Mar 2022
1/2
Allegations Ben Roberts-Smith kicked an unarmed, handcuffed detainee off a cliff in Afghanistan were reported to senior command within the SAS in 2013, but no action was taken, with the regimental sergeant major saying it was "over his head", the federal court has been told.
Roberts-Smith, a recipient of the Victoria Cross and one of Australia's most decorated soldiers, is suing the Age, the Sydney Morning Herald and the Canberra Times for defamation over a series of ?reports he alleges portray him as committing war crimes, including murder.
The newspapers are pleading a defence of truth. Roberts-Smith denies all wrongdoing.
One of the key allegations made against Roberts-Smith concerns a 2012 SAS mission to the village of Darwan in Uruzgan province.
The trial has heard evidence from a former SAS soldier, anonymised before court as Person 4, that he saw Roberts-Smith during that operation kick an unarmed, handcuffed and captive Afghan man in the chest, "catapulting him" off a cliff.
"I saw the individual smash his face on a rock, and I saw the teeth explode out of his face," he told the court.
Person 4 said the Australian soldiers then walked down a track to the bottom of the cliff where Roberts-Smith ordered him and another subordinate soldier to drag the badly injured man under a tree, where he was shot by the other soldier after discussion with Roberts-Smith.
On Friday afternoon in the federal court, another former comrade of Roberts-Smith, a still-serving member of the SAS anonymised as Person 18, said Person 4 had broken down during a drinking session later in 2012, back in Australia, as he recounted the event.
"He said 'I watched Ben Roberts-Smith kick a detainee off a cliff'," Person 18 told the court.
Person 18 said a meeting was organised with the SAS regimental Sergeant Major in early 2013 to discuss the allegation.
"The RSM [regimental sergeant major] said, words to the effect of, 'it was out of his hands, it was way over his head, he honestly didn't know what to do with it'."
Person 18 said no further action was taken.
"The outcome of the first meeting wasn't ... it wasn't receptive," he told the court.
In 2014, in another meeting with a new regimental sergeant major, the allegation was raised again.
"[In this meeting] Person 4 said the same thing: 'They were conducting a mission in Darwan, they had detained persons in Darwan ... he turned around and he saw his team commander kick a detainee off a cliff'."
Person 18 said the regimental sergeant major "had a list of topics he wanted to talk to us about".
"It was the allegations that something had happened during 2012 rotation; allegations of things that had happened in 2009; discrepancies between people in regards to Tizak [the site of a battle in 2010]; allegations of bullying; he went through each one of these, asking what we knew.
"The main thing I recall was Person 4 talking about Darwan ... he broke down in the office."
Roberts-Smith has denied ever kicking anybody off a cliff.
(continued)
#15779131 at 2022-03-04 09:14:26 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Ben Roberts-Smith checked whether drone recorded events on day of alleged murders, court told
Michaela Whitbourn - March 4, 2022
1/2
War veteran Ben Roberts-Smith checked whether a defence force drone had captured specific events on camera on the same day that he was allegedly involved in two unlawful killings in Afghanistan, a Special Air Service soldier has told the Federal Court.
Person 18, a serving SAS soldier whose identity cannot be revealed for national security reasons, gave evidence in Mr Roberts-Smith's defamation case on Friday that he overheard a soldier dubbed Person 5 telling Mr Roberts-Smith during a mission on Easter Sunday, 2009, that "you've just done this" while a drone was "still flying above".
The court has heard evidence that camera-equipped drones, known as Intelligence Surveillance Reconnaissance devices, were used to film some missions from the air. Person 5 told Mr Roberts-Smith on the day of the so-called Whiskey 108 mission that the drone "may have recorded" him, Person 18 said.
Mr Roberts-Smith replied to Person that "we need to find out if the ISR was still above us", Person 18 said, and Person 5 sent a message on a troop internal chat asking where the drone was and if it was recording.
Defence personnel replied that the drone had been "pushed into another threat area" in a compound dubbed Whiskey 108, Person 18 said.
A former SAS soldier known as Person 19 has previously given evidence that Mr Roberts-Smith said during a training exercise in Australia that drones, "which can see what's going on", should be pushed off "to observe another area" during a "sensitive site exploitation".
Person 19 said that Mr Roberts-Smith went on to say: "That's when any people that we suspected of being enemy combatants, we'd take them into a room and shoot the c-nts."
Person 18 told the court on Friday that he found and searched the bodies of three Afghan men during the Whiskey 108 mission. He said he found one body, an Afghan man dressed in white, inside the compound "roughly near" a tunnel entrance. Person 18 told the court that he had seen two to three SAS soldiers earlier that day around an Afghan man in white near the tunnel, and the man had plastic flexicuffs on his wrists.
The court has previously heard evidence from another serving SAS soldier that Mr Roberts-Smith told a soldier dubbed Person 4 to shoot a captive Afghan man who had been discovered in the tunnel at Whiskey 108.
Person 18 said he heard Person 5 tell Mr Roberts-Smith after the mission that they had "blooded the rookie". He didn't know what they were talking about at the time, Person 18 said, but it was a "running joke" that Person 4 was the "rookie".
(continued)
#15770041 at 2022-03-03 07:16:51 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Tensions boil in Ben Roberts-Smith trial as soldier says he was 'manipulated'
PERRY DUFFIN - MARCH 3, 2022
1/2
An SAS soldier, who testified Ben Roberts-Smith kicked an unarmed Afghan off a cliff, says he was "manipulated" by Mr Roberts-Smith's enemies under questioning so heated the judge intervened.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing Nine and its journalists over allegations he was involved in the unlawful killing of six unarmed Afghans while deployed.
Among Nine's allegations against Mr Roberts-Smith is that he kicked a handcuffed shepherd down a cliff before another soldier executed the injured Afghan.
He denies every allegation - Nine maintains they are true.
A decorated SAS soldier known as Person 4 told the court, this week, he witnessed Mr Roberts-Smith kick Mr Jan in the chest during the Darwan raid.
Person 4 claimed he helped drag Mr Jan across a dry creek bed and was standing just metres away as another SAS soldier, Person 11, shot Mr Jan dead in front of Mr Roberts-Smith.
Back at the SAS base, Person 4 told the Federal Court on Thursday, he watched Mr Roberts-Smith tell a group of soldiers "I kicked that c*** off the cliff".
"What you told the court is a fantasy by you," Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister Arthur Moses SC said to Person 4.
"That is not correct," the soldier responded.
Mr Roberts-Smith has told the court other soldiers within the ranks of the SAS regiment wanted to bring him down - partly because he had been awarded Australia's top military honour for his actions in the 2011 battle of Tizak.
Person 4 told the court he fought alongside Mr Roberts-Smith in the crucial moments of the battle of Tizak overcoming the overwhelming odds pitted against the SAS by two Taliban machine guns.
Mr Roberts-Smith, in his Victoria Cross citation, is credited with killing both gunners but Person 4 claims he felled one gunner with rifle fire.
Despite Person 4's bravery during Tizak, the court has heard, he did not get a Victoria Cross - it took two years for him to be awarded the Medal For Gallantry for his actions at Tizak and that upset him greatly.
"The regiment doesn't deserve lies and cowardice and, Your Honour, I'm not a liar or a coward," Person 4 told Justice Anthony Besanko on Thursday.
Mr Moses asked Person 4 if he was suggesting Mr Roberts-Smith was a liar or a coward.
"Absolutely not, I've seen that individual perform heroic feats on the battlefield," Person 4 said.
(continued)
#15761426 at 2022-03-02 08:10:12 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Ben Roberts-Smith's accuser risked his life in Taliban battle but 'politics' robbed him of top medal, court hears
PERRY DUFFIN - MARCH 2, 2022
1/2
The SAS soldier, who accused Ben Roberts-Smith of kicking an unarmed Afghan off a cliff, has testified he risked his life in the ferocious moments that earned the decorated soldier a Victoria Cross, but never received the same award.
The unnamed SAS soldier said he was passed over for the military's top accolade because Mr Roberts-Smith's role in the battle had been "politicised".
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing Nine newspapers and journalists over a series of articles claiming he killed six unarmed Afghans while deployed.
The SAS veteran denies every allegation - including Nine's centrepiece claim that he kicked unarmed farmer Ali Jan down a sandy cliff in the village of Darwan in 2012.
Person 4, an anonymised SAS soldier, told the court this week that he saw Mr Roberts-Smith kick Mr Jan in the chest, catapulting him down the slope into a rock which "exploded" the teeth from the farmer's head.
The unnamed SAS soldier told the court he and a third soldier dragged the injured farmer across a dry creek bed before the third soldier shot Mr Jan dead in front of Mr Roberts-Smith.
He denies being a source for Nine and now suffers from a range of mental health issues, including flashbacks about his time in Afghanistan.
The Federal Court, on Wednesday, heard emotional testimony from Person 4 about a mission in the town of Tizak in 2010.
Person 4 told the court his SAS patrol was pinned down by "sustained and accurate" two Taliban machine guns.
"I remember laying there and looking toward Roberts-Smith - he was ashen in face - and I looked toward Person 18 and he was ashen faced," Person 4 said, his voice breaking.
"I remember distinctly I would have looked the same - I had a feeling of absolute dread and fear."
Person 4 told the court he and Mr Roberts-Smith advanced toward the machine guns, flanking the Taliban while covering each other.
"I identified two muzzles from machine guns firing directly at us. A signature of gases, exhaust gases coming out of the barrels," Person 4 said.
"As Roberts-Smith cleared the window he screamed at me 'one dead enemy!'"
Person 4 said he exposed himself as Mr Roberts-Smith threw a grenade, and again when Mr Roberts-Smith downed the second gunner.
The soldier was seconds behind Mr Roberts-Smith, he told the court, and "100 per cent" believed he shot one of the gunners dead.
Two machine gunners would normally warrant an attack from 100 soldiers, Person 4 told the court, but it was only himself, Mr Roberts-Smith and later a third SAS soldier facing the muzzles.
"That action, for me, was the highlight of my professional career purely because - excuse me," he said as his words caught in his throat.
"I didn't let them down. We both supported each other. We overcame overwhelming odds together ... There were only two of us that day, plus Person 32, that were able to overcome those odds."
(continued)
#15751401 at 2022-03-01 08:29:06 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Former soldier objects to answering questions on alleged murder in Ben Roberts-Smith case
Michaela Whitbourn - March 1, 2022
A former elite soldier who was allegedly told by war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith to execute an unarmed Afghan man has objected to giving evidence about the incident in the Federal Court on the grounds he might incriminate himself.
Person 4, who was medically discharged from the SAS last year, started giving evidence on Monday in Mr Roberts-Smith's defamation case against The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times.
He has already told the court he witnessed Mr Roberts-Smith kick an unarmed and handcuffed Afghan man off a cliff in Darwan in late 2012, before the man was shot dead.
But Person 4, whose name cannot be revealed for national security reasons, objected to answering a question on Monday by the newspapers' barrister, Nicholas Owens, SC, about his recollection of events during a separate mission in Afghanistan on Easter Sunday, 2009. Justice Anthony Besanko did not compel him to answer the question.
The court has previously heard evidence from a serving SAS soldier that Mr Roberts-Smith told Person 4 during the 2009 mission to shoot a captive Afghan man who had been discovered in a tunnel in a compound known as Whiskey 108.
"RS … walked down and grabbed the Afghan male by the scruff of the shirt, picked him up, marched him a couple of metres forward [until] he was in front of Person 4," the serving soldier, dubbed Person 41, said in early February.
"He then kicked him in the back of the legs behind the knees until he was kneeling down in front of Person 4. He pointed to the [Afghan man] … and said to Person 4, 'Shoot him.'"
Person 41 said he heard but did not see the shots being fired, because he did not want to look. Shortly after he heard the shots, he saw a "dead Afghan male" at the feet of Person 4, Person 41 said.
On Monday, Mr Owens asked Person 4 if he would tell the court what he recalled happened at Whiskey 108.
"Your honour, I object on the grounds that I may incriminate myself," Person 4 said.
On Tuesday, one of Mr Roberts-Smith's barristers, Arthur Moses, SC, returned to the subject in cross-examination.
"You're aware, are you not, that the respondents in this case have alleged that you murdered an unarmed Afghan male on 12 April, 2009, correct?" Mr Moses said.
Justice Besanko compelled him to answer the question, and Person 4 agreed he was aware of that allegation. However, he objected to giving any evidence about the alleged incident.
Mr Roberts-Smith launched defamation proceedings in 2018 over a series of articles that he says accuse him of being a war criminal, among other claims.
He denies all wrongdoing. The media outlets are seeking to rely on a defence of truth and allege Mr Roberts-Smith committed or was involved in six murders of Afghans under the control of Australian troops, when they cannot be killed under the rules of engagement.
Another serving SAS soldier, Person 14, told the court earlier this month that he heard Person 5, the commander of Person 4's patrol, say in front of SAS troops at their Tarin Kowt base before the Whiskey 108 mission that he was going to "blood the rookie".
Asked what he understood that to mean, Person 14 said it referred to a new member of the troop getting a "kill". He believed the "rookie" was Person 4.
Mr Owens asked: "Was Mr Roberts-Smith present on that occasion?"
"Yes," Person 14 replied. The court has heard Mr Roberts-Smith was second-in-charge of the patrol led by Person 5.
Person 14 said he heard Person 5 say after the Easter Sunday mission: "I finally blooded the rookie."
The trial continues.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/former-soldier-objects-to-answering-questions-on-alleged-murder-in-Ben-Roberts-Smith-case-20220301-p5a0kl.html
#15743221 at 2022-02-28 06:33:53 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Ben Roberts-Smith kicked an unarmed and handcuffed man off a cliff, says witness
Michaela Whitbourn - February 28, 2022
1/2
Warning: This report contains graphic content.
A former elite soldier has told the Federal Court that war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith kicked an unarmed and handcuffed man off a cliff before coaching him on the story he should tell about the man's death.
Person 4, a former Special Air Service soldier, gave evidence in Mr Roberts-Smith's defamation case on Monday that he witnessed the decorated soldier kick the cuffed man off a cliff in Darwan, Afghanistan, in 2012, causing the man to sustain a "serious facial injury" when his face hit a rock.
The man's collision with the rock "knocked out a number of his teeth including his front teeth", Person 4 said. The man had then attempted to sit up with his hands still tied but "fell back down again". Person 4 said Mr Roberts-Smith, who was then a patrol commander, instructed him and another soldier, Person 11, to drag the man's body across a dry creek bed towards a large tree.
"At that point the individual was placed down. I moved off a distance. Ben Roberts-Smith and Person 11 had a quick conversation," Person 4 said. "As I moved off and the conversation had started, I quickly turned around and the individual was standing."
Person 4, who cannot be identified for national security reasons, said the man was still handcuffed. "A number of shots rang out … two to three rounds," he said.
He said that he saw Person 11 "still" had his rifle raised in a firing position after he heard shots fired. The shots sounded like they came from an M4 assault rifle, he said, and he was "fairly certain" Person 11 had an M4. He told the court that Mr Roberts-Smith, standing nearby, had an M4.
Under the rules of engagement under which Australian troops operated in Afghanistan, which are consistent with the Geneva Conventions, a person under the control (PUC) of Australian troops cannot be killed, and to kill a person in these circumstances is murder.
Person 4 said Person 11 took photographs of the Afghan man's body, and he saw that a radio known as an ICOM was positioned next to him. He said that to his knowledge the man had not had an ICOM.
The ICOM was "slightly wet" with a "fogged-up" screen, Person 4 said, and it "dawned on" him that he believed the radio came from another Afghan man Mr Roberts-Smith had pursued across the Helmand River before the alleged incident.
(continued)
#15727125 at 2022-02-26 09:56:33 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15727122
2/2
The Office of the Special Investigator was set up in January last year in part to try to resolve this problem, or, as its Director-General Chris Moraitis put it, to "triage" the work of the Brereton inquiry.
It has since spent 14 months quietly building up some of the most formidable investigation teams in the country, drawing on 54 specialist investigators and analysts - 16 seconded from the AFP and 36 from state police forces - led by two commanders.
If ever there are to be criminal prosecutions of Australian soldiers for misdeeds in Afghanistan, it will be because of the work of the Office of the Special Investigator.
Its leadership team is highly experienced, comprising Moraitis, who is a former head of the Attorney-General's Department, and Special Investigator Mark Weinberg, QC, a former judge and onetime Commonwealth director of public prosecutions.
Rounding out the leadership team is Ross Barnett, a former deputy commissioner of the Queensland Police Service. Together with 25 support staff, the agency now has a total of 84 people working for it, with a budget of just over $40 million.
O'Brien says the creation of the Office of the Special Investigator makes Australia unique among its allies, and that no other nations which served alongside in Afghanistan have launched similar inquiries.
"We really are a pack leader in terms of probing whether our own soldiers have committed such crimes," she says.
"It's a highly effective way of doing it, taking it outside the military to ensure that it is independent. The reason the government has created a separate office is because of the complexity of war crimes investigations, the complexity of the situations in which they occur, and also the sheer amount of evidence that is required to prove these kinds of crimes."
The authorities have known this trial was coming for 3? years and could have asked the Federal Court to delay the defamation case while their investigations are under way. But no application was ever made, leaving the newspapers to call more than 20 soldiers as witnesses to defend their stories about the Brereton inquiry.
Moraitis says his organisation is operating in a "complex legal landscape". He has also damped down expectations that its processes will be quick, warning "we must take the time to get this right".
That means, he warns, a "measured, methodical and precautionary" approach, delivering potential suspects "all the protections provided by the Australian criminal justice system" while ensuring "the integrity and robustness of our investigations and any future prosecutions".
In other words, it could be years before the work of the Office of the Special Investigator lands any soldiers in court, says O'Brien.
"These would be serious charges. You don't want to go to trial with insufficient evidence and find that, if someone has committed a war crime, they get away with it because the case was not put together well enough," O'Brien says.
As for the relevance, if any, of the Roberts-Smith defamation case, the Office of the Special Investigator is remaining silent.
"The defamation action brought by Mr Ben Roberts-Smith in the Federal Court of Australia is a civil matter between the parties and it would not be appropriate to comment further," a spokesperson told this masthead.
In Senate committee hearings a week ago, Moraitis told MPs that the case is "a private matter ... [and] to date, we don't think that it has impacted adversely on our work".
But O'Brien says: "I have no doubt they will be keeping a very close eye on the Roberts-Smith defamation trial."
A judgment won't be reached in the case until at least the end of this year. Then there could be an appeal, from whichever side is the loser. A long road remains ahead in this high-stakes legal contest.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/a-vigilant-commonwealth-keeps-watchful-eyes-on-the-Roberts-Smith-case-20220224-p59zg3.html
#15727122 at 2022-02-26 09:56:01 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
A vigilant Commonwealth keeps watchful eyes on the Roberts-Smith case
Deborah Snow - February 26, 2022
1/2
There's an elephant in the courtroom in the Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case, rarely alluded to in the media coverage.
It's the Commonwealth government, which has been keeping a vigilant eye on proceedings from day one.
It has its own team of two, sometimes three barristers, sitting every day behind the front row reserved for Roberts-Smith's senior counsel and the barristers for The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age.
And every so often, the court is reminded of the elephant's presence, when the quietly spoken lead barrister for the Commonwealth, Kristina Stern, SC, gets to her feet, asking presiding Justice Anthony Besanko to suppress the accidentally mentioned name of a soldier (whose identities are meant to be kept secret), or to steer the evidence away from sensitive national security information.
There's a third topic the Commonwealth has declared off-limits: any question to military witnesses about what they might or might not have told the government's secretive war crimes investigation teams.
Those investigations are being conducted well out of public view, by a little-known body called the Office of the Special Investigator, of which more shortly.
The media outlets have chosen to mount a defence of truth in the case, alleging Roberts-Smith committed or was party to six unlawful killings of Afghan males who were unarmed or "persons under control" (that is, not posing a threat) at the time of their deaths.
Roberts-Smith has strongly denied this, saying the deaths occurred in combat and were lawful under Australian army rules of engagement. Such are the basic dynamics that have led to a defamation case, conducted in a civil court, morphing into what many consider to be a de facto war crimes trial.
It's an unprecedented spectacle, says Dr Melanie O'Brien, an international law specialist from the University of Western Australia.
"This has made news around the world" she tells this masthead. "It's absolutely extraordinary to see this playing out in a defamation trial. Those of us in this field in academia are just watching it with our mouths agape because we just can't believe that so much is being said so openly in this kind of [civil] case."
There are, of course, other dimensions to the Roberts-Smith trial that have nothing to do with the fate of Afghan detainees. There are the accusations of bullying and intimidation against some other SAS soldiers, and Roberts-Smith's alleged striking of his former lover, all of which he has forcefully denied.
Another facet of the case was drawn into the light on Wednesday, as the court heard evidence from private investigator, John McLeod, once a trusted gofer for Roberts-Smith, about envelopes he says the Victoria Cross recipient asked him to post. Unbeknown to McLeod (he says), the envelopes contained threatening letters to at least one other SAS member. Roberts-Smith has denied any knowledge of the missives.
But it's the alleged events in Afghanistan that have generated the most headlines.
Thus far, the court has heard from half-a-dozen soldiers, called as witnesses by the media outlets. There are a dozen more to come. Soldiers giving evidence for Roberts-Smith will start to be heard from mid-March.
There have been vivid descriptions of battles, SAS operating procedures, tactics and feats of endurance, and the laying bare of rivalries and grievances between soldiers.
The federal agencies keeping closest watch are the Defence Department, the Australian Federal Police, the Attorney-General and the new body, the Office of the Special Investigator.
The Office of the Special Investigator had its roots in the report of Justice Paul Brereton, released after a four-and-a-half year inquiry in November 2020 conducted under the auspices of the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force.
The Brereton report rocked the country with its conclusion that there was "credible information" of serious war crimes having been committed by up to 25 current or former ADF personnel, though none of the suspects were named.
But because Brereton's findings were the result of an inquiry conducted as part of the military justice system, not a criminal investigation, there was a limit on how they could be used.
Specifically, some information had been compelled from soldiers who were given protection from self-incrimination, meaning portions of it were never going to be admissible in criminal proceedings.
(continued)
#15708130 at 2022-02-24 08:58:25 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Ben Roberts-Smith told another soldier in Afghanistan 'I just want to kill', court hears
Serving officer in Australian Defence Force tells defamation trial Roberts-Smith showed photos of dead insurgents on his iPod
Ben Doherty - 24 Feb 2022
1/2
Ben Roberts-Smith told another soldier "I just want to kill cunts" while on deployment in Afghanistan, and had pictures of slain insurgents on an iPod during training, the federal court has heard.
A former SAS soldier, now an officer still serving in the Australian Defence Force, was subpoenaed to give evidence to Roberts-Smith's defamation hearing this week. He was anonymised before the court as Person Two.
Roberts-Smith is suing the Age, the Sydney Morning Herald and the Canberra Times over reports he alleges are defamatory and portray him as committing war crimes, including murder, as well as acts of bullying and domestic violence.
The newspapers are pleading a defence of truth. Roberts-Smith denies any wrongdoing.
Person Two was a witness for the newspapers.
He told the court he was posted alongside Roberts-Smith on "picket duty" in a big bunker area during deployment in Afghanistan in 2006.
Person Two said Roberts-Smith told him: "I just want to kill cunts. I don't give a fuck, I just want to kill cunts."
Person Two also testified that sitting on a bus following a parachute training course in Australia, Roberts-Smith pulled out an iPod, leaned over the seat of another soldier, and said "hey check this out".
He then allegedly showed the other soldiers photographs of "dead insurgents" on the device.
Person Two was a member of Roberts-Smith's patrol in 2006, including for a mission on a mountain called Koran Ghar above the Chora Pass in Afghanistan's Uruzgan province.
The five-man patrol had carried 60kg packs to the top of the mountain during a 10-hour overnight climb to set up an observation post, watching over the valley, which was to be the scene of an allied assault.
On the second day of the observation mission, Person Two and another soldier spotted a young Afghan male - "about 14 or 15 years old", Person Two told the court - walking on a goat-track, near to the observation post.
He said the teenager was not armed with a weapon, nor carrying a radio or wearing webbing. Person Two said he did not believe the young man had seen the Australian soldiers and so did not open fire on him.
Person Two told the court Roberts-Smith and another soldier, Sergeant Matt Locke, came down to the observation post from another position and berated the soldiers on lookout duty, saying "'why the fuck didn't you shoot him?".
"I said 'because we're in an observation post'."
Person Two explained to the court: "The task for the mission was to observe and surveil ... not to become decisively engaged. That was to be avoided at all costs, because it then affects your ability to complete your larger mission."
The court heard Roberts-Smith and Locke ran off after the teenager. Person Two said "about a minute later, two minutes later, I heard four or five shots, a suppressed M4 and a suppressed SR 25". Those were the two weapons carried by Roberts-Smith and Locke, Person Two told the court.
(continued)
#15697917 at 2022-02-23 07:45:48 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
'Weak dog': Private eye turns on Ben Roberts-Smith in court
PERRY DUFFIN - FEBRUARY 23, 2022
1/3
Ben Roberts-Smith's former private eye has told a court he triggered a police investigation into an "unhinged" SAS soldier, surveilled a woman as she allegedly faked an abortion and dressed as a bartender to spy on network Seven employees all on behalf of Mr Roberts-Smith.
The relationship came to an end, the private investigator told the court, after he called Mr Roberts-Smith a "weak dog" for compromising him in an alleged plot to threaten former SAS soldiers.
Private eye and former policeman John McLeod has denied leaking to the media after the court heard he was closely communicating with Mr Roberts-Smith's detractors who are accused of feeding private information to journalists.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing Nine and its journalists over a series of articles claiming he committed war crimes in Afghanistan, bullied his squadmates and abused his "mistress".
Mr Roberts-Smith has denied every allegation, saying he only killed enemy combatants within the rules of war, did not cheat on his wife and he abhors domestic violence.
THE PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR
High profile private investigator John McLeod, a former fixer for Mr Roberts-Smith, was called to give evidence in the defamation trial on Wednesday.
Mr McLeod told the court he met Mr Roberts-Smith and his wife, Emma Roberts, while working security for a five-star hotel in Brisbane.
Mr McLeod became a fixer for Mr Roberts-Smith, running errands and organising mundane elements of their lives like concert tickets and repairs to their new home in Queensland.
In recent years Mr McLeod has turned against Mr Roberts-Smith and was in recent contact with the SAS veteran's ex wife - and had been accused of leaking to Nine.
GREENSLOPES SURVEILLANCE
By the start of 2018, Mr Roberts-Smith has told the court, his marriage was on the rocks and he was dating a woman known as Person 17.
Nine claims Mr Roberts-Smith was still with his wife at the time and punched Person 17 after they had gone to a ritzy VIP party in Canberra and the woman drunkenly embarrassed herself.
The court has heard Person 17 had travelled to Brisbane for an abortion after telling Mr Roberts-Smith she was carrying his child.
Mr McLeod told the court Mr Roberts-Smith sent him to surveille the woman as she went to Greenslopes clinic for the termination.
Person 17 did not show up at the airport or the clinic but Mr McLeod said he eventually found her at the nearby Greenslopes hospital - which he said does not perform abortions.
Mr McLeod told the court he filmed Person 17, who looked like "a normal woman", coming out of the hospital and sent the video to Mr Roberts-Smith.
Mr Roberts-Smith, in his evidence last year, told the court Person 17 met him in a hotel room minutes later and confessed she did not have an abortion at Greenslopes.
She had the abortion earlier, she allegedly told Mr Roberts-Smith, and he ended the volatile relationship.
"She started to cry and said 'I didn't have the procedure, I had the procedure up in Townsville'," Mr Roberts-Smith told the court in June 2021.
"I said Townville doesn't have a clinic. She said 'I had a miscarriage' so now I had three stories as to what was going on."
"(It) gave me great concern that I was being manipulated so I'd stay in the relationship."
Mr McLeod told the court he invoiced Mr Roberts-Smith $1500 for the job.
(continued)
#15689163 at 2022-02-22 07:39:21 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Former soldier tells court Ben Roberts-Smith ordered mock execution of unarmed prisoner during training exercise
Jamie McKinnell - 22 February 2022
A former elite soldier has told a Sydney court Ben Roberts-Smith surprised colleagues when he ordered the mock execution of an unarmed prisoner during a training exercise.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age, The Canberra Times and three journalists in the Federal Court over a series of 2018 articles.
The Victoria Cross recipient argues he was defamed by false allegations in those stories of unlawful killings, bullying and domestic violence, while publisher Nine Entertainment is seeking to establish a truth defence.
A former colleague, anonymised in court as Person 19 and called by Nine, today recalled a 2012 pre-deployment training exercise in Lancelin involving an assault at a mock Afghan village.
He said another colleague, Person 9, was among soldiers playing the role of villager or civilian and was kneeling on the ground in Afghan robes towards the end of the exercise.
Person 19 said Mr Roberts-Smith directed another member of the patrol, Person 10, to "shoot the PUC (Person Under Confinement)".
"I remember that distinctly because it was unusual," the witness said.
"I remember seeing the look on Person 9's face, they were quite surprised as well, no-one had expected to hear that phrase."
Person 19 said he recalled Person 10 then "saying bang" or shooting at the ground.
The witness recalled another training exercise at Bindoon, also involving an assault on a mock compound.
He said there was a discussion about "sensitive site exploitation", the process of searching a scene to gather intelligence.
Person 19 claimed Mr Roberts-Smith told colleagues: "Any people we suspected of being enemy combatants, we'd take them into a room and shoot the c*nts".
He told the court that either Mr Roberts-Smith or another member of the patrol, Person 35, then discussed the prospect of a "throw down", where a weapon could be placed on a body and "submitted as evidence that they were killed in the conduct of the assault."
This would mean they would "be deemed an enemy combatant," the witness said.
The court heard Person 19 was removed from the patrol days before deployment as a result of disciplinary action, after he left body armour and a plastic bag of ammunition in his car, which was later stolen.
The witness said the car was involved in an accident, leading to a military investigation and charges of losing service property and prejudicial behaviour.
He spent 32 days in defence force jail in September and October 2013, the court heard.
Person 19 also admitted to a "gross error of judgement" by making a false declaration on a form that his girlfriend wasn't living with him, for which he was dismissed in 2014 after pleading guilty to recklessly gaining financial advantage.
Under cross-examination by Arthur Moses SC, for Mr Roberts-Smith, Person 19 admitted he initially asserted he didn't know the ammunition was in the car.
He agreed he was "quite upset" and "disappointed" about not being deployed, describing his errors as "silly" and costing him a 14-year career.
"Is it the case that you harbour anger towards [Mr Roberts-Smith] because he had to raise matters about the ammunition in your vehicle with the unit?" Mr Moses asked.
"No," the witness replied.
Person 19 told the court when he first reported the issue to Mr Roberts-Smith, the veteran replied: "Don't say anything about this and it will go away".
The trial, before Justice Anthony Besanko, continues.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-02-22/Ben-Roberts-Smith-trial-mock-execution-training-exercise/100850172
#15680825 at 2022-02-21 08:13:00 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Army officer tells Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial VC recipient threatened to 'smash his face in'
Jamie McKinnell - 21 February 2022
A senior army officer has told a Sydney court he was left "in shock" when his subordinate, Ben Roberts-Smith, threatened to "smash his face in" at an unofficial soldiers' bar in Afghanistan.
Mr Roberts-Smith, a Victoria Cross recipient, is suing three newspapers and three journalists for defamation, claiming 2018 articles contained false allegations of unlawful killings, bullying and domestic violence.
A witness known as Person 69 today told the Federal Court of his 2006 deployment to Afghanistan where he worked in an operational support role.
Person 69 recalled his understanding of a difficult mission where Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) operators in Mr Roberts-Smith's patrol were "surrounded" by Taliban fighters in the Chora Valley.
The witness, at that time a captain, later attended the Fat Ladies Arms bar with two warrant officers and overheard SAS operators discussing the mission.
He told the court he heard Mr Roberts-Smith say words to the effect of: "I was watching the expression on the guy's face as the bullets crept closer."
Person 69 said he looked over his shoulder towards Mr Roberts-Smith, then a lance corporal, who was sitting about a metre away.
"He saw me, turned to me, and said 'what the f*ck are you doing here … I should smash your face in'," Person 69 told the court.
"I was in shock because I had never been spoken to that way by a subordinate.
"I didn't really know what to say."
Person 69 said one of the warrant officers warned Mr Roberts-Smith to "pull your f*cking head in", while the other gave a "menacing stare".
"I decided it would be best I left and I never returned."
Person 69 said he had only ever been threatened three times during his career by his own team and remembered each occasion.
"It has a profound impact on me that my own team would threaten me," he said.
Under cross-examination by Bruce McClintock SC, Person 69 said he didn't report the matter because he believed it had been dealt with by the warrant officers.
He rejected Mr McClintock's suggestions the conversation never happened.
"It's ludicrous to think of a lance corporal saying that to a captain, isn't it?" Mr McClintock said.
"That's why I remember it," the witness replied.
The alleged conversation was put to Mr Roberts-Smith in the witness box last year, where he rejected that he made the comments or was reprimanded.
Person 69 also claimed earlier that day, in his accommodation, he overheard a junior trooper who was "upset and emotional" complaining of being "ostracised" by his patrol after his weapon jammed on the battlefield.
The court has previously heard that solider, Person 1, forgot oil for his machine gun on the mission.
"I'd never worked with the Australian SAS before and I was shocked they weren't a collegiate team," Person 69 told the court.
"I had worked with other special forces and they seemed to help people who were making mistakes."
The trial, before Justice Anthony Besanko, will resume on Tuesday.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-02-21/Ben-Roberts-Smith-trial-hears-from-army-officer/100848750
#15656298 at 2022-02-18 10:33:21 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Soldier tells court he didn't 'fabricate' Ben Roberts-Smith death threats
Jamie McKinnell - 18 February 2022
An elite soldier who's told a Sydney court decorated war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith bullied him for years has denied blaming others to avoid confronting his own failings.
Codenamed Person 1, the witness was called by publisher Nine Entertainment in its defence of Mr Roberts-Smith's Federal Court defamation case over 2018 newspaper articles.
The Victoria Cross recipient claims the articles included false allegations of bullying of his Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) colleagues, unlawful killings in Afghanistan and domestic violence.
Person 1 has claimed Mr Roberts-Smith twice threatened to kill him, including during a 2006 deployment where he said words to the effect of: "If your performance doesn't improve on the next patrol, you're gonna get a bullet in the back of the head."
The soldier accepted the "elementary" and "basic" mistake of forgetting machine gun oil during a June 2006 mission in the Chora Valley put the lives of his entire team at risk due to weapon stoppages while under enemy attack.
Under cross-examination, Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister Bruce McClintock SC today highlighted assessments from three of Person 1's senior colleagues in 2006 that suggested he be removed from the patrol for his own safety and that of others.
Those criticisms "must have had a devastating effect", Mr McClintock suggested.
"I don't recall my feelings after reading these reports," Person 1 replied.
Mr McClintock said those colleagues, including the late Sergeant Matt Locke, had "justifiable doubts" about going on patrol with him after the Chora Valley mission.
Person 1 agreed, further accepting Mr Roberts-Smith might not have wanted to be in a position where the witness would put his life at risk again.
But he denied he'd come up with bullying allegations against Mr Roberts-Smith and two others to deal with the assessments.
"You couldn't confront the reality of your failings and you tried to blame them on other people," Mr McClintock said.
"That's incorrect," Person 1 replied, adding that he had taken accountability.
Mr McClintock showed the witness a 2013 statement he wrote raising the bullying allegations about Mr Roberts-Smith, which did not record the specific "bullet in your head" phrase Person 1 has attributed to the veteran.
"The encounter is listed, but the words specifically used weren't," Person 1 said.
The document recorded that Mr Roberts-Smith had "burst" into a team room one day and accused Person 1 of not being up to his standard for the SAS.
It recorded Mr Roberts-Smith as saying "on the next job I may get shot if my performance doesn't improve".
Mr McClintock put it to Person 1 that Mr Roberts-Smith's comment was consistent with a warning that Person 1 may be shot by the enemy.
"My client never said anything to you beyond 'if you don't improve you're going to be in trouble out there and you'll be in danger'," he said.
Person 1 disagreed and denied "fabricating" the alleged death threat.
Mr McClintock suggested things Mr Roberts-Smith said to the witness in 2006 were no more than expressions of professional opinion that Person 1 had failings as a soldier at that time.
"It's absurd to characterise any of the things my client said as genuine death threats," the barrister said.
"That's incorrect," Person 1 replied.
The trial, before Justice Anthony Besanko, will continue on Monday.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-02-18/Ben-Roberts-Smith-sas-soldier-denies-fabricating-bullying-claims/100843002
#15648230 at 2022-02-17 08:04:29 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial told of 'bullet in the head' threat
RYAN YOUNG - FEBRUARY 17, 2022
1/2
Decorated Australian war hero Ben Roberts-Smith told a soldier if his performance did not improve he would "get a bullet in the back of the head", a court has been told.
The ex-SAS soldier, who can only be referred to as Person 1 for legal reasons, made the claims at Mr Robert-Smith's defamation trial, which continued in the Federal Court on Thursday.
A distinguished Victoria Cross recipient, Mr Roberts-Smith, 43, is suing Nine and its journalists over reports that he claims were defamatory because they alleged he committed war crimes and murders in Afghanistan between 2006 and 2012.
When questioned by Nine's barrister Nicholas Owens SC, Person 1 said Mr Roberts-Smith was among a group of soldiers who subjected him to poor treatment.
"Members of the team would make disparaging remarks to me about my lack of experience," Person 1 told the court.
"There certainly was a negative attitude towards me ... I was from a reserve background and the rest of the members were from an army background with significantly more experience than me."
When Person 1 and Mr Roberts-Smith were undertaking training at Lancelin, north of Perth, before being deployed to Afghanistan, the court was told of multiple alleged slapping incidents.
"I was driving ... on a regular basis, as we would drive over the rocky off-road terrain. If I hit something, a rather large bump, the applicant (Mr Roberts-Smith) would reach down and slap me across the back of the head," Person 1 said.
"The applicant said to me that he didn't think I had the required skills or ability to deploy to Afghanistan with the task group.
"He also said that he was gonna (sic) do everything he could within his power to have me removed from the team and to get one of his colleagues to replace me."
Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Bruce McClintock SC, objected to numerous questions Mr Owens put to Person 1, claiming they were not previously put to Mr Roberts-Smith when he was in the witness box last year.
Despite the objections, Justice Anthony Besanko allowed most of the questions to be asked.
Person 1 recalled an incident while serving alongside Mr Roberts-Smith in Afghanistan's Chora Valley in 2006.
Person 1 said while manning an observation post involving secret surveillance, a man aged about 15 to 20 was spotted coming out from behind nearby rocks.
"He was a male, he had facial hair and he was wearing the traditional Afghan dress," Person 1 said.
"He was just walking. I observed he had a satchel bag ... I didn't observe it the first time he walked across, I only observed it the second time."
Person 1 said the Afghani man did not appear to have a weapon and because an observation post (OP) was being manned, "the idea was to not compromise yourself" by engaging in unnecessary conflict that could expose the OP.
Afterwards, the court was told that Sergeant Matthew Locke, who was second in command of the mission and died while serving in 2007, and Mr Roberts-Smith "engaged" the individual.
"I heard the shots from their engagement," Person 1 said.
"He (Sergeant Locke) mentioned that when they engaged the individual he had some sort of device on him ... they didn't know whether it was a flair or smoke."
No smoke or flair was observed by Person 1, the court was told.
(continued)
#15640446 at 2022-02-16 09:30:59 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
>>15600712
Ben Roberts-Smith trial: soldier tells court at least two men pulled from tunnel in Afghanistan compound
Events at the compound on 12 April, 2009 have emerged as central to the defamation trial brought by Roberts-Smith
Ben Doherty - 16 Feb 2022
A serving SAS soldier has told a court that at least two men were pulled from a tunnel inside a compound being raided by Australian SAS troops during a 2009 clearance operation in Afghanistan, a mission that has since become a key element of the defamation trial brought by Ben Roberts-Smith.
Roberts-Smith is suing the Age, the Sydney Morning Herald and the Canberra Times for defamation over a series of ?reports he alleges are defamatory and portray him as committing war crimes, including murder. The newspapers are pleading a defence of truth. Roberts-Smith denies any wrongdoing.
Anonymised before the federal court as Person 42, the Warrant Officer Class 2 and veteran of more than two decades' military service appeared in court as a witness for the Nine newspapers' defence.
Person 42 told the court he and other soldiers discovered the hidden tunnel during the raid on a compound called Whiskey 108. The soldiers called out in Pashto for anyone hiding inside to come out.
"They came out unarmed, they came out freely, they came out relatively quickly once we gave them the commands," he said.
Person 42 said he took custody of one of the men and patted him down to ensure he was unarmed before passing him to the control of another soldier. He did not see the man again.
The events at Whiskey 108 on 12 April 2009 - and the presence or otherwise of men in the tunnel - have emerged as central to the allegations made against Roberts-Smith in the newspapers' defence of the defamation claim. Roberts-Smith is a Victoria Cross winner and one of Australia's most decorated soldiers.
Roberts-Smith has been accused in the course of the newspapers' defence of ordering the execution an elderly Afghan man and murdering another man who had a prosthetic leg, both of whom had been taken from the tunnel in the compound. Roberts-Smith denies the allegations and says there was no one discovered in the tunnel.
Two other soldiers have previously given evidence in the trial on behalf of the newspapers about the alleged executions of the two men at Whiskey 108.
One soldier, Person 41, told the court Roberts-Smith and another soldier borrowed his suppressor which was then used in the execution of the elderly man. Person 41 also said he later saw Roberts-Smith "frogmarch" the man with a prosthetic leg outside a village compound, throw him to the ground and machine-gun him to death.
Another soldier, Person 14, said he saw an Australian soldier carrying a distinctive weapon, a Minimi machine gun, throw a human-shaped object to the ground and fire a burst of bullets into it. He said he later saw Roberts-Smith carrying a Minimi during that mission.
Roberts-Smith has consistently denied those versions of events, describing them as "completely false". In his evidence last year, he said he never ordered an elderly man shot, and says he killed the man with a prosthetic leg outside Whiskey 108 because the man was a legitimate target, armed and running away, and was killed in accordance with troops' rules of engagement.
He said no people were taken out of the tunnel in the compound.
"There were no people in the tunnel at Whiskey 108," he told the court.
Whiskey 108 was a compound in the village of Kakarak, known as an insurgent stronghold, on the western side of the Dorafshan River in Uruzgan province and near an allied forward operating base.
In court on Wednesday, Person 42 said Whiskey 108 had been bombed by allied aircraft ahead of the Australian troops' mission to 'clear' the compound on 12 April 2009, checking for insurgents, weapons, and bomb-making materials.
They found some weapons, ammunition and grenades, but "there were no enemy combatants found as part of the assault", he said.
Shown pictures of the bodies of the men allegedly killed during the raid on Whiskey 108, Person 42 said he was unable to positively identify them.
Under cross-examination, he said Australian troops discovered the tunnel after being alerted to it by women, and possibly children, who were in the compound.
Arthur Moses SC, acting for Roberts-Smith, put it to Person 42 that his evidence was not true "because you weren't there".
"That is not true," the soldier replied.
The trial before Justice Anthony Besanko continues.
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2022/feb/16/Ben-Roberts-Smith-trial-soldier-tells-court-at-least-two-men-pulled-from-tunnel-in-afghanistan-compound
#15600712 at 2022-02-11 12:12:33 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
Ben Roberts-Smith described alleged execution of Afghan teen as 'beautiful thing', court hears
Jamie McKinnell - 11 February 2022
1/2
Australian war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith referred to the alleged execution of an Afghan teenager as "the most beautiful thing I've ever seen", an elite soldier has told a Sydney court.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times newspapers and three journalists for defamation over a series of articles published in 2018.
The Victoria Cross recipient denies allegations in those stories of unlawful killings in Afghanistan, bullying of his former Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) comrades and domestic violence.
The third SAS witness called by publisher Nine Entertainment, code named Person 16, told the Federal Court the comment about the young man's death occurred during a 2012 mission in Afghanistan.
Mr Roberts-Smith has denied making the remark.
Person 16 said soon after arriving by helicopter, soldiers intercepted a Toyota Hilux and he placed two of its four occupants under confinement.
He described one as being in his "late teens", without a full beard, "a little bit chubby" and "shaking in terror".
"He appeared extremely nervous and trembling uncontrollably," the witness told the court.
Person 16 said he heard a radio call that improvised explosive device components were discovered in the vehicle and handed the two detained Afghans to Mr Roberts-Smith's patrol for tactical questioning.
Person 16 said about 15 to 20 minutes later he heard Mr Roberts-Smith make a radio call stating: "Two EKIA (enemy killed in action)".
He said he crossed paths with Mr Roberts-Smith in the barracks a day or two later and asked what happened to "that young fella that was shaking like a leaf".
"He said to me 'I shot that c*nt in the head'," Person 16 told the judge.
"And he said, 'Person 15 (another colleague) told me not to kill anyone on the last job, so I pulled out my 9mil, shot the c*nt in the side of the head, blew his brains out, and it was the most beautiful thing I've ever seen'."
Person 16 said he never reported what he claims Mr Roberts-Smith said due to a "code of silence within the regiment as to these things occurring".
"The fear of retribution, it would have been a career-ending move," he told the court.
"I would have been ostracised.
"I also think [for] my personal safety, I would have been in danger by making such allegations against someone so influential, so I thought I just, best keep quiet and move on with life."
(continued)
#15592250 at 2022-02-10 08:42:02 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #21: MIL-CIV ALLIANCE Edition
#20 - Part 4
Malka Leifer Extradition and Prosecution
>>15434839 Malka Leifer's father-in-law arrested over child sex assault allegations - Baruch Pinchas Leifer, the rabbi father-in-law of accused child sex abuser Malka Leifer arrested for allegedly sexually assaulting a child and a teenager in Israel
>>15481355 Ya'acov Litzman, former Israeli Deputy Health Minister cuts plea deal with Israeli Attorney-General over Malka Leifer case. Former minister had been suspected of having used his influence to prioritize the interests of private individuals over the needs of the general public
>>15481360 Israel's Litzman Admits to Breach of Trust in Malka Leifer Affair, to Pay $940 - Former deputy health minister signed a plea deal in case that saw him accused of using his influence to help keep alleged child rapist from being extradited to Australia
>>15534519 Australian Jewish communal leaders urge Israeli Court to reject Yaakov Litzman plea deal
#20 - Part 5
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial
>>15190238 Ben Roberts-Smith wins access to private emails between lawyers defending three newspapers accused of defaming him
>>15427303 Ben Roberts-Smith loses case against ex-wife over allegations she accessed confidential emails, court orders he pay costs
>>15456117 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial to resume next week, despite WA border issues - January 25, 2022
>>15525427 Ben Roberts-Smith shot Afghan captive in the back, SAS member tells defamation trial
>>15534448 SAS soldier accused of 'lying' after telling court Ben Roberts-Smith involved in two war crime killings
>>15542095 Second SAS soldier claims captured one-legged Afghan shot by Australian soldier Ben Roberts-Smith
>>15566381 SAS soldier denies 'rehearsing' damaging evidence about Roberts-Smith
>>15575208 Soldier harboured doubts about Roberts-Smith's VC honour, court told
#15592179 at 2022-02-10 08:21:39 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #20 - INSURGENCY Edition
#20 - Part 4
Malka Leifer Extradition and Prosecution
>>15434839 Malka Leifer's father-in-law arrested over child sex assault allegations - Baruch Pinchas Leifer, the rabbi father-in-law of accused child sex abuser Malka Leifer arrested for allegedly sexually assaulting a child and a teenager in Israel
>>15481355 Ya'acov Litzman, former Israeli Deputy Health Minister cuts plea deal with Israeli Attorney-General over Malka Leifer case. Former minister had been suspected of having used his influence to prioritize the interests of private individuals over the needs of the general public
>>15481360 Israel's Litzman Admits to Breach of Trust in Malka Leifer Affair, to Pay $940 - Former deputy health minister signed a plea deal in case that saw him accused of using his influence to help keep alleged child rapist from being extradited to Australia
>>15534519 Australian Jewish communal leaders urge Israeli Court to reject Yaakov Litzman plea deal
#20 - Part 5
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial
>>15190238 Ben Roberts-Smith wins access to private emails between lawyers defending three newspapers accused of defaming him
>>15427303 Ben Roberts-Smith loses case against ex-wife over allegations she accessed confidential emails, court orders he pay costs
>>15456117 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial to resume next week, despite WA border issues - January 25, 2022
>>15525427 Ben Roberts-Smith shot Afghan captive in the back, SAS member tells defamation trial
>>15534448 SAS soldier accused of 'lying' after telling court Ben Roberts-Smith involved in two war crime killings
>>15542095 Second SAS soldier claims captured one-legged Afghan shot by Australian soldier Ben Roberts-Smith
>>15566381 SAS soldier denies 'rehearsing' damaging evidence about Roberts-Smith
>>15575208 Soldier harboured doubts about Roberts-Smith's VC honour, court told
#15575217 at 2022-02-08 08:28:09 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #20 - INSURGENCY Edition
>>15575208
2/2
Person 14 agreed he did not know what material decision-makers had before them when awarding the honour to Mr Roberts-Smith.
"Do you resent the fact that Mr Roberts-Smith was awarded the VC?" Mr Moses asked. "No," Person 14 said.
"Do you resent the fact that he was awarded a VC in respect of a tour that you were held back from going on?" Mr Moses pressed. "No."
But Person 14 agreed "100 per cent" he was upset he could not go on that tour.
"You've come here to throw Mr Roberts-Smith under the bus any way you can, haven't you?" Mr Moses asked. "No," the SAS soldier replied.
The Age and the Herald, owned by Nine, and The Canberra Times, now under separate ownership, allege Mr Roberts-Smith committed or was involved in six murders of Afghans under the control of Australian troops, when they cannot be killed under the rules of engagement.
Mr Roberts-Smith maintains any killings in Afghanistan were carried out lawfully in the heat of battle.
Later on Tuesday, Justice Anthony Besanko prevented Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team questioning Person 14 about whether he had spoken to any journalist before 2019 about his period of service with the SAS in Afghanistan with Mr Roberts-Smith.
Members of the Defence Force may face criminal and disciplinary action for speaking to the media without authorisation.
"I will not require the witness to give the evidence," Justice Besanko said. He will publish his reasons at a later date.
Person 14 has said he witnessed Mr Roberts-Smith direct an interpreter in 2012 to tell a member of the Afghan Partner Force to kill an Afghan man they had been questioning, "or I will". The man was shot dead, he said.
The SAS soldier has also given evidence that he witnessed an unidentified Australian soldier in 2009 shoot a dark, human-like object with a distinctive machine gun that he later saw in the possession of Mr Roberts-Smith.
The soldier had camouflage paint or "campaint" on his face that was "the same, or similar, campaint style as Ben Roberts-Smith", he said.
Person 14 said he discovered on closer inspection that the dark object was an Afghan man with a prosthetic leg.
He agreed under cross-examination on Monday that he did not know if Mr Roberts-Smith was carrying the same weapon, but said he was carrying the same type of light machine gun.
The hearing continues.
https:// www.smh.com.au/ national/soldier-harboured-doubts-about-Roberts-Smith-s-vc-honour-court-told-20220208 -p59uov. html
#15575208 at 2022-02-08 08:26:06 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #20 - INSURGENCY Edition
>>15456117
Soldier harboured doubts about Roberts-Smith's VC honour, court told
Michaela Whitbourn - February 8, 2022
1/2
A Special Air Service soldier who has given damaging evidence about war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith has told the Federal Court he had doubts about the circumstances in which his former comrade received the Victoria Cross, but denied he was seeking to smear his reputation in court.
The serving soldier, dubbed Person 14, told the court on Tuesday he did not doubt Mr Roberts-Smith put his life in danger during a 2010 battle in Tizak, Afghanistan, for which he was awarded Australia's highest military honour in 2011, but he did have doubts about the award.
Person 14, whose identity cannot be revealed for national security reasons, was not in Afghanistan in 2010, but served alongside Mr Roberts-Smith in 2009 and 2012.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing for defamation over a series of news reports in 2018 he says portray him as a war criminal. Person 14 is the second member of the SAS to give evidence in the Federal Court in Sydney for The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times, as the news outlets seek to establish a defence of truth.
"Did the awarding of the Victoria Cross to Mr Roberts-Smith create division within the SAS?" Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Arthur Moses, SC, asked Person 14 on Tuesday.
"No. I was there for the investiture and it was a good day, actually," Person 14 said.
Person 14 has previously admitted he missed out on a deployment to Afghanistan in 2010, when the battle in Tizak took place, because of a disciplinary issue involving him losing possession of a hard drive containing work-related images. He told the court he self-reported the incident to the Defence Force.
Bruce McClintock, SC, one of a team of barristers acting for Mr Roberts-Smith, said during his opening address to the court last year that the soldier's reputation had been destroyed by a campaign led by "bitter people" in the SAS who were "aided by credulous journalists".
Asked on Tuesday if he had told Mr Roberts-Smith himself that he had his doubts about his Victoria Cross, Person 14 said: "No."
"You don't doubt that he put his life in danger?" Mr Moses asked. "No way," Person 14 replied.
"You're not here to second guess those who determined to award that Victoria Cross to Mr Roberts-Smith, are you?" Mr Moses said. "No," Person 14 replied.
(continued)
#15566381 at 2022-02-07 08:00:10 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #20 - INSURGENCY Edition
>>15456117
SAS soldier denies 'rehearsing' damaging evidence about Roberts-Smith
Michaela Whitbourn - February 7, 2022
1/2
A serving Special Air Service soldier has denied "rehearsing" damaging evidence about Ben Roberts-Smith before appearing in the Federal Court witness box in the war veteran's defamation case.
The soldier, known as Person 14 because he cannot be identified for national security reasons, was present on tours of Afghanistan with Mr Roberts-Smith in 2009 and 2012. He told the court on Friday he witnessed Mr Roberts-Smith tell an interpreter in 2012 to direct a member of the Afghan Partner Force to shoot an Afghan man they had been questioning, "or I will".
Person 14 said the interpreter "stumbled" verbally and "didn't relay" the order at first, before saying something in an "Afghan dialect". A member of the partner force then shot the Afghan man dead, he said.
Mr Roberts-Smith has previously given evidence that he gave no such direction.
Person 14 said he also witnessed a separate incident in 2009 in which an Australian soldier shot an Afghan man at close range with a "distinctive" machine gun, known as the F89 Para Minimi, that he later saw in the possession of Mr Roberts-Smith. "Not many" soldiers carried this light weapon, he said.
The SAS soldier said there were three Australian soldiers around the Afghan man, who appeared from his vantage point like "a black object which was … similar to a human" that was thrown to the ground. It was only on closer inspection that he realised it was an Afghan man with a prosthetic leg, he said.
Person 14 told the court he could not identify any of the three soldiers, although one of them had camouflage paint or "campaint" on his face that was "the same, or similar, campaint style as Ben Roberts-Smith".
He said on Friday he "saw who had the Minimi" after the mission was completed, and it was "Ben Roberts-Smith".
Mr Roberts-Smith has told the court that he did kill an Afghan man in 2009 who had a prosthetic leg, but he was an armed combatant who posed a threat.
Under cross-examination by Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Arthur Moses, SC, Person 14 denied on Monday that he had "rehearsed" his evidence last week.
Person 14 agreed there was "potentially" more than one Para Minimi machine gun carried by soldiers on the mission in 2009, and said there was usually "at least" one.
"You weren't meaning to suggest that the Para Minimi that you say [Mr Roberts-Smith] was carrying was the one that you say you heard made the noise in relation to the dark object?" Mr Moses said.
"No, I'm not suggesting that," Person 14 said.
"You don't know, do you?" Mr Moses said. "No," Person 14 replied. "I know he was carrying an F89 Para."
Asked if the human-like object he saw in 2009 was black or dark, he said on Monday it was "dark".
"Not black?" Mr Moses said. "You said black on Friday to His Honour." Person 14 said it was a dark object. He denied making up or lying about parts of his evidence.
(continued)
#15542095 at 2022-02-04 08:11:40 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #20 - INSURGENCY Edition
>>15456117
Second SAS soldier claims captured one-legged Afghan shot by Australian soldier
PERRY DUFFIN - FEBRUARY 4, 2022
A second SAS soldier has told a court he watched a captured Afghan thrown to the ground and killed with a burst of machine gun fire - and claimed the man later spotted carrying the weapon was decorated soldier Ben Roberts-Smith.
The SAS soldier, known only as Person 14, is the second member of the elite unit to testify against the Victoria Cross recipient in the defamation trial of the century in the Federal Court.
Mr Roberts-Smith has denied allegations by Nine newspapers that he either killed or was involved in the murders of six unarmed, captured Afghans during various missions while deployed.
He is suing the newspapers saying they falsely portrayed him as a war criminal and Nine, this week, has begun calling witnesses it says support the allegations.
Person 14 told the court he was the first soldier to advance on a series of suspected Taliban compounds known as Whiskey 108 and Whiskey 109 in April 2009.
He recounted trudging through water, over rickety bridges and through poppy fields under grey skies toward Whiskey 108 when "fighting age male" Afghans appeared.
The first Afghan male did not spot Person 14's SAS troupe and disappeared into the poppy fields - the second was not so fortunate and Person 14 shot him twice.
A bomb was dropped on the roof of Whiskey 108 before SAS assault teams stormed in to clear out the remaining combatants, the court has heard.
Person 14 said the last light was fading when he heard heavy footsteps stomping to his right.
"As I turned my head to my right, there were three Australian soldiers and a black object, which was similar to a human, that was thrown to the ground," Person 14 told the court on Friday.
Person 14 said the person thudded as they hit the ground and they made an "expulsion of air" noise that sounded as though they were winded.
"Then a soldier raised their Minimi F89 Para and fired an extended burst," Person 14 said, naming the "distinctive" machine gun carried by only some SAS troops.
"It was loud like BRRRRRT for one second."
"I was like okay, and that person turned and walked away out of sight back into Whiskey 108."
Person 14 told the court he couldn't tell who had just unloaded the machine gun into the Afghan as everyone was wet, in military uniform and with painted faces.
But, he told the court, he recognised the distinctive camouflage face paint of one particular SAS patrol.
"Later I saw who had the Para Minimi (machine gun)," Person 14 told the court.
"It was Ben Roberts-Smith."
Person 14 said he had put on his night vision goggles and looked down at the Afghan - he was older with short hair, gunshot wounds in the centre of his body and with perhaps blood coming out his mouth and nose.
The dead man also had a prosthetic leg, Person 14 said.
Person 14 has become the second SAS witness in as many days to accuse Mr Roberts-Smith of machine gunning that Afghan outside Whiskey 108 in similar terms.
Person 41, on Thursday, doubled down on his accusations that Mr Roberts-Smith pushed the man onto the ground, flipped him onto his stomach and fired the Minmi machine gun into his back.
Mr Roberts-Smith has strenuously and repeatedly denied that is how the Afghan died - the SAS veteran says he shot and killed the man who was hurrying outside the compound armed with a rifle.
Mr Roberts-Smith has told the court every single person he killed in Afghanistan was shot within the lawful rules of engagement.
His lawyers questioned Person 41 and accused him of lying and being unable to distinguish fact from fiction in his account of the Afghan killing.
Both Person 14 and Person 41 have given evidence in the defamation trial after Justice Anthony Besanko issued them "immunity" certificates that prevent the evidence being used to prosecute them in Australian courts.
Person 14's lawyer, on Friday, said his client objected to giving evidence on the shooting because it could implicate him as an accessory to murder.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/second-sas-soldier-claims-captured-onelegged-afghan-shot-by-australian-soldier/news-story/fb227abcb8626e8d9b3509b80ad54660
#15534448 at 2022-02-03 08:29:17 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #20 - INSURGENCY Edition
>>15456117
SAS soldier accused of 'lying' after telling court Ben Roberts-Smith involved in two war crime killings
PERRY DUFFIN - FEBRUARY 3, 2022
Ben Roberts-Smith's lawyers have accused his former SAS squadmate of "lying" and asked whether he "enjoys killing people" after the top-secret witness accused Mr Roberts-Smith of involvement in two alleged war crime murders.
The unnamed SAS soldier, who remains in active service, told the court Mr Roberts-Smith had shot one Afghan prisoner with a short burst of machine gun fire during a raid on a Taliban compound known as Whiskey 108.
The SAS witness, known in court as Person 41, claimed Mr Roberts-Smith had ordered a junior soldier shoot another detained Afghan at point blank range in a courtyard just a few minutes earlier in the 2009 raid.
Mr Roberts-Smith denies those accusations and is suing Nine newspapers for defamation saying they falsely portrayed him as a war criminal.
His lawyers had a chance to cross-examine Nine's first SAS witness in the Federal Court trial on Thursday morning.
Barrister Arthur Moses SC spent the day questioning Person 41's recollections, memories and claims of the Whiskey 108 raid.
He accused the SAS soldier of lying about details including when Person 41 claimed another soldier had called out in English as they searched for Taliban in Whiskey 108.
"You're just making this up aren't you? You're lying," Mr Moses said.
"I'm not lying," Person 41 said.
Person 41 said he never reported the Whiskey 108 killings because he wanted to "tow the line" and has claimed speaking out in the SAS could unravel a soldier's career.
"The reason you didn't report (the killings) to your patrol commander is that it didn't happen," Mr Moses said.
"That's incorrect - I know what I saw," The SAS witness replied.
The SAS witness agreed with Mr Moses that he felt guilt and shame following the events of Whiskey 108.
But he disagreed he felt like a "coward" because he didn't stop the alleged murders.
"I was happy to put it in the back of my memory and carry on with the rest of my life," the SAS witness said.
The SAS witness agreed he'd have flashbacks or memories just a few times a year until newspapers and the Inspector General of the Australian Defence Force began investigating and reporting on the allegations of SAS war crimes.
Then the memories increased - he is now diagnosed with anxiety in part because of the court case, the SAS soldier told Justice Anthony Besanko.
Mr Moses has highlighted contradictions between the versions of the events put forward by the SAS witness and Nine's court documents.
Specifically, Nine does not claim Mr Roberts-Smith ordered the killing of the detained Afghan - rather the newspapers claim he did not intervene to stop the alleged murder.
The SAS witness claimed Mr Roberts-Smith had marched the detainee over to a soldier known as Person 4, kicked the elderly Afghan in the legs to make him kneel and then instructed his squadmate to "shoot him".
The SAS witness told the court Person 4 had borrowed his suppressor to shoot the Afghan in the head and he had stepped out of the room while the detainee was killed.
Nine alleges a soldier known as Person 5 ordered the killing - but the SAS witness did not identify Person 5 as being present in the courtyard.
Mr Roberts-Smith has totally denied he ordered the shooting which has come to be known as the "blooding of the rookie".
It's not disputed Mr Roberts-Smith shot the second man at Whiskey 108 but the Victoria Cross recipient said the man was armed and moving quickly outside the compound.
He flatly denies machine gunning the man while he lay on the ground unarmed, as alleged by both Nine and the SAS witness.
The man had a prosthetic leg which was taken back to the SAS base and displayed in a make-shift pub known as the Fat Ladies Arms.
Many of the SAS soldiers, including Person 41, drank from the leg which became a trophy, the court has heard.
The SAS witness said he began to feel shame about drinking from the leg once it emerged in the press because it wasn't the right thing to do.
Mr Moses asked Person 41 about whether the media reports had brought back "bad memories" but the SAS witness said he had only good memories of his time in Afghanistan.
"You enjoyed killing people?" Mr Moses asked.
"I wouldn't say I enjoy it - but it's part of my job," Person 41 replied.
The trial continues.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/sas-soldier-accused-of-lying-after-telling-court-Ben-robertssmith-involved-in-two-war-crime-killings/news-story/fd1c90e7be058f6b2a4e7499e6e7907c
#15525427 at 2022-02-02 07:39:04 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #20 - INSURGENCY Edition
>>15456117
Ben Roberts-Smith shot Afghan captive in the back, SAS member tells defamation trial
Jamie McKinnell - 2 February 2022
An elite soldier has told a Sydney court he witnessed war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith shoot dead an Afghan man during a 2009 mission and order a colleague to execute a second man.
Mr Roberts-Smith's high-stakes defamation trial against three newspapers and three journalists resumed in the Federal Court in Sydney today, after months of delays caused by COVID-19.
The Victoria Cross recipient denies allegations contained in stories published in 2018, including of unlawful killings overseas, bullying of colleagues and domestic violence.
Publisher Nine Entertainment on Wednesday called a current Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) member who has been allocated the pseudonym "Person 41".
One of his four overseas deployments, to Afghanistan, included a 2009 Easter Sunday mission in which several Australian patrols were clearing a compound, codenamed "Whiskey 108".
Person 41 recalled there was "quite a lot of rubble around" after the compound was bombed and said troops found a hidden tunnel entrance while they were clearing a courtyard area.
The witness said he went into another room where he discovered a battery, wires and a "black sticky substance", which turned out to be opium, and decided improvised explosive devices were being made there.
He returned to the courtyard after hearing "commotion".
The court heard Mr Roberts-Smith was also in the courtyard, along with another soldier, Person 4. An older Afghan man wearing traditional clothing was "squatting down" nearby.
The witness said Person 4 asked to borrow his gun's suppressor, which Person 4 then began fitting to his own weapon.
"I then thought to myself, 'I think I know what's about to happen here,'" Person 41 told the court.
He said Mr Roberts-Smith grabbed the Afghan man by the shirt and picked him up before kicking him.
"He pointed to the Afghan and said, 'Shoot him'."
Person 41 said he stepped into a room, not wishing to witness "what was about to happen", and waited while a gunshot rang out.
When he returned to the courtyard, he saw the body of the man with a head wound and said Person 4 "seemed to be in a bit of shock".
The allegation about the older man's death was put to Mr Roberts-Smith during his evidence last year.
The veteran said it was "completely false" to say that he instructed Person 4 to shoot the man, or that a separate colleague had already ordered Person 4 to do so before him.
Mr Roberts-Smith further denied that there were any men found in the compound's secret tunnel.
Person 41 later told the court he left the compound and was about to make his way up to two other buildings when he noticed Mr Roberts-Smith "frogmarch" another Afghan man outside.
He said Mr Roberts-Smith "threw" the man on the ground, turned him onto his stomach and then fired "three to five" rounds of his machine gun into the man's back.
"He (Mr Roberts-Smith) said 'are we all good, all cool', and I just said 'yeah mate, no worries'," he told the court.
The witness said he denied knowing what happened to "two blokes pulled out of the tunnel" when later asked by another colleague.
"I just wanted to keep quiet about the whole thing," he said.
"I was toeing the line, so to speak, I was a new trooper.
"It's the unwritten rule, you just go along with whatever happens."
The court has previously heard Mr Roberts-Smith deny allegations he carried a man with a prosthetic leg outside the Whiskey 108 compound, threw him on the ground, and shot him with a light machine gun.
Mr Roberts-Smith insisted he shot a suspected enemy who ran around a corner of the compound carrying a weapon as he went outside, and that an unnamed colleague shot a second enemy.
Earlier today, Justice Anthony Besanko explained why the evidence of Special Operations Command witnesses would not be accessible to the public as a real-time live stream.
The court will instead release a video of the session afterwards, to avoid the risk of "inadvertent disclosure" of sensitive information.
Person 41's identity is being kept so secret that a video feed of proceedings being viewed by the media is not including any view of him.
The trial continues.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-02-02/Ben-Roberts-Smith-defamation-afghan-man-shoot-dead/100797916
#15456117 at 2022-01-25 09:51:36 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #20 - INSURGENCY Edition
>>15427303
Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial to resume next week, despite WA border issues
Jenny Noyes - January 25, 2022
Former soldier Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial over newspaper reports accusing him of war crimes is set to resume in Sydney next week, despite Western Australia's ongoing hard border posing potential challenges for several witnesses in that state.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times over a series of articles published in 2018 that allege his involvement in six unlawful killings while he served in Afghanistan with Australia's special forces in 2012. The decorated soldier, a Victoria Cross recipient, denies any wrongdoing.
The trial, which was cut short amid Sydney's Delta outbreak and subsequent lockdown last year, had been due to resume in November but was delayed until February due to ongoing border closures in Western Australia and Queensland, which would prevent witnesses from returning home after travelling to Sydney to give evidence.
The decision by Western Australia Premier Mark McGowan last week to further delay reopening the state's border amid surging COVID-19 cases in the eastern states poses a new challenge for the trial, with several witnesses who reside in Western Australia among the first due to appear.
Witnesses subpoenaed to appear have until January 28 to apply to be excused from the trial, which will re-commence on February 2.
At a case management hearing on Tuesday, the newspapers' barrister Nicholas Owens, SC, said four of the first six witnesses he had been planning to call reside in Western Australia. To enable the trial to resume until a solution is found, he proposed to reshuffle his list: 15 witnesses are available to appear in Sydney, he said, and hearing them would take an estimated four weeks.
Those first 15 will include a number of soldiers and Mr Roberts-Smith's ex-wife, Emma Roberts. The war veteran last week lost a legal bid to have Ms Roberts cross-examined over "ill-founded" assertions that she accessed his emails and gave them to the newspapers.
Once the court has heard from the first 15 witnesses, it's hoped Western Australia will have relaxed its border; but if not, and witnesses are unwilling to travel to Sydney to give their evidence, the trial may relocate to Western Australia.
Mr Owens said his team intends to call at least nine witnesses based in Western Australia, or - if an application to hear from a soldier given the pseudonym 'Person 56' is successful - 10.
Commonwealth solicitor Christine Ernst advised the court moving the trial to Perth would take an estimated 8-12 weeks to arrange due to security requirements.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/Ben-Roberts-Smith-defamation-trial-to-resume-next-week-despite-wa-border-issues-20220125-p59r4e.html
#15427303 at 2022-01-21 07:17:54 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #20 - INSURGENCY Edition
Ben Roberts-Smith loses case against ex-wife, court orders he pay costs
Emily Laurence - 22 January 2022
Former soldier Ben Roberts-Smith has lost his court case against his ex-wife over allegations she accessed confidential emails.
Federal Court Justice Bromwich also ordered the Victoria Cross recipient pay Emma Roberts's costs.
"In my view, the material relied upon goes no further than bare possibilities and suspicions, with many such assertions in relation to Ms Roberts being shown to be ill-founded as against her," Justice Bromwich said.
Mr Roberts-Smith sued Ms Smith during his defamation case against the Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times, of which Ms Roberts is a defence witness.
His lawyers then accused her of accessing an email account to obtain confidential information including legal correspondence, alleging she may have then passed it on to the respondents in the defamation trial.
This was despite the respondents not producing "any such material" produced by Ms Roberts", Justice Bromwich said in deciding Mr Roberts-Smith had no arguable case.
Mr Roberts-Smith further alleged Ms Roberts's best friend Danielle Scott and her husband may have accessed the email account for his company, RS Group Australia.
The former SAS soldier provided the court with Telstra records but Justice Bromwich found there was "an unacceptably high chance" that someone other than Ms Roberts, or the proposed respondents, could have accessed the email account.
"This is too significant a margin for error to allow me to infer anything concrete from this evidence, let alone to order that any examination should occur based on it," Justice Bromwich said.
The judge also considered evidence of private messages between Ms Roberts and Ms Scott where the pair discussed the email account.
"It follows that once again, the inferences Mr Roberts-Smith seeks to have the court draw were based upon an incorrect and suspicious interpretation of what was being said, while Ms Roberts's response has been accurate, reliable and credible," Justice Bromwich said of one the message exchanges.
He said "threads of material" in relation to Ms Scott's husband accessing the account did not make a case.
Mr Roberts-Smith and Ms Roberts separated in January 2020.
His defamation case against the three media outlets over allegations of war crimes, bullying and domestic violence has been delayed by COVID but is due to resume on February 2.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-01-21/Ben-Roberts-Smith-loses-case-against-ex-wife/100773308
#15190238 at 2021-12-14 07:33:55 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #20 - INSURGENCY Edition
Ben Roberts-Smith wins access to private emails in defamation case
David Estcourt - December 14, 2021
War veteran Ben Roberts-Smith has won access to a series of messages between lawyers defending three newspapers accused of defamation and a solicitor representing a former soldier who has agreed to testify against the Victoria Cross recipient.
The ex-soldier, known as "Person 56", was a member of Mr Roberts-Smith's patrol in 2012 and participated in missions in Darwan and Fasil. In allegations published in 2018, Mr Roberts-Smith was accused of being involved in the death of handcuffed farmer Ali Jan during the Darwan mission.
In a decision handed down on Tuesday, Federal Court justice Wendy Abraham ruled that the contents of four emails sent by the papers' lawyers, and information contained within another communication with a lawyer for the Department of Defence, were not protected by privilege and must be handed over.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Age, the Herald and The Canberra Times over a series of stories starting in June 2018 that he alleges accused him of war crimes and an act of domestic violence against a woman with whom he was having an extramarital affair. He denies all wrongdoing.
Of the communications, three of the emails contained information that lawyers acting for the newspapers had argued were developed for the purposes of obtaining legal advice and therefore privileged.
Another one of the emails, written by Minter Ellison lawyer Dean Levitan to solicitor Sam Richter, who is representing Person 56, discussed the circumstances under which the former soldier could give evidence in court against Mr Roberts-Smith.
Additionally, the contents of a private conversation between lawyers representing the papers and Mr Richter, which was conveyed by Mr Richter to Department of Defence lawyer Anthony Reilly, must also be handed over.
Client legal privilege is a legal right which entitles individuals and organisations to obtain legal advice about their circumstances and keep it confidential.
Mr Robert-Smith's barrister Arthur Moses, SC, argued that the papers' lawyers had implicitly waived privilege and Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team was therefore entitled to the documents.
The news outlets are relying on a defence of truth to defend their claims, and have applied to the Federal Court to call Person 56 as a witness when the trial resumes next year.
The court had previously found that a report prepared by investigative journalist Ross Coulthart, a former reporter for Channel Seven, which summarised allegations and rumours about Mr Roberts-Smith would remain secret, after it found it could not be used because it was covered by legal privilege.
Federal Court Justice Anthony Besanko said the trial would resume in Sydney in February next year after a six-month pause owing to coronavirus restrictions.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/Ben-Roberts-Smith-wins-access-to-private-emails-in-defamation-case-20211214-p59hf1.html
#15175286 at 2021-12-11 09:52:44 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #20 - INSURGENCY Edition
#19 - Part 7
Malka Leifer Extradition and Prosecution
>>14825539 Malka Leifer's lawyers consider seeking report on fitness for trial, court told
#19 - Part 8
Australian Government Sexual Assault Allegations
>>15104740 Video: Independent Review into Commonwealth Parliamentary Workplaces finds 1 in 3 staff in federal parliament experience sexual harassment
#19 - Part 9
Australian and Regional Resignations
>>14957532 Mike Hughes stands aside as managing director of Landbridge, the Chinese company that owns the lease over the Port of Darwin amid national security concerns
>>15112506 Two senior members of the Morrison government, Health Minister Greg Hunt and former attorney-general Christian Porter, will retire at the federal election
>>15119154 Video: Education Minister Alan Tudge stands aside amid abuse allegations, PM tells parliament
>>15150343 Magellan CEO Brett Cairns's abrupt resignation for "personal reasons" spooks investors
#19 - Part 10
George Papadopoulos Tweets, Alexander Downer and SPYGATE Revelations
>>14928326 George Papadopoulos Tweet: Remember these two individuals (Alexander Downer and Stefan Halper). Their names. And why they met a week before both started spying on me in London. #Durham
>>14928326 George Papadopoulos Tweet: Mueller was never there to "investigate." He was there to cover up. They never thought she would lose
>>14957376 George Papadopoulos Tweet: Strzok looked incredibly unhinged in his interview with Maddow. And we aren't even at the Joseph Mifsud, Stefan Halper, Alexander Downer part of the story
>>14957381 Video: Strzok Calls Out Durham's Russia Scandal Investigation For Pushing Pro-Trump Narrative - MSNBC
>>15002062 George Papadopoulos Tweet: Do not be surprised if the intel community burns all their assets used (Downer, Mifsud, Steele, Halper, Turk) in the Russia collusion trap because they understand what Trump and his team knew all along, as did Kissinger, you will need to cooperate with Russia to contain China
>>15042185 George Papadopoulos Tweet: Big names to watch moving forward in Durham probe: Victoria Nuland - US embassy personnel (London/Athens) - Alexander Downer
#19 - Part 11
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial
>>14789400 Judge refuses to move Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case across state borders
>>14806475 Journalist Ross Coulthart's private investigation into Ben Roberts-Smith, prepared for Seven West Media, should remain secret, say lawyers
>>14865509 Ben Roberts-Smith seeks top-secret evidence of 'key witnesses' in defamation trial - Army fighting a request from Roberts-Smith's lawyers to reveal what 12 Special Forces members told a top-secret inquiry into alleged war crimes in Afghanistan
>>14884963 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial likely to resume in 2022 due to uncertainty about restrictions likely to be in place for witnesses and parties travelling interstate to attend court
>>15025596 Former soldier willing to testify against Ben Roberts-Smith, court hears
>>15033279 Defence Department confirms criminal investigation into conduct of Australian commando platoon in Afghanistan
>>15042210 Australian Special Forces war crimes prosecution could be blown up by legal minefield
>>15061842 Judge rules Seven West Media's secret Ben Roberts-Smith report will not be available at defamation trial
>>15126709 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial set to resume in February
#15175253 at 2021-12-11 09:30:19 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #19 - THE ONLY WAY IS THE MILITARY Edition
#19 - Part 7
Malka Leifer Extradition and Prosecution
>>14825539 Malka Leifer's lawyers consider seeking report on fitness for trial, court told
#19 - Part 8
Australian Government Sexual Assault Allegations
>>15104740 Video: Independent Review into Commonwealth Parliamentary Workplaces finds 1 in 3 staff in federal parliament experience sexual harassment
#19 - Part 9
Australian and Regional Resignations
>>14957532 Mike Hughes stands aside as managing director of Landbridge, the Chinese company that owns the lease over the Port of Darwin amid national security concerns
>>15112506 Two senior members of the Morrison government, Health Minister Greg Hunt and former attorney-general Christian Porter, will retire at the federal election
>>15119154 Video: Education Minister Alan Tudge stands aside amid abuse allegations, PM tells parliament
>>15150343 Magellan CEO Brett Cairns's abrupt resignation for "personal reasons" spooks investors
#19 - Part 10
George Papadopoulos Tweets, Alexander Downer and SPYGATE Revelations
>>14928326 George Papadopoulos Tweet: Remember these two individuals (Alexander Downer and Stefan Halper). Their names. And why they met a week before both started spying on me in London. #Durham
>>14928326 George Papadopoulos Tweet: Mueller was never there to "investigate." He was there to cover up. They never thought she would lose
>>14957376 George Papadopoulos Tweet: Strzok looked incredibly unhinged in his interview with Maddow. And we aren't even at the Joseph Mifsud, Stefan Halper, Alexander Downer part of the story
>>14957381 Video: Strzok Calls Out Durham's Russia Scandal Investigation For Pushing Pro-Trump Narrative - MSNBC
>>15002062 George Papadopoulos Tweet: Do not be surprised if the intel community burns all their assets used (Downer, Mifsud, Steele, Halper, Turk) in the Russia collusion trap because they understand what Trump and his team knew all along, as did Kissinger, you will need to cooperate with Russia to contain China
>>15042185 George Papadopoulos Tweet: Big names to watch moving forward in Durham probe: Victoria Nuland - US embassy personnel (London/Athens) - Alexander Downer
#19 - Part 11
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial
>>14789400 Judge refuses to move Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case across state borders
>>14806475 Journalist Ross Coulthart's private investigation into Ben Roberts-Smith, prepared for Seven West Media, should remain secret, say lawyers
>>14865509 Ben Roberts-Smith seeks top-secret evidence of 'key witnesses' in defamation trial - Army fighting a request from Roberts-Smith's lawyers to reveal what 12 Special Forces members told a top-secret inquiry into alleged war crimes in Afghanistan
>>14884963 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial likely to resume in 2022 due to uncertainty about restrictions likely to be in place for witnesses and parties travelling interstate to attend court
>>15025596 Former soldier willing to testify against Ben Roberts-Smith, court hears
>>15033279 Defence Department confirms criminal investigation into conduct of Australian commando platoon in Afghanistan
>>15042210 Australian Special Forces war crimes prosecution could be blown up by legal minefield
>>15061842 Judge rules Seven West Media's secret Ben Roberts-Smith report will not be available at defamation trial
>>15126709 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial set to resume in February
#15126709 at 2021-12-03 09:55:17 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #19 - THE ONLY WAY IS THE MILITARY Edition
>>15061842
Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial set to resume in February
Michaela Whitbourn - December 3, 2021
War veteran Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial against The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald is set to resume in February after a six-month pause owing to coronavirus restrictions.
On Friday, Federal Court Justice Anthony Besanko, appearing via video link from Adelaide, ordered that the trial would resume in Sydney on Wednesday, February 2.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Age, the Herald and The Canberra Times over a series of stories starting in June 2018 that he alleges accuse him of war crimes and an act of domestic violence against a woman with whom he was having an extramarital affair. He denies all wrongdoing. The media outlets are seeking to rely on a defence of truth.
Barrister Nicholas Owens, SC, acting for the media outlets, told Justice Besanko on Friday that the newspapers' preferred start date was February 14.
The outlets intend to call a number of witnesses from Western Australia who are affected by border restrictions in that state.
West Australian Premier Mark McGowan has indicated his state's borders will reopen when 90 per cent of residents aged 12 and up are fully vaccinated against COVID-19, which is expected to happen in late January or early February.
Mr Owens said a February 14 start date was at the "cautious end of that period that the premier has indicated".
Arthur Moses, SC, appearing for Mr Roberts-Smith, said he didn't "mean to be disrespectful to statements made by the WA premier" but it was not clear when interstate travel would resume without restriction and "the Federal Court can't be held hostage to whims of decisions by a state premier".
"It's been three-and-a-half years since the proceedings were commenced," Mr Moses said.
By February, it would have been seven months since Mr Roberts-Smith gave evidence in the proceedings, he added. Mr Moses proposed that the trial should resume on January 31.
"At the moment, we are delaying and delaying this matter based on press statements made by a premier of a state, and that is no way in which the administration of justice can continue in this case," Mr Moses said.
Justice Besanko said the trial would resume on Wednesday, February 2.
He told Mr Owens that if circumstances changed and he needed to make an application in January to delay the trial "for a short period of time, you can make that application and I'll consider it on the evidence".
https://www.smh.com.au/national/Ben-Roberts-Smith-defamation-trial-set-to-resume-in-february-20211203-p59en0.html
#15061842 at 2021-11-23 06:31:25 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #19 - THE ONLY WAY IS THE MILITARY Edition
>>14806475
Judge rules Seven's secret Ben Roberts-Smith report will not be available at defamation trial
Network commissioned confidential report after allegations of war crimes against former SAS corporal
Ben Doherty - 23 Nov 2021
A secret report ordered by Channel Seven into allegations of war crimes against Ben Roberts-Smith will not be made available to a defamation trial, with a judge ruling that the document is legally privileged.
In 2018, after three newspapers published allegations the former SAS corporal and Victoria Cross recipient committed a series of war crimes while on deployment in Afghanistan, Roberts-Smith's employer, Seven West Media, commissioned a confidential report into the allegations against him.
Roberts-Smith, who emphatically denies the allegations, is suing the Age, the Sydney Morning Herald and the Canberra Times for defamation in the federal court.
In a decision handed down on Tuesday, Justice Wendy Abraham said journalist Ross Coulthart, then an employee of the public relations firm Cato & Clegg, was commissioned by the general counsel and commercial director of Seven West Media, Bruce McWilliam, to "prepare a report" on the Roberts-Smith allegations. The report was to consider and summarise "all of the known rumours and allegations that are circulating or have been published about Ben Roberts-Smith and get his response to each of them, as well as conduct investigations and make other enquiries as you see fit".
Coulthart was told to give the report directly to McWilliam, who would pass it on to legal counsel.
McWilliam told Roberts-Smith the document would be useful for Seven West Media "as we will likely also be attacked for continuing to employ you".
"I also think a copy should be provided to the chairman [Kerry Stokes] so that he is in a position to obtain can get [sic] legal advice on where things stand and so that he can continue to back you."
Stokes was ultimately given a copy of the report. Roberts-Smith, whose defamation action was being bankrolled by Seven West Media at the time, was not.
Lawyers for the three newspapers sought to subpoena Coulthart's report, arguing that the "dominant purpose" of the report was not to assist in obtaining legal advice, but "the commercial and reputational concerns of Mr Stokes, and Seven West Media were the primary reasons for its commission".
Abraham did not agree, ruling that the document was legally privileged and did not have to be handed over.
The dispute follows debate in court last week about whether the newspapers will be allowed to call an additional witness in their defence against Roberts-Smith's defamation action.
A former comrade of Roberts-Smith, who was serving on his patrol at the scene of an alleged war crime, has, subsequent to the trial starting, agreed to give evidence.
The former soldier, known as Person 56, was a member of Roberts-Smith's patrol in the village of Darwan, in Uruzgan province, on 11 September 2012.
The newspapers' reporting has alleged that on that day Roberts-Smith took a handcuffed non-combatant, a farmer named Ali Jan, and forced him to kneel on the edge of a 10m-high cliff, before kicking him off.
Ali Jan was then carried to a different place and shot, either by Roberts-Smith, or by a subordinate soldier under his command, the newspapers allege in their defence.
Roberts-Smith has consistently and strenuously denied the allegation as "completely without any foundation in truth".
The newspapers, seeking to defend their reporting as true, have been seeking to subpoena Person 56.
Roberts-Smith has vociferously denied the newspaper's account of Ali Jan's death, telling the court the man purported to be Ali Jan was a "spotter" - a forward scout who reports soldiers' movements to insurgents - shot after being discovered hiding in a cornfield. He says the man was in possession of a radio and was a legitimate military target.
Roberts-Smith's lawyers have opposed allowing Person 56 to testify, suggesting they had done a deal with the newspapers to only talk about specific issues. The newspapers deny any such deal but say they expect the witness to object if asked about matters other than Darwan. The court has reserved its decision on the issue.
The defamation trial - which started in 2018 - remains part heard.
It is likely to recommence early in the new year.
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2021/nov/23/judge-rules-sevens-secret-Ben-Roberts-Smith-report-will-not-be-available-at-defamation-trial
#15042210 at 2021-11-20 09:45:40 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #19 - THE ONLY WAY IS THE MILITARY Edition
War crimes prosecution could be blown up by legal minefield
Nick McKenzie and Chris Masters - November 20, 2021
1/2
A three-year federal police investigation into alleged war crimes committed by an Australian special forces soldier in Afghanistan may have been compromised because detectives unwittingly obtained tainted information in what looms as a major blow to police and prosecutors.
The problem relates to the referral to the Australian Federal Police in 2018 of information uncovered by the military Inspector General's war crime inquiry, known as the Brereton inquiry, which finished a year ago.
While police can act on much of the information uncovered by the Brereton inquiry, they are banned from using certain witness transcripts if they are infected by disclosures from soldiers who have since become police targets.
The issue doesn't impact the AFP's highest-profile war crimes inquiry into war hero and ex-SAS soldier Ben Roberts-Smith, and it hadn't affected other war crimes investigations.
But according to four official sources not authorised to comment publicly, it has impacted on aspects of the AFP probe into a former SAS operator, known as soldier Q.
Soldier Q is under investigation over allegations he is implicated in one or more prisoner executions while serving with the SAS in Afghanistan some time between 2006 and 2010. The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald are aware of the precise allegations, including the fact that they have been partly corroborated by multiple witnesses, but is withholding them for legal reasons.
The existence of the police investigation into soldier Q has not before been made public, nor has the concern that the inquiries into him may have been inadvertently sullied.
The area of law that governs how police may use Brereton inquiry information is complex, partly because it has not been thoroughly tested before the High Court.
Four official sources who briefed The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald had differing opinions on the damage caused by the AFP's handling of information, with one stating it was fatal to the man's prosecution but another stressing that it could be remedied.
A third source said the Office of the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions was being unnecessarily conservative in its damage assessment, given the legal uncertainty and the fact that the criminal brief of evidence about soldier Q was yet to be finalised.
The AFP refused to comment, citing ongoing investigations.
The revelations are sensitive for the AFP given the high-profile nature of its war crimes investigations and concerns in defence and political circles that the agency lacked the legal expertise to investigate the allegations when they were referred to it by the Brereton inquiry in 2018.
But the potential compromise of an aspect of the AFP's work is also significant because it highlights the challenges facing the newly created war crimes agency, the Office of the Special Investigator.
The office was launched in January to investigate the alleged war crimes unearthed by Justice Paul Brereton except those few cases referred to the AFP in 2018. It is the first anniversary of the Brereton inquiry's final report, which last November identified credible information that up to 39 Afghan prisoners and civilians may have been executed by Australian special forces soldiers.
(continued)
#15025596 at 2021-11-18 07:56:01 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #19 - THE ONLY WAY IS THE MILITARY Edition
Former soldier willing to testify against Ben Roberts-Smith, court hears
Jenny Noyes - November 18, 2021
A former soldier who served with Ben Roberts-Smith in Afghanistan has indicated he is prepared to testify against the Victoria Cross recipient, who is suing three newspapers including this masthead for publishing allegations he was involved in war crimes.
The ex-soldier, known as "person 56", was a member of Mr Roberts-Smith's patrol in 2012 and participated in missions in Darwan and Fasil. In allegations published in 2018, Mr Roberts-Smith is accused of being involved in the death of handcuffed farmer Ali Jan during the Darwan mission.
It's one of six unlawful killings that reports in The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times accused Mr Roberts-Smith of involvement in. Mr Roberts-Smith, one of Australia's most decorated war veterans, denies any wrongdoing.
The news outlets are relying on a defence of truth to defend their claims, and have applied to the Federal Court to call Person 56 as a witness when the trial resumes next year.
At an interlocutory hearing in response to that application on Thursday, Mr Robert-Smith's barrister Arthur Moses, SC, told the court that Person 56 is someone the newspapers allege was "involved in the cover-up of the murder of Ali Jan".
Mr Moses is seeking to access correspondence between Person 56 and the media outlets' lawyers, saying the latter has "flipped and flopped and flipped again" in calling him as a witness.
"Despite making those allegations of war crimes concerning Person 56, the respondents appear to have reached an agreement" to not ask him "any other questions in relation to any other matters", Mr Moses said.
Barrister for the media outlets, Nicholas Owens, SC, denied that there was any "side deal" with Person 56, and noted his attempts to subpoena the potential witness before the trial were denied.
"After the applicant's cross-examination and the evidence of the Afghan witnesses … we have been able to, for the first time, establish contact with Person 56," Mr Owens said.
"He agreed to speak to us about Darwan… We didn't agree not to ask questions."
Mr Owens said Person 56 indicated he would object to questions on other topics "on the grounds of self-incrimination" and "we would not apply to have him compelled to give that evidence over his objection".
He told the court the evidence from Person 56 was "vital" and that it "corroborates the evidence of the Afghan witnesses" and contradicts that of Mr Roberts-Smith.
The planned resumption of the defamation trial at the start of this month was delayed due to ongoing border closures in Western Australia and Queensland, which would prevent witnesses from returning home after travelling to Sydney to give evidence.
The matter will return to court before Justice Anthony Besanko on November 29, with a decision expected on whether Person 56 will give evidence next month.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/former-soldier-willing-to-testify-against-Ben-Roberts-Smith-court-hears-20211118-p59a33.html
#14884963 at 2021-10-30 08:48:11 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #19 - THE ONLY WAY IS THE MILITARY Edition
>>14789400
Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial likely to resume in 2022
HEATH PARKES-HUPTON - OCTOBER 29, 2021
Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial against former Fairfax newspapers and journalists will likely not resume this year because of uncertainty about where it will be held.
The Victoria Cross recipient is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times over stories alleging he committed war crimes while deployed as an SAS soldier.
Mr Roberts-Smith denies the allegations, which include him committing or being complicit in the murder of Afghan civilians, and refutes claims he assaulted a woman with whom he was allegedly having an affair.
The publications are defending the reports from 2018 as true. The trial in Sydney began in June but was abandoned in ?August because of Covid-19.
Judge Anthony Besanko on Friday said a new trial date was to be fixed following a hearing on December 3. Justice Besanko also chose not to order the trial to move to Adelaide, as argued for by Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers.
In his judgment Justice Besanko said there was considerable uncertainty about the restrictions likely to be in place for witnesses and parties travelling interstate to attend court.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/media/Ben-robertssmith-defamation-trial-likely-to-resume-in-2022/news-story/3f06364107c1823288afa18c213c3126
#14865509 at 2021-10-27 07:23:28 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #19 - THE ONLY WAY IS THE MILITARY Edition
>>14789400
Ben Roberts-Smith seeks top-secret evidence of 'key witnesses' in defamation trial
HEATH PARKES-HUPTON - OCTOBER 27, 2021
The army is fighting a request from Ben Roberts-Smith's lawyers to reveal what 12 Special Forces members told a top-secret inquiry into alleged war crimes in Afghanistan.
The Federal Court has been told the Victoria Cross recipient has asked for transcripts - if they exist - of "key witnesses" who were on the same missions during which newspaper articles allege he committed, or was complicit in, six murders.
Arthur Moses SC, acting for Mr Roberts-Smith, said the confidential accounts witnesses were suspected of giving to the Brereton Inquiry were crucial to the credibility of the evidence they were expected to give in a defamation trial before the court.
Australian Defence Force Inspector-General James Gaynor has claimed public interest immunity over the interviews, saying their release could negate attempts to break a "culture of silence" within Special Forces ranks and impact on the ability to hold similar inquiries in the future.
Kristine Stern SC, appearing for General Gaynor and the ADF, would not confirm or deny in open court whether the soldiers did testify in the inquiry or whether the transcripts sought existed at all.
Australia's most decorated living soldier, Mr Roberts-Smith is suing former Fairfax newspapers and journalists over reports he committed atrocities while deployed in the Middle East and allegations of violence against women.
His lawyers have issued a subpoena seeking documents related to current and former members of the Special Forces who they suspect gave evidence in the landmark inquiry.
They are looking for evidence linked to "certain identified events" that are the subject of the trial and for which the newspapers have filed a defence of truth, the court was told on Wednesday.
The court was told those events, between 2006 and 2012, centred on allegations of Mr Roberts-Smith shooting unarmed civilians and directing other soldiers to kill innocent Afghans.
All of the 12 witnesses identified, including Federal MP Andrew Hastie, are expected to be called by the publications during the defamation trial, Mr Moses told the court.
Some of the published allegations "don't come from the investigative skills of the journalists", Mr Moses claimed, but were sourced from "other mechanisms" and what they believed was contained in the Brereton report.
It would be critical for the court to know if the witnesses had given any prior inconsistent accounts of what happened on the missions in question and the incidents that Mr Roberts-Smith denied, he said.
"This is a credit case in the field of battle of events dating back as far as 2006," Mr Moses said.
Ms Stern said granting the subpoena would savage the trust and confidence in the Defence Force, which has worked to shed a "code of silence" adopted by members of the Special Forces.
"Because this claim relates to transcripts of evidence in relation to precisely the cohort of persons where the code of silence was identified as a significant problem," she said.
"Efforts to break down the culture of silence ... would be undermined."
That toxic culture not only made it difficult to find the truth but was also considered to be a "contributing factor" to the conduct being investigated by the inquiry, Ms Stern said.
She said it would be inappropriate to disclose the evidence, as the IGADF "took very careful and elaborate steps to maintain the confidentiality of the inquiry".
However, Mr Moses said they could not be given an "absolute guarantee" that another affected party wouldn't seek the information via subpoena.
Nor could they be seen as whistleblowers, he said, because it was unknown whether the people identified had been compelled to give evidence before the inquiry.
The hearing before Justice Wendy Abraham is set to continue in a closed court.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/breaking-news/Ben-robertssmith-seeks-topsecret-evidence-of-key-witnesses-in-defamation-trial/news-story/f053619f4a2f6d6037e821cf9d119e95
#14806475 at 2021-10-18 07:57:25 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #19 - THE ONLY WAY IS THE MILITARY Edition
>>14789400
Journalist's Ben Roberts-Smith report should remain secret, say lawyers
Tammy Mills - October 18, 2021
1/2
A director of Seven West Media deployed a Walkley-award winning journalist to look into war crime allegations against the company's employee, former special forces soldier Ben Roberts-Smith, in a secret report later dubbed the "McWilliam project".
Lawyers for Mr Roberts-Smith in his defamation case against The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald, now say journalist Ross Coulthart's report for Seven commercial director Bruce McWilliam and chairman Kerry Stokes should not be released to the newspapers, arguing it is protected by legal professional privilege, which keeps communication between lawyers and clients confidential.
The inner workings of how Seven responded to the allegations against Mr Roberts-Smith, who held a senior executive position at the company, is part of the broader defamation case in which Mr Roberts-Smith is suing the Nine-owned publications over a series of stories that allege he committed murders while on deployment to Afghanistan.
Mr Roberts-Smith, who has stepped aside from his position as general-manager at Seven in Queensland while he fights the case, denies all wrongdoing. The Age and Herald are relying on a defence of truth.
While the defamation trial is on hold until at least January, the latest stoush in the Federal Court on Monday centres on access to documents, specifically a report and a series of emails by Coulthart, a freelance journalist who at the time had been hired by public relations company Cato & Clive.
Mr McWilliam said in an affidavit that after media articles began to be published in 2017 about Mr Roberts-Smith, he asked Coulthart, an investigative reporter who had previously worked for the organisation, to look into the allegations and prepare a report for him and Seven boss Kerry Stokes.
Nine wants access to Coulthart's report, which the barrister acting for Nine, Nicholas Owens, SC, called the "McWilliam project". Nine also wants access to subsequent emails Coulthart sent to Mr McWilliam, Mr Stokes and Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers containing media statements he drafted for the war veteran as part of a public relations response to the allegations.
Mr Roberts-Smith is resisting releasing the documents on the basis that they are covered by legal professional privilege.
In his affidavit, Mr McWilliam said a report setting out the allegations and Mr Roberts-Smith's responses would assist the former solider's lawyers, Mark O'Brien and Arthur Moses, in advising him ahead of being questioned in a war crimes inquiry and a soon-to-come defamation suit.
The fact that Seven were, at that time, footing the war veteran's legal bills was also a consideration.
"I wanted to ensure that any decision by SWM [Seven West Media] to continue to support the applicant [Mr Roberts-Smith] was a considered one," Mr McWilliam said.
Mr Owens said the purpose of the report was a commercial one, not a legal one.
"There's just been a series of very serious allegations made, and Seven West Media wants to make sure that it's spending its money wisely, presumably," Mr Owens said.
(continued)
#14789400 at 2021-10-15 09:24:24 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #19 - THE ONLY WAY IS THE MILITARY Edition
Judge refuses to move Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case across state borders
Tammy Mills - October 15, 2021
A Federal Court judge has resisted moving a high-profile defamation case involving war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith from NSW to South Australia.
The running of the trial, involving witnesses from five different states and territories, as well as Afghanistan, has faced significant hurdles caused by border closures and lockdowns during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Mr Roberts-Smith, a former Special Air Service soldier, is suing The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald in the Federal Court for defamation over stories published in 2018 that alleged he was involved in unlawful killings during missions in Afghanistan.
The 42-year-old has denied all wrongdoing and told the court earlier this year he had only killed Taliban insurgents in the heat of battle.
The news outlets are defending the claims and relying on a defence of truth. Four Afghan witnesses have given evidence in the trial, including one who said he saw a "big soldier" kick his uncle, Ali Jan, off a cliff before shots were heard.
The defamation trial was adjourned in August because of COVID-19 pandemic restrictions in Sydney.
On Friday, one of Mr Roberts-Smith's barristers applied for the trial to be moved to South Australia in the hope there would be less of a chance of interruptions there, as well as less restrictive travel requirements for witnesses.
But Justice Anthony Besanko was not persuaded that he should relocate the case, and he resisted setting a date for the trial to resume.
"It seems to me the circumstances are too uncertain for me to do that," Justice Besanko said.
Justice Besanko said he wanted the option to resume the trial from January 17, depending on the situation with the pandemic and the parties involved in the case.
The court heard there were 10 barristers and a "battalion of solicitors" involved in the proceedings.
Courts in NSW have indicated they intend to slowly reopen this month. While NSW Premier Dominic Perrottet has said NSW borders would reopen from November 1, there is uncertainty over the borders in other states.
The defamation trial was still to hear from nine witnesses in Western Australia, seven in Queensland, more than six in NSW, two from Victoria and another from the ACT, the court heard on Friday.
There was particular concern over whether witnesses from Western Australia, some of whom were special forces soldiers, would be able to return home if they travelled interstate to give evidence because of the hard border closure there.
The newspapers' lawyer, Nicholas Owens, SC, said it seemed "very unlikely" that Western Australia would treat South Australia any differently than NSW if the trial was moved.
Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Arthur Moses, SC, said WA police had confirmed that witnesses who were active military personnel could still return to their home state from NSW, considered an "extreme risk jurisdiction", if they were required to be on duty, as long as they self-quarantined for two weeks when they returned.
But Mr Owens said his advice was that defence personnel could rely on that exemption only if they were travelling on defence business.
Mr Moses said witnesses for Mr Roberts-Smith were "prepared to come from WA and will do what is required to come to court to give evidence".
"These are special forces soldiers, some of them. Self-quarantine is not a hardship, your honour … they can come to court and self-quarantine for 14 days," Mr Moses said.
A further case management hearing will take place on December 3.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/judge-refuses-to-move-Ben-Roberts-Smith-defamation-case-across-state-borders-20211015-p5908b.html
#14789329 at 2021-10-15 09:02:57 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #19 - THE ONLY WAY IS THE MILITARY Edition
#18 - Part 15
Julian Assange Indictment and Extradition
>>14684581 Australia reveals it raised case of Julian Assange with US, amid 'kidnap plot' claim
>>14697983 PDF: Julian Assange supporters write to Scott Morrison over reported CIA plot to kidnap or kill WikiLeaks founder
#18 - Part 16
Cardinal George Pell and Vatican Financial Scandal Allegations
>>14648895 Cardinal Pell says he 'never really approved' of Benedict XVI's decision to resign
>>14657285 Catholics should debate issues, not debase each other, Cardinal George Pell said at "The Church Up Close" seminar
>>14657313 Video: VII Edition - The Church Up Close - September 23 - santacrocevideo
#18 - Part 17
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial
>>14404558 SAS soldiers who faced the sack after extraordinary press conference accusing them of war crimes will FINALLY keep their jobs - and at least one is already back in Kabul saving Aussies from the Taliban
>>14461837 Defence Minister Peter Dutton apologises to any special forces troops wrongly accused of war crimes in Afghanistan
>>14490409 'Insensitive insult': Fury over move to disband Aussie SAS unit, 2 Squadron
>>14490463 As Australia's war crimes investigations drag on, misinformation is catching up - Nick McKenzie and Chris Masters - theage.com.au
>>14555183 SAS survives to fight another day as Defence Minister Peter Dutton blocks move to merge selection courses for Perth-based SASR and Sydney-based 2nd Commando Regiment from next year
>>14698105 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial should be moved out of Sydney, lawyer says - Long delays and postponements mean former SAS soldier may not receive a fair trial, says his barrister
>>14716165 He's Australia's Most Decorated Soldier. Did He Also Kill Helpless Afghans? - Ben Roberts-Smith is suing three newspapers that accused him of unlawful killings in Afghanistan. But much more than the reputation of one soldier is at stake
#14789246 at 2021-10-15 08:42:13 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #18 - Talisman Sabre: MAGIC SWORD Edition
#18 - Part 15
Julian Assange Indictment and Extradition
>>14684581 Australia reveals it raised case of Julian Assange with US, amid 'kidnap plot' claim
>>14697983 PDF: Julian Assange supporters write to Scott Morrison over reported CIA plot to kidnap or kill WikiLeaks founder
#18 - Part 16
Cardinal George Pell and Vatican Financial Scandal Allegations
>>14648895 Cardinal Pell says he 'never really approved' of Benedict XVI's decision to resign
>>14657285 Catholics should debate issues, not debase each other, Cardinal George Pell said at "The Church Up Close" seminar
>>14657313 Video: VII Edition - The Church Up Close - September 23 - santacrocevideo
#18 - Part 17
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial
>>14404558 SAS soldiers who faced the sack after extraordinary press conference accusing them of war crimes will FINALLY keep their jobs - and at least one is already back in Kabul saving Aussies from the Taliban
>>14461837 Defence Minister Peter Dutton apologises to any special forces troops wrongly accused of war crimes in Afghanistan
>>14490409 'Insensitive insult': Fury over move to disband Aussie SAS unit, 2 Squadron
>>14490463 As Australia's war crimes investigations drag on, misinformation is catching up - Nick McKenzie and Chris Masters - theage.com.au
>>14555183 SAS survives to fight another day as Defence Minister Peter Dutton blocks move to merge selection courses for Perth-based SASR and Sydney-based 2nd Commando Regiment from next year
>>14698105 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial should be moved out of Sydney, lawyer says - Long delays and postponements mean former SAS soldier may not receive a fair trial, says his barrister
>>14716165 He's Australia's Most Decorated Soldier. Did He Also Kill Helpless Afghans? - Ben Roberts-Smith is suing three newspapers that accused him of unlawful killings in Afghanistan. But much more than the reputation of one soldier is at stake
#14716172 at 2021-10-04 06:40:46 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #18 - Talisman Sabre: MAGIC SWORD Edition
>>14716165
2/3
Courtroom Showdown
Ben Roberts-Smith's path to the battlefields of Afghanistan was set at an early age.
He was educated at a prestigious private boys' school in Western Australia that has spawned politicians and mining magnates. Following in the footsteps of his father, a retired army major general and state Supreme Court justice, he joined the military at 18.
He went on to become the only current member to receive the military's two top honors. He was awarded the Medal of Gallantry in 2006 and the Victoria Cross in 2011, both for actions in Afghanistan.
In 2013, the year he left the full-time army, he was named Australia's Father of the Year. Two portraits of him are displayed in the nation's war memorial, as is a uniform he wore in Afghanistan, for which the memorial had to make a special mannequin because Mr. Roberts-Smith stands about 6 feet 8 inches tall.
"Wherever he went, wherever it was, he was the subject and object of what I would regard as reverential mobs," Brendan Nelson, a former defense minister who once led the war memorial, said during the defamation trial.
That changed in 2018, after The Age, a Melbourne newspaper, and its sister newspapers The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times published a series of articles reporting that a powerful and charismatic senior officer had killed or been involved in the murder of Afghan detainees.
Mr. Roberts-Smith was not named in the articles, but he later asserted that he was clearly identifiable. Soon after their publication, he began defamation proceedings against the newspapers.
The papers, which under Australian law have the onus of proving that what they reported was substantially true, have said in court that Mr. Roberts-Smith was involved in six killings, none of which occurred "in the heat of battle."
But over nearly two weeks of testimony in June, Mr. Roberts-Smith strenuously denied the allegations, saying that five of the deaths occurred during combat and that the sixth never happened.
In a packed Sydney courtroom, he painted a noble image of special forces soldiers. "I did everything that I was supposed to do, and I followed the rules," he said.
His virtuous portrayal sometimes clashed with bizarre and lurid details that emerged during the trial. Mr. Roberts-Smith admitted hiring a private investigator to spy on a girlfriend at an abortion clinic after they had agreed to end her pregnancy. He told the court that soldiers had used the prosthetic leg of an Afghan he had killed - an armed Taliban insurgent in his telling, and a prisoner in the journalists' - as a drinking vessel.
As for the centerpiece allegation - that he kicked an Afghan man off a cliff and witnessed his murder - Mr. Roberts-Smith said, "Frankly, I can't see how they can believe it, because none of it adds up."
Three Afghan witnesses, testifying through an interpreter via video from Kabul, told a very different story. They said that they had known Mr. Jan as a laborer who had no Taliban connections. Two said they had seen a "big soldier" kick him off a cliff and later found Mr. Jan's body with bullet wounds.
Mohammed Hanifa, who said he was Mr. Jan's step-nephew, testified that he had been detained alongside Mr. Jan. Both had their hands tied behind their backs, he said.
"I told Ali Jan, don't laugh or don't smile, because they do not like when you smile or when you laugh," he said.
But then the big soldier came, Mr. Hanifa said, and Mr. Jan smiled. The soldier "kicked him really hard," and Mr. Jan "was rolling down, rolling down until he reached the river. The soldier was looking at him. He was standing and looking at him."
Shortly after the Afghan men testified in late July, the proceedings were delayed until November because of a coronavirus outbreak in Sydney. The trial is expected to run well into next year.
(continued)
#14716165 at 2021-10-04 06:38:58 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #18 - Talisman Sabre: MAGIC SWORD Edition
He's Australia's Most Decorated Soldier. Did He Also Kill Helpless Afghans?
Ben Roberts-Smith is suing three newspapers that accused him of unlawful killings in Afghanistan. But much more than the reputation of one soldier is at stake.
Yan Zhuang - Oct. 3, 2021
1/3
MELBOURNE, Australia - The elite Australian troops stormed into a mud-walled Afghan village in the late summer of 2012 on a white-hot mission.
Days earlier, a rogue Afghan Army soldier had killed three of their comrades. A tip indicated that the assailant might be hiding in the village. While a search failed to turn him up, the Australian special forces fatally shot another Afghan man they encountered there.
That much is known. But the moments just before the man's death have become the subject of an intense legal dispute involving Australia's most decorated living soldier, rekindling hard questions about the costs of the country's 20-year mission in Afghanistan and the conduct of its most highly trained soldiers.
In one version of events, the dead man was a laborer named Ali Jan, and he was kicked off a cliff by the decorated soldier, Ben Roberts-Smith. According to this account, Mr. Jan, bound in handcuffs, hit the ground with such force that his teeth were knocked out, and he was then shot dead as Mr. Roberts-Smith watched. This is the story told by three Australian journalists who wrote about the episode and by three Afghan men who say they were at the scene.
In the other version, told by Mr. Roberts-Smith, there was no cliff and no kick, and little evidence that the man was even called Ali Jan. The special forces, Mr. Roberts-Smith said, legitimately engaged and killed the man, who was a Taliban scout.
The two accounts have emerged as Mr. Roberts-Smith, 42, sues three newspapers for defamation in what has been called Australia's trial of the century. He is seeking the largest damages award in Australian history, most likely in the millions of dollars.
Australia removed the last of its troops from Afghanistan in June, weeks before the United States did the same, allowing a rapid takeover of the country by the Taliban. Seven months earlier, the Australian military had released a damning public accounting of years of battlefield misconduct among its special forces in Afghanistan, including "credible evidence" that 25 soldiers had been involved in the murders of 39 Afghan civilians.
No soldiers were named in the report. But it has been revealed in court that Mr. Roberts-Smith, and the events of the late-summer day in 2012, are under police investigation over potential war crimes. With further investigation into battlefield misconduct likely to take years to resolve, the defamation case is the first time any inquiry into soldiers' actions in Afghanistan has played out in open court.
Mr. Roberts-Smith is a symbol of the "Anzac myth," a belief that modern-day Australia was forged by soldiers, stretching back to World War I, who embodied the national values of camaraderie, courage and sacrifice, said John Blaxland, a national security expert and war historian at the Australian National University. "And this case is exposing the weak foundations of the myth," he said.
(continued)
#14698105 at 2021-10-01 07:14:14 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #18 - Talisman Sabre: MAGIC SWORD Edition
Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial should be moved out of Sydney, lawyer says
Long delays and postponements mean former SAS soldier may not receive a fair trial, says his barrister
Ben Doherty - 1 Oct 2021
Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation action should be moved to a new city, his lawyers say, lest it become like "waiting for Godot", as the high-profile trial faces another long delay.
After a week of dramatic evidence from Afghanistan in August, the New South Wales trial was abruptly halted when witnesses could not be brought to Sydney from interstate because of Covid-19 restrictions on their travel.
The court was told it would take between two and three months to relocate the trial to another city and, given the security-sensitive nature of the evidence, the court was not willing to entertain having witnesses appear by video link.
The case was adjourned until 1 November, but there is almost no chance the case will restart then: it appears set to be delayed until at least February next year.
Roberts-Smith is suing the Age, the Sydney Morning Herald and the Canberra Times for defamation over a series of ?reports published in 2018 that he alleges are defamatory because they portray him as someone who "broke the moral and legal rules of military engagement" and committed war crimes, including several murders.
The 42-year-old has consistently denied the allegations, saying they are "false", "baseless" and "completely without any foundation in truth". The newspapers are defending their reporting as true.
Roberts-Smith's barrister, Arthur Moses SC, said the opportunity for Roberts-Smith, a former SAS corporal and winner of the Victoria Cross, to receive a fair trial was being hampered by delays. Roberts-Smith has spent 12 days in the witness box, including seven days of cross-examination, during which allegations of war crimes that have not yet been tested were put to him in open court.
The only other witnesses have been two character witnesses, and the evidence of three Afghan nationals from the village of Darwan, the site of one of the allegations of murder made against Roberts-Smith. Many of the witnesses to come - called by the newspapers - are fellow former members of the SAS who served alongside Roberts-Smith.
Pointing out that the case was first brought in 2018, Moses said the court should actively consider relocating the trial, suggesting Adelaide. South Australia has - at the moment - few Covid cases and lighter restrictions than other states.
"No lawyer can stand here and tell you this trial will resume in February [in NSW]," Moses told Justice Anthony Besanko. "It's a mirage."
He said the defamation action "has to be brought to an end one way or another".
"We need to have a solution, not just keep raising problems. Otherwise we will truly be 'waiting for Godot', waiting for this to finish."
Nicholas Owens SC, for the newspapers, told the court the majority of witnesses for the remainder of the trial were based in Western Australia. Under the current travel restrictions regime, those witnesses would not be allowed to return to WA after giving evidence.
Owens said both sides agreed that the trial could not restart on 1 November, but proposed for the trial be rescheduled to 28 February next year.
He said the Western Australian premier, Mark McGowan, had indicated border and travel restrictions would be relaxed in the months after the state reached 80% double-dose vaccination rate, likely in "February-March-April" of 2022.
But Moses said declarations from state premiers were unreliable.
"One can't rely on the public statements of any politician" for the setting of court dates, he said.
Besanko has reserved his decision.
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2021/oct/01/Ben-Roberts-Smith-defamation-trial-should-be-moved-out-of-sydney-lawyer-says
#14490475 at 2021-08-30 07:35:49 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #18 - Talisman Sabre: MAGIC SWORD Edition
>>14490473
5/5
By June this year, the army had issued 17 notices that required special forces soldiers to "show cause" as to why they should not be sacked. But 13 of these 17 had already been discharged on health or other grounds. Of the four remaining soldiers issued notices, two are reservists (one is serving with the UAE armed forces). Of the 17, this masthead confirmed only one soldier who remains on active duty with the SAS in Perth.
Defence hierarchy is refusing to provide details about why they did not force the 17 men's sacking, but many ADF insiders point out that given most were already discharged, it was hardly the scandal some wanted it to be.
For its part, the Daily Mail's editor is standing by its reporting, including the false claim of a war crimes accused deployed to Kabul (it reported the false claim a second time on Thursday), as well as his outlet's role switching a World War I Iron Cross with a World War II medal engraved with a swastika in a story he later pulled from the internet.
"The stories broken by Daily Mail Australia surrounding our elite soldiers are extraordinary - but they are fair, accurate, and written by a respected journalist with more than 25 years' reporting experience. These are stories that need to be told," Mr Heywood said in a statement.
By far the most serious recommendation of the Brereton inquiry was the referral of serving and former soldiers for criminal investigation. All 19 soldiers referred for their alleged participation in executions remain under active investigation by the AFP and the Office of the Special Investigator.
The apparent attempt to wish away the severity of Brereton's findings ignore that fact.
PR and spin
The most prominent war crimes accused in Australia, Ben Roberts-Smith, has issued no public statements in the past few weeks. He is the subject of three active federal police investigations, including two war crimes inquiries that have sent briefs of evidence to the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions to rule on whether the police case is strong enough to charge him.
Roberts-Smith is also suing this masthead and the authors for defamation. But for almost four years, he has been paying public relations advisers Sue Cato and, more recently, Helen McCombie, to advise him how to maximise positive media coverage.
In the last month, Roberts-Smith's employer, SevenWestMedia, published not only the false story about the war crimes accused sent to Kabul, but also the Daily Mail's copy about the SAS soldier and the swastika-engraved Iron Cross.
Weeks before that, the Daily Telegraph published a front-page story that falsely claimed another key police witness against Roberts-Smith was party to the covert recordings of conversations involving the war hero. The recordings captured Roberts-Smith talking about destroying the reputations of journalists, politicians and soldiers who had challenged his war record.
One of Roberts-Smith's defamation lawyers is also a lawyer for the Daily Mail.
There is no evidence or suggestion that Roberts-Smith, his lawyers or his PR agents, are tied to the latest misreporting.
Some in Defence are frustrated that General Angus Campbell and other senior officers and politicians are not seeking to counter the misinformation and remind the public that it was special forces soldiers themselves who chose to stand up against the alleged misdeeds of a very small number of their colleagues.
But talking about accountability for war crimes remains politically unpopular, says Neil James. And as the ongoing AFP and OSI investigations into 19 former soldiers are likely to take many months, if not years, to resolve, there is plenty of time for a misinformation campaign to build.
And now, even the fact that men such as Soldier X chose truth and redemption over a cover-up is at risk of being obscured by half-truths, lies and spin.
https://www.theage.com.au/national/as-australia-s-war-crimes-investigations-drag-on-misinformation-is-catching-up-20210826-p58m31.html
#14490469 at 2021-08-30 07:33:55 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #18 - Talisman Sabre: MAGIC SWORD Edition
>>14490465
3/5
But even without these confidential reports to the inquiry, there is plenty of evidence. Whistleblowers have provided significant public statements. Three Afghan war veterans, ex-SAS medic Dusty Miller, ex-SAS signals intelligence officer Braden Chapman and ex-SAS operator "Tom", have all given extensive interviews to Mark Willacy for his book, Rogue Forces, released this month.
The book gives the most in-depth account yet of an alleged execution, captured on helmet camera, of an apparently unarmed Afghan man lying in a field. Footage of this incident infamously shows a now former SAS soldier asking his superior: "Do you want me to drop this c-nt?," then shooting the man dead.
Dusty Miller, whose story was first told by this masthead in 2019, has spoken up repeatedly in defence of the Brereton Inquiry, and about how an injured unarmed Afghan, Haji Sardar, was allegedly murdered by a senior SAS soldier after he was taken from Mr Miller's care.
"There's lots of us that have gone, 'This happened. That happened'," Miller has said, describing the Brereton report as "vindication".
Despite all this, some media are now undermining the war crimes narrative in the public mind.
The tabloid Daily Mail website has been the recent launching pad for much of this misinformation, but other outlets such as The West Australian, Sydney's Daily Telegraph, and shock jock radio hosts are taking it up with enthusiasm.
Tracing misinformation
The first hint of a campaign appeared in December in The Guardian which ran two pictures supplied by a freelance reporter. One featured two SAS soldiers skylarking in a makeshift bar with the prosthetic leg of a Taliban fighter allegedly executed weeks earlier by ex-SAS soldier Ben Roberts-Smith.
Hundreds of photos exist depicting dozens of SAS soldiers and officers at the same bar also posing with the leg. The fact of the leg's removal and use as a drinking vessel was revealed by this masthead in 2018. Why were these specific pictures released? Perhaps it's related to the fact that both men are witnesses for the AFP because they allege they saw another SAS soldier execute a prisoner.
The freelancer has declined to answer questions about this, but has privately told colleagues at The Guardian that he was unaware of this critical fact. One of the two men also voluntarily revealed to the Brereton inquiry in 2018 that he was the one who had taken the leg from the allegedly executed Taliban prisoner. He also provided the Brereton inquiry with photos of the leg mounted on a board. He made the disclosure, which at the point was unknown to investigators, despite the likely adverse impact on his own career.
Two weeks after The Guardian's article, the Daily Mail took the story up. It ran the same photo but also falsely asserted both men were "facing the sack". One of the men would later be issued a show-cause notice for misconduct unrelated to the leg, but it was overturned. The second SAS soldier was, to the contrary, recommended for promotion by the Brereton inquiry for his bravery in exposing alleged war crimes. Just last week, he was deployed on an SAS mission to Kabul to help rescue stranded Australians.
(continued)
#14385834 at 2021-08-18 07:30:43 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #18 - Talisman Sabre: MAGIC SWORD Edition
#17 - Part 21
Coronavirus / COVID-19 Pandemic, Australia and Worldwide - Part 2
>>14200915 Anti-lockdown protests a coalition of the alienated and the far-right: Nationalists, so-called "sovereign citizens", anti-vaccination groups, QAnon and Trump followers - Miki Perkins - brisbanetimes.com.au
>>14200931 Revealed: the fringe groups where Sydney's lockdown protest began - Fergus Hunter and Laura Chung - smh.com.au
>>14200941 Inside Telegram fringe groups behind protests where conspiracy theories spread - Rohan Smith - news.com.au
>>14206587 George Christensen appears at anti-lockdown rally alongside QAnon supporters - Tobi Loftus - abc.net.au
>>14206651 Who's behind Australia's anti-lockdown protests? The German conspiracy group "Worldwide Demonstration" driving marches - Christopher Knaus and Michael McGowan - theguardian.com
>>14206760 Hotel quarantine raid for child abuse material; Border Force seize childlike sex dolls
>>14213333 PM: Lockdowns a 'thing of the past' by Christmas as vaccine rollout ramps up - Sky News Australia
>>14213379 Australian Federal Police investigators offer help to state counterparts dealing with online organisers of violent anti-lockdown protests
>>14213414 Coronavirus Australia: Protests show we may be in for a rude shock - Jack The Insider (Peter Hoysted) - theaustralian.com.au
>>14213655 Suicidal, stressed Aussie kids flood emergency wards - Lockdowns and online learning fuelling anxiety, some too scared to breathe outdoors due to virus fears
>>14220726 Australia's Sydney posts record daily rise in COVID-19 cases, seeks military help
>>14220773 Worldwide hacking warning issued on how businesses are being compromised during COVID-19
>>14220789 U.S., U.K., and Australia Issue Joint Cybersecurity Advisory - Australian Cyber Security Centre - July 2021
>>14228786 Video: Prime Minister Scott Morrison says lockdowns to end once 80 per cent of the Australian population is vaccinated against COVID-19
>>14228831 Covid case linked to Sydney's anti-lockdown protest investigated for breaching self-isolation rules
>>14228845 Intelligence officials looking at the role of foreign actors in stirring up Australian anti-lockdown rallies
>>14243099 Australia's east coast battles rising COVID-19 cases
>>14243113 Sydney anti-lockdown protest never arrived, but the movement is just getting started
>>14243136 Covid cocktail given to Trump now recommended for Aussies - casirivimab plus imdevimab, or REGEN-COV, made by US company Regeneron
>>14243180 YouTube restricts Sky News Australia channel over 'COVID misinformation'
>>14245410 Our resilience has silenced Covid prophets of doom - "You are more resilient than you think…The Covid pandemic has done its worst and humanity has survived"
>>14245420 Vaccination the gold medal we aspire to - Prime Minister Scott Morrison - theaustralian.com.au
>>14245938 "Forcing qr checkin is illegal. - PRIVACY ACT 1988 - SECT 94H - Requiring the use of COVIDSafe"
>>14249450 Video: YouTube's Murdoch ban over COVID lies - Kevin Rudd
>>14249826 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case adjourned due to Sydney COVID outbreak
>>14257276 Australia can 'realistically' reach COVID-19 vaccine targets by end of year, infectious disease experts say
>>14265549 Covid-19 returns to Wuhan, China - Wuhan is in a "wartime state", local officials say
>>14273935 Sydney suffers worst day of pandemic, Victoria state to enter sixth lockdown
>>14282319 Delta spreads in Sydney as Australia widens COVID-19 restrictions
>>14282778 Video: Bill gates praises Australia's Covid response, plays down relevance of virus origins investigations
#14385831 at 2021-08-18 07:30:22 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #18 - Talisman Sabre: MAGIC SWORD Edition
#17 - Part 20
Coronavirus / COVID-19 Pandemic, Australia and Worldwide - Part 1
>>14020199 Lockdown measures extended in Australia amid COVID-19 outbreak - June 2021
>>14020312 Video: Queensland's Chief Health Officer Jeannette Young rejects Prime Minister's comments on AstraZeneca's COVID-19 vaccine for under-40s
>>14020328 'A personal choice': NSW clinics will not give AstraZeneca to under-40s
>>14021844 Video: "Lone woman on train harassed by police who then absconded with her property."
>>14035752 Australia to slash traveller intake, PM announces four-phase pathway out of COVID-19
>>14041172 Covid-19 vaccine targets to unlock the path to freedom - National cabinet agrees to four-step blueprint for phased easing of restrictions once Australians have met new vaccine thresholds
>>14041436 Lockdowns 'can stop in two months' when Covid-19 vaccines hit 30pc: Deakin University chair in epidemiology Catherine Bennett
>>14050812 'Eat a bat and die': Vile threats against Wuhan lab conspiracy-buster, Australian virologist Danielle Anderson
>>14050829 Ben Roberts-Smith's long wait to face accusers - landmark trial adjourned for at least a month after Sydney's COVID-19 outbreak
>>14057811 OPINION: Greg Hunt has failed to vaccinate the nation and must go - Kevin Rudd - brisbanetimes.com.au
>>14085663 Covid-19: Australia 'talks softly and carries a big ?vaccine' in Pacific
>>14098337 Australia reports first 2021 COVID-19 death, highest case number
>>14105467 Senior business figures turned to former PM Kevin Rudd to intervene in bringing forward Australia's Pfizer vaccine supply
>>14105480 Malcolm Turnbull Tweet: Thank you @MrKRudd for speaking to the Chairman of Pfizer to secure an earlier delivery of vaccines. Staggered the vaccination of Australians was apparently not important enough to warrant a call from @ScottMorrisonMP or @GregHuntMP to the Pfizer boss.
>>14105482 Pfizer denies Kevin Rudd helped Australia gain earlier access to COVID-19 vaccines
>>14105484 Defence Minister Peter Dutton tears into Rudd's talks with Pfizer
>>14105492 Peter Dutton Tweet: @MrKRudd - Pfizer statement: Recent media reports suggesting that any third party or individual has had any role in contractual agreements reached between Pfizer and the Australian government are inaccurate. The only two parties involved in these agreements are Pfizer and the Australian government.
>>14110865 Australian Vax push isn't supported by the data
>>14127170 Melbourne joins Sydney in lockdown as COVID-19 spreads in Australia
>>14141277 Sydney tightens lockdown as Australia's COVID-19 cases rise
>>14141315 Scott Morrison demands answers over COVID origins after WHO Wuhan lab leak concession
>>14141320 Video: Premature to rule out lab leak: World Health Organisation Director-General Tedros Adhanom - Sky News Australia
>>14141323 Video: PM says world 'deserves answers' over COVID origins - Sky News Australia
>>14159491 Australia's COVID-19 lockdowns cover more than half the 25 million population
>>14172626 Video: Prime Minister says 'sorry' for problems with COVID-19 vaccine rollout program
>>14174776 SA-Best Party MP Frank Pangallo Says Unvaccinated People "Need To Be Controlled And Restricted"
>>14180599 Sydney's COVID-19 outbreak throws harsh spotlight on Australia vaccine rollout
>>14180610 Australia's TGA finds Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine is safe for children aged 12 to 15
>>14194970 Australians may face longer lockdown after "reckless" mass protests
>>14200877 Lockdown protesters plotted on social media - Anthony Khallouf and "Australians vs The Agenda" - Rhiannon Down - theaustralian.com.au
#14385818 at 2021-08-18 07:28:14 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #18 - Talisman Sabre: MAGIC SWORD Edition
#17 - Part 14
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial
>>14035776 Allegations of serious criminal conduct exposed in Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case
>>14050829 Ben Roberts-Smith's long wait to face accusers - landmark trial adjourned for at least a month after Sydney's COVID-19 outbreak
>>14071758 Ben Roberts-Smith secures hospital records after claim 'mistress' faked pregnancy
>>14079290 Taliban circle as Afghan witnesses in Ben Roberts-Smith case wait in a safe house
>>14092203 The Untouchables: Top detectives to investigate 'disgraceful' Afghanistan kill squad
>>14120285 Media seeks urgent hearing for Afghan witnesses in Roberts-Smith case
>>14153436 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial to resume to hear from four Afghan witnesses
>>14159595 'Anguished' Ben Roberts-Smith calls for trial to resume
>>14166231 No medical record of Roberts-Smith 'mistress' abortion, court told
>>14200983 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial told radio device was planted on body of dead Afghan farmer
>>14206696 Afghan farmer tells Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial Australian soldiers who raided villages are 'infidels'
>>14206700 'Wrong morally': Official photo of Ben Roberts-Smith was altered to hide Crusader's cross
>>14213699 Afghan villager tells Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial he'll tell truth even if it gets him killed
>>14220805 Foreign soldiers killed 'innocent' Afghans, Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial told
>>14228975 Ben Roberts-Smith trial hears from Afghan witness who says 'big soldier' kicked man into creek
>>14249826 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case adjourned due to Sydney COVID outbreak
>>14257322 Barrister acting for Ben Roberts-Smith urges Federal Court to admit into evidence WhatsApp messages that allegedly show key witness for Nine newspapers, Afghan villager Mohammed Hanifa, gave "inconsistent statement" while under cross-examination
>>14257358 PDF: 'Serious failings': Defence quietly releases war crimes inquiry response plan
>>14347185 Ben Roberts-Smith's alleged USB backyard burial revealed in pictures taken by his ex wife
>>14347246 'Not that f*cking stupid': How 'threats' ruined Roberts-Smith's friendship with private investigator John McLeod
>>14375655 Why we lost Afghanistan: War hero Ben Roberts-Smith says the West never understood the Taliban were more than a 'rag-tag group of bogey men'
#14019875 at 2021-06-30 06:26:39 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
#16 - Part 17
Coronavirus / COVID-19 Pandemic, Australia and Worldwide - Part 2
>>13890985 Chinese Consulate General in Sydney Tweet: Proponents of the theory that the virus which causes #COVID_19 was created in and escaped from #China's Wuhan Institute of Virology imply that new evidence has emerged to support it, but in fact none has: Australian Citizens Party.
>>13890985 Still no evidence for COVID-19 leak from Wuhan lab: media - xinhuanet.com
>>13890985 Still no evidence for COVID 'lab leak' theory - Richard Bardon, Australian Alert Service - citizensparty.org.au
>>13895726 Video: WORLD EXCLUSIVE: Footage proves bats were kept in Wuhan lab - Sky News Australia -
>>13898710 Video: Wuhan live bat video contradicts WHO investigation - Sharri Markson - theaustralian.com.au
>>13907925 Wuhan bat video shows much of pandemic origin information was 'Chinese disinformation' - Sky News Australia / Fox News / Tucker Carlson
>>13914986 Victoria continued to use Uighur labour firm to avoid delays on $2.4b rail project
>>13929552 Video: Bombshell Evidence: Live Bats in Wuhan Lab & "Intense Clashes" Between China & France - Inconvenient Truths by Jennifer Zeng
>>13929580 Video: (Google Translation) Record the construction and research team of Wuhan P4 laboratory of Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences - zmkxj.cas.cn
>>13929743 Coronavirus: WA, Qld Covid check-in data accessible to foreign authorities
>>13949295 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial resumes after war veteran tests negative for COVID
>>13984301 Greg Hunt orders review into risky Wuhan research - CSIRO and several Australian universities engaged in at least 10 joint projects with Wuhan Institute of Virology in the past decade
>>13998806 China's terrifying virus warning - Warnings of the 'threat to mankind' came in Beijing's declaration to a UN meeting under the Biological Weapons Convention
>>14003854 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial headed for adjournment due to COVID lockdown
>>14003983 Australian scientist Danielle Anderson - the sole foreign researcher at the Wuhan lab speaks out
>>14004038 Australia's COVID-19 response team holds urgent meeting amid outbreak
>>14006907 PDF: Australian researcher's stunning Covid origin find - "coronavirus appears to be best adapted to attack human cells" - Professor Nikolai Petrovsky
>>14008034 9 News National Vaccine Rollout coverage: Total Doses Administered: 7,364,666
>>14012112 Chinese Consulate General in Sydney Tweet: Video: The accusation of "Wuhan laboratory leaking the novel coronavirus" has no factual basis. "I do not believe the virus was manmade." said #Australia's Dr. Danielle Anderson, the #Wuhan Institute of Virology's last foreign scientist, about the Institute.
>>14012285 'We'll take it': Countries line up to take CSL's Australian-made AstraZeneca vaccine
#14019856 at 2021-06-30 06:21:03 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
#16 - Part 10
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 2
>>13907649 Roberts-Smith hired investigator to check woman was having an abortion
>>13915189 Ben Roberts-Smith used pre-paid phones due to phone hacking fears, defamation trial hears
>>13922371 Ben Roberts-Smith tells defamation trial soldiers were allowed to use 'whatever force was necessary'
>>13929610 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case: Elite soldiers 'covered up' cliff execution, court told
>>13929643 PDF: MP Andrew Hastie set to testify on allegedly 'blooded' rookie soldier in Ben Roberts-Smith case
>>13936569 Video: Media's barrister circles Ben Roberts-Smith, campaign by campaign
>>13949295 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial resumes after war veteran tests negative for COVID
>>13955973 Ben Roberts-Smith denies murdering Afghan prisoner and watching execution of elderly man, court hears
>>13979274 Ben Roberts-Smith in fiery exchange with Channel 9 lawyer - calling accusations he cheated on bravery medal to cover up killing teenager "disgusting"
>>13979328 Ben-Roberts Smith punched woman in face in Canberra hotel room, court told - 'The whole story is a fabrication,' soldier says
>>13979455 Afghan translators who helped military flown to Australia on protection visas
>>13984690 There are two versions of the facts at Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial. Neither is kind to the SAS
>>14003827 Former defence minister Brendan Nelson backs 'revered' Ben Roberts-Smith
>>14003854 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial headed for adjournment due to COVID lockdown
>>14012226 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial halted for a month because of Sydney's COVID-19 outbreak
#14019853 at 2021-06-30 06:20:16 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
#16 - Part 9
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry and Ben Roberts-Smith Defamation Trial - Part 1
>>13748711 Ben Roberts-Smith wiped laptop days after being told to retain documents, court told
>>13748743 Australian Embassy in Kabul packs up as troops prepare to leave
>>13805129 Ben Roberts-Smith's old comrade ordered to hand documents to media
>>13812141 War crimes investigators to monitor Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial
>>13812152 National security concerns likely to keep Ben Roberts-Smith trial offline
>>13819262 Ben Roberts-Smith's lawyers say ex-wife leaked photos of soldiers drinking from prosthetic leg
>>13819270 Ben Roberts-Smith 'extremely paranoid and obsessive' over inquiry, courts hears
>>13826910 Peter Dutton's war crimes meddling risks truth telling: researcher Dr Samantha Crompvoets
>>13826954 Ben Roberts-Smith launches proceedings against ex-wife on eve of trial
>>13848125 'Corrosive jealousy and lies' behind Ben Roberts-Smith war crime claims, court told
>>13848138 Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial told soldiers drank beer from dead Afghan man's prosthetic leg
>>13855419 Court told Ben Roberts-Smith to seek huge payout after reputation 'smashed and destroyed'
>>13855472 Afghan translators for Australian diggers now targets of Taliban threats
>>13862445 Ben Roberts-Smith's case against ex-wife complicated after judge raises 'relationship' with lawyer, Monica Allen
>>13869304 Ben Roberts-Smith's claims 'inherently implausible' media's barrister tells court
>>13869327 Ben Roberts-Smith: veteran launches attack on ex-colleagues
>>13877222 Ben Roberts-Smith tells defamation trial he did not kick handcuffed man off cliff
>>13884615 Australia owes Afghani interpreters for their combat bravery - former SAS team commander Harry Moffitt
>>13884625 Video: Scott Morrison gives strongest indication yet that Afghan interpreters will be offered protection
>>13907636 Ben Roberts-Smith tells defamation trial he's disgusted by domestic violence claims
#14012226 at 2021-06-29 07:22:46 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial halted for a month because of Sydney's COVID-19 outbreak
Jamie McKinnell - 29 June 2021
The high-stakes defamation trial of war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith has been paused for at least a month due to Sydney's COVID-19 lockdown.
Justice Anthony Besanko today adjourned the case for mention in three weeks, with a view to the trial starting again one week later.
It comes after the Federal Court heard three weeks of evidence and Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team closed his case on Monday.
The court has been told defence witnesses due to travel to Sydney would either be barred from returning home or endure quarantine impediments.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age, The Canberra Times and three journalists over reports published in 2018 which contained serious allegations about his deployments to Afghanistan.
The Victoria Cross recipient has denied allegations of unlawful killings in Afghanistan, bullying of his former soldier colleagues in the Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) and committing an act of domestic violence against his then-lover in 2018 at a Canberra hotel.
Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team closed his case on Monday after three weeks of evidence, about a third of which he spent under tense cross-examination in the witness box.
But Nicholas Owens SC, the barrister for two of the newspapers, yesterday said the lockdown meant interstate defence witnesses would either be barred from returning home or face quarantine impediments if they travelled to Sydney.
The judge agreed the real issue was not the expiry of Sydney's stay-at-home orders, but the hard borders with other states and self-isolation requirements.
"In my opinion, it would not be a fair or proportionate exercise to enforce the attendance of these witnesses in the circumstances and at this point in time," Justice Besanko told the court today.
Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Bruce McClintock SC, yesterday conceded the adjournment was "a tragedy", but said he wasn't willing to cross-examine over video link and witnesses had a right for their lives not to be "completely upended".
Publisher Nine Entertainment is relying on a truth defence and will call 21 former or current SAS operatives, Mr Roberts-Smith's ex-wife Emma Roberts, and the woman with whom he had an affair.
A group of people known as "the Afghan witnesses" will also give evidence over video link from Afghanistan at some point in the proceedings.
Mr Owens today said the security situation in Afghanistan was "deteriorating rapidly" and Nine is concerned to have the evidence of the witnesses, currently in Kabul, heard as soon as possible.
They are expected to speak about the death of a farmer named Ali Jan, who Mr Roberts-Smith is accused of interrogating, handcuffing and kicking over a cliff during a 2012 mission in the village of Darwan.
Nine alleges he then entered into an agreement with other soldiers that Ali Jan be executed, before covering up the conduct by making it look like he was shot during a legitimate engagement.
Mr Roberts-Smith, 42, has told the court a man shot dead during that mission was a suspected Taliban "spotter" who had been hiding in a cornfield.
The adjournment will cause a blowout in the trial's lengthy duration, which was already estimated to take up to 10 weeks.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-06-29/Ben-Roberts-Smith-defamation-trial-paused-due-to-covid-outbreak/100251262
#14003854 at 2021-06-28 09:26:11 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial headed for adjournment due to COVID lockdown
Jamie McKinnell - 28 June 2021
The defamation trial of war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith is "bedevilled by the virus", his barrister says and appears headed towards an unavoidable adjournment.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and the Canberra Times, along with three journalists, over a series of articles they published in 2018.
But as his legal team closed their case on Monday after three weeks of evidence, the barrister for two of the newspapers, Nicholas Owens SC, told the Federal Court the prospect of their witnesses travelling to Sydney had been complicated by the city's COVID lockdown.
"The problem is, although people could get here, there is a prohibition on them returning home or a very great burden placed on them in relation to their travel home," he said.
Mr Owens said witnesses from WA, Victoria and Queensland would either be barred completely from returning after being in Sydney or endure various forms of hotel or home quarantine.
He accepted it was an "entirely unsatisfactory" position, but one which the court had been "driven to by unforeseen circumstances".
Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Bruce McClintock SC, said it was "a terrible quandary" and his client very much wanted the case to continue and conclude.
"This case is bedevilled by the virus I'm afraid," he said.
Mr McClintock said he was not willing to forego the opportunity to cross-examine witnesses in person, making audio-visual link appearances unlikely.
Justice Anthony Besanko has adjourned the trial until Tuesday morning to consider the situation.
Earlier, former Liberal leader Brendan Nelson told the court Mr Roberts-Smith was "the most respected, admired and revered Australian soldier in more than half a century".
Dr Nelson, who was the director of the Australian War Memorial from 2012, was today called as a witness by Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team to give evidence about his reputation prior to the articles.
"Ben Roberts-Smith, VC, MG, was the most respected, admired and revered Australian soldier in more than half a century since Keith Payne VC of the Vietnam war," he told the Federal Court in Sydney.
"Wherever he went, wherever it was, he was the subject and the object of what I would regard as reverential mobs," he continued.
Mr Roberts-Smith has denied all allegations in the stories, including alleged involvement in unlawful killings in Afghanistan, bullying of Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) colleagues, and domestic violence against his then-lover in a Canberra hotel in 2018.
Dr Nelson said he "immediately" knew the first article was about Mr Roberts-Smith, despite him not being identified by name, due to references like his tattoos and stature.
Dr Nelson explained his concern for Mr Roberts-Smith after noticing changes in him following the publication.
"He'd become despondent, he'd become anxious, introspective, much less willing to engage in public events which he had willingly given of himself to previously, and the invitations to do so had declined," Dr Nelson said.
The proceedings have moved online in the fourth week of the trial due to Sydney's COVID-19 lockdown, with members of the public excluded from the city's Law Courts building.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-06-28/Ben-Roberts-Smith-brendan-nelson-defamation-trial/100248658
#14003827 at 2021-06-28 09:20:58 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Former defence minister Brendan Nelson backs 'revered' Ben Roberts-Smith
Michaela Whitbourn - June 28, 2021
Former federal defence minister Brendan Nelson has described Ben Roberts-Smith as "the most respected, admired and revered" Australian soldier in more than half a century and accused the media outlets at the centre of the war veteran's Federal Court defamation case of trying to tarnish his good reputation.
Giving reputation evidence, Dr Nelson, a former director of the Australian War Memorial, said he had become "very concerned" about Mr Roberts-Smith's mental health in the wake of a series of articles starting in June 2018. The newspapers "seemed to be intent on bringing him down," and the former soldier had become despondent, anxious and introspective, Dr Nelson said in Sydney on Monday.
The former Liberal minister gave evidence on the 15th day of Mr Roberts-Smith's defamation trial against The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald over articles that he says accuse him of war crimes, and an act of domestic violence against a woman with whom he had an extramarital affair. Mr Roberts-Smith, a former Special Air Service (SAS) soldier, denies all wrongdoing. The newspapers are seeking to rely chiefly on a defence of truth, but also say he is not identified in some of the articles.
An at-times emotional Dr Nelson said "I'll try not to get angry about this" as he recounted a media conference in 2018 about an exhibition on First Nations Australians' military service, at which there was "not one single question" on that topic but a string of questions about Mr Roberts-Smith. He was asked if he regretted his support for Mr Roberts-Smith and if the former soldier should have his Victoria Cross removed.
"It has been devastating, the impact on him," Dr Nelson said. He added he was cautioned by a very senior public figure, "not the prime minister", seemingly about his public association with Mr Roberts-Smith.
Dr Nelson said he recognised Mr Roberts-Smith "immediately" in two stories in June 2018 referring to a soldier dubbed "Leonidas". The articles referred to tattoos and a "fearsome warrior", Dr Nelson said, and it was clear to him this was a reference to the two-metre-tall Mr Roberts-Smith, a "tall, imposing, warrior-like figure" who has a number of tattoos.
Prior to the articles, Mr Roberts-Smith was "the most respected, admired and revered Australian soldier in more than half a century, since Keith Payne, VC, of the Vietnam War", he said.
Dr Nelson recalled that "wherever he went … he was the subject and the object of what I would describe as reverential mobs", and he witnessed people at the War Memorial "fall into his arms" describing their experiences.
He said he was "certainly unaware of any such behaviour" when asked about the allegation of domestic violence, which has been vehemently denied by Mr Roberts-Smith.
Dr Parbodh Gogna, formerly chief medical officer and surgeon-general of the Department of Home Affairs and Australian Border Force in Canberra, said via audiovisual link from the Bahamas that there was a "large cloud" hanging over his friend Mr Roberts-Smith since the articles and he had become withdrawn and apprehensive.
During re-examination by his own barrister on Monday, Mr Roberts-Smith said he "didn't ask for any of my medals nor did I expect any recognition" for doing his job, and it was "disgraceful" of the newspapers to challenge the basis for his Victoria Cross in court.
Mr Roberts-Smith has taken leave during the trial from his position as general manager of media company Seven Queensland. His employer, Seven West Media chairman Kerry Stokes, is chairman of the Australian War Memorial and is funding the defamation case.
The Federal Court streamed the trial online on Monday after the NSW government imposed a two-week lockdown in Greater Sydney on Saturday following a growing cluster of COVID-19 cases linked to Bondi. The parties and their lawyers remained in court.
Barrister Nicholas Owens, SC, for the media outlets, said the "bottom line … with much regret", was the proceedings would likely need to be halted temporarily within days because most witnesses to be called by the newspapers would be affected by hard border closures or quarantine restrictions in their home states.
"As soon as things are open again, we're ready to go," Mr Owens said
"This case is bedevilled by the virus," Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Bruce McClintock, SC, said.
Justice Anthony Besanko will make a decision about the timetabling of the trial on Tuesday.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/former-defence-minister-brendan-nelson-backs-revered-Ben-Roberts-Smith-20210628-p584v4.html
#13984690 at 2021-06-26 01:07:25 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
There are two versions of the facts at Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial. Neither is kind to the SAS
Nick Grimm - 26 June 2021
1/3
Ben Roberts-Smith is a hard bloke to miss.
I almost barrelled into the two-metre-plus former soldier on Sydney's Macquarie Street as I rushed to buy a coffee.
We danced that familiar shuffle performed by thousands of city-street pedestrians every day as our brains calculated the best odds of shifting either left or right to avoid collision. Australia's most decorated soldier smiled and with a polite "excuse me", we each continued on our solitary way.
Me to that coffee shop. Him to Courtroom 18D of the Australian Federal Court in Sydney to face another day in the witness box at his headline-grabbing defamation proceedings where at one point he was asked how he felt people viewed him.
"I walk down the street and people will look at me," he told the court through tears.
"The first thing I think of is that they think I hit a woman."
But the allegation he punched his lover in the face after a day of heavy drinking isn't his only source of torment. Killing teenaged insurgents is another.
"I saw things in Afghanistan and I did things in Afghanistan like having to engage adolescents that I'm not proud of and I live with that ... I accept that and that is a trauma I've lived with."
Mr Roberts-Smith has brought the defamation proceedings in a bid to clear his name of the slew of allegations in newspaper articles that he says labelled him as a war criminal, a bully and a domestic violence offender.
The man heaped with honour and distinctions for his war service insists he was immediately identifiable as the soldier dubbed "Leonidas" in the stories, thanks to his family connections in the military, distinctive tattoos and his towering height.
"I've had to watch my family's good name dragged through the mud for three years," he told the court.
But the case is also seeing the good name of Australia's military get dragged through the muck.
Both legal teams have presented unflattering pictures of SAS
Legal counsel acting for the defendants, Nine Entertainment, Nicholas Owens has told the court it will be presented with two diametrically opposed versions of events that unfolded during Australia's involvement in the war in Afghanistan.
But regardless of which side succeeds in this case, both legal teams have presented distinctly unflattering pictures of the Australian Army's elite SAS regiment, certain to tarnish the image of a professional, highly disciplined and drilled fighting force.
Nine will argue that war criminals served within its ranks, men who murdered or were complicit in the murder of unarmed prisoners. And while Mr Roberts-Smith vehemently denies being a war criminal or a witness to war crimes, he himself describes a military force wracked by "corrosive jealousy" and infighting, bitter resentments and often prone to displays of outright incompetence on the battlefield.
It stands in stark contrast to the SAS's long-held image as the best of the best.
In his 2006 book The Partnership: The Inside Story of US-Australian Alliance Under Howard and Bush, Greg Sheridan gave this description of the regiment:
"The SAS is the cream of the Australian military ... as good as any special forces formation in the world."
The author goes on to quote former US deputy secretary of state Richard Armitage.
"The Australian SAS are shit-hot, and our people love to work with them," he said.
(continued)
#13979328 at 2021-06-25 11:45:10 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Ben-Roberts Smith punched woman in face in Canberra hotel room, court told
'The whole story is a fabrication,' soldier says after court hears he also took pictures of the unconscious woman naked
Ben Doherty - 25 Jun 2021
1/2
Ben Roberts-Smith has been accused in court of punching a woman in the face in a Canberra hotel room, taking pictures of her naked body while she was unconscious and then initiating sex with her.
The soldier has vehemently denied the allegations, saying they are "completely false".
"The whole story is a fabrication," he told the court.
The details of Roberts-Smith's tempestuous relationship with a woman, known in court documents as "Person 17" , were put before the federal court as part of the Victoria Cross recipient's defamation against three newspapers he says have defamed him by portraying him as a war criminal and an abuser of women.
The court heard at one point in their relationship, after an altercation, he sent her a message by phone: "Don't fucking abuse me again, because it won't end well."
Roberts-Smith did not deny sending the message but said "it wasn't a threat", and that he did not know the context in which it was sent.
The court has previously heard Roberts-Smith hired a private investigator to secretly surveil and film Person 17 as she attended a Brisbane abortion clinic to terminate a pregnancy the pair had agreed to end.
Roberts-Smith said he did so because he didn't believe the woman was pregnant and that she was trying to manipulate him.
Roberts-Smith and Person 17 had a subsequent discussion at a hotel, in which he showed her the secret surveillance video of her at the abortion clinic, and she said she had been pregnant but had earlier had a miscarriage.
Owens put it to Roberts-Smith he said to Person 17: "I will burn your house down if you turn on me and it might not be you that gets hurt but people that you love". Roberts-Smith denied saying those words.
Roberts-Smith has been accused of assaulting Person 17 in a Canberra hotel room after a dinner at the great hall of Parliament House on 28 March 2018.
The woman fell downstairs as she was leaving Parliament House with Roberts-Smith.
He has told the court she injured her head - resulting in a black eye - from this fall.
The newspapers allege the injury resulted from him punching her later on in the hotel.
Nicholas Owens, SC, for the newspapers, said that following the woman's fall, Roberts-Smith helped her into the back seat of a commonwealth car that would drive them to the Realm hotel.
Owens put it to Roberts-Smith the woman had asked to be taken to hospital, and the driver offered - twice - to take them, but he refused, saying he could look after her.
In the hotel room, the court was told, Roberts-Smith shook Person 17 by the shoulders and said: "Fuck … what have you done? You were all over men at dinner. I should have just left you there because now everyone's going to know we're having an affair."
Owens said Person 17 moved towards the bed holding Roberts-Smith's hands and said that her head hurt.
Roberts-Smith replied either "It's going to hurt more" or "I'll show you what hurt is", withdrew his right hand from hers and punched her in the left temple with his right hand.
Person 17 staggered backwards and fell onto the bed, Owens said.
"That is a complete fabrication," Roberts-Smith said.
"I've never hit a woman. I never would hit a woman. And I certainly never hit Person 17."
(continued)
#13979295 at 2021-06-25 11:39:02 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13979285
4/4
Ben Roberts-Smith revealed last week that he had secretly tailed his mistress as she faked having a pregnancy termination because he believed she was lying about being pregnant to keep him in their affair.
The war hero said that in February 2018, some months after the woman - known as Person 17 - had threatened to self harm, she had met up with him to attend a pregnancy termination "appointment".
The appointment was at Brisbane's Greenslopes Hospital and he had her surveilled on video by private eye John McLeod, because he believed she wasn't really having an abortion.
Person 17 later told him that was true, but the pair continued their relationship until March, when they attended a function at Parliament House in Canberra hosted by then prime minister, Malcolm Turnbull.
The court heard the woman had taken a Valium pill and drunk a bottle of wine and after the event had fallen down stairs and injured her left eye.
Mr Roberts-Smith told the court he had cared for the woman who had been "incoherent" and "passed out" in the Hotel Realm.
She later accused him of assaulting her by punching her in the left eye, which Mr Roberts-Smith vehemently denies.
He said the claim of domestic violence assault, which was published in a Nine Newpapers article, had seriously damaged him and his family.
"Now I walk down the street, people will look at me and think I hit a woman," he said.
"I couldn't protect my kids which is extremely hard to take.
"I was worried about my children physically and emotionally, what someone might say to them, what someone might do to them," he told the Federal Court.
He said that when the article was published identifying him as having allegedly beaten Person 17, "I started to think my life is over."
Mr Roberts-Smith said that after media had pursued him in late 2017 and early 2018, he became aware he was the subject of "a whispering campaign".
He was aware former SAS soldiers had made allegations about what had happened in Afghanistan.
"The bottom line is I felt I was being attacked publicly in the press and had no way of defending myself," he said.
"I wanted to understand how ... we're not allowed to speak to the media. I'm bound by the Secrets Act."
Mr Roberts-Smith agreed he had asked Mr McLeod to get the home addresses of former unit members, but said he hadn't used them to intimidate his former comrades.
Asked by Mr McClintock if he had ever sent former unit members threatening letters or caused others to, Mr Roberts-Smith said no he hadn't.
In the trial's first week, Mr Roberts-Smith broke down several times, once while recalling the 2010 Battle of Tizak, for which he was awarded the medal for valour, the Victoria Cross.
On the second occasion he recalled discovering that one of the soldiers he had killed - of 76 insurgents shot dead during 14 hours of fighting - was a 15-year-old boy.
Asked by Mr McClintock how he dealt with that fact, Mr Roberts-Smith said "I struggle".
Also asked about Mr Owens' opening statement last week in which he called the ex-soldier "a mass murderer", Mr Roberts-Smith said he was both sad and "very angry" at accusations of executing unarmed Taliban fighters.
https://www.news.com.au/national/courts-law/Ben-robertssmith-takes-a-swipe-at-his-exwife/news-story/8983b3ff69c95009217ff35c4c24b6e7
#13979279 at 2021-06-25 11:36:04 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13979274
2/4
Asked by Nicholas Owens SC, for Nine newspapers, if he had not been breaking the law by discussing Person 5's testimony to a confidential national inquiry, Mr Roberts-Smith said he hadn't discussed the contents of the testimony.
He also denied telling his then-wife that the Director General of the Australian Defence Force (IGADF) inquiry into what SAS soldiers did in Afghanistan would "still have to be able to prove it".
"It looks like she is forming her own opinion, which is reasonably typical about my ex-wife," Mr Roberts-Smith told the court.
"I probably was a bit frustrated and upset.
"I told my wife they were questioning my awards, because that's what I believe was happening."
Mr Roberts-Smith also told the court his ex-wife "went through my email account and went through deleted and junk folders" to retrieve emails he thought he had got rid of.
The emails contained possibly sensitive material which Mr Roberts-Smith said his ex-wife had then given to the media lawyers.
Mr Owens grilled Mr Roberts-Smith over a Tupperware container filled with USB sticks, which the ex-soldier said had been anonymously sent to him after he asked comrades for images of their Afghanistan missions.
The media lawyer produced two photographs he claimed showed where the USB container had been buried by Ben Roberts-Smith in the backyard of his matrimonial home on the Sunshine Coast in Queensland.
The first photo, taken at 2.06pm on June 5, 2020 the location showed "an airconditioning compressor with a hose reel. Under the hose reel there was a rock".
Asked if "that was the location the USBs were buried in", Mr Roberts-Smith said "incorrect".
A further photo taken at 2.32pm on the same day showed the rock removed and a hole which he alleged Mr Roberts-Smith had left after he "dug up the USBs and removed the container".
The ex-soldier denied removing the container, and said he had never buried it, always storing it in a desk drawer of the home.
Asked if the USBs contained hundreds of photos of soldiers drinking from the prosthetic leg of a man Mr Roberts-Smith had killed in Afghanistan, he agreed, saying "thousands" of such images had been taken.
Asked by Mr Owens if he had deliberately "physically hid" the USBs in the back yard to conceal evidence, Mr Roberts-Smith said that wasn't true.
Mr Roberts-Smith told the court that he and Emma Roberts-Smith had finally parted ways in about the third week of January, 2020.
"I was going through a very difficult divorce, I wasn't focused on USBs.
"(I was) trying to work out where I was going to live, what I was going to do."
He agreed he had been dining with one of his lawyers, Monica Allen, in late 2019 when he had dinner with a former SAS comrade at a Woolloomooloo restaurant on December 4, 2019.
Ms Allen was photographed holding hands with Mr Roberts-Smith in Brisbane in August last year, but at the beginning of the defamation trial denied she was in a relationship with him.
Mr Roberts-Smith also denied threatening an SAS member, Person 14, who Mr Owens claimed had told the VC winner that "he would not lie on the stand" to the IGADF inquiry about the prosthetic leg incident.
Asked by Mr Owens if Mr Roberts-Smith had said "it's going to be like that is it" and "leant forward" and said "be careful who you f*cking talk to".
Mr Roberts-Smith said the suggested exchange was "a complete lie".
Mr Roberts-Smith said "was shocked" at Person 14, who he thought "was recording" the conversation with him "because the whole thing was a stitch up".
Mr Roberts-Smith did agree that on the USB sticks he received was an image of a penis with wings attached to it and the words, "Welcome to Tizak".
The image, which he suspected had been drawn by an SAS friend, is an apparent parody of the SAS crest which is a winged sword, or a sword flanked by flames, with the motto "Who Dares Wins".
The Battle of Tizak, in 2010, resulted in Mr Roberts-Smith being awarded his Victoria Cross.
(continued)
#13979274 at 2021-06-25 11:34:35 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Ben Roberts-Smith in fiery exchange with Channel 9 lawyer
Candace Sutton - JUNE 24, 2021
1/4
Ben Roberts-Smith has engaged in a fiery exchange with the lawyer for Channel 9, calling accusations he cheated on his bravery medal to cover up killing a teenager "disgusting".
Sensational allegations were made on day six of Ben Roberts-Smith's cross-examination suggesting had "exaggerated" his bravery to win a medal and had really just shot an unarmed teenage boy.
Nine newspaper's lawyer alleged Mr Roberts-Smith's act of bravery, in Afghanistan's Chora Valley in 2006, was fictional and covered up a campaign of bullying of a young soldier who knew the truth.
In the Federal Court, Nicholas Owens SC said Mr Roberts-Smith had given untrue accounts of the engagement to media and in an interview with Australian War Memorial historian Dr Peter Pederson.
Mr Roberts-Smith agreed that he had "conflated" more than one battle when giving his account of the incident which won him his MG, but had not meant to.
Mr Owens retorted: "You only did that because you didn't want the public to think the engagement for which you won the Medal of Gallantry (MG) was for shooting an unarmed teenager".
Mr Roberts-Smith: "Not only do I find that a disgusting comment, it's completely false."
In a barrage of accusations on Mr Roberts-Smith's sixth day of cross-examination and eleventh day in the witness box, Mr Owens suggested the wording of the MG citation was false.
The war veteran was awarded the MG four years before he earned his Victoria Cross, and the medal's citation states that an Afghan militia attempted to outflank Mr Roberts-Smith's patrol.
The citation says that he "ensured that his patrol remained secure by holding this position without support for twenty minutes".
Mr Owens put it to Mr Roberts-Smith that he hadn't held the position for 20 minutes alone because he had been joined by Person 1, a soldier the war veteran is accused of bullying.
Denying the suggestion, the veteran said he believed he had been awarded the medal for pushing "out the front by myself".
Described as a "small and quiet soldier", Person 1 had jammed his minimi machine gun while on the mission.
Mr Owens accused Mr Roberts-Smith of thereafter physically assaulting and abusing Person 1 and calling him a "useless c*nt" and threatening to kill him, which Mr Roberts-Smith denied.
He agreed that in a subsequent media interview and the discussion with Dr Pederson, he mixed up details of the engagement with later battlefield incidents.
"I've conflated that with something that happened later in the day," Mr Roberts-Smith told the court.
"It happened after a number of tours. I acknowledge those mistakes."
Mr Owens said Mr Roberts-Smith had plagued Person 1 with bullying comments and had invented a scenario in which the young soldier woke up with "night terrors" pointing a machine gun.
Mr Owens put it to Mr Roberts-Smith that it was he who had pointed his gun at Person 1, and his bullying had escalated after the Chora Pass mission because the young soldier knew about the unarmed teenager.
Mr Roberts-Smith said none of those suggestions were true and "I just didn't trust Person 1 with my life and that's a dangerous thing in Afghanistan".
In earlier evidence on Thursday, Mr Roberts-Smith took a swipe at his ex-wife Emma, after the contents of a text message between Ms Roberts-Smith and her best friend were revealed in court.
The war veteran's defamation trial heard on Thursday morning that Emma Roberts-Smith had texted her school friend and divulged a conversation between her then-husband and an SAS comrade.
The text message, sent on May 9, 2018 by Emma Roberts-Smith to Danielle Scott, followed a conversation the night before her ex-husband had with a soldier known as Person 5.
Person 5, who had been Mr Roberts-Smith's patrol commander had just appeared before an inquiry into Australian soldiers in Afghanistan.
The court heard that Emma Roberts-Smith texted Ms Scott, writing "Hey mate, (person 5) rang BRS late" and included a sad face emoji.
She then texted: "he was grilled for hours. Lots of questions about (Ben Roberts-Smith). He didn't get much sleep.
"It is obvious someone said a hell of a lot about Ben. They still have to be able to prove it."
Both Ms Roberts-Smith and Ms Scott are due to testify against Mr Roberts-Smith at the trial in coming weeks.
(continued)
#13955973 at 2021-06-22 09:36:07 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Ben Roberts-Smith denies murdering Afghan prisoner and watching execution of elderly man, court hears
Decorated Australian soldier admits to shooting man who had prosthetic leg, but tells defamation hearing the man was an armed, legitimate target
Ben Doherty - 21 Jun 2021
1/2
Ben Roberts-Smith has been accused in court of dragging an unarmed prisoner outside a compound wall during a raid in Afghanistan before killing him with a burst of machine gun fire, as well as standing by while a subordinate soldier executed an elderly man.
In a fierce, and at times heated, cross-examination, the former SAS corporal consistently rejected a version of events - incompatible with his own earlier testimony before the court - put to him about a raid on a compound called Whiskey 108, in the village of Kakarak, on Easter Sunday in 2009.
Nicholas Owens SC, acting for the newspapers Roberts-Smith is suing for defamation over allegations he committed war crimes, put it to Roberts-Smith that, during the raid on Whiskey 108, a tunnel was discovered inside the compound.
After soldiers called into the tunnel, two unarmed men surrendered and were taken into custody under the control of the Australian soldiers.
Owens told the court Roberts-Smith was present when Roberts-Smith's patrol commander - anonymised in court documents as Person 5 - ordered a subordinate SAS soldier - Person 4 - to "shoot the old man". Roberts-Smith did not object to the illegal order.
Together, Person 4 and Roberts-Smith walked over to another Australian soldier - Person 41 - and asked to borrow his suppressor, used to muffle the sound of a weapon. Person 41 handed it over, Owens said.
Owens said Person 4 and Roberts-Smith walked back to where the two prisoners were being held. Roberts-Smith allegedly pulled the older man into a kneeling position.
Person 4 shot the prisoner, Owens said.
Roberts-Smith consistently denied every element of Owens's sequence of events.
"That is completely false ... there were no men in the tunnel," he said.
Owens alleged Roberts-Smith then picked up the remaining prisoner - the man with the prosthetic leg - and carried or "forcefully manhandled" the man outside the compound where he threw him to the ground.
"You then shot the man with the prosthetic leg with an extended burst of machine gun fire until you had a stoppage," Owens put to Roberts-Smith.
"That is totally false," Roberts-Smith said.
Over repeated objections from Roberts-Smith's barrister, Arthur Moses SC, Owens put it to Roberts-Smith he returned to the inside of the compound where he approached Person 41 - the soldier who had lent his suppressor - and said: "are we cool?"
Roberts-Smith said it never happened: "no, that's a lie."
Person 5 raised with Roberts-Smith the potential issue of the killings being recorded on ISR - the 'intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance' platform that monitors and supports soldiers' missions.
Roberts-Smith said Owens's allegation he responded "what do we do to stop this, is the ISR still filming?", was "a ridiculous assertion".
(continued)
#13949295 at 2021-06-21 08:09:37 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial resumes after war veteran tests negative for COVID
Jamie McKinnell - 21 June 2021
Ben Roberts-Smith has tested negative for COVID-19 after a visit to an exposure site in Sydney's CBD delayed his high-stakes defamation trial.
The 42-year-old was due to face a third day being cross-examined in the Federal Court, as the trial entered its third week.
But this morning, his barrister Arthur Moses SC told the court Mr Roberts-Smith had been instructed by NSW Health to get tested after visiting "a venue in the CBD" on Thursday.
After lunch, Mr Moses informed the court Mr Roberts-Smith had received a negative result and was told he no longer had to isolate.
The court will return for a late sitting from 3.30pm.
NSW Health has listed a city Fitness First gym as an exposure site on Thursday afternoon, saying anyone who attended between 3.10pm to 4.30pm was a "close contact" and must get tested, remaining isolated until further advice from the department.
The MLC Food Court at Martin Place, which is a short walk from the Federal Court building, was also a potential exposure site for casual contact on Thursday morning.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age, The Canberra Times and three journalists over stories published in 2018.
The series of articles included serious allegations against the ex-soldier, including involvement in unlawful killings and bullying of colleagues in Afghanistan, and that he committed an act of domestic violence against a woman in Canberra.
Mr Roberts-Smith denies all of the allegations, while Nine Entertainment Co, the publisher of two of the papers, is relying on a defence of truth.
Mr Roberts-Smith's second day of cross-examination on Friday included several tense exchanges with Nine's barrister, Nicholas Owens SC, who accused him of lying to the court.
The veteran had volunteered a correction to evidence about the position of the body of a suspected insurgent shot dead during a 2009 mission, insisting he made "a mistake" and wanted to be accurate.
But Mr Owens seized on the change, suggesting Mr Roberts-Smith must have realised a photo of the body would show his version was implausible and was having difficulty keeping his story straight.
Mr Roberts-Smith rejected the attack.
He also rejected an account of a September 2012 mission, in which he is alleged to have kicked an unarmed man named Ali Jan over a cliff and entered an agreement with Special Air Service Regiment (SAS) colleagues that he be executed.
Mr Owens put to Mr Roberts-Smith that he interrogated three men that day, assaulted Ali Jan, and left his body near a cornfield with a radio to cover it up.
Mr Roberts-Smith has insisted a man killed in that area was a Taliban "spotter" who was shot dead as his patrol made their way up a creek bed.
The trial, before Justice Anthony Besanko, is expected to run for up to 10 weeks.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-06-21/Ben-Roberts-Smith-defamation-trial-paused-due-to-covid-exposure/100230044
#13936569 at 2021-06-19 10:48:13 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Media's barrister circles Ben Roberts-Smith, campaign by campaign
Deborah Snow - June 19, 2021
1/3
As the first fortnight of the Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial drew to a close it became clear why, as the lawyers predicted, this epic clash could run for another eight weeks or longer.
It was not until Thursday morning that Nicholas Owens, SC, the barrister for The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times was able to begin cross-examining the towering former soldier, whose first days in the witness box had been spent under the sympathetic questioning of his own barrister, Bruce McClintock, SC.
Roberts-Smith had come across as a disciplined and articulate performer on the stand. Now it was up to Owens to try and take his story apart.
By Friday morning, the barrister for the media outlets was starting to move in on his quarry, putting to a periodically rattled-looking Roberts-Smith that parts of his evidence were "implausible" and lies, doubling back again and again over the testimony the ex-soldier had given, picking out inconsistencies, gaps in memory, and growing uncertainties about who in the SAS field of operations had done what, when and where.
Roberts-Smith denies any falsehoods. He says he is an honourable man, devoted to his country, who served with valour and distinction in Afghanistan and who - contrary to the allegations of the media outlets - never murdered or connived in the murder of six prisoners and never committed an act of domestic violence against his one-time lover.
He spoke during the week about the "nightmare" he'd been living since the allegations against him were first published three years ago, detailing the impact on his reputation and his family, the fears about the effect of his public disgrace on his children and parents, the loss of income that followed the cancellation of the many speaking engagements he'd once enjoyed, and the loss of a lucrative job offer with big four consultancy firm, PwC.
At times he'd wondered if life was worth carrying on, he told Federal Court judge Anthony Besanko, who is presiding over the trial with unwavering inscrutability.
But the three newspapers say behind the public image of the Victoria Cross-winner lies a bully who, for all his military awards for valour, is guilty of the acts they accuse him of.
Owens has now begun the task of trying to prove the truth of the newspaper's allegations, first put forward in June 2018 by investigative reporters Nick McKenzie and Chris Masters, who are also being sued by Roberts-Smith. Both were present in the courtroom this week, Masters from the beginning and McKenzie arriving on Thursday having just escaped Melbourne's latest lockdown. One or other and sometimes both of Roberts-Smith's parents, Len and Sue, have also been regulars in the courtroom.
Owens began on Thursday laying the groundwork for the media outlets' defence much as a spider spins a web: methodically and purposively, his seemingly leisurely pace masking lethal intent.
Initially he probed Roberts-Smith's understanding of the international rules of warfare - reflected in Australia's rules of engagement - which require protection to be given to combatants (or suspected combatants) who've been disarmed and rendered Persons Under Control (or PUCs in military jargon).
Yes, Roberts-Smith said, he understood those rules. And yes, he agreed he'd be complicit in a crime if he killed or assaulted a PUC, or stood by as another soldier ordered or committed such an action.
Owens then took him through the intricate detail of how Australian special forces handled villagers, women, children, "fighting age males" (or FAMs) and prisoners during their sweeps through Afghan settlements and compounds, before turning to several key events which lie at the heart of the newspapers' published allegations.
One, in 2012, centres on the death of a man described by Roberts-Smith as a Taliban "spotter", whom he says he helped kill in a cornfield in the vicinity of a dry creek-bed near the village of Darwan. The media outlets say that individual was really a harmless farmer named Ali Jan, kicked down a cliff by Roberts-Smith who then either shot him or stood by as another soldier did so before their SAS patrol exited the area by helicopter.
(continued)
#13934173 at 2021-06-19 00:47:35 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
HOW IS THIS NOT CORRUPT AF
Gladys Berejiklian dating high-profile lawyer Arthur Moses
NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian reportedly has a new boyfriend, with her sister uploading a picture of her and a high-profile Sydney lawyer.
NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian is reportedly in a new relationship, with her sister uploading a picture of her and a high-profile Sydney lawyer.
Ms Berejiklian has recently started dating Arthur Moses, SC, the lawyer who represented her at a corruption hearing into her former partner Daryl Maguire.
A spokesman for the premier confirmed that the couple had recently started seeing each other.
"They have recently begun spending private time together. The Premier will not discuss her private life," the spokesman said.
It comes after Ms Berejiklian's sister, Mary, posted a photo of the pair on Instagram.
"After work Friday feels with these two. Glad and her boo," she captioned a picture showing Ms Berejiklian and Mr Moses smiling and looking at each other.
According to The Daily Telegraph, rumours about the couple's budding romance have been swirling for months after they were seen by some ministers having coffee and visiting her office.
Mr Moses served as president of the NSW Bar Association and president of the Law Council of Australia and is currently representing Ben Roberts-Smith in his defamation case against Nine newspapers.
https://www.news.com.au/national/nsw-act/politics/gladys-berejiklian-dating-highprofile-lawyer-arthur-moses/news-story/4b99f92a56b5138fdd6ef1fd9dcee54f
#13929643 at 2021-06-18 08:36:06 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
MP Andrew Hastie set to testify on allegedly 'blooded' rookie soldier in Ben Roberts-Smith case
The Liberal MP is a former SAS captain who served in Afghanistan and was trained by Roberts-Smith
Ben Doherty - 18 Jun 2021
1/2
The assistant defence minister, Andrew Hastie, is slated to give evidence to the federal court in relation to an SAS mission in Afghanistan where a rookie soldier was allegedly "blooded", or ordered to kill an unarmed prisoner, by Ben Roberts-Smith.
Hastie, a former SAS captain and now a Liberal MP, was confirmed on Thursday as a "likely" witness to be called on behalf of three newspapers alleged by Roberts-Smith to have defamed him over allegations of war crimes.
The newspapers have alleged in their defence documents that Victoria Cross recipient Roberts-Smith committed six murders while on deployment with the SAS in Afghanistan, as well as an act of domestic violence in Australia.
The evidence involving Hastie concerns an allegation that Roberts-Smith ordered a subordinate soldier - anonymised before the court as Person 66 - to kill an unarmed Afghan in Syahchow during a mission in October 2012. Roberts-Smith confirmed in court on Friday that Hastie was present: "he came on the mission".
Court documents filed by the newspapers as part of their defence allege that during the mission Roberts-Smith directed Person 66 to take two prisoners from a compound where they were being held to a nearby field.
It's alleged that Roberts-Smith ordered Person 66 to shoot one of the Afghan prisoners, which he did. After the incident, Roberts-Smith is alleged to have said he had "blooded" the new soldier.
Person 66, who was not a regular member of Roberts-Smith's patrol, is also expected to give evidence to the trial, called by the newspapers.
In his earlier opening to the case, barrister Bruce McClintock SC, appearing for Roberts-Smith, told the court "the essence of the allegation is that, gratuitously, my client [Roberts-Smith] ordered Person 66 to shoot one of two Afghan males, which Person 66 then did".
"My client's response to that is that the incident in question never happened," he said.
"The only other evidence - and I use that word with quotation marks - that may be before the court is from Mr Hastie, a member of the House of Representatives. Mr Hastie has long been a commentator for the respondents and anti-[Roberts-Smith], if I could put it like that.
"His outline offers nothing probative, except that when the mission was over, he saw Person 66 looking anxious and uncomfortable. There might be many reasons, after combat, why someone looked anxious and uncomfortable."
(continued)
#13929610 at 2021-06-18 08:18:20 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case: Elite soldiers 'covered up' cliff execution, court told
KIERAN GAIR - 18 June 2021
War hero Ben Roberts-Smith conspired with two special forces soldiers in an effort to "cover up" the murder of a handcuffed man by "inventing" a story about an ambush in an Afghan cornfield, a court has heard.
Mr Roberts-Smith, 42, is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times, now under separate ownership, over reports published in 2018 that alleged he committed murder during deployments to Afghanistan. He denies the allegations and says the reports portray him as a murderous war criminal.
On the second day of his cross-examination in the Federal Court by barrister Nicholas Owens, SC, for Nine newspapers, Mr Roberts-Smith was questioned in detail about key events surrounding Nine's "centrepiece" allegation - the murder of unarmed civilian Ali Jan in Darwan, Uruzgan province, on September 11, 2012.
As part of its truth defence, the newspapers allege that Mr Roberts-Smith committed or was complicit in six unlawful killings in Afghanistan, including the murder of Jan. They allege the farmer was kicked off a cliff while handcuffed and then shot dead by Australian soldiers in the village of Darwan in 2012.
Mr Owens suggested the war hero had kicked a PUC - an acronym for persons safely and securely under the control of Australian soldiers - in the chest and "over the cliff" after the man twice laughed at him.
"You and person 11 dragged him into a cornfield and either you or person 11 shot him," Mr Owens said. "That's completely false," Mr Roberts-Smith replied.
Mr Owens showed the Victoria Cross recipient a photo of the man's body with four bullet wounds, an "open gaping wound in his chest", an injury around the man's mouth, and injuries "consistent" with being handcuffed.
Mr Owens asked: "When this man was shot, his arms were handcuffed behind his back, won't they?" "No, they weren't," Mr Roberts-Smith said. "You, person 4 and person 11 all discussed how to cover up the killing, correct?" "That's false," Mr Roberts-Smith replied.
Last week, Bruce McClintock, SC, for Mr Roberts-Smith dismissed the outlets' "centrepiece" allegation - the murder of Jan on September 11, 2012 - as a "ludicrous" accusation that "did not happen". Asked by Mr McClintock about the allegation, Mr Roberts-Smith said: "Every time I have to read that or hear it, I can't believe it has been written. It feels like a nightmare, to be frank."
The court has heard that the rules of war - as outlined in the Geneva Convention and the Australian Defence Force's rules of engagement - ban the killing of persons under the control of Australian soldiers.
On the ninth day of the defamation case, the war hero was also accused of lying in the witness box after he said he had made a mistake in his evidence about the killing of an Afghan man with a prosthetic leg.
On Thursday, Mr Roberts-Smith told the court he dragged the man he killed back to the compound wall while the second SAS operator dragged the second insurgent. However, on Friday he said he'd realised his evidence had been "wrong" - the second soldier did not move the second insurgent's body.
"He lay where he fell," Mr Roberts-Smith said. "It was a mistake in my evidence I felt I should correct."
Mr Roberts-Smith told the court he was involved in over "300 missions" across six deployments to Afghanistan and that "sometimes you mix it up".
"You find it hard to keep your story straight, don't, you?" Mr Owens asked. "No," Mr Roberts-Smith replied. Mr Owens later asked: "You've thrown this man on the ground and then rolled him over and shot him, correct?" "No," Mr Roberts-Smith replied.
At one point, Mr Roberts-Smith accused the barrister of peddling a "fanciful story."
"You would not pick someone up and put yourself in danger like that, it's a ridiculous story."
Mr Roberts-Smith is also suing over reports alleging he assaulted a woman - a key witness in the defamation proceedings - at a Canberra hotel in March 2018.
A substantial part of Mr Roberts-Smith's cross-examination is expected to be held behind closed doors on Monday to ensure national security information is not divulged in open court.
The hearing continues.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/Ben-robertssmith-defamation-case-elite-soldiers-covered-up-cliff-execution-court-told/news-story/79e5c4f8f423cc50a87059a2c6d2898c
#13922371 at 2021-06-17 08:24:19 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Ben Roberts-Smith tells defamation trial soldiers were allowed to use 'whatever force was necessary'
Jamie McKinnell - 17 June 2021
War veteran Ben Roberts-Smith has told a Sydney court Australian soldiers were permitted to use "whatever force was necessary" to arrest insurgents in Afghanistan, including punching those who were fighting back.
Mr Roberts-Smith is being cross-examined on his fifth day in the witness box during a high-stakes defamation trial against three newspapers in the Federal Court.
The 42-year-old is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times, along with three journalists, over several 2018 stories which reported allegations of wrongdoing related to his time deployed in Afghanistan.
The publisher of two of the papers, Nine Entertainment Co, is relying on a defence of truth and Mr Roberts-Smith has denied all wrongdoing, including his alleged involvement in up to six unlawful killings.
Under questioning by Nine's barrister, Nicholas Owens SC, Mr Roberts-Smith agreed it was never permissible, under both the rules of engagement and the Geneva Conventions, to kill someone once they became a "person under confinement" (PUC) of the Australian soldiers.
He said all "fighting-aged males" in a "target building", such as a compound, would become PUCs, while care was taken to not touch women or children due to cultural sensitivities.
"Is there a strict definition in terms of age about a fighting-aged male?" Mr Owens asked.
"There is no strict description of a fighting-aged male. Effectively anyone that you felt was old enough to directly take part," Mr Roberts-Smith replied.
Mr Roberts-Smith was then questioned about the use of force with PUCs.
"You could use what force was necessary and required to effect the arrest of the PUC," the veteran said.
"Would that include punching them?" Mr Owens asked.
"If required, yes," he said.
Force such as a punch would be required "if they were fighting back", he added.
Mr Roberts-Smith said soldiers were also permitted to physically move someone if they were non-compliant.
He could not recall if the process for placing a person under confinement and bringing them back to base was different for an adult as opposed to an adolescent.
Mr Roberts-Smith has previously told the court some male insurgents he "engaged" with were as young as 15.
The process of placing a person under confinement is central to the case, as Mr Roberts-Smith's is arguing he was defamed by imputations that he "broke the moral and legal rules of military engagement" and "disgraced his country".
He has today agreed that at all times in Afghanistan, it was his understanding that if a soldier killed a PUC in any circumstance they would have committed murder.
He agreed that it would effectively break the legal and moral rules of military engagement.
Mr Roberts-Smith has previously denied killing any person who had been placed under the control of the Australian forces.
The veteran also agreed that it would never be permissible to "order, direct or encourage" another soldier to kill a PUC, and that there would be an obligation to take reasonable steps to prevent that conduct if the situation arose.
Today he also explained the evolving techniques of the Taliban insurgency, such as placing improvised explosive devices against walls that Australians would use for cover, using cornfields for ambushes, and firing upon Australian forces as they were "extracted" from missions by helicopter.
Mr Roberts-Smith is also suing over what he claims were defamatory imputations that he bullied colleagues in the Special Air Services Regiment (SAS) and committed an act of domestic violence on a woman in a Canberra hotel room.
He has denied all the allegations.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-06-17/Ben-Roberts-Smith-gives-evidence-for-fifth-day-defamation-trial/100221992
#13915189 at 2021-06-16 08:50:11 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Ben Roberts-Smith used pre-paid phones due to phone hacking fears, defamation trial hears
Jamie McKinnell - 16 June 2021
1/2
Ben Roberts-Smith used pre-paid mobile phones to communicate with soldier colleagues after he was accused of war crimes because he was worried about phone hacking, a court has heard.
On his fourth day giving evidence to a high-stakes defamation trial in Sydney, the war veteran blamed two members of Special Air Services Regiment (SAS) for "poisoning the well" by speaking to the media about missions in Afghanistan.
The 42-year-old is suing The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times newspapers over a series of 2018 stories, which reported serious allegations against Mr Roberts-Smith related to his Afghanistan deployments, including unlawful killings.
Mr Roberts-Smith told the Federal Court that after reading the first article in June 2018, he spoke to four current or ex-SAS officers who were on the missions mentioned.
After initially using his own mobile phone, Mr Roberts-Smith asked a friend of his ex-wife to buy pre-paid mobiles for further communication.
"My view was that I just needed to talk on something that wasn't compromised by the media and used in another article," he told the court.
Mr Roberts-Smith said the News of the World phone-hacking scandal was "playing heavily on my mind".
He said he spoke with the soldiers about their recollection of the missions and who was responsible for the allegations.
"Everyone had a view on which individuals were trying to poison the well with the media," Mr Roberts-Smith said.
He said two soldiers, referred to by the pseudonyms Person 6 and Person 7, were thought to be "the key drivers of the negative campaign".
Mr Roberts-Smith denied he used the pre-paid mobile phones to avoid the attention of the Inspector General of the Australian Defence Force.
He also denied burying a number of USB drives that contained sensitive photographs and information from Afghanistan in his Sunshine Coast backyard.
Mr Roberts-Smith said the drives were sent to him anonymously in the mail and included footage from missions and photographs from parties at the unofficial SAS bar, the Fat Lady's Arms.
The former soldier recalled attempting to obtain the home addresses of six SAS officers from a private investigator, John McLeod, as he was attempting to work out who was speaking to the media.
He denied ever sending threats in the mail and said while he was never given the addresses, he intended to pass them on to a WA-based private investigations firm so it could discover who was speaking to journalists.
(continued)
#13907649 at 2021-06-15 09:08:05 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Roberts-Smith hired investigator to check woman was having an abortion
Michaela Whitbourn - June 15, 2021
Former special forces soldier Ben Roberts-Smith has told a court that he hired a private investigator to follow a woman with whom he had been having a relationship to check whether she had an abortion because he suspected she was lying about being pregnant.
Mr Roberts-Smith, a Victoria Cross recipient, is suing The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald for defamation over stories in 2018 that he says accuse him of being a war criminal and of punching a woman, with whom he was having an extramarital affair, in the face after a dinner in Canberra on March 28 that year.
Giving evidence in the Federal Court in Sydney on Tuesday, Mr Roberts-Smith replied "absolutely not" when asked by his barrister, Bruce McClintock, SC, if he had hit the woman.
"That particular allegation, I feel, coupled with being called a war criminal, ruined my life," he said. "For a long time, I found it very difficult to leave the house after that."
He said domestic violence was "highly reprehensible" and his parents had instilled in him a "very good set of values". He had no tolerance for anybody who would raise a hand to a woman, he said.
The woman, known as Person 17 to protect her identity, had been "extremely intoxicated" after a dinner at Parliament House in Canberra, the former Special Air Services soldier said, and had fallen down a flight of stairs.
He said he iced the resultant bump on her head after putting her to bed in their room at the Hotel Realm.
The woman subsequently texted Mr Roberts-Smith that her husband "didn't believe that I had fallen down stairs" but added that her other bruises would "hopefully make the falling story more believable".
"Well, hopefully, he believes you," Mr Roberts-Smith replied.
Mr Roberts-Smith told the court that the events in Canberra had been "highly embarrassing for her and I" and they had discussed how she would explain her injury because she hadn't told her husband that they were together at the time.
Mr Roberts-Smith said he had separated from his now ex-wife, Emma Roberts, in late September 2017 and they remained separated for about six months.
He attempted to end the relationship with Person 17 after he went on a trip with his family to Singapore in early 2018, he said, but he had concerns from messages she sent him from London that she was "potentially going to self harm".
Later, in February that year, the woman told him she was pregnant. He said they agreed to terminate the pregnancy, but he suspected it was not real.
Mr Roberts-Smith told the court he hired a private investigator to check if the woman attended a hospital in Brisbane for a termination. He believed video footage of her leaving the hospital confirmed that she had not had a termination because she was able to pick up her own bag, was "dressed nicely", and did not appear to have had an "invasive procedure".
He said that he showed Person 17 the footage later that day, and she admitted she had not had the procedure but said she did have a termination at an earlier date in Townsville. He said she subsequently told him she had had a miscarriage, meaning that she had provided "three stories" about what had happened.
Mr Roberts-Smith said he believed he was being "manipulated so that I would stay in the relationship".
"You continued with the relationship after this, didn't you?" Mr McClintock asked.
"I did," Mr Roberts-Smith replied.
The court heard the relationship ended in April 2018 and the pair had met at an airport when Mr Roberts-Smith was about to catch a flight to Canberra. He believed Person 17 had "come to the airport to ensure I boarded the plane", and then drove to his matrimonial home.
"I landed in Canberra and received a message from my wife that Person 17 was there," he said.
The trial continues.
Lifeline, 131 114
Beyondblue 1300 22 4636
https://www.lifeline.org.au
https://www.beyondblue.org.au
https://www.smh.com.au/national/Roberts-Smith-hired-investigator-to-check-woman-was-having-an-abortion-20210615-p5818t.html
#13907636 at 2021-06-15 09:04:26 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Ben Roberts-Smith tells defamation trial he's disgusted by domestic violence claims
Jamie McKinnell - 15 June 2021
Australian war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith has denied punching a woman in a Canberra hotel room, telling a Sydney court domestic violence is "a disgusting act of cowardice".
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times newspapers, along with three journalists, over a series of articles published in 2018.
The 42-year-old alleges he was defamed by imputations including that he committed an act of violence against a woman, with whom he was having an affair, in a Canberra hotel room in March 2018.
Mr Roberts-Smith today told the Federal Court in Sydney he met the woman, referred to as "Person 17" due to a suppression order over her identity, in mid-October 2017 and began a relationship.
He had separated from his wife, Emma Roberts, towards the end of September 2017.
In March 2018, Mr Roberts-Smith took the woman to an event in Parliament House.
He told the court she became "extremely intoxicated" and fell down some stairs, leading to "a significant bump on the top of her left eye".
Mr Roberts-Smith said she "wasn't really coherent", was "extremely unsteady on her feet" and "couldn't really string words together".
He said he took her to Hotel Realm, where she "completely passed out" and he left her on the bed with some ice for her injury.
Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Bruce McClintock SC, asked his client if he struck the woman.
"No, I didn't," he replied.
When asked about his attitude towards domestic violence, Mr Roberts-Smith described it as "deplorable" and "reprehensible".
"My mother and father brought me up with a very good set of values," he said.
"I respect women a great deal. I have no tolerance for anyone who would ever raise a hand to women.
"I find it a disgusting act of cowardice."
In a Whatsapp message chain, Mr Roberts-Smith discussed the woman's injury with her the next day and urged her to tell her husband she fell down some stairs while at an event with him.
He said the incident was "effectively the final straw" of their relationship.
In an affidavit, Person 17 claimed she was punched by Mr Roberts-Smith in the hotel room who then "coached" her in messages about how to explain a black eye to her husband.
She said in the document that she told police she did not wish to make a formal complaint, as she was "genuinely scared about my safety and that of my children if I am identified in the media".
Mr Roberts-Smith today said the newspaper report about the alleged assault had "ruined his life".
"For a long time, I found it very difficult to leave the house after that, just simply because I have such disdain for those types of people," he said.
"To be labelled as someone like that and just have to wear that, it was very difficult."
The court heard that before the Canberra event, Mr Roberts-Smith told Ms Roberts about the affair during a trip to Singapore in January the next year when the couple decided to try to work through their ongoing problems.
He told the court that in February 2018, Person 17 contacted him to let him know how hurt she was about the end of their relationship.
Not long after, she texted Mr Roberts-Smith to inform him she was pregnant, but he said after helping her arrange an appointment to terminate the pregnancy in Brisbane, he didn't believe she was telling the truth.
Mr Roberts-Smith hired a private investigator, John McLeod, who filmed Person 17 at Greenslopes Hospital, where she claimed to have been having the procedure.
"I just wanted to know the truth," he said.
"I felt I was being manipulated."
Mr Roberts-Smith said Person 17 later admitted she'd lied about having the procedure, but then claimed to have had a miscarriage.
Mr Roberts-Smith's case also alleges he was defamed by imputations that he "broke the moral and legal rules of war" on deployment in Afghanistan and bullied colleagues.
The former Special Air Services Regiment soldier has denied wrongdoing.
Nine Entertainment Co is relying on a defence of truth.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-06-15/Ben-Roberts-Smith-denies-punching-woman-defamation-trial/100215224
#13877222 at 2021-06-11 09:36:06 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Ben Roberts-Smith tells defamation trial he did not kick handcuffed man off cliff
Jamie McKinnell - 11 June 2021
1/2
War veteran Ben Roberts-Smith has dismissed as a "fanciful story" claims he handcuffed a man, led him to a cliff, kicked him over and conspired with a colleague to execute him.
The 42-year-old gave evidence in the witness box at his Federal Court defamation trial against Nine Entertainment Co for the second day in a row.
Mr Roberts-Smith this afternoon said no men were taken "under control" during a 2012 mission, and he also denied there was any cliff, kick, dragging over a dry creek bed or agreement to kill.
"How does it (the allegation) make you feel?" barrister Bruce McClintock, SC, asked his client.
"It makes me feel disappointed," Mr Roberts-Smith replied.
"Because I cannot believe a fanciful story like that could, let alone be believed, could be printed in the paper and maintained for a series of years.
"I can't see how it can be believed, because none of it makes sense, none of it adds up."
Mr Roberts-Smith said a man he killed in a compound that day was legitimately engaged in combat as a suspected Taliban "spotter", or lookout.
He said it made "absolutely perfect sense" the dead man was a spotter, because he was hiding in a cornfield unlike civilians who would stay on the edge, and the patrol had intelligence spotters had previously operated in the area.
Mr Roberts-Smith said he had never killed an unarmed person who was under the control of the Australian soldiers.
"It's terrible," he said of the allegation.
"Every time I have to read that or hear it, I can't believe it's been written.
"You feel like you're in a bloody nightmare, to be frank."
Earlier, he told the court that being awarded the Victoria Cross "put a target on his back" and led to his colleagues belittling him.
His evidence came 11 years to the day since Australian troops stormed a Taliban stronghold, killing 76 insurgents during fierce fighting that led to 11 military awards, including Mr Roberts-Smith's Victoria Cross.
Mr McClintock asked Mr Roberts-Smith what the award meant to him.
"I have such a respect for the institution of the Victoria Cross, but I'm nowhere near as proud of that as I am to be able to count myself amongst the number of men in that battle," he said.
"Everybody fought with bravery, everybody fought with gallantry, and everyone at some point was fighting for their lives."
But Mr Roberts-Smith said the award led to a change in attitude among his colleagues.
"For all of the good that it has brought me and enabled me to do, particularly, it is, unfortunately, the case, in my instance, it has also brought me a lot of misfortune and pain," he told the court.
"It put a target on my back."
Mr Roberts-Smith referred to becoming a "tall poppy" and the award giving others a chance to "belittle" him and "broaden their attacks" on him.
Mr Roberts-Smith said he would often find "childish" things written on a noticeboard during 2012, designed to "undermine" him and "stir resentment", including that he was "just trying to get another medal".
"They would say things like that to try to incite some animosity," he said.
(continued)
#13869327 at 2021-06-10 08:49:16 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Ben Roberts-Smith: veteran launches attack on ex-colleagues
KIERAN GAIR - 10 June 2021
1/2
Ben Roberts-Smith has launched a pre-emptive attack against former army colleagues who are expected to give evidence for Nine newspapers at his defamation trial, with the war hero describing one soldier that was more "worried" about eating "noodles" than he was about helping his comrades escape a Taliban attack.
On the fourth day of the decorated veteran's high-stakes defamation trial against Nine newspapers, he told the court he had "spent my life fighting for my country" and was left "devastated" after a series of allegedly defamatory stories were published in The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age in June and August 2018.
In an opening address on Thursday, the barrister acting for Nine newspapers, Nicholas Owens, SC, said the newspapers would be calling 21 current and former members of the SAS, including one soldier "who would himself confess to murder", as they try and prove that six alleged murders did not occur in the "heat of battle".
"The suggestion that the testimony of 21 men is a fabrication of the result of jealousy or a product of trauma is not plausible and we submit will not survive the telling of their stories," Mr Owens said.
Appearing in the witness box on Thursday, Mr Roberts said the allegations that he committed war crimes during deployments in Afghanistan and was complicit in six unlawful murders had broken "my heart".
"I spent my life fighting for my country and I did everything I possibly could to ensure I did it with honour," Mr Roberts-Smith said. "I listened to that, and I really cannot comprehend how people on the basis of rumour and innuendo can maintain that (war crimes allegations) in a public forum. It breaks my heart, actually."
The court heard a soldier who had accused Mr Roberts-Smith of bullying, and is expected to give evidence for Nine, was "removed" from the SAS by a patrol commander.
Among a litany of mistakes allegedly linked to "person 1", was the "noodle" incident, Mr Roberts-Smith said. While the soldier was "cooking his lunch" the troops were attacked by insurgents who had fired "mortar rounds" at their vehicles.
"Person 1 was more concerned about throwing his noodles away than jumping in the vehicle," Mr Roberts-Smith said. "When you have ordinance in the air, you don't really want to stuff around worrying about whether your lunch is ready."
In a separate incident involving another SAS soldier, Mr Roberts-Smith told the court the special forces member crashed their vehicle during a patrol in Afghanistan because he wanted to "shoot" a "stray dog."
"Person 2 saw a stray dog walking down the road and he pulled his pistol out and started trying to engage the dog," Mr Roberts-Smith said. "He then crashed the vehicle into the side wall of the road, which is effectively a cliff … there was no need to shoot that dog, it wasn't aggressive."
He also rejected suggestions that he showed the soldier a picture of a "dead insurgent", saying the pair didn't "really get on" and that the court would likely "find out" why when the soldier gives evidence.
"We didn't really get on and we've made no secret about that," he said. "He doesn't like me and I don't like him, and I'm sure we'll find out his reasons."
(continued)
#13869304 at 2021-06-10 08:41:42 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Ben Roberts-Smith's claims 'inherently implausible' media's barrister tells court
Michaela Whitbourn - June 10, 2021
1/2
The barrister acting for media companies being sued for defamation by Ben Roberts-Smith has described as "inherently implausible" the former soldier's claim that 21 current or former comrades who will give evidence against him are motivated by jealousy or have memories tainted by trauma.
Barrister Nicholas Owens, SC, who is representing The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald in the landmark case, alleged Mr Roberts-Smith had committed or been involved in six murders as a Special Air Service soldier in Afghanistan.
The killings were unlawful under the Geneva conventions, Mr Owens told the Federal Court in Sydney, and could not be explained as being in the "heat of battle" or "fog of war".
But Mr Roberts-Smith, who began what is expected to be several days of evidence on Thursday, said the allegations were "devastating" and based on "rumour and innuendo". One made him "really angry".
At the end of the day's proceedings, the two-metre-tall former soldier appeared to wipe tears from his eyes as he spoke about the events for which he was awarded the Victoria Cross.
The defamation trial, which started on Monday and is expected to run for up to 10 weeks, centres on articles published in 2018 that Mr Roberts-Smith alleges portrayed him as a war criminal and a perpetrator of domestic violence.
The media outlets outlined their truth defence on Thursday, before Mr Roberts-Smith entered the witness box.
Mr Owens said none of the six alleged murders involved "the difficulty of distinguishing between a civilian and a non-uniformed insurgent, or making a split-second assessment of whether the way that a person was moving indicated hostile intent".
Instead, all of the alleged victims were so-called PUCs - persons safely and securely under the control of Australian forces, he said.
Mr Owens said the rules of engagement under which Australian troops operated in Afghanistan were consistent with the Geneva Conventions. Once a person had been brought under the control of Australian troops, no matter whether they were "the most brutal, vile member of the Taliban imaginable", they could not be killed. To kill in these circumstances "is murder".
The media outlets' case did not "shy away" from the fact that most, but not all, of the six people killed were almost certainly insurgents, Mr Owens said.
He alleged Mr Roberts-Smith had constructed a "false narrative" that five of the six killings occurred during combat. Mr Roberts-Smith said the sixth killing did not occur and the person, an Afghan teenager, was released.
Justice Anthony Besanko was "presented with a stark choice", Mr Owens said, and ultimately must decide "who is lying".
(continued)
#13862445 at 2021-06-09 09:39:35 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
Ben Roberts-Smith's case against ex-wife complicated after judge raises 'relationship' with lawyer
Jamie McKinnell - 9 June 2021
Legal action launched by Ben Roberts-Smith against his ex-wife has been complicated after a judge raised the potentially "embarrassing" situation of media reports that he spent time socially with a lawyer.
Mr Roberts-Smith took Emma Roberts to court last week, on the eve of his high-stakes defamation trial against Nine Entertainment Co, over allegations she was accessing an email account he used for confidential legal correspondence.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times in a separate case over allegations of war crimes, bullying and domestic violence.
The veteran's legal team told the court it had questioned whether Ms Roberts passed the information, which is alleged to have included privileged material about the defamation case and the Afghanistan inquiry, on to other parties including Nine Entertainment Co.
But during a hearing in the Federal Court this morning, Justice Robert Bromwich raised a media report about Mr Roberts-Smith's connection to solicitor Monica Allen, who has been working on the defamation case.
Last August, News Corp published photographs of Mr Roberts-Smith riding scooters and holding hands with Ms Allen in Brisbane.
Ms Allen was the deponent of an affidavit filed in the case against Emma Roberts.
"I'm trying not to put the deponent of the affidavit in an awkward position," Justice Bromwich said.
"It's an embarrassing potential situation, it may be false. I have to deal with the reality that I have become aware of info that may or may not be correct."
The judge requested Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Arthur Moses SC, seek instructions about any "purported or alleged" relationship.
"It's potentially a personally delicate thing, but if the relationship between the deponent of the affidavit and the applicant is anything other than a purely professional relationship, I want to know what that wasn't disclosed," he said.
The judge said he was "surprised" it was left to him to raise the matter.
Mr Moses said he was conscious not to turn the separate case into "a satellite hearing to distract from the substantive [defamation] hearing".
"Female lawyers have enough to deal with in this profession without having those kinds of aspersions being put against them," he said.
Justice Bromwich said he raised the matter "with some anxiety".
"It's not something I find appealing at all, but I have to deal with the cards that are served on me."
Justice Bromwich said the problem was he had exercised power and made orders last week based on "an affidavit where there is at least a basis for a concern there has not been compliance with the duty of utmost good faith and disclosure".
Mr Moses agreed to provide further material to back up the orders.
Ms Allen did not comment as she left the court, but Seven West Media executive Bruce McWilliam denied there was any relationship and said any suggestion in the media to the contrary was a "deplorable slur".
"There's absolutely no truth attached to any of it and it's a very bad way to treat a very talented solicitor who's very good at what she does," he said.
In another hearing in the afternoon, Mr Moses produced a "gossip column" that linked Mr Roberts-Smith and Ms Allen published by the Australian Financial Review, now owned by Nine, this week.
"The applicant and the deponent are not in a relationship, full stop," Mr Moses said.
Mr Moses said the extensive media reports about today's development had "understandably caused embarrassment and concern to an officer of this court".
Mr Moses said there were "serious issues" about the respondents in the defamation matter conducting an attack on lawyers acting for Mr Roberts-Smith, saying it may constitute contempt of court by seeking to intimidate.
He said it could not be expected that every time a media party writes an article the lawyer concerned needs to attach it to an affidavit.
"That would constitute the potential harassment and belittling of a female practitioner."
Justice Bromwich also raised a separate matter regarding Mr Roberts-Smith's father, former judge Len Roberts-Smith QC, saying he had recognised him from an ABC News report on Monday night.
The judge said seven or eight years ago, he met Len Roberts-Smith as the head of the Defence Abuse Response Taskforce, and while a meeting between the pair was sought it never eventuated.
Justice Bromwich said he saw no reason to justify recusing himself from the proceedings, but Mr Moses told him he will seek instruction on the matter.
The case returns to court next Tuesday.
The defamation trial has been adjourned until Thursday morning.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-06-09/Ben-Roberts-Smith-sues-ex-wife-emma-roberts/100200862
#13855427 at 2021-06-08 09:35:57 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13855419
2/2
The court heard that in another newspaper report, it had been claimed Ben Roberts-Smith punched a woman who was a supporter of anti-violence campaigner Rosie Batty, and with whom the ex-soldier had been having an affair.
The incident with the woman occurred on May 28, 2018, after a dinner attended by the-then prime minister Malcolm Turnbull in Canberra.
The woman had attended the dinner with Mr Roberts-Smith, become "very, very drunk" and Mr Roberts-Smith had feared his affair with her would be exposed.
On leaving the dinner, Mr McClintock said it was caught on CCTV that the woman took to the stairs and "lost her footing ... hit her head and sustained ... a very severe impact to her left temple and eye".
He said that the woman had then told her doctor and others, including Mr Roberts-Smith's ex-wife Emma, that she had fallen down stairs.
But Mr McClintock said media had then falsely alleged that she had been struck by his client and that allegation had been even more damaging to Mr Roberts-Smith than claims of war crimes.
He told the court that should allegations against Mr Roberts-Smith that he was a murderer and had assaulted the woman be proved false he would be due the highest aggravated damages ever in Australia.
During the trial, Afghani witnesses will testify from a link in the Afghanistan capital, Kabul, via interpreters for the Afghani language, Pashto.
Mr McClintock said that although former Governor-General of Australia, Quentin Bryce, would not be testifying, she still supported Mr Roberts-Smith.
"Ms Quentin Bryce ... won't be appearing for personal reasons," Mr McClintock said, but he said that did not mean she was withdrawing her support of his client.
Earlier last week in the Federal Court in Sydney, Justice Wendy Abraham ordered a witness in the forthcoming trial to hand over documents about a military inquiry into alleged war crimes in Afghanistan.
Justice Abraham ruled an SAS soldier known as "Person 35", who will give evidence at the trial, must hand over documents linked to an inquiry by the Inspector-General of Defence into the conduct of Australian soldiers in Afghanistan.
"Person 35" is one of several witnesses who have asked for their evidence to the Inspector-General of Defence inquiry to not be made public.
Justice Abraham said "Person 35" has not been able to successfully argue the need for "public interest immunity".
The newspapers have withdrawn one allegation of unlawful killing from their defence, which involved Roberts-Smith swimming across a river and allegedly shooting an Afghan man.
Nine will contend the killing took place but will no longer contend it was unlawful. Four paragraphs of its defence have been withdrawn.
That killing took place on the same day as Roberts-Smith is alleged to have been involved in the murder of Afghan farmer Ali Jan, who was kicked off a cliff and then shot.
Mr Roberts-Smith has denied those events ever took place.
Last Friday, Mr Roberts-Smith launched a court action against his ex-wife ahead of the start of the start of this week's proceedings.
The action alleged Emma Roberts-Smith had deleted emails and attachments from his account which allegedly may have contained sensitive material of national security significance.
Len Roberts-Smith, a former judge Advocate General of the Australian Defence Force and his wife Sue flew in to Sydney last weekend to "support their son" at the trial after he had been under attack for several years.
"We are very proud of him for the father and son that he is," they said in a statement prior to the commencement of the trial.
"We love and care for him like every parent love and cares for their child."
https://www.news.com.au/national/courts-law/court-told-Ben-robertssmith-to-seek-huge-payout-after-reputation-smashed-and-destroyed/news-story/9615a4e6443656b6a70492ad8984d366
#13855419 at 2021-06-08 09:34:37 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Court told Ben Roberts-Smith to seek huge payout after reputation 'smashed and destroyed'
Ben Roberts-Smith will seek huge damages to compensate for his reputation being "smashed and destroyed", a court has heard.
Candace Sutton - JUNE 8, 2021
1/2
War hero Ben Roberts-Smith will seek a huge "uncapped" sum in damages to compensate for his reputation being "smashed and destroyed", a court has heard.
Day two of the highly-decorated war hero's blockbuster defamation trial was told that his earning capacity had dwindled to "none" after media claims of war crimes and an assault on a woman.
"There could not be a soldier better-known or more highly-regarded than (Ben Roberts-Smith)" prior to news reports claiming he was a war criminal and assaulted a woman the Federal Court in Sydney heard.
Bruce McClintock SC said the effect of those reports had been to "smash and destroy ... that reputation".
He told the court that invitations to speak publicly had dried up and that Mr Roberts-Smith had to withdraw from a lucrative job offer.
His annual income after leaving the SAS had been $325,000 in the 2018 financial year.
Mr McClintock said that an expert accountant would estimate his client's public speaking engagement losses as up to $475,000.
He said the primary income for Mr Roberts-Smith since he left the army was to be "engaged in a profitable career in public speaking for which he was paid".
He said the former soldier would be seeking "damages enough to restore (his) reputation so he can say ... the attacks on him are false.
"The more serious the attack, the greater the amount of money necessary to vindicate (him).
"These are not trivial attacks, these are allegations of murder and war crimes and there really can be nothing more serious than that.
"Equally, the allegation of domestic violence is extremely serious ... (and) inordinately damaging to my client."
Mr McClintock said the reports by media outlets publishing these claims had continued to be republished.
Mr McClintock then requested the court be closed so that "sensitive documents" could be tendered.
Roberts-Smith is suing three journalists and three one-time Fairfax newspapers, two of which are now owned by Nine.
The Afghanistan war hero claims he has been defamed by false allegations in news reports he committed war crimes in Afghanistan and punched a former girlfriend in the face.
The 203cm tall SAS veteran is suing over reports he says wrongly accused him of murder during his tours of Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012.
His lawyer, Bruce McClintock, SC, told the court on Monday the allegations were fuelled by "corrosive jealousy, cowardice and lies" by soldiers, some of whom were incompetent.
Mr McClintock said it had been Mr Roberts-Smith job to kill Taliban enemy insurgents in Afghanistan and he had been successful in doing so
Around 60 witnesses including Mr Roberts-Smith's former wife Emma, soldiers he fought with and Afghan villagers are expected to give evidence over the next few months.
Costs in the landmark defamation trial held inside 18D of the Federal Court in Sydney's Queens Square are expected to exceed $10m.
The 42-year-old denies all wrongdoing and the newspapers will seek to prove the truth of their allegations as their defence.
On the trial's opening day on Monday, Mr McClintock described as "ludicrous" and "unbelievable" allegations printed in the media that his client had boasted about killing a teenage boy and another that he had punched a woman.
Mr McClintock said the false allegation about the boy in Afghanistan had been made after a "visibly and extremely nervous" boy aged between 14 and 16 had been intercepted by Australian soldiers on November 5, 2012.
He was intercepted in a Toyota HiLux by a patrol led by Ben Roberts-Smith.
Mr McClintock said a witness had later asked Mr Roberts "what happened to the young bloke who was shaking like a leaf".
He said the witness's account was that Mr Roberts-Smith then said: "I shot that c*nt in the head. I pulled out my nine millimetre and shot him in the head.
"It was the most beautiful thing."
Mr McClintock said the false allegations made his client sound like "an ostentatious psychopath".
(continued)
#13848138 at 2021-06-07 07:42:07 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13848125
Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial told soldiers drank beer from dead Afghan man's prosthetic leg
Jamie McKinnell - 7 June 2021
1/2
Drinking beer from the prosthetic leg of an Afghan man allegedly shot dead by decorated veteran Ben Roberts-Smith was a way for soldiers to "decompress", a defamation trial has heard.
Bruce McClintock SC today opened the Victoria Cross recipient's case in the Federal Court in Sydney against Nine Entertainment Co over a series of articles published in 2018.
Mr McClintock said the reports, which contained allegations including involvement in the unlawful killing of Afghans and bullying of Special Air Services Regiment (SAS) colleagues, "destroyed" Mr Roberts-Smith's reputation as an "exceptional soldier".
"This is a case about courage, devotion to duty, self-sacrifice," Mr McClintock told the court.
He said the case also involved "dishonest", "corrosive" journalism and jealousy from Mr Roberts-Smith's colleagues after he was awarded for his bravery.
Mr Roberts-Smith, 42, is suing the publisher of The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times newspapers, along with three journalists.
He said he was defamed by imputations including that he "broke the moral and legal rules of military engagement" while on deployment in Afghanistan and is "therefore a criminal".
Mr Roberts-Smith alleges the inferences included that he unlawfully killed up to six Afghan men, or procured soldiers under his control to do so and also committed an act of domestic violence against a woman in a Canberra hotel.
Mr Roberts-Smith denies the allegations and the media company is relying on a truth defence.
Mr Roberts-Smith claims some inferences arise out of a specific incident in 2009, where he was alleged to have shot dead, at close range, a man with a prosthetic leg after clearing a compound.
Mr McClintock said the media company's legal team had attempted to paint the man as "a defenceless, disabled man because he had a prosthesis" when evidence pointed to him being a member of the enemy.
Mr Roberts-Smith is alleged to have shot the man 10 to 15 times after carrying him over his shoulder, but Mr McClintock said he would show the court a photograph of the dead man's body suggesting there were as little as two bullet wounds, consistent with his client's account.
Mr McClintock said the man's leg was "souvenired" by another SAS officer - an enemy of Mr Roberts-Smith - who took it back to base and had it mounted.
The leg was later used as a "novelty beer-drinking vessel" and many photographs of the prosthetic being used for this purpose have emerged.
"It might appear bad taste to drink from a souvenir prosthetic leg taken from a dead enemy," Mr McClintock told the court.
"In the scheme of human wickedness, it does not, in my submission, rate terribly high.
"And allowances should be made - my client will say something along these lines - for the necessity for men who've engaged in armed combat to decompress afterwards."
Mr McClintock said his client did not drink from the leg.
(continued)
#13848125 at 2021-06-07 07:32:51 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
'Corrosive jealousy and lies' behind Ben Roberts-Smith war crime claims, court told
Michaela Whitbourn - June 7, 2021
1/2
Former special forces soldier Ben Roberts-Smith's reputation was destroyed by a campaign fuelled by bitter and jealous soldiers who made allegations of war crimes to The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald, his barrister has alleged on the first day of his high-stakes defamation trial.
Sydney defamation barrister Bruce McClintock, SC, acting for Mr Roberts-Smith, told the Federal Court on Monday that the case was about "courage, devotion to duty [and] self-sacrifice", on the one hand, and "dishonest journalism, corrosive jealousy, cowardice and lies", on the other.
An allegation that Mr Roberts-Smith had killed an Afghan teenager and then boasted to another soldier about it in 2012 was "far fetched" because it was the kind of thing only an "ostentatious psychopath" would say.
Mr McClintock said Mr Roberts-Smith's reputation had been destroyed by a campaign led by "bitter people" in the Special Air Services who were "aided by credulous journalists".
He alleged "a number of soldiers had developed enormous jealousy towards my client", and "some might call it tall poppy syndrome". Some soldiers expected to give evidence for the media outlets might be "confused, mistaken or have false memories because of the trauma", Mr McClintock added.
Mr Roberts-Smith, a Victoria Cross recipient, launched the defamation lawsuit in 2018 over reports that he says accused him of murder during his 2009 to 2012 tour of Afghanistan and committing an act of domestic violence against a woman with whom he was having an extramarital affair. Along with the two media outlets now owned by Nine, he is suing three journalists and The Canberra Times, which is now under separate ownership.
Mr Roberts-Smith denies all wrongdoing. The media outlets are relying chiefly on a defence of truth. The trial is expected to run for up to 10 weeks.
In a lengthy opening address that is expected to continue into Tuesday, Mr McClintock rejected as "ridiculous" an allegation that Mr Roberts-Smith shot an Afghan teenager in the head in 2012 and told a fellow soldier "I shot that c— in the head" … It was the most beautiful thing I've ever seen".
"It's like [actor] Robert Duvall in Apocalypse Now; it's sort of thing that would be said by an ostentatious psychopath," Mr McClintock said. "He's not that."
He said Mr Roberts-Smith was an exceptional soldier; competent in battle and effective at engaging in killing. Some in the community might "blush" at the characterisation of killing as a virtue, he said, but, if so, their quarrel was with the government who sent young people to war.
He quoted former British Prime Minister Winston Churchill, who is said to have remarked: "We sleep soundly in our beds because rough men stand ready in the night to visit violence on those who would do us harm."
Mr Roberts-Smith killed many insurgents, he said, as did other Australian soldiers.
"War is violent," Mr McClintock said, and "the simple fact is that some who have reported on matters concerning my client have forgotten that fact … in their rush to tear him down."
He said the soldiers had "no way of knowing" whether a person was an insurgent or an ordinary villager in Afghanistan because "they didn't wear uniforms; they didn't carry a sign saying 'insurgent'."
(continued)
#13826954 at 2021-06-04 08:02:37 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
Ben Roberts-Smith launches proceedings against ex-wife on eve of trial
Michaela Whitbourn - June 3, 2021
1/2
Former special forces soldier Ben Roberts-Smith has filed Federal Court proceedings against his ex-wife just days before his high-stakes defamation case against The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald is due to start.
His estranged ex-wife, Emma Roberts, is expected to give evidence for the newspapers in that case.
Mr Roberts-Smith, a Victoria Cross recipient, launched the defamation lawsuit over reports that he says accused him of murder during his 2009 to 2012 tour of Afghanistan. He is also suing the parties, that include The Canberra Times, now under separate ownership, and three journalists, over an allegation of committing an act of domestic violence against a woman with whom he was having an extramarital affair.
Mr Roberts-Smith denies all wrongdoing. The trial, estimated to run for up to 10 weeks, is due to begin in the Federal Court in Sydney on Monday.
Ms Roberts was initially expected to be a witness for her ex-husband, saying the couple were separated when Mr Roberts-Smith started a new relationship and that it was not an affair. However, Ms Roberts now says that is false and she was being pressured by Mr Roberts-Smith to lie.
At a pre-trial hearing in April, the former soldier's barrister, Bruce McClintock, SC, said that if Ms Roberts gave evidence he would have to cross-examine her in court, and suggested the media outlets should "rethink what they're doing" because "sometimes you can pay too high a price" by involving family members in proceedings.
Nicholas Owens, SC, acting for the media outlets, said this was an "egregious submission".
Now the Federal Court has listed a new case launched by Mr Roberts-Smith against his former wife with a "return of subpoena" to be heard at 2.15pm on Friday before Justice Robert Bromwich.
The nature of the dispute between the two is not yet clear. However, Mr Owens told the court in April that Mr Roberts-Smith had warned Ms Roberts in a letter that month that if she spoke to lawyers for the news outlets about potential evidence, he would seek an injunction, attempt to sue her and take steps to undo a property settlement between them.
Mr McClintock said the letter was not a threat. He said a confidentiality agreement had been struck between two legally represented parties this year and "we do not waive" it.
(continued)
#13819270 at 2021-06-03 08:18:53 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13748711
Ben Roberts-Smith 'extremely paranoid and obsessive' over inquiry, courts hears
MAX MADDISON and KIERAN GAIR - JUNE 3, 2021
Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith became "extremely paranoid and obsessive" after Nine Entertainment published allegations he had committed war crimes while serving in Afghanistan, a court has heard.
In a Federal Court judgment on Wednesday, judge Anthony Besanko said the war hero's ex-wife, Emma Roberts, asked her former husband to "seek professional help" to address concerns about his alleged "excessive" drinking, anxiety and depression.
Mr Roberts-Smith, 42, is suing Nine newspapers the Sydney Morning Herald and The Age for defamation over a series of reports published in 2018, which he says portrayed him as a murderous war criminal during his time as a Special Air Service soldier in Afghanistan in 2009-12.
The decorated veteran has denied the allegations, while Nine has indicated it will defend the allegations using a truth defence when the matter goes to trial in Sydney on June 7.
The court heard allegations that Ms Roberts, who will give evidence on behalf of Nine, had leaked hundreds of images of soldiers drinking out of a prosthetic leg to the press.
The evidence from Ms Roberts is related to her deposition with the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force, as part of a wider military inquiry conducted by Major-General Paul Brereton.
"She states that following the commencement of the Inspector-General's investigation, the applicant became, at times, erratic and suffered from mood swings," the judgment reads.
"According to Ms Roberts, these circumstances coincided with an increased consumption of alcohol by the applicant on a nightly basis when he was in her presence."
"The applicant asked his friend, an ex-army doctor, Dr (Parbodh) Gogna, to prescribe him beta blockers for excessive alcohol usage, anxiety and depression ... Ms Roberts refers to the applicant's behaviour when intoxicated. I need not set out the details."
The judgment details how the pair sought counselling at the Psychology Cafe from October 2017 through till the end of 2018. Nine alleges Mr Robert-Smith's assault of his mistress, who will be referred to in the trial as Person 17, took place in March 2018.
While psychiatrist Robi Sonderegger, who the subpoena was directed to, was not their counsellor, he holds the files for Psychology Cafe. Ms Roberts's credibility as a witness is expected to be challenged by her former husband's lawyers, who have previously said they will put to her that she is a liar during cross-examination.
Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers had sought to exclude this evidence being presented, but Justice Besanko dismissed the request, saying the documents were relevant due to their ability to address the alleged separation of the couple and Mr Roberts-Smith's affair.
However, he did agree with Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers that the class of documents relating to Dr Gogna's subpoena was "too wide" and extended to "irrelevant medical information".
"There are unlikely to be documents in the medical file which are relevant to Dr Gogna's proposed evidence as to the applicant's character or the identification of him in the articles," he said.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/media/Ben-robertssmith-extremely-paranoid-and-obsessive-over-inquiry-courts-hears/news-story/58f70edfc8827b6eb1178169d9234281
#13819262 at 2021-06-03 08:15:49 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13748711
Ben Roberts-Smith's lawyers say ex-wife leaked photos of soldiers drinking from prosthetic leg
Jamelle Wells - 2 June 2021
Lawyers for Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith have told the Federal Court his former wife leaked photos of soldiers drinking out of a prosthetic leg to the media.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing Nine owned newspapers, which include The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age, over stories that allege he committed war crimes in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012 and punched a woman in the face in Canberra in 2018.
In a high-profile trial due to open Monday, the newspapers will rely on truth as a defence.
One of the barristers on Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team, Matthew Richardson, told a pre-trial hearing the team was still going through various images on USB drives that were part of the case.
Nine has alleged in court the drives contain images of soldiers drinking from the prosthetic leg of a dead Afghan man and that the drives were found buried in Mr Roberts-Smith's yard.
After the court heard the legal teams for the newspapers still didn't have access to the USB drives, Mr Richardson said Mr Roberts-Smith's ex-wife, Emma Roberts, leaked the images to the media.
He said the images of the prosthetic leg won't all be processed by the time the trial opens because it is an "onerous" task.
One of the lawyers acting for the newspapers, Lyndelle Barnett, disputed his claim, saying her clients did not have the material and did not receive it from Ms Roberts-Smith.
Ms Barnett said only one of her clients had the information being discussed but could not hand it over to lawyers due to national security laws.
Justice Anthony Besanko said the court would be open to the public for the trial but proceedings were unlikely to be live-streamed as there was a risk of disclosing national security information.
"My present inclination is not to," he said.
"That risk seems to be one that needs to be taken into account."
The court heard the opening address by Mr Roberts-Smith's chief barrister Bruce McClintock SC would run for two to three days.
Mr Roberts-Smith will be the first witness and his evidence is likely to take four days.
The trial is expected to run for up to 10 weeks.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-06-02/Ben-Roberts-Smith-ex-wife-leaked-photos-court-hears/100186212
#13812152 at 2021-06-02 08:10:15 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13748711
National security concerns likely to keep Ben Roberts-Smith trial offline
Harriet Alexander - June 2, 2021
The judge overseeing the defamation action brought by Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith over war crimes allegations said he was inclined not to allow live streaming of the trial to prevent the inadvertent disclosure of national security information.
Justice Anthony Besanko told parties to the trial, which is due to commence in the Federal Court on Monday, that he was concerned sensitive material could find its way into the public domain if it was live streamed, even though the Commonwealth had indicated it was not opposed and the parties are in favour of live streaming.
"But that risk seems to me to be one that needs to be taken into account," Justice Besanko said.
Mr Roberts-Smith, a decorated war veteran, is suing The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald, The Canberra Times and three journalists over a series of articles about his 2009 to 2012 tour of Afghanistan that he says portrayed him as a murderer, war criminal and perpetrator of domestic violence. The publications are relying on a truth defence.
Whether or not the trial is live streamed, the Sydney courtroom will be open to the public. Justice Besanko said alternatives to the live stream included a delayed recording stream or a recording that was published subject to appropriate editing.
The trial is expected to run for 10 weeks, with both sides calling multiple SAS soldiers. Justice Besanko was told at an interlocutory hearing on Wednesday morning that the cross-examination of witnesses was expected to take weeks.
The court may also need to rely on an interpreter based in Canada to overcome the difficulty in obtaining a qualified local interpreter for the Afghan witnesses.
Last week the media outlets dropped one element of their truth defence, related to the alleged killing of an unarmed Afghan, constituting murder, but they are seeking to prove that Mr Roberts-Smith killed that unarmed man, and six other murders.
Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Matthew Richardson, said he would seek aggravated damages in relation to the claim about the unarmed Afghan due to the lack of fundamental evidence for it.
The court also heard that the publications' legal representatives had still not been granted access to material contained on USB sticks that were relevant to the trial, including photographs of soldiers drinking from a prosthetic leg that belonged to a man alleged to have been unlawfully killed.
A previous hearing heard Mr Roberts-Smith had condensed the material onto one USB and transferred it to his laptop, which he subsequently wiped.
Mr Richardson said the publications had access to those documents anyway because the USBs had been provided to them by Mr Roberts-Smith's ex-wife.
But Lyndelle Barnett, acting for the newspapers, said that only one of her clients had possession of the material and he was prevented from giving it to his lawyers under National Security Information legislation.
"We don't have the material on the USBs and … my client did not receive them from the applicant's ex-wife," Ms Barnett said.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/national-security-concerns-likely-to-keep-Ben-Roberts-Smith-trial-offline-20210602-p57xbu.html
#13812141 at 2021-06-02 08:06:43 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13748711
War crimes investigators to monitor Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial
Harriet Alexander - June 1, 2021
Investigators probing alleged war crimes by Australian soldiers in Afghanistan will monitor the defamation case brought by Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith against The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald for any material that might assist in a potential criminal prosecution against the war hero.
Mr Roberts-Smith, a former Special Air Service Regiment soldier, is suing the media outlets over reports that he says accused him of murder during his 2009 to 2012 tour of Afghanistan. The trial is due to begin on Monday.
The Australian Federal Police and the Office of the Special Investigator, which was established in January to examine the findings of the Brereton inquiry into allegations of war crimes, discussed the Benefits and disadvantages of the defamation trial going ahead, according to sources who were not permitted to comment publicly.
They formed the view that the defamation trial could yield invaluable evidence for any future criminal prosecution against Mr Roberts-Smith or any other soldier, the sources said.
In late May 2018 the federal police launched two separate war crimes investigations into Mr Roberts-Smith, both of which have submitted briefs of evidence to the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions, who will decide whether charges should be laid.
The Brereton inquiry was a fact-finding exercise that gave witnesses immunity in that their testimony could not be used against them in a criminal trial but could be used against others.
Sources who are not authorised to speak publicly said this meant that some of the evidence from the Brereton inquiry was inadmissable, but the Federal Court defamation trial could be plumbed for first-hand witnesses to alleged war crimes and evidence not otherwise available to the Office of the Special Investigator.
Investigations are likely to be impeded by the closure of the Australian embassy in Kabul. OSI director-general Chris Moraitis told a Senate estimates hearing last week that the decision to close the embassy made it more difficult to gain access to witnesses in Afghanistan while preparing the brief of evidence.
Several witnesses appearing for Mr Roberts-Smith have been served "potentially affected persons" notices to indicate that they are under investigation, raising the prospect they might incriminate themselves by giving evidence.
They will have the opportunity to ask for a certificate as they appear to prevent their evidence being used against them in any future criminal proceedings. A certificate would be granted at the discretion of the judge.
But the witnesses need to assert that their own evidence may tend to prove that they have committed an offence, otherwise they will have no reason to ask for a certificate. The AFP and the Special Investigator will then be able to use the statements given by those soldiers in the Federal Court to inform future investigations.
The AFP and the Special Investigator will also be able to consider any discrepancies between what witnesses told the Brereton inquiry and what they told the Federal Court, and if they exist, potentially charge people with perjury.
Civil trials are often stayed in order to avoid prejudicing upcoming criminal trials. Actor Craig McLachlan's defamation action against the ABC, Fairfax (now Nine) and an actor was stayed in 2019 until the completion of criminal proceedings against him. He was found not guilty last year.
In a separate Victorian case this year, a man involved in criminal proceedings appealed his conviction on the basis that part of the case against him had been taken from the evidence he gave in civil proceedings, which he would not have given had he known he was under investigation.
Mr Roberts-Smith launched his defamation action in April 2018, more than two years before the Special Investigator was appointed and before an investigation into allegations that he intimidated war crimes victims had begun.
He is unlikely to apply for an immunity certificate because he brought the defamation action and he denies having committed a criminal offence.
A spokesperson for the Office of the Special Investigator said the defamation proceedings were a private matter between the parties.
The AFP declined to comment.
https://www.smh.com.au/national/war-crimes-investigators-to-monitor-Ben-Roberts-Smith-defamation-trial-20210601-p57x3l.html
#13805129 at 2021-06-01 08:34:35 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
>>13748711
Ben Roberts-Smith's old comrade ordered to hand documents to media
Adam Cooper - June 1, 2021
A soldier who is to appear as a witness for Ben Roberts-Smith in a looming defamation trial must hand over documents related to his own involvement in a military inquiry that investigated alleged war crimes in Afghanistan.
On Tuesday The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald, which are being sued by Mr Roberts-Smith, were granted access to documents about an SAS soldier's involvement in the inquiry by the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force, which probed the conduct of Australian soldiers in Afghanistan.
Mr Roberts-Smith, a highly decorated former SAS soldier, is suing the media outlets over reports he allegedly committed murder during deployments to Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012 and that he allegedly punched the woman with whom he was having an affair in Canberra in 2018.
He denies the allegations and says the reports are defamatory because they portray him as a criminal.
The media will defend the claim using a truth defence at a defamation trial in the Federal Court starting on Monday and set to run up to eight weeks.
Among the allegations against Mr Roberts-Smith, the news outlets have reported he shot and killed an unarmed and detained Afghan man on Easter Sunday in 2009. The outlets allege his conduct that day constituted murder.
One of Mr Roberts-Smith's then-colleagues, a soldier known as Person 35, is to give evidence in the defamation trial about what he saw and knew about that day.
In the countdown to the trial, Justice Wendy Abraham ruled on Tuesday that Person 35 must hand over documents related to his involvement in the inspector-general's inquiry. The documents could include papers advising Person 35 that an adverse finding was found against him by Major-General Paul Brereton, who conducted the inquiry.
Person 35 opposed releasing his files to lawyers for the news outlets and argued they were not in the public interest.
Justice Abraham did not provide reasons for her orders.
The news outlets allege that after Mr Roberts-Smith shot and killed the Afghan man, Australian soldiers took the dead man's prosthetic leg as a souvenir and then used the artificial limb as a drinking vessel. The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald have published photographs of Mr Roberts-Smith alongside Australian and US soldiers drinking from the prosthetic leg at a party at a coalition military base in southern Afghanistan in 2012.
The case will return to court on Wednesday for a directions hearing. The trial starts in Sydney on Monday, with Mr Roberts-Smith to be the first witness to give evidence.
If you are a current or former ADF member, or a relative, and need counselling or support, contact the Defence All-Hours Support Line on 1800 628 036 or Open Arms on 1800 011 046.
https://www1.defence.gov.au/adf-members-families/health-well-being/services-support-fighting-fit/need-help-now/all-hours-support-line
https://www.openarms.gov.au
https://www.smh.com.au/national/Ben-Roberts-Smith-s-old-comrade-ordered-to-hand-documents-to-media-20210601-p57wzl.html
#13748711 at 2021-05-25 08:26:09 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
Ben Roberts-Smith wiped laptop days after being told to retain documents, court told
Georgina Mitchell - May 25, 2021
1/2
Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith wiped the contents of his laptop five days after he was told by lawyers in a defamation case to retain certain information and documents, a court has heard.
Mr Roberts-Smith, 42, is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times over a series of stories published in 2018, which he says are defamatory because they portray him as someone who "broke the moral and legal rules of military engagement" and committed murder.
A trial, due to begin in Sydney on June 7, is expected to last six to eight weeks.
On Tuesday, the newspapers' barrister Lyndelle Barnett told the Federal Court her clients have asked for a series of USB sticks retrieved from Mr Roberts-Smith's former home in June 2020 to be produced to the court. However, they were told the contents of the USBs had been "condensed" onto Mr Roberts-Smith's laptop in August or September last year and the USBs were then discarded.
"We then sought the laptop, with a view to it being inspected by an expert, and were told on Friday night that the applicant has wiped the hard drive of that laptop very recently, on the 17th of April," Ms Barnett said. "Nonetheless, we still press for production of that laptop."
Ms Barnett said the newspapers plan for an independent expert to examine the laptop to see if anything is recoverable, and to examine any metadata on the laptop so it might be seen how it was wiped.
"That did occur five days after we wrote to the applicant requiring him to retain documents associated with the USBs, so we are concerned about the hard drive having been wiped in those circumstances. It is something we wish to explore," Ms Barnett said.
"We don't accept it was appropriate for the applicant to wipe his hard drive after being asked to retain it, but that will be a matter for trial."
Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister Bruce McClintock, SC, said he is happy to provide the laptop, adding "there's nothing sinister in what occurred".
"My client was in the course of buying a new computer and trading in the old one, and that's the reason for these events," Mr McClintock said. "The five USBs, or whatever number they were, were in fact condensed into one USB."
He said this USB remains with his instructing solicitors because, "I believe there are national security issues."
(continued)
#13741333 at 2021-05-24 09:28:47 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #16 - INFILTRATION NOT INVASION Edition
#15 - Part 10
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry
>>13342017 Ben Roberts-Smith: Afghan civilians to testify via video link in former soldier's defamation case
>>13407722 Buried evidence and threats: How Ben Roberts-Smith tried to cover up his alleged crimes
>>13407783 War hero Ben Roberts-Smith hits back at bombshell report
>>13407814 'I'm going to do everything I can to f-cking destroy them': Secret Ben Roberts-Smith audio revealed
>>13407824 Seven stands by senior executive Ben Roberts-Smith over new evidence he attempted to cover up alleged crimes
>>13408195 Ben Roberts-Smith under fresh investigation over burner phones and sealed envelopes
>>13410361 Video: Shocking evidence of potential war crime exposed in major investigation - 60 Minutes Australia
>>13422740 Australian Federal Police confirm probe into Ben Roberts-Smith for allegedly burying sensitive Defence files in his backyard
>>13424966 High-ranking Army officer facing sack over debauched party in Afghan bar - "Fat Lady's Arms" pub set up by Australian troops at Tarin Kowt headquarters
>>13459865 Peter Dutton overrules Chief of the Defence Force Angus Campbell's decision to strip Meritorious Unit Citation from Special Forces soldiers
>>13459872 Video: Peter Dutton and PM 'strongly of the same view' on citation stripping reversal - Sky News Australia
>>13460103 Video: Government announces royal commission into veteran and serving Defence member suicides
>>13499771 Ben Roberts-Smith case: Media can't amend defence but can call on witnesses to detail Mr Roberts-Smith's involvement in alleged murders of two Afghan men
>>13515316 Ben Roberts-Smith takes leave from Seven Network role during defamation case against newspaper journalists
>>13515323 Ben Roberts-Smith welcomes Royal Commission, slams treatment of veterans, says a royal commission is "desperately needed"
>>13539684 Ben Roberts-Smith allegedly threatened to sue his ex-wife over defamation case, court told
>>13626087 Fears of Taliban retribution raised in Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case
>>13665040 Police probe sealed envelopes, scraps of paper in Ben Roberts-Smith case
#13741263 at 2021-05-24 09:03:36 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
#15 - Part 10
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry
>>13342017 Ben Roberts-Smith: Afghan civilians to testify via video link in former soldier's defamation case
>>13407722 Buried evidence and threats: How Ben Roberts-Smith tried to cover up his alleged crimes
>>13407783 War hero Ben Roberts-Smith hits back at bombshell report
>>13407814 'I'm going to do everything I can to f-cking destroy them': Secret Ben Roberts-Smith audio revealed
>>13407824 Seven stands by senior executive Ben Roberts-Smith over new evidence he attempted to cover up alleged crimes
>>13408195 Ben Roberts-Smith under fresh investigation over burner phones and sealed envelopes
>>13410361 Video: Shocking evidence of potential war crime exposed in major investigation - 60 Minutes Australia
>>13422740 Australian Federal Police confirm probe into Ben Roberts-Smith for allegedly burying sensitive Defence files in his backyard
>>13424966 High-ranking Army officer facing sack over debauched party in Afghan bar - "Fat Lady's Arms" pub set up by Australian troops at Tarin Kowt headquarters
>>13459865 Peter Dutton overrules Chief of the Defence Force Angus Campbell's decision to strip Meritorious Unit Citation from Special Forces soldiers
>>13459872 Video: Peter Dutton and PM 'strongly of the same view' on citation stripping reversal - Sky News Australia
>>13460103 Video: Government announces royal commission into veteran and serving Defence member suicides
>>13499771 Ben Roberts-Smith case: Media can't amend defence but can call on witnesses to detail Mr Roberts-Smith's involvement in alleged murders of two Afghan men
>>13515316 Ben Roberts-Smith takes leave from Seven Network role during defamation case against newspaper journalists
>>13515323 Ben Roberts-Smith welcomes Royal Commission, slams treatment of veterans, says a royal commission is "desperately needed"
>>13539684 Ben Roberts-Smith allegedly threatened to sue his ex-wife over defamation case, court told
>>13626087 Fears of Taliban retribution raised in Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case
>>13665040 Police probe sealed envelopes, scraps of paper in Ben Roberts-Smith case
#13665040 at 2021-05-15 02:26:47 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
>>13407722
Police probe sealed envelopes, scraps of paper in Ben Roberts-Smith case
Nick McKenzie and Chris Masters - May 15, 2021
1/2
A new police taskforce investigating former soldier Ben Roberts-Smith has uncovered scraps of paper with the hand-written names and addresses of SAS soldiers, created as part of an alleged plot to threaten witnesses to a war crimes inquiry.
The discovery of the scraps of paper, along with witness testimony alleging that Mr Roberts-Smith was behind the 2018 plot to intimidate witnesses, is the biggest breakthrough yet for the recently launched Australian Federal Police taskforce as it investigates the former soldier for serious criminal offences.
If it was proven that Mr Roberts-Smith had sought to threaten any of his fellow Special Air Service Regiment soldiers to stop them testifying at the Brereton inquiry into alleged war crimes, he could face up to five years in jail.
The former soldier has denied any involvement in the intimidation plot and is suing The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald over reports detailing his alleged involvement in war crimes, bullying and assaulting a woman.
In late April, AFP Deputy Commissioner Ian McCartney told a parliamentary estimates committee that the federal police had in late March launched a new "priority" investigation into Mr Roberts-Smith and that the witness intimidation allegations were being treated "seriously".
Mr McCartney refused to provide the committee with further details and the AFP has declined to respond to inquiries, citing ongoing investigations. But multiple sources with knowledge of the investigation, who were not authorised to speak publicly, said the handwritten scraps of paper contained the names of two SAS soldiers who had served with Mr Roberts-Smith in Afghanistan.
Both SAS veterans hold adverse information about the decorated former soldier and both men were ordered to appear before the Brereton inquiry, a major probe into alleged war crimes run between 2016 and 2020 by the military Inspector-General and overseen by senior judge Paul Brereton.
Detectives working on the case have also recovered four envelopes containing threatening anonymous messages warning the two SAS soldiers to cover up damning alleged misconduct in Afghanistan.
Two of the envelopes were sent to one of the witnesses via a post office servicing the elite SAS headquarters in Perth. They were seized by the AFP in June 2018. The remaining envelopes were never sent. They were recovered by police in March 2020.
In 2018, the then chief of the defence force, Mark Binskin, described the sending of the anonymous letters as a disgraceful criminal act aimed at scaring witnesses from testifying before the Brereton inquiry. He said defence had called the AFP in to urgently investigate, although the original police inquiry stalled until the recent discovery of the handwritten notes.
That discovery triggered AFP Commissioner Reece Kershaw to launch a new police taskforce. The AFP taskforce is operating in Brisbane and is the third investigating Mr Roberts-Smith.
(continued)
#13626087 at 2021-05-10 08:03:03 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
Fears of Taliban retribution raised in Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case
LANE SAINTY - MAY 7, 2021
Fears of brutal Taliban retribution against Afghan witnesses in the Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case have been raised in court as parties battle over whether certain documents should, if they exist, stay secret.
After the possibility of "barbaric punishment or death" was mooted by a lawyer for the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force, Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister Arthur Moses SC retorted that his client might be the one in danger.
Mr Roberts-Smith is "the father of two children, has been accused of war crimes against the Taliban and he wears those allegations like a loaded gun every day", Mr Moses said.
Mr Roberts-Smith, a former SAS soldier and Victoria Cross recipient, is suing Nine newspapers for defamation over reports alleging he committed war crimes while on deployment in Afghanistan and punched a woman in a Canberra hotel.
Nine will vigorously defend its reporting at an eight-week trial due to start on June 7.
Mr Roberts-Smith has subpoenaed the ADF and Australian Federal Police in relation to four Afghan witnesses, the Federal Court was told on Friday.
The four people, from the village of Darwan, are expected to testify remotely from Kabul about an allegation that Mr Roberts-Smith kicked an Afghan man named Ali Jan off a small cliff and ordered another officer to shoot him.
But Inspector-General James Gaynor has filed a public interest immunity claim against Mr Roberts-Smith's request, contending the documents - which may or may not exist - should be kept confidential.
The case is already subject to extensive national security confidentiality measures.
On Friday, lawyers were at pains to say they were speaking only in hypotheticals before the hearing was closed to the public altogether.
Barrister Andrew Berger QC said the immunity claim was necessary to protect people in Afghanistan who had co-operated with the Brereton inquiry into Australian war crimes and to ensure Mr Gaynor could continue to carry out his work as Inspector-General.
Mr Berger argued the mere possibility of Taliban retribution should weigh heavily in favour of the claim.
"The Taliban can and does punish people who are perceived to have acted inconsistently with their ideology and objectives," he said.
Mr Berger also argued the immunity claim should outweigh concerns about the administration of justice as it was a civil, not criminal, case. "Liberty is not at stake in these proceedings and nor is the protection of the community," he said.
Mr Moses suggested the threat of Taliban retribution could equally apply to Mr Roberts-Smith. "We should just pause for a moment and think what the Taliban may or may not do to someone they think has engaged in such war crimes if they ever got their hands on him or his family," he said.
He said if the Afghan witnesses had previously put forward a version of events about what happened with Ali Jan, Mr Roberts-Smith was entitled to have it.
The immunity claim is being supported by the Australian Federal Police.
Justice Wendy Abraham has reserved her decision.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/media/fears-of-taliban-retribution-raised-in-Ben-robertssmith-defamation-case/news-story/db59c3a82bc821b00e7a3ef78f4b1faa
#13539684 at 2021-04-29 09:47:57 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
Ben Roberts-Smith allegedly threatened to sue his ex-wife over defamation case, court told
Jamie McKinnell - 29 April 2021
Decorated Australian soldier Ben Roberts-Smith allegedly threatened to sue his ex-wife if she breached a confidentiality agreement while speaking to lawyers acting in his defamation case, a court has heard.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing three former Fairfax newspapers, The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times, as well as three journalists over a series of 2018 articles.
The Victoria Cross recipient claims the reports were defamatory and wrongly portrayed him as a criminal due to his alleged conduct while on deployment in Afghanistan, including the alleged murder of an unarmed civilian.
He claims the articles contained imputations including that he "broke the moral and legal rules of military engagement", "disgraced his country", bullied a fellow soldier and committed an act of domestic violence against a woman in a Canberra hotel.
Mr Roberts-Smith denies the specific events mentioned in the stories took place, while the media companies claim they are able to justify the imputations.
Ahead of a lengthy trial beginning in June, the Federal Court today heard lawyers acting for the media companies provided an outline of evidence set to be given by his ex-wife Emma Roberts to Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team.
When more detail was requested, they sought an agreement that he would not rely on a confidentiality agreement but never received a response.
Barrister Nicholas Owens SC, for the media companies, said Mr Roberts-Smith wrote to Ms Roberts with threats of an injunction, to sue her for damages and to overturn a property settlement.
Mr Roberts-Smith's barrister, Bruce McClintock QC, later said he was "simply not in a position" to waive the confidentiality agreement, and also rejected the classification of the correspondence as a threat.
"It wasn't a threat," he said.
"It was simply a requirement that she obey an agreement she entered into in February this year, only two or three months ago."
Mr McClintock said despite the case being "pretty awful already" he would need to cross-examine Ms Roberts to put to her that she is a liar.
He suggested his opponents should "re-think what they're doing" because "sometimes you can pay too high a price to air a family's dirty linen".
Mr Owens insisted Ms Roberts's evidence will be "carefully limited" so as to relate to matters directly relevant to the case, including allegations of witness intimidation and covert communication with witnesses by Mr Roberts-Smith.
The court also heard military witnesses who may give evidence risk consequences of "extraordinary gravity" including accusations of murder.
During arguments about the order in which evidence should flow, Mr McClintock said he wanted his client to be the first witness ahead of military witnesses.
But he said the position of those military witnesses must be considered due to the gravity of what is alleged against them, including the commission of murder and war crimes of the most serious kind.
Mr McClintock said the witnesses had a right to know the extent of the allegations before they were called.
He said the starkest examples were two people known by the pseudonyms 'person 5' and 'person 11'.
"The consequences for those two men, person 5 and person 11, could be of extraordinary gravity," he said.
"Indeed they could be of extraordinary gravity just by giving evidence in chief.
"In my submission, people in their positions should be entitled to hear and know the actual evidence against them before they're called upon to respond."
Mr Roberts-Smith is claiming damages, including aggravated damages, interest and costs, arguing the articles "brought [him] into public disrepute, odium, ridicule and contempt".
The trial begins on June 7.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-04-29/Ben-Roberts-Smith-warned-ex-wife-about-confidentiality-agreement/100104166
#13515323 at 2021-04-26 08:33:51 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
>>13515316
Ben Roberts-Smith welcomes Royal Commission, slams treatment of veterans
Australia's most decorated war hero has delivered a scathing attack on the Australian Defence Force and says a royal commission is "desperately needed."
Matthew Benns and Josh Hanrahan - April 25, 2021
1/2
Australia's most decorated war hero has delivered a scathing attack on the Australian Defence Force's top brass for their "disgusting" treatment of veterans and "staggering" lack of direction.
Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith said military commanders had run Australia's longest-ever conflict in Afghanistan from the safety and comfort of Dubai without ever having a campaign strategy.
And he thanked the Australian public for pushing for a royal commission into veteran suicides in the face of resistance from defence force chiefs afraid "because we're going to uncover systemic failures and systemic flaws''.
"That is the point of this royal commission ... it's what we need to do to protect the future of the military and more importantly, the people that are willing to sacrifice everything," he said.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing Nine newspapers for defamation over articles alleging he was being investigated by the Australian Federal Police for killing six Afghans outside of combat and was a war criminal.
The expensive legal battle is set to start in June and on Friday former governor-general Quentin Bryce was named as a reputation witness for Mr Roberts-Smith, who now runs Channel 7 in Queensland.
The 42-year-old former SAS corporal would not talk about his own experiences but said the treatment of his colleagues when they returned showed that a Royal Commission was desperately needed.
"It is a giant step forward for the prime minister to make this announcement and commit to a royal commission," he said.
"It is something that is very much needed given the disproportionate rates of suicide that we see in Australia. We really need to address it."
Mr Roberts-Smith said the person running the commission needed to be independent of the Australian Defence Force and "should not have ever been a service member or indeed anyone who potentially has ever worked in the same forms of government."
He said the problem of veteran suicide lay squarely at the door of the top brass.
The "first flaw" in taking care of veterans was that "the psychological screening was a farce".
"It was mostly an exercise designed to cover the senior leadership. It did not create any effect that would be conducive with protecting soldiers, sailors, airmen and mental health," he said.
"We have been let down by our own military. We didn't have as many casualties as perhaps we could have because the men and women that serve were bloody good at their job.
"And yet now a lot of these issues are stemming from the fact that veterans feel that their own military family is taking that away from them.
"It's disgusting."
(continued)
#13515316 at 2021-04-26 08:31:44 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
Ben Roberts-Smith takes leave from Seven Network role during defamation case against newspaper journalists
Matthew Doran - 26 April 2021
Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith is taking leave as boss of the Seven Network's Queensland operations, as he pursues a defamation case in the Federal Court.
The announcement was made by Seven West's CEO James Warburton in an all-staff email on Monday.
Mr Roberts-Smith launched the defamation case against The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times newspapers over a series of stories from 2018 alleging he committed war crimes in Afghanistan - which he strongly denies.
The newspapers reject his claim, and the trial is due to start in the Federal Court in early June.
Mr Warburton said Mr Roberts-Smith's leave from his position as general manager Seven Brisbane and 7Queensland would begin immediately.
"Ben and I believe this mutual decision is best for both him and our company," Mr Warburton said.
"We expect Ben to return to his role upon the completion of his defamation proceedings.
"As the trial is currently set down for eight weeks, it's likely this won't be until after August."
Earlier this month Mr Roberts-Smith labelled further allegations about his conduct, broadcast on the Nine Network, as "baseless".
60 Minutes alleged he had buried USB drives containing purportedly compromising material in his backyard, rather than providing them to police and military investigators.
The program also broadcast secret recordings of Mr Roberts-Smith, in which he appeared to say he was indebted to Seven West chairman Kerry Stokes for financially supporting his legal battle and promised to destroy journalists who were publishing stories about him.
At the time Mr Roberts-Smith took aim at Nine's journalist Nick McKenzie, arguing he had not put any of the allegations to him before broadcast.
The Australian Federal Police have confirmed to federal Parliament fresh investigations into Mr Roberts-Smith had been launched following 60 Minutes' reporting.
Last year the Federal Court heard eyewitnesses had detailed to investigators how Mr Roberts-Smith allegedly committed a violent war crime, by kicking a handcuffed Afghan civilian off a cliff in 2012.
Mr Roberts-Smith denied the "false allegations", and said the newspapers reporting and defence of the defamation suit were "completely without any foundation in truth".
The newspapers scored a win in pre-trial wrangling in April, with Justice Anthony Besanko allowing four Afghan villagers and a member of the ADF to give evidence in the court case.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-04-26/Ben-Roberts-Smith-leave-seven-network-role-defamation-case/100095586
#13499771 at 2021-04-24 04:01:13 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
>>13407722
Ben Roberts-Smith case: Media can't amend defence but can call on witnesses
Adam Cooper - April 23, 2021
1/2
The news outlets being sued by Ben Roberts-Smith have lost their bid to include in a defamation trial evidence of new allegations of serious criminal conduct against the former SAS soldier over his conduct in Afghanistan.
But a Federal Court judge on Friday granted The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald permission to use new evidence of eight Australian soldiers who are expected to detail Mr Roberts-Smith's involvement in several incidents including the alleged murders of two Afghan men in 2009, to bolster the news outlets' truth defence.
Mr Roberts-Smith, a highly decorated former soldier and Victoria Cross recipient, is suing The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald over reports he allegedly committed murder during deployments to Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012, and that he also allegedly punched his mistress in the face in Canberra in 2018.
Mr Roberts-Smith denies the allegations and says the reports are defamatory because they portray him as a criminal.
The media will defend the claim using a truth defence at a trial to start on June 7.
The news outlets this month applied to Justice Anthony Besanko to amend their defence to include evidence of two more incidents of what they called "very serious criminal conduct" on top of Mr Roberts-Smith's alleged involvement in six unlawful killings as an Australian soldier in Afghanistan.
Justice Besanko on Friday refused the media's application, but granted the news outlets' lawyers the right to call on a group of Australian soldiers to give evidence about what they saw and knew about several incidents including the deaths of two Afghan men allegedly unlawfully killed on Easter Sunday 2009.
The judge said he was not yet ready to provide reasons for his decisions because of potential national security concerns.
Justice Besanko will next week hear arguments on whether the news outlets can include evidence from Mr Roberts-Smith's former wife, Emma, one of her friends and a man who claims the former soldier attempted to intimidate a witness in an investigation into alleged war crimes.
The judge will also next week hear argument on which side presents its case first at trial.
Nicholas Owens, SC, for the publishers, said on Friday that it was agreed the news outlets would present their case first given they made the serious allegations, although Mr Roberts-Smith wanted to be the first witness.
Mr Owens said the "hybrid model" of Mr Roberts-Smith giving evidence during the media's case was unworkable.
But Bruce McClintock, SC, for Mr Roberts-Smith, said it was his client's "right" to be the first witness and rejected the suggestion the parties had agreed on a running order.
"The plaintiff [Mr Roberts-Smith] brings these proceedings. He wants to get into the witness box first and give his side of the story," Mr McClintock said.
"My client wants to get into the witness box and say what happened in Afghanistan and face cross-examination. It's something he actually looks forward to."
(continued)
#13424975 at 2021-04-14 18:48:48 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
>>13424966
2/2
The disciplinary action comes after Defence Force Chief Angus Campbell last month told a Senate estimates hearing he had been unaware of the existence of the Fat Lady's Arms at the coalition base in Afghanistan's Oruzgan province and any soldier found to have drunk there should face the sack.
The Australian has been made aware of the identity of several officers who allegedly frequented the makeshift pub while on deployment in Afghanistan and who have gone on to hold high-level positions within the army.
Defence confirmed it was investigating the lewd exploits carried out by special forces troops at the Fat Lady's Arms but would not detail how many members it had identified as having visited the bar nor what action had been taken against them.
"Defence acknowledges behavioural issues centering on the Fat Lady's Arms in Afghanistan. The Australian Army is inquiring into these issues," a spokeswoman said.
It comes just months after Justice Paul Brereton revealed the findings of his five-year investigation into alleged war crimes committed by Australian troops between 2005 and 2016.
The report, released in November, recommended 19 soldiers be investigated by police in connection with alleged murders of 39 prisoners and civilians and alleged cruel treatment of two others. It found "credible information" that 25 serving or former ADF personnel were involved in serious crimes or at least had been accessories to them.
It blamed a "warrior culture" within the SASR for creating an environment in which war crimes were allegedly committed and said the existence of the Fat Lady's Arms demonstrated how the regiment's ethical leadership had been compromised.
At least 10 Special Air Service Regiment soldiers have since been issued with termination notices, as Defence scrambles to respond to the damning report.
Justice Brereton did not find any credible information that special forces commanders had any knowledge of or were recklessly indifferent to crimes committed and concealed at patrol commander level, but he said senior officers ultimately bore "moral command responsibility and accountability for what happened under their command".
The photograph of the colonel and revelations that other officers frequented the Fat Lady's Arms have been seized on by furious SASR troops who believe they have been unfairly criticised in the Brereton report for the regiment's "broken" culture.
They said it was proof that senior officers were not only aware of some of the regimental practices condemned in Justice Brereton's findings but had also participated in them.
The images came to light after allegedly being found on USB drives at the home of decorated war hero, Ben Roberts-Smith, a former patrol commander with the SASR's 2 Squadron.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/defence/army-officer-facing-sack-over-debauched-party-in-afghan-bar/news-story/a2eb5c5a9bdfa2b0bafe1fa9e8f8abad
#13422740 at 2021-04-14 09:04:49 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
>>13407722
AFP confirms probe into Ben Roberts-Smith video allegations
Anthony Galloway and Nick McKenzie - April 14, 2021
1/2
The Australian Federal Police has confirmed it has launched a fresh investigation into Ben Roberts-Smith for allegedly burying sensitive Defence files in his backyard and is treating an accusation he attempted to intimidate a witness in an investigation into war crimes "as a priority".
Mr Roberts-Smith on Wednesday denied he hid the USB drives in his backyard or that he threatened witnesses to stop them from co-operating with the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force's inquiry into war crime allegations.
The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald revealed on Wednesday the alleged war criminal kept more than a dozen Department of Defence drone videos of Afghanistan military operations buried in his backyard, including videos watermarked as "secret" and only to be shared among certain NATO forces.
The files buried by Mr Roberts-Smith in a pink, child's lunch box included 13 videos of drone vision taken by NATO military forces in Afghanistan as well as copies of classified operational reports from a Special Air Service mission in Southern Afghanistan and contained images of soldiers misbehaving at a makeshift bar.
In a statement released on Wednesday afternoon, the former SAS Regiment soldier said the allegation he "hid" or failed to disclose material to the Inspector-General's inquiry was false, saying he fully co-operated with the probe. Mr Roberts-Smith, now a senior executive with Channel Seven, also denied threatening any witness or potential witness to the war crimes inquiry.
"The allegation that he buried USBs in his backyard is false. This simply did not happen," the statement said.
"Mr Roberts-Smith risked his life for his country, having served in Afghanistan over six years through scores of missions where his safety and that of other members of the SAS was in constant jeopardy.
"He does not seek any special treatment because of those facts, but only the same impartial reporting that is the right of any Australian whose acts may deserve public attention. Nine media's reporting is a parody of responsible journalism, exhibiting both bias and prejudgment."
In a separate email to employees at Channel Seven on Wednesday, Mr Roberts-Smith apologised for comments he made in leaked recordings in which he expressed disdain for colleagues and the business, saying he took "full responsibility" for the remarks where he described the company as dysfunctional.
(continued)
#13410361 at 2021-04-12 18:53:21 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
>>13407722
Shocking evidence of potential war crime exposed in major investigation
60 Minutes Australia
12 Apr 2021
It's not pleasant busting a long-held myth about a much-admired and highly-decorated veteran of the Afghanistan war. But Australia really needs to know the truth about VC recipient, Ben Roberts-Smith. For the last three years he's been under police investigation, accused of war crimes. The former soldier emphatically denies any wrongdoing, repeatedly saying he has nothing to hide about his time in Afghanistan. 60 MINUTES, the Sydney Morning Herald and the Age newspaper reveal startling new information that will shock the nation. It's about Roberts-Smith's efforts to conceal evidence and threaten SAS witnesses who dared to stand up to him.
And a warning: This joint investigation by 60 MINUTES, the Sydney Morning Herald and the Age newspaper, contains confronting material.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u76c7Eqxz28
#13408195 at 2021-04-12 09:15:54 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
>>13407722
Ben Roberts-Smith under fresh investigation over burner phones and sealed envelopes
Nick McKenzie, Chris Masters and Joel Tozer - April 12, 2021
The Australian Federal Police is launching fresh investigations into former special forces soldier Ben Roberts-Smith and has already seized evidence implicating the war hero in an alleged conspiracy to silence witnesses.
The new evidence includes letters Mr Roberts-Smith allegedly placed in sealed envelopes and planned to send anonymously to SAS soldiers he feared would testify against him at a war crimes inquiry.
The AFP has also uncovered the existence of at least five "burner" phones that the Victoria Cross recipient arranged to be purchased in 2018, according to records sighted by The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald. Authorities have identified multiple Optus and Telstra SIM cards purchased for use in burner phones belonging to Mr Roberts-Smith in 2018 and 2019.
Burner phones are disposable mobile phones subscribed in the name of a third party to obscure the true identity of the user from police phone taps and are typically used by people concerned they might be bugged by authorities. After use they are usually destroyed.
Lawyers for Mr Roberts-Smith were contacted on Monday for comment but did not respond.
A joint investigation by The Age, the Herald and 60 Minutes revealed allegations that Mr Roberts-Smith, an accused war criminal, dug a hole in the backyard of his Queensland house and buried USB drives inside a pink plastic children's lunchbox, hiding them from both police and military investigations. The USB drives contained images of bad behaviour by soldiers at a makeshift bar in Afghanistan, as well as classified documents and videos.
The AFP has seized the contents of the USBs and is investigating the Victoria Cross recipient's handling of the sensitive files.
The two sealed envelopes recently seized by detectives are in addition to a threatening letter previously seized by police and which was posted anonymously in June 2018 to an SAS witness to the military Inspector-General's war crimes inquiry. That letter warned the witness to stay quiet.
Police are investigating if Mr Roberts-Smith sent that anonymous letter and later sought to destroy the two other envelopes he also had planned to send. Multiple sources speaking on condition of anonymity said a third party, who was allegedly told by Mr Roberts-Smith to destroy the envelopes, kept them instead.
Police seized the envelopes last month, and earlier this month a police forensics team at the AFP Brisbane office was assigned to examine them. The AFP declined to comment, but multiple sources said inquiries were being "prioritised" by the federal agency.
The new investigation probing Mr Roberts-Smith for allegedly intimidating witnesses and concealing evidence is in addition to two AFP taskforces investigating Mr Roberts-Smith for allegedly executing and brutalising unarmed Afghan prisoners in 2009 and 2012.
The new revelations of sealed envelopes and burner phones come as Mr Roberts-Smith's employer, the Seven Network, is standing by him in his role as senior executive. Mr Roberts-Smith and Seven released a statement saying the former soldier denies new allegations that he attempted to thwart police and military investigations by burying USBs.
Seven is also backing the ex-soldier after he was caught on secretly recorded audio lauding his media mogul boss, Kerry Stokes, for financing his fight to "destroy" those in politics, the media and the SAS who have accused him of war crimes.
In separate secret recordings, which were lawfully made, Mr Roberts-Smith revealed his disdain for the business he helps run, his dislike of his fellow Seven executives and his incredulity that he is still running the company's Queensland operations despite being at the centre of a war crimes scandal.
Mr Stokes, who is also chairman of the Australian War Memorial, has provided significant financial support to the former special forces soldier to form an expensive legal and public relations team to combat the allegations investigated by the military Inspector-General and detailed in media reporting in The Age and Herald. Mr Roberts-Smith is running a defamation case against the mastheads.
In its statement, the Seven Network said it noted the denial by the Victoria Cross recipient of the allegations unearthed by 60 Minutes and this masthead.
"Insofar as most of the material aired is old, Seven notes that it is before the Federal Court and the court process should be respected," the company said. "Insofar as new allegations are made they do not appear to be supported by evidence."
https://www.theage.com.au/national/Ben-Roberts-Smith-under-fresh-investigation-over-burner-phones-and-sealed-envelopes-20210412-p57if9.html
#13407824 at 2021-04-12 07:15:42 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
>>13407722
Seven stands by senior executive Ben Roberts-Smith over new evidence he attempted to cover up alleged crimes
Anthony Galloway - April 12, 2021
1/2
The Seven Network is standing by its senior executive Ben Roberts-Smith, saying the former soldier denies new allegations that he attempted to cover up police and military investigations into alleged war crimes.
Mr Roberts-Smith has been caught on secretly recorded audio lauding his media mogul boss, Kerry Stokes, for financing his fight to "destroy" those in politics, the media and the SAS who have accused him of war crimes.
A joint investigation by The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and 60 Minutes has also revealed allegations that the accused war criminal dug a hole in the backyard of his house and buried USB drives inside a pink plastic children's lunchbox, hiding them from both police and military investigations. The USB drives contained images of soldiers misbehaving at a makeshift bar in Afghanistan, as well as classified documents and videos.
In separate secret recordings, which were lawfully made, Mr Roberts-Smith revealed his disdain for the business he helps run, his dislike of his fellow Seven executives and his incredulity that he is still running the company's Queensland operations despite being at the centre of a war crimes scandal.
Mr Stokes, who is also chairman of the Australian War Memorial, has provided significant financial support to the former special forces soldier to form an expensive legal and public relations team to combat the allegations investigated by the military Inspector-General and detailed in media reporting in The Age and Herald. Mr Roberts-Smith is running a defamation case against the mastheads.
In a statement, the Seven Network said it noted the denials of the Victoria Cross recipient.
"Insofar as most of the material aired is old, Seven notes that it is before the Federal Court and the court process should be respected," the company said.
"Insofar as new allegations are made they do not appear to be supported by evidence. In the circumstances Seven does not need to reconsider its position concerning Mr Roberts Smith and him continuing in his position."
The company said Mr Roberts-Smith held "grave concerns" as to whether the broadcast was an "attempt to intimidate him into not proceeding with his case" against the newspapers and reporter Nick McKenzie.
"The allegations aired this evening are baseless. These allegations are not supported by any evidence filed by Mr McKenzie and Nine in what has been an extensive pre-trial process," the company said.
"Mr Roberts-Smith denies that he has engaged in any unlawful conduct and he will not be intimidated by Mr McKenzie or Nine into not continuing with the Federal Court proceedings against them."
(continued)
#13407814 at 2021-04-12 07:13:25 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
>>13407722
'I'm going to do everything I can to f-cking destroy them': Secret Ben Roberts-Smith audio revealed
Nick McKenzie, Joel Tozer and Chris Masters - April 11, 2021
1/2
Accused war criminal Ben Roberts-Smith has been caught on secretly recorded audio lauding his media mogul boss, Kerry Stokes, for financing his fight to "destroy" those in politics, the media and the SAS who have accused him of war crimes.
In the recordings, which were lawfully made, Mr Roberts-Smith, a senior executive of the Stokes-chaired Seven West Media, reveals his disdain for the business he helps run, his dislike of his fellow Seven executives and his incredulity that he is still running the company's Queensland operations despite being at the centre of a war crimes scandal.
"It's bizarre. Other businesses would have just gone, 'Mate, it's not tenable'. I offered to resign at the start [of the war crimes scandal] and they said, 'Nah'," Mr Roberts-Smith says to an associate in one conversation.
The recordings capture multiple conversations between Mr Roberts-Smith and three other people. The conversations occurred at the time the inquiry of the military Inspector-General, Paul Brereton, was uncovering evidence from SAS whistleblowers that Mr Roberts-Smith was implicated in multiple unlawful executions while serving as an SAS soldier in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012. That evidence prompted the Australian Federal Police to launch two ongoing taskforces in June 2018 targeting Mr Roberts-Smith.
The tapes cast fresh light on the extraordinary relationship Mr Stokes has maintained with Mr Roberts-Smith, while revealing the embattled war hero's view that the billionaire is happy to run sections of his media empire at a loss in return for political power. Mr Roberts-Smith says the media is such "a powerful tool" that its owners say, "I'll take that [financial] loss if it means I have political influence … Politicians are scared of guys that own media networks."
Encrypted communications
Mr Roberts-Smith describes how the influence of Mr Stokes, who is also the chairman of the Australian War Memorial, has forced those who supported scrutiny of the accused war criminal to back down.
"They seemed to have smelled blood in the water and thought, 'Oh, Roberts-Smith is going down, we'll f-cking chime in.' I'm talking politicians and all kinds of people," he says.
But after it became known Mr Stokes supported him, these same critics "are like, 'Oh, thanks Kerry, glad you can help Ben out'. What the f-ck is that? You wanted me to go down, you piece of shit."
Mr Roberts-Smith also reveals how he talks to Mr Stokes on "encrypted" phone applications and "intelligence agencies cannot recover it".
"So if I am talking to KMS for example - Kerry - we only talk on Telegram and then delete the messages after … People use them so it can't be intercepted," he says.
There is no suggestion that Mr Stokes uses the applications to avoid interception by Australian authorities, but multiple sources told The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald that Mr Roberts-Smith has used such applications to avoid interception by the ongoing AFP inquiries.
'I'm indebted to Kerry'
In the recordings, Mr Roberts-Smith makes multiple references to Mr Stokes' support of his fight to contest war crimes allegations and those airing them.
"There's no f-ckng way I'd be able to keep paying what I'm paying for until Kerry got into it. That's why now they're shitting themselves because they realise he's prepared to run his bank down to do it," Mr Roberts-Smith is recorded saying.
"I probably won't leave the fold now … I think I'm indebted a little bit now to Kerry. Bottom line, I'd be f-cked without him … we've certainly had those conversations already."
(continued)
#13407783 at 2021-04-12 07:07:45 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
>>13407722
War hero Ben Roberts-Smith hits back at bombshell report
RHIANNON DOWN - APRIL 12, 2021
Ben Roberts-Smith has accused Nine Entertainment of attempting to intimidate him "into not proceeding" with a defamation suit against the company and its star investigative reporter Nick McKenzie.
Nine's 60 Minutes program on Sunday reported Mr Roberts-Smith, one of the country's most decorated veterans, buried in his backyard evidence of depraved conduct by Special Air Services Regiment soldiers instead of handing it over to war crimes investigators.
The images - first published by The Sydney Morning Herald - show one soldier at the Fat Ladies Arms, a makeshift on-base bar, dressed in a Ku Klux Klan outfit and others drinking alcohol from a prosthetic leg taken from a Taliban fighter killed by an Australian soldier in 2009.
Other images show senior SAS officers pretending to engage in sex acts with subordinates.
Mr Roberts-Smith said the allegations were "not supported by any evidence filed by Mr McKenzie and Nine in what has been an extensive pre-trial process".
"Mr McKenzie has chosen not to give evidence in support of the allegations he has made against Mr Roberts-Smith repeatedly over the past three years," he said in a statement.
"The allegations aired this evening are baseless.
"These allegations are not supported by any evidence filed by Mr McKenzie and Nine in what has been an extensive pre-trial process.
"These allegations were not put to Mr Roberts-Smith prior to being broadcast on 60 Minutes and published in the Nine newspapers.
"Mr Roberts-Smith denies that he has engaged in any unlawful conduct and he will not be intimidated by Mr McKenzie or Nine into not continuing with the Federal Court proceedings against them."
The images, 60 Minutes reported, were stored on USB drives buried in a garden.
Mr Roberts-Smith is engaged in a high-profile defamation action against Nine Entertainment after the company - then Fairfax Media - published a series of stories alleging the Victoria Cross recipient murdered an unarmed Afghan civilian by kicking him off a cliff.
Nine has argued that the allegations are substantially true.
Australian Special Forces soldiers are now accused of murdering 39 Afghan civilians and prisoners and of "blooding" new recruits by forcing them to shoot unarmed detainees.
That was the conclusion of a four-year investigation by NSW Supreme Court judge Paul Brereton that found "credible information" that up to 25 soldiers were involved in - and covered up - alleged war crimes.
In recordings published by 60 Minutes on Sunday, Mr Roberts-Smith appears to praise Seven West Media chairman Kerry Stokes for financing him and his fight to "destroy" his enemies.
"There's no f..king way I'd be able to keep paying what I'm paying for until Kerry got into it," Mr Roberts-Smith is heard saying in one recording. "That's why now they're shitting themselves because they realise he's prepared to run his bank down to do it.
"I probably won't leave the fold now ... I think I'm indebted a little bit now to Kerry. Bottom line, I'd be fed without him ... we've certainly had those conversations already."
Mr Roberts-Smith was hired by Mr Stokes to run his company's operation in Queensland.
The Australian Federal Police has told Mr Roberts-Smith it has "eyewitness accounts" implicating him in alleged war crimes in Afghanistan, Nine's lawyers have told the Federal Court.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/war-hero-buried-proof-of-lewd-conduct/news-story/2e862921224ae510477998d73bbf3cb4
#13407746 at 2021-04-12 06:58:49 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
>>13407740
4/4
'My sole f-cking mission'
Ben Roberts-Smith has long been at the centre of a storm. By June 2018, the federal police had launched two separate taskforces into allegations he was involved in the executions of Afghan prisoners in 2009 and 2012, and the Brereton Inquiry was also focused on his alleged role in multiple executions of unarmed Afghans, including prisoners. The media had begun exposing his alleged misdeeds and he has since launched defamation action against The Age, the Herald and 60 Minutes. The trial in that case is due to start soon.
But covert recordings of the war hero talking to various associates and now published for the first time, give a rare insight into his confidence. The Roberts-Smith heard on the recordings is bullish.
"All kinds of people have chimed in for their own Benefits. They seemed to have smelled blood in the water and thought, 'Oh, Roberts-Smith is going down, we'll f-cking chime in'. I'm talking politicians and all kinds of people," he says of those accusing him of wrongdoing.
But, with the backing of his employer, Seven West Media chairman and billionaire Kerry Stokes, he is full of confidence. He would, he said, go "all the way".
"There's no f-cking way I'd be able to keep paying … until Kerry got into it. That's why now they're shitting themselves because he's prepared to run his bank down to do it," Roberts-Smith says in one conversation.
"But, Seven's been good … Other businesses would have just gone, 'Mate, it's not tenable' ... I offered to resign at the start and they said, 'Nah'. But it's good it's played out the way it has behind closed doors because they now understand."
Secure in his confidence that he would retain Stokes' support and his high-paid career as Seven West Media's Queensland manager, Roberts-Smith is recorded gloating about those, including politicians, journalists and other former soldiers, that he will bring down.
"I'm going to do everything I can to f-cking destroy them mate ... That's my sole f-cking mission in life."
The police, though, have never downed tools. In around April 2020, the AFP sent two briefs of evidence to Commonwealth prosecutors. The briefs outline the police case that Roberts-Smith is implicated in the execution of Afghan prisoners, including one who was kicked off a small cliff in 2012.
A number of sources have also confirmed that it was some time in 2020 that federal agents covertly obtained the contents of the USBs that Roberts-Smith had buried in his backyard.
Police detectives have also gathered evidence that has allowed them to trace back to Roberts-Smith the threatening letter and the emails that prompted a police raid on a Brereton Inquiry witness.
Now this alleged conduct is out in the open, Roberts-Smith may be counting more than ever on support from one of Australia's most powerful media moguls. In the recordings of the former soldier speaking to his associates, Roberts-Smith describes how he is "indebted to Kerry".
"I probably won't leave the fold now," he says of Stokes' business empire.
"Bottom line, I'd be f-cked without him ... we've certainly had those conversations already."
Open Arms - Veterans and Families Counselling provides support for current and ex-serving ADF personnel and their families. Free and confidential help is available 24/7. Phone 1800 011 046 (international: +61 1800 011 046 or +61 8 8241 4546) or visit www.OpenArms.gov.au
https://www.openarms.gov.au
https://www.smh.com.au/national/buried-evidence-and-threats-how-Ben-Roberts-Smith-tried-to-cover-up-his-alleged-crimes-20210408-p57hlr.html
#13407740 at 2021-04-12 06:56:52 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
>>13407731
3/4
Intimidating witnesses
In June 2018, two years after the Brereton Inquiry was launched and as it was beginning to call in witnesses to testify about Ben Roberts-Smith, an SAS soldier who served with the Victoria Cross winner received a threat in the mail. It warned the soldier that if he did not recant war crimes allegations he would be targeted and would "go down".
The soldier reported to the federal police the attempt to intimidate him into silence. Police seized the letter and tested it for DNA. The then chief of the defence force, Air Chief Marshal Mark Binskin, publicly criticised whoever was behind the missive.
"I think it is disgusting that a disaffected person thought they could threaten a witness and look to influence the inquiry," Binskin said on June 15.
Former NSW Supreme Court judge Anthony Whealy said the offence of intimidating a witness, if proven in a court, could carry a jail term of up to five years. He described the sending of the letter as "the sort of thing we'd see in The Godfather or mafia-type movies".
"If it does happen, then it's demonstrative of the worst kind of affront to the judicial system. Intimidating witnesses is a horrifying thing to happen in our community."
The police forensics team could not identify the letter's sender and the AFP investigation quickly stalled. But multiple sources, each with knowledge of different aspects of the threatening letter, now say Roberts-Smith organised it. He had bought the paper and stamps, printed the letter at a Seven Network office in regional Queensland and then arranged for a former contractor to send it from a postbox in Tweed Heads in northern NSW.
There is no suggestion Stokes or any other person at Seven West Media knew anything about Roberts-Smith's alleged efforts to intimidate witnesses or conceal evidence.
Warnings of a massacre
Months earlier, as another SAS soldier prepared to deliver adverse information about Ben Roberts-Smith to the inquiry, three anonymous emails were sent: one to the federal police, one to independent politician Nick Xenophon and the third to the The Australian newspaper's editor and the paper's former WA-based reporter Andrew Burrell.
The emails variously claimed the soldier was at grave risk of committing a violent act in public, including gunning down civilians in Perth. One of the emails referenced the Las Vegas massacre that was carried out by a lone gunman in October 2017 and claimed 60 lives. Spurred into action, authorities arrived at the witness's family home in Perth with a search warrant and raided the SAS soldier's family home.
Senior barrister Greg Barns SC, who has spoken to the SAS soldier's lawyers in Perth and analysed the anonymous emails, described the raid as a "terribly traumatic event" for a family otherwise "living an ordinary Australian life".
Police found nothing to suggest the soldier was planning a mass shooting, but The Australian seized on allegations in the email and produced a front-page story that alleged the raided soldier had "smuggled automatic weapons from Perth to Afghanistan". Barns says the emails were designed to force police to act.
"One would assume that the reference [to the Las Vegas massacre] was there to indicate that this person would go out and shoot up a huge number of people … You can't think in our society of a more chilling and serious allegation," Barns said. It put the soldier, "in a position where they're inevitably going to be subjected to a raid from police".
The Age, the Herald and 60 Minutes has confirmed the emails were sent by a former contractor to Ben Roberts-Smith. A number of sources, who cannot be named because they have requested anonymity and in some cases fear retribution, say the contractor was acting on Roberts-Smith's instructions.
Barns says concocting a false police complaint may amount to a criminal offence if proven in court. And he says the ostensibly anonymous emails appear to have an ultimate aim: to silence the SAS witness before the Brereton Inquiry.
"The point is to make sure that that whistleblower is of no further impact."
The SAS witness, who retained his job in the regiment, later complained to authorities that the raid was designed to intimidate him into silence before the Brereton Inquiry.
(continued)
#13407731 at 2021-04-12 06:55:36 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
>>13407722
2/4
Brereton's landmark investigation report into alleged war crimes in Afghanistan last year posed the greatest challenge to the Australian military in decades after he found serious allegations of up to 39 murders committed by special forces. Roberts-Smith has repeatedly denied committing war crimes or any other wrongdoing and is suing The Age and Herald for defamation. He has insisted he has cooperated fully with the Brereton Inquiry and the federal police.
But further evidence obtained by The Age, the Herald and 60 Minutes shows the former soldier - who is now an executive at Seven West Media's Queensland operations - intimidated witnesses in an attempt to stop them giving evidence in inquiries.
Meanwhile leaked recordings of the decorated soldier speaking frankly to a number of associates suggest he is confident that he can see off those seeking to hold him accountable. As long as his employer and Benefactor, Seven chairman Kerry Stokes, keeps funding his cause, he says, he will not only win, he will "f-cking destroy" his enemies.
A trophy of war
On September 20, 2012, Ben Roberts-Smith's patrol choppered towards the village of Tizak in Southern Afghanistan. A battle was looming at a scrubby, stony stretch of land that the 203-centimetre soldier knew well.
It was at Tizak in 2010, two years earlier, that Roberts-Smith had earned his VC by displaying an "extreme devotion to duty" paired with "a total disregard for his own safety" as he "stormed the enemy position", according to the official citation.
Two years later, Afghans would also die in Tizak. But unlike the famed battle of 2010, this fight would not involve stories of heroism. Instead, SAS members who spoke on the condition of confidentiality say the Brereton Inquiry questioned soldiers about whether some of the Afghan people left dead by Roberts-Smith's small patrol team had been illegally executed while unarmed.
The Brereton Inquiry's findings about this Tizak mission were released in November 2020 but were heavily redacted. Multiple sources, including SAS soldiers, said several deaths during this operation had been the subject of investigation. Some of the same sources said the inquiry never obtained one photo from that day. It was lying under dirt and a rock in Roberts-Smith's backyard.
The image shows an Afghan man killed by the patrol team led by Roberts-Smith. The man is lying on his back on a woven mat. He has a trimmed dark black beard and looks to be in his 30s. His left arm appears badly injured, a bullet wound appears on his head and his face is smeared with fresh blood. No weapon is pictured.
On each of his eyes is a souvenir military coin. One bears the winged dagger emblem of the SAS, the second shows a picture of bushranger Ned Kelly posing with two six-shooters - the emblem of Roberts-Smith's SAS 2 squadron. The coins were intended to be given to Afghan military allies after joint operations.
Former Chief of the Defence Force and Vietnam veteran, Chris Barrie, says the placement of the coins on a deceased man's eyes amounts to "barbaric trophy hunting". The practice may also be illegal under international law - the Geneva Conventions prohibit the disrespecting of corpses on the battlefield. Barrie said the image trampled over basic military standards.
Though it is not known who is responsible for the death of this Afghan man, or who placed the coins on his eyes, the picture invites questions for potential investigators from the Brereton Inquiry or the federal police. The boots of two different SAS soldiers can be seen in the shot. These are people who might hold critical information.
(continued)
#13407722 at 2021-04-12 06:53:05 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
Buried evidence and threats: How Ben Roberts-Smith tried to cover up his alleged crimes
Australia's most decorated soldier sought to hide shameful images and evidence of war crimes. Now they have been unearthed.
Nick McKenzie, Chris Masters and Joel Tozer - APRIL 11, 2021'
1/4
It's September 2012 inside a coalition military base in Tarin Kowt in southern Afghanistan and an Australian soldier wearing the white gown and pointed hood of the Ku Klux Klan poses for the camera.
His face obscured by the hood, the soldier holds up a noose like those used by the white supremacist group to lynch African-Americans. In another picture, the man stands with a burning cross, staring at the camera as his colleagues cheer around him.
The images, taken at a fancy-dress party in an unauthorised military bar called the Fat Ladies Arms, capture soldiers from the elite Perth-based Special Air Services Regiment a decade into Australia's longest war. They were fighting an insurgency and trying to win hearts and minds in a Muslim country whose inhabitants had already made multiple complaints that some of their number - including that certain friends of the soldier dressed in KKK gear had executed their fathers, brothers and husbands.
A series of images from parties at the makeshift bar hint at one of those suspected killings.
They show soldiers drinking beer from the prosthetic leg of a Taliban fighter killed by an Australian soldier in 2009. Most of the soldiers would have known little about the history of the leg, which they called "Das Boot". But at least one man knew it represented something more sinister, because he had allegedly murdered its former owner outside the laws of combat on Easter Sunday, 2009.
That soldier was allegedly Corporal Ben Roberts-Smith, Australia's most decorated Afghan war veteran and, until recently, a man lauded by politicians as the embodiment of Australia's ideal fighter. Roberts-Smith is pictured, smiling and pumping his fist, in the background as the soldier in the KKK outfit - one of his mates - burns the cross. He is also happily pictured with people drinking from the leg - despite comments to the Federal Court from his lawyer, Bruce McClintock, in 2019 that his client "thought it was disgusting to souvenir a body part".
The images published here, and hundreds more, were in the possession of Roberts-Smith. Among them is one that shows what former defence force chief Chris Barrie has told The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and 60 Minutes is credible evidence of the war crime of desecrating a corpse.
They are clear illustrations of what, when he came to investigate Australian military war crimes in Afghanistan, military Inspector-General Paul Brereton described as a culture in which "ethical leadership was compromised by [the] toleration, acceptance and participation in a widespread disregard for behavioural norms". Justice Brereton singled out alcohol consumption at the Fat Ladies Arms as one part of that failure of discipline.
One of the photographs shows a senior commissioned Special Air Services Regiment commanding officer simulating a sex act with a high-ranking soldier using an object taken from a model camel.
The images were stored on a series of USB drives that also contained classified documents and videos. But despite Brereton's order at the start of his probe in 2016 that soldiers hand over all images and files, Roberts-Smith did not do so, according to sources with knowledge of the cache but who have asked to remain anonymous.
Instead, the sources say, Roberts-Smith dug a hole in the backyard of his house in the Sunshine Coast hinterland and buried the USB drives inside a pink plastic children's lunchbox to hide them from both police and military investigations.
Once the Victoria Cross recipient had filled in the hole, he placed a rock on top to mark the spot.
According to multiple sources familiar with the matter, federal police who are conducting war crimes investigations into the war hero, have since obtained the contents of the USBs.
(continued)
#13342017 at 2021-04-01 08:59:01 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
Ben Roberts-Smith: Afghan civilians to testify via video link in former soldier's defamation case
Fairfax Media's case bolstered after court agrees witnesses would have little hope of travelling to Australia to give evidence
Christopher Knaus - 1 Apr 2021
Afghan civilian witnesses will be allowed to give evidence via remote link in the Ben Roberts-Smith war crimes defamation proceedings against the Age and Sydney Morning Herald, a judge has ruled.
The ruling is a win for the old Fairfax newspapers, allowing them to rely on alleged eye-witnesses as they fight allegations they defamed Roberts-Smith, a Victoria Cross winner and special forces veteran, by suggesting he committed war crimes.
The newspapers published a series of reports about Roberts-Smith's actions between 2009 and 2012, including an allegation he kicked an Afghan civilian named Ali Jan off a cliff while he was bound. Jan was later shot.
Roberts-Smith has vehemently denied the allegations and is suing in the federal court.
The newspapers have been attempting to bolster their defence by introducing new evidence about Roberts-Smith's alleged actions during deployment.
That has included evidence from five witnesses, including four Afghan civilians, who are unable to travel to Australia to appear in the federal court. The civilians include relatives of Ali Jan and witnesses to the alleged crime, the court heard.
One of the witnesses, known as person 62, was captured by Australian forces alongside Ali Jan. Person 62 says he was watching through a doorway when he saw a "big soldier" kick Ali Jan down a hill.
"Person 62 then moved from the door way to the outside," the court said. "He then saw Ali Jan being taken from the dry creek bed below the slope/hill to the cornfield, 'which was approximately 30 metres away' by two soldiers."
"Person 62 states that Ali Jan was then shot multiple times. After the soldiers had left in the helicopters, Person 62 saw Ali Jan's body in the cornfields. He saw that he had been shot in the face, body and his arm."
The court heard the witnesses had low prospects of travelling to Australia to give evidence, including because they would be unlikely to obtain visas.
Roberts-Smith's lawyers opposed them giving evidence via video link from Afghanistan, saying it was "simply unworkable". The witnesses would need to be shown photographs, maps and other representations of the landscape, structures and the persons involved, they argued. The secrecy restrictions governing the trial forbid the sharing of such sensitive documents via video-link, they said.
The evidence was also at odds with the testimony of other witnesses, his lawyers argued, meaning it needed to be led with precision on distance, proximity and location. That was said to be not possible via video-link and would be further complicated by the use of interpreters.
But in a decision on Thursday, Justice Anthony Besanko ruled it was permissible for the witnesses to give evidence from Afghanistan.
He said the evidence of the witnesses, if accepted as identifying Roberts-Smith, was "evidence of very serious misconduct" and was an "important aspect of the respondents' case".
Besanko said there was some risk of disadvantage to Roberts-Smith by the use of the video link. But he said two principles favoured allowing the witnesses to give evidence remotely.
"First, the application is based on the assumption that if the Afghan witnesses are not permitted to give evidence by [audio-visual link], then they will not give evidence in the proceedings," he said. "The respondents have said that they will continue their efforts to bring the Afghan witnesses to Australia for the trial, but the assumption underlying the application is that that will not be possible and, absent an order that permits them to give evidence by AVL, they will not give evidence at the trial."
"Secondly, I am satisfied that the respondents have made all reasonable efforts to bring the Afghan witnesses to Australia. Those efforts are likely to be unsuccessful."
Nick McKenzie, the award-winning investigative reporter who authored the stories, described the decision as landmark and said it would be the first time Afghans would testify in an Australian case about an alleged war crime.
"The world will be watching," he tweeted.
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2021/apr/01/Ben-Roberts-Smith-afghan-civilians-to-testify-via-video-link-in-former-soldiers-defamation-case
https://twitter.com/Ageinvestigates/status/1377469432918761472
#13341730 at 2021-04-01 06:50:56 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #15 - NEVER RETREAT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD Edition
#14 - Part 4
Dassi Erlich Tweets / Malka Leifer Extradition and Prosecution
>>13190070 Fears alleged sex offender principal Malka Leifer could dodge justice - years of publicity may preclude a fair trial by an unbiased jury
#14 - Part 5
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry
>>13168726 Brigadier Ian Langford, commander during period when Australian troops allegedly committed war crimes, prevented from handing back distinguished leadership medal
>>13241878 'Very serious criminal conduct': Ben Roberts-Smith faces allegations of two more crimes on top of alleged involvement in six unlawful killings
#14 - Part 6
Cardinal George Pell and Vatican Financial Scandal Allegations
>>13165358 Video: Cardinal George Pell is a keynote speaker at the Australian #ChurchAndState Summit in 2021 - Church And State
>>13273728 Vatican money transfers no crime: Australian Federal Police
#14 - Part 7
Australian and Regional Resignations
>>13190628 'Personal cost': Deloitte Australia CEO Richard Deutsch in shock early resignation
>>13248113 Hockeyroos coach Paul Gaudoin in shock resignation amid 'distressing' allegations of bullying, body-shaming and homophobic behaviour
>>13335678 Nationals MP Michael Johnsen resigns from NSW parliament following rape allegation he denies
#14 - Part 8
2020 US Presidential Election - Australian Perspectives
>>13165228 YouTube chief Susan Wojcicki: Donald Trump can return when risk of violence abates
>>13165440 Pentagon considers extending the stay of National Guard troops at Capitol for "the next couple of months"
>>13328396 THE OFFICE OF DONALD J. TRUMP - 45th President of the United States - 45office.com - White House Rose Garden with Australian Flag
#13341672 at 2021-04-01 06:35:12 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #14 - THE ART OF WAR Edition
#14 - Part 4
Dassi Erlich Tweets / Malka Leifer Extradition and Prosecution
>>13190070 Fears alleged sex offender principal Malka Leifer could dodge justice - years of publicity may preclude a fair trial by an unbiased jury
#14 - Part 5
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry
>>13168726 Brigadier Ian Langford, commander during period when Australian troops allegedly committed war crimes, prevented from handing back distinguished leadership medal
>>13241878 'Very serious criminal conduct': Ben Roberts-Smith faces allegations of two more crimes on top of alleged involvement in six unlawful killings
#14 - Part 6
Cardinal George Pell and Vatican Financial Scandal Allegations
>>13165358 Video: Cardinal George Pell is a keynote speaker at the Australian #ChurchAndState Summit in 2021 - Church And State
>>13273728 Vatican money transfers no crime: Australian Federal Police
#14 - Part 7
Australian and Regional Resignations
>>13190628 'Personal cost': Deloitte Australia CEO Richard Deutsch in shock early resignation
>>13248113 Hockeyroos coach Paul Gaudoin in shock resignation amid 'distressing' allegations of bullying, body-shaming and homophobic behaviour
>>13335678 Nationals MP Michael Johnsen resigns from NSW parliament following rape allegation he denies
#14 - Part 8
2020 US Presidential Election - Australian Perspectives
>>13165228 YouTube chief Susan Wojcicki: Donald Trump can return when risk of violence abates
>>13165440 Pentagon considers extending the stay of National Guard troops at Capitol for "the next couple of months"
>>13328396 THE OFFICE OF DONALD J. TRUMP - 45th President of the United States - 45office.com - White House Rose Garden with Australian Flag
#13241878 at 2021-03-17 08:51:25 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #14 - THE ART OF WAR Edition
'Very serious criminal conduct': Ben Roberts-Smith faces allegations of two more crimes
Adam Cooper - March 17, 2021
1/2
The news outlets being sued for defamation by Ben Roberts-Smith argue they have evidence of two more incidents of "very serious criminal conduct" on top of his alleged involvement in six unlawful killings as an Australian soldier in Afghanistan.
And Mr Roberts-Smith's former wife is to give evidence for the media and against her ex-husband at this year's trial, the Federal Court heard on Wednesday.
Mr Roberts-Smith, a highly decorated former Australian soldier, is suing The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald over reports he allegedly committed murder on deployments to Afghanistan and that he also punched his mistress in the face in Canberra in 2018.
The Victoria Cross recipient denies the allegations and says the reports are defamatory.
The media will defend the claim using a truth defence at a trial in June.
Lawyers for the news outlets have applied to amend their defence and strengthen it with evidence of more allegations of crimes against Mr Roberts-Smith.
Nicholas Owens, SC, acting for the media, told the court on Wednesday the news outlets wanted to amend their defence to include "two new allegations of very serious criminal conduct against Mr Roberts-Smith".
Mr Owens did not outline the specific details of the additional allegations, due to restrictions about what national security information can be said in open court, but The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald have already included as part of their case that Mr Roberts-Smith was involved in six unlawful deaths in Afghanistan.
They include allegations Mr Roberts-Smith kicked handcuffed farmer Ali Jan off a cliff in Darwan in 2012, and that the soldier then agreed with a colleague, referred to as Person 11, that Mr Jan would be shot dead.
The Australian Federal Police is investigating Mr Jan's death and, the court has heard, considers Mr Roberts-Smith a suspect. No charges have been laid.
The news outlets also allege Mr Roberts-Smith ordered a junior colleague, Person 66, to shoot and kill a detained man in Syachow in 2012. After Person 66 did so, the outlets allege, Mr Roberts-Smith said his colleague had been "blooded" because he had never killed before.
The outlets' application to amend their defence will be heard in Sydney on April 7, when lawyers appear before Justice Anthony Besanko in person.
(continued)
#13168726 at 2021-03-08 01:01:46 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #14 - THE ART OF WAR Edition
Officer Brigadier Ian Langford to keep Afghan medal
Ben PACKHAM - MARCH 6, 2021
1/2
Defence has prevented one of its senior officers from handing back a distinguished leadership medal earned as a commander in Afghanistan during a period when Australian troops allegedly committed up to 16 war crimes.
Brigadier Ian Langford told superiors soon after the Brereton war crimes report was released that he wanted to hand back his Distinguished Service Cross, but was stopped from doing so because there was no formal process to deal with the request.
More than three months later, Defence's response to the inquiry has stalled, shielding senior leaders - even those who want to speak out - from accountability for alleged war crimes on their watch.
An analysis by The Weekend Australian reveals 83 per cent of the war crimes allegations identified as "credible" by judge Paul Brereton occurred under the command of two senior officers - Brigadier Langford and Lieutenant Colonel Jon "Irish" Hawkins.
Brigadier Langford, one of the army's most decorated senior officers and a potential future chief of army, was task group commander in Afghanistan from July 2012 to February 2013.
That rotation, which included the Special Air Service's now-disbanded 2 Squadron and Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith, was marred by 16 credible allegations of war crimes - the highest of any of Australia's 20 troop rotations in the Afghanistan war. There were nine credible allegations of war crimes during the January-July 2012 rotation, commanded by the now-retired Lieutenant Colonel Hawkins. Both men are highly respected in Defence circles and received the nation's top medal for military leadership, the Distinguished Service Cross, for their 2012 commands.
Multiple sources close to Brigadier Langford said he was "deeply shocked" as he watched the Chief of the Defence Force Angus Campbell's press conference releasing the Brereton report, which found 39 Afghan civilians and prisoners were allegedly murdered by up to 25 Australian soldiers.
He has told friends he was unaware of the alleged crimes by those under his command, and he approached Defence leaders about a week later saying he wanted to return the DSC.
He was told "a mechanism did not exist for him to do that", and he would have to wait until one was put in place. The direction followed General Campbell's order, which was later overturned by Scott Morrison, for meritorious unit citations to be stripped from about 2000 soldiers.
Brigadier Langford declined to comment when approached by The Weekend Australian.
Defence told The Weekend Australian it was aware of two ADF personnel "who have indicated their intention to voluntarily return their awards".
But a process is yet to be established for awards to be handed back, or stripped against the recipient's will.
Lieutenant Colonel Hawkins now runs a specialist security company, Omni Executive Pty Ltd, which won nearly $80m in Defence contracts in just five years, including more than $8m in work that didn't go to competitive tender. The company is a major employer of special forces veterans, and conducts highly classified work for Special Operations Command and intelligence agencies including the Australian Signals Directorate.
Lieutenant Colonel Hawkins told The Weekend Australian: "I did not witness any wrongdoings by those in my command.
"Where complaints or allegations were raised directly with me, they were acted on and investigated in line with established protocol, as the Brereton inquiry report identified."
(continued)
#13043459 at 2021-02-25 05:39:35 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #13 - THE WAR IS REAL Edition
>>13043453
2/2
Justice Brereton also urged General Campbell and General Burr to consider special treatment for those "whose conduct is such that they cannot be rewarded by promotion, but who, having made disclosures to the Inquiry in protected circumstances when they reasonably believed they would not be used against them, and whose evidence was ultimately of considerable assistance to the Inquiry, ought not fairly be the subject of adverse administrative action".
"Again, it will be an important signal that they have not been disadvantaged for having ultimately assisted to uncover misconduct, even though implicating themselves."
When he announced Justice Brereton's findings in November, General Campbell described being "deeply appreciative of people who came forward to speak with concern of what they had seen, in some cases of what they had participated in".
"It was a very brave thing for them to do, because in the climate and the culture I have described, they would have been very concerned for doing so," he said in comments which suggested General Campbell was aware that key whistleblowers had also disclosed their own wrongdoing.
But since then, senior officers working under General Burr's ultimate command have, in at least three cases, disregarded the advice from the Inspector-General and issued termination notices that inform a soldier they will be sacked unless they provide mitigating circumstances.
The question of how to deal with special forces veterans who have admitted to egregious acts is not simple. Even considering their assistance to the inquiry, their alleged conduct may be so serious that it warrants dismissal. However, that is the same workplace penalty suffered by SAS and commando soldiers who have been found to have repeatedly lied about their own role in war crimes only to have it disclosed by others.
The tension comes amid confusion about how the federal police and Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions will work with the new Office of the Special Investigator, which was announced by Prime Minister Scott Morrison in November to help prosecute those accused of war crimes. The Office of the Special Investigator (OSI), led by former Victorian judge Mark Weinberg, is analysing what information from the Brereton inquiry can be used in criminal prosecutions and what must be withheld because it was obtained under a special power that gives immunity to those who confess to wrongdoing.
However, the OSI is at risk of replicating steps already taken by the Australian Federal Police, which was referred war crimes allegations by Justice Brereton in 2018. Federal police agents have spent almost three years investigating former special forces soldier and Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith, who is accused of multiple war crimes, and are also investigating serious allegations against another soldier known as "Soldier C".
Shifting these investigations to a newly created bureaucracy is potentially fraught if it causes delays, as witnesses' memories fade or suspects find opportunities to collude. It may also leave some already traumatised witnesses dealing with new investigators with whom they have no prior relationship or who have no corporate investigation knowledge.
Former SAS soldiers said federal police agents had taken statements and built rapport with key witnesses in 2018 and 2019. Official sources in Canberra said it was unclear how many federal agents would be seconded to the new office, although it would involve at least some of the AFP taskforces set up in 2018 to probe war crimes.
https://www.theage.com.au/national/fight-erupts-over-defence-moves-to-sack-special-forces-whistleblowers-20210223-p5752d.html
#12772898 at 2021-01-31 01:34:59 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #13 - THE WAR IS REAL Edition
#12 - Part 7
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry
>>12113707 Ben Roberts-Smith pictured cheering soldiers drinking from the prosthetic leg of a man he shot
>>12249390 Australia's war crimes commanders to soon learn their fate
>>12272708 Soldier drinking from dead Taliban fighter's prosthetic leg exposed as highly-respected senior officer, featured in recent article on 'good soldiering'
>>12704226 Special Forces soldiers issued "show cause" notice in the wake of war crime allegations will submit defence on why they shouldn't be sacked from the military
>>12759698 Afghan henchman 'used ADF troops', says Dutch journalist Bette Dam
>>12759711 How flawed information created a 'Taliban' threat - Bette Dam - theaustralian.com.au
#12 - Part 8
Dassi Erlich Tweets and Malka Leifer Extradition
>>12173622 Malka Leifer is due to be extradited from Israel to Australia, but how do you do do that during the COVID-19 pandemic?
>>12705499 Accused sex predator principal Malka Leifer extradited to Australia
>>12705544 Israel extradites Malka Lefier, wanted for sex crimes, to Australia
>>12705574 Malka Leifer extradited to Australia to face child sexual abuse charges
>>12705589 Dassi Erlich Tweet: Leifer is on the way back to Australia. #leiferonthewayback
>>12727992 Former Victorian attorney-general Martin Pakula says he is "very pleased" Malka Leifer will soon face an Australian court
>>12728054 Video: Former Adass Israel School board president 'can't recall helping Malka Leifer flee'
>>12739668 Dassi Erlich Tweet: Leifer has arrived in Melbourne.
>>12739687 Video: Malka Leifer lands in Melbourne after extradition from Israel, ahead of court appearance today
>>12739702 Ex-principal Malka Leifer faces court charged with sexually abusing students
>>12739732 Adass Israel School defends response to Leifer fallout
>>12759610 We won't bail out sex case principal Malka Leifer: Adass community
>>12760280 'She took them into her home': Leifer chaplain knew alleged victims
#12076391 at 2020-12-18 07:44:02 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #11 - THE SILENT WAR CONTINUES Edition
#11 - Part 6
Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry - Part 1
>>11495844 General Angus Campbell Tweet: Today I have received the Afghanistan Inquiry report from the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force
>>11495844 General Angus Campbell Tweet: I strongly encourage current and former serving ADF members…affected by the IGADF Afghanistan Inquiry to access welfare support
>>11495844 Statement - Angus J. Campbell, AO, DSC - I intend to speak about the key findings once I have read and reflected on the report
>>11495844 Afghanistan Inquiry - Department of Defence and Department of Veterans' Affairs - Welfare Support - Please ask for help if you need it
>>11571508 Afghanistan war crimes inquiry - Department of Defence 'to strip offenders of medals'
>>11593710 Court orders war hero Ben Roberts-Smith to hand over documents to lawyers acting for the media companies he is suing for defamation
>>11604576 Chief investigator appointed to probe alleged war crimes by Australian special forces soldiers in Afghanistan
>>11606201 Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith confirms his conduct in Australia's special forces is being investigated in Afghanistan Inquiry report
>>11610740 Ten SAS soldiers under investigation by war crimes investigators over summary execution of at least 12 Afghan non-combatants or prisoners
>>11665665 Video: Killings of Afghans 'happened all the time' - Dr Samantha Crompvoets, author of 2016 report commissioned by military chief Angus Campbell
>>11665944 How sociologist Samantha Crompvoets' review of the 2014 Lindt cafe siege exposed army atrocities
>>11688552 OPINION - 'They are not one of us': SAS soldiers condemn war crime perpetrators - By SAS Soldiers -smh.com.au
>>11688717 Conflict of interest questions on Defence war crime troika - Major General Adam Findlay, Lieutenant General Rick Burr and General Angus Campbell
>>11689784 The inquiry into Australian soldiers in Afghanistan is finally over. The reckoning is about to begin
>>11694954 Australia to await final decision from Trump on Afghan troop withdrawal
>>11702658 PDF: Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry Report (Public Release Version)
>>11702706, >>11702759 Video: Chief of the Defence Force, General Angus Campbell, announces the findings of the Afghanistan Inquiry report
>>11702983 President of Afghanistan Ashraf Ghani Tweet: Prime Minister of Australia expressed his deepest sorrow over the misconduct by some Australian troops in Afghanistan
>>11703205 Brereton war crimes report: Defence urges probe into 19 soldiers over 39 alleged murders
>>11703243 Special Air Service second squadron (2 Squadron) disbanded over Afghan claims
>>11703264 Ben Roberts-Smith puts Victoria Cross up as collateral for $1m legal fees loan from billionaire businessman Kerry Stokes
>>11705983 Whistleblowers relieved as war crimes report prompts calls for justice
>>11706088 Afghan war crimes inquiry: 2 Squadron dishonoured by its abolition
#11761020 at 2020-11-24 04:07:52 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #11 - THE SILENT WAR CONTINUES Edition
>>11702658
>>11760984
SAS must put honour before glory
'Shamed' by the Brereton report, soldier turned federal MP Andrew Hastie says 'we ignored the true nature of war and sanitised it'.
ANDREW HASTIE - November 23, 2020
1/3
Red rocky earth cut into our flesh, numbing our hands. It was well after midnight, perhaps 3am. Floodlights lit up the group.
Cadence push-ups on bleeding knuckles in the dead of night is the sort of misery that either consumes you, or clarifies your sense of mission.
Corporal Ben Roberts-Smith, fresh back from the Battle of Tizak, towered over us, the 25 officer candidates on the 2010 Special Air Service Regiment selection course, his displeasure writ large in his menacing body language. He switched out our hand position from palms down to knuckles.
"You f..king officers. You always take the easy option. Lower. Hold!"
An eternity passed as our fatigued muscles trembled close to the ground.
"Raise!"
The irony might have been lost on him, but not on me. Humbling myself before Ben Roberts-Smith was not easy. Nor would be serving in the SASR in the weeks, months and years ahead. SASR selection is an exacting experience. For an officer, your command, leadership and character is closely scrutinised for 21 days. They break down your body to see who you really are and what you are like when you're tired, hungry and dejected.
Moments like this over the following fortnight thinned the ranks of officers. Men, gifted in command and planning, departed on their own terms, withdrawing quietly. Others were removed by the directing staff.
The rest of us pressed on, reaching a point of insanity in the final week. No food for days, almost no sleep, impossible physical tasks. What was the point of it all?
The last week posed this question for those candidates remaining: when there is nothing left to give, who can go beyond and finish the mission? For the first time I understood Clausewitz's dictum that war is a contest of wills.
Finish the job, or fail.
We finished selection on Friday August 13, 2010. When I called my wife to tell her, I wept. I was cold, shivering and spent. I'd lost 12kg in three weeks and I had no emotional reserves. That day, SASR Trooper Jason Brown died bravely - under fire - in Afghanistan serving with the Special Operations Task Group. It was a subdued mood back at Swanbourne. There were no high fives.
Starved, physically exhausted and emotionally shattered, we sat around a radio cleaning our rifles the next morning. We quietly listened to the voices of our prime minister Julia Gillard and leader of the opposition Tony Abbott express their condolences at the death of another digger in Australia's longest war.
That day set a course for me. I served in the SAS for the next five years, deploying to Afghanistan as a Troop Commander in 2013 as part of the Special Operations Task Group. I did not anticipate that 10 years later I would be a member of parliament, explaining how we found ourselves in a dark place.
Like all of us, I am grieved by the findings of the Brereton Report, handed down by the Chief of the Defence Force.
There is much to be troubled by: the report details credible information regarding allegations of unlawful killings by Australian soldiers. Specifically, 23 incidents of alleged unlawful killings of 39 people, perpetrated by 25 Australian special forces soldiers - mainly from the Special Air Service Regiment.
The report is hard reading. It is comprehensive, detailed and unsparing in its judgment on those alleged to have committed war crimes. As a former officer of the SASR and someone who believes in regimental honour, I feel great shame in what has occurred.
We were sent to Afghanistan in a double trust: to defend Australia's values and interests by force, but also to uphold those values in our battlefield conduct. Many good soldiers honoured that trust; a small number of soldiers did not.
Many people want to know: how did this happen? Here are some personal observations on the Brereton inquiry that are shaped by five years of service in SASR and five years as a member of the federal parliament.
(continued)
#11747028 at 2020-11-23 05:03:24 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #11 - THE SILENT WAR CONTINUES Edition
>>11747021
2/2
Lieutenant-General Burr also dismissed criticism from decorated SAS Afghanistan-war veteran Ben Roberts-Smith - whom the Federal Court has heard is under federal police investigation for alleged war crimes - that the inquiry was little more than an amalgam of "rumours".
"The Inspector-General has made his findings very clear. He speaks to credible information across a range of issues," Lieutenant-General Burr said. "This report is so important. We asked for this inquiry, we've waited 4½ years for it. We welcome its findings."
Lieutenant-General Burr refused to comment on whether it was appropriate for media mogul Kerry Stokes to remain as chairman of the Australian War Memorial, after he vowed to use his money to fund the legal defences of the more than two dozen soldiers accused of war crimes and of lying about their own war history.
Lieutenant-General Burr said he had no plans to stand down as a director of the war memorial and that it was "for others" to comment on Mr Stokes' position, which he declined to endorse. But the army chief thanked the SAS whistleblowers, such as medic Dusty Miller, who spoke up about war crimes they encountered in Afghanistan despite risking blowback from accused colleagues.
"I thank Dusty, I thank all like Dusty who have come forward. It's taken tremendous courage to do that. I know there is a lot of hurt and a lot of pain that has been endured by many, for a long period of time," he said.
Lieutenant-General Burr also expressed his "very heartfelt, very sincere apology to the people of Afghanistan".
And he defended his decision to disband the SAS's 2nd Squadron, which hosted Mr Roberts-Smith before he left the SAS in 2015. Soldiers from the 2nd Squadron who never served in Afghanistan or who were whistleblowers are angered at the decision to scrap the squadron, given only a small number of its former members are accused of war crimes.
But Lieutenant-General Burr said the Brereton report "makes clear that there was a nexus of these [alleged war crimes] activities" to 2nd Squadron "at a particular point in time".
"We must all pay the price," he said.
General Campbell told the ABC's Insiders program that he supported the Brereton review's recommendation to mandate the wearing of bodycams for all personnel because it could improve both training and accountability.
"I think it is a very good idea. It creates a degree of objectivity and a capacity for learning, development and record keeping. That material would become a digital archive, permanently and securely held so that if claims were to arise, they would be, they would contribute to understanding what may have happened."
If you are a current or former ADF member, or a relative, and need counselling or support, contact the Defence All-Hours Support Line on 1800 628 036 or Open Arms on 1800 011 046.
https://www1.defence.gov.au/adf-members-families/health-well-being
https://www.openarms.gov.au/
https://www.theage.com.au/national/how-did-this-happen-chief-of-army-saw-nothing-of-alleged-atrocities-in-afghanistan-20201122-p56gu1.html
#11734641 at 2020-11-22 06:17:39 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #11 - THE SILENT WAR CONTINUES Edition
>>11734632
2/3
The war in Afghanistan was one that many Australians had lost track of. It had dragged on for 15 years after the September 11 attacks first led to a Western coalition invading the battle-weary nation. As the war's progress stagnated, the bravery of individual elite special forces soldiers on capture and kill missions informed the public narrative pushed by defence and successive governments. Much of it was true.
But while Brereton's inquiry would concentrate on the actions of a relatively small number of soldiers who allegedly went rogue - 25 soldiers are allegedly responsible for 39 murders - it would inevitably risk tainting Australia's entire Afghan contribution.
'Enormous challenges'
Justice Brereton has never spoken publicly about his work, but an annual report released by the Office of the Inspector-General in February gave the first glimpse of the judge's methodology. He appointed a small team of trusted military lawyers, led by experienced barrister Matt Vesper. More lawyers and investigators could have expedited the probe, but a larger, less cohesive taskforce would be at risk of skating over key lines of inquiry. Instead, Brereton's small team focused on building personal bonds of trust with SAS and Commando whistleblowers.
In his report released on Thursday, Brereton described "enormous challenges in eliciting truthful disclosures in the closed, closely-bonded, and highly compartmentalised Special Forces community, in which loyalty to one's mates, immediate superiors and the unit are regarded as paramount, in which secrecy is at a premium, and in which those who 'leak' are anathema."
"In such an environment, it is hardly surprising that it has taken time, opportunity, and encouragement for the truth to emerge, and that it has not necessarily done so at the first opportunity or interview, or fully. It is often not the first, or even the second, interview at which the story, either full or in-part, emerges; it takes time for trust to be established, and for the discloser's conscience to prevail over any impediments."
Most of Brereton's witnesses had served in Afghanistan and many were also mentally scarred by their service.
Brereton also appointed an officer dedicated to witness welfare, especially for whistleblowers facing mental health pressures.
One of the few public whistleblowers, SAS medic Dusty Miller, described in August how Brereton not only painstakingly recorded his testimony about the alleged execution of an injured and unarmed Afghan farmer, but later personally called Miller to check on his mental state.
A PR offensive
From the start the Brereton inquiry was clear about its aims. Its focus would not be on "fog of war" or "heat of the moment" incidents. but only egregious and cowardly executions of Afghans prisoners.
No potential evidence was seen as out of reach. Brereton's trip to Afghanistan in 2019, accompanied by federal police detectives, was aimed at corroborating the statements of what the federal police later described in a letter as SAS "eyewitnesses".
While Brereton investigated, he refused dozens of media interview requests. But where Brereton stayed silent, his critics did not. Those sceptical of his exhaustive inquiry approach, or the fact that alleged war crimes were being probed at all, suggested inaccurately that minor "heat of the battle" incidents were under scrutiny.
Meanwhile, reporting in The Age and the Herald was naming one of Australia's best-known Afghanistan veterans, Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith, as having participated in the execution of prisoners.
Former prime minister Tony Abbott urged Australians not to rush to judge soldiers who were "operating in the heat of combat under the fog of war". Former defence minister Brendan Nelson, a close friend of Roberts-Smith, made similar comments.
Roberts-Smith himself hired a team of lawyers and an expensive public relations firm, run by Sue Cato and employing ex-journalist Ross Coulthart, to counter the serious war crimes allegations he vehemently denies. Seven West Media chairman Kerry Stokes, a backer of Roberts-Smith who employed him as a senior manager in 2015, funded a defamation action against The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald, while Roberts-Smith's defamation lawyer, Mark O'Brien, made a formal but false complaint that the Brereton inquiry was biased and leaking information.
(continued)
#11706088 at 2020-11-19 17:51:31 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #11 - THE SILENT WAR CONTINUES Edition
>>11703243
>>11703264
Afghan war crimes inquiry: 2 Squadron dishonoured by its abolition
The Special Air Service's troubled 2 Squadron - in which Australia's most decorated soldier, Ben Roberts-Smith, served - will be disbanded after being singled out amid the damning findings of the Afghanistan war crimes inquiry.
The heavily redacted Brereton report does not detail offences by soldiers from the squadron, known as the Bushrangers, but at least two of its Afghanistan veterans are likely to face prosecution as alleged war criminals.
Chief of Army Rick Burr told SASR members in Perth on Thursday that 2 Squadron - one of four in the regiment - would be "struck off" the Australian Army's organisational structure in a symbolic dishonouring of the sub-unit.
"Although the incidents outlined in the inquiry occurred across the regiment, the report has made it clear that there was a nexus of alleged serious criminal activities in 2 Squadron, SASR, at a point in time," he said.
"This alleged grave misconduct has severely damaged our professional standing.
"Future generations will be reminded of this moment in our military history from the gap in our squadron numbering system," Lieutenant General Burr said.
The 2 Squadron was raised in September 1964, saw its first service in Borneo and was later deployed to Vietnam.
It was heavily involved in Operation Slipper in Afghanistan, including in the fraught Oruzgan Province.
There will be a permanent record of the striking of the squadron title from the order of battle, and a new squadron - with a new name - will take its place.
The names of individual soldiers were redacted from the publicly released Brereton report, and Mr Roberts-Smith has repeatedly denied involvement in war crimes while serving in Afghanistan.
He declined to comment.
Mr Roberts-Smith, a former corporal who was awarded the nation's highest award for bravery, will keep his job at Seven West Media, where he has been a senior manager within the company's Queensland division since 2015.
Along with a Victoria Cross - which has been given to only four living Australians - Mr Roberts-Smith also holds a Medal for Gallantry and was awarded a commendation for distinguished service.
The disbandment of 2 Squadron falls short of a more severe option, the abolishment of the entire SASR, but Defence sources told The Australian that abolishing the entire unit was ruled out as too disruptive and a threat to national security.
Despite not being named in the publicly released Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry report, the Federal Court has heard Mr Roberts-Smith received a "potentially affected person" notice.
Those documents were used by the inquiry to warn individuals that they were to be the subject of adverse findings ahead of the report's conclusion.
Mr Roberts-Smith has launched defamation proceedings against Nine Entertainment over reports in The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age that detailed his actions in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012, including a claim he kicked a bound Afghan civilian off a cliff. He vehemently denies the allegations.
A former member, who spoke to The Australian on condition of anonymity because they are not authorised to speak to the media, described 2 Squadron as "infected by cancer". "The old Diggers will be absolutely gutted. But better we lose a squadron than a regiment," he said.
Former members of the 2 Squadron have long been split about the IGADF inquiry.
Chief of Defence Force Angus Campbell also said all special operations soldiers who served in Afghanistan would lose their meritorious unit citation awards, which are worn on their uniforms.
"These are actions that deal with a collective accountability that will not be forgotten, and the circumstances arising to lead to these outcomes will not be forgotten," he said.
Given the Brereton report's findings that battlefield reports were routinely fabricated, General Campbell said medals for valour or gallantry could also be re-examined "after any further processes or proceedings are concluded".
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/afghan-war-crimes-inquiry-2-squadron-dishonoured-by-its-abolition/news-story/f30cc32211f5d73c71387313d2260b6d
#11703264 at 2020-11-19 07:15:57 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #11 - THE SILENT WAR CONTINUES Edition
>>11606201
>>11702658
Ben Roberts-Smith puts Victoria Cross up as collateral for $1m legal fees loan
Former SAS corporal Ben Roberts-Smith offered up his prized Victoria Cross, and other wartime medals, as collateral for a $1 million loan from billionaire businessman Kerry Stokes, which helped fund his defamation action against Nine Entertainment.
Mr Stokes, chairman of Seven West Media, has been a long-time backer of Mr Roberts-Smith, and told The Australian on Thursday that the decorated soldier retains his full support in the wake of the allegations arising from the Brereton report.
Mr Stokes said the funding of the ex-soldier's legal action was "a private matter".
"However he has put his medals up as collateral on a loan and will relinquish them if required," he said.
If Mr Roberts-Smith is unable to repay the loan - which is understood to be in the vicinity of $1 million - Mr Stokes will donate the medals to the Australian War Memorial.
Mr Stokes said Mr Roberts-Smith would continue to work for his company's Queensland division in a senior executive position.
The media mogul also reiterated his long-held view that much of the reporting concerning Mr Roberts-Smith's wartime service has been "very prejudicial".
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/defence/Ben-robertssmith-puts-victoria-cross-up-as-collateral-for-1m-legal-fees-loan/news-story/472518806cc5af290ddad7ef49b82167
#11689864 at 2020-11-18 05:27:28 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #11 - THE SILENT WAR CONTINUES Edition
>>11689850
5/5
So do the Chief of the ADF and the head of the Army, men who boast a special forces pedigree, have a potential conflict of interest when it comes to the IGADF report?
Some think they should declare a conflict of interest. They will be key to implementing its recommendations and in moving ahead with possible charges against special forces soldiers.
But the ABC has been told that Campbell has been nothing but supportive of the IGADF inquiry, and respectful of its independence.
Defence did not answer specific questions the ABC put to it about whether or not Angus Campbell and Rick Burr should declare any possible conflicts of interest.
"The Inquiry is being conducted at arm's length from the ADF chain of command and Government to ensure the independence and integrity of the process," said a Defence spokesman. "Defence strongly supports the IGADF Afghanistan Inquiry and respects the integrity and independence of the process."
The Australian Federal Police is already investigating two alleged incidents involving Victoria Cross winner and former SAS operator, Ben Roberts-Smith, as well as "Soldier C", the SAS operator featured in the Four Corners Killing Field story shooting the unarmed Afghan.
Those cases, and others arising from the Brereton report, will now be passed to, and investigated by, a newly established Office of the Special Investigator. Set up by the Federal Government, its job will be to prosecute allegations of Australian war crimes in Afghanistan. It will have to interview witnesses, gather evidence, and prepare briefs for the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions (CDPP).
The CDPP will then have to decide whether to proceed with charges.
After more than four years of waiting for the Brereton report, another decade may pass before any prosecutions are finalised.
'Carrying all that shit'
For some, the IGADF report offers hope of vindication. For others, it could provide a possible release from years of torment.
The tragedy of this war spans continents and years.
Its victims were not just left lying in the fields, valleys or compounds of Afghanistan.
Its victims also came home to Australia.
Among them were special forces personnel who saw their comrades kill indiscriminately, who felt compromised and corrupted by what they witnessed, and who were morally and psychologically torn by feelings that they were part of the cover up.
To them, their silence was complicity.
"After the IGADF, when I gave all my evidence, it was like someone had stood off from my chest," said one former SAS operator. "Because you're carrying all that shit around where you know what had occurred was wrong."
For eight years this former operator had carried around that shit, in his case the horrific memory of a comrade shooting an unarmed, disabled man in the head as the Afghan ran away in fear of the helicopter and the SAS soldiers it disgorged. To this fleeing man these strangers could have been from another planet, with their savage dogs, suppressed weapons and painted faces. This indiscriminate and brutal killing not only haunted the SAS operator's dreams, but his waking hours too.
He had been honoured to have been selected for the SAS, only for his experiences in Afghanistan to make him question himself, and everything the regiment supposedly stood for.
The unvarnished truth
The IGADF inquiry doesn't just touch on the uncomfortable issue of Australian war crimes. It also offers up a mirror to Australia as a nation - how we hold up our special forces as heroes, yet send them on relentless deployments lacking an achievable objective; how governments and the military employ operational secrecy that stifles transparency; how that secrecy corrupted the special forces culture by allowing some to go rogue; and how any questioning of our military heroes is waved away or denounced as the work of "traitors" or "unpatriotic swill".
For one former special forces officer, the IGADF report should not be seen as a cure-all, but rather a time for all of us to reflect - soldier and civilian alike.
"How did the very best of us deviate so much for so long? How did we refuse to see the truth and evidence for what it was? How did the culture struggle and fail in the face of this test? And finally, as a society, are we honest and courageous enough to look at this in its unvarnished truth so that we can learn and ensure we emerge from this better?"
Watch our Secrets of War collection on iview.
https://iview.abc.net.au/collection/secrets-of-war
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-11-18/igadf-inquiry-into-special-forces-in-afghanistan-is-over/12816626
#11610740 at 2020-11-12 17:50:39 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #11 - THE SILENT WAR CONTINUES Edition
Ten SAS soldiers under investigation by war crimes investigators over 12 Afghan deaths
1/2
Federal police, Commonwealth prosecutors and a special counsel appointed by Prime Minister Scott Morrison will investigate the summary execution of at least 12 Afghan non-combatants or prisoners in what is shaping to be among the most complex law enforcement inquiries in Australian history.
Allegations about the conduct of an estimated 10 Australian Special Air Services Regiment (SAS) veterans who served in Afghanistan, including five still-serving members, have been or will soon be referred to authorities, according to Defence sources and special forces insiders.
But it is unclear how many commandos - another arm of Australia's special forces - will be referred to police as a result of the recently completed four-year investigation by the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force. The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald have previously reported that a former commando confessed to executing a prisoner in southern Afghanistan in 2012.
The investigation, conducted by senior judge Paul Brereton, canvassed alleged war crimes committed by special forces troops between 2005 and 2016. A public summary, which names no individual soldiers, is set to be released by Defence Force Chief Angus Campbell next week.
Special forces sources who are not authorised to speak publicly have confirmed that the inquiry heard a number of confessions from soldiers. This poses a potentially significant but not insurmountable challenge for investigators seeking to turn Justice Brereton's findings into evidence that can be admitted to court in a criminal prosecution. Confessions obtained during compulsory questioning, and evidence derived from these confessions, cannot be used to prosecute the confessor in Australian law, but witness testimony can be used in future trials.
Prime Minister Scott Morrison announced on Thursday that the government would appoint a special investigator to work with police and prosecutors overseeing the cases to be referred by Justice Brereton. The appointment acknowledges the limitations of evidence collected by the Inspector-General.
Mr Morrison also said any soldiers subject to the allegations needed to face the consequences, and it was also important to hold those accountable up the chain of command who had "responsibility for the environment in which those Australians served".
Mr Morrison said Australian Defence Force personnel had a lot to be proud of and it was important all members were not tarnished by the report. But he said the high standards and respect for the ADF "requires us to deal with honest and brutal truths". Mr Morrison said Australia needed to have a "deep respect for justice and the rule of law".
In 2018, then chief of the Defence Force Mark Binskin referred Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith for investigation by the federal police, which recently submitted a brief of evidence to the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions. The DPP is assessing whether the war hero should be charged.
Mr Roberts-Smith, who denies wrongdoing and has launched defamation proceedings against The Age and Herald, will be among the SAS figures referred to the special investigator, special forces sources said.
On Thursday evening, Mr Roberts-Smith released a statement that falsely asserted that a "member of the media" triggered the police taskforces into his alleged war crimes. In fact, Air Chief Marshal Binskin referred Mr Roberts-Smith to the AFP following an earlier referral the Defence chief received about the VC's recipient's alleged criminal conduct from Justice Brereton.
Mr Roberts-Smith's statement also sought to dismiss Justice Brereton's inquiry as founded in "rumours", despite the senior judge conducting more than 350 interviews on oath and examining thousands of classified documents. He welcomed the announcement by Mr Morrison and Defence Minister Linda Reynolds, saying it was "heartening" that the matters would be examined by a special investigator's office.
(continued)
#11606206 at 2020-11-12 09:10:37 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #11 - THE SILENT WAR CONTINUES Edition
>>11606201
2/2
During the defamation hearings, Nine detailed two new allegations implicating Mr Roberts-Smith in the execution of two Afghan prisoners during SASR missions in August and October 2012.
Mr Roberts-Smith told The Australian newspaper in June that he also denied these claims and accused Fairfax of changing their story on the death of Ali Jan.
"In relation to Syahchow they purport to rely in a brief outline from a soldier (Person 66) who we believe has never spoken to Fairfax,'' Mr Roberts-Smith said. "Fairfax have given not evidence to explain how this allegation suddenly fell into their lap.''
This week, the Federal Court ordered Ben Roberts-Smith to hand over confidential documents relating to the defence force inquiry into alleged war crimes as part of the defamation case he brought against three newspapers.
Mr Roberts-Smith is suing The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and The Canberra Times over reports his lawyers have argued falsely painted him as a murderous war criminal during his time as a Special Air Service soldier in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012.
Nine had sought access to documents revealing if Mr Roberts-Smith had received a Potentially Affected Persons notice (PAP notice) from the inquiry.
But the ADF inquiry and Mr Roberts-Smith, fought against the documents' release, arguing it could prejudice the inquiry.
On November 11, Federal Court Justice Craig Colvin dismissed this argument ruling the "risk was low" of that occurring if the documents were properly handled.
The journalist who wrote the story, investigative journalist Nick McKenzie took to social media on Wednesday to claim the decision "outed" Mr Roberts-Smith as a target of the inquiry.
"Big news. Alleged war criminal Ben Roberts-Smith VC ordered by judge to disclose files he fought hard to keep secret,'' he said.
"They detail adverse findings made by war crime probe. RS' own defamation action has now outed himself as Brereton inquiry and AFP target. Stunning."
Earlier on Thursday, Prime Minister Scott Morrison revealed a special investigator will be appointed to consider allegations of war crimes by Australia's soldiers in the Middle East following the completion of a long-running defence investigation into the claims. The conduct of more than 30 individuals will be investigated in the report.
The final report from IGADF will be released next week, after a four-year inquiry examining the conduct of the special forces in Afghanistan between 2005 and 2016.
"This is going to be very difficult for Australians. It is going to be very difficult for our serving community and our veterans community,'' Mr Morrison said.
"It is going to be difficult for all of us. But what we are seeking to do, as a government, I think what we have to do as a country, is to absorb this in a way that enables us to uphold the integrity of our justice system and uphold the integrity of our defence forces. We rely vitally on both of these institutions, absolutely vitally.
"Given the likely allegations of serious and possibly criminal misconduct, the matters raised in the inquiry must be assessed, investigated and where allegations are substantiated, prosecuted in court. To undertake this role, the government is establishing the Office of the Special Investigator."
Defence Minister Linda Reynolds confirmed the scandal could involve stripping soldiers of medals if misconduct is proven and they are ultimately convicted of crimes.
She said the Chief of the Defence Force General Angus Campbell is "considering all of those options".
https://www.news.com.au/national/politics/Ben-robertssmith-confirms-bombshell-investigation/news-story/403a613d014eff3d7e44faae9ad711ff
#11606201 at 2020-11-12 09:09:28 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #11 - THE SILENT WAR CONTINUES Edition
>>11593710
>>11604576
Ben Roberts-Smith confirms bombshell investigation
Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith has confirmed his conduct in Australia's special forces is being investigated in a report released next week.
1/2
Australia's most decorated living soldier Ben Roberts-Smith has confirmed his own conduct is being investigated in a bombshell report to be released next week.
The SAS hero, who was awarded the Victoria Cross in 2011 for bravery under fire during his fifth tour of Afghanistan, has strongly denied any wrongdoing.
In a statement, Mr Roberts-Smith said he welcomed the appointment of a special investigator to test the claims.
"I welcome the announcement today by the Prime Minister and the Minister for Defence which has for the first time accurately clarified that it was no part of the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force's (IGADF) remit to make any findings of fact in relation to rumours concerning special forces soldiers," he said.
"It is heartening to hear that these matters, which have been the subject of rumours for years, will now be examined by a Special Investigator's Office with expertise and experience to consider evidence not rumours and make decisions based on evidence rather than on unsubstantiated rumours.
"It is regrettable that the IGADF Inquiry took such an extraordinarily long time to be finalised. While I appreciate the complexity of the task ahead for the Special Investigator, I am hopeful that this next phase will be completed as expeditiously as possible so that all the current and former special forces soldiers who have been deeply impacted by the Inquiry process can move on with their lives."
The 42-year-old former soldier, who left the Army as a Corporal in 2013, is involved in a long-running defamation case involving Fairfax and the Nine network.
"I would also like to take this opportunity to correct the false claims repeatedly made in the Nine press that the IGADF Inquiry referred any matter about me to the AFP for investigation," he said.
"That is untrue. As the Federal Court heard on 8 October 2020 in my defamation proceedings against Nine, the AFP investigations were commenced in May 2018 following a referral from a member of the Melbourne media."
Corporal Benjamin Roberts-Smith, a former SAS soldier who was awarded the Victoria Cross on 23 January 2011 for "most conspicuous gallantry in action of great peril" strenuously denies any wrongdoing.
But the fact he is being investigated by the report has been laid bare in a defamation case in the Federal Court this week, after he was required to disclose to Fairfax media if he is advised of any adverse findings against him.
The Federal Court decision means that while Mr Roberts-Smith's name may be redacted in the IDGAF report, the investigation into his conduct has been confirmed in a separate defamation claim he fought in the Federal Court.
Fairfax media first reported in July, 2018, that Mr Roberts-Smith was "one of a small number of soldiers subject to investigation by an inquiry looking into the actions of Australian special forces soldiers in Afghanistan."
The newspapers claims cover his service in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012, including an allegation that he kicked an Afghan civilian named Ali Jan off a cliff. The injured man was later shot and died.
(continued)
#11593710 at 2020-11-11 17:45:30 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #11 - THE SILENT WAR CONTINUES Edition
>>11495844
>>11571508
Court orders war hero Ben Roberts-Smith to hand over documents to media
Highly decorated former soldier Ben Roberts-Smith has been ordered to hand over the preliminary findings made by a war crimes inquiry into his conduct in Afghanistan to lawyers acting for the media companies he is suing for defamation.
The Federal Court ruling on Wednesday ordered Mr Roberts-Smith to provide the documents he had argued should remain secret. The documents are significant because they confirm the Afghan war veteran has been a focus of the long-running Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force inquiry into war crimes.
That inquiry's damning findings are likely to be released next week by Defence Force Chief Angus Campbell, but Defence sources who cannot be identified because they are not authorised to speak publicly anticipate that no individual soldier will be named to preserve future criminal prosecutions.
However, on Wednesday, the court heard that Mr Roberts-Smith had been issued preliminary findings about his conduct made by Justice Paul Brereton after four years of investigations and hundreds of interviews with SAS insiders.
The former soldier was ordered to hand these findings, which are believed to include hundreds of pages of analysis and evidence, to The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald, which are being sued by Mr Roberts-Smith over reports he allegedly committed murder on deployments to Afghanistan and that he punched a woman in the face in Canberra.
The documents could include a notice from the inquiry that Mr Roberts-Smith is a "potentially affected person". A "PAP notice" is issued to people who are the subject of an adverse finding or recommendation, and it is designed to give recipients a final chance to respond to allegations against them.
The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald have alleged that Mr Roberts-Smith was involved in multiple unlawful killings as an Australian soldier in Afghanistan, including that of Ali Jan, a farmer who in 2012 in Darwan was kicked off a cliff while handcuffed and then shot dead. Mr Roberts-Smith is also alleged to have ordered soldiers in his command to shoot dead detained Afghan men.
The Australian Federal Police is investigating Mr Jan's death and, the Federal Court has heard, considers Mr Roberts-Smith a suspect. The AFP has interviewed the former soldier and has obtained eyewitness accounts implicating him in war crimes. No charges have been laid.
The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald have also reported an allegation Mr Roberts-Smith punched a woman when the pair left a function at Parliament House in 2018. The woman alleges she and Mr Roberts-Smith were having an affair at the time.
He denies the allegations and says the reports are defamatory because they portray him as a criminal. The news outlets are defending the claim on a truth defence. The defamation trial is to start next year.
The developments in the Federal Court on Wednesday come more than two years after Mr Roberts-Smith issued defamation proceedings. In 2018, he also stated publicly that he had not been contacted by the Brereton inquiry, which has been running since 2016, or an Australian Federal Police war crimes taskforce and that the allegations about his conduct were mere rumours.
Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers last month launched a last-ditch attempt to keep the crucial inquiry documents hidden from lawyers for the news outlets, but Justice Craig Colvin ruled in the Federal Court on Wednesday that the files should be released to the media.
However, not all the documents sought will be released so as not to jeopardise potential criminal proceedings against Mr Roberts-Smith and other soldiers.
Justice Colvin ordered redactions to documents containing information that Mr Roberts-Smith and other soldiers gave to the Inspector-General's inquiry. The judge found there was a "sufficient risk" the soldiers facing potential prosecution could apply for a permanent stay in future criminal proceedings if their evidence to the inquiry was disclosed.
The Inspector-General has finished its investigation into allegations of misconduct by Australian soldiers in Afghanistan from 2005 to 2016 and has delivered it to General Campbell, who has said he will publicly discuss the key findings.
If you are a current or former ADF member, or a relative, and need counselling or support, contact the Defence All-Hours Support Line on 1800 628 036 or Open Arms on 1800 011 046.
https://www.theage.com.au/national/court-orders-war-hero-Ben-Roberts-Smith-to-hand-over-documents-to-media-20201111-p56dn6.html
#11414903 at 2020-11-02 23:27:13 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #11 - THE SILENT WAR CONTINUES Edition
#10 - Part 4
Australian Politics and Society - Part 4
>>11319051 US Election 2020: Why Donald Trump will win again on November 3 - Ben Graham - news.com.au
>>11319280 Japanese Hentai Is Now Banned in Australia - regarded as "illegal pornography" following fears of child porn being brought into the country
>>11319297 Japanese adult retailer J-List statement - "Australia Bans Waifus, Onaholes, and Fun!"
>>11319746 Video: 'Blood lust, killings, cover-ups': Report describes Australian special forces soldiers' 'Abu Ghraib' moment
>>11338405 Jeffrey Epstein donated $650k to Kevin Rudd's International Peace Institute
>>11338560, >>11339269 Video: Kevin Rudd's denial of Jeffrey Epstein donation 'not credible' says Peter Dutton
>>11339701 University of Melbourne academic Dr Kylie Moore-Gilbert in 'secret safe house' in Iran
>>11353447 Video: Trump will be 'annihilated' by Biden: Anthony Scaramucci - 9 News Australia
>>11355482 President of Kevin Rudd's International Peace Institute quits over Jeffrey Epstein loan
>>11355493 PDF: Statement by the Board of the International Peace Institute - RESIGNATION OF PRESIDENT TERJE RØD-LARSEN
>>11355874 'I don't give a f**k what you think about me': Vegan cafe brands itself a Trump-supporting 'safe zone' ahead of the US election
>>11356010 Iran moves detained academic Kylie Moore-Gilbert back to Tehran prison
>>11356072 Former national security adviser Andrew Shearer will be the next Director-General of the Office of National Intelligence
>>11356149 Australia's domestic spy agency ASIO seeks new powers to question children as young as 14 and people suspected of foreign influence
>>11356523 Q Post #4941 - OPEN LETTER TO THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, DONALD J. TRUMP - Carlo Maria Viganò, Tit. Archbishop of Ulpiana
>>11369364 Video: Washington Insider Anthony Scaramucci On Trump's Chances Of Another Term As U.S. President - The Project
>>11371740 Disability Royal Commission needs more time to explore 'endemic' neglect, violence, abuse and exploitation of people with a disability in Australia
>>11371777 PDF: Royal Commission into Violence, Abuse, Neglect and Exploitation of People with Disability - Interim report
>>11385274 'No matter who wins, the country is still going to be divided': Americans in Australia gear up for US Election
>>11386109 Rudd backs FriendlyJordies as serious 'broadcaster' despite controversial acts - 'Uighur population causing trouble, radicalised by CIA'
>>11387695 FBI fugitive Andrea Dorothy Chan Reyes secretly extradited from Adelaide to the US over 2017 hit-run death of Agustin Rodriguez Jr
>>11387711 Whittier Police Department Facebook Post: Vehicular Homicide Suspect Extradited from Australia, in Whittier Police custody
>>11399083 Kevin Rudd name-dropped by Hunter Biden's jailed associate Devon Archer in letter to US ambassador Max Baucus
>>11399083 PDF: Letter from Devon Archer, Vice Chairman BHR Partners, to Max Baucus, US Ambassador to the People's Republic of China - 30th September 2015
>>11399146 Kevin Rudd Tweet: The Murdoch personal smear efforts continue…they want to know what meetings I may have had with... wait for it... Hunter Biden!
>>11399146 Kevin Rudd Tweet: Here are the questions Murdoch put to my office last night, and the answers that were sent back
>>11402713 Why I would grit my teeth and vote for Trump - Alexander Downer
>>11402781 Video: Former foreign affairs minister Alexander Downer says the contrast between Biden and Trump couldn't be more dramatic - Sky News Australia
>>11404065 Former Special Air Service soldier and Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith asked wife to lie about his affair, court told
>>11404435 Donald Trump's passion, policies and unprecedented rally schedule mean he can still win - Joe Hockey
>>11404641 Australia's federal ICAC to conduct phone taps, undercover surveillance but not public hearings
#10 - Part 5
Australian and Regional Resignations
>>10739647 Australian judge James Spigelman resigns from Hong Kong court - no further reasons for the termination were given
>>10893345 Headmaster of Sydney private school St Joseph's College, Dr Chris Hayes, announces sudden resignation "effective immediately"
>>11034645 Chris Eccles, Victorian Premier Daniel Andrews' top bureaucrat, resigns after hotel quarantine inquiry requests phone records
>>11282691 ASIC deputy chairman Daniel Crennan quits following housing expenses scandal
>>11282691 ASIC chairman James Shipton stands aside after Australian National Audit Office raises concerns over taxation expenses
>>11402587 Christine Holgate resigns as Australia Post boss after Cartier watch scandal
#11414831 at 2020-11-02 23:23:23 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #11 - THE SILENT WAR CONTINUES Edition
#10 - Part 2
Australian Politics and Society - Part 2
>>10941290 Miranda Devine is a conservative Australian columnist and writer…As of early 2020, her columns appear in the New York Post
>>10941290 Coronavirus battle shows the bravery of President Trump: Devine - Miranda Devine - nypost.com
>>10941326 "Those who know Cardinal George Pell, the pope's honest former finance minister, always suspected he had been set up" - Miranda Devine
>>10960152 2020 race: Donald Trump on track to lose by a landslide - Cameron Stewart - theaustralian.com.au
>>10976399 US Embassy Canberra Twitter Thread: Ambassador Culvahouse will be sharing his outlook on the future of the #USwithAUS
>>10976399 "As long as the United States and Australia continue to work together, I am confidently optimistic about the future." - Ambassador Culvahouse
>>10976399 Transcript: Ambassador Culvahouse Speech - ASPI Indo-Pacific Leaders Dialogue - October 7, 2020
>>10976426 Video: Indo-Pacific Leaders Dialogue: The future of US-Australia relations - US Ambassador to Australia, Arthur B. Culvahouse Jr. - ASPICanberra
>>10977747 Secretary of State Michael Pompeo Tweet: Great to meet again with Australian Foreign Minister @MarisePayne…to discuss Quad cooperation
>>10977747 Foreign Minister Marise Payne Tweet: The #Quad is a diplomatic network with a positive agenda: a region governed by rules, not power
>>10979128 Awkward moment Scott Morrison confronts Leigh Sales over her 'irresponsible question' when she grills him about the US presidential election
>>10994627 National Australia Bank didn't maintain records of human traffickers until 2019
>>10994640 PDF: Parliament of Australia - Review Of The Four Major Banks - National Australia Bank - Anti-money laundering
>>11007426 SAS at war: Internal military investigation finds Ben Roberts-Smith may have threatened to shoot a fellow soldier in the back of the head
>>11008088 Freemasons NSW & ACT recruitment add in a local paper
>>11008922 ADF personnel warned about social media use after offensive Instagram account uncovered
>>11020501 US elections were changed for better (and worse) by the secret 'Australian ballot'
>>11034788 Trump needs to take fight up to Biden and land some punches - Joe Hockey - theaustralian.com.au
>>11035007, >>11035014 Democrat Barbara Bollier's praise of strict Australian gun laws roils Kansas Senate race
>>11048335 US election: Joe Biden in the White House would be good for us - Troy Bramston - theaustralian.com.au
>>11048472 Defence Minister Linda Reynolds Tweet: They operate in the shadows, but shed light that helps keep Australia safe - Defence Intelligence Organisation
>>11048507 Alarm as neo-Nazi group National Socialist Network expands to Adelaide
>>11063585 'An apocalyptic list': Home Affairs secretary Michael Pezzullo says climate change, pandemics warrant security rethink
>>11063601 Video: Securing Australia: In conversation with Michael Pezzullo - national security in an increasingly complex and interconnected world
>>11079845 Bruce Springsteen: 'If Trump wins I'm moving to Australia' - Poppy Reid - tonedeaf.thebrag.com - tonedeaf logo symbolism
>>11080248 Pacific Marines Tweet: The ninth iteration of @mrfdarwin has wrapped up in the Northern Territory of #Australia
>>11080248 Video: Colonel David Banning, Marine Rotational Force - Darwin Commanding Officer
>>11080293 Police won't charge ABC journalist over 'Afghan Files' stories
>>11098507 NBC Moderator Savannah Guthrie (born in Melbourne, Australia) hailed for keeping Trump in check at town hall
>>11098719 Video: Savannah Guthrie: Australian-born town hall moderator who held Trump to task, married to former Al Gore political operative Michael Feldman
>>11098850 Australian-born billionaire Rupert Murdoch Predicts a Landslide Win for Biden - THE GREAT OZ HAS SPOKEN
>>11099297 Video: Lowy Institute Live: In conversation with General James Mattis and Sir Angus Houston - https://qanon.pub/?q=mattis
>>11099672 Australian Defence Force orders ban on destruction of evidence from Afghanistan war, as inquiry into alleged war crimes nears end
>>11100195 ASIO warns foreign spies are secretly 'cultivating politicians' across Australia
>>11100315 PDF: ASIO Annual Report 2019-20 "Parliament grants ASIO extraordinary powers, but those powers must always be exercised legally and ethically"
>>11100891 'Without peer': Top spy Nick Warner, Director-General of the Office of National Intelligence to retire this year
>>11112388 US election 2020: Voters are tired of Trump's catastrophic presidency - Troy Bramston - theaustralian.com.au
>>11125093 Murder and abduction claims have Rwandan Government accused of intimidating critics in Australia
>>11125850 Video: Australia One - Riccardo Bosi Talks To Sacha Stone
>>11134109 PDF: Bit-chute replacements for YouTube patriot accounts
#11414100 at 2020-11-02 22:48:07 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #10 - INFORMATION WARFARE Edition
#10 - Part 4
Australian Politics and Society - Part 4
>>11319051 US Election 2020: Why Donald Trump will win again on November 3 - Ben Graham - news.com.au
>>11319280 Japanese Hentai Is Now Banned in Australia - regarded as "illegal pornography" following fears of child porn being brought into the country
>>11319297 Japanese adult retailer J-List statement - "Australia Bans Waifus, Onaholes, and Fun!"
>>11319746 Video: 'Blood lust, killings, cover-ups': Report describes Australian special forces soldiers' 'Abu Ghraib' moment
>>11338405 Jeffrey Epstein donated $650k to Kevin Rudd's International Peace Institute
>>11338560, >>11339269 Video: Kevin Rudd's denial of Jeffrey Epstein donation 'not credible' says Peter Dutton
>>11339701 University of Melbourne academic Dr Kylie Moore-Gilbert in 'secret safe house' in Iran
>>11353447 Video: Trump will be 'annihilated' by Biden: Anthony Scaramucci - 9 News Australia
>>11355482 President of Kevin Rudd's International Peace Institute quits over Jeffrey Epstein loan
>>11355493 PDF: Statement by the Board of the International Peace Institute - RESIGNATION OF PRESIDENT TERJE RØD-LARSEN
>>11355874 'I don't give a f**k what you think about me': Vegan cafe brands itself a Trump-supporting 'safe zone' ahead of the US election
>>11356010 Iran moves detained academic Kylie Moore-Gilbert back to Tehran prison
>>11356072 Former national security adviser Andrew Shearer will be the next Director-General of the Office of National Intelligence
>>11356149 Australia's domestic spy agency ASIO seeks new powers to question children as young as 14 and people suspected of foreign influence
>>11356523 Q Post #4941 - OPEN LETTER TO THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, DONALD J. TRUMP - Carlo Maria Viganò, Tit. Archbishop of Ulpiana
>>11369364 Video: Washington Insider Anthony Scaramucci On Trump's Chances Of Another Term As U.S. President - The Project
>>11371740 Disability Royal Commission needs more time to explore 'endemic' neglect, violence, abuse and exploitation of people with a disability in Australia
>>11371777 PDF: Royal Commission into Violence, Abuse, Neglect and Exploitation of People with Disability - Interim report
>>11385274 'No matter who wins, the country is still going to be divided': Americans in Australia gear up for US Election
>>11386109 Rudd backs FriendlyJordies as serious 'broadcaster' despite controversial acts - 'Uighur population causing trouble, radicalised by CIA'
>>11387695 FBI fugitive Andrea Dorothy Chan Reyes secretly extradited from Adelaide to the US over 2017 hit-run death of Agustin Rodriguez Jr
>>11387711 Whittier Police Department Facebook Post: Vehicular Homicide Suspect Extradited from Australia, in Whittier Police custody
>>11399083 Kevin Rudd name-dropped by Hunter Biden's jailed associate Devon Archer in letter to US ambassador Max Baucus
>>11399083 PDF: Letter from Devon Archer, Vice Chairman BHR Partners, to Max Baucus, US Ambassador to the People's Republic of China - 30th September 2015
>>11399146 Kevin Rudd Tweet: The Murdoch personal smear efforts continue…they want to know what meetings I may have had with... wait for it... Hunter Biden!
>>11399146 Kevin Rudd Tweet: Here are the questions Murdoch put to my office last night, and the answers that were sent back
>>11402713 Why I would grit my teeth and vote for Trump - Alexander Downer
>>11402781 Video: Former foreign affairs minister Alexander Downer says the contrast between Biden and Trump couldn't be more dramatic - Sky News Australia
>>11404065 Former Special Air Service soldier and Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith asked wife to lie about his affair, court told
>>11404435 Donald Trump's passion, policies and unprecedented rally schedule mean he can still win - Joe Hockey
>>11404641 Australia's federal ICAC to conduct phone taps, undercover surveillance but not public hearings
#10 - Part 5
Australian and Regional Resignations
>>10739647 Australian judge James Spigelman resigns from Hong Kong court - no further reasons for the termination were given
>>10893345 Headmaster of Sydney private school St Joseph's College, Dr Chris Hayes, announces sudden resignation "effective immediately"
>>11034645 Chris Eccles, Victorian Premier Daniel Andrews' top bureaucrat, resigns after hotel quarantine inquiry requests phone records
>>11282691 ASIC deputy chairman Daniel Crennan quits following housing expenses scandal
>>11282691 ASIC chairman James Shipton stands aside after Australian National Audit Office raises concerns over taxation expenses
>>11402587 Christine Holgate resigns as Australia Post boss after Cartier watch scandal
#11413969 at 2020-11-02 22:41:21 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #10 - INFORMATION WARFARE Edition
#10 - Part 2
Australian Politics and Society - Part 2
>>10941290 Miranda Devine is a conservative Australian columnist and writer…As of early 2020, her columns appear in the New York Post
>>10941290 Coronavirus battle shows the bravery of President Trump: Devine - Miranda Devine - nypost.com
>>10941326 "Those who know Cardinal George Pell, the pope's honest former finance minister, always suspected he had been set up" - Miranda Devine
>>10960152 2020 race: Donald Trump on track to lose by a landslide - Cameron Stewart - theaustralian.com.au
>>10976399 US Embassy Canberra Twitter Thread: Ambassador Culvahouse will be sharing his outlook on the future of the #USwithAUS
>>10976399 "As long as the United States and Australia continue to work together, I am confidently optimistic about the future." - Ambassador Culvahouse
>>10976399 Transcript: Ambassador Culvahouse Speech - ASPI Indo-Pacific Leaders Dialogue - October 7, 2020
>>10976426 Video: Indo-Pacific Leaders Dialogue: The future of US-Australia relations - US Ambassador to Australia, Arthur B. Culvahouse Jr. - ASPICanberra
>>10977747 Secretary of State Michael Pompeo Tweet: Great to meet again with Australian Foreign Minister @MarisePayne…to discuss Quad cooperation
>>10977747 Foreign Minister Marise Payne Tweet: The #Quad is a diplomatic network with a positive agenda: a region governed by rules, not power
>>10979128 Awkward moment Scott Morrison confronts Leigh Sales over her 'irresponsible question' when she grills him about the US presidential election
>>10994627 National Australia Bank didn't maintain records of human traffickers until 2019
>>10994640 PDF: Parliament of Australia - Review Of The Four Major Banks - National Australia Bank - Anti-money laundering
>>11007426 SAS at war: Internal military investigation finds Ben Roberts-Smith may have threatened to shoot a fellow soldier in the back of the head
>>11008088 Freemasons NSW & ACT recruitment add in a local paper
>>11008922 ADF personnel warned about social media use after offensive Instagram account uncovered
>>11020501 US elections were changed for better (and worse) by the secret 'Australian ballot'
>>11034788 Trump needs to take fight up to Biden and land some punches - Joe Hockey - theaustralian.com.au
>>11035007, >>11035014 Democrat Barbara Bollier's praise of strict Australian gun laws roils Kansas Senate race
>>11048335 US election: Joe Biden in the White House would be good for us - Troy Bramston - theaustralian.com.au
>>11048472 Defence Minister Linda Reynolds Tweet: They operate in the shadows, but shed light that helps keep Australia safe - Defence Intelligence Organisation
>>11048507 Alarm as neo-Nazi group National Socialist Network expands to Adelaide
>>11063585 'An apocalyptic list': Home Affairs secretary Michael Pezzullo says climate change, pandemics warrant security rethink
>>11063601 Video: Securing Australia: In conversation with Michael Pezzullo - national security in an increasingly complex and interconnected world
>>11079845 Bruce Springsteen: 'If Trump wins I'm moving to Australia' - Poppy Reid - tonedeaf.thebrag.com - tonedeaf logo symbolism
>>11080248 Pacific Marines Tweet: The ninth iteration of @mrfdarwin has wrapped up in the Northern Territory of #Australia
>>11080248 Video: Colonel David Banning, Marine Rotational Force - Darwin Commanding Officer
>>11080293 Police won't charge ABC journalist over 'Afghan Files' stories
>>11098507 NBC Moderator Savannah Guthrie (born in Melbourne, Australia) hailed for keeping Trump in check at town hall
>>11098719 Video: Savannah Guthrie: Australian-born town hall moderator who held Trump to task, married to former Al Gore political operative Michael Feldman
>>11098850 Australian-born billionaire Rupert Murdoch Predicts a Landslide Win for Biden - THE GREAT OZ HAS SPOKEN
>>11099297 Video: Lowy Institute Live: In conversation with General James Mattis and Sir Angus Houston - https://qanon.pub/?q=mattis
>>11099672 Australian Defence Force orders ban on destruction of evidence from Afghanistan war, as inquiry into alleged war crimes nears end
>>11100195 ASIO warns foreign spies are secretly 'cultivating politicians' across Australia
>>11100315 PDF: ASIO Annual Report 2019-20 "Parliament grants ASIO extraordinary powers, but those powers must always be exercised legally and ethically"
>>11100891 'Without peer': Top spy Nick Warner, Director-General of the Office of National Intelligence to retire this year
>>11112388 US election 2020: Voters are tired of Trump's catastrophic presidency - Troy Bramston - theaustralian.com.au
>>11125093 Murder and abduction claims have Rwandan Government accused of intimidating critics in Australia
>>11125850 Video: Australia One - Riccardo Bosi Talks To Sacha Stone
>>11134109 PDF: Bit-chute replacements for YouTube patriot accounts
#11404065 at 2020-11-02 07:25:55 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #10 - INFORMATION WARFARE Edition
>>11007426
Ben Roberts-Smith asked wife to lie about his affair, court told
Ben Roberts-Smith asked his wife to lie about an affair he had with another woman, a court has heard, amid revelations the former Australian soldier heavily redacted information from documents sent to news outlets as part of a defamation case.
Mr Roberts-Smith, a former Special Air Service soldier and Victoria Cross recipient, is suing The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald over reports he allegedly committed murder on deployments to Afghanistan and that he punched his mistress in the face in Canberra.
He denies the allegations and says the reports are defamatory because they portray him as a criminal.
The news outlets are defending the claim on a truth defence. The defamation trial is to start next year.
On Monday the Federal Court was told that without its permission Mr Roberts-Smith redacted information from documents before they were sent to the news outlets as part of the defamation case.
The court heard that among the papers was a document from Mr Roberts-Smith's wife, Emma, in which she said her husband asked her to lie and say that they were separated at the time of the affair.
Mr Roberts-Smith and his wife have previously publicly said they were separated at the time he had the relationship with the woman and that the relationship was not an affair.
But the other woman, referred to as Person 17, alleges she and Mr Roberts-Smith had an affair between October 2017 and April 2018 and that he punched her hard to the left side of her face when the pair left a function at Parliament House in March 2018.
Barrister Lyndelle Barnett, appearing for the news outlets, told the court on Monday the information in the affidavits raised questions about the credibility of Mr and Ms Roberts-Smith, which could be an issue at trial. Ms Roberts-Smith is expected to be called as a witness for her husband.
Bruce McClintock, SC, appearing for Mr Roberts-Smith, said the material was redacted from the documents because it was "deeply personal" and irrelevant to the allegations at the centre of the defamation trial.
But Ms Barnett said a party didn't have the right to redact information without a court's permission.
She said she was conscious of the sensitivities surrounding the documents and conceded some redacted information might be irrelevant but suggested the documents could be released only to lawyers for The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald.
In response, Mr McClintock said his client opposed the disclosure of the information "including to lawyers for hostile parties" and that it would be unfair to Mr Roberts-Smith if disclosed.
Mr McClintock applied for Justice Anthony Besanko to rule on the matter. The judge will do so at a later date.
The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald have also alleged that Mr Roberts-Smith was involved in multiple unlawful killings as an Australian soldier in Afghanistan, including that of Ali Jan, a farmer who in 2012 was kicked off a cliff in Darwan while handcuffed and was then shot dead.
Mr Roberts-Smith is also alleged to have ordered soldiers in his command to shoot dead detained Afghan men.
The Australian Federal Police is investigating Mr Jan's death and, the court has heard, considers Mr Roberts-Smith a suspect. The AFP has interviewed Mr Roberts-Smith and has obtained eyewitness accounts implicating him in war crimes. No charges have been laid.
If you are a current or former ADF member, or a relative, and need counselling or support, contact the Defence All-Hours Support Line on 1800 628 036 or Open Arms on 1800 011 046.
https://www.defence.gov.au/health/dmh/allhourssupportline.asp
https://www.openarms.gov.au/
https://www.smh.com.au/national/Ben-Roberts-Smith-asked-wife-to-lie-about-his-affair-court-told-20201102-p56aqk.html
#11007439 at 2020-10-10 02:25:44 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #10 - INFORMATION WARFARE Edition
>>11007426
2/2
The Federal Court heard this week that Justice Brereton has issued Mr Roberts-Smith with a "potentially affected person" notice, meaning the former soldier is the subject of allegations made to the inquiry.
The court has previously heard Mr Roberts-Smith is a suspect in an AFP war crimes inquiry for alleged murder and cruel treatment of an Afghan farmer, Ali Jan, who was allegedly kicked off a cliff while handcuffed and before being shot dead in September 2012.
The Weekend Australian has spoken independently to multiple SAS veterans of the Afghanistan conflict who said Mr Roberts-Smith's alleged threat against Corporal M was consistent with his behaviour
According to one, Mr Roberts-Smith appeared to have an intense dislike of the smaller, quieter Corporal M.
Another said: "I know that Ben Roberts-Smith harassed, was abusive and disrespectful to (Corporal M) at the time. It got to the point where it was so bad (Corporal M) was moved out of the patrol."
Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyer Mark O'Brien said the allegation his client bullied the other soldier "is completely false".
He said Corporal M's complaint against Mr Roberts-Smith was "was made at the urging of a couple of senior patrol commanders ... who have well known animosity towards my client."
There have been conflicting accounts of the Chora Pass battle.
According to Robert-Smith's official Medal for Gallantry citation, an observation post manned by his patrol "had become the focus of the anti-coalition militia force".
It records his repeated moves to leave the covered position to "neutralise" the enemy, and his taking up of an exposed position ahead of the patrol, halting "a group of sixteen" Taliban combatants with his sniper rifle while experiencing "very accurate small arms fire".
The citation omits mention of what attracted the enemy to the observation post, which was directing fire on insurgents in the valley below.
Journalist Chris Masters' 2017 book, No Front Line: Australian special forces at war in Afghanistan, said the then-trooper Mr Roberts-Smith had disagreed with a decision made by the then-trooper M and another soldier who opted not to shoot a teenage boy who came within about 75 metres of the hidden position.
"He wore traditional Afghan garb and with no chest rig or weapons," Masters wrote.
The teenager might have been a "spotter", but the operators believed their position had not been compromised, Masters wrote.
But Mr Roberts-Smith told the Australian War Memorial in February 2011 that "a couple of blokes" came close to the observation post, potentially compromising the hideout.
"(They) just walked up literally, probably about two hours before dark, walked straight up to the front of the OP."
He said the patrol's job was "not to start a fight", but believing the insurgents may have spotted the patrol, he and Sergeant Matt Locke, who was killed in action in 2007, "hunted them down and got rid of them".
He said the gunfire set off a flare carried by one of the insurgents in a "chest rig", which attracted the attention of other enemy fighters.
In a later interview with The Australian, in April 2011, Mr Roberts-Smith said he and Sgt Locke engaged just a single armed insurgent who walked within 30m of the position.
In the ensuing battle, Corporal (then trooper) M's Minimi machine gun jammed, which Mr Roberts-Smith said placed the patrol in danger, according to his interview with the War Memorial.
"When the gun broke, that's why it was desperate, because that was 25 per cent of the firepower," he said.
Mr Roberts-Smith was later awarded the Victoria Cross for his role in a 2010 battle, in which he stormed two enemy machine gun positions in Afghanistan while the rest of his squad was pinned down.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/defence/Ben-robertssmith-i-will-shoot-you-in-the-head-sas-at-war/news-story/b32c06b4c7a6ea2d81e0a5b2e9527143
#11007426 at 2020-10-10 02:24:40 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #10 - INFORMATION WARFARE Edition
SAS at war: 'I will shoot you in the head'
1/2
The toxic culture within the Australian Army's elite Special Air Service is under renewed scrutiny as it emerges that an internal military investigation into the nation's most decorated soldier Ben Roberts-Smith found that he may have threatened to shoot a fellow soldier in the back of the head after a battle with insurgents in Afghanistan.
Ahead of the imminent release of the findings of a four-year war crimes inquiry for the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force, The Weekend Australian can reveal an SAS captain investigated the alleged bullying incident, finding it was likely Mr Roberts-Smith acted inappropriately in the aftermath of the firefight in 2006 - for which he was later awarded the Medal for Gallantry
According to an internal SAS document, obtained by The Weekend Australian, the investigating captain concluded in 2013 that, despite the seven-year gap between the alleged incident and the complaint, "there is reasonable suspicion that an incident of unacceptable behaviour did occur".
A mediation process was ordered after the investigation, consistent with ADF policy that "complaints of unacceptable behaviour are resolved at the lowest appropriate level".
The revelation of the SAS captain's findings expose the deep divisions that have been percolating within the elite regiment for years - and the split has only widened in recent times as Mr Roberts-Smith has been accused of a series of war crimes, prompting many serving and former members of the unit to take sides.
Mr Roberts-Smith, who is suing Nine Entertainment for defamation over a series of articles alleging he committed multiple unlawful killings while on deployment in Afghanistan, told the 2013 assessment that the claims arising from the 2006 firefight were "fabricated".
The official report of the allegations against Mr Roberts-Smith casts a further shadow over the operations of the SAS on the battlefields of Afghanistan, with accusations the force was overused, beset by a poor culture, and inappropriately used as "door kickers" and big-battle soldiers when they were specifically trained for stealth operations.
The upcoming Inspector-General's crimes report by NSW Supreme Court judge Major General Paul Brereton is expected to make further allegations in relation to Mr Roberts-Smith, a recipient of the Victoria Cross.
The SAS "quick assessment brief" obtained by The Weekend Australian concerns a complaint by a fellow operator, "Corporal M", who was a trooper in a six-man patrol with then-trooper Roberts-Smith during the June 2, 2006, battle near Chora Pass in Afghanistan's Oruzgan province.
Corporal M, who cannot be identified because he is still serving in the regiment, told the investigator in 2013 that he was "bullied and verbally harassed" by Mr Roberts-Smith, according to the four page "staff-in-confidence" briefing prepared for the regiment's commanding officer.
"During the deployment and post the patrol Cpl Roberts-Smith came up to me and said 'Next time we go out on patrol, if your performance doesn't improve I will shoot you in the back of the head' or words to that effect," the operator said. It is understood Corporal M did not interpret Mr Roberts-Smith's comment as a literal threat to kill, but was nevertheless distressed by it.
Corporal M alleged Mr Roberts-Smith later "demeaned (his) character/ability as an SAS patrol member" during a 2012 squadron conference. He made the official complaint in an August 2013 interview - seven years after the alleged incident - amid swirling rumours over the conduct of some SAS members.
The Weekend Australian is not suggesting the allegations are true, only that they were made.
Mr Roberts-Smith told the investigator: "These allegations are simply not true and have been fabricated ... (Corporal M) has been communicating with other members of the unit to try and concoct stories and statements to verify his allegations."
In his official report, the investigating captain found "there is sufficient evidence to suggest that CPL Roberts-Smith may have verbally insulted (Corporal M)", and that "an act of unacceptable behaviour may have been carried out by CPL Roberts-Smith during that deployment". Mr Roberts-Smith announced several months later he was leaving full-time army service to pursue a career in business. There is no suggestion this was linked to Corporal M's complaint.
(continued)
#10795091 at 2020-09-26 07:15:00 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #10 - INFORMATION WARFARE Edition
>>10794782
Cocks and Stirrers: Markers on the path to the SAS going rogue
1/2
Looking back, the 2010 "Stirrer's Parade" was one of the earliest obvious signposts that something was going badly wrong in the Special Air Services Regiment, Australia's elite fighting force.
It was the best part of a decade into the conflict in Afghanistan, and Special Forces - the SAS and Commandos - had deployed 15 separate rotations and was already weary. But proud too. Multiple honours and awards had come their way. Though worn they were battle hardened and still eager for the fight.
In December that year the SAS Regiment's annual "Stirrer's Parade" was three months late. Usually held on the regimental birthdate of September 4, this time it was delayed to await the return of 1 Squadron.
The gathering was meant to get stuff off the collective chest. At its best, it was an opportunity for subtle, take-the-piss feedback to inform future operations. But too readily it could turn nasty. It had happened before.
A perennial problem with Australia's premier regiment was the power of the Sergeants Mess. Medalled, experienced and often revered, the job of keeping the sergeants in check was tougher than usual for the officers. In contrast to a linear line of command in conventional forces, the Special Forces command structure is more flexible, the requirement for agility giving greater authority and autonomy to those participating in the close fight.
A feature of the Parade was the annual "Cock of the Year" award, which was as rude as it sounds and in 2010 was "awarded" to a young officer who was otherwise respected as an experienced soldier. More to the point though, he was principled in holding his soldiers to account for their moral or ethical failings.
The award was an attack on a junior leader. But what was most telling was the silence from on high. Senior officers let it happen, and by doing so, signalled who was really in charge and reinforced a growing sense of entitlement among the operators.
In future, junior officers would be more than aware of the opprobrium associated with offending the warriors. "Likership" over leadership, an eternal challenge for command, was unleashed. Other junior leaders, such as now Federal MP Andrew Hastie, who also took a stand on doing the right thing, would also cop the brunt of the so-called non-commissioned officer, or NCO "Mafia".
Ethics, morals and integrity
Six years later, in April 2016 Special Operations Commander Major General Jeff Sengelman sent a remarkably prescient letter. It came in response to an earlier request to serving members of the Special Air Service Regiment to speak up truthfully about rumours of rogue behaviour in Afghanistan.
The rumours, in effect, were some of these revered dogs of war had slipped the leash.
"Others have expressed to me that the need to be an exceptional warrior at the pinnacle of the tradecraft and adept at finding, fixing and finishing the enemy is the premier and dominant characteristic that should define who we are and our culture," Sengelman's letter said.
"While I agree this has its place, let me be absolutely clear, there is much more to being a role model for [Special Operations Forces] attributes than martial prowess.
"Given a choice between this and ethical behaviour, moral outlook, or integrity of character, martial prowess will always be secondary."
Weeks after that letter was sent, the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force commenced an inquiry into "rumours of possible breaches of the Laws of Armed Conflict". Now, four years later we are on the eve of what many predict will be a harrowing finding, with Sengelman's words still resonating.
The narrative spun about the Inspector-General's inquiry until now includes a complex maze of interwoven arguments about Australia needing to know the truth and the preservation of moral authority, versus how much do we really need to know about what occurs on the battlefield and that no good can come of second guessing our heroes.
The ingrained secrecy associated with Special Operations and the subsequent clamour of public debate has made for some confusion.
So let's try to peer through the fog of war at where the SAS started to go wrong. And in doing so after tracking this for some time, two incidents stand out as pivotal to us: the Stirrer's parade of 2010, and one other key moment: the awarding of the Victoria Cross to Corporal Ben Roberts-Smith.
(continued)
#10794782 at 2020-09-26 06:13:28 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #10 - INFORMATION WARFARE Edition
A warrior culture and the murders that followed: What went wrong with the SAS
1/2
A rogue squad of SAS soldiers is accused of murdering multiple bound or defenceless Afghan detainees, according to insiders who have some knowledge of the landmark Brereton inquiry into war crimes which is due to report within weeks.
The report, by senior judge Paul Brereton, has taken four years to complete and is underpinned by detailed confessions by Commando and Special Air Service Regiment soldiers who have admitted that they participated in or covered up the execution of unarmed prisoners and defenceless Afghans. The killings breach the rules of war and Australia's criminal code.
The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald have also obtained a letter written by Australia's former special forces commander, Jeff Sengelman, who blames the war crimes scandal on a "compromised" chain of command, describes special forces' misdeeds and cover-ups as "shameful and embarrassing", and warns a failure to reform would render the SAS and Commando regiments "strategically irrelevant".
"Many have opined to me that the unacceptable behaviours … were somehow justified by operational imperatives, our sacrifice, and the stressors associated with combat operations," Mr Sengelman wrote in the April 2016 letter.
"While I am not insensitive to how this attitude may have arisen and am the first to acknowledge the exceptional commitment and sacrifice that operational service has required; this is not and never will be a satisfactory justification for deviation from standards or unacceptable behaviour. This cannot be in doubt. If it is for you, then we need to speak."
While the contents of the Brereton report will remain classified after Justice Brereton hands it to Defence Force Chief Angus Campbell in coming weeks, some insiders have received general briefings about its findings and it is believed Justice Brereton will identify a small group of rogue SAS soldiers as responsible for multiple murders.
Justice Brereton is expected to send several war crimes referrals to the Australian Federal Police, sparking new police investigations in a move likely to require the AFP to dramatically boost the resourcing of its existing war crimes investigation teams. Those teams have been conducting two war crimes investigations since June 2018 into Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith after referrals by now former defence chief Mark Binskin. Mr Roberts-Smith denies all wrongdoing and is suing Nine Entertainment, the owner of this masthead, for publishing allegations that he is a war criminal, a key target of the Brereton inquiry and that he punched a woman in a domestic violence incident.
Defence has spent months planning its public response to the independent Brereton inquiry report, according to Defence sources who spoke on the condition of anonymity because they were not authorised to speak to the media. The sources anticipate a summary of Mr Brereton's findings will be released to the public.
The Age and Herald have interviewed more than a dozen serving and former insiders who have some knowledge of the findings and defence's anticipated response. The Brereton report is expected to expose:
* a rogue group of SAS soldiers, variously consisting of four to five men, executed multiple bound or defenceless prisoners to boost "kill counts" - a personal tally of Afghans shot dead - with no regard for the laws of armed conflict;
* a small number of commandos and SAS soldiers executed prisoners believing more senior soldiers had given tacit support for unlawful killings; and
* poor leadership and oversight, with some officers blind to warning signs that pointed to a collapse in basic morality among small soldier cliques.
The sources said they did not believe senior or mid-level officers had direct knowledge about war crimes. The evidence suggests small cliques of soldiers with relatively low ranks either participated in or witnessed war crimes but covered them up from the chain of command.
(continued)
#10705270 at 2020-09-19 05:59:07 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #10 - INFORMATION WARFARE Edition
#9 - Part 11
>>10491577 'We don't respond to coercion': Frydenberg rejects Facebook news boycott threat
>>10491684 Prominent Australian TV anchor Cheng Lei detained in China 'without charge'
>>10491693 Detained Australian journalist Cheng Lei authored Facebook posts about Wuhan coronavirus cover-up
>>10491722 AFP consider Ben Roberts-Smith a suspect in war crimes, court told
>>10495009 Australia risks backsliding into a poor country in Asia Pacific - globaltimes.cn
>>10498841 Who is Q FAQ - https://qanon.news/Archives/x/10472611#10472992
>>10501740 José Ramos-Horta urges Australia to drop Witness K and Bernard Collaery prosecution
>>10501793 Australia in the US Tweet: #OTD in 1951, (Australia, New Zealand and the United States) signed the #ANZUS mutual defense treaty
>>10501813 Pacific Marines Tweet: After fighting together in World War II, the U.S. remains committed to our mutual defense treaty with #Australia
>>10506023 Q Post #4629 - CORRUPT. CONTROLLED. ENEMIES OF THE REPUBLIC.
>>10506023 Q Post #4634 - Why did it take a political outsider to [finally] confront China?
>>10508278 Daniel Andrews' Belt and Road deal with China rejected by Victorian voters
>>10512833 Alleged Adelaide paedophile Jadd William Brooker intends to infect children and adults with HIV, court told
>>10512938, >>10512953, >>10512966 Australian special forces Instagram account mocks war crime allegations, calls to 'Make Diggers Violent Again'
>>10513223 Pacific Air Forces Tweet: BREAKING: US & Australian militaries demonstrate rapid long-distance air strike capabilities #B2 Spirits
>>10524154 Cyber attacks on Australia blurring the lines between peace and war, Defence Minister says
>>10524154 PDF: Inaugural ACSC Annual Cyber Threat Report: July 2019 to June 2020
>>10524698 'I will fight to the end': Australian writer Yang Hengjun's message from behind bars in China
>>10524749 Video: Ambassador Culvahouse Commemorates the 75th Anniversary of the End of World War II - US Embassy Canberra
>>10533827 Federal liberal MPs push for investigation into South Australian MP Jing Lee over alleged China links
>>10534202 Q Research General #13481: Aussies Fight Back! Edition - https://8kun.top/qresearch/res/10533922.html
>>10539776 Video: Pedos Down Under Radio Episode #4 with Laurence
>>10539782 Video: VIP Abuse Ring - Australian Survivor Speaks #2 - "This content is not available on this country domain due to a defamation complaint."
>>10540210 Video: Sacha Stone - Message to all Australians
>>10543689 Marine Rotational Force - Darwin Tweet: #Marines and #YourADF are able to work together in any environment, day or night
>>10544589 Foetal cells are used to make the Oxford coronavirus vaccine. But they came from a foetus in 1973
>>10553877 ACCC stand against Facebook and Google backed by international media
>>10554450 Defence Minister Linda Reynolds Tweet: Looking forward to meeting personnel from #YourADF and @USMC with US Ambassador to Australia, Arthur Culvahouse Jr
>>10559397 Video: The Truth goes Mainstream as the boot clamps down (Beast System Reveals itself)
>>10562981 Man attacking the Police during the Melbourne protests. Agent Provocateur?
>>10563323, >>10563337 Parents warned about shocking suicide video on TikTok that may be hidden in other content
>>10563752, >>10563761 OPINION: Kevin Rudd - Scott Morrison is yearning for a Donald Trump victory
>>10563843, >>10563846, >>10563852 Australian correspondents Bill Birtles and Mike Smith pulled out of China after five-day diplomatic standoff over national security case
>>10564187 Marine Rotational Force - Darwin Tweet: Low light live fires train #Marines to be #ready to execute, even in the dark. #MRFD #freeandopenindopacific
>>10567685 Queensland passes law to jail priests for not reporting confessions of child sexual abuse
>>10574893 Scott Morrison issues stark warning to TikTok over suicide video
>>10574945 Prime Minister Scott Morrison Facebook Post - Keeping kids safe online - The laws and standards of behaviour from the real world must also apply online
>>10574945 Video: Prime Minister Scott Morrison - No child should be exposed to horrifying content like the video which has been circulating on TikTok
>>10575446 Man in custody after incident near ASIO building
>>10575494 Paedophile crackdown will see sick perverts jailed for 20 YEARS for owning a child sex doll
#10704939 at 2020-09-19 05:21:36 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #9 - Welcome to the Digital Battlefield Edition
#9 - Part 11
>>10491577 'We don't respond to coercion': Frydenberg rejects Facebook news boycott threat
>>10491684 Prominent Australian TV anchor Cheng Lei detained in China 'without charge'
>>10491693 Detained Australian journalist Cheng Lei authored Facebook posts about Wuhan coronavirus cover-up
>>10491722 AFP consider Ben Roberts-Smith a suspect in war crimes, court told
>>10495009 Australia risks backsliding into a poor country in Asia Pacific - globaltimes.cn
>>10498841 Who is Q FAQ - https://qanon.news/Archives/x/10472611#10472992
>>10501740 José Ramos-Horta urges Australia to drop Witness K and Bernard Collaery prosecution
>>10501793 Australia in the US Tweet: #OTD in 1951, (Australia, New Zealand and the United States) signed the #ANZUS mutual defense treaty
>>10501813 Pacific Marines Tweet: After fighting together in World War II, the U.S. remains committed to our mutual defense treaty with #Australia
>>10506023 Q Post #4629 - CORRUPT. CONTROLLED. ENEMIES OF THE REPUBLIC.
>>10506023 Q Post #4634 - Why did it take a political outsider to [finally] confront China?
>>10508278 Daniel Andrews' Belt and Road deal with China rejected by Victorian voters
>>10512833 Alleged Adelaide paedophile Jadd William Brooker intends to infect children and adults with HIV, court told
>>10512938, >>10512953, >>10512966 Australian special forces Instagram account mocks war crime allegations, calls to 'Make Diggers Violent Again'
>>10513223 Pacific Air Forces Tweet: BREAKING: US & Australian militaries demonstrate rapid long-distance air strike capabilities #B2 Spirits
>>10524154 Cyber attacks on Australia blurring the lines between peace and war, Defence Minister says
>>10524154 PDF: Inaugural ACSC Annual Cyber Threat Report: July 2019 to June 2020
>>10524698 'I will fight to the end': Australian writer Yang Hengjun's message from behind bars in China
>>10524749 Video: Ambassador Culvahouse Commemorates the 75th Anniversary of the End of World War II - US Embassy Canberra
>>10533827 Federal liberal MPs push for investigation into South Australian MP Jing Lee over alleged China links
>>10534202 Q Research General #13481: Aussies Fight Back! Edition - https://8kun.top/qresearch/res/10533922.html
>>10539776 Video: Pedos Down Under Radio Episode #4 with Laurence
>>10539782 Video: VIP Abuse Ring - Australian Survivor Speaks #2 - "This content is not available on this country domain due to a defamation complaint."
>>10540210 Video: Sacha Stone - Message to all Australians
>>10543689 Marine Rotational Force - Darwin Tweet: #Marines and #YourADF are able to work together in any environment, day or night
>>10544589 Foetal cells are used to make the Oxford coronavirus vaccine. But they came from a foetus in 1973
>>10553877 ACCC stand against Facebook and Google backed by international media
>>10554450 Defence Minister Linda Reynolds Tweet: Looking forward to meeting personnel from #YourADF and @USMC with US Ambassador to Australia, Arthur Culvahouse Jr
>>10559397 Video: The Truth goes Mainstream as the boot clamps down (Beast System Reveals itself)
>>10562981 Man attacking the Police during the Melbourne protests. Agent Provocateur?
>>10563323, >>10563337 Parents warned about shocking suicide video on TikTok that may be hidden in other content
>>10563752, >>10563761 OPINION: Kevin Rudd - Scott Morrison is yearning for a Donald Trump victory
>>10563843, >>10563846, >>10563852 Australian correspondents Bill Birtles and Mike Smith pulled out of China after five-day diplomatic standoff over national security case
>>10564187 Marine Rotational Force - Darwin Tweet: Low light live fires train #Marines to be #ready to execute, even in the dark. #MRFD #freeandopenindopacific
>>10567685 Queensland passes law to jail priests for not reporting confessions of child sexual abuse
>>10574893 Scott Morrison issues stark warning to TikTok over suicide video
>>10574945 Prime Minister Scott Morrison Facebook Post - Keeping kids safe online - The laws and standards of behaviour from the real world must also apply online
>>10574945 Video: Prime Minister Scott Morrison - No child should be exposed to horrifying content like the video which has been circulating on TikTok
>>10575446 Man in custody after incident near ASIO building
>>10575494 Paedophile crackdown will see sick perverts jailed for 20 YEARS for owning a child sex doll
#10491722 at 2020-09-01 08:37:37 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #9 - Welcome to the Digital Battlefield Edition
>>10315185
>>10209217
AFP consider Ben Roberts-Smith a suspect in war crimes, court told
Australian Federal Police have confirmed that they obtained eyewitness accounts implicating Ben Roberts-Smith in war crimes while he was an Australian soldier serving in Afghanistan, the Federal Court has heard.
Extensive media reporting has linked Mr Roberts-Smith to allegations he was directly involved in the death of farmer Ali Jan, an Afghan man who was allegedly kicked off a cliff while handcuffed and then shot dead in the village of Darwan in September 2012.
But barrister Sandy Dawson, SC, representing the news outlets being sued for defamation by Mr Roberts-Smith, on Tuesday revealed for the first time that the AFP had independently obtained witness statements from past and current Australian Defence Force members who contradicted the Victoria Cross recipient's position that Mr Jan's death was a legitimate act in war.
The AFP wrote to Mr Roberts-Smith through his lawyers last December telling him that it had obtained "contemporaneous" reporting from the ADF and had also conducted its own inquiries. The police investigation began in mid-2018 following a referral from the then chief of defence force Mark Binskin, Mr Dawson said.
He said the AFP considers Mr Roberts-Smith a suspect in the war crimes offences of cruel treatment and murder.
Mr Dawson said Mr Roberts-Smith "is a suspect in that investigation into war crimes", and the AFP had interviewed Mr Roberts-Smith about Mr Jan's death.
The revelations came during calls for the release of confidential documents that outline the extent of Mr Roberts-Smith's participation in an inquiry by the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force into claims of misconduct by Australian soldiers in Afghanistan between 2005 and 2016.
Mr Roberts-Smith, a former Special Air Service soldier, is suing The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald over reports he allegedly committed murder on deployments to Afghanistan. He denies the allegations and says the reports are defamatory because they portray him as a war criminal.
The media outlets are defending the claim. They allege Mr Roberts-Smith was involved in six unlawful deaths as an Australian soldier on deployments to Afghanistan. Besides Mr Jan's death, the newspapers also allege Mr Roberts-Smith ordered junior soldiers in his command to kill unarmed and detained Afghan men.
The defamation trial is set to be held next year.
Lawyers for The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald have called for the release of documents including a notice from the IGADF to Mr Roberts-Smith that he is a "potentially affected person (PAP)". A PAP notice allows a recipient to respond to the Inspector-General's findings before they are released.
But lawyers for the ADF are resisting those calls and argue they are immune from public interest. Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyers also oppose the release of the documents to the news outlets.
Barrister Anna Mitchelmore, SC, acting for the Commonwealth, said the release of the documents would potentially undermine the integrity of the inquiry led by Major-General Paul Brereton, who since 2016 has been investigating allegations of misconduct by Australian soldiers in Afghanistan.
The inquiry was still gathering information and evidence, Ms Mitchelmore said, and the release of confidential documents had the potential to dissuade people from co-operating.
Major-General Brereton's inquiry was held in private and evidence kept confidential so participants could be confident in telling the truth, she said, and so they could speak "with frankness and candour" about incidents "that they may have otherwise kept to themselves".
Lawyers for the news outlets do not know if Mr Roberts-Smith has been issued with a PAP notice, and Ms Mitchelmore said she would neither confirm nor deny whether one had been issued to the former soldier. Mr Dawson said it would be surprising if Mr Roberts-Smith had not been served with one.
Mr Dawson said his clients did not want to imperil Major-General Brereton's inquiry given it had involved hundreds of witnesses and uncovered matters of significance that would warrant the action of law-enforcement agencies.
The documents were sought, he said, so the newspapers could fairly defend themselves during the defamation trial as there was a "legitimate forensic purpose" in having them handed over. If disclosed, the documents were not to be published and would be restricted only to lawyers for the news outlets and the two journalists who wrote the stories.
The court heard that although Major-General Brereton's inquiry was being conducted in private, it was expected the findings would be made public.
Justice Craig Colvin reserved his decision on the release of the documents.
https://www.theage.com.au/national/afp-consider-Ben-Roberts-Smith-a-suspect-in-war-crimes-court-told-20200901-p55rdk.html
#10315198 at 2020-08-17 06:21:46 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #9 - Welcome to the Digital Battlefield Edition
>>10315193
3/3
Mr Keelty said that prior to meeting Mr Roberts-Smith, he had told then-commissioner Andrew Colvin that, "I was asked to reach out to BRS [Ben Roberts-Smith] who was in 'a world of hurt' following public allegations that he was involved in potential improper conduct while deployed overseas."
Mr Keelty claimed that "Colvin agreed to the approach and made no reference to current investigations only to say there is 'stuff running around' and that he, Colvin was not in a position to approach BRS". Mr Colvin declined to comment other than stating the case had been referred to the corruption watchdog.
ACLEI confirmed in a statement that the AFP had notified it on June 21, 2018, of allegations that Mr Roberts-Smith had been told sensitive information about the federal police's interest in him. ACLEI said that a week later, on June 27 that year, former Integrity Commissioner Michael Griffin launched a joint covert investigation with the AFP into the alleged leak.
"An eminent Australian"
Asked why Mr Keelty gave welfare support to a person he didn't know and who might be under potential investigation by the policing agency he once led, Mr Keelty said: "You are viewing him [Roberts-Smith] as a [an alleged] war criminal. At the times we met, I was viewing him as an eminent Australian who had been publicly vilified. I was not concerning myself with anything other than welfare."
Referrals to police must be handled secretly to allow proper evidence collection and ensure the safety of complainants.
The AFP war crimes inquiries gathered evidence, including from eyewitnesses, that led to the AFP submitting a brief of evidence against Mr Roberts-Smith earlier this year. The brief alleges Mr Roberts-Smith is involved in the execution of prisoner Ali Jan in September 2012.
There is no suggestion Mr Roberts-Smith did anything wrong in meeting Mr Keelty. He has denied any involvement in war crimes or assaulting a woman and is suing this masthead for reporting the allegations. The Age and Herald are also not suggesting Mr Keelty acted with intent to compromise the AFP inquiry.
Mr Keelty said that he had advised Mr Roberts-Smith "about the AFP process that a referral is not a guarantee of an investigation". Mr Keelty said that while he was told by AFP officers of the three Roberts-Smith referrals, he was not told if they were still in the assessment phase or had progressed to full-blown inquiries.
"No one [from the AFP] ever confirmed to me at any time that the AFP converted those referrals to an investigation of BRS," Mr Keelty said.
"I considered it appropriate to contact the AFP about BRS to ensure that I was not crossing over any current operations by meeting with him. It was solely to de-conflict - it was never to advise BRS anything that you would not tell any person in a similar situation who was complaining that he was being prosecuted in the media but had not yet been spoken to by anyone from either Defence or the AFP."
Multiple sources said that Mr Keelty had fallen out with former commissioner Mr Colvin, ACLEI and serving senior AFP officers over the saga. In his statement, Mr Keelty said: "These matters could have been dealt with very easily at the start by someone [from the AFP] saying to me: 'I think you're going to be too busy to see BRS.' Nothing more needed to be said."
https://www.smh.com.au/national/covert-war-crimes-inquiry-compromised-by-former-afp-chief-mick-keelty-20200812-p55kzj.html
#10315185 at 2020-08-17 06:19:09 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #9 - Welcome to the Digital Battlefield Edition
>>10209217
Covert war crimes inquiry compromised by former AFP chief Mick Keelty
1/3
The Australian Federal Police's war crimes investigation into former special forces soldier Ben Roberts-Smith was compromised after former AFP chief Mick Keelty was told secret details by serving police and then passed them on to Mr Roberts-Smith.
Mr Keelty passed on confidential information to Mr Roberts-Smith just days after the AFP had launched what were supposed to be covert inquiries into the Afghan veteran and Victoria Cross recipient in early June 2018. Mr Keelty's information confirmed to Mr Roberts-Smith that he was the subject of police interest according to official sources familiar with the matter speaking on the condition of anonymity.
The police watchdog, the Australian Commission for Law Enforcement Integrity, has confirmed Mr Keelty's actions have resulted in an inquiry into "a potential corruption issue relating to the alleged release of information by an unknown AFP member to Mr Ben Roberts-Smith about an investigation into Mr Roberts-Smith".
Sources with knowledge of the events say Mr Keelty's intervention allowed Mr Roberts-Smith to take precautions against police inquiries at a time when he should not have known he was under scrutiny. The disclosures meant the covert phase of a war crimes inquiry - one of the most sensitive probes in AFP history - was blown only days after it started.
In a written statement to The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald, Mr Keelty defended his actions, stressing he had only ever acted out of concern for Mr Roberts-Smith's welfare. Mr Keelty said he did not know the former soldier when he met him twice to give him welfare support in June 2018.
ACLEI said its inquiry "has not uncovered admissible evidence against any person within ACLEI's jurisdiction" but that it would examine any further information "that would support further action in relation to the allegation". Mr Keelty is not within the ACLEI's jurisdiction because he left the AFP in 2009 and ACLEI only has power to investigate allegations of corrupt conduct by serving AFP members. There is no suggestion Mr Keelty has engaged in corruption, only that his disclosures compromised a covert inquiry.
The ACLEI inquiry into serving police suspected of giving information to Mr Keelty led it to target former deputy commissioner Ramzi Jabbour who was suspended in March 2019 and then resigned months later over other alleged misconduct.
Mr Jabbour was charged over claims he misused his service weapon. He denies the claims and his court case will conclude in the ACT Magistrates Court next year. In late 2019, Mr Keelty appointed Mr Jabbour to a government integrity role, reporting to Mr Keelty in his capacity as Australia's water resources watchdog.
The inquiry into Mr Keelty's disclosures also meant he was under ACLEI scrutiny when he was appointed in December 2018 to a three-person panel by the federal government to advise it on whether ACLEI should be expanded into a new national integrity body with broader jurisdiction. Multiple sources close to Mr Keelty say he is furious at ACLEI and the AFP's handling of the disclosure issue.
(continued)
#10250953 at 2020-08-11 09:45:42 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #9 - Welcome to the Digital Battlefield Edition
>>10250950
2/2
Defence told The Australian that Professor Frame would begin interviewing serving special forces personnel and veterans after the IGADF's findings were handed down.
The study was independent of the IGADF inquiry and would not be a historical record, the department said.
"Professor Frame's work will aim to provide an understanding of Australia's special forces, including consideration of the ethical standards and command culture of Special Operations Command and its people on operations from 1999 until the present day, with a focus on service in Afghanistan," Defence said.
"It is expected the publication will be used as an academic reference to guide our leaders in the years ahead and contribute to professional development of the ADF today and in the future."
Former Nationals leader John Anderson, a personal friend of Professor Frame, said he believed the study would be a "deeply considered and very honest" assessment of what went wrong.
"He will quite clinically analyse the realities of what has happened, and he will do so in the context of somebody who has a very sharp understanding of right and wrong," he said.
Defence Minister Linda Reynolds warned last week that the nation needed to prepare itself for the Brereton inquiry's findings, saying the report would make for some "uncomfortable" reading.
"I think that will make some very significant findings, ones that I am certain will make many Australians uncomfortable, and also dismayed at," she said.
In its annual report to parliament, the IGADF said 338 witnesses had been interviewed by the Brereton inquiry up until July 2019.
It said the alleged breaches of the Law of Armed Conflict being examined were "predominantly unlawful killings of persons who were non-combatants or were no longer combatants, but also 'cruel treatment' of such persons".
The inquiry was not focused on decisions made in the "heat of battle" but on "the treatment of persons who were clearly non-combatants or ... no longer combatants", the IGADF said.
Australia's most decorated soldier, Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith, is among those caught in the investigation.
He has been publicly accused of committing war crimes while serving with the SAS in Afghanistan - allegations he has denied, claiming his anonymous accusers were motivated by professional jealousy and personal vendettas.
He is suing Nine Entertainment over those allegations he says are false.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/defence/defence-to-probe-special-forces-cultural-and-leadership-flaws/news-story/19e46a7f170e487266bfe53db0521479
#10209217 at 2020-08-07 08:09:11 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #9 - Welcome to the Digital Battlefield Edition
>>10208990
War crimes report will make uncomfortable reading, says Linda Reynolds
Defence Minister Linda Reynolds has warned the nation needs to prepare itself for the findings of an upcoming report on dozens of alleged war crimes by Australian special forces in Afghanistan, saying it will make for "uncomfortable" reading.
Senator Reynolds said the inquiry led by NSW Supreme Court judge, Major General Paul Brereton, would soon be completed.
While she had not read Justice Brereton's findings, she warned they would be confronting.
"I think that will make some very significant findings, ones that I am certain will make many Australians uncomfortable, and also dismayed at," she said.
"So I think we do need to prepare ourselves for that."
Her comments to an Australian Strategic Policy Institute webinar on Friday follow the appointment of a non-SAS commander to lead the nation's special forces for the first time.
Major General Paul Kenny, a Commando officer who is currently the acting head of the ADF's COVID-19 taskforce, will become the next Special Operations Commander for Australia, with a brief to continue wide-ranging cultural reforms.
He will take over from Major General Adam Findlay, who led Australia's special forces since 2017, amid ongoing fallout over alleged breaches of the laws of war being examined by Justice Brereton.
Senator Reynolds said the army and its special forces regiments had already been doing "a significant amount of self reflection on how some of these reported circumstances could have happened, and what needs to happen structurally and culturally to make sure that these events do not happen again".
"I would stress that I do not for a second think that those issues that will be reported on ... (reflect) on our current serving men and women, both here and overseas, who are doing an extraordinary job for our nation.
"There clearly has been a problem and we wait now to see the outcome of Justice Brereton's report, and CDF will speak more publicly about that after the release of the report."
The Special Operations Command has been responsible since 2003 for the secretive SAS regiment, based in Western Australia, and the Commando regiment, based in NSW.
Justice Brereton's inquiry, conducted for the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force, is examining at least 55 potential instances of unlawful conduct, the military watchdog has revealed in February.
In its annual report to parliament, the IGADF said 338 witnesses had been interviewed by the Brereton Inquiry up until July 2019.
It said the alleged breaches of the Law of Armed Conflict being examined were "predominantly unlawful killings of persons who were non-combatants or were no longer combatants, but also 'cruel treatment' of such persons".
The inquiry was not focused on decisions made in the "heat of battle", but on "the treatment of persons who were clearly non-combatants or who were no longer combatants", the IGADF said.
Australia's most decorated soldier, Victoria Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith, is among those caught in the investigation.
He has been publicly accused of committing war crimes while serving with the SAS in Afghanistan - allegations he has denied, claiming his anonymous accusers were motivated by professional jealousy and personal vendettas.
He is suing Nine Entertainment over those allegations he says are false.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/defence/war-crimes-report-will-make-uncomfortable-reading-says-linda-reynolds/news-story/d4fccaa8ed3d182f3dd50a56a3291589
#10099686 at 2020-07-28 09:51:42 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #9 - Welcome to the Digital Battlefield Edition
Notables
are not endorsements
#8 - Part 1
>>9062596 Child Abuse Royal Commission's key findings on Cardinal George Pell
>>9076396 Cardinal Pell pushes back on royal commission report
>>9076459 STATEMENT FROM CARDINAL GEORGE PELL
>>9076459 STATEMENT from Most Rev Peter A Comensoli, Archbishop of Melbourne
>>9076496 Cardinal George Pell: Victoria police to assess unredacted royal commission findings
>>9077042 Three children rescued in the Philippines after tip-off from Australian authorities
>>9077240 US Embassy Canberra Tweet: This week we pause to remember the Battle of #CoralSea, when U.S. and Australian forces fought together
>>9077240 US Embassy Canberra Tweet: Privileged to interview @Australian_Navy veteran Gordon Johnson (dec.) on his experience at the Battle of #CoralSea
>>9106746 Video: WWG1WGA at the Melbourne Freedom Rally
>>9106795 #QAnon trending on Twitter in Australia - 6:20 pm Sunday, 10 May 2020 (AEST)
>>9118857 #ObamaGate trending on Twitter in Australia - 3:00 pm, Monday, 11 May 2020 (AEST)
>>9119058 Ten arrested and police officer injured at protest against Victoria's Covid-19 lockdown laws
>>9120100 "The Pyramid" - public art works sculpture, Forbes, New South Wales - Naked Rabbitwoman and Dogman symbolism
>>9120100 Gillie and Marc - Australian collaborative artist couple, known for human-animal hybrid and abstract sculptures
>>9120100 Gillie and Marc sculptures - 'Deerman with coffee' and 'Deerman thought a pear a day would help him play'
>>9127356 #ObamaGate / #obamagate trending on Twitter in Australia - 6:20 am, Tuesday, 12 May 2020 (AEST)
>>9136594 Celebrity Chef Pete Evans Is Sharing QAnon Conspiracy Theory Posts On Instagram After Losing His Job
>>9137174 Clergy abuse survivor draws support for petition to defrock Pell
>>9137174 Defrock Cardinal George Pell - Paul Levey started this petition to Pope Francis, Arch Bishop Peter Comesoli and Bishop Paul Bird
>>9137335 Three men charged, four children removed from harm after AFP investigation into child exploitation network
>>9137427 Sydney man jailed for online exploitation and extortion of children
>>9137447 Statement from father of victim of online child exploitation
>>9152032 New powers for ASIO to question 14-year-olds and go after foreign spies
>>9152389 Video: Elon Musk's prediction for the future of energy in Australia
>>9166350 More jail time means Gerald Ridsdale is 'likely to die in custody'
>>9181529 Alexander Downer may face scrutiny in US probe
>>9181688 Westpac failed to properly monitor 12 suspicious customers in AUSTRAC case
>>9197754 Five Eyes governments legal challenge to Facebook's 'dangerous' encryption of messages between terrorists, paedophiles and criminals
>>9198211 Multi-millionaire Sir Ron Brierley to plead on child porn charges, court hears
>>9198276 Catholic brother nicknamed 'The Rat' jailed for sex abuse of four Traralgon schoolboys
>>9198418 NICOLE KIDMAN "INJURED" AND WEARING A MCSTAIN-STYLE AIRCAST
>>9209294 Australian Federal Police tip-off leads to rescue of child sex slaves
>>9221671 Q Post #4277 - https://twitter.com/EYEDROPMEDIA/status/1262146618419183616 - WWG1WGA!!!
>>9221671 EYE DROP MEDIA Tweet - It's BIGGER than anyone can imagine!
>>9221671 June Lorraine Lee Tweet: They never thought that she would lose - Now they all LOSE
>>9235671 House Judiciary GOP Tweet: @Jim_Jordan & @RepMikeJohnson invite Bill Priestap and Joe Pientka to appear before the Judiciary Committee
>>9235831 Former soldier to prosecute cases of alleged war crimes by Australian special forces in Afghanistan
>>9235839 Top Sydney barrister to oversee war crimes probe against Ben Roberts-Smith
>>9235966 US Embassy Canberra Tweet: 78th anniversary of the Battle of the #CoralSea…shared history and values that drive our Unbreakable Alliance
>>9236096 Mark @awakeinaus_ Tweet: Katherine Keating has links to Epstein, Maxwell, Rachel Chandler, Balasz, Standard Hotel, Soros, Prince Andrew…
#10099609 at 2020-07-28 09:25:17 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #8 - WE ARE THE CURE Edition
Notables
are not endorsements
#8 - Part 1
>>9062596 Child Abuse Royal Commission's key findings on Cardinal George Pell
>>9076396 Cardinal Pell pushes back on royal commission report
>>9076459 STATEMENT FROM CARDINAL GEORGE PELL
>>9076459 STATEMENT from Most Rev Peter A Comensoli, Archbishop of Melbourne
>>9076496 Cardinal George Pell: Victoria police to assess unredacted royal commission findings
>>9077042 Three children rescued in the Philippines after tip-off from Australian authorities
>>9077240 US Embassy Canberra Tweet: This week we pause to remember the Battle of #CoralSea, when U.S. and Australian forces fought together
>>9077240 US Embassy Canberra Tweet: Privileged to interview @Australian_Navy veteran Gordon Johnson (dec.) on his experience at the Battle of #CoralSea
>>9106746 Video: WWG1WGA at the Melbourne Freedom Rally
>>9106795 #QAnon trending on Twitter in Australia - 6:20 pm Sunday, 10 May 2020 (AEST)
>>9118857 #ObamaGate trending on Twitter in Australia - 3:00 pm, Monday, 11 May 2020 (AEST)
>>9119058 Ten arrested and police officer injured at protest against Victoria's Covid-19 lockdown laws
>>9120100 "The Pyramid" - public art works sculpture, Forbes, New South Wales - Naked Rabbitwoman and Dogman symbolism
>>9120100 Gillie and Marc - Australian collaborative artist couple, known for human-animal hybrid and abstract sculptures
>>9120100 Gillie and Marc sculptures - 'Deerman with coffee' and 'Deerman thought a pear a day would help him play'
>>9127356 #ObamaGate / #obamagate trending on Twitter in Australia - 6:20 am, Tuesday, 12 May 2020 (AEST)
>>9136594 Celebrity Chef Pete Evans Is Sharing QAnon Conspiracy Theory Posts On Instagram After Losing His Job
>>9137174 Clergy abuse survivor draws support for petition to defrock Pell
>>9137174 Defrock Cardinal George Pell - Paul Levey started this petition to Pope Francis, Arch Bishop Peter Comesoli and Bishop Paul Bird
>>9137335 Three men charged, four children removed from harm after AFP investigation into child exploitation network
>>9137427 Sydney man jailed for online exploitation and extortion of children
>>9137447 Statement from father of victim of online child exploitation
>>9152032 New powers for ASIO to question 14-year-olds and go after foreign spies
>>9152389 Video: Elon Musk's prediction for the future of energy in Australia
>>9166350 More jail time means Gerald Ridsdale is 'likely to die in custody'
>>9181529 Alexander Downer may face scrutiny in US probe
>>9181688 Westpac failed to properly monitor 12 suspicious customers in AUSTRAC case
>>9197754 Five Eyes governments legal challenge to Facebook's 'dangerous' encryption of messages between terrorists, paedophiles and criminals
>>9198211 Multi-millionaire Sir Ron Brierley to plead on child porn charges, court hears
>>9198276 Catholic brother nicknamed 'The Rat' jailed for sex abuse of four Traralgon schoolboys
>>9198418 NICOLE KIDMAN "INJURED" AND WEARING A MCSTAIN-STYLE AIRCAST
>>9209294 Australian Federal Police tip-off leads to rescue of child sex slaves
>>9221671 Q Post #4277 - https://twitter.com/EYEDROPMEDIA/status/1262146618419183616 - WWG1WGA!!!
>>9221671 EYE DROP MEDIA Tweet - It's BIGGER than anyone can imagine!
>>9221671 June Lorraine Lee Tweet: They never thought that she would lose - Now they all LOSE
>>9235671 House Judiciary GOP Tweet: @Jim_Jordan & @RepMikeJohnson invite Bill Priestap and Joe Pientka to appear before the Judiciary Committee
>>9235831 Former soldier to prosecute cases of alleged war crimes by Australian special forces in Afghanistan
>>9235839 Top Sydney barrister to oversee war crimes probe against Ben Roberts-Smith
>>9235966 US Embassy Canberra Tweet: 78th anniversary of the Battle of the #CoralSea…shared history and values that drive our Unbreakable Alliance
>>9236096 Mark @awakeinaus_ Tweet: Katherine Keating has links to Epstein, Maxwell, Rachel Chandler, Balasz, Standard Hotel, Soros, Prince Andrew…
#9374890 at 2020-05-30 09:13:12 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #8 - WE ARE THE CURE Edition
>>9296102
>Australian prosecutors have charged "Witness K", a former senior intelligence officer, and his lawyer Bernard Collaery - a former attorney-general for the Australian Capital Territory - with revealing state secrets.
>They allege the two men broke the law by revealing that Alexander Downer, a former Australian foreign minister, ordered the bugging of East Timor's Cabinet Office in 2004 in a move that Benefited an Australian resources company, Woodside, to the detriment of East Timor.
1/2
'I am unable to say much': anger simmers as Timor bugging hearing goes ahead in secret
High-powered witnesses have testified in the prosecution of Witness K's lawyer, Bernard Collaery, but what they said may never be known
On Wednesday, in Canberra's labyrinthine new court complex, a procession of remarkable power made its way past the guards stationed outside Bernard Collaery's hearing.
Intelligence leaders, diplomats and former ministers lingered briefly in the waiting area of the oddly quiet ACT supreme court, before entering a room where journalists could not follow.
What was said may never be known.
Collaery stands accused of sharing protected intelligence information by helping his client, the former spy Witness K, expose Australia's bugging of Timor-Leste government offices in 2004, while the two allies were negotiating to carve up lucrative oil and gas reserves in the Timor Sea.
The barrister cannot speak about the case. But he remains unbowed.
"Our profession will not be cowed into ignoring those with a genuine grievance," Collaery told the Guardian. "My colleagues and I shall continue to represent those who expose impropriety even at a cost to our own selves."
Anthony Whealy, a former judge who has presided over NSW's highest courts, has followed the case closely through its various twists and turns.
He, like the former leaders of Timor-Leste, sees Collaery as a hero, not a criminal.
"I think Collaery must be seen as somebody who's done something quite heroic in the public interest, rather than someone who has committed an offence and is facing trial and a possible jail sentence," he said. "That in itself places Australia in a position where its reputation would be very poorly received internationally."
A lawyer on trial, national security and secret hearings
On Monday, reporters, including from the ABC and the Canberra Times, gathered in the public gallery for the start of Collaery's pre-trial hearing.
The hearing is designed, largely, to work out what evidence can be heard publicly. Reporters were, initially at least, asked to hand over their mobile phones before entering.
Then, after a short explanation, they were booted out of the courtroom.
As they left, Collaery handed them a statement.
"I am unable to say much and you are unable to report much. This is the state of our now fragile democracy," it read.
Justice David Mossop, a well-respected judge sworn in three years ago, has spent the time since hearing evidence in closed court.
He has little choice.
The commonwealth has intervened in the matter by invoking powers in the National Security Information Act, which strictly govern how sensitive information is handled by the courts.
Those powers have caused controversy in a string of cases in recent years.
In fact, as the Collaery case was heard on Wednesday, the same powers were being used to prevent the public airing of evidence in a defamation case brought by special forces veteran Ben Roberts-Smith, which is canvassing disputed allegations of war crimes by Australian troops in Afghanistan.
Two years earlier, the commonwealth powers were used to prosecute and jail a former military intelligence officer, Witness J, through the ACT's courts in extraordinary secrecy. Not even the ACT's justice minister knew of the proceedings.
The powers are designed to stop sensitive information finding its way into the wrong hands. The identities of intelligence officers, for example, or information about military tactics and capabilities.
There is little dispute that such material must be guarded closely, absent compelling public interest otherwise.
But critics say the NSI Act is not striking the right balance between principles of open justice, press freedom, and national security.
The powers are being closely monitored by the Law Council of Australia, among others.
(continued)
#9235839 at 2020-05-19 09:24:45 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #8 - WE ARE THE CURE Edition
>>9235831
Top Sydney barrister to oversee war crimes probe against Ben Roberts-Smith
The Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions has appointed top Sydney barrister David McLure SC to lead efforts to prosecute decorated Afghan veteran Ben Roberts-Smith for alleged war crimes.
The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald has confirmed Mr McLure, a former legal officer attached to the special forces turned rising star of the Sydney bar, was appointed recently by the CDPP to handle one of the most sensitive cases in its history.
Mr Roberts-Smith, Australia's most decorated Afghan veteran, has been referred by the federal police to the CDPP to face possible charges for alleged war crimes.
The CDPP may advise there is insufficient evidence to prosecute or ask police to find more witnesses to strengthen a case, while in the case of war crimes federal Attorney-General Christian Porter will also need to approve any possible prosecution.
Mr McLure was the defence barrister in the bungled prosecution against two Australian commandos who had been charged with manslaughter in Afghanistan in 2011. The charges were thrown out by a military judge.
He has previously worked on some of the Australian Federal Police and Australian Tax Office's highest-profile cases, and was last year appointed to lead an inquiry into corruption claims surrounding Crown Resorts' international high-roller program.
The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald confirmed earlier this month a brief of evidence has been submitted by federal agents to prosecutors outlining allegations Mr Roberts-Smith kicked a defenceless prisoner off a cliff and covered up his subsequent murder during a special forces mission in Afghanistan in September 2012.
Multiple special forces sources have also confirmed more of Mr Roberts-Smith's fellow SAS soldiers have come forward to allege he was involved in other serious war crimes during his various tours of Afghanistan.
The alleged murders have been reported to a military inspector general inquiry or the federal police, according to special forces personnel who are aware of the allegations, and the allegations are in addition to the cliff kicking allegations referred to the CDPP.
The Age and Herald are not suggesting Mr Roberts-Smith has been found guilty of any war crime, only that he is the target of police probes - and the subject of a brief of evidence handed to prosecutors - as a result of allegations made by his SAS colleagues.
Asked for comment on the appointment of Mr McLure, the CDPP said it would be "inappropriate for the CDPP to comment on matters which remain the subject of an ongoing investigation".
https://www.theage.com.au/politics/federal/top-sydney-barrister-to-oversee-war-crimes-probe-against-Ben-Roberts-Smith-20200518-p54u49.html
#9062520 at 2020-05-07 09:27:56 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #8 - WE ARE THE CURE Edition
#7 - Part 11
>>8398280 Australian Signals Directorate - Leadership - Principal Deputy Director-General Lieutenant General John Frewen DSC AM
>>8398369 Judge Napolitano says Trump should veto FISA bill: Nothing but 'cosmetic' reforms
>>8398457 Parole denied for Hey Dad! sex predator Robert Hughes
>>8407234 Foreign Minister Marise Payne Tweet: A timely meeting with friend @SecPompeo to discuss #COVID19, infrastructure…
>>8408824 Peripatetic Katherine Keating pops up at Palm Beach
>>8419490 Defence Minister Linda Reynolds Tweet: Tackling orphanage trafficking needs us to work together in Australia & globally
>>8419490 Modern Day Slavery, Orphanage Tourism and the Modern Slavery Act 2018
>>8434230 Nicole Kidman and family 'relocating back to Australia to be closer to mother Janelle'
>>8434619 NSW south coast man charged with terrorism offences
>>8437036 Man arrested after allegedly planning terror attack on electrical substation
>>8438540 Fraser Anning declared bankrupt by courts on 'egging' anniversary
>>8459350 High Court overturns SA pedophile sentence
>>8459467 Video: Killing Field: Explosive new allegations of Australian special forces war crimes | Four Corners
>>8459498 Footage Shows Australian Special Forces Shoot And Kill Unarmed Man In Afghanistan
>>8459638 Wikileaks Tweet: Newly obtained video by ABC's @4corners shows alleged execution of unarmed Afghan by Australian SAS soldier
>>8468637 Australian "Hey Dad" Actor Robert Hughes - Timeline of allegations of sexual misconduct, arrest, and conviction
>>8472720 Ghislaine Maxwell, citing death threats and extensive legal fees, sues Jeffrey Epstein's estate
>>8486065 Evil 8 paedophile Alfred Impicciatore's appeal dismissed over notorious WA child abuse case
>>8486065 The horrors of the 'Evil 8' and how a young girl was preyed upon by her father, strangers (2017)
>>8486290 Defence Minister Linda Reynolds Media Releases - Statements on Four Corners report
>>8494961 Second NSW South Coast man charged with a terrorism offence
>>8528467 Third man charged following operational activity on the NSW South Coast
>>8542385 Q Post #3898 - The key that opens all doors. The 'Start'. (Links to this Daily Caller article >>8375168)
>>8543343 War hero Ben Roberts-Smith interviewed by police over alleged killing
>>8543613 Jill, @1Swinging_Voter Tweet: ABC smartarse Andrew Probyn hogging the press conference just got owned by the Prime Minister
>>8543613 Jill, @1Swinging_Voter Tweet: We need to see more of this from the Prime Minister!! Don't dance to the media tune!
>>8543613 Video: Prime Minister Scott Morrison to ABC journalist Andrew Probyn - "You don't run the Press Conference, OK?"
>>8543726 Australian Secret Intelligence Service - Black Ops Arm Of The Aus Deep State?
>>8557079 Malcolm Turnbull's wife Lucy suddenly stands down from her high-powered job 'for personal reasons'
>>8568249 Christchurch mosque attacker Brenton Tarrant changes plea to guilty, to be sentenced for 51 murders
>>8568301 Australian paedophile fights to stop police alerting Indonesia to convictions
>>8568600 Chinese government prepares to charge Australian academic
>>8569098 Video: Trump 'came to appreciate' Turnbull standing up for Australia
>>8569161 Q Posts #479, 908 and 910 - What phone call between POTUS and X/AUS leaked? Why that specific conversation? Focus - why AUS?
>>8569655 The Australian Store Where Everything Sold Is Sent to China
>>8569706 Chinese-backed company's mission to source Australian medical supplies
>>8582388 Australian police crack online child exploitation network
>>8582418 New South Wales woman charged with child exploitation offences
>>8587984 Man hands out $100 to every Person Waiting in Line for Welfare
>>8588025 Police identify 11 alleged victims in case of immigration agent accused of rape
#9062430 at 2020-05-07 08:53:21 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #7 - FIRE & FURY Edition
#7 - Part 11
>>8398280 Australian Signals Directorate - Leadership - Principal Deputy Director-General Lieutenant General John Frewen DSC AM
>>8398369 Judge Napolitano says Trump should veto FISA bill: Nothing but 'cosmetic' reforms
>>8398457 Parole denied for Hey Dad! sex predator Robert Hughes
>>8407234 Foreign Minister Marise Payne Tweet: A timely meeting with friend @SecPompeo to discuss #COVID19, infrastructure…
>>8408824 Peripatetic Katherine Keating pops up at Palm Beach
>>8419490 Defence Minister Linda Reynolds Tweet: Tackling orphanage trafficking needs us to work together in Australia & globally
>>8419490 Modern Day Slavery, Orphanage Tourism and the Modern Slavery Act 2018
>>8434230 Nicole Kidman and family 'relocating back to Australia to be closer to mother Janelle'
>>8434619 NSW south coast man charged with terrorism offences
>>8437036 Man arrested after allegedly planning terror attack on electrical substation
>>8438540 Fraser Anning declared bankrupt by courts on 'egging' anniversary
>>8459350 High Court overturns SA pedophile sentence
>>8459467 Video: Killing Field: Explosive new allegations of Australian special forces war crimes | Four Corners
>>8459498 Footage Shows Australian Special Forces Shoot And Kill Unarmed Man In Afghanistan
>>8459638 Wikileaks Tweet: Newly obtained video by ABC's @4corners shows alleged execution of unarmed Afghan by Australian SAS soldier
>>8468637 Australian "Hey Dad" Actor Robert Hughes - Timeline of allegations of sexual misconduct, arrest, and conviction
>>8472720 Ghislaine Maxwell, citing death threats and extensive legal fees, sues Jeffrey Epstein's estate
>>8486065 Evil 8 paedophile Alfred Impicciatore's appeal dismissed over notorious WA child abuse case
>>8486065 The horrors of the 'Evil 8' and how a young girl was preyed upon by her father, strangers (2017)
>>8486290 Defence Minister Linda Reynolds Media Releases - Statements on Four Corners report
>>8494961 Second NSW South Coast man charged with a terrorism offence
>>8528467 Third man charged following operational activity on the NSW South Coast
>>8542385 Q Post #3898 - The key that opens all doors. The 'Start'. (Links to this Daily Caller article >>8375168)
>>8543343 War hero Ben Roberts-Smith interviewed by police over alleged killing
>>8543613 Jill, @1Swinging_Voter Tweet: ABC smartarse Andrew Probyn hogging the press conference just got owned by the Prime Minister
>>8543613 Jill, @1Swinging_Voter Tweet: We need to see more of this from the Prime Minister!! Don't dance to the media tune!
>>8543613 Video: Prime Minister Scott Morrison to ABC journalist Andrew Probyn - "You don't run the Press Conference, OK?"
>>8543726 Australian Secret Intelligence Service - Black Ops Arm Of The Aus Deep State?
>>8557079 Malcolm Turnbull's wife Lucy suddenly stands down from her high-powered job 'for personal reasons'
>>8568249 Christchurch mosque attacker Brenton Tarrant changes plea to guilty, to be sentenced for 51 murders
>>8568301 Australian paedophile fights to stop police alerting Indonesia to convictions
>>8568600 Chinese government prepares to charge Australian academic
>>8569098 Video: Trump 'came to appreciate' Turnbull standing up for Australia
>>8569161 Q Posts #479, 908 and 910 - What phone call between POTUS and X/AUS leaked? Why that specific conversation? Focus - why AUS?
>>8569655 The Australian Store Where Everything Sold Is Sent to China
>>8569706 Chinese-backed company's mission to source Australian medical supplies
>>8582388 Australian police crack online child exploitation network
>>8582418 New South Wales woman charged with child exploitation offences
>>8587984 Man hands out $100 to every Person Waiting in Line for Welfare
>>8588025 Police identify 11 alleged victims in case of immigration agent accused of rape
#8543343 at 2020-03-24 06:38:24 (UTC+1)
Q Research AUSTRALIA #7 - FIRE & FURY Edition
>>8486290
War hero Ben Roberts-Smith interviewed by police over alleged killing
The Australian Federal Police has interviewed former SAS soldier Ben Roberts-Smith over allegations he kicked an Afghan prisoner off a cliff in a serious development in the long-running saga involving Australia's most decorated Afghan veteran.
Legal sources confirmed that the federal police recently requested Mr Roberts-Smith to attend a formal interview to respond to allegations made by special forces insiders that he kicked a detainee off a cliff in September 2012.
Sources with knowledge of the situation say the Victoria Cross recipient recently attended a police interview in Canberra and, as is standard practice, was cautioned that what he said could be used against him if he was ever criminally prosecuted. While the AFP does not comment on investigations, requesting to interview a subject normally comes near the end of an exhaustive probe and after critical witness statements have been collected.
About 90 minutes after Mr Roberts-Smith's lawyer, Mark O'Brien, was contacted by The Age and Herald for comment, The Australian's defence writer Paul Maley quoted Mr Roberts-Smith confirming the police interview had taken place, and claiming he had volunteered for it.
In September, The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald revealed that an AFP taskforce was investigating Mr Roberts-Smith over allegations he kicked a handcuffed and innocent detainee, Ali Jan, off a cliff in the village of Darwan in September 2012. The Darwan taskforce has obtained co-operation from SAS witnesses and support staff willing to testify on oath against the decorated soldier. A second police investigation is looking into allegations Mr Roberts-Smith is implicated in the summary execution of a man at a compound in southern Afghanistan in April 2009.
The Age and Herald are not suggesting Mr Roberts-Smith has been found guilty of any war crime, only that he is the subject of police probes sparked by allegations made by his SAS colleagues.
Mr Roberts-Smith is one of the most decorated veterans to have served with coalition forces in Afghanistan, has stridently denied all wrongdoing and has launched a defamation case against The Age and Herald for first uncovering and reporting the allegations made about him by his fellow soldiers.
While the AFP's focus has for many months been on him, it is almost certainly going to open up a third probe into a different soldier from another SAS squadron. This follows the broadcast on the ABC's Four Corners program of footage of an SAS 3 squadron soldier shooting an apparently unarmed and subdued Afghan in May 2012. That soldier was still active until last week, when he was stood down in the wake of that footage being aired.
Many more AFP probes could follow depending on the findings of a long-running military Inspector-General's inquiry into war crimes.
The organisation revealed in its recent annual report that Supreme Court of Appeal Judge Paul Brereton had, over four years, been probing multiple alleged executions involving SAS and Commandos.
Several of these cases are those reported over the last two years by The Age and Herald, according to defence personnel.
They include a case involving the confession of a Commando who admitted to personally executing an Afghan prisoner and also witnessing other executions. Another case involves claims made in 2019 by SAS medic Dusty Miller that an injured prisoner was taken from his care and allegedly executed in March 2012.
Defence sources said that for the past two years, the Inspector-General has focused on allegations of war crimes involved the SAS's 2 squadron. Mr Roberts-Smith is one of the 2 squadron members under investigation.
The release of the vision on ABC's Four Corners of an Afghan man being shot has spurred fresh inquires into the conduct of 3 squadron as well, according to defence sources. This has the potential to delay the imminent release of the Brereton report, despite increasing political pressure for the historic and likely damning inquiry to be completed.
https://www.theage.com.au/national/war-hero-Ben-Roberts-Smith-interviewed-by-police-over-alleged-killing-20200323-p54cze.html
8chan/8kun QResearch JAPAN Posts (1)
#15732745 at 2022-02-27 00:48:24 (UTC+1)
Q Research Nihon/Japan #4 Learn QR/GreatAwakening Edition
NOTABLES????
>>15732369 #19892
>>15731666, >>15731676, >>15731698 United States, Canada, European allies move to block 'selected' Russian banks from SWIFT
??????????????????????SWIFT??????????????????????
>>15731698, >>15732036 EU to ban certain Russian banks from #SWIFT, paralyze assets of the Russian central bank, and further freeze assets of oligarchs
EU???????????#SWIFT????????????????????????????????????
>>15731674, >>15731720, >>15731768 Proverbs 29:11 A fool gives full vent to his spirit, but a wise man quietly holds it back
?? 29:11 ????????????????????????????????
>>15731683 Does this look like a hot war? Or are we watching a movie/show?
???????????????????????????????????????
>>15731693, >>15731707, >>15731700 4chan is out-faking the fake news
4chan????????????????
>>15731709 Masks Still Required For Air Travel Despite CDC's New Guidance
CDC????????????????????????????????
>>15731723 Powerful prima facie case to charge billionaire Kerry Stokes, Ryan Stokes and Ben Roberts-Smith with attempting to pervert the course of justice
?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
>>15731730, >>15731735 Never seen before 911 Video drops same day as Ukraine invasion
???911???????????????????
>>15731737 Starlink service is now active in Ukraine. More terminals en route.
??????????????????????????????????
>>15731742, >>15731761, >>15731824, >>15731825, >>15731848, >>15731851, >>15732325, >>15732328 Muh WW3
>>15731871, >>15731874, >>15731891, >>15732011, >>15731930, >>15731973, >>15732011 Muh WW3
>>15731828, >>15732020, >>15732031 Rocket Man getting in on the action!
?????????!
>>15731836 Trump's motorcade arrives ar CPAC greeted by crowd of supporters. #CPAC
????????CPAC??????????????????#CPAC
>>15731846 CIA is teaching covert ops to Ukraine forces
CIA????????????????
>>15731880 Physicists test real quantum theory in an optical quantum network
????????????????????????
>>15731879, >>15731986 Trump is getting ready to speak @ CPAC
???????????????@CPAC
>>15732000, >>15732018 "Russian" 9K35 Strela-10 apparently swerving to run over a civilian vehicle is false / fake news. now archived in Wag The Dog thread
?????9K35 Strela-10??????????????????/??????????
>>15732020 North Korea fires unidentified projectile eastward
????????????????
>>15732036, >>15732099, >>15732109,>>15732133 EU, US Agree To Expel "Selected Russian Banks" From SWIFT, Sanction Russian Central Bank?
EU????SWIFT?????????????????????????????????????
>>15732051 Sen. John Kennedy Full Remarks at CPAC 2022 in Orlando
?????????????CPAC2022??????????
>>15732115 Kiev Live Feed
>>15732044, >>15732088 Social disruption followed by alternative media/network & Q 4511
????????????/???????Q 4511????????
>>15732214,>>15732248 President Donald J. Trump will hold a rally in Florence, South Carolina, on Saturday, March 12, 2022, at 7:00PM EST
?????J?????????????????????????2022?3?12??????7????????????????
>>15732221 Russian Solders address the Ukrainian army
??????????????
>>15732223 Lt Dan poll on whether the Government should be able to see your banking transactions
?????????????????????????????????????
>>15732245 "The resistance from the Ukrainians is stronger than the Russians anticipated" + additional obstacles
?????????????????????????????
>>15732288 NASA Will Keep Its Partnership With Russian Space Agency
NASA??????????????????
>>15732298 YouTube Blocks Monetization of Russia-Affiliated Channels, Including RT
YouTube?RT?????????????????????
>>15732311 Facebook, YouTube and Twitter limit ads over Russia's invasion of Ukraine
????????????????Facebook?YouTube?Twitter??????
>>15732339 How RINO Paul Ryan is Connected to Biden's Radical Leftist SCOTUS Pick
RINO???????????????????SCOTUS??????????????????
>>15732345 US DoD funds Ukraine Biolabs PROOF & SITE GONE
?????????????????????? ?? & ???????
?????????
QR??? ??????????? WWG1WGA